Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Optics Express

Counterintuitive causal structures in inter-chip photonic quantum computing

Yaxuan Wang, Yizhi Wang, Dongyang Wang, Junjie Wu

Published Jun 5, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Causal theory provides a consistent framework for describing relations among events or variables, and has recently been applied to quantum systems. Here, we apply causal analysis to the remote-controlled quantum computing model and uncover a bidirectional causal structure rooted in quantum entanglement, which inherently admits a counterintuitive causal component. Unlike the unidirectional causal structure in classical computing, this framework allows the quantum operation to precede-and causally influence-the parameters that nominally control it, thereby exhibiting counterintuitive causal behavior. We experimentally verify this phenomenon on two photonic chips connected by two 15-meter fibers, achieving an average fidelity of 90.43±2.42% over 100 single-qubit unitaries. Timing analysis further shows that, in our setup, the control parameter can theoretically lag behind the operation by 129.14 ns. To our knowledge, this is the first systematic use of causal modeling to analyze and experimentally reveal the non-classical causal features induced by quantum entanglement in a quantum computing setting, with implications for both quantum computing and causal inference theory.

DOI
10.1364/oe.589703

Related papers

Experimental test of quantum causal influences

Iris Agresti, Davide Poderini, Beatrice Polacchi +8 more

Since Bell's theorem, it is known that local realism fails to explain quantum phenomena. Bell inequality violations manifestly show the incompatibility of quantum theory with classical notions of cause and effect. As recently found, however, the instrumental scenario-a pivotal tool in causal inference-allows for nonclassicality signatures going beyond this paradigm. If we are not limited to observational data and can intervene in our setup, then we can witness quantum violations of classical bounds on the causal influence among the involved variables even when no Bell-like violation is possible. That is, through interventions, the quantum behavior of a system that would seem classical can be demonstrated. Using a photonic setup-faithfully implementing the instrumental causal structure and switching between observation and intervention run by run-we experimentally witness such a nonclassicality. We also test quantum bounds for the causal influence, showing that they provide a reliable tool for quantum causal modeling.

arXiv:2108.08926•Science Advances•Feb 25, 2022•23 citations

Optical Causal Structure Measurement

Jincheng Zhang

The measurement of causal relationships within an optical field is a fundamental challenge that bridges quantum optics, photonics, and the theory of causality. This paper proposes a systematic framework for identifying and quantifying the causal structure between discrete optical events in a complex light network. Central to the approach is the construction of a causal matrix C_{ij} that represents the probability of event i causing event j, conditioned on the measurement of photon correlations, time‑stamping, and spatial mode overlap. By exploiting high‑resolution detectors and engineered photonic pathways, the framework can resolve causality in real time, even when multiple photons interfere within integrated photonic circuits. The potential for uncovering deep causal links in photonic systems suggests a pathway to Nobel‑level discoveries, unifying the physics of light with the emerging discipline of causal inference.

•Aug 17, 2026•0 citations

Realization of algorithmic identification of cause and effect in quantum correlations

Zhaoan Wang, Yu Meng, Zhenghao Liu +10 more

Causal inference revealing causal dependencies between variables from empirical data has found applications in multiple subfields of scientific research. A quantum perspective of correlations holds the promise of overcoming the limitation of Reichenbach's principle and enabling causal inference with only observational data. However, it is still not clear how quantum causal inference can provide operational advantages in general cases. Here, we have devised a photonic setup and experimentally realized an algorithm capable of identifying any two-qubit statistical correlations generated by the two basic causal structures under an observational scenario, thus revealing a universal quantum advantage in causal inference over its classical counterpart. We further demonstrate the explainability and stability of our causal discovery method, which is widely sought in data processing algorithms. Employing a fully observational approach, our result paves the way for studying quantum causality in general settings.

arXiv:2304.10192•Physical Review A•Jan 3, 2024•0 citations

Causal Discovery of Photonic Bell Experiments

Patrick Daley

A causal understanding of a physical theory is vital. They provide profound insights into the implications of the theory and contain the information required to manipulate, not only predict, our surroundings. Unfortunately, one of the most broadly used and successful theories, quantum theory, continues to evade a satisfactory causal description. The progress is hindered by the difficulty of faithfully testing causal explanations in an experimental setting. This thesis presents a novel causal discovery algorithm which allows a direct comparison of a wide variety of causal explanations for experimental data. They include causal influences both classical and quantum mechanical in nature. First we provide relevant background information, predominately on quantum mechanics, quantum optics and statistical inference. Next, we review the framework of classical causality and the connection between a causal assumption and statistical model. We then present a novel causal discovery algorithm for noisy experimental data. Finally, we perform two Bell experiments and apply the newly developed algorithm on the resulting data. \nThe causal discovery algorithm operates on observational data without any interven- tions required. It utilizes the concept of predictive accuracy to assign a score to each causal explanation. This allows the simultaneous consideration of classical and quantum causal theories. In addition, this approach allows the identification of overly complex explanations as these perform poorly with respect to this criterion. \nBoth experiments are implemented using quantum optics. The first Bell experiment has a near maximally entangled shared resource state while the second has a separable resource state. The results indicate that a quantum local causal explanation bests describes the first experiment, whereas a classical local causal explanation is preferred for the second. A super-luminal or super-deterministic theory are sub-optimal for both.

•Jan 13, 2020•0 citations

Cyclic quantum causal models

Jonathan Barrett, Robin Lorenz, Ognyan Oreshkov

Causal reasoning is essential to science, yet quantum theory challenges it. Quantum correlations violating Bell inequalities defy satisfactory causal explanations within the framework of classical causal models. What is more, a theory encompassing quantum systems and gravity is expected to allow causally nonseparable processes featuring operations in indefinite causal order, defying that events be causally ordered at all. The first challenge has been addressed through the recent development of intrinsically quantum causal models, allowing causal explanations of quantum processes - provided they admit a definite causal order, i.e. have an acyclic causal structure. This work addresses causally nonseparable processes and offers a causal perspective on them through extending quantum causal models to cyclic causal structures. Among other applications of the approach, it is shown that all unitarily extendible bipartite processes are causally separable and that for unitary processes, causal nonseparability and cyclicity of their causal structure are equivalent.

arXiv:2002.12157•Nature Communications•Feb 9, 2021•96 citations

Quantum entanglement dynamics in multi-photon systems: A theoretical framework for enhanced quantum computing

Dr. Lakshmi Narasappa

Quantum entanglement represents a fundamental resource for quantum information processing, yet the dynamics of multi-photon entangled systems remain inadequately characterized for practical quantum computing applications. This research investigates the generation, manipulation, and characterization of entangled states involving two to eight photons using spontaneous parametric down-conversion techniques. Through theoretical analysis and numerical simulations, we developed a comprehensive framework that quantifies entanglement fidelity, decoherence rates, and Bell inequality violations across various multi-photon configurations. Our findings reveal that entanglement fidelity decreases exponentially with increasing photon number, exhibiting a decay constant of 0.087±0.012 per additional qubit in optical systems. The research demonstrates significant variations in decoherence times across different physical implementations, with ion trap systems maintaining coherence 1.7 times longer than photonic platforms for equivalent qubit numbers. We established mathematical relationships between system parameters and entanglement quality metrics, identifying critical thresholds for fault-tolerant quantum gate operations. The theoretical framework incorporates realistic noise models, environmental coupling mechanisms, and measurement-induced perturbations that affect practical implementations. Our analysis indicates that five-photon entangled states maintain sufficient fidelity (>83.5%) for error-corrected quantum algorithms when decoherence times exceed 75 microseconds. These results provide essential guidelines for designing scalable quantum processors and establishing benchmarks for experimental validation of multi-qubit entanglement protocols.

International Journal of Physics and Mathematics•Jan 1, 2022•0 citations
Causal theory provides a consistent framework for describing relations among events or variables, and has recently been applied to quantum systems. Here, we apply causal analysis to the remote-controlled quantum computing model and uncover a bidirectional causal structure rooted in quantum entanglement, which inherently admits a counterintuitive causal component. Unlike the unidirectional causal structure in classical computing, this framework allows the quantum operation to precede-and causally influence-the parameters that nominally control it, thereby exhibiting counterintuitive causal behavior. We experimentally verify this phenomenon on two photonic chips connected by two 15-meter fibers, achieving an average fidelity of 90.43±2.42% over 100 single-qubit unitaries. Timing analysis further shows that, in our setup, the control parameter can theoretically lag behind the operation by 129.14 ns. To our knowledge, this is the first systematic use of causal modeling to analyze and experimentally reveal the non-classical causal features induced by quantum entanglement in a quantum computing setting, with implications for both quantum computing and causal inference theory.
Since Bell's theorem, it is known that local realism fails to explain quantum phenomena. Bell inequality violations manifestly show the incompatibility of quantum theory with classical notions of cause and effect. As recently found, however, the instrumental scenario-a pivotal tool in causal inference-allows for nonclassicality signatures going beyond this paradigm. If we are not limited to observational data and can intervene in our setup, then we can witness quantum violations of classical bounds on the causal influence among the involved variables even when no Bell-like violation is possible. That is, through interventions, the quantum behavior of a system that would seem classical can be demonstrated. Using a photonic setup-faithfully implementing the instrumental causal structure and switching between observation and intervention run by run-we experimentally witness such a nonclassicality. We also test quantum bounds for the causal influence, showing that they provide a reliable tool for quantum causal modeling.
The measurement of causal relationships within an optical field is a fundamental challenge that bridges quantum optics, photonics, and the theory of causality. This paper proposes a systematic framework for identifying and quantifying the causal structure between discrete optical events in a complex light network. Central to the approach is the construction of a causal matrix C_{ij} that represents the probability of event i causing event j, conditioned on the measurement of photon correlations, time‑stamping, and spatial mode overlap. By exploiting high‑resolution detectors and engineered photonic pathways, the framework can resolve causality in real time, even when multiple photons interfere within integrated photonic circuits. The potential for uncovering deep causal links in photonic systems suggests a pathway to Nobel‑level discoveries, unifying the physics of light with the emerging discipline of causal inference.
Causal inference revealing causal dependencies between variables from empirical data has found applications in multiple subfields of scientific research. A quantum perspective of correlations holds the promise of overcoming the limitation of Reichenbach's principle and enabling causal inference with only observational data. However, it is still not clear how quantum causal inference can provide operational advantages in general cases. Here, we have devised a photonic setup and experimentally realized an algorithm capable of identifying any two-qubit statistical correlations generated by the two basic causal structures under an observational scenario, thus revealing a universal quantum advantage in causal inference over its classical counterpart. We further demonstrate the explainability and stability of our causal discovery method, which is widely sought in data processing algorithms. Employing a fully observational approach, our result paves the way for studying quantum causality in general settings.
A causal understanding of a physical theory is vital. They provide profound insights into the implications of the theory and contain the information required to manipulate, not only predict, our surroundings. Unfortunately, one of the most broadly used and successful theories, quantum theory, continues to evade a satisfactory causal description. The progress is hindered by the difficulty of faithfully testing causal explanations in an experimental setting. This thesis presents a novel causal discovery algorithm which allows a direct comparison of a wide variety of causal explanations for experimental data. They include causal influences both classical and quantum mechanical in nature. First we provide relevant background information, predominately on quantum mechanics, quantum optics and statistical inference. Next, we review the framework of classical causality and the connection between a causal assumption and statistical model. We then present a novel causal discovery algorithm for noisy experimental data. Finally, we perform two Bell experiments and apply the newly developed algorithm on the resulting data. \nThe causal discovery algorithm operates on observational data without any interven- tions required. It utilizes the concept of predictive accuracy to assign a score to each causal explanation. This allows the simultaneous consideration of classical and quantum causal theories. In addition, this approach allows the identification of overly complex explanations as these perform poorly with respect to this criterion. \nBoth experiments are implemented using quantum optics. The first Bell experiment has a near maximally entangled shared resource state while the second has a separable resource state. The results indicate that a quantum local causal explanation bests describes the first experiment, whereas a classical local causal explanation is preferred for the second. A super-luminal or super-deterministic theory are sub-optimal for both.
Causal reasoning is essential to science, yet quantum theory challenges it. Quantum correlations violating Bell inequalities defy satisfactory causal explanations within the framework of classical causal models. What is more, a theory encompassing quantum systems and gravity is expected to allow causally nonseparable processes featuring operations in indefinite causal order, defying that events be causally ordered at all. The first challenge has been addressed through the recent development of intrinsically quantum causal models, allowing causal explanations of quantum processes - provided they admit a definite causal order, i.e. have an acyclic causal structure. This work addresses causally nonseparable processes and offers a causal perspective on them through extending quantum causal models to cyclic causal structures. Among other applications of the approach, it is shown that all unitarily extendible bipartite processes are causally separable and that for unitary processes, causal nonseparability and cyclicity of their causal structure are equivalent.
Quantum entanglement represents a fundamental resource for quantum information processing, yet the dynamics of multi-photon entangled systems remain inadequately characterized for practical quantum computing applications. This research investigates the generation, manipulation, and characterization of entangled states involving two to eight photons using spontaneous parametric down-conversion techniques. Through theoretical analysis and numerical simulations, we developed a comprehensive framework that quantifies entanglement fidelity, decoherence rates, and Bell inequality violations across various multi-photon configurations. Our findings reveal that entanglement fidelity decreases exponentially with increasing photon number, exhibiting a decay constant of 0.087±0.012 per additional qubit in optical systems. The research demonstrates significant variations in decoherence times across different physical implementations, with ion trap systems maintaining coherence 1.7 times longer than photonic platforms for equivalent qubit numbers. We established mathematical relationships between system parameters and entanglement quality metrics, identifying critical thresholds for fault-tolerant quantum gate operations. The theoretical framework incorporates realistic noise models, environmental coupling mechanisms, and measurement-induced perturbations that affect practical implementations. Our analysis indicates that five-photon entangled states maintain sufficient fidelity (>83.5%) for error-corrected quantum algorithms when decoherence times exceed 75 microseconds. These results provide essential guidelines for designing scalable quantum processors and establishing benchmarks for experimental validation of multi-qubit entanglement protocols.