Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Reciprocal Emergence of Determinacy and Indeterminacy in Opposition: The Construction of a New Ontological Principle and Its Scientific Corroboration

Qiaowei Sun

Published May 11, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract Traditional philosophy has long enshrined "determinacy" as the essential attribute of Being, while relegating "indeterminacy" to the status of a temporary defect of human cognition, a vague state awaiting elimination. The revolutionary development of quantum mechanics has thoroughly shattered this millennia-old cognitive presupposition: the superposition state of microscopic particles is not an "undetermined intermediate state," but an intrinsic property of Being itself; wave-particle duality is not a random mutation of particles, but the determinate manifestation of the same indeterminate ontological substance, emerging within different observational relations. This paper proposes a fundamentally new ontological principle: determinacy is the skeleton of Being that emerges from and is anchored by indeterminacy; indeterminacy, in turn, is the primordial matrix from which determinacy is generated, described, and manifested. These two dimensions do not exist in a relation of sequential dependence or hierarchical subordination, but constitute a reciprocal generative structure in which they define each other in opposition and emerge simultaneously in dynamic interaction. Taking quantum mechanical superposition and wave-particle duality as its core empirical evidence, this paper demonstrates the universal penetrative power of this ontological principle, and points out that eliminating indeterminacy is not the core task of philosophy; rather, modern philosophy must urgently break free from the shackles of traditional paradigms and return to the dynamic, authentic state of Being itself in order to reconstruct cognition. Keywords: Determinacy; Indeterminacy; Reciprocal Emergence in Opposition; Emergence; Manifestation; Desire/Contradiction; Ontology

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.20118553

Related papers

An Indeterminacy-based Ontology for Quantum Theory

Francisco Pipa

I present and defend a new ontology for quantum theories (or ``interpretations'' of quantum theory) called Generative Quantum Theory (GQT). GQT postulates different sets of features, and the combination of these different features can help generate different quantum theories. Furthermore, this ontology makes quantum indeterminacy and determinacy play an important explanatory role in accounting for when quantum systems whose values of their properties are indeterminate become determinate. The process via which determinate values arise varies between the different quantum theories. Moreover, quantum states represent quantum properties and structures that give rise to determinacy, and each quantum theory specifies a structure with certain features. I will focus on the following quantum theories: GRW, the Many-Worlds Interpretation, single-world relationalist theories such as Relational Quantum Mechanics, Bohmian Mechanics, hybrid classical-quantum theories, and Environmental Determinacy-based (EnD) Quantum Theory. I will argue that GQT should be taken seriously because it provides a series of important benefits that current widely discussed ontologies lack, namely, wave function realism and primitive ontology, without some of their costs. For instance, it helps generate quantum theories that are compatible with relativistic causality, such as EnD Quantum Theory. Also, GQT has the benefit of providing new ways to compare and evaluate quantum theories, which may lead to philosophical and scientific progress.

arXiv:2404.07197•Apr 10, 2024•2 citations

Between quantum indeterminacy and biological mutation: stability and uncertainty in a probabilistic living world

Dhia Bouktila

The classical deterministic worldview that dominated science from the seventeenth to the nineteenth century has been profoundly challenged by developments in modern physics and biology. Quantum mechanics has revealed that indeterminacy and probability are not merely epistemic limitations, but intrinsic features of physical reality. At the same time, evolutionary biology has shown that random genetic variation, filtered by natural selection, is the fundamental driver of biological diversity and adaptation. This article explores the conceptual parallel between quantum indeterminacy and evolutionary randomness, not as a reduction of biology to physics, but as an epistemological reflection on how stability and order emerge from probabilistic processes across different levels of organization. By examining emergence, contingency, historical irreversibility, and the limits of prediction, the paper argues that determinism is best understood as a scale-dependent approximation rather than a foundational ontological principle. The absence of finality in nature does not imply chaos or nihilism, but invites a renewed philosophical understanding of explanation, responsibility, and scientific humility in a probabilistic universe.

Science & philosophy•Jun 1, 2026•0 citations

An Indeterminacy-based Local Approach and Ontology for Quantum Theory

Francisco Pipa

In this dissertation, I propose two frameworks to address some important scientific and philosophical issues with quantum theory (QT). First, I propose Environmental Determinacy-based Quantum Theory (EnDQT) and argue that contrary to the other well-known quantum theories, it has the great benefit of being a local, non-relational, and non-superdeterministic/non-retrocausal "interpretation" of quantum theory, or quantum theory (QT). EnDQT has the benefit of being conservative, not modifying the fundamental equations of QT, and, in principle, allowing arbitrary systems to be placed in a coherent superposition for an arbitrary amount of time. Also, EnDQT is able to give a local causal explanation of quantum correlations. Via EnDQT, I also argue that i) QT is local in the sense of not being in conflict with relativity but without the need to adopt a relationalist, a superdeterminist, or a retrocausal approach. I also argue that ii) the notorious measurement problem can be addressed without modifying the quantum formalism, adding hidden variables, or adopting relationalism. Second, I propose Generative Quantum Theory (GQT) as a new ontology for quantum theories and show how it can be implemented via GRW, the MWI and single-world relationalist views, Bohmian Mechanics, hybrid classical-quantum theories, and EnDQT. I also distinguish it from the most discussed ontologies for quantum theories, namely, wavefunction realism and primitive ontology, and argue that it has certain benefits that they lack without some of their costs, such as non-locality. Due to the overall benefits of GQT compared with these widely debated ontological frameworks, and given that GQT, contrary to these frameworks, considers the wavefunction more like a predictor and that quantum indeterminacy plays an important explanatory role, I will argue that iii) the wavefunction is more like a predictor for different possibilities rather than a law or a field in a multidimensional space, and that iv) quantum indeterminacy plays a key explanatory role instead of a derivative role in order to understand QT.

•Jan 1, 2024•0 citations

The Principle of Simultaneous Emergence (SzEM) – A System-Ontological Approach to Quantum Mechanics

Balazs Sebestyen

The main interpretations of modern quantum mechanics (Many-Worlds, Copenhagen, Pilot-Wave) often appear in the current scientific discourse as mutually exclusive paradigms. The Principle of Simultaneous Emergence is fundamentally a deductive framework, built upon the premise that each of these mainstream interpretations is concurrently and experimentally substantiated. It proposes an ontological framework in which these theories are not competing concepts, but constitute different states of a single, simultaneous informational topology. The Principle of Simultaneous Emergence resolves the apparent paradox by defining time merely as a characteristic (and limitation) of macroscopic cognition, while universal information and its manifestation is a simultaneous process at the system level. The document is available in both English and Hungarian.

•May 11, 2026•0 citations

Reconstructing Quantum Ontology: A Counterfactual Philosophical and Physical Paradigm Study of Quantum Mechanics Based on the Law of Coexisting Mutually Exclusive Descriptions

Jincheng Zhang

In the late 1920s, Niels Bohr’s "Principle of Complementarity" became a cornerstone of the Copenhagen interpretation, asserting that the wave and particle aspects of micro-entities are mutually exclusive yet complementary properties manifested under distinct experimental arrangements. However, this classical-bound formulation inadvertently entangled quantum physics in a century-long ontological debate over what a microscopic system "really is." This paper presents a counterfactual historical and philosophical critique: had Bohr bypassed the binary framing of wave-particle duality and instead posited the Law of Coexisting Mutually Exclusive Descriptions—which dictates that a single physical system fundamentally possesses multiple, irreducible, and mutually exclusive descriptions simultaneously—the foundational paradigm of quantum mechanics would have undergone a decisive transformation. Under this proposed paradigm, the focus of quantum physics shifts from seeking a singular underlying "substance" to mapping how non-commutative, coexisting descriptions collectively construct physical reality. We demonstrate how this law redefines the quantum measurement problem, dissolves the misconception of "uncertainty" as an inherent ontological vagueness, and provides a unified conceptual framework for quantum entanglement and emergent spacetime in modern field theory. Ultimately, this work establishes a non-reductionist "Multitudinous Description Realism" that offers a clearer conceptual tool for contemporary quantum foundations and quantum information science.

•Jul 24, 2026•0 citations

Indeterminacy

Alastair Wilson

Abstract In Everettian quantum mechanics, the universal quantum state is fundamental, non-contingent, and wholly determinate. By contrast, the parallel worlds of diverging EQM, and the contingency constituted by self-location amongst those worlds, are emergent and partly indeterminate. In particular, it is indeterminate both how many worlds there are, and what microscopic qualitative features those worlds have. This chapter discusses various ways to understand indeterminacy in the Everettian multiverse, and argues that the indeterminacies of EQM present no obstacle to the analytic ambitions of quantum modal realism. Everettians can understand quantum indeterminacy using models of indeterminacy that are familiar from the philosophical literature on vagueness.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Feb 11, 2020•0 citations
Abstract Traditional philosophy has long enshrined "determinacy" as the essential attribute of Being, while relegating "indeterminacy" to the status of a temporary defect of human cognition, a vague state awaiting elimination. The revolutionary development of quantum mechanics has thoroughly shattered this millennia-old cognitive presupposition: the superposition state of microscopic particles is not an "undetermined intermediate state," but an intrinsic property of Being itself; wave-particle duality is not a random mutation of particles, but the determinate manifestation of the same indeterminate ontological substance, emerging within different observational relations. This paper proposes a fundamentally new ontological principle: determinacy is the skeleton of Being that emerges from and is anchored by indeterminacy; indeterminacy, in turn, is the primordial matrix from which determinacy is generated, described, and manifested. These two dimensions do not exist in a relation of sequential dependence or hierarchical subordination, but constitute a reciprocal generative structure in which they define each other in opposition and emerge simultaneously in dynamic interaction. Taking quantum mechanical superposition and wave-particle duality as its core empirical evidence, this paper demonstrates the universal penetrative power of this ontological principle, and points out that eliminating indeterminacy is not the core task of philosophy; rather, modern philosophy must urgently break free from the shackles of traditional paradigms and return to the dynamic, authentic state of Being itself in order to reconstruct cognition. Keywords: Determinacy; Indeterminacy; Reciprocal Emergence in Opposition; Emergence; Manifestation; Desire/Contradiction; Ontology
I present and defend a new ontology for quantum theories (or ``interpretations'' of quantum theory) called Generative Quantum Theory (GQT). GQT postulates different sets of features, and the combination of these different features can help generate different quantum theories. Furthermore, this ontology makes quantum indeterminacy and determinacy play an important explanatory role in accounting for when quantum systems whose values of their properties are indeterminate become determinate. The process via which determinate values arise varies between the different quantum theories. Moreover, quantum states represent quantum properties and structures that give rise to determinacy, and each quantum theory specifies a structure with certain features. I will focus on the following quantum theories: GRW, the Many-Worlds Interpretation, single-world relationalist theories such as Relational Quantum Mechanics, Bohmian Mechanics, hybrid classical-quantum theories, and Environmental Determinacy-based (EnD) Quantum Theory. I will argue that GQT should be taken seriously because it provides a series of important benefits that current widely discussed ontologies lack, namely, wave function realism and primitive ontology, without some of their costs. For instance, it helps generate quantum theories that are compatible with relativistic causality, such as EnD Quantum Theory. Also, GQT has the benefit of providing new ways to compare and evaluate quantum theories, which may lead to philosophical and scientific progress.
The classical deterministic worldview that dominated science from the seventeenth to the nineteenth century has been profoundly challenged by developments in modern physics and biology. Quantum mechanics has revealed that indeterminacy and probability are not merely epistemic limitations, but intrinsic features of physical reality. At the same time, evolutionary biology has shown that random genetic variation, filtered by natural selection, is the fundamental driver of biological diversity and adaptation. This article explores the conceptual parallel between quantum indeterminacy and evolutionary randomness, not as a reduction of biology to physics, but as an epistemological reflection on how stability and order emerge from probabilistic processes across different levels of organization. By examining emergence, contingency, historical irreversibility, and the limits of prediction, the paper argues that determinism is best understood as a scale-dependent approximation rather than a foundational ontological principle. The absence of finality in nature does not imply chaos or nihilism, but invites a renewed philosophical understanding of explanation, responsibility, and scientific humility in a probabilistic universe.
In this dissertation, I propose two frameworks to address some important scientific and philosophical issues with quantum theory (QT). First, I propose Environmental Determinacy-based Quantum Theory (EnDQT) and argue that contrary to the other well-known quantum theories, it has the great benefit of being a local, non-relational, and non-superdeterministic/non-retrocausal "interpretation" of quantum theory, or quantum theory (QT). EnDQT has the benefit of being conservative, not modifying the fundamental equations of QT, and, in principle, allowing arbitrary systems to be placed in a coherent superposition for an arbitrary amount of time. Also, EnDQT is able to give a local causal explanation of quantum correlations. Via EnDQT, I also argue that i) QT is local in the sense of not being in conflict with relativity but without the need to adopt a relationalist, a superdeterminist, or a retrocausal approach. I also argue that ii) the notorious measurement problem can be addressed without modifying the quantum formalism, adding hidden variables, or adopting relationalism. Second, I propose Generative Quantum Theory (GQT) as a new ontology for quantum theories and show how it can be implemented via GRW, the MWI and single-world relationalist views, Bohmian Mechanics, hybrid classical-quantum theories, and EnDQT. I also distinguish it from the most discussed ontologies for quantum theories, namely, wavefunction realism and primitive ontology, and argue that it has certain benefits that they lack without some of their costs, such as non-locality. Due to the overall benefits of GQT compared with these widely debated ontological frameworks, and given that GQT, contrary to these frameworks, considers the wavefunction more like a predictor and that quantum indeterminacy plays an important explanatory role, I will argue that iii) the wavefunction is more like a predictor for different possibilities rather than a law or a field in a multidimensional space, and that iv) quantum indeterminacy plays a key explanatory role instead of a derivative role in order to understand QT.
The main interpretations of modern quantum mechanics (Many-Worlds, Copenhagen, Pilot-Wave) often appear in the current scientific discourse as mutually exclusive paradigms. The Principle of Simultaneous Emergence is fundamentally a deductive framework, built upon the premise that each of these mainstream interpretations is concurrently and experimentally substantiated. It proposes an ontological framework in which these theories are not competing concepts, but constitute different states of a single, simultaneous informational topology. The Principle of Simultaneous Emergence resolves the apparent paradox by defining time merely as a characteristic (and limitation) of macroscopic cognition, while universal information and its manifestation is a simultaneous process at the system level. The document is available in both English and Hungarian.
In the late 1920s, Niels Bohr’s "Principle of Complementarity" became a cornerstone of the Copenhagen interpretation, asserting that the wave and particle aspects of micro-entities are mutually exclusive yet complementary properties manifested under distinct experimental arrangements. However, this classical-bound formulation inadvertently entangled quantum physics in a century-long ontological debate over what a microscopic system "really is." This paper presents a counterfactual historical and philosophical critique: had Bohr bypassed the binary framing of wave-particle duality and instead posited the Law of Coexisting Mutually Exclusive Descriptions—which dictates that a single physical system fundamentally possesses multiple, irreducible, and mutually exclusive descriptions simultaneously—the foundational paradigm of quantum mechanics would have undergone a decisive transformation. Under this proposed paradigm, the focus of quantum physics shifts from seeking a singular underlying "substance" to mapping how non-commutative, coexisting descriptions collectively construct physical reality. We demonstrate how this law redefines the quantum measurement problem, dissolves the misconception of "uncertainty" as an inherent ontological vagueness, and provides a unified conceptual framework for quantum entanglement and emergent spacetime in modern field theory. Ultimately, this work establishes a non-reductionist "Multitudinous Description Realism" that offers a clearer conceptual tool for contemporary quantum foundations and quantum information science.
Abstract In Everettian quantum mechanics, the universal quantum state is fundamental, non-contingent, and wholly determinate. By contrast, the parallel worlds of diverging EQM, and the contingency constituted by self-location amongst those worlds, are emergent and partly indeterminate. In particular, it is indeterminate both how many worlds there are, and what microscopic qualitative features those worlds have. This chapter discusses various ways to understand indeterminacy in the Everettian multiverse, and argues that the indeterminacies of EQM present no obstacle to the analytic ambitions of quantum modal realism. Everettians can understand quantum indeterminacy using models of indeterminacy that are familiar from the philosophical literature on vagueness.