A. Thomson's model considered the atom as a plum pudding, in which positive and negative charges were mixed together.Some students mixed up ideas coming from different models: 10% of them described Thomson's atom as a planetary model, and 3% of them stated that it had a nucleus with protons and neutrons.For example:A. It had a positive nucleus and electrons rotating around it.A. It had a positive nucleus made of protons and neutrons, and elliptical orbits on which electrons rotated.A. Definitely the conservation of energy.Probably also momentum, but I do not know why.On the other hand, 72% of students used both the conservation laws for explaining the Compton effect.It is interesting to note how, for many students, the photoelectric effect and the Compton effect are seen as two completely distinct phenomena: in the photoelectric effect the photon is in fact "absorbed" by the electron (43%), while in the Compton effect the electron is "bumped and pushed away" by the photon (49%).17% of students recalled the fact that, dealing with photons, the relativistic formulas must be used, while 21% of them highlighted that the photon must be considered as a small material body.A. The photons, colliding with the electrons, behave like small material bodies, and for this reason both momentum and energy are conserved in the collision. Moreover, several students (51%) referred to the quantization of energy:A. In the photoelectric effect and in the Compton effect, Planck's hypothesis and the conservation of momentum and energy are used.No students described the two effects as the same phenomenon, at different energy values.Teachers' answers 22% of teachers used both the conservations laws for the photoelectric effect, compared to 88% for the Compton effect, in line with the percentages related to textbooks.Only 9% of teachers focused on the difference in energy between the two phenomena:A. The principle of conservation of energy and momentum are requested in both (as in all elastic collisions).The only difference is the energy involved in the two phenomena.A. The energy involved in the Compton effect is higher than the one involved in the photoelectric effect.Only 4 people recalled the aspects related to the three-bodies problem:A. Considering both the conservation of energy and the conservation of momentum, it turns out, at some point, that the equations are incompatible unless the energy is zero (there would be no interaction!).And this is because we have three bodies and not two: namely, the photon, the electron, and the metal.In addition to this, 15% of teachers mentioned the quantisation of energy:A. For both the phenomena, the quantisation of energy introduced by Planck is required.
A. Thomson's model considered the atom as a plum pudding, in which positive and negative charges were mixed together.Some students mixed up ideas coming from different models: 10% of them described Thomson's atom as a planetary model, and 3% of them stated that it had a nucleus with protons and neutrons.For example:A. It had a positive nucleus and electrons rotating around it.A. It had a positive nucleus made of protons and neutrons, and elliptical orbits on which electrons rotated.A. Definitely the conservation of energy.Probably also momentum, but I do not know why.On the other hand, 72% of students used both the conservation laws for explaining the Compton effect.It is interesting to note how, for many students, the photoelectric effect and the Compton effect are seen as two completely distinct phenomena: in the photoelectric effect the photon is in fact "absorbed" by the electron (43%), while in the Compton effect the electron is "bumped and pushed away" by the photon (49%).17% of students recalled the fact that, dealing with photons, the relativistic formulas must be used, while 21% of them highlighted that the photon must be considered as a small material body.A. The photons, colliding with the electrons, behave like small material bodies, and for this reason both momentum and energy are conserved in the collision. Moreover, several students (51%) referred to the quantization of energy:A. In the photoelectric effect and in the Compton effect, Planck's hypothesis and the conservation of momentum and energy are used.No students described the two effects as the same phenomenon, at different energy values.Teachers' answers 22% of teachers used both the conservations laws for the photoelectric effect, compared to 88% for the Compton effect, in line with the percentages related to textbooks.Only 9% of teachers focused on the difference in energy between the two phenomena:A. The principle of conservation of energy and momentum are requested in both (as in all elastic collisions).The only difference is the energy involved in the two phenomena.A. The energy involved in the Compton effect is higher than the one involved in the photoelectric effect.Only 4 people recalled the aspects related to the three-bodies problem:A. Considering both the conservation of energy and the conservation of momentum, it turns out, at some point, that the equations are incompatible unless the energy is zero (there would be no interaction!).And this is because we have three bodies and not two: namely, the photon, the electron, and the metal.In addition to this, 15% of teachers mentioned the quantisation of energy:A. For both the phenomena, the quantisation of energy introduced by Planck is required.
Although the calculation of the Compton effect on the basis of the theory of light quantum is well known through text books in modern physics, it is not so well known that Compton attempted to explain the result of X-ray scattering by means of the effect of interference, but confronted with a serious difficulty, and thus turned to the theory of light quantum. About the time of the discovery of the Compton effect, Schrödinger derived, by making use of the conservation law of energy and momentum, from the standpoint of the theory of light quantum, the formula for the Doppler effect, and Duane, by applying the quantum condition and also from the viewpoint of the theory of light quantum, the Bragg formula for X-ray scattering. It is interesting to see the process by which they came to apply the theory of light theory to wave phenomena. It should be noted especially that de Broglie's wave theory actually resulted from the theory of light quantum. As we shall see in the text, de Broglie's attempt to understand the particle-nature of light quantum by means of the rest mass of light quantum brought forth, rather, the concept of the wave-nature of material particles. Bohr, who was in doubt about the theory of light quantum, proposed in collaboration with Kramers and Slater the law of statistical conservation of energy and momentum and treated the dispersion of light as a typical wave phenomenon. They proposed the law of statistical conservation of energy and momentum and treated the dispersion of light as a typical wave phenomenon. Their proposal of the law of statistical conservation of energy and momentum was, however, negated immediately by Compton and Simon's experiment with the use of a Wilson chamber. It is scarcely told, so far, in textbooks on the history of science that Kramers and Heisenberg, in generalizing Kramers' wave-theoretical formula for the dispersion of light to include the case of incoherent scattering of light, took account of Smekal's study of the scattering of light on the basis of the theory of light quantum.
The idea of the photon has stirred the imaginations of physicists ever since 1905 when Einstein originally proposed the use of light quanta to explain the photoelectric effect. This concept is formalized in the quantum theory of radiation, which has had unfailing success in explaining the interaction of electromagnetic radiation with matter, seemingly limited only by the ability of physicists to perform the indicated calculations. Nevertheless, it has its conceptual problems—various infinities and frequent misinterpretations. Consequently an increasing number of workers are asking, “to what extent is the quantized field really necessary and useful?” In fact the experimental results of the photoelectric effect were explained by G. Wentzel in 1927 without the quantum theory of radiation. Similarly most electro-optic phenomena such as stimulated emission, reaction of the emitted field on the emitting atom, resonance fluorescence, and so on, do not require the quantization of the field for their explanation. As we will see, these processes can all be quantitatively explained and physically understood in terms of the semiclassical theory of the matter–field interaction in which the electric field is treated classically while the atoms obey the laws of quantum mechanics. The quantized field is fundamentally required for accurate descriptions of certain processes involving fluctuations in the electromagnetic field: for example, spontaneous emission, the Lamb shift, the anomalous magnetic moment of the electron, and certain aspects of blackbody radiation. (The Compton effect also fits here, but see later under references 8b and c.) Here we will outline how the photon concept originated and developed, where it is not required and is often misused, and finally where it plays an essential role in the understanding of physical phenomena. In our discussion we will attempt to give a logically consistent definition of the word “photon”—a statement far more necessary than one might think, for so many contradictory uses exist of this elusive beast. In particular consider the original coining of the word by G. N. Lewis: “[because it appears to spend] only a minute fraction of its existence as a carrier of radiant energy, while the rest of the time it remains an important structural element within the atom…, I therefore take the liberty of proposing for this hypothetical new atom which is not light but plays an essential part in every process of radiation, the name photon!” (our exclamation point). Clearly the present usage of the word is very different.
The first quarter of the twentieth century saw two great scientific revolutions: firstly relativity, which deeply changed our view of space and time, and secondly quantum mechanics, which deeply changed the way we think about states of matter and energy. Quantum mechanics provided a deep understanding of a wide variety of phenomena, from the most fundamental properties of elementary particles to many aspects of chemistry. Quantum theory opened the door to the micro-cosmos, thereby explaining many of the properties of vastly different types of materials such as insulators, metals, semiconductors and superconductors. Modern physics is still deeply involved in further exploiting the ever-surprising worlds of quantum solids, liquids and gases. The quantum revolution implied a radical shake-up of the foundations of theoretical physics. It was caused among others by the inadequacy of the classical theories of Newton and Maxwell to account for the observed structure of atoms. The atom supposedly consisted of a positively charged nucleus surrounded by a number of negatively charged electrons, exactly compensating the nuclear charge. The problem that arose may be explained as follows. Newton told us that in the proposed configuration the electrons would ‘circle’ very rapidly around the nucleus (like a tiny planetary system), and therefore these electrons would continuously be strongly accelerated. Maxwell, however, told us that an accelerated charge would start radiating and thereby losing energy at an appreciable rate, so that in the end the electrons would fall into the nucleus. A little calculation showed that the lifetime of the atom would be something like a billionth of a second. According to our theoretical knowledge, therefore, atoms would just not exist, bluntly contradicting the observations. Quantum theory came to the rescue. Looking back, one of the outstanding achievements of quantum theory is that it explained the structure but also the stability of atoms and molecules, and therefore of all matter. In quantum theory the atomic bound states of the electrons with the nucleus form a discrete set – the allowed states are quantized, with a stable lowest energy state. The theory is based on a number of postulates which are of great generality, providing a framework that should in principle be applicable to any physical system. To put it briefly: our world is quantum-mechanical.
When a theory is framed trying to explain a discrepant system of facts, it is a necessary process of thought to take some branch of the theory as more completely true than the rest, and to adjust the remaining parts in such a way that they will fit in with this base, though they may still conflict with one another. This has certainly been true of the quantum theory; the speculations connected with it have as their base the law of the conservation of energy. Now a critical examination of fundamentals does not by any means justify this faith. It is of course a fact of observation that in the gross energy is conserved, but this only means an averaged energy; and as pure dynamics has failed to explain many atomic phenomena there seems no reason to maintain the exact conservation of energy, which is only one of the consequences of the dynamical equations. Indeed it is hardly too much to say that had the photoelectric effect been discovered a century ago, it is probable that no one would ever have suggested that the status of the first law of thermodynamics was in any way different from that of the second. On the other hand, Bohr's theory, and especially Sommerfeld's extension of it, have given great encouragement to the belief that in dynamics lay the way to the complete truth, so that in consequence of the triumphs of that theory there has been little thought in other directions. Another impediment is that our whole ideas are saturated with the principles of energy, so that denying it leaves hardly any foundation from which to start.
We tried to introduce the idea of quantization in Chapter 9 as a completion of a one semester course. However, we skipped over some really interesting events in the history of Science between 1900 and 1913 when Bohr derived the quantized energy of the H atom. First we want to carry out the 1901 Planck derivation of the formula for blackbody radiation [1]. Many texts just show the curve, write e¼ hn, and move on. As a student, this author found that limited explanation very frustrating since energy quantization is a fundamental concept. Even among graduate texts in quantum mechanics, we are aware of only one that does the complete treatment which we will draw upon for the mathematics [2] but supplement with a narrative that we have found helpful to students over the years. Then in 1905, Albert Einstein (1879-1955), one of the most influential scientists of all time, gave an explanation of the photoelectric effect [3] for which he received the Nobel Prize in 1921. Even reducing our list to essential topics, we need to discuss the Davisson-Germer experiment [4]. The photoelectric effect introduces the idea that light waves can act as particles while the Davisson-Germer experiment showed that particles can act like waves and confirmed the De Broglie equation [5]. However, you can be assured that it will not be as difficult as you might have anticipated and if you can absorb the meaning of just these three key experiments you should be able to begin thinking in terms of quantum mechanics! Despite our slow historical development, this is 2010 and we have to get to the twenty-first century somehow!
The Compton scattering is an elastic collision of the x-ray or gamma photons with free electrons (or loosely bound valence shell electrons). This scattering is demonstrated in Fig. 1. In this communication we are combining Heisenberg's uncertainty principle and the Compton scattering. Note, that some of the expressions (including their derivations) of this communication can be found in modern physics textbooks. Figure 1. Schematic representation of Compton scattering, in which an incoming photon scatters from an electron at rest. The electron of the rest mass m e has the rest energy of E r = m e c 2. The Compton scattered electron (hereinafter the Compton electron) posses a relativistic kinetic energy, the relativistic speed υ e and the linear momentum p e = m e υ e. Before scattering, let the photon moves along the positive x-axis having an energy E 0 = hν 0 , frequency ν 0 , wavelength λ 0 and linear momentum p 0 = hν 0 /c, where h (= 6.63 × 10-34 J s) is the Planck constant and c (= 2.99792×10 8 m s-1) is the speed of light. After scattering, the photon moves at an angle θ off the x-axis with an energy E = hν, frequency ν, wavelength λ and momentum p = hν/c. The conservation of linear momentum of the electron after the collision yields, p e 2 = p 0 2 + p 2-2p 0 pcosθ.