Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Notes on Quantum States, Unitarity and Non-locality

Kaushik Ghosh

Published May 1, 2026• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

In this article we will demonstrate that the detection of electrons in an interference experiment with electrons is a transition between two Hilbert spaces caused by interactions with the detecting screen. The first Hilbert space is that of the free electrons before detection and the second is that of the bound electrons in the screen after detection. This transition can be described by unitary quantum-mechanical perturbation theory where the grand Hilbert space required to describe the electrons is the direct sum of these two Hilbert spaces. We can say an electron is detected at the screen only after the interaction between the two has caused an observable effect like an atomic transition. Detection of the electrons does not solely indicate modification of the quantum states taking place in the Hilbert space used to describe the electron before detection. It cannot be used to imply a non-unitary transformation of the quantum states belonging to this Hilbert space only. Similarly, emission of electrons from a material to free space is a transition from the set of bound states to the set of free states. This transition can be described by using time-dependent perturbation theory without referring to any non-unitary transformation. In both the cases, relevant transitions would be given by the time evolution of exact solutions of the interacting theory and rescind the requirement of introducing any non-unitary transformation. This interpretation may be extended to other measurement processes. We will conclude the article with a brief discussion on non-locality in quantum mechanics. This is based on the necessity of complex functions in quantum theory and perception of human brain on imaginary numbers.

Related papers

Non-unitary evolution of a pure state into a mixed state in the measurement problem from standard Quantum Mechanics and its impact on complex space-time, no-boundary proposal and information loss paradox of singularity-free Quantum Cosmology

Chatterjee, Pradip Kumar

In order to resolve the measurement problem of Quantum Mechanics, non-unitary time evolution has been derived from the unitarity of standard quantum formalism. New wave functions of free and non-free quantum systems follow from Schroedinger equation after inserting an ansatz. Quantum systems show up as probability waves before measurement. A pure entangled state of a composite system evolves non-unitarily, only to disentangle itself into a definite state after reduction at the measurement point. A classical space-time point is created momentarily in this event. Unitarity is restored at that point. The non-Hermitian observables defined in the domain of rigged Hilbert space transform into Hermitian ones at the measurement point. The problem of preferred basis is resolved by the requirement of specifying the position of measurement point. Two theorems prove that time is a non-Hermitian operator, thus placing space and time on an equal footing. Bound states are found to need discrete space-time, which supports its use in loop quantum gravity. Non-unitarity in the theory helps buttress the no-boundary proposal; and uncertainty relation makes a leeway to singularity-free Quantum Cosmology. Quantum Mechanics also accommodates complex and negative probabilities.

arXiv:quant-ph/0412144•Dec 18, 2004•1 citation

On a new prediction of Causal Quantum Mechanics for the two-slit interference experiment with electrons

Eduardo Sergio Santini, Germán M. Chiappe, González, Rafael

The causal quantum mechanics (i.e. Bohmian or de Broglie-Bohm or Bohm-de Broglie quantum mechanics) has made possible to calculate the trajectories of electrons in a typical double-slit experiment [C. Philippidis et al., Il Nuovo Cimento, 52 B, 15-28 (1979)]. The trajectories do not correspond to an uniform movement but to an accelerated one. The acceleration is caused by the quantum potential. From the quantum theoretical point of view, there is a probability for the electron to emit photons, with a certain emission power, during its movement from the slits to the screen. We find a quantum general formula for the emission power of photons, valid independently of the interpretation. Then, according to the Copenhagen interpretation, this formula gives a strictly zero value for the emission power because the electron moves as a free particle after it leaves the slit and before reach the screen. Then, there is no emission of photons. In the case of the causal interpretation, the emission power results, for a concrete real experiment, in a very tiny but not a zero value, driven by the square of the quantum potential gradient. We give an idea of the type of spectrum that could be measured. A brief idea of a possible experimental arrangement in order to detect this effect, is given.

arXiv:1801.02096•Jan 6, 2018•0 citations

Disappearance of Interference Terms as Quantum Effect

Riuji Mochizuki

We show that it is possible to explain the quantum measurement process within the framework of quantum mechanics without any additional postulates. The key concept of the theory is decoherence, which appears as an inherent characteristic of quantum mechanics and results from the uncertainty relation. In contrast to environment-induced decoherence, this decoherence exists prior to a measurement being made. To clarify our idea, we examine three elemental experiments: a Stern-Gerlach-like experiment, the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen-Bohm (EPR-Bohm) experiment, and the double-slit experiment. By considering the first experiment, we explain how the uncertainty relation between position and momentum introduces decoherence prior to measurement. Consideration of the EPR-Bohm experiment leads us to conclude that the correlation of the EPR pair is not a consequence of what is known as the collapse of the wave function. Our theory of decoherence can also be applied to experiments with continuous eigenvalues, such as the double-slit experiment. Consideration of the double-slit experiment leads us to understand how pure quantum mechanics describes the fact that quanta behave as interfering particles.

•Apr 12, 2017•0 citations

The Structural Inevitability of Complex Numbers in Quantum Mechanics: A Derivation from Symmetry, Unitarity, and Composition

Y. Li

The presence of the imaginary unit $i$ in quantum mechanics is frequently treated as a computational postulate. We demonstrate that the complex structure of Hilbert space is not a decorative choice but a structural necessity derived from the first principles of modern physics: continuous symmetry, the requirement of unitarity to preserve probability, and the correspondence between generators and observables. By examining the Lie algebra of the unitary group, we prove that a real-valued theory fails to map self-adjoint observables to generators of continuous evolution without sacrificing local tomography or the existence of non-trivial phases. We conclude that $i$ is the unique logical bridge between symmetry and observability.

•Mar 7, 2026•0 citations

Does quantum mechanics require non-locality?

Ghenadie N. Mardari

There is a gap between experiment and theory in quantum mechanics. On paper, quantum observables collapse to sharp states instantaneously, as soon as there is a possibility of extracting information. In real life, experimenters have to wait until the wave-function evolves to acquire sharp states, or they have to modify the physical context. Furthermore, the general perception is that quanta reveal component properties (with corresponding histories) during collapse, whereas they always express the local net state of the wave-function in any experiment. This discrepancy is due to the fact that operator algebra is too abstract. It gives correct predictions, but leaves out the transient details of the wave-like processes behind quantum phenomena. This oversimplification is the reason for the measurement problem, and ultimately for the EPR paradox. If the theory is expanded to include the irrelevant physical details, then many conceptual complications can be avoided, including the problem of non-locality. Furthermore, this conclusion entails new ways to violate Bell's inequality, with pairs of variables that are not otherwise expected to do that.

•Sep 7, 2006•0 citations

Entanglement and Quantum non-locality: an experimental perspective

Alessio Avella, Marco Gramegna, Marco Genovese

The theory of Quantum Mechanics is one of the mainstay of modern physics, a well-established mathematical clockwork whose strength and accuracy in predictions are currently experienced in worldwide research laboratories. As a matter of fact, Quantum Mechanics laid the groundwork of a rich variety of studies ranging from solid state physics to cosmology, from bio-physics to particle physics. The up-to-date ability of manipulating single quantum states is paving the way for emergent quantum technologies as quantum information and computation, quantum communication, quantum metrology and quantum imaging. In spite of the impressive matemathical capacity, a long-standing debate is even revolving around the foundational axioms of this theory, the main bones of content being the non-local effects of entangled states, the wave function collapse and the concept of measurement in Quantum Mechanics, the macro-objectivation problem (the transition from a microscopic probabilistic world to a macroscopic deterministic world described by classical mechanics). Problems that, beyond their fundamental interest in basic science, now also concern the impact of these developing technologies. Without claiming to be complete, this article provides in outline the living matter concerning some of these problems, the implications of which extend deeply on the connection between entanglement and space-time structure.

EPJ Web of Conferences•Jan 1, 2013•1 citation
In this article we will demonstrate that the detection of electrons in an interference experiment with electrons is a transition between two Hilbert spaces caused by interactions with the detecting screen. The first Hilbert space is that of the free electrons before detection and the second is that of the bound electrons in the screen after detection. This transition can be described by unitary quantum-mechanical perturbation theory where the grand Hilbert space required to describe the electrons is the direct sum of these two Hilbert spaces. We can say an electron is detected at the screen only after the interaction between the two has caused an observable effect like an atomic transition. Detection of the electrons does not solely indicate modification of the quantum states taking place in the Hilbert space used to describe the electron before detection. It cannot be used to imply a non-unitary transformation of the quantum states belonging to this Hilbert space only. Similarly, emission of electrons from a material to free space is a transition from the set of bound states to the set of free states. This transition can be described by using time-dependent perturbation theory without referring to any non-unitary transformation. In both the cases, relevant transitions would be given by the time evolution of exact solutions of the interacting theory and rescind the requirement of introducing any non-unitary transformation. This interpretation may be extended to other measurement processes. We will conclude the article with a brief discussion on non-locality in quantum mechanics. This is based on the necessity of complex functions in quantum theory and perception of human brain on imaginary numbers.
In order to resolve the measurement problem of Quantum Mechanics, non-unitary time evolution has been derived from the unitarity of standard quantum formalism. New wave functions of free and non-free quantum systems follow from Schroedinger equation after inserting an ansatz. Quantum systems show up as probability waves before measurement. A pure entangled state of a composite system evolves non-unitarily, only to disentangle itself into a definite state after reduction at the measurement point. A classical space-time point is created momentarily in this event. Unitarity is restored at that point. The non-Hermitian observables defined in the domain of rigged Hilbert space transform into Hermitian ones at the measurement point. The problem of preferred basis is resolved by the requirement of specifying the position of measurement point. Two theorems prove that time is a non-Hermitian operator, thus placing space and time on an equal footing. Bound states are found to need discrete space-time, which supports its use in loop quantum gravity. Non-unitarity in the theory helps buttress the no-boundary proposal; and uncertainty relation makes a leeway to singularity-free Quantum Cosmology. Quantum Mechanics also accommodates complex and negative probabilities.
The causal quantum mechanics (i.e. Bohmian or de Broglie-Bohm or Bohm-de Broglie quantum mechanics) has made possible to calculate the trajectories of electrons in a typical double-slit experiment [C. Philippidis et al., Il Nuovo Cimento, 52 B, 15-28 (1979)]. The trajectories do not correspond to an uniform movement but to an accelerated one. The acceleration is caused by the quantum potential. From the quantum theoretical point of view, there is a probability for the electron to emit photons, with a certain emission power, during its movement from the slits to the screen. We find a quantum general formula for the emission power of photons, valid independently of the interpretation. Then, according to the Copenhagen interpretation, this formula gives a strictly zero value for the emission power because the electron moves as a free particle after it leaves the slit and before reach the screen. Then, there is no emission of photons. In the case of the causal interpretation, the emission power results, for a concrete real experiment, in a very tiny but not a zero value, driven by the square of the quantum potential gradient. We give an idea of the type of spectrum that could be measured. A brief idea of a possible experimental arrangement in order to detect this effect, is given.
We show that it is possible to explain the quantum measurement process within the framework of quantum mechanics without any additional postulates. The key concept of the theory is decoherence, which appears as an inherent characteristic of quantum mechanics and results from the uncertainty relation. In contrast to environment-induced decoherence, this decoherence exists prior to a measurement being made. To clarify our idea, we examine three elemental experiments: a Stern-Gerlach-like experiment, the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen-Bohm (EPR-Bohm) experiment, and the double-slit experiment. By considering the first experiment, we explain how the uncertainty relation between position and momentum introduces decoherence prior to measurement. Consideration of the EPR-Bohm experiment leads us to conclude that the correlation of the EPR pair is not a consequence of what is known as the collapse of the wave function. Our theory of decoherence can also be applied to experiments with continuous eigenvalues, such as the double-slit experiment. Consideration of the double-slit experiment leads us to understand how pure quantum mechanics describes the fact that quanta behave as interfering particles.
The presence of the imaginary unit iii in quantum mechanics is frequently treated as a computational postulate. We demonstrate that the complex structure of Hilbert space is not a decorative choice but a structural necessity derived from the first principles of modern physics: continuous symmetry, the requirement of unitarity to preserve probability, and the correspondence between generators and observables. By examining the Lie algebra of the unitary group, we prove that a real-valued theory fails to map self-adjoint observables to generators of continuous evolution without sacrificing local tomography or the existence of non-trivial phases. We conclude that iii is the unique logical bridge between symmetry and observability.
There is a gap between experiment and theory in quantum mechanics. On paper, quantum observables collapse to sharp states instantaneously, as soon as there is a possibility of extracting information. In real life, experimenters have to wait until the wave-function evolves to acquire sharp states, or they have to modify the physical context. Furthermore, the general perception is that quanta reveal component properties (with corresponding histories) during collapse, whereas they always express the local net state of the wave-function in any experiment. This discrepancy is due to the fact that operator algebra is too abstract. It gives correct predictions, but leaves out the transient details of the wave-like processes behind quantum phenomena. This oversimplification is the reason for the measurement problem, and ultimately for the EPR paradox. If the theory is expanded to include the irrelevant physical details, then many conceptual complications can be avoided, including the problem of non-locality. Furthermore, this conclusion entails new ways to violate Bell's inequality, with pairs of variables that are not otherwise expected to do that.
The theory of Quantum Mechanics is one of the mainstay of modern physics, a well-established mathematical clockwork whose strength and accuracy in predictions are currently experienced in worldwide research laboratories. As a matter of fact, Quantum Mechanics laid the groundwork of a rich variety of studies ranging from solid state physics to cosmology, from bio-physics to particle physics. The up-to-date ability of manipulating single quantum states is paving the way for emergent quantum technologies as quantum information and computation, quantum communication, quantum metrology and quantum imaging. In spite of the impressive matemathical capacity, a long-standing debate is even revolving around the foundational axioms of this theory, the main bones of content being the non-local effects of entangled states, the wave function collapse and the concept of measurement in Quantum Mechanics, the macro-objectivation problem (the transition from a microscopic probabilistic world to a macroscopic deterministic world described by classical mechanics). Problems that, beyond their fundamental interest in basic science, now also concern the impact of these developing technologies. Without claiming to be complete, this article provides in outline the living matter concerning some of these problems, the implications of which extend deeply on the connection between entanglement and space-time structure.