Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Unal-Snell Paradox Quantum Uncertainty Limits of Refractive Indices and Information Restoration.

Hakan ÜNAL

Published May 13, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.5281/zenodo.20154954

Related papers

THE UNAL PRINCIPLE QUANTUM UNCERTAINTY AS THE FOUNDATION OF OPTICAL REFRACTION AND CAMOUFLAGE.

Hakan ÜNAL

•Mar 22, 2026•0 citations

Uncertainty Principle in the Light of Quantum Information Science

Saptarshi Sahoo, Amit Kumar Mandal, Nirmalya Misra +1 more

Algorithms for intelligent systems•Jan 1, 2022•0 citations

The Hakan ÜNAL Principle How Atomic Energy and Refraction Redefine Quantum Exclusion

Hakan ÜNAL

•Jul 28, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Information and Optics

Andrew G. White

•Mar 1, 2002•1 citation

Schrödinger’s equation from Snell’s law

Nathan Willig Lima, Ricardo Karam

Abstract A new derivation of Schrödinger’s equation is presented, based on Schrödinger’s original discussions on refraction and the optical-mechanical analogy, but adopting a much simpler formalism: Newtonian mechanics and some basic elements of classical wave theory (such as Snell’s law). We compare how particles and waves refract and show that the ‘law of particle refraction’ and the ‘law of wave refraction’ may become consistent if one assumes that a particle can be represented by a wave group. In this case, the differential equation whose solutions represent the waves forming such wave group is the Schrödinger equation. Due to the simplicity of the adopted mathematical formalism, we argue that this derivation can be used in quantum mechanics courses at introductory level to give students an idea of Schrödinger’s original path to his wave equation.

European Journal of Physics•Feb 17, 2022•0 citations

Is Fermat's Least Time Principle Equivalent to a Least Information Approach?

Francesco R. Ruggeri

Fermat’s Least Time Principle clearly refers to a path in space which is associated with the least time of travel. In particular, one could apply this approach to derive Snell’s law, assuming a fixed initial (xo=0,yo), change in index of refraction below y=0 and a fixed end point (x0=L, -yo). Officially, the integral which is minimized is: Integral ds/v (1) where ds is a unit length on the curve traversed and v, the velocity. In this note, we point out that dt= ds/v is sometimes used in the literature as being proportional to the probability for a particle to be found in ds (see (2)). If a particle is moving fast, then dt is small and there is less probability of finding the particle (hence less information) than if it moves slowly. We argue that one may consider that Fermat’s Least Time Principle is equivalent to a minimization of information. This suggests the notion of probability instead of deterministic physics which might at first be implied by the notion of minimal time. This interpretation of information or least time may be fine for the derivation of the 2-D Snell’s law, but fails in the analysis of 1-D reflection-refraction at an n1-n2 interface. This suggests that something more may be occurring. The notion of dt representing the probability for a detection-measurement hit is based on the idea of an interaction occurring at the center-of-mass point of the particle. Given the photon example, and E=pc, we suggest that there might be a different interpretation of information. For fixed E, if c1=c/2, then p1=2p. By taking 1/p1, one obtains the factor ½ again. Thus, one might be able to consider 1/p as linked with information. Formally, t=distance/c = p* distance for light, but we suggest using this in general for both light and particles with rest mass. Then, 1/p is linked with information. High p means low 1/p and high information. One wishes to minize information. A function which enforces the 1/p resolution is exp(ipx) such that exp(ipx)exp(-ipx) =1 like dt=constant. This would explain the 2-D Snell’s law Fermat’s Least Time Principle case, but it also has implications for p= mo v = (2mo) (v/2). In this case, the particle’s have the same momentum, but different speeds. If one only thinks in terms of speed, then they carry different information, but in terms of an impulse hit, they carry the same information. If one insists that impulse hit is linked to information, then using 1/p as the information quantity seems to hold. As a result, one no longer follows the center-of-mass in space and time in such an approach. This suggests a different scheme which is ultimately equivalent to the statement that for dt=contstant, v=constant, one has the same probability for each dx. Mathematically, exp(ipx) creates periodic regions proportional to 1/p, but exp(ipx)exp(-ipx) =1 yields a constant for each dx which is akin to dt=constant in each of these dx regions. The form exp(ipx) allows one to solve 1D reflection-refraction, while minimization of information px (part of the action -Et+px) allows one to find Snell’s law.

•May 11, 2026•0 citations
Abstract A new derivation of Schrödinger’s equation is presented, based on Schrödinger’s original discussions on refraction and the optical-mechanical analogy, but adopting a much simpler formalism: Newtonian mechanics and some basic elements of classical wave theory (such as Snell’s law). We compare how particles and waves refract and show that the ‘law of particle refraction’ and the ‘law of wave refraction’ may become consistent if one assumes that a particle can be represented by a wave group. In this case, the differential equation whose solutions represent the waves forming such wave group is the Schrödinger equation. Due to the simplicity of the adopted mathematical formalism, we argue that this derivation can be used in quantum mechanics courses at introductory level to give students an idea of Schrödinger’s original path to his wave equation.
Fermat’s Least Time Principle clearly refers to a path in space which is associated with the least time of travel. In particular, one could apply this approach to derive Snell’s law, assuming a fixed initial (xo=0,yo), change in index of refraction below y=0 and a fixed end point (x0=L, -yo). Officially, the integral which is minimized is: Integral ds/v (1) where ds is a unit length on the curve traversed and v, the velocity. In this note, we point out that dt= ds/v is sometimes used in the literature as being proportional to the probability for a particle to be found in ds (see (2)). If a particle is moving fast, then dt is small and there is less probability of finding the particle (hence less information) than if it moves slowly. We argue that one may consider that Fermat’s Least Time Principle is equivalent to a minimization of information. This suggests the notion of probability instead of deterministic physics which might at first be implied by the notion of minimal time. This interpretation of information or least time may be fine for the derivation of the 2-D Snell’s law, but fails in the analysis of 1-D reflection-refraction at an n1-n2 interface. This suggests that something more may be occurring. The notion of dt representing the probability for a detection-measurement hit is based on the idea of an interaction occurring at the center-of-mass point of the particle. Given the photon example, and E=pc, we suggest that there might be a different interpretation of information. For fixed E, if c1=c/2, then p1=2p. By taking 1/p1, one obtains the factor ½ again. Thus, one might be able to consider 1/p as linked with information. Formally, t=distance/c = p* distance for light, but we suggest using this in general for both light and particles with rest mass. Then, 1/p is linked with information. High p means low 1/p and high information. One wishes to minize information. A function which enforces the 1/p resolution is exp(ipx) such that exp(ipx)exp(-ipx) =1 like dt=constant. This would explain the 2-D Snell’s law Fermat’s Least Time Principle case, but it also has implications for p= mo v = (2mo) (v/2). In this case, the particle’s have the same momentum, but different speeds. If one only thinks in terms of speed, then they carry different information, but in terms of an impulse hit, they carry the same information. If one insists that impulse hit is linked to information, then using 1/p as the information quantity seems to hold. As a result, one no longer follows the center-of-mass in space and time in such an approach. This suggests a different scheme which is ultimately equivalent to the statement that for dt=contstant, v=constant, one has the same probability for each dx. Mathematically, exp(ipx) creates periodic regions proportional to 1/p, but exp(ipx)exp(-ipx) =1 yields a constant for each dx which is akin to dt=constant in each of these dx regions. The form exp(ipx) allows one to solve 1D reflection-refraction, while minimization of information px (part of the action -Et+px) allows one to find Snell’s law.