Phase-Invariant Condition for Optimal Feedforward in ZZ-Coupled Quantum Systems: Experimental Validation on IBM Heron r2 and IQM Garnet
Takeshi Okuda
Abstract
WITHDRAWN (v1.1, November 2026). The main claim of this preprint — that πνZZτ* ≈ 0.873 rad is an observed invariant across IBM and IQM superconducting devices — is withdrawn by the author. 0.873 was an input, not an observation. In every IBM run (2026-03-28 to 04-19) the delay was set to τ = 0.873/(πνZZ) from the measured νZZ before execution; πνZZτ recomputed from the run logs is 0.8730 for every run, so the constancy in Table 1 holds by construction. Table 1 mixes values from different sessions and experiments. Only the Q13–Q14 row matches a logged run at the listed τ*; other rows match a calibration-file plan or Bell-clock results at other delays. The reported GPS is not the quantity defined in the paper. The logged value for Q13–Q14 (+0.199) is Fff − Fstatic from a dynamic mid-circuit-measurement protocol, not Pff − Pref for the static circuit described. Pair selection. Eight IBM pairs were run; four are reported. IQM. The raw IQM scans (2026-04-14/15) give GPS at τ = 7 µs of −0.006 ± 0.007 (all 18 values); the tabulated +0.026 ± 0.011 (n = 5) could not be reproduced. No IQM optimum is supported. The measurements remain available as records of GPS at the set operating point πνZZτ = 0.873; they do not test whether this point is optimal. The derivation φ*ff = arg⟨eiφ⟩ (Sec. 2) is unaffected. The PDF contains the withdrawal notice followed by the original text unchanged.