Quantum-resource language is often triggered by a nonzero diagnostic marker: a complementarity residual, a coherencepattern, a protected Liouvillian mode, a Fisher-information increase, or a nonstabilizer witness. In open, noisy,monitored, or partially identifiable systems, this shortcut is unsafe. The same marker can remain positive after theinterpretation attached to an ideal calibration limit has become invalid, invisible to the available detector, or dependenton additional model assumptions. We formulate a conservative framework of operational support layers. A resourceclaim is specified not by a marker alone, but by a marker together with the support, readout, calibration, encoding,or identifiability layer that licenses its interpretation. The framework introduces marker-support pairs, unsupportedmarkerregions, a non-converse rule for failed layer tests, and a practical claim protocol. Four technical pillars organizethe discussion: complementarity residuals require entanglement-support tests; qutrit coherence geometries require calibrationand model-identifiability layers; persistent Liouvillian modes require detector-relative readability; and Fishergrowth requires encoding-aware classification. The resulting grammar separates what exists formally, what is resourcesupported,what is readable, and what is identifiable from the available data, and it supplies a referee-facing checklistfor avoiding unsupported resource claims in quantum-technology settings.
Quantum-resource language is often triggered by a nonzero diagnostic marker: a complementarity residual, a coherencepattern, a protected Liouvillian mode, a Fisher-information increase, or a nonstabilizer witness. In open, noisy,monitored, or partially identifiable systems, this shortcut is unsafe. The same marker can remain positive after theinterpretation attached to an ideal calibration limit has become invalid, invisible to the available detector, or dependenton additional model assumptions. We formulate a conservative framework of operational support layers. A resourceclaim is specified not by a marker alone, but by a marker together with the support, readout, calibration, encoding,or identifiability layer that licenses its interpretation. The framework introduces marker-support pairs, unsupportedmarkerregions, a non-converse rule for failed layer tests, and a practical claim protocol. Four technical pillars organizethe discussion: complementarity residuals require entanglement-support tests; qutrit coherence geometries require calibrationand model-identifiability layers; persistent Liouvillian modes require detector-relative readability; and Fishergrowth requires encoding-aware classification. The resulting grammar separates what exists formally, what is resourcesupported,what is readable, and what is identifiable from the available data, and it supplies a referee-facing checklistfor avoiding unsupported resource claims in quantum-technology settings.
Complementarity residuals quantify local-information budgets that can coincide with entanglement remainders in calibrated pure-state settings. In noisy and mixed multipartite systems, however, the same residual can remain positive even after the resource interpretation inherited from the pure-state limit is no longer justified. This preprint analyzes that change of meaning and introduces a support-layer diagnostic for complementarity residuals under mixedness. The paper separates three logical levels: the residual itself, the independent support layer, and the resource-specific interpretation that is allowed only when both are present. In the pure three-qubit calibration limit, the residual agrees with a known residual-tangle interpretation. In mixed four-qubit white-noise families, however, the residual can remain finite after the chosen all-cut NPT support layer has disappeared. A separable product-state construction further shows that local mixedness alone can generate a positive residual, so the residual is not an entanglement witness and not a genuine multipartite entanglement witness. The result is an operational hierarchy for noisy multipartite quantum states. A positive complementarity residual flags unresolved local-information budget, while independent support tests determine whether an entanglement-related interpretation is justified. The approach is intended as a safe diagnostic protocol: it preserves the usefulness of complementarity residuals while preventing overinterpretation in regimes where mixedness, local decoherence, environmental correlations, or classical mixing contribute to the observed residual.
This paper develops an engineering-facing diagnostic bridge between the recoverability-based theory of structural irreversibility and practical evaluation in quantum error correction and monitored quantum platforms. The central problem addressed in this work is that structural recoverability, threshold-like margins, false-collapse, and Recoverability Index–type diagnostics provide useful theoretical distinctions, but they do not by themselves specify how experimentalists or engineers should organize platform-level data, compare regimes, or report recoverability-relevant behavior. The paper therefore introduces a proxy map from structural quantities to engineering diagnostics. Generalized recoverability is associated with recovery performance, decoder-assisted restoration, logical-state fidelity, and related reconstruction-sensitive quantities. Threshold-like margins are associated with entropy-like, noise-sensitive, or transition-localizing proxies. False-collapse is associated with mismatch windows in which collapse-like or transition-like indicators become strong while recovery-sensitive records still indicate residual recoverability. The paper also proposes a minimal diagnostic architecture for QEC and monitored platforms. This architecture consists of four layers: an appearance-sensitive proxy, a recoverability-sensitive proxy, a threshold-like locator, and a window-based reporting layer. Together, these layers support regime classification, early-warning detection, false-collapse-like mismatch identification, finite-window reporting, and cross-regime comparison. A QEC-oriented realization is presented to show how syndrome histories, logical-failure markers, logical recovery performance, entropy-like proxies, false-collapse window frequencies, and RI-like summaries can be organized into a coherent diagnostic workflow. The goal is not to replace detailed decoder analysis or hardware-specific benchmarking, but to provide a bridge-level language for deciding what should be logged, estimated, compared, and reported when studying the approach to effective irreversibility in error-managed quantum systems. This work should be read as an engineering and experimental companion to the broader recoverability program. Its contribution is to make structural irreversibility operationally legible by mapping theoretical quantities to measurable, computable, and reportable diagnostics in contemporary quantum platforms.
Quantum mechanics supplies outcome probabilities through the Born rule, while measurement physics describes how interactions, decoherence, amplification, and environmental encoding produce records. We reformulate quantum admissibility around the distinction between quantum support, Born probability, operational record support, and realized record. The reformulation is motivated by a no-go result for a legacy strong ansatz in which Born probabilities are multiplied by an independently specified scalar admissibility factor: independence from the Born distribution together with arbitrary coarse-graining consistency forces that factor to be uniform, while the corresponding positive-operator construction reduces to an ordinary quantum state update. Rather than replacing this failed weighting by an unstructured support predicate, we connect record support explicitly to existing quantum-to-classical formalisms. Quantum-Darwinist redundancy, classically accessible information, quantum discord, and distance to spectrum-broadcast structure provide a context-dependent operational record profile from which prospectively specified support criteria can be constructed without modifying the Born rule. We also show why Bell correlations cannot supply the missing content of a binary support relation: a non-product joint support set is shared by classically correlated systems, while generic Bell-violating distributions may have full Cartesian support and differ only in their probabilityweights. Bell and no-signaling therefore constrain any future probability-modifying extension but do not establish relational realization as a new physical quantity. The resulting framework has three levels: a conceptual grammar, an operational record-support layer entirely within standard quantum theory, and a distinct strong route requiring independently predicted deviations from the best standard quantum-plus-apparatus model. The principal claim is consequently a boundary result: objective record support can be operationalized without a second probability law, whereas the natural scalar attempt to convert such support into probability reweighting is stronglyconstrained.
This preprint studies operational equivalence and recovery in a twenty-dimensional residual system with a fixed four-sector representation of dimensions 8, 8, 2 and 2. It distinguishes what a declared observation algebra can detect, what a channel preserves, and what a retained classical record makes recoverable. Record-resolved criteria separate useful reversible-error records from unrelated labels and measured-sector records, even when the discarded channel is the same. For a specified coarse-record model, the work identifies exactly recoverable observable algebras and proves an optimal entanglement-fidelity expression on a fixed four-state orbit code. Preparation-aware recovery is then classified over all one-use isometric subspaces in the stated family. An explicit ten-dimensional marker code attains exact recovery under a specified stochastic record where the whole-sector support restriction permits only eight dimensions. Its encoding, nonbaseline marker measurement, and conditional inverse operations remain supplied resources. Scoped Lean evidence verifies the explicit arbitrary-complex-matrix recovery construction and related finite identities; it does not formalize the general complete-positivity/reference framework or optimal-dimension theorem. The recorded-error model is not derived from the companion exchange-timing model, and no protection of its long pulse sequence is claimed.
This record contains a manuscript and supporting reproducibility materials for “Ledger-Valid Recovery Diagnostics for Quantum Computing: A Prespecified Sequential Audit for Claim-Limited Recovery Validation.” The paper proposes a methodological validation framework for quantum-computing recovery claims. Its central claim is that endpoint recovery success is necessary but not sufficient for a strong recovery claim when calibration failure, false-carrier acceptance, postselection artifacts, leakage, sentinel blindness, or hidden discard can carry failure modes out of view. The manuscript introduces a prespecified S0–S4 ledger audit that converts familiar diagnostic ingredients—label calibration, candidate recovery, false-carrier challenge tests, postselection/leakage accounting, and sentinel observability—into an ordered, claim-limiting taxonomy. A supportive recovery claim is permitted only when all required gates pass; otherwise, the first failed stage determines a lower claim ceiling and an interpretable failure class. The evaluation is based on synthetic endpoint-level validation suites rather than circuit-level simulation or hardware data. These suites test the behavior of the decision architecture under clean support, degraded observability, false-carrier artifacts, postselection/leakage artifacts, sentinel-blind cases, correlated artifacts, and adversarial overlap. The results show a strong specificity/sensitivity tradeoff: the full ledger protocol sharply reduces synthetic non-support supportive-call rates relative to endpoint-only reporting, but with substantial loss of mechanism-positive support sensitivity. The paper explicitly treats this as a conservative claim-validity architecture, not as a new quantum error-correcting code, new physical observable, hardware speedup, or proof of improved device performance. The supporting materials document the final synthetic validation protocol, endpoint definitions, decision-bound implementation, direction-aware threshold sensitivity analysis, latent-threshold eligibility analysis, mechanism-negative/latent-eligible boundary cases, and figure/table traceability. The archive is intended to support review of the manuscript’s aggregate numerical claims and methodological provenance. Hardware implementation, independent simulator validation, and full raw-event-ledger reproduction are identified as future extensions. Suggested keywords: quantum computing; quantum error correction; validation methodology; recovery diagnostics; leakage; postselection; benchmarking; synthetic validation; decision architecture; reproducibility.
This document formulates a pre-registered falsification programme for entanglement and wavefunction-collapse phenomenology in open quantum systems. The framework adopts a register-oriented convention: an entangled AB preparation is represented as a single non-factorisable boundary-informational unit, while A and B denote locally addressable access components used in the operational workspace for control, marginalisation, tomography, and state-level entanglement readout. Measurement is described as apparatus-channel activation of an addressed logical sector. This convention fixes the interpretation of the symbols, but the tests are stated entirely in terms of operational diagnostics. The core programme compares reconstructed open-system descriptions through irreversible entropy production, entropy flux, Landauer-deficit variables, dissipator-level synchronisation, non-Markovian memory response, entanglement-sudden-death threshold timing, and Sagawa–Ueda feedback-information saturation. Five pre-registered predictions are stated. P-EC1 tests the collective-versus-local Landauer-deficit ordering in a bright-sector Dicke benchmark. P-EC2 tests the finite-rate approach of an apparatus-channel deficit toward the readout-completed asymptote under continuous diffusive monitoring, formulated on a stationary-window ensemble estimator. P-EC3 tests the spectral dependence of the non-Markovian Landauer-deficit excess. P-EC4 compares the first concurrence zero-crossing (entanglement-sudden-death threshold) with thermodynamic relaxation timing. P-EC5 tests Sagawa–Ueda bound-saturation and saturation-curve behaviour under feedback information, including an operational proxy mapping for the Yada et al. iterative-feedback anchor. Each prediction is assigned a status in a decision tree with positive controls, quantitative windows, consistency bands, platform anchors, and explicit fail conditions. The programme distinguishes worked-case consistency checks from independent-platform primary falsification tests, and separates core falsification claims from near-future or conditional routes. A boundary-clock extension is also recorded as a non-conservative layer with its own handles; its near-dark chart-inversion observable, tracked by the bounded marker η_chart(t) and the integrated observable 𝐼ₖ₅, is reported as a conditional outlook, not as a core prediction. The document therefore does not claim to derive the Born rule, prove an ontology of collapse, or modify standard quantum mechanics. It asks whether a specific boundary-persistence architecture survives a set of pre-registered operational tests.