Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Discover Networks

Research evolution in security involved for quantum computing and machine learning through scientometric review analysis

Basil Hanafi, Mohammad Sadik Ali

Published May 25, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The present scientometric analysis evaluates the interaction between quantum computing, security, and machine learning by analyzing 495 peer-reviewed articles published in 2018-mid 2025, as indexed on Scopus and Web of Science. The findings reveal an increasing trend in the research output from year to year, from five papers in 2018 to 165 in 2024, while the latter number is provisional due to incomplete data available for the year 2025. As can be seen from citation data, citation rate reached its peak in 2021, declining afterwards, which may be explained by citation delay and the fast growing volume of published studies. A source analysis demonstrates a clustered distribution of sources and reveals that a Bradford core consisting of 12 titles covers a large percentage of output and is represented primarily by IEEE Access and Lecture Notes in Networks and Systems. Author productivity is also very skewed with most authors publishing one article in total, as expected of Lotka productivity distribution. At the national level, the USA, India, and China are among the top countries producing publications, whereas the citation distribution is relatively less balanced amongst nations. Keyword analysis shows that quantum computation, machine learning, and security concepts are at the heart of the quantum machine learning literature, and quantum cryptography, quantum machine learning, and privacy concepts have been gaining prominence in recent times. From the above results, it can be concluded that although this field is growing very fast, it is doing so in a relatively consolidated manner. The future directions in this field would comprise topics such as quantum-hybrid systems, quantum resilient security, noise-resistant quantum learning, and secure IoT.

DOI
10.1007/s44354-026-00029-y

Related papers

Exploring the Role of Material Science in Advancing Quantum Machine Learning: A Scientometric Study

Manish Tomar, Sunil Prajapat, Dheeraj Kumar +3 more

Quantum Machine Learning (QML) opens up exciting possibilities for tackling problems that are incredibly complex and consume a lot of time. The drive to make QML a reality has sparked significant progress in material science, inspiring a growing number of research publications in the field. In this study, we extracted articles from the Scopus database to understand the contribution of material science in the advancement of QML. This scientometric analysis accumulated 1926 extracted publications published over 11 years spanning from 2014 to 2024. A total of 55 countries contributed to this domain of QML, among which the top 10 countries contributed 65.7% out of the total number of publications; the USA is on top, with 19.47% of the publications globally. A total of 57 authors contributed to this research area from 55 different countries. From 2014 to 2024, publications had an average citation impact of 32.12 citations per paper; the year 2015 received 16.7% of the total citations, which is the highest in the 11 years, and the year 2014 had the highest number of citations per paper, which is 61.4% of the total. The study also identifies the most significant document in the year 2017, with the source title Journal of Physics Condensed Matter, having a citation count of 2649 and a normalized citation impact index (NCII) of 91.34.

Mathematics•Mar 14, 2025•5 citations

Bibliometric Survey of Quantum Machine Learning

Mandaar Bhaskar Pande, Preeti Mulay

Quantum Machine Learning (QML) is one of the core research fields in the larger paradigm of Quantum Computing (also known alternatively as Quantum Information). In recent years, researchers have taken deep interest in QML, given the potential time and cost advantages that solutions to real-life problems using QML algorithms provide, in comparison to their classical (or digital) machine learning equivalents. This is still a very new and exciting area of research with new algorithms and their uses being developed almost every other day. Deep research interest in this area has picked up only in the past 5–6 years. Given the background, this paper focuses on studying Scopus and Web of Science databases for the past 6 years (2014–2019) to identify various publication trends in the areas of Quantum Machine Learning. The authors have done an in-depth study of the Scopus and Web of Science publication data pertaining to this area and have come up with interesting insights. The survey covers 276 publications in Scopus and 154 publications in Web of Science. From the Scopus database, it is found that there has been a consistent growth in the number of publications in this period. Four research areas, namely, Physics, Astronomy, Computer Science, and Mathematics, have contributed 68.1% of the research publications. The USA leads the top 10 countries with nearly half (49.2%) of the research publications. A total of 148 patents have been published with 94 of these being published in the last four years (2016–2019). This essentially translates to one patent for every two publications. The Web of Science database, though bringing out 154 publications in the period, shows similar trends across the metrics. We have carried out a comparative study of some of the metrics in Scopus and Web of Science databases. Overall the study identifies the top 10 Institutions, authors, and research journals.

Science & Technology Libraries•Jun 16, 2020•39 citations

Cuántica e inteligencia artificial: explorando su convergencia desde la cienciometría

Carlos Alberto Oviedo Machado, Luiyi David Brito Palmezano, William Alcides Trillos Sarmiento +1 more

Technological and scientific advancements in recent years have enabled us to manipulate technologies that were once considered unimaginable. Among these, Artificial Intelligence (AI) and quantum physics have emerged as pivotal forces, significantly enhancing our capacity to achieve goals and solve complex problems. Given their growing relevance, a comprehensive review of the scientific output underpinning this new era is both timely and necessary. Such a review allows us to trace the increasing scholarly interest in these domains and to identify emerging trends in the synergy between them. Accordingly, the objective of this article is to present a scientometric analysis of the academic literature related to both AI and quantum science. To achieve this, we examined peer-reviewed articles from prestigious databases such as Scopus and Web of Science. The study spans the period from 2004 to 2024, analyzing key metrics such as publication growth, influential authors, leading institutions, and the geographic distribution of research. The results reveal an exponential growth trajectory, with a marked increase in interdisciplinary publications over the last decade. This analysis provides a structured overview of the intersection between quantum computing and AI, offering a solid foundation for researchers and practitioners to identify priority areas for future innovation.

Interfaces•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

Mapping the quantum computing landscape: growth, collaboration, and thematic convergence

Daniel Conde-Torres, Alejandro Seco-González, Ángel Piñeiro +1 more

Abstract Quantum computing has rapidly emerged as one of the fastest-growing research domains, driven by both technological breakthroughs and the promise of computational advantages over classical systems. This study presents a comprehensive bibliometric analysis of the global quantum computing literature from 1980 to 2025, comprising 31,662 publications indexed in Scopus and accumulating over 800,000 citations. Using advanced bibliometric techniques—including co-authorship mapping, keyword co-occurrence networks, co-citation analysis, and centrality measures—we characterize publication trends, institutional contributions, collaborative structures, and thematic evolution across the field. The results reveal exponential growth in output since 2015, led primarily by the United States, China, and Europe, with key institutions such as MIT, the Chinese Academy of Sciences, CNRS, and the University of Waterloo at the forefront. The intellectual structure exhibits a dual-core configuration, with foundational algorithmic work (e.g. Shor, Grover, Nielsen & Chuang) tightly connected to emerging NISQ-era applications such as quantum machine learning, cryptography, and hybrid algorithms. Keyword analysis reveals the progressive expansion from core quantum algorithms toward increasingly diverse applied domains in healthcare, finance, chemistry, energy, and climate modeling. Public funding bodies (e.g. NSFC, NSF, European Commission, DOE, DoD, MoST) and private-sector investment from major technology firms are jointly driving this translational acceleration. Together, these findings provide an integrated quantitative map of the field’s evolution, offering valuable insight for future scientific policy, international collaboration, and strategic funding initiatives.

EPJ Quantum Technology•Jan 15, 2026•2 citations

A Bibliometric Analysis of Quantum Machine Learning Research

Ali Asghar Ahmadikia, Arman Shirzad, Ali Mohammad Saghiri

Quantum Machine Learning is an interdisciplinary field that combines the principles of quantum physics, quantum computers, and machine learning to enhance computational performance. In recent years, there have been significant advancements in the field of quantum machine learning. Researchers have developed quantum algorithms for various tasks. Furthermore, quantum machine learning has been applied to various domains, such as chemistry, cryptography, and finance. Previous bibliometric surveys in this area covered the period from 2014 to 2020. However, as demonstrated in this paper, the pace of publication has increased significantly from 2018 to the present. Therefore, it has become essential to provide a new analysis of the current state of research in this field. In this paper, we deployed visualization tools to analyze co-authorships, co-occurrences, and keyword density in this research area. Our study covers and analyzes a total of 918 publications from the Web of Science database and 1171 publications from the Scopus database from 2006 to 2022. Following the analysis, we identify research questions, opportunities, and research gaps in the field of Quantum Machine Learning.

Science & Technology Libraries•Jan 3, 2024•5 citations

Machine Learning and Quantum Machine Learning: A Comprehensive Review of Algorithms, Applications, and Future Directions

Loveleen Kumar, Rajesh Rajaan, Nilam Choudhary +1 more

The rapid advancement of artificial intelligence has positioned Machine Learning (ML) as a cornerstone technology across scientific and industrial domains. In parallel, the emergence of quantum computing has catalyzed a new interdisciplinary field—Quantum Machine Learning (QML)—which promises to transcend the computational barriers faced by classical algorithms. This review paper systematically examines the evolution of ML from foundational statistical models to contemporary transformer architectures, and provides a structured analysis of QML paradigms including variational quantum circuits (VQCs), quantum kernel methods, and quantum neural networks (QNNs). Drawing from 95+ peer-reviewed publications indexed in Scopus and Science Citation Index (SCI) journals—with particular emphasis on 2025–2026 publications in IEEE Access, Nature Communications, Nature Computational Science, and Physical Review Letters—we analyze performance benchmarks, identify hardware constraints, and outline algorithmic innovations shaping the near-term quantum advantage landscape. Our findings indicate that while classical ML retains superiority in large-scale perception tasks, QML demonstrates significant advantages in combinatorial optimization and quantum chemistry simulation. Recent 2025 advances in error mitigation on superconducting qubits and improved VQC barren-plateau mitigation are narrowing this gap rapidly. The paper concludes with a forward-looking research agenda covering fault-tolerant QML, hybrid architectures, and quantum NLP.

International Journal of Advanced Engineering Research and Science•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations
The present scientometric analysis evaluates the interaction between quantum computing, security, and machine learning by analyzing 495 peer-reviewed articles published in 2018-mid 2025, as indexed on Scopus and Web of Science. The findings reveal an increasing trend in the research output from year to year, from five papers in 2018 to 165 in 2024, while the latter number is provisional due to incomplete data available for the year 2025. As can be seen from citation data, citation rate reached its peak in 2021, declining afterwards, which may be explained by citation delay and the fast growing volume of published studies. A source analysis demonstrates a clustered distribution of sources and reveals that a Bradford core consisting of 12 titles covers a large percentage of output and is represented primarily by IEEE Access and Lecture Notes in Networks and Systems. Author productivity is also very skewed with most authors publishing one article in total, as expected of Lotka productivity distribution. At the national level, the USA, India, and China are among the top countries producing publications, whereas the citation distribution is relatively less balanced amongst nations. Keyword analysis shows that quantum computation, machine learning, and security concepts are at the heart of the quantum machine learning literature, and quantum cryptography, quantum machine learning, and privacy concepts have been gaining prominence in recent times. From the above results, it can be concluded that although this field is growing very fast, it is doing so in a relatively consolidated manner. The future directions in this field would comprise topics such as quantum-hybrid systems, quantum resilient security, noise-resistant quantum learning, and secure IoT.
Quantum Machine Learning (QML) opens up exciting possibilities for tackling problems that are incredibly complex and consume a lot of time. The drive to make QML a reality has sparked significant progress in material science, inspiring a growing number of research publications in the field. In this study, we extracted articles from the Scopus database to understand the contribution of material science in the advancement of QML. This scientometric analysis accumulated 1926 extracted publications published over 11 years spanning from 2014 to 2024. A total of 55 countries contributed to this domain of QML, among which the top 10 countries contributed 65.7% out of the total number of publications; the USA is on top, with 19.47% of the publications globally. A total of 57 authors contributed to this research area from 55 different countries. From 2014 to 2024, publications had an average citation impact of 32.12 citations per paper; the year 2015 received 16.7% of the total citations, which is the highest in the 11 years, and the year 2014 had the highest number of citations per paper, which is 61.4% of the total. The study also identifies the most significant document in the year 2017, with the source title Journal of Physics Condensed Matter, having a citation count of 2649 and a normalized citation impact index (NCII) of 91.34.
Quantum Machine Learning (QML) is one of the core research fields in the larger paradigm of Quantum Computing (also known alternatively as Quantum Information). In recent years, researchers have taken deep interest in QML, given the potential time and cost advantages that solutions to real-life problems using QML algorithms provide, in comparison to their classical (or digital) machine learning equivalents. This is still a very new and exciting area of research with new algorithms and their uses being developed almost every other day. Deep research interest in this area has picked up only in the past 5–6 years. Given the background, this paper focuses on studying Scopus and Web of Science databases for the past 6 years (2014–2019) to identify various publication trends in the areas of Quantum Machine Learning. The authors have done an in-depth study of the Scopus and Web of Science publication data pertaining to this area and have come up with interesting insights. The survey covers 276 publications in Scopus and 154 publications in Web of Science. From the Scopus database, it is found that there has been a consistent growth in the number of publications in this period. Four research areas, namely, Physics, Astronomy, Computer Science, and Mathematics, have contributed 68.1% of the research publications. The USA leads the top 10 countries with nearly half (49.2%) of the research publications. A total of 148 patents have been published with 94 of these being published in the last four years (2016–2019). This essentially translates to one patent for every two publications. The Web of Science database, though bringing out 154 publications in the period, shows similar trends across the metrics. We have carried out a comparative study of some of the metrics in Scopus and Web of Science databases. Overall the study identifies the top 10 Institutions, authors, and research journals.
Technological and scientific advancements in recent years have enabled us to manipulate technologies that were once considered unimaginable. Among these, Artificial Intelligence (AI) and quantum physics have emerged as pivotal forces, significantly enhancing our capacity to achieve goals and solve complex problems. Given their growing relevance, a comprehensive review of the scientific output underpinning this new era is both timely and necessary. Such a review allows us to trace the increasing scholarly interest in these domains and to identify emerging trends in the synergy between them. Accordingly, the objective of this article is to present a scientometric analysis of the academic literature related to both AI and quantum science. To achieve this, we examined peer-reviewed articles from prestigious databases such as Scopus and Web of Science. The study spans the period from 2004 to 2024, analyzing key metrics such as publication growth, influential authors, leading institutions, and the geographic distribution of research. The results reveal an exponential growth trajectory, with a marked increase in interdisciplinary publications over the last decade. This analysis provides a structured overview of the intersection between quantum computing and AI, offering a solid foundation for researchers and practitioners to identify priority areas for future innovation.
Abstract Quantum computing has rapidly emerged as one of the fastest-growing research domains, driven by both technological breakthroughs and the promise of computational advantages over classical systems. This study presents a comprehensive bibliometric analysis of the global quantum computing literature from 1980 to 2025, comprising 31,662 publications indexed in Scopus and accumulating over 800,000 citations. Using advanced bibliometric techniques—including co-authorship mapping, keyword co-occurrence networks, co-citation analysis, and centrality measures—we characterize publication trends, institutional contributions, collaborative structures, and thematic evolution across the field. The results reveal exponential growth in output since 2015, led primarily by the United States, China, and Europe, with key institutions such as MIT, the Chinese Academy of Sciences, CNRS, and the University of Waterloo at the forefront. The intellectual structure exhibits a dual-core configuration, with foundational algorithmic work (e.g. Shor, Grover, Nielsen & Chuang) tightly connected to emerging NISQ-era applications such as quantum machine learning, cryptography, and hybrid algorithms. Keyword analysis reveals the progressive expansion from core quantum algorithms toward increasingly diverse applied domains in healthcare, finance, chemistry, energy, and climate modeling. Public funding bodies (e.g. NSFC, NSF, European Commission, DOE, DoD, MoST) and private-sector investment from major technology firms are jointly driving this translational acceleration. Together, these findings provide an integrated quantitative map of the field’s evolution, offering valuable insight for future scientific policy, international collaboration, and strategic funding initiatives.
Quantum Machine Learning is an interdisciplinary field that combines the principles of quantum physics, quantum computers, and machine learning to enhance computational performance. In recent years, there have been significant advancements in the field of quantum machine learning. Researchers have developed quantum algorithms for various tasks. Furthermore, quantum machine learning has been applied to various domains, such as chemistry, cryptography, and finance. Previous bibliometric surveys in this area covered the period from 2014 to 2020. However, as demonstrated in this paper, the pace of publication has increased significantly from 2018 to the present. Therefore, it has become essential to provide a new analysis of the current state of research in this field. In this paper, we deployed visualization tools to analyze co-authorships, co-occurrences, and keyword density in this research area. Our study covers and analyzes a total of 918 publications from the Web of Science database and 1171 publications from the Scopus database from 2006 to 2022. Following the analysis, we identify research questions, opportunities, and research gaps in the field of Quantum Machine Learning.
The rapid advancement of artificial intelligence has positioned Machine Learning (ML) as a cornerstone technology across scientific and industrial domains. In parallel, the emergence of quantum computing has catalyzed a new interdisciplinary field—Quantum Machine Learning (QML)—which promises to transcend the computational barriers faced by classical algorithms. This review paper systematically examines the evolution of ML from foundational statistical models to contemporary transformer architectures, and provides a structured analysis of QML paradigms including variational quantum circuits (VQCs), quantum kernel methods, and quantum neural networks (QNNs). Drawing from 95+ peer-reviewed publications indexed in Scopus and Science Citation Index (SCI) journals—with particular emphasis on 2025–2026 publications in IEEE Access, Nature Communications, Nature Computational Science, and Physical Review Letters—we analyze performance benchmarks, identify hardware constraints, and outline algorithmic innovations shaping the near-term quantum advantage landscape. Our findings indicate that while classical ML retains superiority in large-scale perception tasks, QML demonstrates significant advantages in combinatorial optimization and quantum chemistry simulation. Recent 2025 advances in error mitigation on superconducting qubits and improved VQC barren-plateau mitigation are narrowing this gap rapidly. The paper concludes with a forward-looking research agenda covering fault-tolerant QML, hybrid architectures, and quantum NLP.