Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Discussion on the Self Consistency of Quantum Mechanics

Runsheng Tu

Published May 10, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

根据薛定谔方程,可以推导出波函数的波能、德布罗意波的能量和粒子动能之间的关系。这种关系与狄拉克方程所识别的情况不一致(狄拉克方程中波函数的波能而薛定谔方程中的波能不包含该项)。动态和稳态薛定谔方程所识别的关系并不完全一致。量的E/p和λν均为超光速。必须承认,德布罗意波只能被视为波包,且只能使用其群速度。然而,电子绕射实验直接证明,运动电子的德布罗意波不是波包,而是单色波。只要这个单色波是无法与运动电子分离的物理现实,运动电子的德布罗意单色波的相速度不能快于光速。这些量子力学中的根本问题表明,现有量子理论的自洽性并不令人满意。

DOI
10.6084/m9.figshare.30884711

Related papers

Critical temperature of finite systems in d dimensions

Cyril Domb

The critical temperature of an Ising system consisting of n(d-1) dimensional layers in d dimensions is estimated for large n from the properties of random and self-avoiding walks (SAW) in the finite system. Denoting the deviation of T c (n) from T c ( infinity ) by 1/n lambda it is found that there are two contributions, a finite size effect which applies both to a torus and a strip and for which lambda =d-2+ eta , and a free boundary effect which applies to a strip alone and for which lambda =1/ nu d . ( nu d , eta are exponents associated with the spin pair correlation function using the standard notation of Fisher). The results are based on a perturbation expansion for SAW which should be reliable for d>or=4, but which needs further examination when d=3. Some, but not all, of the above features are in agreement with the results of Fisher and Barber for the spherical model.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical Nuclear and General•Sep 1, 1973•53 citations

New Understanding for Philosophy of Quantum Mechanics

桂起权

对范弗拉森量子哲学要害问题--量子测量、量子概率和量子关联(特别是令人困惑的测量问题)进行梳理和澄清,并作出新的概括和再解释.尤为可贵的是万小龙对全同粒子的哲学分析,不仅填补了我国学界的一个空白,而且在分析的形而上学方面提出了自己独到的见解.

Journal of Shandong University of Science and Technology•Jan 1, 2005•0 citations

On the interpretation of quantum mechanics

A. V. Tiaglo

В общем контексте проблемы недооценки социально-гуманитарной мысли профессионалами различных областей науки и техники обсуждается пример интерпретации квантовой механики. Аргументирована перспектива формирования этой интерпретации с учетом квантовой концепции целостности как особенного воплощения рационального холизма.

•Jan 1, 2018•0 citations

Some rigorous results concerning the uniform metallic ground states of single-band Hamiltonians in arbitrary dimensions

Behnam Farid

We reproduce and review some of the main results of three of our earlier papers, utilizing in doing so a considerably more transparent formalism than originally utilized. The most fundamental result to which we pay especial attention in this paper, is that the exact Fermi surface (FS) of the uniform metallic ground state (GS) of any single-band Hamiltonian, describing fermions, is a subset of the FS within the framework of the exact Hartree-Fock theory. We also review some of the physical implications of the latter result. Our considerations reveal that the interacting FS of a uniform metallic GS cannot be calculated exactly to order ν(ν\ge 2) in the coupling constant λof the interaction potential in terms of the self-energy calculated to order νin a non-self-consistent fashion. We show this to be interlinked with the failure of the Luttinger-Ward identity, and thus of the Luttinger theorem, for a self-energy that is not appropriately related to the single-particle Green function from which the FS is deduced. We further show that the same mechanism that embodies the Luttinger theorem within the framework of the exact theory, accounts for a non-trivial dependence of the exact self-energy on λthat cannot be captured within a non-self-consistent framework. We thus establish that the extant calculations that purportedly prove deformation of the interacting FS of the metallic GS of the single-band Hubbard Hamiltonian with respect to its Hartree-Fock counterpart at the second order in the on-site interaction energy U, are fundamentally deficient. In an appendix we show that the number-density distribution function, to be distinguished from the site-occupation distribution function, corresponding to the GS of the Hubbard Hamiltonian is not non-interacting v-representable, a fact established earlier numerically. [Abridged Abstract]

arXiv:1305.2089•May 9, 2013•3 citations

量子因果论(Quantum causality theory)

Huilin Zhao

摘 要:主流经济学因果认知先后经历决定论因果与概率因果两次革命,二者共享经典力学世界观的强本体论预设:因果关系客观先在、变量可独立分离、观测行为中立无扰、因果作用局域链式传递。这使得现代实证因果推断始终面临内生性无解、预期自实现、观测干预扭曲与非局部联动失效等底层困境。本文突破传统框架,原创性提出经济学意义上的量子因果论,将经济因果关系重构为因果叠加、因果纠缠与观测坍缩共同规定的量子态演化过程。文章严格证明:经典确定性因果是量子因果在“高频观测、大规模平均、强制度约束”条件下的统计近似;概率因果则是量子因果在“弱叠加、弱纠缠、弱观测干扰”情形下的退化特例。本文构建量子因果的公理体系、态空间表示、因果相干性判据与观测坍缩机制,首次提出经济退相干原理,有效化解量子叠加性与日常确定性因果的表观矛盾。研究表明,量子因果论能够统一解释从个体决策到宏观波动、从市场均衡到系统性风险的所有经济现象,为重新理解内生性、预期效应、政策传导与系统风险提供一般化基础,也为中国自主经济学知识体系构建提供具有范式革新意义的理论工具。 关键词:量子因果论;因果叠加;因果纠缠;观测坍缩;经济退相干

•Jun 4, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Mechanics: Internal Motion in Theory and Experiment

Antony J. Bourdillon

Dispersion dynamics applies wave-particle duality, together with Maxwell’s electromagnetism, and with quantization E = hν = ħω (symbol definitions in footnote) and p = h/λ = ħk, to special relativity E2 = p2c2 + m2c4. Calculations on a wave-packet, that is symmetric about the normal distribution, are partly conservative and partly responsive. The complex electron wave function is chiefly modelled on the real wave function of an electromagnetic photon; while the former concept of a “point particle” is downgraded to mathematical abstraction. The computations yield conclusions for phase and group velocities, vp⋅vg = c2 with vp ≥ c because vg ≤ c, as in relativity. The condition on the phase velocity is most noticeable when p≪mc. Further consequences in dispersion dynamics are: derivations for ν and λ that are consistently established by one hundred years of experience in electron microscopy and particle accelerators. Values for vp = νλ = ω/k are therefore systematically verified by the products of known multiplicands or divisions by known divisors, even if vp is not independently measured. These consequences are significant in reduction of the wave-packet by resonant response during interactions between photons and electrons, for example, or between particles and particles. Thus the logic of mathematical quantum mechanics is distinguished from experiential physics that is continuous in time, and consistent with uncertainty principles. [Footnote: symbol E = energy; h = Planck’s constant; ν = frequency; ω = angular momentum; p = momentum; λ = wavelength; k = wave vector; c = speed of light; m = particle rest mass; vp = phase velocity; vg = group velocity].

Journal of Modern Physics•Jan 1, 2023•3 citations
根据薛定谔方程,可以推导出波函数的波能、德布罗意波的能量和粒子动能之间的关系。这种关系与狄拉克方程所识别的情况不一致(狄拉克方程中波函数的波能而薛定谔方程中的波能不包含该项)。动态和稳态薛定谔方程所识别的关系并不完全一致。量的E/p和λν均为超光速。必须承认,德布罗意波只能被视为波包,且只能使用其群速度。然而,电子绕射实验直接证明,运动电子的德布罗意波不是波包,而是单色波。只要这个单色波是无法与运动电子分离的物理现实,运动电子的德布罗意单色波的相速度不能快于光速。这些量子力学中的根本问题表明,现有量子理论的自洽性并不令人满意。
The critical temperature of an Ising system consisting of n(d-1) dimensional layers in d dimensions is estimated for large n from the properties of random and self-avoiding walks (SAW) in the finite system. Denoting the deviation of T c (n) from T c ( infinity ) by 1/n lambda it is found that there are two contributions, a finite size effect which applies both to a torus and a strip and for which lambda =d-2+ eta , and a free boundary effect which applies to a strip alone and for which lambda =1/ nu d . ( nu d , eta are exponents associated with the spin pair correlation function using the standard notation of Fisher). The results are based on a perturbation expansion for SAW which should be reliable for d>or=4, but which needs further examination when d=3. Some, but not all, of the above features are in agreement with the results of Fisher and Barber for the spherical model.
В общем контексте проблемы недооценки социально-гуманитарной мысли профессионалами различных областей науки и техники обсуждается пример интерпретации квантовой механики. Аргументирована перспектива формирования этой интерпретации с учетом квантовой концепции целостности как особенного воплощения рационального холизма.
We reproduce and review some of the main results of three of our earlier papers, utilizing in doing so a considerably more transparent formalism than originally utilized. The most fundamental result to which we pay especial attention in this paper, is that the exact Fermi surface (FS) of the uniform metallic ground state (GS) of any single-band Hamiltonian, describing fermions, is a subset of the FS within the framework of the exact Hartree-Fock theory. We also review some of the physical implications of the latter result. Our considerations reveal that the interacting FS of a uniform metallic GS cannot be calculated exactly to order ν(ν\ge 2) in the coupling constant λof the interaction potential in terms of the self-energy calculated to order νin a non-self-consistent fashion. We show this to be interlinked with the failure of the Luttinger-Ward identity, and thus of the Luttinger theorem, for a self-energy that is not appropriately related to the single-particle Green function from which the FS is deduced. We further show that the same mechanism that embodies the Luttinger theorem within the framework of the exact theory, accounts for a non-trivial dependence of the exact self-energy on λthat cannot be captured within a non-self-consistent framework. We thus establish that the extant calculations that purportedly prove deformation of the interacting FS of the metallic GS of the single-band Hubbard Hamiltonian with respect to its Hartree-Fock counterpart at the second order in the on-site interaction energy U, are fundamentally deficient. In an appendix we show that the number-density distribution function, to be distinguished from the site-occupation distribution function, corresponding to the GS of the Hubbard Hamiltonian is not non-interacting v-representable, a fact established earlier numerically. [Abridged Abstract]
摘 要:主流经济学因果认知先后经历决定论因果与概率因果两次革命,二者共享经典力学世界观的强本体论预设:因果关系客观先在、变量可独立分离、观测行为中立无扰、因果作用局域链式传递。这使得现代实证因果推断始终面临内生性无解、预期自实现、观测干预扭曲与非局部联动失效等底层困境。本文突破传统框架,原创性提出经济学意义上的量子因果论,将经济因果关系重构为因果叠加、因果纠缠与观测坍缩共同规定的量子态演化过程。文章严格证明:经典确定性因果是量子因果在“高频观测、大规模平均、强制度约束”条件下的统计近似;概率因果则是量子因果在“弱叠加、弱纠缠、弱观测干扰”情形下的退化特例。本文构建量子因果的公理体系、态空间表示、因果相干性判据与观测坍缩机制,首次提出经济退相干原理,有效化解量子叠加性与日常确定性因果的表观矛盾。研究表明,量子因果论能够统一解释从个体决策到宏观波动、从市场均衡到系统性风险的所有经济现象,为重新理解内生性、预期效应、政策传导与系统风险提供一般化基础,也为中国自主经济学知识体系构建提供具有范式革新意义的理论工具。 关键词:量子因果论;因果叠加;因果纠缠;观测坍缩;经济退相干
Dispersion dynamics applies wave-particle duality, together with Maxwell’s electromagnetism, and with quantization E = hν = ħω (symbol definitions in footnote) and p = h/λ = ħk, to special relativity E2 = p2c2 + m2c4. Calculations on a wave-packet, that is symmetric about the normal distribution, are partly conservative and partly responsive. The complex electron wave function is chiefly modelled on the real wave function of an electromagnetic photon; while the former concept of a “point particle” is downgraded to mathematical abstraction. The computations yield conclusions for phase and group velocities, vp⋅vg = c2 with vp ≥ c because vg ≤ c, as in relativity. The condition on the phase velocity is most noticeable when p≪mc. Further consequences in dispersion dynamics are: derivations for ν and λ that are consistently established by one hundred years of experience in electron microscopy and particle accelerators. Values for vp = νλ = ω/k are therefore systematically verified by the products of known multiplicands or divisions by known divisors, even if vp is not independently measured. These consequences are significant in reduction of the wave-packet by resonant response during interactions between photons and electrons, for example, or between particles and particles. Thus the logic of mathematical quantum mechanics is distinguished from experiential physics that is continuous in time, and consistent with uncertainty principles. [Footnote: symbol E = energy; h = Planck’s constant; ν = frequency; ω = angular momentum; p = momentum; λ = wavelength; k = wave vector; c = speed of light; m = particle rest mass; vp = phase velocity; vg = group velocity].