Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Secure Computation Protocols for Set Operations Based on Polynomial Representation of Sets

Ou Ruan, Zihao WANG, Yongxiong LU

Published Jan 1, 2019• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

In order to improve efficiency and solve the security vulnerabilities of the secure set computation protocols in practical applications, two secure two-party protocols for set membership and set intersection were proposed based on discrete logarithm problem and the polynomial representation of sets with which the set operation problem could be transformed into a polynomial evaluation problem. Firstly, a latest efficient secure set membership protocol was analyzed, and a security vulnerability of leaking the privacy of the participants by obtaining the element of participants on the brute attack was found. To overcome the security vulnerability, a new method was introduced by representing sets by polynomials and randomizing the polynomials, which could ensure the security of the participants without any leakage of interactions. Based on the discrete logarithm problem and the new method, a new secure set membership protocol was presented. The protocol could judge set-element membership with high-efficiency, and did not leak any other information about the participants besides the size of the set. Further, a secure set intersection protocol was showed according to the same technique. The security proofs of both protocols were given under the semi-honest model by using the probability polynomial time simulator, which indicated that the simulator views were computationally indistinguishable from the original protocols’ execution views. Finally, the detailed analysis about the protocols’ performance was presented, showing that both protocols were more efficient than other protocols since their communication complexity and computational complexity were smaller.

Related papers

Communication preserving protocols for secure function evaluation

Moni Naor, Kobbi Nissim B

A secure function evaluation protocol allows two parties to jointly compute a function f(x; y) of their inputs in a manner not leaking more information than necessary. A major result in this field is: "any function f that can be computed using polynomial resources can be computed securely using polynomial resources" (where `resources' refers to communication and computation). This result follows by a general transformation from any circuit for f to a secure protocol that evaluates f . Although the resources used by protocols resulting from this transformation are polynomial in the circuit size, they are much higher (in general) than those required for an insecure computation of f . We propose a new methodology for designing secure protocols, utilizing the communication complexity tree (or branching program) representation of f . We start with an efficient (insecure) protocol for f and transform it into a secure protocol. In other words, "any function f that can be computed using communication complexity c can be can be computed securely using communication complexity that is polynomial in c and a security parameter". We show several simple applications of this new methodology resulting in protocols efficient either in communication or in computation. In particular, we exemplify a protocol for the "millionaires problem ", where two participants want to compare their values but reveal no other information. Our protocol is more efficient than previously known ones in either communication or computation. 1.

ACM Symposium on Theory of Computing (STOC)•Jul 6, 2001•166 citations

Securely Computing Protocol of Set Intersection under the Malicious Model

Xin Liu, Weitong Chen, Naixue N. Xiong +3 more

Private set intersection (PSI) is a valuable technique with various practical applications, including secure matching of communication packets in the Internet of Things. However, most of the currently available two-party PSI protocols are based on the oblivious transfer (OT) protocol, which is computationally expensive and results in significant communication overhead. In this paper, we propose a new coding method to design a two-party PSI protocol under the semi-honest model. We analyze possible malicious attacks and then develop a PSI protocol under the malicious model using the Paillier cryptosystem, cut-and-choose, zero-knowledge proof, and other cryptographic tools. By adopting the real/ideal model paradigm, we prove the protocol’s security under the malicious model, which is more efficient compared to the existing related schemes.

Electronics•May 26, 2023•1 citation

Efficient quantum secure multi-party greatest common divisor protocol and its applications in private set operations

Zixian Li, Wenjie Liu, Bing-Mei Su

Private set intersection (PSI) has important application value, however, current quantum PSI protocols are either unsuitable for multi-party scenarios or inefficient. Recently, Imran (arXiv: 2303.17196v3 , 2023) proposed two quantum secure multi-party greatest common divisor (GCD) protocols that can be used for PSI, but with the downside of information leakage and resource consumption. In this paper, we propose a novel quantum secure multi-party GCD protocol that has higher security and lower complexity. To hide privacy, each party randomly selects a coefficient within a range determined by his input integer, and with the assistance of a semi-honest third party TP, all parties secretly calculate the linear combination of their inputs under these coefficients. Once enough linear combinations are collected, TP calculates the GCD of these combinations, which is equal to the GCD of all input integers. To verify the honesty of participants, a quantum zero-knowledge proof sub-protocol is designed. Analysis shows that our GCD protocol is correct and has security against malicious attacks. Moreover, its complexity is polynomial level and lower than Imran’s. Furthermore, we demonstrate the scalability of our GCD protocol in private set operations, such as private set intersection, private set intersection cardinality, private multi-set intersection, etc.

EPJ Quantum Technology•Sep 9, 2024•7 citations

Quantum private set intersection based on single qubits

Cai Zhang, Zhuoxuan Zhan, Zhiwei Sun

Private Set Intersection (PSI) is a crucial Secure Multi-Party Computation (SMPC) primitive which enables participants to securely obtain the intersection of their private sets without revealing their individual set information. The advent of quantum computing threatens classical PSI protocols, driving the development of Quantum PSI (QPSI) alternatives. We propose a two-party QPSI protocol based on a semi-honest third party. This protocol achieves set intersection using only single-qubit unitary operations and single-qubit states. Security analysis shows that our protocol can resist common attacks. Validation experiments conducted on the IBM Qiskit simulator confirm the protocol’s correctness and feasibility. Furthermore, we compare the proposed protocol with existing QPSI protocols in terms of quantum states, unitary operations, measurements, and fairness, demonstrating gains in quantum resource efficiency, fairness, and practical feasibility.

EPJ Quantum Technology•Oct 20, 2026•0 citations

Efficient Secure Multiparty Computation of the Maximum and the Minimum

Zhang Wenfang, Wanwan ZHANG, Xiaomin WANG

Secure multiparty computation is valuable for studying data privacy protection issues due to its decentralization, input privacy, fairness, etc. One of the most fundamental problems is to confidentially compute the maximum and the minimum of multiple data. In this paper, an efficient secure multipart computation scheme that can compute the maximum and the minimum simultaneously without a trusted third party was proposed to address the problems of existing secure multi-party computation protocols, such as inability of computing the maximum and the minimum at one time, low efficiency, and security risks caused by unique designated decryption key holder. In the scheme, an encoding method that can simultaneously compute the maximum and the minimum was first provided, whose basic idea was to give a complete set of ordinal numbers with potential l (l ≥ the number of participants n), and each participant encodes its data into an array with length l where the location of the data in the complete set was coded as a random number and the other positions were coded as 1. The positions of the leftmost and rightmost non-1 values in the product array were the positions of the maximum and minimum in the whole set. Based on the proposed encoding method, the ElGamal homomorphic encryption algorithm was used to guarantee the confidentiality of all participants’ data, and the maximum threshold decryption was used to make each participant hold part of the decryption key, which avoids the security threats caused by centralized decryption of calculation result by designated key holder. The proposed scheme was proven to be resistant to collusive attacks by any participant under a semi-honest model based on an ideal-realistic simulation paradigm. Finally, the efficiency analysis and performance comparison with related maximum (minimum) computing schemes were given, which showed that the proposed protocol has advantages over existing schemes in terms of computational complexity and communication complexity under the premise of higher security.

•Sep 1, 2023•0 citations

Communication Complexity and Secure Function Evaluation

Moni Naor, Kobbi Nissim B

We suggest two new methodologies for the design of efficient secure protocols, that differ with respect to their underlying computational models. In one methodology we utilize the communication complexity tree (or branching for f and transform it into a secure protocol. In other words, "any function f that can be computed using communication complexity c can be can be computed securely using communication complexity that is polynomial in c and a security parameter". The second methodology uses the circuit computing f, enhanced with look-up tables as its underlying computational model. It is possible to simulate any RAM machine in this model with polylogarithmic blowup. Hence it is possible to start with a computation of f on a RAM machine and transform it into a secure protocol. We show many applications of these new methodologies resulting in protocols efficient either in communication or in computation. In particular, we exemplify a protocol for the "millionaires problem", where two participants want to compare their values but reveal no other information. Our protocol is more efficient than previously known ones in either communication or computation.

arXiv:cs/0109011•Electronic colloquium on computational complexity•Sep 9, 2001•33 citations
In order to improve efficiency and solve the security vulnerabilities of the secure set computation protocols in practical applications, two secure two-party protocols for set membership and set intersection were proposed based on discrete logarithm problem and the polynomial representation of sets with which the set operation problem could be transformed into a polynomial evaluation problem. Firstly, a latest efficient secure set membership protocol was analyzed, and a security vulnerability of leaking the privacy of the participants by obtaining the element of participants on the brute attack was found. To overcome the security vulnerability, a new method was introduced by representing sets by polynomials and randomizing the polynomials, which could ensure the security of the participants without any leakage of interactions. Based on the discrete logarithm problem and the new method, a new secure set membership protocol was presented. The protocol could judge set-element membership with high-efficiency, and did not leak any other information about the participants besides the size of the set. Further, a secure set intersection protocol was showed according to the same technique. The security proofs of both protocols were given under the semi-honest model by using the probability polynomial time simulator, which indicated that the simulator views were computationally indistinguishable from the original protocols’ execution views. Finally, the detailed analysis about the protocols’ performance was presented, showing that both protocols were more efficient than other protocols since their communication complexity and computational complexity were smaller.
A secure function evaluation protocol allows two parties to jointly compute a function f(x; y) of their inputs in a manner not leaking more information than necessary. A major result in this field is: "any function f that can be computed using polynomial resources can be computed securely using polynomial resources" (where `resources' refers to communication and computation). This result follows by a general transformation from any circuit for f to a secure protocol that evaluates f . Although the resources used by protocols resulting from this transformation are polynomial in the circuit size, they are much higher (in general) than those required for an insecure computation of f . We propose a new methodology for designing secure protocols, utilizing the communication complexity tree (or branching program) representation of f . We start with an efficient (insecure) protocol for f and transform it into a secure protocol. In other words, "any function f that can be computed using communication complexity c can be can be computed securely using communication complexity that is polynomial in c and a security parameter". We show several simple applications of this new methodology resulting in protocols efficient either in communication or in computation. In particular, we exemplify a protocol for the "millionaires problem ", where two participants want to compare their values but reveal no other information. Our protocol is more efficient than previously known ones in either communication or computation. 1.
Private set intersection (PSI) is a valuable technique with various practical applications, including secure matching of communication packets in the Internet of Things. However, most of the currently available two-party PSI protocols are based on the oblivious transfer (OT) protocol, which is computationally expensive and results in significant communication overhead. In this paper, we propose a new coding method to design a two-party PSI protocol under the semi-honest model. We analyze possible malicious attacks and then develop a PSI protocol under the malicious model using the Paillier cryptosystem, cut-and-choose, zero-knowledge proof, and other cryptographic tools. By adopting the real/ideal model paradigm, we prove the protocol’s security under the malicious model, which is more efficient compared to the existing related schemes.
Private set intersection (PSI) has important application value, however, current quantum PSI protocols are either unsuitable for multi-party scenarios or inefficient. Recently, Imran (arXiv: 2303.17196v3 , 2023) proposed two quantum secure multi-party greatest common divisor (GCD) protocols that can be used for PSI, but with the downside of information leakage and resource consumption. In this paper, we propose a novel quantum secure multi-party GCD protocol that has higher security and lower complexity. To hide privacy, each party randomly selects a coefficient within a range determined by his input integer, and with the assistance of a semi-honest third party TP, all parties secretly calculate the linear combination of their inputs under these coefficients. Once enough linear combinations are collected, TP calculates the GCD of these combinations, which is equal to the GCD of all input integers. To verify the honesty of participants, a quantum zero-knowledge proof sub-protocol is designed. Analysis shows that our GCD protocol is correct and has security against malicious attacks. Moreover, its complexity is polynomial level and lower than Imran’s. Furthermore, we demonstrate the scalability of our GCD protocol in private set operations, such as private set intersection, private set intersection cardinality, private multi-set intersection, etc.
Private Set Intersection (PSI) is a crucial Secure Multi-Party Computation (SMPC) primitive which enables participants to securely obtain the intersection of their private sets without revealing their individual set information. The advent of quantum computing threatens classical PSI protocols, driving the development of Quantum PSI (QPSI) alternatives. We propose a two-party QPSI protocol based on a semi-honest third party. This protocol achieves set intersection using only single-qubit unitary operations and single-qubit states. Security analysis shows that our protocol can resist common attacks. Validation experiments conducted on the IBM Qiskit simulator confirm the protocol’s correctness and feasibility. Furthermore, we compare the proposed protocol with existing QPSI protocols in terms of quantum states, unitary operations, measurements, and fairness, demonstrating gains in quantum resource efficiency, fairness, and practical feasibility.
Secure multiparty computation is valuable for studying data privacy protection issues due to its decentralization, input privacy, fairness, etc. One of the most fundamental problems is to confidentially compute the maximum and the minimum of multiple data. In this paper, an efficient secure multipart computation scheme that can compute the maximum and the minimum simultaneously without a trusted third party was proposed to address the problems of existing secure multi-party computation protocols, such as inability of computing the maximum and the minimum at one time, low efficiency, and security risks caused by unique designated decryption key holder. In the scheme, an encoding method that can simultaneously compute the maximum and the minimum was first provided, whose basic idea was to give a complete set of ordinal numbers with potential l (l ≥ the number of participants n), and each participant encodes its data into an array with length l where the location of the data in the complete set was coded as a random number and the other positions were coded as 1. The positions of the leftmost and rightmost non-1 values in the product array were the positions of the maximum and minimum in the whole set. Based on the proposed encoding method, the ElGamal homomorphic encryption algorithm was used to guarantee the confidentiality of all participants’ data, and the maximum threshold decryption was used to make each participant hold part of the decryption key, which avoids the security threats caused by centralized decryption of calculation result by designated key holder. The proposed scheme was proven to be resistant to collusive attacks by any participant under a semi-honest model based on an ideal-realistic simulation paradigm. Finally, the efficiency analysis and performance comparison with related maximum (minimum) computing schemes were given, which showed that the proposed protocol has advantages over existing schemes in terms of computational complexity and communication complexity under the premise of higher security.
We suggest two new methodologies for the design of efficient secure protocols, that differ with respect to their underlying computational models. In one methodology we utilize the communication complexity tree (or branching for f and transform it into a secure protocol. In other words, "any function f that can be computed using communication complexity c can be can be computed securely using communication complexity that is polynomial in c and a security parameter". The second methodology uses the circuit computing f, enhanced with look-up tables as its underlying computational model. It is possible to simulate any RAM machine in this model with polylogarithmic blowup. Hence it is possible to start with a computation of f on a RAM machine and transform it into a secure protocol. We show many applications of these new methodologies resulting in protocols efficient either in communication or in computation. In particular, we exemplify a protocol for the "millionaires problem", where two participants want to compare their values but reveal no other information. Our protocol is more efficient than previously known ones in either communication or computation.