Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Competing Informational and Dynamical Criteria for Subsystem Structure: Relational Emergence Model — Revised Version 5

Yoshifumi Maruko

Published Apr 18, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

REM_lambda Version 4 Version 4 presents a corrected numerical implementation of the variational selection framework used in the Relational Emergence Model (REM). The model evaluates candidate Hilbert-space factorisations through competition between informational differentiation and dynamical boundary cost. $$\Phi(F)=\Phi_S(F)-\lambda C_H(F)$$ The informational term is $$\Phi_S(F)=I(A:B)$$ and the sign-definite quadratic dynamical cost is $$C_H(F)=\mathrm{Tr}(\rho H_{\partial F}^{2})=\langle H_{\partial F}^{2}\rangle$$ Numerical correction in Version 4 Version 4 corrects two implementation issues in the numerical analysis accompanying REM_lambda Version 3. The discrete-cut implementation previously calculated $$ \langle H_{\partial F}\rangle^{2} $$ instead of the intended quadratic boundary-fluctuation cost $$ \langle H_{\partial F}^{2}\rangle $$ The previous continuous-factorisation routine transformed the state and the full Hamiltonian together, making the dynamical cost invariant under the candidate unitary transformation. Consequently, the Version 3 optimiser effectively maximised mutual information rather than the complete REM functional. Version 4 corrects both issues and recomputes all affected numerical results. Three-qubit XY-chain benchmark The numerical benchmark uses the asymmetric three-qubit XY-chain Hamiltonian $$H=J_{12}(X_1X_2+Y_1Y_2)+J_{23}(X_2X_3+Y_2Y_3)+h\sum_i Z_i$$ The parameters are $$J_{12}=1.5,\qquad J_{23}=0.6,\qquad h=0.2$$ The ground state is obtained through exact diagonalisation. For the two site-contiguous candidate partitions, the corrected dynamical cost is evaluated as $$C_H=\langle H_{\partial F}^{2}\rangle$$ At $$\lambda=0.2$$ the best site-contiguous partition achieves $$\Phi=0.560$$ The crossover between the information-dominated and dynamics-dominated contiguous partitions remains $$\lambda^*\approx0.165$$ Continuous factorisation optimisation For each candidate unitary $U$, the rotated Hamiltonian is $$H_U=UHU^\dagger$$ It is decomposed into local and interaction components: $$H_U=H_A(U)+H_B(U)+H_{\partial}(U)$$ The local components are obtained through partial-trace projection with an identity-component correction. The continuous optimisation evaluates the complete REM functional: $$\Phi(U)=I(A:B)_{U\psi}-\lambda\langle\psi_U|H_{\partial}(U)^2|\psi_U\rangle$$ A search over a four-parameter generator submanifold recovers $$\Phi=1.05$$ This exceeds the best site-contiguous result: $$\Phi=0.560$$ The corrected numerical improvement is therefore $$0.560\rightarrow1.05$$ The previously reported Version 3 result $$0.68\rightarrow1.32$$ is withdrawn because it was obtained using an incorrect objective function. Factorisation-space dimension The full factorisation space is represented by $$U(8)/(U(4)\otimes U(2))$$ The tensor-product representation of $U(4)\times U(2)$ has a one-dimensional kernel. The effective local-unitary subgroup therefore has dimension $$16+4-1=19$$ Since $$\dim U(8)=64$$ the quotient manifold has real dimension $$64-19=45$$ The present numerical implementation explores a four-parameter generator submanifold of this 45-dimensional quotient manifold. The recovered factorisation is a higher-scoring solution within the explored submanifold. It is not claimed to be the global optimum over the full factorisation manifold. Finite-size scaling Finite-size calculations were performed for $$N=3,4,6,8$$ under weak-center, linear, and step coupling profiles. All finite-size values were recomputed using the corrected quadratic dynamical cost $$C_H=\langle H_{\partial F}^{2}\rangle$$ Validation and reproducibility The accompanying reproducibility package includes: exact diagonalisation for asymmetric XY chains; evaluation of site-contiguous candidate cuts; factorisation-dependent reconstruction of the interaction Hamiltonian; continuous optimisation on a four-parameter generator submanifold; finite-size scaling calculations; deterministic benchmark values; 16 automated tests; GitHub Actions continuous integration for Python 3.12 and 3.13. The regression tests verify: exact agreement with $\langle H_{\partial F}^{2}\rangle$; the distinction between $\langle H_{\partial F}^{2}\rangle$ and $\langle H_{\partial F}\rangle^{2}$; factorisation dependence of the reconstructed boundary cost; consistency at the identity transformation; reproduction of corrected benchmark values; successful finite-size and output-generation workflows. Scope Version 4 supersedes the numerical results reported in Version 3. The theoretical REM functional and the use of the sign-definite quadratic boundary-fluctuation cost remain unchanged. Source and reproducibility GitHub repository: https://github.com/malko73/rem Version 4 DOI: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21427776

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.19641343

Related papers

The Relational Emergence Model: Generative Differentiation via Variational Selection on Factorization Manifold

Yoshifumi Maruko

The Relational Emergence Model (REM) is a generative framework for the articulation of relational structure in quantum theory. While Relational Quantum Mechanics (RQM) defines physical states relative to other systems, it does not specify how subsystem structure itself becomes determined. REM addresses this gap by modeling subsystem differentiation as a variational selection process over candidate tensor-product factorizations of Hilbert space. The model introduces a three-layer architecture: Layer 0 — a pre-relational Hilbert space without a privileged tensor-product structureLayer 1 — differentiation as relational articulationLayer 2 — decoherence as stabilization of articulated structure Differentiation is formulated as an optimization problem on a factorization manifold, F ≅ U(N)/(U(n_A) ⊗ U(n_B)), with selection governed by a variational functional Φ = Φ_S + λ Φ_H, combining informational articulation (mutual information) and dynamical stability (boundary Hamiltonian contribution). The parameter λ controls the balance between informational correlation and dynamical coherence, admitting interpretations analogous to inverse temperature, timescale ratio, or renormalization-scale dependence. A three-qubit toy model demonstrates nontrivial factorization selection and a crossover between informationally favored and dynamically stabilized regimes. The framework connects relational quantum mechanics, decoherence theory, information geometry, subsystem structure in gauge theory, and variational optimization on quotient manifolds. The present work is not proposed as a complete physical theory but as a mathematically structured foundational proposal for studying how relational structure itself may become selected, stabilized, and rendered physically meaningful. The REM framework aims to clarify the generative layer underlying relational description and provides a basis for further development including continuous factorization flow, tensor-network formulations, categorical structure, and operational implementations.

•Mar 22, 2026•0 citations

Selection Principles for the Differentiation Map in the Relational Emergence Model

Yoshifumi Maruko

The Relational Emergence Model (REM) extends Relational Quantum Mechanics (RQM) by treating relational structure as *generated* rather than assumed. This companion paper addresses the central open question left in the main REM framework: what selects the differentiation map 𝒟 that articulates a specific tensor-product decomposition out of the pre-relational Hilbert space (Layer 0 → Layer 1). We introduce a variational formulation over candidate factorizations ℱ, with functionals based on von Neumann entropy maximization (Φ_S), mutual-information maximization (Φ_I), and energetic stability (Φ_H). A combined functional Φ = Φ_S + λ Φ_H allows continuous interpolation between purely informational and dynamically stabilized regimes. A concrete 3-qubit numerical example (with entropy landscape visualization) demonstrates that informational extremization induces nontrivial bipartition selection. The framework is further embedded in three mathematical structures: information geometry on factorization space, categorical quantum mechanics (Frobenius algebra selection), and gauge-theoretic subsystem construction (boundary degrees of freedom analogy). Connections to recent integrated-information approaches in relational quantum dynamics (Zaghi 2025) are discussed as natural extensions. This work complements the main REM paper by supplying the missing selection mechanism, transforming REM from a conceptual proposal into a mathematically structured generative model of relational quantum reality. Related publication: "Relational Emergence Model: A Generative Extension of Relational Quantum Mechanics" (Maruko 2026, Zenodo DOI: [https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19123314]) This is the companion paper providing the selection mechanism for the differentiation map 𝒟 introduced in the main REM framework.

•Mar 22, 2026•0 citations

Relational Emergence Model: A Generative Extension of Relational Quantum Mechanics

Yoshifumi Maruko

Relational Quantum Mechanics (RQM) proposes that physical states exist only relative to other systems, but does not explain how such relational structures arise. This paper introduces the Relational Emergence Model (REM), which addresses this foundational gap by modeling the generation of relational structure as an explicit physical process. The central contribution is the differentiation map 𝒟 — not a unitary operator, but a structural bipartition-selecting map that produces explicit system–observer correlations from a pre-relational Hilbert space (Layer 0). Environmental decoherence 𝓔 then acts as a CPTP map on the articulated structure, stabilizing effectively classical facts (Layer 2). This three-layer architecture (pre-relational potential → relational articulation → phenomenal stabilization) provides a mathematically structured account of how relational reality becomes determinate. REM is compared with RQM, QBism, and Many-Worlds interpretations. Unlike these approaches, REM does not presuppose that relational structures are already formed — it models the generative phase that precedes perspectival consistency. The framework also provides a natural analysis of Wigner's Friend scenarios as multi-level differentiation processes. A structural correspondence (not equivalence) with Buddhist concepts of dependent origination (pratītyasamutpāda) and emptiness (śūnyatā) is identified: Layer 0 corresponds to the absence of intrinsic nature prior to differentiation; Layer 1 corresponds to the arising of relational structure through differentiation events. --- This is Paper 1 of the 6-paper Relational Emergence Model (REM) series: - REM1 (this paper) — Foundational framework: three-layer architecture and differentiation map- REM2 — Selection principles for the differentiation map (variational formulation) https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19155166- REM3 — Generative differentiation via variational selection on factorization manifold https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19157709- REM4 — Competing informational and dynamical criteria for subsystem structure https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19637584- REM5 — Variational selection of tensor-product structure in quantum systems https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19637651- REM_lambda — Variational generation of relational structure (physical interpretation of λ) https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19641344

•Mar 20, 2026•0 citations

Paper 39 The Schrödinger Equation as Expansion-Dominated Relational Evolution

Barry Kieran Radcliffe

In this work, we present a relational reinterpretation of the Schrödinger equation in which quantum evolution is understood as arising from the balance between competing tendencies toward propagation and localization. Within this framework, the Hamiltonian is re-expressed as an effective generator of relational tension, and quantum measurement is interpreted as a transition into a localization-dominated regime rather than a fundamental collapse. To test this interpretation, we analyze publicly available experimental data from monitored quantum circuits exhibiting measurement-induced transitions (Feng et al., Communications Physics, 2026). Using the merged dataset (k4-z-data-merged.npy), we examine the structure of variability in the experimentally defined order parameter across measurement strength and circuit depth. The analysis shows that variability is not adequately described by a single control parameter. Instead, it exhibits clear multi-variable structure, with significant dependence on circuit depth. Furthermore, incorporating prior-state information—specifically, the observable value at the previous depth—improves predictive accuracy, demonstrating that the system exhibits measurable path dependence. At the same time, a structured residual component remains, indicating that the system is only partially predictable within the available variable set. These findings show that quantum variability in this system is not featureless or purely stochastic, but instead reflects organized, multi-variable, and history-dependent structure. This result does not alter the formal predictions of quantum mechanics. Rather, it provides a data-supported interpretation in which quantum uncertainty is understood as the projection of deeper relational dynamics into a reduced descriptive framework. The presence of path dependence and partial predictability suggests that variability arises from partially resolved structure rather than irreducible randomness.

•Apr 7, 2026•0 citations

Isolation of Topological Degrees of Freedom under Coarse-Graining

Deivison Ramos do Rosario

This work presents an exact finite-dimensional construction for the compatibility between microscopic duality and coarse-graining in a two-dimensional Z2 lattice gauge model on a finite square torus. Using cellular homology and cohomology, gauge-invariant Hilbert spaces, and a tree-cotree decomposition, the study isolates a four-dimensional topological Hilbert sector from local degrees of freedom. The construction distinguishes the physical gauge quotient from its dual cycle-space representation and establishes their relationship through a finite-group Fourier transform. Two coarse-graining isometries are defined independently of the microscopic duality. Their compatibility is established through an exact intertwining relation, yielding a unitary effective transformation on the retained topological sector. The mathematical construction is supported by a reproducible Python verification program, with exact algebraic checks and finite-dimensional tests for lattice sizes L = 2 through L = 6. Version 6 incorporates corrections to the explicit 2×2 lattice benchmark, strengthens the treatment of primal-dual identifications, and clarifies the scope and limitations of the results. The work provides a controlled mathematical benchmark for investigating the preservation of topological degrees of freedom under coarse-graining. It does not claim a universal renormalization-group construction or establish dynamical equivalence for arbitrary lattice gauge theories. Related research: Work 2: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23428851 Work 3: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23480354 Author: Deivison Ramos do Rosario Version: 6 License: Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0).

•Sep 6, 2026•0 citations

Relational Information Dynamics, Paper 4: Deriving the Coupling Amplitude a_n from the Vacuum Variance of the Modular Hamiltonian

Ricardo Fernández

Paper 1 of the RID series derives g† = 2cH_{0,dS}/π² as a conjectural effective relation and explicitly flags one heuristic step: the coupling amplitude a_n ∝ τ_n is asserted rather than derived. This paper derives a_n via two independent routes. Route 1 (primary): a_n ≡ √⟨0|x_n²|0⟩ = 1/(2nH) follows in two exact lines from the modular Hamiltonian K and canonical commutation relations. Route 2 (corroborating): the exact KMS two-point function G(τ) = −(1/2H) ln(1 − e^{−H|τ|}) expands as Σ_n a_n e^{−nH|τ|} with a_n = 1/(2nH), independently confirming the same coefficients from the Green's function alone. Three open items are stated explicitly: (i) the overhead functional form (a_n/τ_n)² is FDT-motivated but the γ = 1 normalisation remains open (Paper 5); (ii) τ_n = π/(2nH) is now derived as the first zero of the KMS two-point function G_n(s), with E = ω_n following from the correlator frequency rather than assumed; the residual open item is the identification of the first zero as the synchronisation timescale (Paper 5); (iii) the critical exponent ν = 1/2: its slope face is now derived and directly measured (deep-MOND log–log slope 0.54; deep- and transition-restricted fits 0.485/0.504; §8.7); a Bayesian Υ*-marginalisation (2026-07) gives ν = 0.452 [0.444, 0.458] at that stage; completing the hierarchy with per-galaxy distance and inclination priors (SPARC Table 1) gives ν = 0.503 [0.495, 0.509] (0.489–0.520 across prior widths): the exact-1/2 form is fully consistent, the Υ-only softness is a nuisance-omission artifact, and the residual caveat moves to the scale — the all-nuisance global g† is ridge/prior-dominated, so the joint fit constrains shape while the absolute-scale comparison is a nominal-calibration statement (§8.7). The paper closes the a_n heuristic and upgrades two of the three open items from assumed/conjectural to derived or physically grounded.

•Sep 23, 2026•0 citations
REM_lambda Version 4 Version 4 presents a corrected numerical implementation of the variational selection framework used in the Relational Emergence Model (REM). The model evaluates candidate Hilbert-space factorisations through competition between informational differentiation and dynamical boundary cost. Φ(F)=ΦS(F)−λCH(F)\Phi(F)=\Phi_S(F)-\lambda C_H(F)Φ(F)=ΦS​(F)−λCH​(F) The informational term is ΦS(F)=I(A:B)\Phi_S(F)=I(A:B)ΦS​(F)=I(A:B) and the sign-definite quadratic dynamical cost is CH(F)=Tr(ρH∂F2)=⟨H∂F2⟩C_H(F)=\mathrm{Tr}(\rho H_{\partial F}^{2})=\langle H_{\partial F}^{2}\rangleCH​(F)=Tr(ρH∂F2​)=⟨H∂F2​⟩ Numerical correction in Version 4 Version 4 corrects two implementation issues in the numerical analysis accompanying REM_lambda Version 3. The discrete-cut implementation previously calculated ⟨H∂F⟩2\langle H_{\partial F}\rangle^{2}⟨H∂F​⟩2 instead of the intended quadratic boundary-fluctuation cost ⟨H∂F2⟩\langle H_{\partial F}^{2}\rangle⟨H∂F2​⟩ The previous continuous-factorisation routine transformed the state and the full Hamiltonian together, making the dynamical cost invariant under the candidate unitary transformation. Consequently, the Version 3 optimiser effectively maximised mutual information rather than the complete REM functional. Version 4 corrects both issues and recomputes all affected numerical results. Three-qubit XY-chain benchmark The numerical benchmark uses the asymmetric three-qubit XY-chain Hamiltonian H=J12(X1X2+Y1Y2)+J23(X2X3+Y2Y3)+h∑iZiH=J_{12}(X_1X_2+Y_1Y_2)+J_{23}(X_2X_3+Y_2Y_3)+h\sum_i Z_iH=J12​(X1​X2​+Y1​Y2​)+J23​(X2​X3​+Y2​Y3​)+h∑i​Zi​ The parameters are J12=1.5,J23=0.6,h=0.2J_{12}=1.5,\qquad J_{23}=0.6,\qquad h=0.2J12​=1.5,J23​=0.6,h=0.2 The ground state is obtained through exact diagonalisation. For the two site-contiguous candidate partitions, the corrected dynamical cost is evaluated as CH=⟨H∂F2⟩C_H=\langle H_{\partial F}^{2}\rangleCH​=⟨H∂F2​⟩ At λ=0.2\lambda=0.2λ=0.2 the best site-contiguous partition achieves Φ=0.560\Phi=0.560Φ=0.560 The crossover between the information-dominated and dynamics-dominated contiguous partitions remains λ∗≈0.165\lambda^*\approx0.165λ∗≈0.165 Continuous factorisation optimisation For each candidate unitary UUU, the rotated Hamiltonian is HU=UHU†H_U=UHU^\daggerHU​=UHU† It is decomposed into local and interaction components: HU=HA(U)+HB(U)+H∂(U)H_U=H_A(U)+H_B(U)+H_{\partial}(U)HU​=HA​(U)+HB​(U)+H∂​(U) The local components are obtained through partial-trace projection with an identity-component correction. The continuous optimisation evaluates the complete REM functional: Φ(U)=I(A:B)Uψ−λ⟨ψU∣H∂(U)2∣ψU⟩\Phi(U)=I(A:B)_{U\psi}-\lambda\langle\psi_U|H_{\partial}(U)^2|\psi_U\rangleΦ(U)=I(A:B)Uψ​−λ⟨ψU​∣H∂​(U)2∣ψU​⟩ A search over a four-parameter generator submanifold recovers Φ=1.05\Phi=1.05Φ=1.05 This exceeds the best site-contiguous result: Φ=0.560\Phi=0.560Φ=0.560 The corrected numerical improvement is therefore 0.560→1.050.560\rightarrow1.050.560→1.05 The previously reported Version 3 result 0.68→1.320.68\rightarrow1.320.68→1.32 is withdrawn because it was obtained using an incorrect objective function. Factorisation-space dimension The full factorisation space is represented by U(8)/(U(4)⊗U(2))U(8)/(U(4)\otimes U(2))U(8)/(U(4)⊗U(2)) The tensor-product representation of U(4)×U(2)U(4)\times U(2)U(4)×U(2) has a one-dimensional kernel. The effective local-unitary subgroup therefore has dimension 16+4−1=1916+4-1=1916+4−1=19 Since dim⁡U(8)=64\dim U(8)=64dimU(8)=64 the quotient manifold has real dimension 64−19=4564-19=4564−19=45 The present numerical implementation explores a four-parameter generator submanifold of this 45-dimensional quotient manifold. The recovered factorisation is a higher-scoring solution within the explored submanifold. It is not claimed to be the global optimum over the full factorisation manifold. Finite-size scaling Finite-size calculations were performed for N=3,4,6,8N=3,4,6,8N=3,4,6,8 under weak-center, linear, and step coupling profiles. All finite-size values were recomputed using the corrected quadratic dynamical cost CH=⟨H∂F2⟩C_H=\langle H_{\partial F}^{2}\rangleCH​=⟨H∂F2​⟩ Validation and reproducibility The accompanying reproducibility package includes: exact diagonalisation for asymmetric XY chains; evaluation of site-contiguous candidate cuts; factorisation-dependent reconstruction of the interaction Hamiltonian; continuous optimisation on a four-parameter generator submanifold; finite-size scaling calculations; deterministic benchmark values; 16 automated tests; GitHub Actions continuous integration for Python 3.12 and 3.13. The regression tests verify: exact agreement with ⟨H∂F2⟩\langle H_{\partial F}^{2}\rangle⟨H∂F2​⟩; the distinction between ⟨H∂F2⟩\langle H_{\partial F}^{2}\rangle⟨H∂F2​⟩ and ⟨H∂F⟩2\langle H_{\partial F}\rangle^{2}⟨H∂F​⟩2; factorisation dependence of the reconstructed boundary cost; consistency at the identity transformation; reproduction of corrected benchmark values; successful finite-size and output-generation workflows. Scope Version 4 supersedes the numerical results reported in Version 3. The theoretical REM functional and the use of the sign-definite quadratic boundary-fluctuation cost remain unchanged. Source and reproducibility GitHub repository: https://github.com/malko73/rem Version 4 DOI: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21427776
The Relational Emergence Model (REM) is a generative framework for the articulation of relational structure in quantum theory. While Relational Quantum Mechanics (RQM) defines physical states relative to other systems, it does not specify how subsystem structure itself becomes determined. REM addresses this gap by modeling subsystem differentiation as a variational selection process over candidate tensor-product factorizations of Hilbert space. The model introduces a three-layer architecture: Layer 0 — a pre-relational Hilbert space without a privileged tensor-product structureLayer 1 — differentiation as relational articulationLayer 2 — decoherence as stabilization of articulated structure Differentiation is formulated as an optimization problem on a factorization manifold, F ≅ U(N)/(U(n_A) ⊗ U(n_B)), with selection governed by a variational functional Φ = Φ_S + λ Φ_H, combining informational articulation (mutual information) and dynamical stability (boundary Hamiltonian contribution). The parameter λ controls the balance between informational correlation and dynamical coherence, admitting interpretations analogous to inverse temperature, timescale ratio, or renormalization-scale dependence. A three-qubit toy model demonstrates nontrivial factorization selection and a crossover between informationally favored and dynamically stabilized regimes. The framework connects relational quantum mechanics, decoherence theory, information geometry, subsystem structure in gauge theory, and variational optimization on quotient manifolds. The present work is not proposed as a complete physical theory but as a mathematically structured foundational proposal for studying how relational structure itself may become selected, stabilized, and rendered physically meaningful. The REM framework aims to clarify the generative layer underlying relational description and provides a basis for further development including continuous factorization flow, tensor-network formulations, categorical structure, and operational implementations.
The Relational Emergence Model (REM) extends Relational Quantum Mechanics (RQM) by treating relational structure as *generated* rather than assumed. This companion paper addresses the central open question left in the main REM framework: what selects the differentiation map 𝒟 that articulates a specific tensor-product decomposition out of the pre-relational Hilbert space (Layer 0 → Layer 1). We introduce a variational formulation over candidate factorizations ℱ, with functionals based on von Neumann entropy maximization (Φ_S), mutual-information maximization (Φ_I), and energetic stability (Φ_H). A combined functional Φ = Φ_S + λ Φ_H allows continuous interpolation between purely informational and dynamically stabilized regimes. A concrete 3-qubit numerical example (with entropy landscape visualization) demonstrates that informational extremization induces nontrivial bipartition selection. The framework is further embedded in three mathematical structures: information geometry on factorization space, categorical quantum mechanics (Frobenius algebra selection), and gauge-theoretic subsystem construction (boundary degrees of freedom analogy). Connections to recent integrated-information approaches in relational quantum dynamics (Zaghi 2025) are discussed as natural extensions. This work complements the main REM paper by supplying the missing selection mechanism, transforming REM from a conceptual proposal into a mathematically structured generative model of relational quantum reality. Related publication: "Relational Emergence Model: A Generative Extension of Relational Quantum Mechanics" (Maruko 2026, Zenodo DOI: [https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19123314]) This is the companion paper providing the selection mechanism for the differentiation map 𝒟 introduced in the main REM framework.
Relational Quantum Mechanics (RQM) proposes that physical states exist only relative to other systems, but does not explain how such relational structures arise. This paper introduces the Relational Emergence Model (REM), which addresses this foundational gap by modeling the generation of relational structure as an explicit physical process. The central contribution is the differentiation map 𝒟 — not a unitary operator, but a structural bipartition-selecting map that produces explicit system–observer correlations from a pre-relational Hilbert space (Layer 0). Environmental decoherence 𝓔 then acts as a CPTP map on the articulated structure, stabilizing effectively classical facts (Layer 2). This three-layer architecture (pre-relational potential → relational articulation → phenomenal stabilization) provides a mathematically structured account of how relational reality becomes determinate. REM is compared with RQM, QBism, and Many-Worlds interpretations. Unlike these approaches, REM does not presuppose that relational structures are already formed — it models the generative phase that precedes perspectival consistency. The framework also provides a natural analysis of Wigner's Friend scenarios as multi-level differentiation processes. A structural correspondence (not equivalence) with Buddhist concepts of dependent origination (pratītyasamutpāda) and emptiness (śūnyatā) is identified: Layer 0 corresponds to the absence of intrinsic nature prior to differentiation; Layer 1 corresponds to the arising of relational structure through differentiation events. --- This is Paper 1 of the 6-paper Relational Emergence Model (REM) series: - REM1 (this paper) — Foundational framework: three-layer architecture and differentiation map- REM2 — Selection principles for the differentiation map (variational formulation) https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19155166- REM3 — Generative differentiation via variational selection on factorization manifold https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19157709- REM4 — Competing informational and dynamical criteria for subsystem structure https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19637584- REM5 — Variational selection of tensor-product structure in quantum systems https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19637651- REM_lambda — Variational generation of relational structure (physical interpretation of λ) https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19641344
In this work, we present a relational reinterpretation of the Schrödinger equation in which quantum evolution is understood as arising from the balance between competing tendencies toward propagation and localization. Within this framework, the Hamiltonian is re-expressed as an effective generator of relational tension, and quantum measurement is interpreted as a transition into a localization-dominated regime rather than a fundamental collapse. To test this interpretation, we analyze publicly available experimental data from monitored quantum circuits exhibiting measurement-induced transitions (Feng et al., Communications Physics, 2026). Using the merged dataset (k4-z-data-merged.npy), we examine the structure of variability in the experimentally defined order parameter across measurement strength and circuit depth. The analysis shows that variability is not adequately described by a single control parameter. Instead, it exhibits clear multi-variable structure, with significant dependence on circuit depth. Furthermore, incorporating prior-state information—specifically, the observable value at the previous depth—improves predictive accuracy, demonstrating that the system exhibits measurable path dependence. At the same time, a structured residual component remains, indicating that the system is only partially predictable within the available variable set. These findings show that quantum variability in this system is not featureless or purely stochastic, but instead reflects organized, multi-variable, and history-dependent structure. This result does not alter the formal predictions of quantum mechanics. Rather, it provides a data-supported interpretation in which quantum uncertainty is understood as the projection of deeper relational dynamics into a reduced descriptive framework. The presence of path dependence and partial predictability suggests that variability arises from partially resolved structure rather than irreducible randomness.
This work presents an exact finite-dimensional construction for the compatibility between microscopic duality and coarse-graining in a two-dimensional Z2 lattice gauge model on a finite square torus. Using cellular homology and cohomology, gauge-invariant Hilbert spaces, and a tree-cotree decomposition, the study isolates a four-dimensional topological Hilbert sector from local degrees of freedom. The construction distinguishes the physical gauge quotient from its dual cycle-space representation and establishes their relationship through a finite-group Fourier transform. Two coarse-graining isometries are defined independently of the microscopic duality. Their compatibility is established through an exact intertwining relation, yielding a unitary effective transformation on the retained topological sector. The mathematical construction is supported by a reproducible Python verification program, with exact algebraic checks and finite-dimensional tests for lattice sizes L = 2 through L = 6. Version 6 incorporates corrections to the explicit 2×2 lattice benchmark, strengthens the treatment of primal-dual identifications, and clarifies the scope and limitations of the results. The work provides a controlled mathematical benchmark for investigating the preservation of topological degrees of freedom under coarse-graining. It does not claim a universal renormalization-group construction or establish dynamical equivalence for arbitrary lattice gauge theories. Related research: Work 2: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23428851 Work 3: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23480354 Author: Deivison Ramos do Rosario Version: 6 License: Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0).
Paper 1 of the RID series derives g† = 2cH_{0,dS}/π² as a conjectural effective relation and explicitly flags one heuristic step: the coupling amplitude a_n ∝ τ_n is asserted rather than derived. This paper derives a_n via two independent routes. Route 1 (primary): a_n ≡ √⟨0|x_n²|0⟩ = 1/(2nH) follows in two exact lines from the modular Hamiltonian K and canonical commutation relations. Route 2 (corroborating): the exact KMS two-point function G(τ) = −(1/2H) ln(1 − e^{−H|τ|}) expands as Σ_n a_n e^{−nH|τ|} with a_n = 1/(2nH), independently confirming the same coefficients from the Green's function alone. Three open items are stated explicitly: (i) the overhead functional form (a_n/τ_n)² is FDT-motivated but the γ = 1 normalisation remains open (Paper 5); (ii) τ_n = π/(2nH) is now derived as the first zero of the KMS two-point function G_n(s), with E = ω_n following from the correlator frequency rather than assumed; the residual open item is the identification of the first zero as the synchronisation timescale (Paper 5); (iii) the critical exponent ν = 1/2: its slope face is now derived and directly measured (deep-MOND log–log slope 0.54; deep- and transition-restricted fits 0.485/0.504; §8.7); a Bayesian Υ*-marginalisation (2026-07) gives ν = 0.452 [0.444, 0.458] at that stage; completing the hierarchy with per-galaxy distance and inclination priors (SPARC Table 1) gives ν = 0.503 [0.495, 0.509] (0.489–0.520 across prior widths): the exact-1/2 form is fully consistent, the Υ-only softness is a nuisance-omission artifact, and the residual caveat moves to the scale — the all-nuisance global g† is ridge/prior-dominated, so the joint fit constrains shape while the absolute-scale comparison is a nominal-calibration statement (§8.7). The paper closes the a_n heuristic and upgrades two of the three open items from assumed/conjectural to derived or physically grounded.