Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Classical two-channel detector model reproducing quantum correlations in Bell experiments

Roberto Pavani

Published Jun 17, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A study in inverse model identification. Using only pre-quantum physics (analogue mixer, low-pass filtering, Malus's law, Pearson correlation), we build a deterministic local coherent-detection model whose raw correlations are Bell-compliant (|S_raw| = √2/4). Pearson normalisation yields −cos(a−b), and the CHSH polynomial on these coefficients gives 2√2 (scale-invariant). This C_Pearson is not a Bell correlator and no Bell violation is claimed. The point: the value 2√2, taken from normalised correlation data alone (blind test), does not uniquely identify the generating mechanism — an explicit classical pre-image of the same data is exhibited. Bell-CHSH is used only as an extreme illustration.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.20728380

Related papers

Quantum Entangled Photons are Synchronized Waves

Michael Macdonald

This letter challenges the standard interpretation of Bell test results, which has been used to argue for the abandonment of local realism. We demonstrate that the quantum-mechanical correlation Pc (θ) = cos2 (θ) and the classical Malus' Law result Pc (θ) = 1/2 cos2 (θ) + 1/4 are not contradictory but are complementary descriptions of two distinct source preparations. By modeling light as a real transverse electromagnetic wave, we identify the initial phase orientation of the wavefront as a local hidden variable. Stochastic (randomly prepared) photon sources produce four equally likely phase combinations, yielding the full Malus' Law distribution. Correlated sources, however, are physically constrained to produce only the synchronized subset of these combinations, yielding the cos2 (θ) correlation. We argue that standard Bell test analysis conflates these distinct populations and violates the Fair Sampling Assumption, rendering Bell's inequality inapplicable to the aggregated data. The observed "quantum" correlation is therefore the signature of a correlated source producing pre-synchronized wavefronts, not evidence of non-local communication. We conclude that local realism remains a viable, classical framework for describing these phenomena.

•Oct 12, 2026•0 citations

Born rule, non-orthogonal projections, and the origin of Bell-CHSH violations

Roberto Pavani

We decompose the Bell-CHSH correlator for the Bell state into a diagonal (classical mixture) contribution and a coherent (off-diagonal) contribution using the density matrix formulation.The diagonal part produces correlations satisfying |S|≤2; the entire enhancement to |S|=2√2 originates from the coherent cross term Re(A₁*A₂), which generates a setting-dependent redistribution of probability among measurement outcomes. This cross term sums to zero over all outcomes (preserving normalisation) but modifies individual coincidence probabilities in a manner that depends on the measurement basis. The coherent contribution is precisely the component that takes Born-rule probabilities outside the class of factorisable probabilities assumed in the derivation of Bell's inequality. We show that this structure is formally parallel to the variance normalisation producing apparent Bell violations in classical coherent-detection systems: in both cases, a setting-dependent operation on coherent amplitudes transforms correlations from |S|≤2 to |S|=2√2.

•Aug 24, 2026•0 citations

A Local Phase-Field Framework for Spin Entanglement Correlations

Doron Kwiat

We introduce a local phase-field framework for spin-entanglement correlations. In this framework, the relevant hidden variable is an internal scalar phase associated with each fermion and derived from two underlying real fields. The fields are assumed to evolve locally in ordinary spacetime. When a particle pair is produced at a common spacetime event, the pair acquires a shared phase-locking condition at creation; after separation, the two internal phases evolve independently and no nonlocal interaction is introduced. Spin measurements by Stern–Gerlach analyzers are modeled as local filtering operations. Each local response depends only on the internal phase carried by the particle and on the orientation of the local analyzer. The local response function A(α,λ) = cos(λ − 2α) is derived from the spinorial transformation law of the underlying real field pair and the projection geometry of the detector interaction; it is not a phenomenological ansatz. From these deterministic local responses we derive an analog correlator. The raw product moment of the continuous detector outputs evaluates to ⟨AB⟩ = −½ cos 2(α − β), which satisfies classical Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) bounds. After Pearson normalization—the operationally appropriate correlation measure for continuous analog detector outputs, justified by channel-contrast physics and scale invariance—the normalized correlator yields E(α,β) = −cos 2(α − β), matching the quantum singlet correlator in functional form. When this normalized correlator is inserted into the CHSH expression, it yields the numerical value 2√2. This result is a structural consequence of the reduced marginal variance of continuous response functions relative to the unit-variance dichotomic observables assumed in Bell’s derivation; it does not constitute a violation of Bell’s inequality. The model does not reproduce quantum singlet statistics at the level of binary detector outcomes, where the correlator takes a triangular rather than cosine form. The contribution is therefore ontological and conceptual rather than predictive. The framework preserves parameter independence and no-signaling throughout. It provides a concrete real-field ontology for spin correlations based on internal phase structure, and it demonstrates that the functional form of the quantum singlet correlation can be obtained from a strictly local deterministic description, provided that the detector responses are treated as continuous analog quantities and normalized accordingly. We compare the model with earlier phase-based approaches and discuss experimental configurations—including time-resolved and multi-stage Stern–Gerlach measurements—that could in principle probe the proposed internal-phase dynamics at the pre-registration level.

Quantum Reports•May 15, 2026•0 citations

Causality and local determinism versus quantum nonlocality

Marian Kupczyński

The entanglement and the violation of Bell and CHSH inequalities in spin polarization correlation experiments (SPCE) is considered to be one of the biggest mysteries of Nature and is called quantum nonlocality . In this paper we show once again that this conclusion is based on imprecise terminology and on the lack of understanding of probabilistic models used in various proofs of Bell and CHSH theorems. These models are inconsistent with experimental protocols used in SPCE. This is the only reason why Bell and CHSH inequalities are violated. A probabilistic non-signalling description of SPCE, consistent with quantum predictions, is possible and it depends explicitly on the context of each experiment. It is also deterministic in the sense that the outcome is determined by supplementary local parameters describing both physical signals and measuring instruments. The existence of such description gives additional arguments that quantum theory is emergent from some more detailed theory respecting causality and local determinism. If quantum theory is emergent then there exist perhaps some fine structures in time-series of experimental data which were not predicted by quantum theory. In this paper we explain how a systematic search for such fine structures can be done. If such reproducible fine structures were found it would show that quantum theory is not predictably complete, which would be a major discovery.

arXiv:1312.0636•Journal of Physics Conference Series•Apr 14, 2014•18 citations

Homodyne detection and parametric down-conversion: a classical approach applied to proposed "loophole-free" Bell tests

Caroline H. Thompson

A classical model is presented for the features of parametric down-conversion and homodyne detection relevant to recent proposed ``loophole-free'' Bell tests. The Bell tests themselves are uncontroversial: there are no obvious loopholes that might cause bias and hence, if the world does, after all, obey local realism, no violation of a Bell inequality will be observed. Interest centres around the question of whether or not the proposed criterion for ``non-classical'' light is valid. If cit is not, then the experiments will fail in their initial concept, since both quantum theorists and local realists will agree that we are seeing a purely classical effect. The Bell test, though, is not the only criterion by which the quantum-mechanical and local realist models can be judged. If the experiments are extended by including a range of parameter values and by analysing, in addition to the proposed digitised voltage differences, the raw voltages, the models can be compared in their overall performance and plausibility.

arXiv:quant-ph/0508024•Aug 2, 2005•1 citation

A Probability Model for the Bell Experiment

Kees van Hee, Kees van Berkel, J. de Graaf

The Bell inequality constrains the outcomes of measurements on pairs of distant entangled particles. The Bell contradiction states that the Bell inequality is inconsistent with the calculated outcomes of these quantum experiments. This contradiction led many to question the underlying assumptions, viz. so-called realism and locality. The probability model underlying the Bell inequality is generally left implicit. We propose an explicit probability model for the CHSH version of the Bell experiment. This model has only two simultaneously observable detector settings per measurement, and therefore does not assume realism. The quantum expectation now becomes a conditional expectation, given the two detector settings. This probability model is in full agreement with both quantum mechanics and experiments. As a result, the model satisfies the Bell inequality; there are no so-called violations. We extend this model to include a hidden variable. This extended model is not Bell-separable. This non-separability implies that the model is non-deterministic or non-local (or both).

arXiv:2302.05174•Quantum Reports•Feb 14, 2026•1 citation
A study in inverse model identification. Using only pre-quantum physics (analogue mixer, low-pass filtering, Malus's law, Pearson correlation), we build a deterministic local coherent-detection model whose raw correlations are Bell-compliant (|S_raw| = √2/4). Pearson normalisation yields −cos(a−b), and the CHSH polynomial on these coefficients gives 2√2 (scale-invariant). This C_Pearson is not a Bell correlator and no Bell violation is claimed. The point: the value 2√2, taken from normalised correlation data alone (blind test), does not uniquely identify the generating mechanism — an explicit classical pre-image of the same data is exhibited. Bell-CHSH is used only as an extreme illustration.
This letter challenges the standard interpretation of Bell test results, which has been used to argue for the abandonment of local realism. We demonstrate that the quantum-mechanical correlation Pc (θ) = cos2 (θ) and the classical Malus' Law result Pc (θ) = 1/2 cos2 (θ) + 1/4 are not contradictory but are complementary descriptions of two distinct source preparations. By modeling light as a real transverse electromagnetic wave, we identify the initial phase orientation of the wavefront as a local hidden variable. Stochastic (randomly prepared) photon sources produce four equally likely phase combinations, yielding the full Malus' Law distribution. Correlated sources, however, are physically constrained to produce only the synchronized subset of these combinations, yielding the cos2 (θ) correlation. We argue that standard Bell test analysis conflates these distinct populations and violates the Fair Sampling Assumption, rendering Bell's inequality inapplicable to the aggregated data. The observed "quantum" correlation is therefore the signature of a correlated source producing pre-synchronized wavefronts, not evidence of non-local communication. We conclude that local realism remains a viable, classical framework for describing these phenomena.
We decompose the Bell-CHSH correlator for the Bell state into a diagonal (classical mixture) contribution and a coherent (off-diagonal) contribution using the density matrix formulation.The diagonal part produces correlations satisfying |S|≤2; the entire enhancement to |S|=2√2 originates from the coherent cross term Re(A₁*A₂), which generates a setting-dependent redistribution of probability among measurement outcomes. This cross term sums to zero over all outcomes (preserving normalisation) but modifies individual coincidence probabilities in a manner that depends on the measurement basis. The coherent contribution is precisely the component that takes Born-rule probabilities outside the class of factorisable probabilities assumed in the derivation of Bell's inequality. We show that this structure is formally parallel to the variance normalisation producing apparent Bell violations in classical coherent-detection systems: in both cases, a setting-dependent operation on coherent amplitudes transforms correlations from |S|≤2 to |S|=2√2.
We introduce a local phase-field framework for spin-entanglement correlations. In this framework, the relevant hidden variable is an internal scalar phase associated with each fermion and derived from two underlying real fields. The fields are assumed to evolve locally in ordinary spacetime. When a particle pair is produced at a common spacetime event, the pair acquires a shared phase-locking condition at creation; after separation, the two internal phases evolve independently and no nonlocal interaction is introduced. Spin measurements by Stern–Gerlach analyzers are modeled as local filtering operations. Each local response depends only on the internal phase carried by the particle and on the orientation of the local analyzer. The local response function A(α,λ) = cos(λ − 2α) is derived from the spinorial transformation law of the underlying real field pair and the projection geometry of the detector interaction; it is not a phenomenological ansatz. From these deterministic local responses we derive an analog correlator. The raw product moment of the continuous detector outputs evaluates to ⟨AB⟩ = −½ cos 2(α − β), which satisfies classical Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) bounds. After Pearson normalization—the operationally appropriate correlation measure for continuous analog detector outputs, justified by channel-contrast physics and scale invariance—the normalized correlator yields E(α,β) = −cos 2(α − β), matching the quantum singlet correlator in functional form. When this normalized correlator is inserted into the CHSH expression, it yields the numerical value 2√2. This result is a structural consequence of the reduced marginal variance of continuous response functions relative to the unit-variance dichotomic observables assumed in Bell’s derivation; it does not constitute a violation of Bell’s inequality. The model does not reproduce quantum singlet statistics at the level of binary detector outcomes, where the correlator takes a triangular rather than cosine form. The contribution is therefore ontological and conceptual rather than predictive. The framework preserves parameter independence and no-signaling throughout. It provides a concrete real-field ontology for spin correlations based on internal phase structure, and it demonstrates that the functional form of the quantum singlet correlation can be obtained from a strictly local deterministic description, provided that the detector responses are treated as continuous analog quantities and normalized accordingly. We compare the model with earlier phase-based approaches and discuss experimental configurations—including time-resolved and multi-stage Stern–Gerlach measurements—that could in principle probe the proposed internal-phase dynamics at the pre-registration level.
The entanglement and the violation of Bell and CHSH inequalities in spin polarization correlation experiments (SPCE) is considered to be one of the biggest mysteries of Nature and is called quantum nonlocality . In this paper we show once again that this conclusion is based on imprecise terminology and on the lack of understanding of probabilistic models used in various proofs of Bell and CHSH theorems. These models are inconsistent with experimental protocols used in SPCE. This is the only reason why Bell and CHSH inequalities are violated. A probabilistic non-signalling description of SPCE, consistent with quantum predictions, is possible and it depends explicitly on the context of each experiment. It is also deterministic in the sense that the outcome is determined by supplementary local parameters describing both physical signals and measuring instruments. The existence of such description gives additional arguments that quantum theory is emergent from some more detailed theory respecting causality and local determinism. If quantum theory is emergent then there exist perhaps some fine structures in time-series of experimental data which were not predicted by quantum theory. In this paper we explain how a systematic search for such fine structures can be done. If such reproducible fine structures were found it would show that quantum theory is not predictably complete, which would be a major discovery.
A classical model is presented for the features of parametric down-conversion and homodyne detection relevant to recent proposed ``loophole-free'' Bell tests. The Bell tests themselves are uncontroversial: there are no obvious loopholes that might cause bias and hence, if the world does, after all, obey local realism, no violation of a Bell inequality will be observed. Interest centres around the question of whether or not the proposed criterion for ``non-classical'' light is valid. If cit is not, then the experiments will fail in their initial concept, since both quantum theorists and local realists will agree that we are seeing a purely classical effect. The Bell test, though, is not the only criterion by which the quantum-mechanical and local realist models can be judged. If the experiments are extended by including a range of parameter values and by analysing, in addition to the proposed digitised voltage differences, the raw voltages, the models can be compared in their overall performance and plausibility.
The Bell inequality constrains the outcomes of measurements on pairs of distant entangled particles. The Bell contradiction states that the Bell inequality is inconsistent with the calculated outcomes of these quantum experiments. This contradiction led many to question the underlying assumptions, viz. so-called realism and locality. The probability model underlying the Bell inequality is generally left implicit. We propose an explicit probability model for the CHSH version of the Bell experiment. This model has only two simultaneously observable detector settings per measurement, and therefore does not assume realism. The quantum expectation now becomes a conditional expectation, given the two detector settings. This probability model is in full agreement with both quantum mechanics and experiments. As a result, the model satisfies the Bell inequality; there are no so-called violations. We extend this model to include a hidden variable. This extended model is not Bell-separable. This non-separability implies that the model is non-deterministic or non-local (or both).