Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Comparison Between Quantum Spatial and Temporal Interactions

Francesco R. Ruggeri

Published Jun 9, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The notion of temporal and spatial interactions exists in Newtonian mechanics and we suggest it is useful to compare the two as they differ even though time and x are both considered co-ordinates of spacetime. In particular, space has two directions for every spatial co-ordinate (positive and negative) and so one may move backwards in space. This is associated with a force which may be positive or negative. Even though one may write a spatial equation in terms of energy, if kinetic energy becomes zero due to a negative force, then after this, the particle moves in the negative direction. As a result, one has a potential or interaction energy V(x) which is linked to force = -grad V(r). (We only consider V(x), not V(x,t) here). Things are different with interactions which take place in time only, even though these too may be considered in terms of energy. In general, these seem to be more statistical in nature. In particular, a bound system may absorb a photon. This is an interaction in time, but all subsequent interactions are in increasing time. There is no going backwards in time. An excited state may lose energy or gain more energy. There is an interaction, but no force backwards in time. In such a case, the energy of the photons is their state energy , while V(x) is not a state energy of the system creating it. For example, a charged particle has a V(r) = -kq/r, but its state energy is .5 eo Electric field dot Electric field, where Electric field = -grad V(r). One may already see differences in time interactions in classical statistical mechanics even if a V(x) exists. As a result, of the differences between positive and negative motion in x and only positive motion in t, one may have a localized particle in space and this leads to boundary conditions which yield discrete energy levels. At the same time, a distribution in free particles p’s in the wavefunction W(x) = Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx) leads to a spatial distribution W*(x)W(x). At the same time, interactions in time (with photons for example), lead to a distribution in atom states in the wavefunction, W(x,t) = Sum over n exp(-En/T) Wn(x) and a time distribution Integral dx W*(x,t)W(x,t).

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.20616566

Related papers

Quantum Probabilistic Interactions and +p/-p Invariance Breaking

Francesco R. Ruggeri

In classical physics, a particle traveling to the right is the mirror image of one traveling to the left. In terms of a spatial density (the time spent in each constant dx), the value is the same, as is the energy. A similar notion of such a spatial invariance is in the classical conservation of energy equation for a bound particle: p(x)p(x)/2m + V(x) = E. Quantum mechanics seems to be different because exp(ipx) and exp(-ipx) are distinctly different spatial probabilities, i.e. they are dynamic. It is not just that case that a particle moves to the right for exp(ipx) and to the left for exp(-ipx). The impulse hit probabilities (represented by exp(ipx) and exp(-ipx)) are distinctly different. If one wishes to create an OR situation and write: W(x) = Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx) and use this in a conservation of energy equation, then simply including only positive or negative p values in W(x) leads to a complex average kinetic energy -1/2m d/dx dW/dx / W which cannot be used with V(x) and E. Furthermore, W_ (only negative p) and W+ (only positive p) values do not yield the same average kinetic energy. Fortunately, given that this is a statistical average for a localized object (somewhat analogous to a gas), one may combine W+ + W- and obtain a real kinetic energy. We have argued in previous notes that there exists a quantum-classical duality. For example, for a free particle one has two independent notions. One is x=vt which describes the center-of-mass of the particle. We take this to represent a state description which treats v and -v as mirror images. exp(ipx), on the other hand, represents probabilistic impulse hits and does not define the state by itself, we argue, only its interactions. Interactions are physical and define what happens in an interacting system. One may, however, measure a system, i.e interact with exp(ipx), and this should define a measurement state ( a second state ensemble average). For example, exp(ipx)exp(-ipx) = 1 which is equivalent to the constant dt in each dx associated with x=vt. Thus, the two states coincide, but exp(ipx)exp(-ipx) means that one may place the 2-slit apparatus at any x point and is not about the center-of-mass, as x=vt is. In some cases, the two states are quite different. W*(x)W(x) represents an interaction state, but vrms(x) from .5mvrms(x)vrms(x) = -1/2m d/dx dW/dx / W represents a center-of-mass state description. (Note: in these cases a state means an average state, i.e. an average over many ensemble entries.) If one takes W*(x)W(x) and integrates over x, then interference terms vanish and one obtains a classical counting of distinct p value states with their weight a*(p)a(p).This, we argue, leads to the notion of orthogonality of probabilities. In classical probability, there is no such notion, but there is the notion of AND (multiply) probabilities. Given exp(ipx) and exp(-ipx), if one multiplies one removes p, i.e. the interactions and only sees the state left. W*(x)W(x) yields a set of peaks which represent a pattern of probabilistic hits in space which define a state which one would measure in space. The interference pattern, however, must be one such that if one integrates over x, one only obtains a classical sum of probabilities a*(p)a(p)’s as mentioned above. This leads to the notion of orthogonal exp(ipx)’s (which follows mathematically anyway). If one considers different bound En states, then these two are orthogonal because W*n1(x)Wn2(x) mean n1 and n2 are associated with different energies and integrating over x cannot show a result which looks like a state result, where W*n(x)Wn(x) shows a state result. In order to achieve this orthogonality (linked directly to the notion of a state) one must have that Wn(2) usually has 0 points and is positive and negative with the possible exception of a ground state. In other words, if Wn1*(x)Wn2(x) integrated over x is not 0, one violates conservation of energy. As a result, we argue an average probability for a bound state must statistically include +p and -p contributions and must create a function which has positive and negative peaks (except possibly for the ground state), i.e. W(x) must have 0 points. This W(x) is linked to a measurement state W*(x)W(x), but this is strictly considering exp(ipx)s. We argue that there are two pieces of information for a free particle, x=vt and exp(ipx). There must also be an average state linked to x=vt and this given by KEave(x) = .5m vrms(x)vrms(x) + V(x) = E which shows that the particle may exist and have average kinetic energy even at W(x)=0 points. When measuring a system, one interacts with the exp(ipx)s and so the W*(x)W(x) state is the one which is traditionally presented, but whether one measures the center-of-mass motion or not, one also has the notion of the x=vt, i.e. vrms(x) state (average) as well, we argue.

•May 20, 2026•0 citations

Space-Dependent Potential and Interaction Through Quantum Resonances?

Francesco R. Ruggeri

In Newtonian mechanics, a space-dependent potential V(x) is associated with both a change in energy in x and a conservative force -dV/dx. There is no notion of an interaction through a resonance, even though classically resonance situations exist. A quantum free particle is represented by the space and time two-dimensional probability distributions exp(ipx) and exp(-iEt) with x and t representing independent variables, even though on average there exists the relationship x= p/m t. In the case of the time-independent Schrodinger equation, one uses a potential V(x) taken from “classical” physics which is combined with the nonclassical exp(ipx) (i.e. with time removed). An immediate issue, we argue, is that V(x) implies different potential energy values at each x, while exp(ipx) → cos(px) describes probabilities at different x points associated with the same p. According to classical mechanics, p should change from one x point to another in a deterministic manner governed by V(x). Thus there exists a contradiction. We argue that the probabilistic form cos(px) remains intact, but that the interaction between an exp(ipx) and V(x) involves the formation of a probability resonance which involves other exp(ipx)s in the problem. In other words, V(x)=Sum over k Vk exp(ikx) suggests that the potential also behaves in a probabilistic manner and one may have Vkexp(ikx) a(p-k) exp(i (p-k) x) = Vka(p-k) exp(ipx). One may argue that Sum over k Vk expIkx) is simply a mathematical formalism (namely a Fourier series) without any physical manifestation. In this note, however, we argue against this and suggest that the “resonance” involved is linked with physical probability distributions which exist in both V(x) and external energy-supplying objects (such as a photon). According to the time-independent Schrodinger equation there are discrete energy levels associated with this differential equation, so an entity which may provide energy is required to lift a quantum bound particle from one energy level to the next. Electrons in an atom absorb photons to move to higher levels. Thus the photon is an energy-supplier and the fact that it has a spatial wavelength does not seem to directly enter into the solution of the time-dependent Schrodinger equation. If, however, a particle may only interact through a probability resonance, we argue that it is not only the potential V(x) which must physically be able to interact in a probabilistic way, but also any energy entities used to supply energy. Thus we argue that a photon must have a spatial distribution i..e wavelength to allow it to be part of the formation of spatial resonances in the particle - V(x) system which it in fact does. Thus we argue that the wavelength of a photon is experimental evidence for x-probability distribution resonances which occur between V(x) and a bound particle.

•Feb 13, 2023•0 citations

Differing Space and Time Interactions in Quantum Mechanics

Francesco R. Ruggeri

The wavefunction for a quantum free particle is exp(-iEt + ipx) In this case, E and p are linked through either E=pp/2m (nonrelativistic case) or EE =pp + momo (relativistic case c=1). We argue that there are different interactions involved with E and p. P (momentum) is energy flow and is involved in impulse type interactions with a potential usually V(x). For V(x,t) matters are more complicated, but will also be discussed. The impulse hits are associated with exp(ipx) and lead to interfering plane waves and an overall crest-trough spatial scenario. There is a kinetic energy (nonrelativistic case) associated with each p, but a new overall energy En (n= eigenlevel) is created which yields the free form exp(-iEnt). This energy is linked to the cycling of exp(ipx)’s. It is also part of the new mass of the bound state system i.e. mo+En. This new system could be considered as an overall free particle and obtain a new overall momentum. (The initial bound state has 0 overall momentum.) Thus, time and space parts of the wavefunction behave in very different manners due to the nature of the interaction even though there is a link between 1/E and cycling of exp(ipx) terms. We call this case an impulse or space based type of interaction. It is also possible to have a time based interaction i.e. the absorption of a photon, phonon etc. In such a case, there is momentum conservation and so the whole system receives a new momentum, but this is usually ignored. The main effect is for the system to move from one bound state E(n1) to another E(n2). This has consequences on the spatial density and cycling of exp(ipx) terms in the wavefunction, but is not an impulse interaction in space. In the case of a system: W(x,t)= Sum over n an(En) exp(-iEnt) Wn(x), one has time based interactions which knock the system from one bound state to another (as in heat bath interaction). Again there are links between each En and the spatial density, but there is an overall spatial density(x,t) and average energy(x,t) which depends on the interference of exp(-iEnt) terms. (This disappears if one integrates over all x.) This is similar to the diffraction/interference spatial pattern, but in time. In the impulse scenario for a(p)=a(-p) one has cross terms in the spatial density of cos( (pi-pj)x) which create the crest/trough pattern seen. For the heat bath time type interaction, there exist cos( (Ei-Ej)t) type terms if an(En)=a*n(En) which are linked to the energy Ei-Ej of the intermediary photon/phonon etc and its time period. Thus in both cases, the quantum crest/trough pattern (in space or time) seems to be linked to the momentum or energy transfer. The energy transfer is known to be linked to periodic objects (photons/phonons) and it seems the momentum transfer pi-pj also has a similar periodicity, but in space. It is almost as if these “entities” are creating the unusual quantum crest/trough patterns.

•Nov 20, 2021•0 citations

Lack of Absolute Time in Quantum Mechanics?

Francesco R. Ruggeri

Quantum mechanics seems to function at two levels in terms of probability. One level is represented by classical probabilities P(x)=W*(x)W(x) and P(p)=a*(p)a(p) where W(x)=wavefunction= Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx). For a free particle this level maps into continuous space and time i.e. exp(-iEt+ipx)*exp(-iEt+ipx)=1, but at a more fundamental level (the wavefunction level) there seems to be spatial and time resolution. Spatial resolution for a free particle is based on exp(ipx) i.e. a resolution pattern cos(px) and its space shifted sin(px) representing motion. This resolution carries over to bound states for which P(x) is not 1, but is represented by crests and troughs. exp(-iEt) represents resolution in time, we argue and is linked to 1/E where E is an energy associated with an interaction. As a result a bound system may have an overall exp(-i (M1 + m2 + En) t) where En is binding energy and an overall frequency (or spatial resolution of 1/(M1 + m2 + En), but exp(-iEnt) represents a frequency of 1/En which is linked to the interaction between M1 and m2. Thus the time resolution seems to be associated with energy and there may be various kinds of energy in a system (e.g. rest mass energy, binding energy) etc. These appear to be linked to different time resolutions. If En becomes 0, i.e. M1 and m2 no longer interact, then M1 has a time resolution proportional to 1/M1 and m2, to 1/m2. Thus at the wavefunction level it does not seem there is an absolute time, rather there are various time resolutions associated with different energies.

•Jun 27, 2022•0 citations

Conditional Probability and Time in Quantum Bound States

Francesco R. Ruggeri

We argue that in a quantum bound state with one particle, the particle receives stochastic hits from a potential. As a result, if one examines a point x, the particle may be present at ti with momentum pi (in both the forward and backward directions) leading to a momentum distribution with a conditional probability P(p/x) = a(p) exp(ipx)/W(x) where W(x) is the wavefunction. Thus, one does not follow a stochastic particle in time, but rather describes it by a probability distribution at each x. One may next ask whether this conditional probability at x changes in time? This is not the actual time related to stochastic motion of the particle. To answer this question, we argue one must consider interactions which occur at x which are part of an energy equation. Even in classical physics, the energy equation at x indicates how a particle’s motion changes. Thus, we argue one does not simply take measurements at x of ti and pi, but that at each ti, a particle with pi is undergoing dynamic changes and these may be considered as well. If one describes the quantum picture by W(x) i.e. a momentum distribution, one may find a collective interaction given by -1/2m d/dx d/dx W + VW. The coupling between V(x)=Sum over k V(x)exp(ikx) and the particle conditional probabilities in W is apparent in the VW term. This energy term should describe whether the momentum distribution changes in time i.e should be proportional to dW/dt (partial derivative), but should also equal the average energy. Thus, a link exists between ensemble energy and time. In this note, we argue that these ideas may be applied to P(p/x) in a bound state resonance because the same E applies to each p.

•Oct 7, 2020•0 citations

Quantum Bound Density and Time Through Impulse

Francesco R. Ruggeri

A classical bound system may be said to have a spatial density proportional to the amount of time dt a particle spends in a constant dx region i.e. C/v(x) (1) We stress that in this scenario there is a well defined and constant dx so that “dt” may be linked to velocity v(x). We also note that there is no spatial representation of action-reaction here even though this exists in Newton’s theory. In a classical Maxwell-Boltzmann gas there are many particles which each act dynamically according to .5mvv+V(x) = E (where v and E are particular to the particle when it is not colliding). At the same time there is a spatial density which “represents” macroscopic static chunks of matter which are balanced through pressure differences (P=spatial density(x) RT) and -dV/dx density where V(x) is the potential. From the pressure equation, T is proportional to energy which in turn is proportional to RMS speed squared. RMS speed may then be linked to a dt if a fixed dx is understood. In the classical statistical case, however, spatial density is directly linked to the number of particles in a region. Time enters in the pressure expression through a term proportional to the average kinetic energy i.e. pv where p is like an impulse and v a flux. What happens in a single particle quantum bound state? In a sense it is like a classical bound state as the equation: prms(x)prms(x)/2m + V(x) = En holds for any energy level. Can one then take vrms(x), choose a fixed dx and argue that spatial density should be equal to dt or C/vrms(x)? We argue that one cannot due to the lack of defined “dx” quantity. Why is dx problematic to define? We argue that it is because quantum mechanics is based on action-reaction x-probaiblity distributions linked to impulse. For example, exp(ipx) for a free particle captures only p or impulse (not velocity) and cos(px) and sin(px) are its action-reaction regions.These lead ultimately to a density is given by the well-known W*(x)W(x) where W(x)=Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx), although kinetic energy with pp/2m = .5pv is used to find W(x) as well. . W*(x)W(x) has crests and troughs similar to cos(px) in exp(ipx), except that these now have varying heights and widths. We try to argue that even though each x point maps to a different KEave(x), the hump physically represents action-reaction in the system (just as the humps in cos(px) do except for a single p) while KE(x) represents an average of p’s. This action-reaction is linked with impulses. In general, if one takes d/dx of the time-independent Schrodinger equation one finds an average impulse term, -dV/dx and KE(x) dW/dx / W where dW/dx / W is the average impulse. At peaks, dW/dx =0 and so an average force through time*impulse term balances -dV/dx=Newtonian force. These peaks are also associated with W*(x at peak)W(x at peak) which is the spatial density. We interpret this as representing the average time the single particle spends near x at peak. This value, however, follows from ideas of impulse and not from speed as there is no well defined dx even though there is a well defined vrms(x). Thus the ratio of W*(x)W(x) at two peaks is not the inverse of the ratio of vrms(x) except apparently when the energy level n becomes very high. We investigate these ideas.

•Feb 16, 2023•0 citations
The notion of temporal and spatial interactions exists in Newtonian mechanics and we suggest it is useful to compare the two as they differ even though time and x are both considered co-ordinates of spacetime. In particular, space has two directions for every spatial co-ordinate (positive and negative) and so one may move backwards in space. This is associated with a force which may be positive or negative. Even though one may write a spatial equation in terms of energy, if kinetic energy becomes zero due to a negative force, then after this, the particle moves in the negative direction. As a result, one has a potential or interaction energy V(x) which is linked to force = -grad V(r). (We only consider V(x), not V(x,t) here). Things are different with interactions which take place in time only, even though these too may be considered in terms of energy. In general, these seem to be more statistical in nature. In particular, a bound system may absorb a photon. This is an interaction in time, but all subsequent interactions are in increasing time. There is no going backwards in time. An excited state may lose energy or gain more energy. There is an interaction, but no force backwards in time. In such a case, the energy of the photons is their state energy , while V(x) is not a state energy of the system creating it. For example, a charged particle has a V(r) = -kq/r, but its state energy is .5 eo Electric field dot Electric field, where Electric field = -grad V(r). One may already see differences in time interactions in classical statistical mechanics even if a V(x) exists. As a result, of the differences between positive and negative motion in x and only positive motion in t, one may have a localized particle in space and this leads to boundary conditions which yield discrete energy levels. At the same time, a distribution in free particles p’s in the wavefunction W(x) = Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx) leads to a spatial distribution W*(x)W(x). At the same time, interactions in time (with photons for example), lead to a distribution in atom states in the wavefunction, W(x,t) = Sum over n exp(-En/T) Wn(x) and a time distribution Integral dx W*(x,t)W(x,t).
In classical physics, a particle traveling to the right is the mirror image of one traveling to the left. In terms of a spatial density (the time spent in each constant dx), the value is the same, as is the energy. A similar notion of such a spatial invariance is in the classical conservation of energy equation for a bound particle: p(x)p(x)/2m + V(x) = E. Quantum mechanics seems to be different because exp(ipx) and exp(-ipx) are distinctly different spatial probabilities, i.e. they are dynamic. It is not just that case that a particle moves to the right for exp(ipx) and to the left for exp(-ipx). The impulse hit probabilities (represented by exp(ipx) and exp(-ipx)) are distinctly different. If one wishes to create an OR situation and write: W(x) = Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx) and use this in a conservation of energy equation, then simply including only positive or negative p values in W(x) leads to a complex average kinetic energy -1/2m d/dx dW/dx / W which cannot be used with V(x) and E. Furthermore, W_ (only negative p) and W+ (only positive p) values do not yield the same average kinetic energy. Fortunately, given that this is a statistical average for a localized object (somewhat analogous to a gas), one may combine W+ + W- and obtain a real kinetic energy. We have argued in previous notes that there exists a quantum-classical duality. For example, for a free particle one has two independent notions. One is x=vt which describes the center-of-mass of the particle. We take this to represent a state description which treats v and -v as mirror images. exp(ipx), on the other hand, represents probabilistic impulse hits and does not define the state by itself, we argue, only its interactions. Interactions are physical and define what happens in an interacting system. One may, however, measure a system, i.e interact with exp(ipx), and this should define a measurement state ( a second state ensemble average). For example, exp(ipx)exp(-ipx) = 1 which is equivalent to the constant dt in each dx associated with x=vt. Thus, the two states coincide, but exp(ipx)exp(-ipx) means that one may place the 2-slit apparatus at any x point and is not about the center-of-mass, as x=vt is. In some cases, the two states are quite different. W*(x)W(x) represents an interaction state, but vrms(x) from .5mvrms(x)vrms(x) = -1/2m d/dx dW/dx / W represents a center-of-mass state description. (Note: in these cases a state means an average state, i.e. an average over many ensemble entries.) If one takes W*(x)W(x) and integrates over x, then interference terms vanish and one obtains a classical counting of distinct p value states with their weight a*(p)a(p).This, we argue, leads to the notion of orthogonality of probabilities. In classical probability, there is no such notion, but there is the notion of AND (multiply) probabilities. Given exp(ipx) and exp(-ipx), if one multiplies one removes p, i.e. the interactions and only sees the state left. W*(x)W(x) yields a set of peaks which represent a pattern of probabilistic hits in space which define a state which one would measure in space. The interference pattern, however, must be one such that if one integrates over x, one only obtains a classical sum of probabilities a*(p)a(p)’s as mentioned above. This leads to the notion of orthogonal exp(ipx)’s (which follows mathematically anyway). If one considers different bound En states, then these two are orthogonal because W*n1(x)Wn2(x) mean n1 and n2 are associated with different energies and integrating over x cannot show a result which looks like a state result, where W*n(x)Wn(x) shows a state result. In order to achieve this orthogonality (linked directly to the notion of a state) one must have that Wn(2) usually has 0 points and is positive and negative with the possible exception of a ground state. In other words, if Wn1*(x)Wn2(x) integrated over x is not 0, one violates conservation of energy. As a result, we argue an average probability for a bound state must statistically include +p and -p contributions and must create a function which has positive and negative peaks (except possibly for the ground state), i.e. W(x) must have 0 points. This W(x) is linked to a measurement state W*(x)W(x), but this is strictly considering exp(ipx)s. We argue that there are two pieces of information for a free particle, x=vt and exp(ipx). There must also be an average state linked to x=vt and this given by KEave(x) = .5m vrms(x)vrms(x) + V(x) = E which shows that the particle may exist and have average kinetic energy even at W(x)=0 points. When measuring a system, one interacts with the exp(ipx)s and so the W*(x)W(x) state is the one which is traditionally presented, but whether one measures the center-of-mass motion or not, one also has the notion of the x=vt, i.e. vrms(x) state (average) as well, we argue.
In Newtonian mechanics, a space-dependent potential V(x) is associated with both a change in energy in x and a conservative force -dV/dx. There is no notion of an interaction through a resonance, even though classically resonance situations exist. A quantum free particle is represented by the space and time two-dimensional probability distributions exp(ipx) and exp(-iEt) with x and t representing independent variables, even though on average there exists the relationship x= p/m t. In the case of the time-independent Schrodinger equation, one uses a potential V(x) taken from “classical” physics which is combined with the nonclassical exp(ipx) (i.e. with time removed). An immediate issue, we argue, is that V(x) implies different potential energy values at each x, while exp(ipx) → cos(px) describes probabilities at different x points associated with the same p. According to classical mechanics, p should change from one x point to another in a deterministic manner governed by V(x). Thus there exists a contradiction. We argue that the probabilistic form cos(px) remains intact, but that the interaction between an exp(ipx) and V(x) involves the formation of a probability resonance which involves other exp(ipx)s in the problem. In other words, V(x)=Sum over k Vk exp(ikx) suggests that the potential also behaves in a probabilistic manner and one may have Vkexp(ikx) a(p-k) exp(i (p-k) x) = Vka(p-k) exp(ipx). One may argue that Sum over k Vk expIkx) is simply a mathematical formalism (namely a Fourier series) without any physical manifestation. In this note, however, we argue against this and suggest that the “resonance” involved is linked with physical probability distributions which exist in both V(x) and external energy-supplying objects (such as a photon). According to the time-independent Schrodinger equation there are discrete energy levels associated with this differential equation, so an entity which may provide energy is required to lift a quantum bound particle from one energy level to the next. Electrons in an atom absorb photons to move to higher levels. Thus the photon is an energy-supplier and the fact that it has a spatial wavelength does not seem to directly enter into the solution of the time-dependent Schrodinger equation. If, however, a particle may only interact through a probability resonance, we argue that it is not only the potential V(x) which must physically be able to interact in a probabilistic way, but also any energy entities used to supply energy. Thus we argue that a photon must have a spatial distribution i..e wavelength to allow it to be part of the formation of spatial resonances in the particle - V(x) system which it in fact does. Thus we argue that the wavelength of a photon is experimental evidence for x-probability distribution resonances which occur between V(x) and a bound particle.
The wavefunction for a quantum free particle is exp(-iEt + ipx) In this case, E and p are linked through either E=pp/2m (nonrelativistic case) or EE =pp + momo (relativistic case c=1). We argue that there are different interactions involved with E and p. P (momentum) is energy flow and is involved in impulse type interactions with a potential usually V(x). For V(x,t) matters are more complicated, but will also be discussed. The impulse hits are associated with exp(ipx) and lead to interfering plane waves and an overall crest-trough spatial scenario. There is a kinetic energy (nonrelativistic case) associated with each p, but a new overall energy En (n= eigenlevel) is created which yields the free form exp(-iEnt). This energy is linked to the cycling of exp(ipx)’s. It is also part of the new mass of the bound state system i.e. mo+En. This new system could be considered as an overall free particle and obtain a new overall momentum. (The initial bound state has 0 overall momentum.) Thus, time and space parts of the wavefunction behave in very different manners due to the nature of the interaction even though there is a link between 1/E and cycling of exp(ipx) terms. We call this case an impulse or space based type of interaction. It is also possible to have a time based interaction i.e. the absorption of a photon, phonon etc. In such a case, there is momentum conservation and so the whole system receives a new momentum, but this is usually ignored. The main effect is for the system to move from one bound state E(n1) to another E(n2). This has consequences on the spatial density and cycling of exp(ipx) terms in the wavefunction, but is not an impulse interaction in space. In the case of a system: W(x,t)= Sum over n an(En) exp(-iEnt) Wn(x), one has time based interactions which knock the system from one bound state to another (as in heat bath interaction). Again there are links between each En and the spatial density, but there is an overall spatial density(x,t) and average energy(x,t) which depends on the interference of exp(-iEnt) terms. (This disappears if one integrates over all x.) This is similar to the diffraction/interference spatial pattern, but in time. In the impulse scenario for a(p)=a(-p) one has cross terms in the spatial density of cos( (pi-pj)x) which create the crest/trough pattern seen. For the heat bath time type interaction, there exist cos( (Ei-Ej)t) type terms if an(En)=a*n(En) which are linked to the energy Ei-Ej of the intermediary photon/phonon etc and its time period. Thus in both cases, the quantum crest/trough pattern (in space or time) seems to be linked to the momentum or energy transfer. The energy transfer is known to be linked to periodic objects (photons/phonons) and it seems the momentum transfer pi-pj also has a similar periodicity, but in space. It is almost as if these “entities” are creating the unusual quantum crest/trough patterns.
Quantum mechanics seems to function at two levels in terms of probability. One level is represented by classical probabilities P(x)=W*(x)W(x) and P(p)=a*(p)a(p) where W(x)=wavefunction= Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx). For a free particle this level maps into continuous space and time i.e. exp(-iEt+ipx)*exp(-iEt+ipx)=1, but at a more fundamental level (the wavefunction level) there seems to be spatial and time resolution. Spatial resolution for a free particle is based on exp(ipx) i.e. a resolution pattern cos(px) and its space shifted sin(px) representing motion. This resolution carries over to bound states for which P(x) is not 1, but is represented by crests and troughs. exp(-iEt) represents resolution in time, we argue and is linked to 1/E where E is an energy associated with an interaction. As a result a bound system may have an overall exp(-i (M1 + m2 + En) t) where En is binding energy and an overall frequency (or spatial resolution of 1/(M1 + m2 + En), but exp(-iEnt) represents a frequency of 1/En which is linked to the interaction between M1 and m2. Thus the time resolution seems to be associated with energy and there may be various kinds of energy in a system (e.g. rest mass energy, binding energy) etc. These appear to be linked to different time resolutions. If En becomes 0, i.e. M1 and m2 no longer interact, then M1 has a time resolution proportional to 1/M1 and m2, to 1/m2. Thus at the wavefunction level it does not seem there is an absolute time, rather there are various time resolutions associated with different energies.
We argue that in a quantum bound state with one particle, the particle receives stochastic hits from a potential. As a result, if one examines a point x, the particle may be present at ti with momentum pi (in both the forward and backward directions) leading to a momentum distribution with a conditional probability P(p/x) = a(p) exp(ipx)/W(x) where W(x) is the wavefunction. Thus, one does not follow a stochastic particle in time, but rather describes it by a probability distribution at each x. One may next ask whether this conditional probability at x changes in time? This is not the actual time related to stochastic motion of the particle. To answer this question, we argue one must consider interactions which occur at x which are part of an energy equation. Even in classical physics, the energy equation at x indicates how a particle’s motion changes. Thus, we argue one does not simply take measurements at x of ti and pi, but that at each ti, a particle with pi is undergoing dynamic changes and these may be considered as well. If one describes the quantum picture by W(x) i.e. a momentum distribution, one may find a collective interaction given by -1/2m d/dx d/dx W + VW. The coupling between V(x)=Sum over k V(x)exp(ikx) and the particle conditional probabilities in W is apparent in the VW term. This energy term should describe whether the momentum distribution changes in time i.e should be proportional to dW/dt (partial derivative), but should also equal the average energy. Thus, a link exists between ensemble energy and time. In this note, we argue that these ideas may be applied to P(p/x) in a bound state resonance because the same E applies to each p.
A classical bound system may be said to have a spatial density proportional to the amount of time dt a particle spends in a constant dx region i.e. C/v(x) (1) We stress that in this scenario there is a well defined and constant dx so that “dt” may be linked to velocity v(x). We also note that there is no spatial representation of action-reaction here even though this exists in Newton’s theory. In a classical Maxwell-Boltzmann gas there are many particles which each act dynamically according to .5mvv+V(x) = E (where v and E are particular to the particle when it is not colliding). At the same time there is a spatial density which “represents” macroscopic static chunks of matter which are balanced through pressure differences (P=spatial density(x) RT) and -dV/dx density where V(x) is the potential. From the pressure equation, T is proportional to energy which in turn is proportional to RMS speed squared. RMS speed may then be linked to a dt if a fixed dx is understood. In the classical statistical case, however, spatial density is directly linked to the number of particles in a region. Time enters in the pressure expression through a term proportional to the average kinetic energy i.e. pv where p is like an impulse and v a flux. What happens in a single particle quantum bound state? In a sense it is like a classical bound state as the equation: prms(x)prms(x)/2m + V(x) = En holds for any energy level. Can one then take vrms(x), choose a fixed dx and argue that spatial density should be equal to dt or C/vrms(x)? We argue that one cannot due to the lack of defined “dx” quantity. Why is dx problematic to define? We argue that it is because quantum mechanics is based on action-reaction x-probaiblity distributions linked to impulse. For example, exp(ipx) for a free particle captures only p or impulse (not velocity) and cos(px) and sin(px) are its action-reaction regions.These lead ultimately to a density is given by the well-known W*(x)W(x) where W(x)=Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx), although kinetic energy with pp/2m = .5pv is used to find W(x) as well. . W*(x)W(x) has crests and troughs similar to cos(px) in exp(ipx), except that these now have varying heights and widths. We try to argue that even though each x point maps to a different KEave(x), the hump physically represents action-reaction in the system (just as the humps in cos(px) do except for a single p) while KE(x) represents an average of p’s. This action-reaction is linked with impulses. In general, if one takes d/dx of the time-independent Schrodinger equation one finds an average impulse term, -dV/dx and KE(x) dW/dx / W where dW/dx / W is the average impulse. At peaks, dW/dx =0 and so an average force through time*impulse term balances -dV/dx=Newtonian force. These peaks are also associated with W*(x at peak)W(x at peak) which is the spatial density. We interpret this as representing the average time the single particle spends near x at peak. This value, however, follows from ideas of impulse and not from speed as there is no well defined dx even though there is a well defined vrms(x). Thus the ratio of W*(x)W(x) at two peaks is not the inverse of the ratio of vrms(x) except apparently when the energy level n becomes very high. We investigate these ideas.