Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Assessing Claims of Advantage in Quantum Machine Learning: A Critical Review

Stefan Klug, Maximilian Moll

Published May 7, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract Quantum machine learning (QML) has attracted growing interest because quantum states and circuits may provide new representational primitives for learning, yet progress remains constrained by noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) hardware and heterogeneous evaluation practices. This article presents a critical review of recent QML architectures and representative empirical and theoretical studies, with emphasis on work published since 2022 alongside selected seminal references. To improve comparability, “quantum advantage” is assessed in three distinct senses: computational scaling under stated input-access assumptions, empirical predictive performance in the benchmark setting considered, and resource efficiency at a fixed budget accounting for both classical compute and quantum execution, including shot costs. Organized by architecture family and application domain, the review analyzes how baseline strength, hyperparameter optimization, preprocessing, and budget reporting shape conclusions. Overall, quantum feature maps and kernels, as well as variational (often hybrid) pipelines, can be competitive on selected small- to medium-scale benchmarks, but robust end-to-end evidence for a general practical advantage remains limited. Reported gains are often sensitive to budget matching and may be dominated by measurement overheads, dataset and preprocessing effects, and training instabilities. The review concludes that credible progress requires standardized benchmarking, transparent end-to-end resource accounting, and hardware-centered evaluations that test scalability and robustness beyond toy regimes.

DOI
10.21203/rs.3.rs-9311359/v1

Related papers

Assessing The Reality of Quantum Advantage in Machine Learning

Shridhar Jalindar Shelke, Purvaja Mahajan, Atharav Arvind Pujari +1 more

Quantum computing has generated significant expectations for its potential to enhance machine learning (ML) tasks, with theoretical research proposing computational advantages ranging from polynomial to exponential speedups for specific subroutines.However, a critical disconnect remains: theoretical or asymptotic speedup claims do not automatically imply a practical, end-to-end advantage.Current evidence does not clearly establish whether these claimed advantages translate into measurable superiority over optimised classical approaches.This review critically assesses the relationship between theoretical claims of quantum advantage and the currently available practical and experimental evidence.We critically examine the evidence and assumptions underlying claimed speedups, including the overheads associated with data encoding and access, as well as the use of appropriate and competitive classical baselines for fair comparison.The scope of this assessment covers key limiting factors, such as scalability, trainability, hardware noise in the noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) era, and overall resource requirements.By distinguishing between theoretical potential and demonstrated practical performance, this work identifies where current evidence is convincing and where it remains insufficient.The review identifies the specific conditions required for the credible validation of quantum advantage and argues that future progress must be positioned around rigorous, realistic, and end-to-end evaluation rather than theoretical complexity claims alone.

International Journal of Innovative Research in Technology•Oct 13, 2026•0 citations

A systematic review of quantum machine learning: algorithms, application domains, and emerging trends

Raed Abu Zitar, Murad M. Al-Rajab, Samia Loucif +1 more

Quantum Machine Learning (QML) integrates the principles of quantum mechanics superposition, entanglement, and interference into mathematical and logical operations that classical computers cannot emulate. Despite the limitations of today’s noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ-ERA) devices, these platforms already sustain small- to medium-scale machine-learning workloads, catalyzing rapid expansion in QML research. Guided by PRISMA methodology, we systematically screened 5,463 publications published between January 2015 and June 2025 and identified 160 high-quality studies that implemented or evaluated QML algorithms on real or simulated quantum processors. The selected literature converges into four thematic categories: (i) quantum adaptations of classical algorithms, (ii) variational and hybrid quantum–classical models, (iii) quantum linear-algebra accelerators, and (iv) quantum-inspired generative and reinforcement techniques. Application domains span image and signal classification, cybersecurity, finance, chemistry, and healthcare, with benchmarks such as MNIST, CIC-IDS2019 and credit-risk corpora featuring prominently in the reviewed corpus. Separately from the reviewed literature, Sect. 6 reports our own five-seed benchmark of five quantum and two classical classifiers on five public tabular datasets (Breast Cancer, Diabetes, Iris, Sonar and Bank Marketing). Comparative analyses reveal that hybrid QML systems typically match or marginally exceed the performance of state-of-the-art classical baselines while employing fewer parameters. Nevertheless, a clear, reproducible quantum advantage remains elusive, hindered by data-encoding overheads, circuit-depth constraints, environmental noise, and barren-plateau training phenomena. By integrating algorithmic trends, empirical outcomes, and hardware considerations, this review delineates QML’s present capabilities and identifies critical technological milestones error mitigation, scalable qubit architectures, and efficient data-loading schemes needed to unlock its full potential.

Artificial Intelligence Review•Nov 12, 2026•0 citations

A Systematic Literature Review of Quantum Machine Learning and Its Applications

Yusufcan Sekmen, Bekir Parlak

Quantum Machine Learning (QML) has become an important research area in recent years due to its potential to overcome the computational bottlenecks faced by classical machine learning methods. In this study, only SCI/SCI-Expanded journal articles published between 2023 and 2025 and accepted as early access for 2026 are considered, and 30 such articles are systematically examined to provide a comprehensive assessment of the current state of QML methods. The reviewed literature covers variational quantum circuits, quantum kernel methods, hybrid quantum–classical models, quantum annealing approaches, federated QML architectures, data encoding strategies, and adversarial robustness analyses. The findings indicate that QML models can exhibit stronger representational capacity and higher generalization performance compared to classical methods, particularly on high-dimensional, noisy, or small sample datasets. Reported results in domains such as healthcare, chemistry, energy systems, cybersecurity, blockchain, and finance reveal the diversity of QML applications and its interdisciplinary potential. Nevertheless, the limited qubit capacity of current NISQ hardware, constraints on circuit depth, and noise-related issues remain fundamental factors that restrict the scalability of QML models. This study synthesizes methodological trends, identifies open research problems, and proposes a directional roadmap for future QML research focused on hardware-aware circuit design, efficient data encoding schemes, and robust learning frameworks.

Journal of Computers and Computational Science•Dec 31, 2025•0 citations

Advancements In Quantum Machine Learning: Bridging Quantum Computing And Artificial Intelligence

Yichen Zhao

Quantum Machine Learning (QML) unites quantum computing with modern AI to achieve potential gains in expressivity, runtime, and sample efficiency. This paper synthesizes advances in quantum feature maps, variational quantum circuits (VQCs), and hybrid quantum-classical workflows deployable on noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) hardware. We outline design principles for data encoding, ansatz selection, and trainability, and summarize error-aware practices—error mitigation, shot-frugal estimation, and compiler co-design. Using synthetic but instructive experiments, we illustrate scaling behavior, noise sensitivity, end-to-end inference latency across backends, and optimizer convergence in variational training. We conclude with an agenda emphasizing domain-aligned encodings, rigorous benchmarking, and reproducible open science to validate advantage beyond asymptotic claims.

Computer Science Bulletin•Dec 31, 2025•0 citations

Quantum Machine Learning: A Review of Hybrid Classical-Quantum Approaches

Bhavesh B. Prajapati, Riddhi B. Prajapati

An interesting approach to using noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices is hybrid classical-quantum machine learning (QML). In these methods, classical processors handle optimisation and large-scale computation, while quantum hardware is devoted to tasks like feature mapping, nonlinear transformations, or kernel evaluation. Practical near-term demonstrations are made possible by this division of labour, which also mitigates existing hardware restrictions. In specialised fields like molecular modelling, materials discovery, and small-sample learning issues, recent advancements in variational quantum circuits, hybrid neural networks, and quantum kernel techniques have produced promising outcomes. However, scalability and wider applicability are still hampered by enduring issues including noise, barren plateaus, and the expense of repeated measurements. Long-term developments will require fault tolerance, logical qubits, and established software infrastructures, whereas near-term success depends on noise-aware algorithm design, repeatable experimental benchmarks, and enhanced error-mitigation strategies. When taken as a whole, these advancements show a viable path to achieving quantum advantage in machine learning. Quanta 2026; 15: 1–12.

Quanta•Jan 30, 2026•8 citations

Supervised Quantum Machine Learning: A Future Outlook from Qubits to Enterprise Applications

Srikanth Thudumu, Jason Fisher, Hung Du

Supervised quantum machine learning (QML) applies quantum resources to classical tasks such as classification and regression. We examine methods feasible on current Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) hardware, including variational (parameterized) quantum circuits (VQCs/PQCs), quantum kernel methods, data encodings, and hybrid quantumclassical workflows, and we summarize recent experiments in quantum-native and low-data regimes. We clarify theory on generalization and trainability and identify practical blockers: noise and depth limits, encoding overheads, missing standardized benchmarks, and unsettled conditions for advantage. Our main contribution is a ten-year outlook from 2025 to 2035 that maps hardware progress, error mitigation, benchmarking, quantum data generation, federated learning & privacy, and AutoQML to potential enterprise use cases. The roadmap draws on a qualitative synthesis of publication trends, milestone experiments, prior surveys, and practitioner insights. Near-term gains are most likely in niche applications and hybrid deployments; broader adoption depends on scalable error-corrected hardware, shared benchmarks, interdisciplinary training, and calibrated expectations.

arXiv:2505.24765•IEEE International Conference on Quantum Artificial Intelligence (QAI)•Nov 2, 2025•6 citations
Abstract Quantum machine learning (QML) has attracted growing interest because quantum states and circuits may provide new representational primitives for learning, yet progress remains constrained by noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) hardware and heterogeneous evaluation practices. This article presents a critical review of recent QML architectures and representative empirical and theoretical studies, with emphasis on work published since 2022 alongside selected seminal references. To improve comparability, “quantum advantage” is assessed in three distinct senses: computational scaling under stated input-access assumptions, empirical predictive performance in the benchmark setting considered, and resource efficiency at a fixed budget accounting for both classical compute and quantum execution, including shot costs. Organized by architecture family and application domain, the review analyzes how baseline strength, hyperparameter optimization, preprocessing, and budget reporting shape conclusions. Overall, quantum feature maps and kernels, as well as variational (often hybrid) pipelines, can be competitive on selected small- to medium-scale benchmarks, but robust end-to-end evidence for a general practical advantage remains limited. Reported gains are often sensitive to budget matching and may be dominated by measurement overheads, dataset and preprocessing effects, and training instabilities. The review concludes that credible progress requires standardized benchmarking, transparent end-to-end resource accounting, and hardware-centered evaluations that test scalability and robustness beyond toy regimes.
Quantum computing has generated significant expectations for its potential to enhance machine learning (ML) tasks, with theoretical research proposing computational advantages ranging from polynomial to exponential speedups for specific subroutines.However, a critical disconnect remains: theoretical or asymptotic speedup claims do not automatically imply a practical, end-to-end advantage.Current evidence does not clearly establish whether these claimed advantages translate into measurable superiority over optimised classical approaches.This review critically assesses the relationship between theoretical claims of quantum advantage and the currently available practical and experimental evidence.We critically examine the evidence and assumptions underlying claimed speedups, including the overheads associated with data encoding and access, as well as the use of appropriate and competitive classical baselines for fair comparison.The scope of this assessment covers key limiting factors, such as scalability, trainability, hardware noise in the noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) era, and overall resource requirements.By distinguishing between theoretical potential and demonstrated practical performance, this work identifies where current evidence is convincing and where it remains insufficient.The review identifies the specific conditions required for the credible validation of quantum advantage and argues that future progress must be positioned around rigorous, realistic, and end-to-end evaluation rather than theoretical complexity claims alone.
Quantum Machine Learning (QML) integrates the principles of quantum mechanics superposition, entanglement, and interference into mathematical and logical operations that classical computers cannot emulate. Despite the limitations of today’s noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ-ERA) devices, these platforms already sustain small- to medium-scale machine-learning workloads, catalyzing rapid expansion in QML research. Guided by PRISMA methodology, we systematically screened 5,463 publications published between January 2015 and June 2025 and identified 160 high-quality studies that implemented or evaluated QML algorithms on real or simulated quantum processors. The selected literature converges into four thematic categories: (i) quantum adaptations of classical algorithms, (ii) variational and hybrid quantum–classical models, (iii) quantum linear-algebra accelerators, and (iv) quantum-inspired generative and reinforcement techniques. Application domains span image and signal classification, cybersecurity, finance, chemistry, and healthcare, with benchmarks such as MNIST, CIC-IDS2019 and credit-risk corpora featuring prominently in the reviewed corpus. Separately from the reviewed literature, Sect. 6 reports our own five-seed benchmark of five quantum and two classical classifiers on five public tabular datasets (Breast Cancer, Diabetes, Iris, Sonar and Bank Marketing). Comparative analyses reveal that hybrid QML systems typically match or marginally exceed the performance of state-of-the-art classical baselines while employing fewer parameters. Nevertheless, a clear, reproducible quantum advantage remains elusive, hindered by data-encoding overheads, circuit-depth constraints, environmental noise, and barren-plateau training phenomena. By integrating algorithmic trends, empirical outcomes, and hardware considerations, this review delineates QML’s present capabilities and identifies critical technological milestones error mitigation, scalable qubit architectures, and efficient data-loading schemes needed to unlock its full potential.
Quantum Machine Learning (QML) has become an important research area in recent years due to its potential to overcome the computational bottlenecks faced by classical machine learning methods. In this study, only SCI/SCI-Expanded journal articles published between 2023 and 2025 and accepted as early access for 2026 are considered, and 30 such articles are systematically examined to provide a comprehensive assessment of the current state of QML methods. The reviewed literature covers variational quantum circuits, quantum kernel methods, hybrid quantum–classical models, quantum annealing approaches, federated QML architectures, data encoding strategies, and adversarial robustness analyses. The findings indicate that QML models can exhibit stronger representational capacity and higher generalization performance compared to classical methods, particularly on high-dimensional, noisy, or small sample datasets. Reported results in domains such as healthcare, chemistry, energy systems, cybersecurity, blockchain, and finance reveal the diversity of QML applications and its interdisciplinary potential. Nevertheless, the limited qubit capacity of current NISQ hardware, constraints on circuit depth, and noise-related issues remain fundamental factors that restrict the scalability of QML models. This study synthesizes methodological trends, identifies open research problems, and proposes a directional roadmap for future QML research focused on hardware-aware circuit design, efficient data encoding schemes, and robust learning frameworks.
Quantum Machine Learning (QML) unites quantum computing with modern AI to achieve potential gains in expressivity, runtime, and sample efficiency. This paper synthesizes advances in quantum feature maps, variational quantum circuits (VQCs), and hybrid quantum-classical workflows deployable on noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) hardware. We outline design principles for data encoding, ansatz selection, and trainability, and summarize error-aware practices—error mitigation, shot-frugal estimation, and compiler co-design. Using synthetic but instructive experiments, we illustrate scaling behavior, noise sensitivity, end-to-end inference latency across backends, and optimizer convergence in variational training. We conclude with an agenda emphasizing domain-aligned encodings, rigorous benchmarking, and reproducible open science to validate advantage beyond asymptotic claims.
An interesting approach to using noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices is hybrid classical-quantum machine learning (QML). In these methods, classical processors handle optimisation and large-scale computation, while quantum hardware is devoted to tasks like feature mapping, nonlinear transformations, or kernel evaluation. Practical near-term demonstrations are made possible by this division of labour, which also mitigates existing hardware restrictions. In specialised fields like molecular modelling, materials discovery, and small-sample learning issues, recent advancements in variational quantum circuits, hybrid neural networks, and quantum kernel techniques have produced promising outcomes. However, scalability and wider applicability are still hampered by enduring issues including noise, barren plateaus, and the expense of repeated measurements. Long-term developments will require fault tolerance, logical qubits, and established software infrastructures, whereas near-term success depends on noise-aware algorithm design, repeatable experimental benchmarks, and enhanced error-mitigation strategies. When taken as a whole, these advancements show a viable path to achieving quantum advantage in machine learning. Quanta 2026; 15: 1–12.
Supervised quantum machine learning (QML) applies quantum resources to classical tasks such as classification and regression. We examine methods feasible on current Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) hardware, including variational (parameterized) quantum circuits (VQCs/PQCs), quantum kernel methods, data encodings, and hybrid quantumclassical workflows, and we summarize recent experiments in quantum-native and low-data regimes. We clarify theory on generalization and trainability and identify practical blockers: noise and depth limits, encoding overheads, missing standardized benchmarks, and unsettled conditions for advantage. Our main contribution is a ten-year outlook from 2025 to 2035 that maps hardware progress, error mitigation, benchmarking, quantum data generation, federated learning & privacy, and AutoQML to potential enterprise use cases. The roadmap draws on a qualitative synthesis of publication trends, milestone experiments, prior surveys, and practitioner insights. Near-term gains are most likely in niche applications and hybrid deployments; broader adoption depends on scalable error-corrected hardware, shared benchmarks, interdisciplinary training, and calibrated expectations.