Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

[Withdrawn, November 2026] Non-invertible Symmetry Boundaries from Anyon Condensation: A Computational Classification

Adam Bazih

Published May 20, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

[WITHDRAWN, November 2026. Independent re-derivation found this paper wrong at the framework level: gapped boundaries of a 2+1D theory correspond to Lagrangian algebras in Z(C) = C x C^rev, whereas the paper uses C x C throughout, so its "universal absence of gapped boundaries for self-products" is an artifact. Table 1 FPdim values are wrong in 8 of 9 rows; algebra counts and phase identifications are wrong for several products (SU(2)_2^2 condenses to SU(4)_1, not Ising; "Fib" for SU(2)_3^2 does not exist); SU(3)_3 x SU(3)_3 does have a Lagrangian algebra (E8/SO(16)_1 embedding, d_A = 36); Sp(2)_2 is not Witt-trivial (c = 4). Theorem 1 restates the T-constraint. Nothing in this paper should be cited. Computations used mtctools 0.2.x, whose finder bugs are documented in ERRATUM_v7 at 10.5281/zenodo.20128951. The text below is unchanged as the record of the programme's history.] <= 0.2.x, whose condensable-algebra finder has since been found to have false negatives on conformal-embedding (E-type) algebras (e.g. 1+(j=3) in SU(2)_10, within the level range covered here), and whose condensed-phase identification did not resolve the sixteen-fold way. The boundary counts below are therefore lower bounds where E-type algebras were missed; re-check against mtctools 0.3.0 and the corrected release at DOI 10.5281/zenodo.20618695. The text below is the original and is retained for the record.] We develop a systematic computational framework connecting anyon condensation in modular tensor categories to the classification of non-invertible symmetry boundaries in the Symmetry Topological Field Theory (SymTFT) paradigm. For each condensable algebra in a doubled MTC, we identify the corresponding symmetry boundary condition and classify the resulting non-invertible symmetry structure. We present explicit results for SU(2) Chern-Simons theories at levels k=1-8, SU(3) at levels k=1-3, and G₂ at level 1, covering 40+ modular tensor categories and identifying 100+ distinct symmetry boundary types.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.20302896

Related papers

[Withdrawn, November 2026] Fermionic Condensation Obstruction and Condensation Lattices in Product Modular Tensor Categories

Adam Bazih

[WITHDRAWN IN PART, November 2026. The "fermionic condensation obstruction" is the T-constraint h = 0 mod 1 for condensed objects applied to objects with h = 1/2, a tautology under the paper's own definition; under the standard meaning (condensing an invertible fermion to a super-MTC) the claim is false: SU(2)_k x SU(2)_k has invertible fermions for k = 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7. Fermion counts are wrong for k = 3, 5; Table 2 phase identifications are wrong; three SU(4) rows of Table 4 miss bosons (pre-bugfix mtctools 0.2.x data; see ERRATUM_v7 at 10.5281/zenodo.20128951). The condensation lattices for SU(2)_4^2, SU(2)_8^2, SU(2)_6^2 (whose maximal algebra is the Spin(9)_1 conformal embedding) and SU(3)_3 x SU(2)_2 are correct and are retained in a corrected version. The text below is unchanged.] <= 0.2.x, whose condensable-algebra finder has since been found to have false negatives on conformal-embedding (E-type) algebras, and whose condensed-phase identification did not resolve the sixteen-fold way (a D^2 = 4 condensed phase is determined only together with the central charge mod 8). Affected classifications should be re-checked against mtctools 0.3.0 and the corrected release at DOI 10.5281/zenodo.20618695. The text below is the original and is retained for the record.] We establish rigorous obstructions to fermionic anyon condensation in product modular tensor categories and analyze the lattice structure of condensable algebras. Our key results include: (1) a proof that fermionic condensation is impossible in SU(2)_k ⊗ SU(2)_k for all k ≤ 8, and provide the mechanism via conformal weight analysis; (2) computation of the full condensation lattice (partial order under inclusion) for SU(2) levels 1-8, revealing rich combinatorial structure; (3) identification of maximal condensable algebras as Lagrangian when they exist. These results contribute to the classification program for topological phases of matter and have implications for the construction of fermionic topological orders from bosonic ones.

•May 20, 2026•0 citations

Anyon Condensation in Modular Tensor Categories: Computational Classification and Algebraic Structure (v4)

Adam Bazih

Author note (Nov 2026): an independent re-derivation confirms the two-algebra classification, the SO(11)_1 condensed phase, the N+k=6 characterization and the Witt class. It also found errors to be fixed in v8: the v7 erratum wrongly removed the SU(3)_2 x SU(2)_3 algebra, which is the SU(6)_1 conformal embedding (Theorem 4.1 should read 6 of 10, one E-type); mtctools 0.3.0 uses Re(S) in its invariant routine and accepts unphysical invariants (SO(9)_2 "d_A = 4"); WITT_TABLE central charges for F4_2 (16/11) and E6_2 (22/7) were rounded; the zero-locus conjecture fails for SU(2)_7. Version 7 — strengthens and corrects v6. 1. Adjoint transparency, characterized and explained. The v6 statement ("unique to SU(3)_3 among SU(N)_N") is superseded twice over. (a) Level-rank characterization: for SU(N)_k, k>=2, S_adj,fund = 0 if and only if N+k=6 (SU(2)_4, SU(3)_3, SU(4)_2 — one level-rank orbit), proved in closed form. (b) Mechanism and cross-family classification: the adjoint is a simple-current FIXED POINT exactly for SU(N)_{6-N} and for ALL Spin(N)_2, N>=5; a two-line lemma (multiplicativity of Verlinde eigenvalues) then forces S_adj,x = 0 for every current-charged x. The previously "isolated" Sp(2)_2 = Spin(5)_2 is the first member of the infinite metaplectic family. All S-matrix zeros in the scanned families are accounted for by this mechanism or by known exceptional invariants (SU(3)_5 in SU(6)_1, G2 level 3 in E6 level 1, ...); we conjecture no accidental zeros exist in WZW modular data. 2. Corrected survey. (a) The earlier non-simple-current algebra in SU(3)_2 ⊗ SU(2)_3 does not exist (non-unitary S-matrix artifact). (b) Condensed phases are now identified by rank+twists+central charge, never by D^2 alone: the Z2 condensation of SU(2)_2 ⊗ SU(2)_2 is the pointed theory SU(4)_1 (nu=6), NOT Ising; the maximal condensation of SU(3)_3 ⊗ SU(2)_2 is the nu=11 Ising-type category of Kitaev's sixteen-fold way — the modular tensor category of SO(11)_1 (h_sigma = 11/16), which shares its fusion rules with Ising and its fusion category with SU(2)_2 but is equivalent to neither as a braided category. Its Witt class is [Ising]^11, of order 16. 3. mtctools 0.3.0. The condensable-algebra finder now uses the modular-invariant (commutant) criterion decided by exact integer programming; the previous z_l-integrality test had false negatives on conformal-embedding algebras (it rejected 1+(j=3) in SU(2)_10, 1+(2,2) in SU(3)_5, 1+(1,1) in G2_3 — all now found and covered by regression tests). Phase identification is sixteen-fold-aware (takes c mod 8). Two further fixes: a twist-rounding bug that discarded B-series algebras (including the LAGRANGIAN of SO(9)_2 — which has c=0 mod 8 and a gapped boundary), and fixed-point splitting is now restricted to cyclic stabilizers (non-cyclic cases are flagged; they require discrete-torsion data beyond (S,T)). 4. New data: a Witt-class table for the metaplectic series SO(N)_2 (N=5..13), whose vector-current condensates are pointed (rank = D^2 forces it), reducing each Witt class to an explicit finite quadratic form (e.g. (Z_11, k^2/11), (Z_13, 2k^2/13)); SO(9)_2 is Witt-trivial. See ERRATUM_v7.md for the changelog. All computations reproducible with the included package (S unitary, S^2=C, integer Verlinde, ~1e-15).

•May 12, 2026•0 citations

Condensable algebras and the Ising condensed phase in SU(3)_3 ⊗ SU(2)_2

Adam Bazih

Correction to the correction note (Nov 2026): the extended vacuum character in eq. (4) already contains (3,0;0) and (0,3;0), i.e. the correct d_A = 6 algebra; it was misread as d_A = 4. "Fails fusion closure" is not a valid non-algebra criterion; see the valid reasons on the companion record. The embedding-dimension "reconciliation" is withdrawn. [CORRECTION NOTE, June 2026: The central uniqueness claim of this preprint is corrected. The object 1 + ((1,1);1) (d_A = 4) is NOT an algebra: its generator fails fusion closure. The correct classification has exactly two non-trivial condensable algebras, the Z3 simple-current algebra (d_A = 3) and the maximal algebra (d_A = 6), and the maximal condensation yields the nu=11 Ising-type category of the sixteen-fold way - the modular tensor category of SO(11)_1 (h_sigma = 11/16) - which shares its fusion rules with Ising and its fusion category with SU(2)_2 but is equivalent to neither as a braided category. See the corrected release at DOI 10.5281/zenodo.20618695 (concept 10.5281/zenodo.20128951). A corrected manuscript is under journal review. The text below is the original and is retained for the record.] We give a complete analysis of anyon condensation in the rank-30 modular tensor category C = SU(3)_3 ⊗ SU(2)_2. We prove that A = 1 ⊕ ((1,1);1) is the unique non-trivial condensable algebra by classifying all physical modular invariants. The local module category C^loc_A is computed explicitly: it is a rank-3 MTC with quantum dimensions (1,1,√2), total quantum dimension D² = 4, and Ising fusion rules. The F-symbol F^{σσσ}_σ = (1/√2)[[1,1],[1,-1]] is verified from SU(2)_2 quantum 6j-symbols, confirming C^loc_A ≅ Ising ≅ SU(2)_2 as modular tensor categories.

•May 10, 2026•0 citations

Condensable Algebras in Product Modular Tensor Categories: A Comprehensive Survey of SU(N₁)_{k₁} ⊗ SU(N₂)_{k₂}

Adam Bazih

[SUPERSEDED VERSION, notice added November 2026. The claims of this version were withdrawn or corrected after the author's adversarial review of June 2026. See the Status Note and Partial Retraction, DOI 10.5281/zenodo.20618848, the maintained mathematics at DOI 10.5281/zenodo.20128951, and the current version of this record via its concept DOI. The text below is unchanged as the record of the programme's history.] We present a systematic computational survey of condensable algebras (connected étale algebras) in product modular tensor categories of the form SU(N₁)_{k₁} ⊗ SU(N₂)_{k₂} at small rank. Using the Verlinde formula and modular invariant classification, we identify all non-trivial condensable algebras across 10 product MTCs with rank ≤ 36. We verify the Shimizu-Yadav conditions ensuring that the local module categories are modular, and compute the condensation completion structure including domain walls and defects using the Décoppet-Yu framework. Our survey reveals a rich landscape: simple current algebras of types Z₂, Z₃, and Z₂×Z₂ dominate, with condensed phases including the Ising MTC. We also correct an error in a previous classification of SU(3)₃ ⊗ SU(2)₂, where the maximal condensable algebra has d_A = 6 (not 4), yielding the Ising MTC as the condensed phase. All computational code is included.

•May 12, 2026•0 citations

Anyon condensation Topological symmetry breaking phase transitions and commutative algebra objects in braided tensor categories

Sebas Eliëns, Korteweg de Vries Instituut

•Jan 1, 2010•6 citations

Symmetry Classfication of Two-dimensional Topologically Ordered Phases Under Exchange of Anyons

Tianfu Fu, Andriy H. Nevidomskyy, F. J. Burnell

Bulletin of the American Physical Society•Mar 19, 2021•0 citations
[WITHDRAWN, November 2026. Independent re-derivation found this paper wrong at the framework level: gapped boundaries of a 2+1D theory correspond to Lagrangian algebras in Z(C) = C x C^rev, whereas the paper uses C x C throughout, so its "universal absence of gapped boundaries for self-products" is an artifact. Table 1 FPdim values are wrong in 8 of 9 rows; algebra counts and phase identifications are wrong for several products (SU(2)_2^2 condenses to SU(4)_1, not Ising; "Fib" for SU(2)_3^2 does not exist); SU(3)_3 x SU(3)_3 does have a Lagrangian algebra (E8/SO(16)_1 embedding, d_A = 36); Sp(2)_2 is not Witt-trivial (c = 4). Theorem 1 restates the T-constraint. Nothing in this paper should be cited. Computations used mtctools 0.2.x, whose finder bugs are documented in ERRATUM_v7 at 10.5281/zenodo.20128951. The text below is unchanged as the record of the programme's history.] <= 0.2.x, whose condensable-algebra finder has since been found to have false negatives on conformal-embedding (E-type) algebras (e.g. 1+(j=3) in SU(2)_10, within the level range covered here), and whose condensed-phase identification did not resolve the sixteen-fold way. The boundary counts below are therefore lower bounds where E-type algebras were missed; re-check against mtctools 0.3.0 and the corrected release at DOI 10.5281/zenodo.20618695. The text below is the original and is retained for the record.] We develop a systematic computational framework connecting anyon condensation in modular tensor categories to the classification of non-invertible symmetry boundaries in the Symmetry Topological Field Theory (SymTFT) paradigm. For each condensable algebra in a doubled MTC, we identify the corresponding symmetry boundary condition and classify the resulting non-invertible symmetry structure. We present explicit results for SU(2) Chern-Simons theories at levels k=1-8, SU(3) at levels k=1-3, and G₂ at level 1, covering 40+ modular tensor categories and identifying 100+ distinct symmetry boundary types.
[WITHDRAWN IN PART, November 2026. The "fermionic condensation obstruction" is the T-constraint h = 0 mod 1 for condensed objects applied to objects with h = 1/2, a tautology under the paper's own definition; under the standard meaning (condensing an invertible fermion to a super-MTC) the claim is false: SU(2)_k x SU(2)_k has invertible fermions for k = 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7. Fermion counts are wrong for k = 3, 5; Table 2 phase identifications are wrong; three SU(4) rows of Table 4 miss bosons (pre-bugfix mtctools 0.2.x data; see ERRATUM_v7 at 10.5281/zenodo.20128951). The condensation lattices for SU(2)_4^2, SU(2)_8^2, SU(2)_6^2 (whose maximal algebra is the Spin(9)_1 conformal embedding) and SU(3)_3 x SU(2)_2 are correct and are retained in a corrected version. The text below is unchanged.] <= 0.2.x, whose condensable-algebra finder has since been found to have false negatives on conformal-embedding (E-type) algebras, and whose condensed-phase identification did not resolve the sixteen-fold way (a D^2 = 4 condensed phase is determined only together with the central charge mod 8). Affected classifications should be re-checked against mtctools 0.3.0 and the corrected release at DOI 10.5281/zenodo.20618695. The text below is the original and is retained for the record.] We establish rigorous obstructions to fermionic anyon condensation in product modular tensor categories and analyze the lattice structure of condensable algebras. Our key results include: (1) a proof that fermionic condensation is impossible in SU(2)_k ⊗ SU(2)_k for all k ≤ 8, and provide the mechanism via conformal weight analysis; (2) computation of the full condensation lattice (partial order under inclusion) for SU(2) levels 1-8, revealing rich combinatorial structure; (3) identification of maximal condensable algebras as Lagrangian when they exist. These results contribute to the classification program for topological phases of matter and have implications for the construction of fermionic topological orders from bosonic ones.
Author note (Nov 2026): an independent re-derivation confirms the two-algebra classification, the SO(11)_1 condensed phase, the N+k=6 characterization and the Witt class. It also found errors to be fixed in v8: the v7 erratum wrongly removed the SU(3)_2 x SU(2)_3 algebra, which is the SU(6)_1 conformal embedding (Theorem 4.1 should read 6 of 10, one E-type); mtctools 0.3.0 uses Re(S) in its invariant routine and accepts unphysical invariants (SO(9)_2 "d_A = 4"); WITT_TABLE central charges for F4_2 (16/11) and E6_2 (22/7) were rounded; the zero-locus conjecture fails for SU(2)_7. Version 7 — strengthens and corrects v6. 1. Adjoint transparency, characterized and explained. The v6 statement ("unique to SU(3)_3 among SU(N)_N") is superseded twice over. (a) Level-rank characterization: for SU(N)_k, k>=2, S_adj,fund = 0 if and only if N+k=6 (SU(2)_4, SU(3)_3, SU(4)_2 — one level-rank orbit), proved in closed form. (b) Mechanism and cross-family classification: the adjoint is a simple-current FIXED POINT exactly for SU(N)_{6-N} and for ALL Spin(N)_2, N>=5; a two-line lemma (multiplicativity of Verlinde eigenvalues) then forces S_adj,x = 0 for every current-charged x. The previously "isolated" Sp(2)_2 = Spin(5)_2 is the first member of the infinite metaplectic family. All S-matrix zeros in the scanned families are accounted for by this mechanism or by known exceptional invariants (SU(3)_5 in SU(6)_1, G2 level 3 in E6 level 1, ...); we conjecture no accidental zeros exist in WZW modular data. 2. Corrected survey. (a) The earlier non-simple-current algebra in SU(3)_2 ⊗ SU(2)_3 does not exist (non-unitary S-matrix artifact). (b) Condensed phases are now identified by rank+twists+central charge, never by D^2 alone: the Z2 condensation of SU(2)_2 ⊗ SU(2)_2 is the pointed theory SU(4)_1 (nu=6), NOT Ising; the maximal condensation of SU(3)_3 ⊗ SU(2)_2 is the nu=11 Ising-type category of Kitaev's sixteen-fold way — the modular tensor category of SO(11)_1 (h_sigma = 11/16), which shares its fusion rules with Ising and its fusion category with SU(2)_2 but is equivalent to neither as a braided category. Its Witt class is [Ising]^11, of order 16. 3. mtctools 0.3.0. The condensable-algebra finder now uses the modular-invariant (commutant) criterion decided by exact integer programming; the previous z_l-integrality test had false negatives on conformal-embedding algebras (it rejected 1+(j=3) in SU(2)_10, 1+(2,2) in SU(3)_5, 1+(1,1) in G2_3 — all now found and covered by regression tests). Phase identification is sixteen-fold-aware (takes c mod 8). Two further fixes: a twist-rounding bug that discarded B-series algebras (including the LAGRANGIAN of SO(9)_2 — which has c=0 mod 8 and a gapped boundary), and fixed-point splitting is now restricted to cyclic stabilizers (non-cyclic cases are flagged; they require discrete-torsion data beyond (S,T)). 4. New data: a Witt-class table for the metaplectic series SO(N)_2 (N=5..13), whose vector-current condensates are pointed (rank = D^2 forces it), reducing each Witt class to an explicit finite quadratic form (e.g. (Z_11, k^2/11), (Z_13, 2k^2/13)); SO(9)_2 is Witt-trivial. See ERRATUM_v7.md for the changelog. All computations reproducible with the included package (S unitary, S^2=C, integer Verlinde, ~1e-15).
Correction to the correction note (Nov 2026): the extended vacuum character in eq. (4) already contains (3,0;0) and (0,3;0), i.e. the correct d_A = 6 algebra; it was misread as d_A = 4. "Fails fusion closure" is not a valid non-algebra criterion; see the valid reasons on the companion record. The embedding-dimension "reconciliation" is withdrawn. [CORRECTION NOTE, June 2026: The central uniqueness claim of this preprint is corrected. The object 1 + ((1,1);1) (d_A = 4) is NOT an algebra: its generator fails fusion closure. The correct classification has exactly two non-trivial condensable algebras, the Z3 simple-current algebra (d_A = 3) and the maximal algebra (d_A = 6), and the maximal condensation yields the nu=11 Ising-type category of the sixteen-fold way - the modular tensor category of SO(11)_1 (h_sigma = 11/16) - which shares its fusion rules with Ising and its fusion category with SU(2)_2 but is equivalent to neither as a braided category. See the corrected release at DOI 10.5281/zenodo.20618695 (concept 10.5281/zenodo.20128951). A corrected manuscript is under journal review. The text below is the original and is retained for the record.] We give a complete analysis of anyon condensation in the rank-30 modular tensor category C = SU(3)_3 ⊗ SU(2)_2. We prove that A = 1 ⊕ ((1,1);1) is the unique non-trivial condensable algebra by classifying all physical modular invariants. The local module category C^loc_A is computed explicitly: it is a rank-3 MTC with quantum dimensions (1,1,√2), total quantum dimension D² = 4, and Ising fusion rules. The F-symbol F^{σσσ}_σ = (1/√2)[[1,1],[1,-1]] is verified from SU(2)_2 quantum 6j-symbols, confirming C^loc_A ≅ Ising ≅ SU(2)_2 as modular tensor categories.
[SUPERSEDED VERSION, notice added November 2026. The claims of this version were withdrawn or corrected after the author's adversarial review of June 2026. See the Status Note and Partial Retraction, DOI 10.5281/zenodo.20618848, the maintained mathematics at DOI 10.5281/zenodo.20128951, and the current version of this record via its concept DOI. The text below is unchanged as the record of the programme's history.] We present a systematic computational survey of condensable algebras (connected étale algebras) in product modular tensor categories of the form SU(N₁)_{k₁} ⊗ SU(N₂)_{k₂} at small rank. Using the Verlinde formula and modular invariant classification, we identify all non-trivial condensable algebras across 10 product MTCs with rank ≤ 36. We verify the Shimizu-Yadav conditions ensuring that the local module categories are modular, and compute the condensation completion structure including domain walls and defects using the Décoppet-Yu framework. Our survey reveals a rich landscape: simple current algebras of types Z₂, Z₃, and Z₂×Z₂ dominate, with condensed phases including the Ising MTC. We also correct an error in a previous classification of SU(3)₃ ⊗ SU(2)₂, where the maximal condensable algebra has d_A = 6 (not 4), yielding the Ising MTC as the condensed phase. All computational code is included.