Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Informatika i sistemy upravleniya

BOHR STATIONARY ORBITALS AND THE CLASSICAL THEORY OF POLARIZATION. II

I.E. EREMIN

Published Jan 1, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The possibility of continuously deterministic modeling of linear spectra and the electronic structure of matter, implemented within the framework of the scientific prerequisites of classic physics, is considered. The second part of the paper presents a dynamic model of the mechanism of generation of the atomic spectrum of hydrogen, revealing the reason for the splitting of a number of its lines based on consideration of classic Maxwell's equations.

DOI
10.22250/18142400_2026_87_1_22

Related papers

BOHR STATIONARY ORBITALS AND THE CLASSICAL THEORY OF POLARIZATION. I

I.E. EREMIN

The possibility of continuously-deterministic modeling of linear spectra and the electronic structure of matter, implemented within the framework of the scientific prerequisites of classical physics, is considered. The first part of the paper presents formulas for the calculated radii of spectral orbits, derived on the basis of Rutherford's planetary model of the atom without using Bohr's postulates, but taking into account objective relativistic corrections.

Informatika i sistemy upravleniya•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

Derivations

R.C. Olsen

The existence of line spectra can be explained bymeans of the first “quantum”model of the atom, developed by Bohr in 1913. Although the Bohr model of the hydrogen atom was eventually replaced, it yields the correct values for the observed spectral lines, and gives a substantial insight into the structure of atoms in general. The following derivation has the objective of obtaining the energy levels of the Bohr atom. If we can obtain the energy levels, we can reproduce the hydrogen atom spectra. The derivation proceeds with three major elements: first, use force balance to relate the velocity to the radius of the electron orbit, then use a quantum assumption to get the radius, then solve for the energies.

SPIE eBooks•Mar 16, 2010•0 citations

The Quantum of Action and Atomic Models

Mituo Taketani, Masayuki Nagasaki

Einstein consider that in a new electromagnetic theory that would settle the problem of the self-energy of electron, the Planck constant h would be given in terms of the elementary electric charge and light velocity. In contrast to this, Haas supposed that h could be deduced from the atomic radius assumed in the Thomson model of the atom and the charge and mass of electron. In connection with this, it should be greatly appreciated concerning in the history of the formation of quantum mechanics that Sommerfeld gave the view that the existence of the molecule is the function and result of the existence of h. It should never be forgotten also that, different from Ritz who tried to explain the combination rule of spectral lines with special mathematical models, Nicholson followed Sommerfeld's view to discuss the spectra of coronae of the sun on the basis of an atomic model of the Nagaoka type with several electrons, in which no assumption is made of the atomic radius, and came to point out the existence of the quantum nature of angular momentum due to h, together with an estimation of the atomic radius. Bohr, who determined the number of electrons in the hydrogen atom from his analysis of the energy loss of α-rays through hydrogen gas, and thus understood that the problem of the stability of atoms could not be solved with the classical mechanics, presented the Bohr model of the atom, in which the existence of atomic discrete energy levels results from the quantum nature of angular momentum, and the combination rule of spectral lines is grasped with the frequency relation.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Nov 1, 2001•0 citations

Bohr’s molecular model and the melding of classical and quantum mechanics

M. Ya. Amusia

With considerable interest I read the article “Bohr’s molecular model, a century later” by Anatoly Svidzinsky, Marlan Scully, and Dudley Herschbach (Physics Today, January 2014, page 33). It is always interesting to see how our current understanding sheds new light on the revolutionary scientific ideas of the past. I agree with the authors that although quantum mechanics is the real basis for atomic- and molecular-physics computations, the old Bohr model that treats electrons in atoms like tiny planets moving around the sun-nucleus is intuitively clear and very attractive.As I see it, the aim of the article is to show how to use Bohr’s approach to treat not only simple atoms but molecules. An important point in that approach is reconciliation of quantum mechanics with Bohr’s ideas. The authors claim that in infinite dimensions, quantum mechanics “morphs into classical mechanics.”I cannot say, however, that the infinite-dimension system is a clarifying model to describe physical or chemical objects. I do not see that the reference to chromodynamics (and to Edward Witten’s article in Physics Today, July 1980, page 38) is a clarifying one. Far from convincing are statements like “Hence the large-D limit, where 1/D → 0, is closer to the real world (1/D = 1/3) than is the oft-used D = 1 regime. Indeed, results obtained at large D usually resemble those for D = 3.” I confess it sounds too lacking in rigor to be convincing.But the large-D limit per se is not what bothers me. Of great concern is the assumption that the radial part of the D-dimensional Schrödinger equation in Hartree units looks like this:(1)where Z is the nuclear charge and l is the angular momentum.Equation (1) has no sense for D = 1. Indeed, in one dimension, a finite angular momentum requires infinite speed of a rotating particle. Therefore, for D = 1, the correct equation is(2)which does not follow from equation (1) at D = 1.But most important is that equation (1) implies that the Coulomb potential does not depend on D. That could have been considered correct before it became clear that the Coulomb law follows from Maxwell’s equations when one considers a field generated by a point-like electric charge. So to obtain the Coulomb law for a two-dimensional space, one has to consider Maxwell equations in a two-dimensional world. For a point-like charge, those equations lead to a 1/(ln r) instead of 1/r dependence. If one takes into account the D-dependence of the Coulomb potential, derivations performed in the Physics Today article become meaningless. Indeed, when using an unrealistic equation (1), how can one believe that it illuminates Bohr’s quite realistic and physical postulates?© 2014 American Institute of Physics.

Physics Today•Aug 1, 2014•1 citation

The Hydrogen-Like Atom

Uri Peskin

The mere existence of stable atoms, and their arrangement into many-atom nanoscale structures, can only be explained by the laws of quantum mechanics. Indeed, the accumulated evidence regarding the internal structure of atoms motivated the formulation of quantum mechanics at the early twentieth century. Here we focus on single-electron (hydrogen-like) atoms. The dominance of the Coulomb central potential between the electron and nucleus, translates into a simple Schrödinger equation for their relative position distribution. Solving rigorously this equation reveals quantized energy levels, which explains the emission spectra of hydrogen-like atoms (Rydberg formula). The corresponding stationary probability density distributions for the electron around the nucleus are reminiscent of the Bohr model, where classical trajectories (orbits) are replaced by single-electron wave functions (orbitals). The degeneracies of different orbitals, associated with three quantum numbers, will later turn out to be critical for understanding many-electron atoms and the periodic table of the elements.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•May 11, 2023•0 citations

Spectral Lines and Series

Émile Biémont

The empirical description of spectral series in spectra by Rydberg and Ritz as well as the observation of the hydrogen spectrum by Balmer at the end of the 19th century have considerably boosted spectroscopy and have open the way to classical models of the atom like those of N. Bohr and A. Sommerfeld in a first step and then to the quantum descriptions of E. Schr¨odinger and finally of P. A. M. Dirac, in a second step. The study of Rydberg atoms has developed considerably in recent decades and multiple new research directions have emerged and concern fields as varied as precision measurements of fundamental constants, molecular physics, nonlinear quantum optics and quantum computing. New interesting perspectives have been made possible by the trapping and cooling of atoms and ions by laser. The terminology of the” circular atoms” is also defined and it is shown why transitions involving high n levels are interesting.

CRC Press eBooks•Oct 30, 2025•0 citations
The possibility of continuously deterministic modeling of linear spectra and the electronic structure of matter, implemented within the framework of the scientific prerequisites of classic physics, is considered. The second part of the paper presents a dynamic model of the mechanism of generation of the atomic spectrum of hydrogen, revealing the reason for the splitting of a number of its lines based on consideration of classic Maxwell's equations.
The existence of line spectra can be explained bymeans of the first “quantum”model of the atom, developed by Bohr in 1913. Although the Bohr model of the hydrogen atom was eventually replaced, it yields the correct values for the observed spectral lines, and gives a substantial insight into the structure of atoms in general. The following derivation has the objective of obtaining the energy levels of the Bohr atom. If we can obtain the energy levels, we can reproduce the hydrogen atom spectra. The derivation proceeds with three major elements: first, use force balance to relate the velocity to the radius of the electron orbit, then use a quantum assumption to get the radius, then solve for the energies.
Einstein consider that in a new electromagnetic theory that would settle the problem of the self-energy of electron, the Planck constant h would be given in terms of the elementary electric charge and light velocity. In contrast to this, Haas supposed that h could be deduced from the atomic radius assumed in the Thomson model of the atom and the charge and mass of electron. In connection with this, it should be greatly appreciated concerning in the history of the formation of quantum mechanics that Sommerfeld gave the view that the existence of the molecule is the function and result of the existence of h. It should never be forgotten also that, different from Ritz who tried to explain the combination rule of spectral lines with special mathematical models, Nicholson followed Sommerfeld's view to discuss the spectra of coronae of the sun on the basis of an atomic model of the Nagaoka type with several electrons, in which no assumption is made of the atomic radius, and came to point out the existence of the quantum nature of angular momentum due to h, together with an estimation of the atomic radius. Bohr, who determined the number of electrons in the hydrogen atom from his analysis of the energy loss of α-rays through hydrogen gas, and thus understood that the problem of the stability of atoms could not be solved with the classical mechanics, presented the Bohr model of the atom, in which the existence of atomic discrete energy levels results from the quantum nature of angular momentum, and the combination rule of spectral lines is grasped with the frequency relation.
With considerable interest I read the article “Bohr’s molecular model, a century later” by Anatoly Svidzinsky, Marlan Scully, and Dudley Herschbach (Physics Today, January 2014, page 33). It is always interesting to see how our current understanding sheds new light on the revolutionary scientific ideas of the past. I agree with the authors that although quantum mechanics is the real basis for atomic- and molecular-physics computations, the old Bohr model that treats electrons in atoms like tiny planets moving around the sun-nucleus is intuitively clear and very attractive.As I see it, the aim of the article is to show how to use Bohr’s approach to treat not only simple atoms but molecules. An important point in that approach is reconciliation of quantum mechanics with Bohr’s ideas. The authors claim that in infinite dimensions, quantum mechanics “morphs into classical mechanics.”I cannot say, however, that the infinite-dimension system is a clarifying model to describe physical or chemical objects. I do not see that the reference to chromodynamics (and to Edward Witten’s article in Physics Today, July 1980, page 38) is a clarifying one. Far from convincing are statements like “Hence the large-D limit, where 1/D → 0, is closer to the real world (1/D = 1/3) than is the oft-used D = 1 regime. Indeed, results obtained at large D usually resemble those for D = 3.” I confess it sounds too lacking in rigor to be convincing.But the large-D limit per se is not what bothers me. Of great concern is the assumption that the radial part of the D-dimensional Schrödinger equation in Hartree units looks like this:(1)where Z is the nuclear charge and l is the angular momentum.Equation (1) has no sense for D = 1. Indeed, in one dimension, a finite angular momentum requires infinite speed of a rotating particle. Therefore, for D = 1, the correct equation is(2)which does not follow from equation (1) at D = 1.But most important is that equation (1) implies that the Coulomb potential does not depend on D. That could have been considered correct before it became clear that the Coulomb law follows from Maxwell’s equations when one considers a field generated by a point-like electric charge. So to obtain the Coulomb law for a two-dimensional space, one has to consider Maxwell equations in a two-dimensional world. For a point-like charge, those equations lead to a 1/(ln r) instead of 1/r dependence. If one takes into account the D-dependence of the Coulomb potential, derivations performed in the Physics Today article become meaningless. Indeed, when using an unrealistic equation (1), how can one believe that it illuminates Bohr’s quite realistic and physical postulates?© 2014 American Institute of Physics.
The mere existence of stable atoms, and their arrangement into many-atom nanoscale structures, can only be explained by the laws of quantum mechanics. Indeed, the accumulated evidence regarding the internal structure of atoms motivated the formulation of quantum mechanics at the early twentieth century. Here we focus on single-electron (hydrogen-like) atoms. The dominance of the Coulomb central potential between the electron and nucleus, translates into a simple Schrödinger equation for their relative position distribution. Solving rigorously this equation reveals quantized energy levels, which explains the emission spectra of hydrogen-like atoms (Rydberg formula). The corresponding stationary probability density distributions for the electron around the nucleus are reminiscent of the Bohr model, where classical trajectories (orbits) are replaced by single-electron wave functions (orbitals). The degeneracies of different orbitals, associated with three quantum numbers, will later turn out to be critical for understanding many-electron atoms and the periodic table of the elements.
The empirical description of spectral series in spectra by Rydberg and Ritz as well as the observation of the hydrogen spectrum by Balmer at the end of the 19th century have considerably boosted spectroscopy and have open the way to classical models of the atom like those of N. Bohr and A. Sommerfeld in a first step and then to the quantum descriptions of E. Schr¨odinger and finally of P. A. M. Dirac, in a second step. The study of Rydberg atoms has developed considerably in recent decades and multiple new research directions have emerged and concern fields as varied as precision measurements of fundamental constants, molecular physics, nonlinear quantum optics and quantum computing. New interesting perspectives have been made possible by the trapping and cooling of atoms and ions by laser. The terminology of the” circular atoms” is also defined and it is shown why transitions involving high n levels are interesting.