Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Quantum Two-Slit Interference Applied to a Coin

Francesco R. Ruggeri

Published Jun 15, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In this note we try to develop a toy model of quantum interference applied to a coin. Specifically, we consider a fair coin (with a head and tail side) which rotates from a face up (+1) to a face down (-1) state in space while translating with angular velocity w. The coin also translates with a speed linked to w and the coin diameter. In particular, in one rotation, the coin translates a distance equal to the diameter. This coin enters a box with a single slot. There are two interaction spots in this box separated by a length equal to the diameter of the box and so the coin interacts with both in a manner which does not change w, but changes the direction of translation. In particular, we suggest a special correlated OR interaction such that if the coin is released and travels at an angle theta2 with respect to a y axis through the center of the box, then one averages probabilities for each interaction and takes the modulus squared to determine an overall probability for such a theta2 result. The following rule is then used. The coin undergoes periodic rotation, but has equal probability to be at any rotation point. Thus, we model the coin by exp(i theta), where theta is the angle of the coin with the y axis, by exp(i theta), such that the modulus represents 1. exp(i theta) is an ordered pair, linked with projections of the coin on the x and y axes. This probability may then be written as exp(i c x) where x is a distance along the motion ray. The overall effect of the the double interaction in the box is to create an average value exp(i c x) + exp(i c x1) (for each correlated interaction place) for a given angle theta2 from the y axis going through the center of the box. We suggest that this is an unsual interaction because it is as if probabilistically the entire coin is pulled towards one interaction center or the other and probabilities add, i.e. exp(i c x ) + exp(i c x1), where x is linked with distance traveled out along theta2 from interaction point 1 and x1, the distance traveled out along theta2 from interaction point 2. The interaction itself simply sends the particle out along theta2, but there is a probability associated with this sending off, which we discuss in the following paragraph. This average of the two odered pairs leads to a single order pair whose modulus squared represents probability. The maximum probability is 4 (i.e. the two rays lined up vertically along the y axis as an example). One the modulus squared has been calculated for a given angle theta2 with respect to y, then one may generate a random number from 0 to 4. If it is greater than the modulus squared, a different theta2 is chosen, otherwise the coin is sent out along theta2. We suggest that this physical model of a coin mimics quantum 2-slit interference and shows the unusual type of interaction which occurs in the 2-slit region. In other words, the double interaction of the coin with both slits (as if the coin were at both places because its diameter (or interaction region) reaches both interaction places is used to create an average ordered pair whose modulus yields the probability of the coin moving out along theta2 (which is linked with the two ordered pairs which are averaged). While moving along the ray theta2, the coin rotates in its usual manner, just as an exp(ipx) moves as it usually would.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.20702983

Related papers

Quantum Two-Slit Interference Applied to a Coin Part 2

Francesco R. Ruggeri

In Part 1, we tried to create a toy model involving a rotating-translating coin. We examined what kind of interaction is needed to create a typical 2-slit interference pattern. Here we examine a physical object, namely a photon, which has a built-in periodic cycle for its electric and magnetic fields. These are perpendicular and in plane perpendicular to motion and both change as cos(-Et/hbar + px/hbar). We point out that the electric and magnetic fields are both real, they are not described by exp(-iEt+ipx) and furthermore, they are deterministic, not probabilistic. We try to see how such a picture can lead to quantum two slit interference. Basically, we argue that if one only considers the electric field, long range interactions from atoms around both slits interact with a photon heading towards the center between the slits. As a result, the physical interaction must involve both slits, but one has no idea through which slit the photon passes. There is probability in the problem, but at the same time interactions with both slits before the photon passes through and also after. One needs a model which captures both the notion of probability and interaction with both slits. For probability this should be an OR situation (one slit or the other), but it cannot be the usual classical probability scheme which implies that moving through one slit only involves interaction with that slit. Interactions with both slits occur. This seems like a contradiction because one applies OR probability to one slit or another. Given that the interaction with the electric field occurs in a periodic manner cos(-Et+px) hbar=1, we suggest that exp(-iEt+ipx) with its modulus of 1 captures the idea that any electric field position as the same probability, but that there is periodic motion linked with interaction in space. . As a result, one may keep the mathematical notion of an OR probability scheme by introducing an interacting probability exp(ipx). This means that the probaiblities from each slit in the OR (add) scheme interfere or interact which is what is required because an interaction with both slits occurs. exp(ipx) captures the periodicity and also enforces conservation of momentum (exp(ip1x)exp(ip2x) = exp(I (p1+p2)x) and it seems that this is the only information needed.

•Jun 17, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Free Particle Probability and the Notion of Outcomes

Ruggeri, Francesco R.

Classically, probability is considered in terms of the number of possible outcomes. For example, a die toss has six possible outcomes and a coin toss, two. Probability calculations make use of probabilities and hence of the total number of possible outcomes. Thus, they are not deterministic calculations which follow “what happens” as in Newtonian mechanics. We suggest that if free particle quantum mechanics is probabilistic, it must also involve the notion of possible outcomes in an experiment and not represent a deterministic approach. We suggest, however, that something interesting applies to quantum mechanics because we have suggested that free particle quantum mechanics arises from the Lorentz invariant A = -Et+px. We note that there exist x,t trajectory points which follow x=vt. We also note, however, that one may introduce the idea of intervals dx, dt (because Newton’s dx→0, dt→0 is an idealization) and that A is unchanged for x,t and x+hbar/p , t+hbar/E. In other words, we suggest that there are intervals with probability about each x,t trajectory point. A trajectory point is associated with deterministic physics, but probability about this point is not. In other words, one has a kind of hybrid probability scheme. Thus, exp(ipx) and exp(-iEt) really represent fluctuation probabilities about a trajectory point x and t. These ranges of possible x and t fluctuations about a trajectory point x,t allow for further probability to occur in certain interactions. We consider two examples. The first is 2-slit interference which involves a deterministic particle moving along a straight line towards a 2-slit mechanism perpendicular to its path. At the 2-slit apparatus, one considers a probabilistic calculation as the uncertainty in x, i.e. dx=hbar/p allows for possible interaction with both slits. This involves considering all possible outcomes (i.e. motion through one slit or the other which is a classical situation), but exp(i p dot r1) and exp(i p dot r2) “sit on top” of these trajectories at the 2-slit apparatus and one has interference of the probabilities linked with each classical possible outcome. Thus, there are two sets of probabilities which are intertwined, the probability range hbar/p for each path and the two possible paths which have equal probability. One must consider the possible outcomes for both sets together. We suggest that a similar analysis applies to the case of 1-D reflection-refraction for x=0 at an n1-n2 index of refraction junction. Thus, we suggest that a deterministic free particle with x=vt may encounter probabilistic interaction situations, such as a two-slit apparatus or an n1-n2 index of refraction junction. These are probabilistic only because there is a probability fluctuation scheme in x associated with each deterministic x point. It is this probability which allows for a second probability to arise due to interaction with the slits or at the 1-D n1-n2 junction. In such a case, one must consider all possible outcomes which means that one does not only consider the exp(ipx) type probabilities, but also those linked with the physical interaction, i.e. two possible paths, one from each slit, or an incident, reflected and refracted photon at x=0 (n1-n2 junction). It is a combination of all possible paths which must be used in calculations. We thus suggest that even though there is a sense of determinism, i..e free particles move as x=vt and these exist in the 2-slit case and the 1-D reflection-refraction case, in a probabilistic calculation one must consider all probabilistic outcomes consistent with these. Thus, quantum mechanical calculations are true probabilistic calculations in the sense that they involve all possible outcomes in an analysis.

•Dec 1, 2025•0 citations

Quantum Free Particle Probability and the Notion of Outcomes Part 2

Ruggeri, Francesco R.

In Part 1, we argued that the consideration of all possible outcomes is a defining idea of a probabilistic calculation. We then argued that in free particle quantum mechanics there were two sets of outcomes, one driving the other. In particular, a single particle moves as x=vt, but at each x,t point, one has interaction uncertainty/fluctuations of dt and dx linked with exp(-iEt) and exp(ipx). As a result, in a 2-slit interference problem, exp(ipx) (a probability linked with possible positional fluctuations about x) leads to a further probability of interacting with both slits. The two sets of outcomes must be considered, i.e. exp(i p dot r1) + exp(i p dot r2), where r1 is a vector from the center of the first slit to a point on a screen far away, and r2, a vector from the center of the second slit to the same screen point. We also considered the case of reflection-refraction from an n1-n2 index of refraction junction. The point is that these two cases are clearly probabilistic, i.e. not deterministic at all. Here we consider two different scenarios which have the appearance of a deterministic result, but are actually probabilistic and so linked with all possible outcomes, i.e. an average over these which must be understood as an average (as in classical probability). The first is a single particle bound state and the second, transmission through a potential wall. In the bound state case, the analogue is a Newtonian bound state and in fact between the classical turning points KEave(x) + V(x) = E in the probabilistic case which exactly matches the classical one. One is, however, dealing with an average KEave(x) = -1/2m d/dx d/dx W/ W, where W=Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx), it involves all possible outcomes and is not a physical state. Given the similarity to a deterministic problem there is a danger of not considering the quantum bound calculation as a probabilistic one. In the quantum single particle case, one may be surprised by tunneling, but the quantum probabilistic scenario is one in which all possible interaction outcomes are considered together (as is required by probability) and so one cannot possibly ignore interactions linked to a particle entering or leaving the potential region. Furthermore, it is only KEave(x) which equals the classical result and so E which is single value in the classical case, is linked to an average value in the quantum case, i.e. a particle may have a p such that pp/2m is not zero at the classical turning point. Only KEave(x) =0 at this point. An interesting feature is that a probabilistic calculation applies to a single particle run (which only produces one outcome). One, however, cannot measure the full probability associated with a problem without making a very large number of measurements.

•Dec 2, 2025•0 citations

Quantum Two Slit Interference and Determinism Versus Probability in Interactions

Francesco R. Ruggeri

In classical physics, interactions appear to be of the form of cause and effect, as in Newton’s second law is: F = dp/dt. The force F governs the interaction and dp/dt is the effect. In quantum mechanics, there is a probability for an impulse hit interaction by a particle given by exp(ipx) within a wavelength region of size hbar/p. As a result, instead of an interaction occurring within dx->0, the particle itself dictates an interaction region of the size hbar/p. Consequently, in a 2-slit interaction, the slits should be about a wavelength hbar/p apart. In classical physics, an interaction occurs within the interaction region (dx->0), but in the 2-slit case the interaction region includes the space from the first slit to the second, so to ask: What is happening as the particle interacts within this region? means that a particle can pass through one slit and inteact with the other, or it can interact with the slit through which it passes. The interaction region is the smallest region in which the interaction occurs (as if it were a black box). The particle physically passes through one slit or the other, but interacts either way with both slits probabilisitcally because otherwise the interaction region would only be one slit or the other contradicting the probabilistic range hbar/p of interaction. As a result, a two-slit calculation is really a calculation of an interaction within an hbar/p region including both slits. This interaction is probabilistic due to the exp(ipx) interaction hit nature of the particle and so it is the particle which dictates the interaction to a large degree. The fact that the particle must pass through one slit or the other, together with a probabilistic interaction over the hbar/p region means that two key notions are at work, one being the physical location of the particle (passing through one slit or the other) which governs how the probabilistic interaction (due to the particle) operates. In particular, one draws two parallel rays, one from the center of each slit towards a fixed point on a screen far away. The interaction is based on the exp(ipx) probabilistic interaction of the particle and the separation of the two slits because the particle interacts with both as it passes through only one. In other words, reality is not simply based on what one can measure during an interaction. The fact that one does measure through which slit the particle passes does not mean that the positions of the slits cannot stil helpl lead to determinate statements such as zero particles arrive at certain x points on the screen. The slit separation is part of the physical reality of the problem. (Note: there is also diffraction from the two edges of each slit, i.e. diffraction, which follows the same ideas and so one has a combination of diffraction from each slit together with interference.) As a result, we suggest that one consider the entire region from one slit to the other as a quantum interaction region similar to the dx->0 used in Newtonian mechanics. Quantum mechanics then provides a probabilistic, not deterministic, descripition of possible interactions and their probability weights, unlike the cause (force) and effect (deterministic change in p of the particle) of Newtonian mechanics. The exp(ipx), hbar/p gradation form of probability, allows for probabilities to add or subtract at different x points. The walls of the 2-slit apparatus are linked with probabilistic momentum angle changing, with each angle having the same probability (uniform distribution), but otherwise much of the interaction is dictated by the particle, unlike in Netwonian mechanics. For a V(x) = Sum over i Vk exp(ikx), both exp(ipx) and exp(ikx) are one a similar footing.

•Aug 4, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Bound States and Conditional Probability

Francesco R. Ruggeri

It is sometimes stated in the literature (1) that quantum mechanics is based on conditional probabilities. If this is the case, one would expect such conditional probabilities to appear in a single particle bound state. A free quantum particle is associated with a probability to interact of exp(ipx) (linked to 2-slit interference, 1-D reflection-refraction at an n1-n2 junction etc), but the kinetic energy and momentum are pp/2m (nonrelativistic) and p at all x even though each x has a different phase according to exp(ipx). The momentum is p at x, but the probability for an impulse hit at x is not the same even though its modulus is. When different probabilities exp(ipx) add in an OR situation, this leads to a spatial pattern which no longer has a modulus of 1, i.e. translational invariance is broken. Such a pattern also occurs for a single particle bound state W(x)=Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx). W(x) can have 0 points, but the average kinetic energy -1/2m d/dx dW/dx / W is not 0 at such a point. One has, on average (a statistical calculation), no average interaction at such an x point. One might ask why this should have anything to do with average kinetic energy? If one writes a conservation law: KEave(x) + V(x) = 0, then one considers kinetic energy interacting with potential energy. If there is no interaction at some x point for a given p (not W(x) on average), then it should not be part of the conservation of energy at this point. One is only interested in kinetic energy which interacts with potential energy at each x point. Thus, a(p) exp(ipx) + a(-p) exp(-ipx) (with a(p)=a(-p)) may have a 0 point at some x and so it does not have an average interaction at such a point, i.e. pp/2m (a(p)exp(ipx) + a(-p)exp(-ipx)) = 0. As a result, in a bound state, one considers kinetic energy per p, -p multiplied by the average probability (p, -p). Different a(p)exp(ipx) + a(-p)exp(-ipx) (a(p)=a(-p)) weights in this average picture indicate the extent to which the particle interacts. This idea holds for a single p,-p pair, but one must normalize over all such pairs, leading to the idea of a conditional probability. Given that hbar/p must be “created physically” in space so to speak, one must have interaction probability which creates this physical situation even in cos(px)+ i sin(px). This leads to the idea of interaction probability being 0, positive, but <1, or even negative and it is the interaction which allows one to consider conservation of energy with a potential V(x) in the first place. As a result, one cannot include a full pp/2m if there is negative, 0 or only particle interaction. Thus, pp/2m is multiplied by 2 a(p)cos(px) /W(x) for a(p)=a(-p).

•May 29, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Interference/Noninterference Interactions and their Statistics

Francesco R. Ruggeri

In classical statistical mechanics, although one has averages of a system, a single particle within the system has properties which are sharply defined at any x,t, even though these properties change stochastically, i.e. through interactions. A quantum free particle, on the other hand, has information based on the Lorentz invariant -Et+px, multiplied by i to create periodicity which indicates an inherent information, not one based on the outcome of trial runs or interactions. The probability is exp(-iEt+ipx). If E and p are considered as constant, then there are independent probabilistic fluctuations in x and t, which means there may be corresponding probabilistic interactions, both impulse ones (one dimensional reflection/refraction, n-slits) and temporal ones (Rabi frequency). In such a case, one has interference and the form exp(ipx) or exp(-iEt) governing the statistics, not a maximization of entropy linked to interaction/outcome results. Nevertheless, the quantum particle interacts with fields, it seems, which give rise to p or E changes. It seems the key idea is that one has stochastic uncertainty before an interaction occurs and hence interference. The alternative is that such stochastic uncertainty does not exist before a specific interaction, i.e. the inherent probability exp(-iEt) or exp(ipx) has no effect on the interaction. This is not to say that there cannot be probabilities before the interaction. In a Maxwell-Boltzmann gas, there are probabilities P(e1) and P(e2) for particles with e1 and e2, but a specific e1 and e2 have no uncertainty. The uncertainty is in the outcome of the reaction. Another example is a two state electron in an atom which absorbs and emits photons. The rules for time evolution are that the ground state is represented by exp(-iEot), but at some stochastic t value, it changes to exp(-iE1t) and vice versa. The ground state absorbs a photon and the excited emits. The two states are clearly defined by the differing interactions which govern their time dependence which is taken to be simply the changing of Eo to E1 and vice versa. This problem is then based on probabilities based on outcomes of an interaction and maximization of entropy subject to a constraint is employed. There is no initial interference.

•Aug 9, 2023•0 citations
In this note we try to develop a toy model of quantum interference applied to a coin. Specifically, we consider a fair coin (with a head and tail side) which rotates from a face up (+1) to a face down (-1) state in space while translating with angular velocity w. The coin also translates with a speed linked to w and the coin diameter. In particular, in one rotation, the coin translates a distance equal to the diameter. This coin enters a box with a single slot. There are two interaction spots in this box separated by a length equal to the diameter of the box and so the coin interacts with both in a manner which does not change w, but changes the direction of translation. In particular, we suggest a special correlated OR interaction such that if the coin is released and travels at an angle theta2 with respect to a y axis through the center of the box, then one averages probabilities for each interaction and takes the modulus squared to determine an overall probability for such a theta2 result. The following rule is then used. The coin undergoes periodic rotation, but has equal probability to be at any rotation point. Thus, we model the coin by exp(i theta), where theta is the angle of the coin with the y axis, by exp(i theta), such that the modulus represents 1. exp(i theta) is an ordered pair, linked with projections of the coin on the x and y axes. This probability may then be written as exp(i c x) where x is a distance along the motion ray. The overall effect of the the double interaction in the box is to create an average value exp(i c x) + exp(i c x1) (for each correlated interaction place) for a given angle theta2 from the y axis going through the center of the box. We suggest that this is an unsual interaction because it is as if probabilistically the entire coin is pulled towards one interaction center or the other and probabilities add, i.e. exp(i c x ) + exp(i c x1), where x is linked with distance traveled out along theta2 from interaction point 1 and x1, the distance traveled out along theta2 from interaction point 2. The interaction itself simply sends the particle out along theta2, but there is a probability associated with this sending off, which we discuss in the following paragraph. This average of the two odered pairs leads to a single order pair whose modulus squared represents probability. The maximum probability is 4 (i.e. the two rays lined up vertically along the y axis as an example). One the modulus squared has been calculated for a given angle theta2 with respect to y, then one may generate a random number from 0 to 4. If it is greater than the modulus squared, a different theta2 is chosen, otherwise the coin is sent out along theta2. We suggest that this physical model of a coin mimics quantum 2-slit interference and shows the unusual type of interaction which occurs in the 2-slit region. In other words, the double interaction of the coin with both slits (as if the coin were at both places because its diameter (or interaction region) reaches both interaction places is used to create an average ordered pair whose modulus yields the probability of the coin moving out along theta2 (which is linked with the two ordered pairs which are averaged). While moving along the ray theta2, the coin rotates in its usual manner, just as an exp(ipx) moves as it usually would.
In Part 1, we tried to create a toy model involving a rotating-translating coin. We examined what kind of interaction is needed to create a typical 2-slit interference pattern. Here we examine a physical object, namely a photon, which has a built-in periodic cycle for its electric and magnetic fields. These are perpendicular and in plane perpendicular to motion and both change as cos(-Et/hbar + px/hbar). We point out that the electric and magnetic fields are both real, they are not described by exp(-iEt+ipx) and furthermore, they are deterministic, not probabilistic. We try to see how such a picture can lead to quantum two slit interference. Basically, we argue that if one only considers the electric field, long range interactions from atoms around both slits interact with a photon heading towards the center between the slits. As a result, the physical interaction must involve both slits, but one has no idea through which slit the photon passes. There is probability in the problem, but at the same time interactions with both slits before the photon passes through and also after. One needs a model which captures both the notion of probability and interaction with both slits. For probability this should be an OR situation (one slit or the other), but it cannot be the usual classical probability scheme which implies that moving through one slit only involves interaction with that slit. Interactions with both slits occur. This seems like a contradiction because one applies OR probability to one slit or another. Given that the interaction with the electric field occurs in a periodic manner cos(-Et+px) hbar=1, we suggest that exp(-iEt+ipx) with its modulus of 1 captures the idea that any electric field position as the same probability, but that there is periodic motion linked with interaction in space. . As a result, one may keep the mathematical notion of an OR probability scheme by introducing an interacting probability exp(ipx). This means that the probaiblities from each slit in the OR (add) scheme interfere or interact which is what is required because an interaction with both slits occurs. exp(ipx) captures the periodicity and also enforces conservation of momentum (exp(ip1x)exp(ip2x) = exp(I (p1+p2)x) and it seems that this is the only information needed.
Classically, probability is considered in terms of the number of possible outcomes. For example, a die toss has six possible outcomes and a coin toss, two. Probability calculations make use of probabilities and hence of the total number of possible outcomes. Thus, they are not deterministic calculations which follow “what happens” as in Newtonian mechanics. We suggest that if free particle quantum mechanics is probabilistic, it must also involve the notion of possible outcomes in an experiment and not represent a deterministic approach. We suggest, however, that something interesting applies to quantum mechanics because we have suggested that free particle quantum mechanics arises from the Lorentz invariant A = -Et+px. We note that there exist x,t trajectory points which follow x=vt. We also note, however, that one may introduce the idea of intervals dx, dt (because Newton’s dx→0, dt→0 is an idealization) and that A is unchanged for x,t and x+hbar/p , t+hbar/E. In other words, we suggest that there are intervals with probability about each x,t trajectory point. A trajectory point is associated with deterministic physics, but probability about this point is not. In other words, one has a kind of hybrid probability scheme. Thus, exp(ipx) and exp(-iEt) really represent fluctuation probabilities about a trajectory point x and t. These ranges of possible x and t fluctuations about a trajectory point x,t allow for further probability to occur in certain interactions. We consider two examples. The first is 2-slit interference which involves a deterministic particle moving along a straight line towards a 2-slit mechanism perpendicular to its path. At the 2-slit apparatus, one considers a probabilistic calculation as the uncertainty in x, i.e. dx=hbar/p allows for possible interaction with both slits. This involves considering all possible outcomes (i.e. motion through one slit or the other which is a classical situation), but exp(i p dot r1) and exp(i p dot r2) “sit on top” of these trajectories at the 2-slit apparatus and one has interference of the probabilities linked with each classical possible outcome. Thus, there are two sets of probabilities which are intertwined, the probability range hbar/p for each path and the two possible paths which have equal probability. One must consider the possible outcomes for both sets together. We suggest that a similar analysis applies to the case of 1-D reflection-refraction for x=0 at an n1-n2 index of refraction junction. Thus, we suggest that a deterministic free particle with x=vt may encounter probabilistic interaction situations, such as a two-slit apparatus or an n1-n2 index of refraction junction. These are probabilistic only because there is a probability fluctuation scheme in x associated with each deterministic x point. It is this probability which allows for a second probability to arise due to interaction with the slits or at the 1-D n1-n2 junction. In such a case, one must consider all possible outcomes which means that one does not only consider the exp(ipx) type probabilities, but also those linked with the physical interaction, i.e. two possible paths, one from each slit, or an incident, reflected and refracted photon at x=0 (n1-n2 junction). It is a combination of all possible paths which must be used in calculations. We thus suggest that even though there is a sense of determinism, i..e free particles move as x=vt and these exist in the 2-slit case and the 1-D reflection-refraction case, in a probabilistic calculation one must consider all probabilistic outcomes consistent with these. Thus, quantum mechanical calculations are true probabilistic calculations in the sense that they involve all possible outcomes in an analysis.
In Part 1, we argued that the consideration of all possible outcomes is a defining idea of a probabilistic calculation. We then argued that in free particle quantum mechanics there were two sets of outcomes, one driving the other. In particular, a single particle moves as x=vt, but at each x,t point, one has interaction uncertainty/fluctuations of dt and dx linked with exp(-iEt) and exp(ipx). As a result, in a 2-slit interference problem, exp(ipx) (a probability linked with possible positional fluctuations about x) leads to a further probability of interacting with both slits. The two sets of outcomes must be considered, i.e. exp(i p dot r1) + exp(i p dot r2), where r1 is a vector from the center of the first slit to a point on a screen far away, and r2, a vector from the center of the second slit to the same screen point. We also considered the case of reflection-refraction from an n1-n2 index of refraction junction. The point is that these two cases are clearly probabilistic, i.e. not deterministic at all. Here we consider two different scenarios which have the appearance of a deterministic result, but are actually probabilistic and so linked with all possible outcomes, i.e. an average over these which must be understood as an average (as in classical probability). The first is a single particle bound state and the second, transmission through a potential wall. In the bound state case, the analogue is a Newtonian bound state and in fact between the classical turning points KEave(x) + V(x) = E in the probabilistic case which exactly matches the classical one. One is, however, dealing with an average KEave(x) = -1/2m d/dx d/dx W/ W, where W=Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx), it involves all possible outcomes and is not a physical state. Given the similarity to a deterministic problem there is a danger of not considering the quantum bound calculation as a probabilistic one. In the quantum single particle case, one may be surprised by tunneling, but the quantum probabilistic scenario is one in which all possible interaction outcomes are considered together (as is required by probability) and so one cannot possibly ignore interactions linked to a particle entering or leaving the potential region. Furthermore, it is only KEave(x) which equals the classical result and so E which is single value in the classical case, is linked to an average value in the quantum case, i.e. a particle may have a p such that pp/2m is not zero at the classical turning point. Only KEave(x) =0 at this point. An interesting feature is that a probabilistic calculation applies to a single particle run (which only produces one outcome). One, however, cannot measure the full probability associated with a problem without making a very large number of measurements.
In classical physics, interactions appear to be of the form of cause and effect, as in Newton’s second law is: F = dp/dt. The force F governs the interaction and dp/dt is the effect. In quantum mechanics, there is a probability for an impulse hit interaction by a particle given by exp(ipx) within a wavelength region of size hbar/p. As a result, instead of an interaction occurring within dx->0, the particle itself dictates an interaction region of the size hbar/p. Consequently, in a 2-slit interaction, the slits should be about a wavelength hbar/p apart. In classical physics, an interaction occurs within the interaction region (dx->0), but in the 2-slit case the interaction region includes the space from the first slit to the second, so to ask: What is happening as the particle interacts within this region? means that a particle can pass through one slit and inteact with the other, or it can interact with the slit through which it passes. The interaction region is the smallest region in which the interaction occurs (as if it were a black box). The particle physically passes through one slit or the other, but interacts either way with both slits probabilisitcally because otherwise the interaction region would only be one slit or the other contradicting the probabilistic range hbar/p of interaction. As a result, a two-slit calculation is really a calculation of an interaction within an hbar/p region including both slits. This interaction is probabilistic due to the exp(ipx) interaction hit nature of the particle and so it is the particle which dictates the interaction to a large degree. The fact that the particle must pass through one slit or the other, together with a probabilistic interaction over the hbar/p region means that two key notions are at work, one being the physical location of the particle (passing through one slit or the other) which governs how the probabilistic interaction (due to the particle) operates. In particular, one draws two parallel rays, one from the center of each slit towards a fixed point on a screen far away. The interaction is based on the exp(ipx) probabilistic interaction of the particle and the separation of the two slits because the particle interacts with both as it passes through only one. In other words, reality is not simply based on what one can measure during an interaction. The fact that one does measure through which slit the particle passes does not mean that the positions of the slits cannot stil helpl lead to determinate statements such as zero particles arrive at certain x points on the screen. The slit separation is part of the physical reality of the problem. (Note: there is also diffraction from the two edges of each slit, i.e. diffraction, which follows the same ideas and so one has a combination of diffraction from each slit together with interference.) As a result, we suggest that one consider the entire region from one slit to the other as a quantum interaction region similar to the dx->0 used in Newtonian mechanics. Quantum mechanics then provides a probabilistic, not deterministic, descripition of possible interactions and their probability weights, unlike the cause (force) and effect (deterministic change in p of the particle) of Newtonian mechanics. The exp(ipx), hbar/p gradation form of probability, allows for probabilities to add or subtract at different x points. The walls of the 2-slit apparatus are linked with probabilistic momentum angle changing, with each angle having the same probability (uniform distribution), but otherwise much of the interaction is dictated by the particle, unlike in Netwonian mechanics. For a V(x) = Sum over i Vk exp(ikx), both exp(ipx) and exp(ikx) are one a similar footing.
It is sometimes stated in the literature (1) that quantum mechanics is based on conditional probabilities. If this is the case, one would expect such conditional probabilities to appear in a single particle bound state. A free quantum particle is associated with a probability to interact of exp(ipx) (linked to 2-slit interference, 1-D reflection-refraction at an n1-n2 junction etc), but the kinetic energy and momentum are pp/2m (nonrelativistic) and p at all x even though each x has a different phase according to exp(ipx). The momentum is p at x, but the probability for an impulse hit at x is not the same even though its modulus is. When different probabilities exp(ipx) add in an OR situation, this leads to a spatial pattern which no longer has a modulus of 1, i.e. translational invariance is broken. Such a pattern also occurs for a single particle bound state W(x)=Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx). W(x) can have 0 points, but the average kinetic energy -1/2m d/dx dW/dx / W is not 0 at such a point. One has, on average (a statistical calculation), no average interaction at such an x point. One might ask why this should have anything to do with average kinetic energy? If one writes a conservation law: KEave(x) + V(x) = 0, then one considers kinetic energy interacting with potential energy. If there is no interaction at some x point for a given p (not W(x) on average), then it should not be part of the conservation of energy at this point. One is only interested in kinetic energy which interacts with potential energy at each x point. Thus, a(p) exp(ipx) + a(-p) exp(-ipx) (with a(p)=a(-p)) may have a 0 point at some x and so it does not have an average interaction at such a point, i.e. pp/2m (a(p)exp(ipx) + a(-p)exp(-ipx)) = 0. As a result, in a bound state, one considers kinetic energy per p, -p multiplied by the average probability (p, -p). Different a(p)exp(ipx) + a(-p)exp(-ipx) (a(p)=a(-p)) weights in this average picture indicate the extent to which the particle interacts. This idea holds for a single p,-p pair, but one must normalize over all such pairs, leading to the idea of a conditional probability. Given that hbar/p must be “created physically” in space so to speak, one must have interaction probability which creates this physical situation even in cos(px)+ i sin(px). This leads to the idea of interaction probability being 0, positive, but <1, or even negative and it is the interaction which allows one to consider conservation of energy with a potential V(x) in the first place. As a result, one cannot include a full pp/2m if there is negative, 0 or only particle interaction. Thus, pp/2m is multiplied by 2 a(p)cos(px) /W(x) for a(p)=a(-p).
In classical statistical mechanics, although one has averages of a system, a single particle within the system has properties which are sharply defined at any x,t, even though these properties change stochastically, i.e. through interactions. A quantum free particle, on the other hand, has information based on the Lorentz invariant -Et+px, multiplied by i to create periodicity which indicates an inherent information, not one based on the outcome of trial runs or interactions. The probability is exp(-iEt+ipx). If E and p are considered as constant, then there are independent probabilistic fluctuations in x and t, which means there may be corresponding probabilistic interactions, both impulse ones (one dimensional reflection/refraction, n-slits) and temporal ones (Rabi frequency). In such a case, one has interference and the form exp(ipx) or exp(-iEt) governing the statistics, not a maximization of entropy linked to interaction/outcome results. Nevertheless, the quantum particle interacts with fields, it seems, which give rise to p or E changes. It seems the key idea is that one has stochastic uncertainty before an interaction occurs and hence interference. The alternative is that such stochastic uncertainty does not exist before a specific interaction, i.e. the inherent probability exp(-iEt) or exp(ipx) has no effect on the interaction. This is not to say that there cannot be probabilities before the interaction. In a Maxwell-Boltzmann gas, there are probabilities P(e1) and P(e2) for particles with e1 and e2, but a specific e1 and e2 have no uncertainty. The uncertainty is in the outcome of the reaction. Another example is a two state electron in an atom which absorbs and emits photons. The rules for time evolution are that the ground state is represented by exp(-iEot), but at some stochastic t value, it changes to exp(-iE1t) and vice versa. The ground state absorbs a photon and the excited emits. The two states are clearly defined by the differing interactions which govern their time dependence which is taken to be simply the changing of Eo to E1 and vice versa. This problem is then based on probabilities based on outcomes of an interaction and maximization of entropy subject to a constraint is employed. There is no initial interference.