Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The One-Bit-Per-Point Identity: Exact Entanglement Entropy of the Sorkin-Johnston Vacuum — Correction (v2)

F.G.A. van den Berg

Published Jun 7, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

CORRECTION: The global identity Re P+ = (I - P0)/2 remains valid. The one-bit-per-point theorem, the claimed universal regional volume law with coefficient log 2, and the resulting no-go conclusions are withdrawn. The error was to apply a globally normalized projector after restriction to a region: normalization by |iDelta|^(-1/2) is generally nonlocal and does not commute with restriction. The Sorkin-Yazdi prescription restricts the physical Wightman function and commutator first, then solves the generalized eigenvalue problem. The original PDF is retained in the version history and is superseded by this correction for the regional entropy claims. The error was found during an independent check with Claude (AI) and reproduced independently with ChatGPT (AI); the author takes responsibility. The correction note states what remains valid, identifies the invalid restriction step, and reports the reproduced numerical behavior with the complete data and script.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.20583932

Related papers

Finite-size entanglement-entropy coefficients in a causal set depend on the joint global-regional spectral prescription: manuscript and reproducibility package

Glenn Pellegrin

Manuscript and complete reproducibility package for a preregistration-style numerical study of spectral truncation in causal-set spacetime entanglement entropy. Recovering continuum-compatible entanglement-entropy scaling on a causal set requires truncating the Sorkin-Johnston spectrum twice, once on the full causal set and again after restriction to the subregion. Published treatments apply both truncations at the same prescribed geometric scale. This study varies the two stages independently on nested causal diamonds in 2d Minkowski spacetime: 80 Poisson sprinklings at nominal cardinalities 500-4000 form the primary ensemble, with 10 further sprinklings at 8000 reserved for a secondary extrapolation check. Varying the regional cutoff at fixed global cutoff changes the fitted coefficient substantially and produces different compatibility classifications at the same global truncation, so the classification is a property of the joint prescription rather than of the global cutoff alone. Weight interventions that hold the retained subspace and the regional projector fixed produce slope changes that are statistically resolved yet practically equivalent within a prespecified margin. The package contains the analysis plan frozen before the production runs, both production records (5686 rows over 90 sprinklings, zero gate-failed rows), the driver, analysis and validation code, the regression and injection test suites, the frozen analysis output, a dated post-unblinding amendment with its code diff and corrected output, every supplementary analysis as a re-runnable script with its random stream recorded, the figure-generation code, a cell-level rank-retention census and reconciliation report, an eligibility census, and the environment and commands needed to regenerate every table in the manuscript. Contents are organised in seven folders: 1_frozen, 2_amendment_A1, 3_supplementary, 4_figures, 5_census_reconciliation, 6_environment, paper.MANIFEST.json lists a SHA-256 for all files and verify_manifest.py checks them. Evidentiary status. The deposit is retrospective. Hashes establish consistency between the deposited files and the production records, which embed the SHA-256 of the plan they ran under; they do not independently establish chronology. The pre-production freeze is author-reported and no independently timestamped commitment exists. Amendment A1 was made after all results and the frozen verdicts had been seen; the frozen output is the prespecified result and the corrected output is reported alongside it, never in its place. Key identifiers. Frozen analysis plan SHA-256dc6b8bdb3faa8450de3a710204ba18a72e4ed0be54639bae990d945b328a2bf5; primary production record4e3d3a58b6028531884c1de36eae15ac6d30146d1fb2599b150f898bbcf4051f; secondary production record8bf402ccc471ae9331a43d8e6f3bc383861599269922bfe89aa51f29430c5a33. Verified by extracting the archive and re-running: manifest 53/53 files, validation test suites pass, regression suite 35/35, and the frozen-path analysis reproduces every contrast and slope line of the original output.

•Sep 10, 2026•0 citations

The Offset Belongs to the Boundary: the trace split of the entanglement Hamiltonian, a measured Clausius region, and an offset with no bulk

Jeromie Beasley

For a region of a free-fermion ground state the entanglement Hamiltonian K_A = log[(1 - C_A) C_A^-1] splits into a part proportional to the identity and a trace-free remainder. The identity part shifts every level rigidly, so every observable built from level differences is blind to it. This paper is about that part. It is not a bulk quantity. The block carries one ladder per entangling cut, the trace is the difference of the two cut-phase charges, and on the exactly dimerised chain with a single cut carrying the whole charge it has the closed form 2 artanh(v / sqrt(v^2 + t^2)), derived in one line and measured to 10^-11. In exact arithmetic the trace is a definite number: zero to thirty-three digits when the two cut phases agree, and 0.786153199019314523 when they do not. The apparent divergence reported in earlier work was double-precision truncation of a finite sum, and is retired here. Along the two lines through the Rice-Mele plane where the half-line entanglement Hamiltonian is known in closed form, it is proportional to the Bisognano-Wichmann deformation T = (1/2){X, H} with no additive constant, and the ladder spacing and phase are fixed by the literature. Between those lines the commuting operator survives, measured at 10^-13 against controls that fail at 1.5 and 29, but the proportionality does not: the level map acquires an intercept b that is zero to 3 x 10^-9 on both lines and of order 10^-1 in the interior, and is identical whether the region has one entangling cut or two. That intercept is the measured failure of exact Bisognano-Wichmann proportionality. At first order in the staggering v the intercept is derived rather than fitted. The symbol's determinant is det(z - P) = z(z - 1) independently of momentum, so the factorisation is canonical everywhere; its logarithm is affine in an involution R = H/E with R^2 = I; the abelian Szego-type boundary functional is identically even in v and therefore cannot carry an odd intercept; and the first-order piece follows from the chiral zero mode of the dimerised chain, whose amplitudes are (-r)^j C(2j,j) 4^-j in closed form. The result is b/v = 2(E' - K')/(1 - r^2) + K', K' = K(1 - r^2), E' = E(1 - r^2), r = t1/t2, whose expansion in the modulus u is, in exact rationals, h(u)/(pi/8) = 1 - (5/8) u^2 - (9/64) u^4 - (65/1024) u^6 - (595/16384) u^8 - ... So pi/8, -5/8 and -9/64 are consequences rather than recognitions, and the natural elliptic candidate [9E - K]/16 - pi/8 is excluded by 7.7 percent on the first coefficient it does not get to choose. The closed form agrees with direct measurement extrapolated to v -> 0 by two to three orders better than the fitted series it replaces; a previously reported u^6 coefficient of -0.0648 is corrected here to -65/1024 and identified as truncation. The trace-free half is treated in parallel. A Clausius relation with a single temperature holds exactly when that half is proportional to the region's own Hamiltonian. At a ground state it never is, and the measured temperature is zero, which is correct rather than a failure. In a thermal state the same instrument returns 1/beta to five significant figures, and the boundary of the region where it does so collapses onto two dimensionless ratios. Two further results are included. The offset vanishes when the two cuts sit at the same phase in the unit cell, without requiring chirality, time reversal, inversion or cleanliness, and a mirror-symmetrised disordered chain gives a larger offset than its unsymmetrised control, which rules reflection out as the mechanism. And in two dimensions the offset is exactly additive along the boundary for a transverse coupling proportional to the identity in sublattice space, for a reason short enough to state, with a derived crossing past which additivity fails and a sigma_z coupling that breaks it smoothly. Every claim carries one of four grades: [T] proven here, [V] computationally verified with stated controls and a stated failure mode, [C] imported from the cited literature, [H] interpretation. The two exact lines, the commuting deformation, the boundary-locality of the entanglement spectrum, and the first law of entanglement entropy are not this work's and are used as given. Sixteen retired claims, including two withdrawn from earlier versions of this manuscript, are listed with the measurement that killed each. Files in this deposit: the_offset_belongs_to_the_boundary_v8_submission.pdf — 35 pages, gate output verbatim, script listings supplied separately. the_offset_belongs_to_the_boundary_v8_complete.pdf — 59 pages, identical body with all scripts printed inline. offset_v8_scripts.zip — 23 files. Every number quoted in the paper is printed by one of them; the two gate files reproduce their stored output byte for byte. KEYWORDS entanglement Hamiltonian; entanglement spectrum; modular Hamiltonian; Bisognano-Wichmann; Rice-Mele model; SSH model; free fermions; boundary charge; cut-phase charge; corner transfer matrix; Toeplitz operators; Wiener-Hopf factorisation; Szego-Widom asymptotics; algebraic Heun operator; complete elliptic integrals; entanglement first law; area law; Landau-Widom counting function ADDITIONAL NOTES Supersedes earlier versions of this manuscript. Two claims present in versions 1 to 3 are withdrawn and recorded in the kill list: that the incommensurate offset has no value, and that the offset is one quantum. Both were double-precision truncation of a finite sum. The u^6 coefficient of the shape function reported in the companion results ledger is likewise superseded by the derived value. Computational verification, gating and drafting assistance by an AI collaborator (Claude, Anthropic). Every gate is independently re-runnable from the ancillary scripts.

•Aug 31, 2026•0 citations

Entanglement entropy in causal set theory

Rafael D. Sorkin, Yasaman Kouchekzadeh Yazdi

Abstract Entanglement entropy is now widely accepted as having deep connections with quantum gravity. It is therefore desirable to understand it in the context of causal sets, especially since they provide in a natural manner the UV cutoff needed to render entanglement entropy finite. Formulating a notion of entanglement entropy in a causal set is not straightforward because the type of canonical hypersurface-data on which its definition typically relies is not available. Instead, we appeal to the more global expression given in Sorkin (2012 (arXiv:1205.2953)) which, for a Gaussian scalar field, expresses the entropy of a spacetime region in terms of the field’s correlation function within that region (its ‘Wightman function’ W ( x , x ′ ) ). Carrying this formula over to the causal set, one obtains an entropy which is both finite and of a Lorentz invariant nature. We evaluate this global entropy-expression numerically for certain regions (primarily order-intervals or ‘causal diamonds’) within causal sets of 1 + 1 dimensions. For the causal-set counterpart of the entanglement entropy, we obtain, in the first instance, a result that follows a (spacetime) volume law instead of the expected (spatial) area law. We find, however, that one obtains an area law if one truncates the commutator function (‘Pauli–Jordan operator’) and the Wightman function by projecting out the eigenmodes of the Pauli–Jordan operator whose eigenvalues are too close to zero according to a geometrical criterion which we describe more fully below. In connection with these results and the questions they raise, we also study the ‘entropy of coarse-graining’ generated by thinning out the causal set, and we compare it with what one obtains by similarly thinning out a chain of harmonic oscillators, finding the same, ‘universal’ behaviour in both cases.

arXiv:1611.10281•Classical and Quantum Gravity•Feb 19, 2018•47 citations

Crossed Cosmos / ECI v7.3.0 — SU(2) lattice Renyi-2 entanglement entropy BP2008b method validation

Kevin Remondière

⚠️ CORRECTION NOTICE (2026-07-12) - The central result of the abstract and Table I — c₃D(L=12)=0.1215±0.0034, agreeing with log(3)/(2π√2)≈0.1236 at 0.7σ — was produced by the Metropolis kernel deposited with this record (jax_su2_EE_BP2008b_FAST_2026-05-25.py), which contains two independent bugs confirmed the same day this paper was deposited: an SU(2) trace using K† instead of K, and a reversed staple order. A cold-start check on this code gives ⟨plaquette⟩≈−0.18 versus the expected ≈+0.62 at β=2.3 — the sampled configurations never thermalized to the intended Wilson ensemble.- This record was logged internally as "INVALIDE" on its own publication day; that status was never reflected here.- With both bugs fixed, the result is QUALITATIVELY different, not merely refined: κ_EE(SU2)=0.5065±0.010, growing LINEARLY in L (no plateau), corresponding under this paper's own normalization to c₃D≈0.253 — close to the Bekenstein-Hawking value 1/4, not to log(3)/(2π√2). The headline agreement claim is REVERSED.- The companion file PAPER_BP2008b_SU2_EE_JHEP.pdf bundled in this same record inherits the same issue.- The per-link Metropolis speed claim (item 4 of the abstract) is unaffected.``` Cross-lattice measurement of the entanglement entropy C-function in SU(2) 4D lattice gauge theory via Buividovich-Polikarpov alpha-integration. Key result: c_3D = S_2/(2 L_y L_z L_tau) converges monotonically to 0.1222 +/- 0.003 on L = 4,6,8,10,12 at beta=2.4, in 0.7-sigma agreement with the LQG/edge-mode formula log(3)/(2pi*sqrt(2)) = 0.1237 (Donnelly-Wall lattice prediction). Includes: - 4-page PRL letter (PAPER_CFUNCTION_PRL.pdf) - 18-page JHEP method paper (PAPER_BP2008b_SU2_EE_JHEP.pdf) - FAST V3 JAX/GPU code (10x speedup via per-link MH with local staples) - 4 failed methods documented honestly - Analysis script + raw data Method validation pedigree: 4 alternative methods (Donnelly-Wall swap=Jacobien-trivial, plaquette locking, soft A-tying divergent, BAR phase space mismatch) failed before the 5th (BP2008b single-lattice deformed connectivity + Fodor-Endrodi alpha-integration) succeeded. Author: Kevin Remondiere (ORCID 0009-0008-2443-7166), Independent Researcher, Oloron-Sainte-Marie, France.

•May 25, 2026•0 citations

Spacetime entanglement entropy in 1 + 1 dimensions

Mehdi Saravani, Rafael D. Sorkin, Yasaman K Yazdi

Sorkin (Expressing entropy globally in terms of (4D) field-correlations arXiv: 1205.2953 ) defines an entropy for a Gaussian scalar field ϕ in an arbitrary region of either a continuous spacetime or a causal set, given only the correlator within the region. The definition is global and independent of any choice of spacelike hypersurface. As a first application, we compute numerically the entanglement entropy in two cases where the asymptotic form is known or suspected from conformal field theory, finding excellent agreement when the required ultraviolet cutoff is implemented as a truncation on spacetime mode sums. We also show how the symmetry of entanglement entropy reflects the fact that RS and SR share the same eigenvalues, with R and S being arbitrary matrices.

arXiv:1311.7146•Classical and Quantum Gravity•Oct 21, 2014•35 citations

Entanglement at a two-dimensional quantum critical point: aT= 0 projector quantum Monte Carlo study

Stephen Inglis, Roger G. Melko

Although the leading-order scaling of entanglement entropy is non-universal at a quantum critical point (QCP), sub-leading scaling can contain universal behaviour. Such universal quantities are commonly studied in non-interacting field theories, however it typically requires numerical calculation to access them in interacting theories. In this paper, we use large-scale T = 0 quantum Monte Carlo simulations to examine in detail the second Rényi entropy of entangled regions at the QCP in the transverse-field Ising model in 2 + 1 space–time dimensions—a fixed point for which there is no exact result for the scaling of entanglement entropy. We calculate a universal coefficient of a vertex-induced logarithmic scaling for a polygonal entangled subregion, and compare the result to interacting and non-interacting theories. We also examine the shape-dependence of the Rényi entropy for finite-size toroidal lattices divided into two entangled cylinders by smooth boundaries. Remarkably, we find that the dependence on cylinder length follows a shape-dependent function calculated previously by Stephan et al (2013 New J. Phys. 15 015004) at the QCP corresponding to the 2 + 1 dimensional quantum Lifshitz free scalar field theory. The quality of the fit of our data to this scaling function, as well as the apparent cutoff-independent coefficient that results, presents tantalizing evidence that this function may reflect universal behaviour across these and other very disparate QCPs in 2 + 1 dimensional systems.

arXiv:1305.1069•New Journal of Physics•Jul 26, 2013•48 citations
CORRECTION: The global identity Re P+ = (I - P0)/2 remains valid. The one-bit-per-point theorem, the claimed universal regional volume law with coefficient log 2, and the resulting no-go conclusions are withdrawn. The error was to apply a globally normalized projector after restriction to a region: normalization by |iDelta|^(-1/2) is generally nonlocal and does not commute with restriction. The Sorkin-Yazdi prescription restricts the physical Wightman function and commutator first, then solves the generalized eigenvalue problem. The original PDF is retained in the version history and is superseded by this correction for the regional entropy claims. The error was found during an independent check with Claude (AI) and reproduced independently with ChatGPT (AI); the author takes responsibility. The correction note states what remains valid, identifies the invalid restriction step, and reports the reproduced numerical behavior with the complete data and script.
Manuscript and complete reproducibility package for a preregistration-style numerical study of spectral truncation in causal-set spacetime entanglement entropy. Recovering continuum-compatible entanglement-entropy scaling on a causal set requires truncating the Sorkin-Johnston spectrum twice, once on the full causal set and again after restriction to the subregion. Published treatments apply both truncations at the same prescribed geometric scale. This study varies the two stages independently on nested causal diamonds in 2d Minkowski spacetime: 80 Poisson sprinklings at nominal cardinalities 500-4000 form the primary ensemble, with 10 further sprinklings at 8000 reserved for a secondary extrapolation check. Varying the regional cutoff at fixed global cutoff changes the fitted coefficient substantially and produces different compatibility classifications at the same global truncation, so the classification is a property of the joint prescription rather than of the global cutoff alone. Weight interventions that hold the retained subspace and the regional projector fixed produce slope changes that are statistically resolved yet practically equivalent within a prespecified margin. The package contains the analysis plan frozen before the production runs, both production records (5686 rows over 90 sprinklings, zero gate-failed rows), the driver, analysis and validation code, the regression and injection test suites, the frozen analysis output, a dated post-unblinding amendment with its code diff and corrected output, every supplementary analysis as a re-runnable script with its random stream recorded, the figure-generation code, a cell-level rank-retention census and reconciliation report, an eligibility census, and the environment and commands needed to regenerate every table in the manuscript. Contents are organised in seven folders: 1_frozen, 2_amendment_A1, 3_supplementary, 4_figures, 5_census_reconciliation, 6_environment, paper.MANIFEST.json lists a SHA-256 for all files and verify_manifest.py checks them. Evidentiary status. The deposit is retrospective. Hashes establish consistency between the deposited files and the production records, which embed the SHA-256 of the plan they ran under; they do not independently establish chronology. The pre-production freeze is author-reported and no independently timestamped commitment exists. Amendment A1 was made after all results and the frozen verdicts had been seen; the frozen output is the prespecified result and the corrected output is reported alongside it, never in its place. Key identifiers. Frozen analysis plan SHA-256dc6b8bdb3faa8450de3a710204ba18a72e4ed0be54639bae990d945b328a2bf5; primary production record4e3d3a58b6028531884c1de36eae15ac6d30146d1fb2599b150f898bbcf4051f; secondary production record8bf402ccc471ae9331a43d8e6f3bc383861599269922bfe89aa51f29430c5a33. Verified by extracting the archive and re-running: manifest 53/53 files, validation test suites pass, regression suite 35/35, and the frozen-path analysis reproduces every contrast and slope line of the original output.
For a region of a free-fermion ground state the entanglement Hamiltonian K_A = log[(1 - C_A) C_A^-1] splits into a part proportional to the identity and a trace-free remainder. The identity part shifts every level rigidly, so every observable built from level differences is blind to it. This paper is about that part. It is not a bulk quantity. The block carries one ladder per entangling cut, the trace is the difference of the two cut-phase charges, and on the exactly dimerised chain with a single cut carrying the whole charge it has the closed form 2 artanh(v / sqrt(v^2 + t^2)), derived in one line and measured to 10^-11. In exact arithmetic the trace is a definite number: zero to thirty-three digits when the two cut phases agree, and 0.786153199019314523 when they do not. The apparent divergence reported in earlier work was double-precision truncation of a finite sum, and is retired here. Along the two lines through the Rice-Mele plane where the half-line entanglement Hamiltonian is known in closed form, it is proportional to the Bisognano-Wichmann deformation T = (1/2){X, H} with no additive constant, and the ladder spacing and phase are fixed by the literature. Between those lines the commuting operator survives, measured at 10^-13 against controls that fail at 1.5 and 29, but the proportionality does not: the level map acquires an intercept b that is zero to 3 x 10^-9 on both lines and of order 10^-1 in the interior, and is identical whether the region has one entangling cut or two. That intercept is the measured failure of exact Bisognano-Wichmann proportionality. At first order in the staggering v the intercept is derived rather than fitted. The symbol's determinant is det(z - P) = z(z - 1) independently of momentum, so the factorisation is canonical everywhere; its logarithm is affine in an involution R = H/E with R^2 = I; the abelian Szego-type boundary functional is identically even in v and therefore cannot carry an odd intercept; and the first-order piece follows from the chiral zero mode of the dimerised chain, whose amplitudes are (-r)^j C(2j,j) 4^-j in closed form. The result is b/v = 2(E' - K')/(1 - r^2) + K', K' = K(1 - r^2), E' = E(1 - r^2), r = t1/t2, whose expansion in the modulus u is, in exact rationals, h(u)/(pi/8) = 1 - (5/8) u^2 - (9/64) u^4 - (65/1024) u^6 - (595/16384) u^8 - ... So pi/8, -5/8 and -9/64 are consequences rather than recognitions, and the natural elliptic candidate [9E - K]/16 - pi/8 is excluded by 7.7 percent on the first coefficient it does not get to choose. The closed form agrees with direct measurement extrapolated to v -> 0 by two to three orders better than the fitted series it replaces; a previously reported u^6 coefficient of -0.0648 is corrected here to -65/1024 and identified as truncation. The trace-free half is treated in parallel. A Clausius relation with a single temperature holds exactly when that half is proportional to the region's own Hamiltonian. At a ground state it never is, and the measured temperature is zero, which is correct rather than a failure. In a thermal state the same instrument returns 1/beta to five significant figures, and the boundary of the region where it does so collapses onto two dimensionless ratios. Two further results are included. The offset vanishes when the two cuts sit at the same phase in the unit cell, without requiring chirality, time reversal, inversion or cleanliness, and a mirror-symmetrised disordered chain gives a larger offset than its unsymmetrised control, which rules reflection out as the mechanism. And in two dimensions the offset is exactly additive along the boundary for a transverse coupling proportional to the identity in sublattice space, for a reason short enough to state, with a derived crossing past which additivity fails and a sigma_z coupling that breaks it smoothly. Every claim carries one of four grades: [T] proven here, [V] computationally verified with stated controls and a stated failure mode, [C] imported from the cited literature, [H] interpretation. The two exact lines, the commuting deformation, the boundary-locality of the entanglement spectrum, and the first law of entanglement entropy are not this work's and are used as given. Sixteen retired claims, including two withdrawn from earlier versions of this manuscript, are listed with the measurement that killed each. Files in this deposit: the_offset_belongs_to_the_boundary_v8_submission.pdf — 35 pages, gate output verbatim, script listings supplied separately. the_offset_belongs_to_the_boundary_v8_complete.pdf — 59 pages, identical body with all scripts printed inline. offset_v8_scripts.zip — 23 files. Every number quoted in the paper is printed by one of them; the two gate files reproduce their stored output byte for byte. KEYWORDS entanglement Hamiltonian; entanglement spectrum; modular Hamiltonian; Bisognano-Wichmann; Rice-Mele model; SSH model; free fermions; boundary charge; cut-phase charge; corner transfer matrix; Toeplitz operators; Wiener-Hopf factorisation; Szego-Widom asymptotics; algebraic Heun operator; complete elliptic integrals; entanglement first law; area law; Landau-Widom counting function ADDITIONAL NOTES Supersedes earlier versions of this manuscript. Two claims present in versions 1 to 3 are withdrawn and recorded in the kill list: that the incommensurate offset has no value, and that the offset is one quantum. Both were double-precision truncation of a finite sum. The u^6 coefficient of the shape function reported in the companion results ledger is likewise superseded by the derived value. Computational verification, gating and drafting assistance by an AI collaborator (Claude, Anthropic). Every gate is independently re-runnable from the ancillary scripts.
Abstract Entanglement entropy is now widely accepted as having deep connections with quantum gravity. It is therefore desirable to understand it in the context of causal sets, especially since they provide in a natural manner the UV cutoff needed to render entanglement entropy finite. Formulating a notion of entanglement entropy in a causal set is not straightforward because the type of canonical hypersurface-data on which its definition typically relies is not available. Instead, we appeal to the more global expression given in Sorkin (2012 (arXiv:1205.2953)) which, for a Gaussian scalar field, expresses the entropy of a spacetime region in terms of the field’s correlation function within that region (its ‘Wightman function’ W ( x , x ′ ) ). Carrying this formula over to the causal set, one obtains an entropy which is both finite and of a Lorentz invariant nature. We evaluate this global entropy-expression numerically for certain regions (primarily order-intervals or ‘causal diamonds’) within causal sets of 1 + 1 dimensions. For the causal-set counterpart of the entanglement entropy, we obtain, in the first instance, a result that follows a (spacetime) volume law instead of the expected (spatial) area law. We find, however, that one obtains an area law if one truncates the commutator function (‘Pauli–Jordan operator’) and the Wightman function by projecting out the eigenmodes of the Pauli–Jordan operator whose eigenvalues are too close to zero according to a geometrical criterion which we describe more fully below. In connection with these results and the questions they raise, we also study the ‘entropy of coarse-graining’ generated by thinning out the causal set, and we compare it with what one obtains by similarly thinning out a chain of harmonic oscillators, finding the same, ‘universal’ behaviour in both cases.
⚠️ CORRECTION NOTICE (2026-07-12) - The central result of the abstract and Table I — c₃D(L=12)=0.1215±0.0034, agreeing with log(3)/(2π√2)≈0.1236 at 0.7σ — was produced by the Metropolis kernel deposited with this record (jax_su2_EE_BP2008b_FAST_2026-05-25.py), which contains two independent bugs confirmed the same day this paper was deposited: an SU(2) trace using K† instead of K, and a reversed staple order. A cold-start check on this code gives ⟨plaquette⟩≈−0.18 versus the expected ≈+0.62 at β=2.3 — the sampled configurations never thermalized to the intended Wilson ensemble.- This record was logged internally as "INVALIDE" on its own publication day; that status was never reflected here.- With both bugs fixed, the result is QUALITATIVELY different, not merely refined: κ_EE(SU2)=0.5065±0.010, growing LINEARLY in L (no plateau), corresponding under this paper's own normalization to c₃D≈0.253 — close to the Bekenstein-Hawking value 1/4, not to log(3)/(2π√2). The headline agreement claim is REVERSED.- The companion file PAPER_BP2008b_SU2_EE_JHEP.pdf bundled in this same record inherits the same issue.- The per-link Metropolis speed claim (item 4 of the abstract) is unaffected.``` Cross-lattice measurement of the entanglement entropy C-function in SU(2) 4D lattice gauge theory via Buividovich-Polikarpov alpha-integration. Key result: c_3D = S_2/(2 L_y L_z L_tau) converges monotonically to 0.1222 +/- 0.003 on L = 4,6,8,10,12 at beta=2.4, in 0.7-sigma agreement with the LQG/edge-mode formula log(3)/(2pi*sqrt(2)) = 0.1237 (Donnelly-Wall lattice prediction). Includes: - 4-page PRL letter (PAPER_CFUNCTION_PRL.pdf) - 18-page JHEP method paper (PAPER_BP2008b_SU2_EE_JHEP.pdf) - FAST V3 JAX/GPU code (10x speedup via per-link MH with local staples) - 4 failed methods documented honestly - Analysis script + raw data Method validation pedigree: 4 alternative methods (Donnelly-Wall swap=Jacobien-trivial, plaquette locking, soft A-tying divergent, BAR phase space mismatch) failed before the 5th (BP2008b single-lattice deformed connectivity + Fodor-Endrodi alpha-integration) succeeded. Author: Kevin Remondiere (ORCID 0009-0008-2443-7166), Independent Researcher, Oloron-Sainte-Marie, France.
Sorkin (Expressing entropy globally in terms of (4D) field-correlations arXiv: 1205.2953 ) defines an entropy for a Gaussian scalar field ϕ in an arbitrary region of either a continuous spacetime or a causal set, given only the correlator within the region. The definition is global and independent of any choice of spacelike hypersurface. As a first application, we compute numerically the entanglement entropy in two cases where the asymptotic form is known or suspected from conformal field theory, finding excellent agreement when the required ultraviolet cutoff is implemented as a truncation on spacetime mode sums. We also show how the symmetry of entanglement entropy reflects the fact that RS and SR share the same eigenvalues, with R and S being arbitrary matrices.
Although the leading-order scaling of entanglement entropy is non-universal at a quantum critical point (QCP), sub-leading scaling can contain universal behaviour. Such universal quantities are commonly studied in non-interacting field theories, however it typically requires numerical calculation to access them in interacting theories. In this paper, we use large-scale T = 0 quantum Monte Carlo simulations to examine in detail the second Rényi entropy of entangled regions at the QCP in the transverse-field Ising model in 2 + 1 space–time dimensions—a fixed point for which there is no exact result for the scaling of entanglement entropy. We calculate a universal coefficient of a vertex-induced logarithmic scaling for a polygonal entangled subregion, and compare the result to interacting and non-interacting theories. We also examine the shape-dependence of the Rényi entropy for finite-size toroidal lattices divided into two entangled cylinders by smooth boundaries. Remarkably, we find that the dependence on cylinder length follows a shape-dependent function calculated previously by Stephan et al (2013 New J. Phys. 15 015004) at the QCP corresponding to the 2 + 1 dimensional quantum Lifshitz free scalar field theory. The quality of the fit of our data to this scaling function, as well as the apparent cutoff-independent coefficient that results, presents tantalizing evidence that this function may reflect universal behaviour across these and other very disparate QCPs in 2 + 1 dimensional systems.