Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Testing the stability of the holographic area law in quantum circuits with different connectivity topologies: a reproducible protocol and numerical results

Artem Maslennikov

Published Jun 10, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

This work presents a numerical proof-of-concept for an algorithmic pipeline designed to test the stability of the holographic area law in quantum circuits with different connectivity topologies (chain and complete). METHODOLOGY:- Randomized measurements protocol (Elben et al., PRL 2018) for estimating Rényi-2 entropy- Weighted linear regression of S₂ vs classical cut area- Bootstrap error estimation (B=200 iterations, 95% confidence intervals)- Statistical validation of scaling stability via p-value analysis KEY RESULTS:- Chain topology (nearest-neighbor): G_eff = 0.50 ± 0.05- Complete topology (all-to-all): G_eff = 0.26 ± 0.02- Ratio G_eff^chain / G_eff^complete ≈ 1.95 ± 0.25- Scaling stability confirmed for both topologies (p > 0.83) IMPORTANT NOTE ON ZNE:Zero-noise extrapolation (ZNE) is implemented in the algorithmic pipeline but was intentionally NOT applied to this simulator dataset, as no hardware noise is present. This ensures that the reported uncertainties reflect only the statistical uncertainty of the randomized measurements protocol. The ZNE module will be activated in future experiments on real quantum hardware. FILES INCLUDED:- Grav_Article_ENG.pdf: Full article text (6 pages, 3 tables)- main.tex: LaTeX source code of the article- raw_dataset_chain.json: Complete raw measurement data for chain topology (30 subsystem-depth combinations)- raw_dataset_complete.json: Complete raw measurement data for complete topology (30 subsystem-depth combinations)- README.md: Documentation of data format and reproduction instructions LIMITATIONS:- System size: N=4 qubits- Fixed ansatz parameters (θ=π/4, γ=π/4)- Idealized simulator environment (no hardware noise) This study establishes a reproducible baseline protocol. Experimental validation on real quantum hardware is planned for a follow-up publication.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.20632020

Related papers

Numerical Stability and Scaling of a Z-Level Interference Pattern in Quantum Circuits (29–63 Qubits)

Simita Roland

This technical note documents the numerical stability of a two-peak (Z-level) interference pattern observed in a fixed 29-qubit quantum circuit. The analysis was performed using the Qiskit AerSimulator backend under controlled conditions, including variations in shot count and phase-parameter offsets. The results demonstrate that the observed interference structure is reproducible, robust against sampling fluctuations, and not dependent on fine-tuned parameter choices. This document does not present a theoretical proof or physical interpretation. Its sole purpose is to provide an empirical numerical reference for the stability and reproducibility of the observed interference pattern, serving as a supporting record for related theoretical and conceptual works by the author. In version v3, the numerical analysis is extended beyond 63 qubits up to 79 qubits by employing reduced statistical descriptors rather than full state-space representations. This extension demonstrates that the observed Z-level interference stability persists under scalable statistical evaluation, without requiring exponentially growing state-vector simulations. Additional clarification The reported “Z-level progress” refers to an internal, relative coverage metric within the author’s numerical stability framework. It is not a physical completeness measure, nor a claim of global optimality. Earlier high-percentage stability values (e.g. 95–98%) correspond to local robustness indicators such as sampling consistency, seed invariance, and phase-noise tolerance within fixed parameter windows. The lower percentage reported here reflects a stricter, global aggregation across multiple independent stability dimensions. This distinction is intentional and avoids conflating local robustness with global domain coverage. This work reports a numerical stability certificate for X–Z basis statistical divergence measures obtained in controlled simulations. A multiscale grid and zoom analysis identifies a non-trivial stable phase-offset interval (pj ∈ [0.038, 0.052]) in which total variation distance, Shannon entropy, and directed Kullback–Leibler divergences remain reproducible under changes in sampling depth, random seed, and numerical resolution. A persistent directional asymmetry between KL_XZ and KL_ZX is numerically observed across all tested scales. This document reports numerical results only and does not claim physical realization, theoretical proof, or universal validity. Interpretational note: The absence of a direct Lorentz-covariant or gauge-field embedding should not be interpreted as a deficiency of the numerical results, but as a limitation of applying classical spacetime questions to an emergent, resonance-based stability structure. The reported Z-level behavior constrains the space of viable physical interpretations rather than completing one.

•Dec 16, 2025•0 citations

Six Quantum Hardware Protocols Testing Boundary Signatures of the ER=EPR Conjecture on IBM Marrakesh

Horacio Sebastian Caceres

Six quantum circuit experiments performed on ibm_marrakesh (IBM Quantum, 156 qubits, Heron R2 architecture) are reported, designed to test boundary signatures of the ER=EPR conjecture within the AdS₂/JT gravity framework, with the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model as the holographic dual of the black hole horizon. The experiments were executed iteratively: each result raised new questions that directly motivated the next protocol. In order of execution they implement: tripartite entanglement certification via the Mermin operator (|⟨M⟩| = 3.885); a traversable wormhole baseline using a Bell-pair thermofield double (F(g=π/2) = 1.000); black hole evaporation unitarity via the Hayden-Preskill protocol (F_rec = 0.9983, with the decoder reduced to zero two-qubit gates by the compiler); a corrected traversable wormhole using genuine SYK scrambling and exact Majorana coupling (F(g=0) = 0.020, F(g=π/2) = 0.953, GJW gain = 0.933); quantum chaos via out-of-time-order correlators (λ_L = 1.975 ± 0.294, 54.8% of the Maldacena-Shenker-Stanford bound); and black hole entropy under information absorption, where the hardware reproduces the entropy growth S(t) of SYK formation on top of a noise floor and the energy response to Alice’s input (correlation 0.998 with simulation), while the predicted area growth consistent with the Bekenstein law is obtained in simulation but is not resolved above noise on hardware. Total QPU time across all experiments: 7 minutes 2 seconds. Five of the six experiments reproduce the boundary predictions of the ER=EPR framework on hardware; the sixth reproduces them in simulation and only partially on hardware. Version 3 corrects Experiments 2 and 3 following the original laboratory reports. Exp. 2 reports the raw F(g=π/2) = 1.01 ± 0.01 instead of the clipped 1.000. In Exp. 3 the fused U†U circuit is identity by construction; its fidelity (0.9983) is reported as a noise-floor control, not as hardware recovery. The hardware scrambling result (F_scr = 0.530 vs. 0.532 in simulation) is kept; recovery is demonstrated in simulation. Experiments 2b, 5 and 6 are unchanged. Code and data: https://github.com/horca17/er-epr-six-protocols

•Jun 5, 2026•0 citations

Fractal Quantum Holographic Paradigm - Rényi Entanglement Entropy Scaling in Graph States

Pavel Trojan

Attention: This version is preliminary and contains errors that will be corrected in subsequent publications. Within the FKGP (Fractal Quantum Holographic Paradigm) framework we propose and experimentally verify a scaling law for the second-order Rényi entanglement entropy S2(A) in graph states of varying topological dimension D. The key result is S2(A) = rank_GF2(Gamma) · ln 2, where the GF(2)-rank of the A-B boundary adjacency matrix increases by exactly one at each step of the dimensional ladder. On IBM Heron r2 (ibm_fez) with 65,536 shots per circuit, four steps are confirmed: D=2.00 (ΔSNR=76.9σ), D1=2.05 (34.3σ), D2=e (7.8σ), and D=3 (5.1σ). All detections exceed the 5σ threshold. Cosmological hypotheses are advanced: D1 = 2 + Ω_b (baryon fraction) and D2 = e (informational efficiency). This paper includes a complete reproducibility appendix (Batches 1–10): all QASM circuits, measured P₀ values, noise corrections, and ΔSNR calculations.

•Jun 15, 2026•0 citations

Power-Law Holographic Forces and Causal Transport in MERA Quantum Circuits

Jon Cackler

CORRECTION NOTICE (v5, 2026-09-06). The central result of v1-v4 is WITHDRAWN. This record has not been peer reviewed. Issued 2026-09-06 by the author (v5 of this record). This notice was added to the archived record; the manuscript itself is unaltered. This record has not been peer reviewed. What is wrong The force exponent reported here as alpha = 3.92 +/- 0.16 is an artifact of the fitting procedure, not a property of the data. The fit was unweighted least squares in linear space applied to a steeply falling profile, which places 95.8 percent of its objective on the single point at the shortest retained separation. Re-fitting the same data with nothing discarded, changing only the error model, gives 2.82 (relative-error weighting) or 2.89 (log-space regression). Across fifteen combinations of standard estimator and fit window the exponent spans 2.53 to 3.92, and the value published here is the largest of them. What the data show instead, and how firmly The retraction is certain. The replacement is not. On the open 24-site chain the same data give alpha = 2.6 +/- 0.2, where the interval is the spread of a plateau in the local logarithmic slope over six consecutive separations, not a statistical error (the bootstrap error on the published fit to the same data is 0.63); the plateau value was reproduced at 2.5921 by a separately written implementation run on the same recorded state (SIM-2026-073). This is a single geometry at a single size. On a 24-site periodic ring, analysed with chord distance as pre-registered, two probes that are both energy-density-like (Delta = 1) give 1.83 and 2.37 against a CFT two-point value of 2 (SIM-2026-074): one size, not converged, disagreeing with each other by 29 percent, and not attributable to a single operator channel. No corrected exponent is established. The exchange channel is an open question. Treat 2.6 +/- 0.2 as the provisional open-chain value, not as a result. Also withdrawn or voided alpha = 3.92 +/- 0.16 (24 sites) and alpha = 3.97 +/- 0.15 (16 sites, exact) from stress-tensor exchange. Was: headline result and its first corroboration. Now: withdrawn. Why: the same estimator artifact: both move in lockstep under it (3.92 to 2.56, 3.97 to 2.75 on dropping the contact point), because they share one observable, one fit window and one fitting routine. scalar exchange (alpha = 2) excluded. Was: stated as excluded at about 12 sigma. Now: withdrawn. Why: the 12 sigma used the covariance error 0.16; at the bootstrap error 0.63 computed before release the exclusion is about 2.2 sigma, and under any window starting at separation 3 the point estimate itself falls to about 2.56. alpha = 4 is universal; alpha = 4.00 at Ising, tricritical Ising and Potts. Was: confirmed at three classes. Now: withdrawn; the operator towers at all three classes stand. Why: the exponent was measured only at Ising and inherited by the other two; the towers are spectra, not forces. third independent evaluation alpha = 4.07 (chi = 3 MERA), and with it the statement that this was the first holographic force measurement from an optimized tensor network state. Was: supporting evidence and a priority claim. Now: both withdrawn. Why: the profile changes sign inside its own fit window and cannot be a fixed-sign power law; the priority claim rests on that evaluation alone and was never gated against prior work. the discriminating test: stress tensor (Z_j Z_j+1) versus spin primary (X_j). Was: registered killer test. Now: void. Why: at the critical point these are one operator, related by exact Kramers-Wannier self-duality. Measured on the periodic ring: identical expectation values to 1e-15 and identical force profiles to 1e-13 at 14 sites, 2.4e-9 at 24 sites (SIM-2026-074). Open boundaries break the duality, which is why the open-chain run of this test (SIM-2026-073) showed a spurious difference between the two arms. The test compared the energy density to itself. Neither label was correct: Z_j Z_j+1 is the energy density, not the stress tensor; X_j is its dual, not the spin primary. transport time T = (pi/2) l_AdS to 1.2 percent as a geometric prediction. Was: confirmed. Now: measurement stands (T = 2.239 at N = 16); geometric reading not established. Why: l_AdS cancels in the cited derivation, which also gives pi rather than the pi/2 the manuscript compares against; the chi = 3 estimate of l_AdS gives a 57 percent miss; the transport driver never applies a MERA. The true spin primary Z_j was never in the design, and the direct replacement test is blocked: Z_j is odd under the Z2 symmetry, so the energy-difference observable used throughout this work subtracts across symmetry sectors and is undefined for it. A replacement test using two Z2-even probes has been pre-registered (PREREGISTRATION-T.md, committed before its driver) and run; its result is deliberately not part of this correction and will appear in a later version. Not previously reported The published fit has a reduced chi-squared of 6.008 on 9 degrees of freedom, and a bootstrap standard deviation of 0.63 rather than the quoted 0.16. Both were computed before release and omitted. What is unaffected Of the claims in this record: the two-phase optimization method, the chi = 3 criticality threshold, the exact-diagonalization gates, the measured OPE coefficient C_sigma-sigma-epsilon = 0.50 +/- 0.03 against the exact 1/2, and the conformal towers at all three classes. Not part of this record, mentioned only because they are sometimes read together with it: the later C_TTT stress-tensor self-coupling measurements (SIM-2026-067/068/069, dated after this record) and the matched off-critical ring control (SIM-2026-074) are unaffected by this correction and make no claim about the force exponent. How the error was found and what this record contains The error was found by the author's own internal adversarial audit, not by a reviewer; the journal submission it was found after is closed, and no review of this work has taken place. Files in this record: the full re-analysis (SIM-2026-072.json, driver, figure), the pre-registered chain test (SIM-2026-073.json) and ring test (SIM-2026-074.json) with both pre-registrations as committed before the runs, the runnable drivers with their shared module and the negative test suite for their validation gates, and the error register (ERRATA.md). Concept DOI 10.5281/zenodo.19660302 always resolves to the current version. The abstract of the original manuscript follows unchanged, for the record. Every claim in it about the force exponent should be read against the correction above. We report results from classical simulation of critical spin chains that establish quantitative physical content in the MERA-AdS correspondence. First, the interaction energy between boundary-primary excitations follows a power law F(dr) ~ dr^(-alpha) with three consistent evaluations yielding alpha = 3.92 +/- 0.16 (24q), 3.97 +/- 0.15 (16q), and 4.07 +/- 0.18 (16q chi=3 MERA), all consistent with stress-tensor exchange (alpha = 2*Delta_T = 4) and inconsistent with scalar exchange (alpha = 2); the exponent is explained by the Ising CFT fusion rule eps x eps = [1]. Because Delta_T = 2 is fixed by conformal symmetry in every unitary 2D CFT, alpha = 4 is universal: we confirm this at two further fixed points - the tricritical Ising model (c = 7/10), where a scale-invariant MERA recovers the full M(4,5) primary spectrum (Delta_sigma = 0.092, Delta_eps = 0.204, Delta_T = 1.999), and the three-state Potts model (c = 4/5), where a Z3-symmetric MERA at chi = 12 recovers Delta_sigma = 0.134, Delta_eps = 0.805, Delta_T = 2.001 - giving alpha = 4.00 at all three universality classes. Second, the holographic transport time matches the AdS_3 null geodesic prediction T = (pi/2) l_AdS to 1.2% at N = 16 sites on a time-grid-converged measurement, with the residual shrinking from 2.8% at N = 12. Third, we introduce a two-phase optimization method (ALM + Z2 projection) for Z2-symmetric MERA ground states at 24 qubits. Fourth, extending the MERA bond dimension from chi=2 to chi=3 overcomes the expressibility barrier, achieving 0.15% energy error at 16 qubits and enabling the first holographic force measurement from an optimized tensor network state. The OPE coefficient is also measured directly from the fixed-point tensors: C_sigma-sigma-eps = 0.50 +/- 0.03 against the exact Ising value 1/2. A hardware path is designed for Quantinuum Helios (57 CNOTs, 0.57% logical error). Version 4 changes (relative to v3): Transport: N=16 residual restated as the time-grid-converged value of -1.21% (dt = 1e-3), with -2.78% at N=12 showing the finite-size trend; the 0.72% figure in v3 was an artifact of the dt = 0.05 integration grid and is now labeled as such. The N=24 transport point carries a new reliability caveat (double-lobe trace structure). The l_AdS comparison table is recomputed against the converged transport time (best fit 1.425, deviation 1.21%). Effective-mass derivation rewritten in a consistent AdS3 convention m^2 l^2 = Delta(Delta-2); m_eff = 0.693 = 1/l_AdS follows from Delta = 1 exactly. NEW: universality section extended to a third fixed point - a Z3-symmetric MERA at chi = 12 recovers the three-state Potts (c = 4/5) tower, giving alpha = 4.00 at all three universality classes (c = 1/2, 7/10, 4/5). NEW: the OPE coefficient C_sigma-sigma-eps = 0.50 +/- 0.03 measured directly from the fixed-point tensors, with C_sigma-sigma-sigma = 0 at machine precision as the Z2 structural check. Supplemental table row SIM-007 annotated (record lost; script preserved); data availability expanded; Zenodo DOI added to the front matter.

•Apr 20, 2026•1 citation

Exact Entanglement Entropy and Code Distance for Stabilizer States, Computed Without Floating-Point Arithmetic

Joel Cruz Cabrera

Standard quantum circuit simulation represents amplitudes as double-precision complex numbers, so quantities such as entanglement entropy are computed only approximately. We revisit two well-known facts about the stabilizer formalism — that entanglement entropy of a stabilizer state is always an integer, and that the distance of a stabilizer code is a combinatorial quantity — and implement both exactly, using binary linear algebra over F2 on the stabilizer tableau, with no floating-point step anywhere in the computation. We verify the entropy formula against Qiskit's floating-point von Neumann entropy on canonical states and on 30 random Clifford circuits (all matches exact), reproduce the area-law entanglement of the 1D cluster state, and verify the code-distance procedure against three canonical quantum error-correcting codes (Steane, the 5-qubit code, and Shor's code), recovering their published distances exactly. As an illustration of the exact toolkit in use, we report an empirical scaling law for the depth at which entanglement saturates in a specific random-circuit model. Finally, since every result above concerns exact mathematics or exact simulation of noiseless Clifford circuits, we complement it with a small, honestly-labelled real-hardware comparison: the GHZ state on 3–7 qubits, run on IBM Quantum superconducting hardware, measured against the exact noiseless prediction our formalism computes, together with a quantitative check against a naive noise model built from the device's own published calibration data — which the data systematically contradicts by 18–21 percentage points, a discrepancy we report along with our best physical explanation for it. A second, independent hardware experiment measures the cluster state's own stabilizer generators directly, and identifies a single miscalibrated physical qubit as correlated with elevated error; a follow-up control experiment, forcing the circuit onto verified low-error qubits instead, confirms the effect is causal but partial (leakage drops by 1.84 percentage points, roughly a third of the excess) rather than the whole explanation, which we report at its true, unexaggerated size. Applying the naive noise model to the control circuit itself reverses its bias (now optimistic rather than pessimistic) by an amount consistent, to order of magnitude, with ordinary decoherence over the circuit's execution time — a physical effect the naive model was never built to capture.

•Jul 27, 2026•0 citations

Capturing the Universality Class of the 2D Ising Model via Symmetry-Corrected Machine Learning and Finite-Size Scaling

Ali Tozar

Replication Data and Code for: "Capturing the Universality Class of the 2D Ising Model via Symmetry-Corrected Machine Learning and Finite-Size Scaling" This repository contains the complete source code, simulation datasets, and analysis scripts required to reproduce all findings presented in the associated manuscript. The study introduces a symmetry-corrected machine learning pipeline (Gauge-Fixed PCA + Logistic Regression) to identify phase transitions and estimate critical temperatures with high precision, validated on the two-dimensional Ising model. Repository Contents: 01_generate_data.py — Generates 2D Ising model spin configurations using the Wolff cluster algorithm. Produces equilibrium datasets for lattice sizes L∈{32,48,64,96}L \in \{32, 48, 64, 96\} L∈{32,48,64,96} with 10,000 independent configurations per temperature point. 02_analysis_pipeline_v2.py — Core analysis script: performs gauge fixing (σ′=σ⋅sgn(m)\sigma' = \sigma \cdot \mathrm{sgn}(m) σ′=σ⋅sgn(m)), PCA dimensionality reduction (d=16d = 16 d=16, cross-validated), confusion-scheme classification with parabolic sub-grid interpolation, bootstrap uncertainty quantification (Nboot=50N_{\rm boot} = 50 Nboot=50), and pFMp_{\rm FM} pFM computation with isotonic calibration. Outputs summary_ml_v2.json. 03_plot_main_figures.py — Reproduces Figures 1–6 of the main manuscript. 04_plot_supplementary_v2.py — Reproduces Supplementary Figures S1–S5 and Table 1. ablation_preprocessing_S5.py — Standalone preprocessing ablation script: runs raw and ∣m∣|m| ∣m∣-only comparisons and generates Supplementary Figure S5. Does not modify main results. summary_ml_v2.json — Pre-computed results (gauge-fixed pipeline) for immediate reproduction of all main figures without re-running Monte Carlo simulations. summary_ml_v2_raw.json — Pre-computed ablation results: raw (no gauge fixing) preprocessing, L∈{32,64,96}L \in \{32, 64, 96\} L∈{32,64,96}. summary_ml_v2_absm.json — Pre-computed ablation results: ∣m∣|m| ∣m∣-only preprocessing, L∈{32,64,96}L \in \{32, 64, 96\} L∈{32,64,96}. Table1_Tc_Comparison.tex — LaTeX source for Table 1. requirements.txt — Python dependencies. README.txt — Step-by-step reproduction instructions. Methodology Highlights: System sizes: L∈{32,48,64,96}L \in \{32, 48, 64, 96\} L∈{32,48,64,96} 10,000 independent configurations per temperature point; Wolff cluster algorithm with 10410^4 104 thermalization steps Symmetry correction: global Z2\mathbb{Z}_2 Z2 gauge fixing prior to PCA Confusion scheme: validation cross-entropy minimization over T0∈[2.10,2.45]T_0 \in [2.10, 2.45] T0∈[2.10,2.45] (60 candidate values, band Δ=0.05\Delta = 0.05 Δ=0.05, 5-fold CV) Bootstrap: 50 configuration-level resamples; parabolic sub-grid interpolation for discretization bias reduction Key result: Tc≈2.2717(8)T_c \approx 2.2717(8) Tc≈2.2717(8) for L=96L = 96 L=96 (0.6%0.6\% 0.6% from Onsager); universality class confirmed via FSS data collapse with ν=1\nu = 1 ν=1

•Jan 1, 2026•1 citation
This work presents a numerical proof-of-concept for an algorithmic pipeline designed to test the stability of the holographic area law in quantum circuits with different connectivity topologies (chain and complete). METHODOLOGY:- Randomized measurements protocol (Elben et al., PRL 2018) for estimating Rényi-2 entropy- Weighted linear regression of S₂ vs classical cut area- Bootstrap error estimation (B=200 iterations, 95% confidence intervals)- Statistical validation of scaling stability via p-value analysis KEY RESULTS:- Chain topology (nearest-neighbor): G_eff = 0.50 ± 0.05- Complete topology (all-to-all): G_eff = 0.26 ± 0.02- Ratio G_eff^chain / G_eff^complete ≈ 1.95 ± 0.25- Scaling stability confirmed for both topologies (p > 0.83) IMPORTANT NOTE ON ZNE:Zero-noise extrapolation (ZNE) is implemented in the algorithmic pipeline but was intentionally NOT applied to this simulator dataset, as no hardware noise is present. This ensures that the reported uncertainties reflect only the statistical uncertainty of the randomized measurements protocol. The ZNE module will be activated in future experiments on real quantum hardware. FILES INCLUDED:- Grav_Article_ENG.pdf: Full article text (6 pages, 3 tables)- main.tex: LaTeX source code of the article- raw_dataset_chain.json: Complete raw measurement data for chain topology (30 subsystem-depth combinations)- raw_dataset_complete.json: Complete raw measurement data for complete topology (30 subsystem-depth combinations)- README.md: Documentation of data format and reproduction instructions LIMITATIONS:- System size: N=4 qubits- Fixed ansatz parameters (θ=π/4, γ=π/4)- Idealized simulator environment (no hardware noise) This study establishes a reproducible baseline protocol. Experimental validation on real quantum hardware is planned for a follow-up publication.
This technical note documents the numerical stability of a two-peak (Z-level) interference pattern observed in a fixed 29-qubit quantum circuit. The analysis was performed using the Qiskit AerSimulator backend under controlled conditions, including variations in shot count and phase-parameter offsets. The results demonstrate that the observed interference structure is reproducible, robust against sampling fluctuations, and not dependent on fine-tuned parameter choices. This document does not present a theoretical proof or physical interpretation. Its sole purpose is to provide an empirical numerical reference for the stability and reproducibility of the observed interference pattern, serving as a supporting record for related theoretical and conceptual works by the author. In version v3, the numerical analysis is extended beyond 63 qubits up to 79 qubits by employing reduced statistical descriptors rather than full state-space representations. This extension demonstrates that the observed Z-level interference stability persists under scalable statistical evaluation, without requiring exponentially growing state-vector simulations. Additional clarification The reported “Z-level progress” refers to an internal, relative coverage metric within the author’s numerical stability framework. It is not a physical completeness measure, nor a claim of global optimality. Earlier high-percentage stability values (e.g. 95–98%) correspond to local robustness indicators such as sampling consistency, seed invariance, and phase-noise tolerance within fixed parameter windows. The lower percentage reported here reflects a stricter, global aggregation across multiple independent stability dimensions. This distinction is intentional and avoids conflating local robustness with global domain coverage. This work reports a numerical stability certificate for X–Z basis statistical divergence measures obtained in controlled simulations. A multiscale grid and zoom analysis identifies a non-trivial stable phase-offset interval (pj ∈ [0.038, 0.052]) in which total variation distance, Shannon entropy, and directed Kullback–Leibler divergences remain reproducible under changes in sampling depth, random seed, and numerical resolution. A persistent directional asymmetry between KL_XZ and KL_ZX is numerically observed across all tested scales. This document reports numerical results only and does not claim physical realization, theoretical proof, or universal validity. Interpretational note: The absence of a direct Lorentz-covariant or gauge-field embedding should not be interpreted as a deficiency of the numerical results, but as a limitation of applying classical spacetime questions to an emergent, resonance-based stability structure. The reported Z-level behavior constrains the space of viable physical interpretations rather than completing one.
Six quantum circuit experiments performed on ibm_marrakesh (IBM Quantum, 156 qubits, Heron R2 architecture) are reported, designed to test boundary signatures of the ER=EPR conjecture within the AdS₂/JT gravity framework, with the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model as the holographic dual of the black hole horizon. The experiments were executed iteratively: each result raised new questions that directly motivated the next protocol. In order of execution they implement: tripartite entanglement certification via the Mermin operator (|⟨M⟩| = 3.885); a traversable wormhole baseline using a Bell-pair thermofield double (F(g=π/2) = 1.000); black hole evaporation unitarity via the Hayden-Preskill protocol (F_rec = 0.9983, with the decoder reduced to zero two-qubit gates by the compiler); a corrected traversable wormhole using genuine SYK scrambling and exact Majorana coupling (F(g=0) = 0.020, F(g=π/2) = 0.953, GJW gain = 0.933); quantum chaos via out-of-time-order correlators (λ_L = 1.975 ± 0.294, 54.8% of the Maldacena-Shenker-Stanford bound); and black hole entropy under information absorption, where the hardware reproduces the entropy growth S(t) of SYK formation on top of a noise floor and the energy response to Alice’s input (correlation 0.998 with simulation), while the predicted area growth consistent with the Bekenstein law is obtained in simulation but is not resolved above noise on hardware. Total QPU time across all experiments: 7 minutes 2 seconds. Five of the six experiments reproduce the boundary predictions of the ER=EPR framework on hardware; the sixth reproduces them in simulation and only partially on hardware. Version 3 corrects Experiments 2 and 3 following the original laboratory reports. Exp. 2 reports the raw F(g=π/2) = 1.01 ± 0.01 instead of the clipped 1.000. In Exp. 3 the fused U†U circuit is identity by construction; its fidelity (0.9983) is reported as a noise-floor control, not as hardware recovery. The hardware scrambling result (F_scr = 0.530 vs. 0.532 in simulation) is kept; recovery is demonstrated in simulation. Experiments 2b, 5 and 6 are unchanged. Code and data: https://github.com/horca17/er-epr-six-protocols
Attention: This version is preliminary and contains errors that will be corrected in subsequent publications. Within the FKGP (Fractal Quantum Holographic Paradigm) framework we propose and experimentally verify a scaling law for the second-order Rényi entanglement entropy S2(A) in graph states of varying topological dimension D. The key result is S2(A) = rank_GF2(Gamma) · ln 2, where the GF(2)-rank of the A-B boundary adjacency matrix increases by exactly one at each step of the dimensional ladder. On IBM Heron r2 (ibm_fez) with 65,536 shots per circuit, four steps are confirmed: D=2.00 (ΔSNR=76.9σ), D1=2.05 (34.3σ), D2=e (7.8σ), and D=3 (5.1σ). All detections exceed the 5σ threshold. Cosmological hypotheses are advanced: D1 = 2 + Ω_b (baryon fraction) and D2 = e (informational efficiency). This paper includes a complete reproducibility appendix (Batches 1–10): all QASM circuits, measured P₀ values, noise corrections, and ΔSNR calculations.
CORRECTION NOTICE (v5, 2026-09-06). The central result of v1-v4 is WITHDRAWN. This record has not been peer reviewed. Issued 2026-09-06 by the author (v5 of this record). This notice was added to the archived record; the manuscript itself is unaltered. This record has not been peer reviewed. What is wrong The force exponent reported here as alpha = 3.92 +/- 0.16 is an artifact of the fitting procedure, not a property of the data. The fit was unweighted least squares in linear space applied to a steeply falling profile, which places 95.8 percent of its objective on the single point at the shortest retained separation. Re-fitting the same data with nothing discarded, changing only the error model, gives 2.82 (relative-error weighting) or 2.89 (log-space regression). Across fifteen combinations of standard estimator and fit window the exponent spans 2.53 to 3.92, and the value published here is the largest of them. What the data show instead, and how firmly The retraction is certain. The replacement is not. On the open 24-site chain the same data give alpha = 2.6 +/- 0.2, where the interval is the spread of a plateau in the local logarithmic slope over six consecutive separations, not a statistical error (the bootstrap error on the published fit to the same data is 0.63); the plateau value was reproduced at 2.5921 by a separately written implementation run on the same recorded state (SIM-2026-073). This is a single geometry at a single size. On a 24-site periodic ring, analysed with chord distance as pre-registered, two probes that are both energy-density-like (Delta = 1) give 1.83 and 2.37 against a CFT two-point value of 2 (SIM-2026-074): one size, not converged, disagreeing with each other by 29 percent, and not attributable to a single operator channel. No corrected exponent is established. The exchange channel is an open question. Treat 2.6 +/- 0.2 as the provisional open-chain value, not as a result. Also withdrawn or voided alpha = 3.92 +/- 0.16 (24 sites) and alpha = 3.97 +/- 0.15 (16 sites, exact) from stress-tensor exchange. Was: headline result and its first corroboration. Now: withdrawn. Why: the same estimator artifact: both move in lockstep under it (3.92 to 2.56, 3.97 to 2.75 on dropping the contact point), because they share one observable, one fit window and one fitting routine. scalar exchange (alpha = 2) excluded. Was: stated as excluded at about 12 sigma. Now: withdrawn. Why: the 12 sigma used the covariance error 0.16; at the bootstrap error 0.63 computed before release the exclusion is about 2.2 sigma, and under any window starting at separation 3 the point estimate itself falls to about 2.56. alpha = 4 is universal; alpha = 4.00 at Ising, tricritical Ising and Potts. Was: confirmed at three classes. Now: withdrawn; the operator towers at all three classes stand. Why: the exponent was measured only at Ising and inherited by the other two; the towers are spectra, not forces. third independent evaluation alpha = 4.07 (chi = 3 MERA), and with it the statement that this was the first holographic force measurement from an optimized tensor network state. Was: supporting evidence and a priority claim. Now: both withdrawn. Why: the profile changes sign inside its own fit window and cannot be a fixed-sign power law; the priority claim rests on that evaluation alone and was never gated against prior work. the discriminating test: stress tensor (Z_j Z_j+1) versus spin primary (X_j). Was: registered killer test. Now: void. Why: at the critical point these are one operator, related by exact Kramers-Wannier self-duality. Measured on the periodic ring: identical expectation values to 1e-15 and identical force profiles to 1e-13 at 14 sites, 2.4e-9 at 24 sites (SIM-2026-074). Open boundaries break the duality, which is why the open-chain run of this test (SIM-2026-073) showed a spurious difference between the two arms. The test compared the energy density to itself. Neither label was correct: Z_j Z_j+1 is the energy density, not the stress tensor; X_j is its dual, not the spin primary. transport time T = (pi/2) l_AdS to 1.2 percent as a geometric prediction. Was: confirmed. Now: measurement stands (T = 2.239 at N = 16); geometric reading not established. Why: l_AdS cancels in the cited derivation, which also gives pi rather than the pi/2 the manuscript compares against; the chi = 3 estimate of l_AdS gives a 57 percent miss; the transport driver never applies a MERA. The true spin primary Z_j was never in the design, and the direct replacement test is blocked: Z_j is odd under the Z2 symmetry, so the energy-difference observable used throughout this work subtracts across symmetry sectors and is undefined for it. A replacement test using two Z2-even probes has been pre-registered (PREREGISTRATION-T.md, committed before its driver) and run; its result is deliberately not part of this correction and will appear in a later version. Not previously reported The published fit has a reduced chi-squared of 6.008 on 9 degrees of freedom, and a bootstrap standard deviation of 0.63 rather than the quoted 0.16. Both were computed before release and omitted. What is unaffected Of the claims in this record: the two-phase optimization method, the chi = 3 criticality threshold, the exact-diagonalization gates, the measured OPE coefficient C_sigma-sigma-epsilon = 0.50 +/- 0.03 against the exact 1/2, and the conformal towers at all three classes. Not part of this record, mentioned only because they are sometimes read together with it: the later C_TTT stress-tensor self-coupling measurements (SIM-2026-067/068/069, dated after this record) and the matched off-critical ring control (SIM-2026-074) are unaffected by this correction and make no claim about the force exponent. How the error was found and what this record contains The error was found by the author's own internal adversarial audit, not by a reviewer; the journal submission it was found after is closed, and no review of this work has taken place. Files in this record: the full re-analysis (SIM-2026-072.json, driver, figure), the pre-registered chain test (SIM-2026-073.json) and ring test (SIM-2026-074.json) with both pre-registrations as committed before the runs, the runnable drivers with their shared module and the negative test suite for their validation gates, and the error register (ERRATA.md). Concept DOI 10.5281/zenodo.19660302 always resolves to the current version. The abstract of the original manuscript follows unchanged, for the record. Every claim in it about the force exponent should be read against the correction above. We report results from classical simulation of critical spin chains that establish quantitative physical content in the MERA-AdS correspondence. First, the interaction energy between boundary-primary excitations follows a power law F(dr) ~ dr^(-alpha) with three consistent evaluations yielding alpha = 3.92 +/- 0.16 (24q), 3.97 +/- 0.15 (16q), and 4.07 +/- 0.18 (16q chi=3 MERA), all consistent with stress-tensor exchange (alpha = 2*Delta_T = 4) and inconsistent with scalar exchange (alpha = 2); the exponent is explained by the Ising CFT fusion rule eps x eps = [1]. Because Delta_T = 2 is fixed by conformal symmetry in every unitary 2D CFT, alpha = 4 is universal: we confirm this at two further fixed points - the tricritical Ising model (c = 7/10), where a scale-invariant MERA recovers the full M(4,5) primary spectrum (Delta_sigma = 0.092, Delta_eps = 0.204, Delta_T = 1.999), and the three-state Potts model (c = 4/5), where a Z3-symmetric MERA at chi = 12 recovers Delta_sigma = 0.134, Delta_eps = 0.805, Delta_T = 2.001 - giving alpha = 4.00 at all three universality classes. Second, the holographic transport time matches the AdS_3 null geodesic prediction T = (pi/2) l_AdS to 1.2% at N = 16 sites on a time-grid-converged measurement, with the residual shrinking from 2.8% at N = 12. Third, we introduce a two-phase optimization method (ALM + Z2 projection) for Z2-symmetric MERA ground states at 24 qubits. Fourth, extending the MERA bond dimension from chi=2 to chi=3 overcomes the expressibility barrier, achieving 0.15% energy error at 16 qubits and enabling the first holographic force measurement from an optimized tensor network state. The OPE coefficient is also measured directly from the fixed-point tensors: C_sigma-sigma-eps = 0.50 +/- 0.03 against the exact Ising value 1/2. A hardware path is designed for Quantinuum Helios (57 CNOTs, 0.57% logical error). Version 4 changes (relative to v3): Transport: N=16 residual restated as the time-grid-converged value of -1.21% (dt = 1e-3), with -2.78% at N=12 showing the finite-size trend; the 0.72% figure in v3 was an artifact of the dt = 0.05 integration grid and is now labeled as such. The N=24 transport point carries a new reliability caveat (double-lobe trace structure). The l_AdS comparison table is recomputed against the converged transport time (best fit 1.425, deviation 1.21%). Effective-mass derivation rewritten in a consistent AdS3 convention m^2 l^2 = Delta(Delta-2); m_eff = 0.693 = 1/l_AdS follows from Delta = 1 exactly. NEW: universality section extended to a third fixed point - a Z3-symmetric MERA at chi = 12 recovers the three-state Potts (c = 4/5) tower, giving alpha = 4.00 at all three universality classes (c = 1/2, 7/10, 4/5). NEW: the OPE coefficient C_sigma-sigma-eps = 0.50 +/- 0.03 measured directly from the fixed-point tensors, with C_sigma-sigma-sigma = 0 at machine precision as the Z2 structural check. Supplemental table row SIM-007 annotated (record lost; script preserved); data availability expanded; Zenodo DOI added to the front matter.
Standard quantum circuit simulation represents amplitudes as double-precision complex numbers, so quantities such as entanglement entropy are computed only approximately. We revisit two well-known facts about the stabilizer formalism — that entanglement entropy of a stabilizer state is always an integer, and that the distance of a stabilizer code is a combinatorial quantity — and implement both exactly, using binary linear algebra over F2 on the stabilizer tableau, with no floating-point step anywhere in the computation. We verify the entropy formula against Qiskit's floating-point von Neumann entropy on canonical states and on 30 random Clifford circuits (all matches exact), reproduce the area-law entanglement of the 1D cluster state, and verify the code-distance procedure against three canonical quantum error-correcting codes (Steane, the 5-qubit code, and Shor's code), recovering their published distances exactly. As an illustration of the exact toolkit in use, we report an empirical scaling law for the depth at which entanglement saturates in a specific random-circuit model. Finally, since every result above concerns exact mathematics or exact simulation of noiseless Clifford circuits, we complement it with a small, honestly-labelled real-hardware comparison: the GHZ state on 3–7 qubits, run on IBM Quantum superconducting hardware, measured against the exact noiseless prediction our formalism computes, together with a quantitative check against a naive noise model built from the device's own published calibration data — which the data systematically contradicts by 18–21 percentage points, a discrepancy we report along with our best physical explanation for it. A second, independent hardware experiment measures the cluster state's own stabilizer generators directly, and identifies a single miscalibrated physical qubit as correlated with elevated error; a follow-up control experiment, forcing the circuit onto verified low-error qubits instead, confirms the effect is causal but partial (leakage drops by 1.84 percentage points, roughly a third of the excess) rather than the whole explanation, which we report at its true, unexaggerated size. Applying the naive noise model to the control circuit itself reverses its bias (now optimistic rather than pessimistic) by an amount consistent, to order of magnitude, with ordinary decoherence over the circuit's execution time — a physical effect the naive model was never built to capture.
Replication Data and Code for: "Capturing the Universality Class of the 2D Ising Model via Symmetry-Corrected Machine Learning and Finite-Size Scaling" This repository contains the complete source code, simulation datasets, and analysis scripts required to reproduce all findings presented in the associated manuscript. The study introduces a symmetry-corrected machine learning pipeline (Gauge-Fixed PCA + Logistic Regression) to identify phase transitions and estimate critical temperatures with high precision, validated on the two-dimensional Ising model. Repository Contents: 01_generate_data.py — Generates 2D Ising model spin configurations using the Wolff cluster algorithm. Produces equilibrium datasets for lattice sizes L∈{32,48,64,96}L \in \{32, 48, 64, 96\} L∈{32,48,64,96} with 10,000 independent configurations per temperature point. 02_analysis_pipeline_v2.py — Core analysis script: performs gauge fixing (σ′=σ⋅sgn(m)\sigma' = \sigma \cdot \mathrm{sgn}(m) σ′=σ⋅sgn(m)), PCA dimensionality reduction (d=16d = 16 d=16, cross-validated), confusion-scheme classification with parabolic sub-grid interpolation, bootstrap uncertainty quantification (Nboot=50N_{\rm boot} = 50 Nboot=50), and pFMp_{\rm FM} pFM computation with isotonic calibration. Outputs summary_ml_v2.json. 03_plot_main_figures.py — Reproduces Figures 1–6 of the main manuscript. 04_plot_supplementary_v2.py — Reproduces Supplementary Figures S1–S5 and Table 1. ablation_preprocessing_S5.py — Standalone preprocessing ablation script: runs raw and ∣m∣|m| ∣m∣-only comparisons and generates Supplementary Figure S5. Does not modify main results. summary_ml_v2.json — Pre-computed results (gauge-fixed pipeline) for immediate reproduction of all main figures without re-running Monte Carlo simulations. summary_ml_v2_raw.json — Pre-computed ablation results: raw (no gauge fixing) preprocessing, L∈{32,64,96}L \in \{32, 64, 96\} L∈{32,64,96}. summary_ml_v2_absm.json — Pre-computed ablation results: ∣m∣|m| ∣m∣-only preprocessing, L∈{32,64,96}L \in \{32, 64, 96\} L∈{32,64,96}. Table1_Tc_Comparison.tex — LaTeX source for Table 1. requirements.txt — Python dependencies. README.txt — Step-by-step reproduction instructions. Methodology Highlights: System sizes: L∈{32,48,64,96}L \in \{32, 48, 64, 96\} L∈{32,48,64,96} 10,000 independent configurations per temperature point; Wolff cluster algorithm with 10410^4 104 thermalization steps Symmetry correction: global Z2\mathbb{Z}_2 Z2 gauge fixing prior to PCA Confusion scheme: validation cross-entropy minimization over T0∈[2.10,2.45]T_0 \in [2.10, 2.45] T0∈[2.10,2.45] (60 candidate values, band Δ=0.05\Delta = 0.05 Δ=0.05, 5-fold CV) Bootstrap: 50 configuration-level resamples; parabolic sub-grid interpolation for discretization bias reduction Key result: Tc≈2.2717(8)T_c \approx 2.2717(8) Tc≈2.2717(8) for L=96L = 96 L=96 (0.6%0.6\% 0.6% from Onsager); universality class confirmed via FSS data collapse with ν=1\nu = 1 ν=1