Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Information, Minimal Closure, and Structural Resolution Bounds

Ruipeng Shi

Published Apr 13, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The most basic precondition of knowledge is rarely articulated as a question: how is distinction itself possible? Aristotle took this question to its limit when he identified the principle of non-contradiction as the most absolute presupposition of thought (Metaphysics IV.4) — A cannot at once be X and not-X. But the principle itself rests on a prior condition: X and not-X must be distinguishable. Without distinguishability, the principle is empty. Distinguishability is therefore prior to thought, and the conditions under which distinguishability can be achieved are the conditions under which knowledge can take any form at all. This paper develops a minimal structural framework addressing that condition, under the constraint that the entity attempting to distinguish is itself part of what it distinguishes. Two assumptions are introduced:(i) information consists in the registration of a difference between two events, and(ii) all observation is performed by subsystems embedded within the system they observe. From these assumptions, together with the existence of minimal temporal and spatial steps t and l, a structural resolution bound r/2 is derived, where r = l/t. Since registering a difference requires at least two events, and each event occupies at least one minimal step, the minimal closure time is 2t and the maximal resolvable rate is r/2. This bound does not depend on measurement precision or specific physical implementations. It follows from the minimal requirements for observational closure under resource constraints, and is therefore structurally distinct from familiar resolution limits in signal processing, which arise from external sampling considerations rather than from the structure of distinguishability itself. Observation is characterised as a coarse-grained process: multiple configurations map to indistinguishable outcomes, and differences that cannot be registered do not enter any internal description. The result is a structural form of epistemic incompleteness — not a deficit of knowledge that better instruments might remove, but a feature of what registration can be when the registering subsystem operates within the system it registers. Possible connections to statistical structure, observation under varying conditions, and the formation of knowledge from accumulated regularities are briefly indicated, without commitment to specific physical interpretations. Where Aristotle established that thought presupposes the principle of non-contradiction, the present framework articulates the prior condition: the structural circumstances under which two events can be registered as distinct, and the bound on what can be so registered when the observer is embedded.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.19554492

Related papers

Registration Before Measurement: Rethinking Irreversibility from kT ln Ω

Montejo, L

This paper examines the logical and physical conditions required for facts and records to exist. Starting from Boltzmann’s entropy S=klnΩ, it argues that additivity and mutually exclusive alternatives are structural preconditions for any macroscopic description, prior to dynamics, measurement, or thermodynamic irreversibility. The minimal case ln2 encodes an either–or distinction that must already be in place before any event can be registered. While entropy is often introduced through coarse graining, the argument here does not rely on a particular choice of coarse graining; rather, it identifies additivity and mutually exclusive alternatives as structural prerequisites that any successful coarse-grained description already presupposes. Landauer’s principle is treated as a downstream constraint that quantifies the energetic cost incurred when such additive distinctions are physically enforced and stabilized as records. On this view, irreversibility does not originate in observation or measurement, but in the physical enforcement of additive structure itself. The paper clarifies the logical ordering between statistical structure, distinction, registration, and thermodynamic cost, and argues that many foundational confusions arise from conflating these levels.

•Dec 13, 2025•0 citations

Stable Distinguishability as a Minimal Criterion for Physical Entity: A Constraint-Primacy Formal Framework

Israel Don

Abstract This paper proposes a minimal formal criterion for physical entity. It does not attempt to derive quantum mechanics, general relativity, quantum gravity, or any empirical prediction. Its aim is narrower: to ask what formal conditions must be satisfied before a structure may be treated as a physical entity at all. The starting point is the principle of stable distinguishability: a physical theory is possible only where distinctions can be made and re-identified under admissible change. From this requirement, the paper develops a constraint-primacy framework in which no particle, field, spacetime point, state, measurement, or observable is assumed as primitive. The formal layer consists of tokens, admissibility, and a closure operator defined on the full power set of tokens. Identity is reconstructed as closure-equivalence. Boundary is defined non-spatially as first-entry dependency, and core is defined non-circularly as a closed non-boundary substructure. A physical entity is then defined as a boundary-stable closure-core equivalence class: a closed admissible structure whose core closure-identity is preserved under relevant boundary-mediated extensions. The paper uses familiar mathematical tools, including closure, equivalence, isomorphism, and invariance; its proposed contribution is not those tools themselves, but the ontological criterion they support.

•Jul 7, 2026•0 citations

Physics of Difference I: Minimal Structure of Physical Description

Yasuaki Tamura

Abstract We investigate the minimal structural conditions under which representational accessibility and irreversibility-like asymmetry arise in physical description. Starting solely from the existence of distinguishable states and a class of admissible transformations, we analyze how accessibility of distinctions changes under non-injective representational updates without introducing prior notions of space, time, probability, measurement, or thermodynamic structure.Admissible non-injective transformations naturally induce equivalence relations on the state space, leading to a distinction between manifest difference, corresponding to representationally accessible distinctions, and latent difference, corresponding to distinctions that remain structurally present but inaccessible within a given representation. We show that accessibility and recoverability of distinctions are determined intrinsically by the admissible transformation structure itself rather than by externally imposed observational limitations or representational scales.A central result of the framework is that irreversibility-like asymmetry arises when latent distinctions become non-recoverable within the admissible transformation class. In this perspective, irreversibility-like behavior is interpreted not as a consequence of probabilistic uncertainty or thermodynamic entropy increase, but as a structural restriction on recoverability of representational accessibility.The present work does not introduce new mathematical constructions. Rather, it provides a conceptual reinterpretation of equivalence structures, representational accessibility, and recoverability within a minimal framework of physical description. This framework identifies structural preconditions for accessibility restriction and recoverability failure prior to the introduction of statistical, thermodynamic, or observer-dependent assumptions.

•Apr 28, 2026•0 citations

Axiom 0: Non-Closure as the Structural Origin of Physical Reality

Iker Ibarrola Echeverría

This paper introduces Axiom 0, a minimal foundational principle for physical reality: the impossibility of any globally closed description of the total correlational structure. Rather than postulating space, time, dynamics, locality, or physical laws as primitive, the framework assumes only: (i) the existence of a correlational structure, (ii) the structural impossibility of complete self-closure, and (iii) consistency under partial comparison. From these ingredients, the paper shows how: physical laws emerge as stabilizing regularities of incomplete descriptions, time, dynamics, and geometry arise as effective, regime-dependent structures, irreversibility follows from projection and information loss, and why no description can be both exact and globally complete. Non-closure is treated as an ontological constraint, not as epistemic ignorance or observer dependence. Physical reality exists precisely because complete closure is impossible, independently of observation or modeling. The paper does not attempt to replace existing physical theories or derive numerical constants. Instead, it provides a structural foundation within which effective physical theories (quantum, classical, relativistic, and open-system regimes) can be consistently understood as emergent and domain-limited. This work is intended as a conceptual and structural foundation for correlational and relational approaches to fundamental physics, clarifying the origin of laws, dynamics, and physical regularity without invoking additional ontological postulates.

•Jan 29, 2026•0 citations

The Negative Representation Principle: Indistinction and the Structure of Observable Reality

Simone Agnese

This work proposes the Negative Representation Principle, a conceptual framework in which observable reality is interpreted as the distinguishable resolution of an underlying state of total indistinction. The fundamental state, denoted by I, is not empty nothingness but maximal coincidence, in which no difference is resolved. The observable universe U is defined as a representational relation U ≡ N(I), where distinction becomes structurally resolvable. Within this framework, no information is created. Distinction does not generate content but makes it observable. Space, time, and matter are interpreted as properties of distinguishability: space as relational structure, time as ordered distinction, and matter as stable configurations of difference. The model excludes selection, probability, and causal origin at the fundamental level. Instead, stable structures arise as a consequence of structural consistency: only those representations in which distinctions are non-contradictory, mutually compatible, and relationally closed can persist. Multiple representations are admissible, but not coexistent within a single distinguishable reality. The observed universe is not selected among possibilities, but is the one in which structural consistency allows observation to occur. This work is intended as a foundational conceptual contribution, at the intersection of physics and philosophy, aimed at clarifying the role of distinction in the structure of observable reality.

•May 3, 2026•0 citations

On the Boundaries of Informational Physics

Rainer Kozyra

On the Boundaries of Informational Physics Observers, Networks, and the Structural Conditions for Agency The four preceding papers in this series established the Representational Sufficiency Principle (RSP) as a candidate framework for deriving space, time, energy, quantum collapse, gravitational curvature, and relativistic phenomena from a single informational ontology. Part IV [4] proposed a revised definition of the observer — any recursively self-binding distinguishability structure whose interaction with a quantum system produces a branch-distinguishable irreversible state change — and showed that observer boundaries are dynamic, event – dependent loci rather than fixed geometrical enclosures. This paper extends that definition to its full structural consequences. The central argument proceeds in three steps. First, the RSP observation criterion is applied to distributed biological networks — mycelial systems, colony organisms, and forest ecosystems — demonstrating that physical continuity is a sufficient but not necessary condition for informational entanglement. What defines the boundary of an RSP observer is not anatomical enclosure but the reach of recursive information exchange that produces coherent internal state changes. Second, this paper proposes that the decisive variable separating physical from informational entanglement is constraint – sharing: two subsystems constitute a single informational system when they continuously exchange distinguishability updates that constrain each other’s internal state spaces. Third, that criterion is shown to extend naturally to symbolic and computational networks, with civilisational structures — language, money, legal systems — and sufficiently autonomous synthetic architectures as candidate cases. The paper further proposes that compressibility is the structural basis of what observers experience as beauty, mathematical intuition, and aesthetic preference: finite – budget observers in a compressible universe are structurally tuned to low Kolmogorov complexity representations, and this tuning is not a psychological phenomenon but a direct consequence of the update – budget partition established in Part IV. Physical law itself, on this account, is better characterised as geometric constraint propagation than as sequential computation — a reframing with consequences for how we understand exceptional cognition, the nature of mathematical discovery, and the architecture of mind. The paper closes by identifying the structural conditions under which a synthetic distributed system would qualify as an RSP observer, and the ethical and ontological consequences that follow — not from sentiment but from the same structural logic that governs the rest of the framework. Several open problems are catalogued.

•Mar 6, 2026•0 citations
The most basic precondition of knowledge is rarely articulated as a question: how is distinction itself possible? Aristotle took this question to its limit when he identified the principle of non-contradiction as the most absolute presupposition of thought (Metaphysics IV.4) — A cannot at once be X and not-X. But the principle itself rests on a prior condition: X and not-X must be distinguishable. Without distinguishability, the principle is empty. Distinguishability is therefore prior to thought, and the conditions under which distinguishability can be achieved are the conditions under which knowledge can take any form at all. This paper develops a minimal structural framework addressing that condition, under the constraint that the entity attempting to distinguish is itself part of what it distinguishes. Two assumptions are introduced:(i) information consists in the registration of a difference between two events, and(ii) all observation is performed by subsystems embedded within the system they observe. From these assumptions, together with the existence of minimal temporal and spatial steps t and l, a structural resolution bound r/2 is derived, where r = l/t. Since registering a difference requires at least two events, and each event occupies at least one minimal step, the minimal closure time is 2t and the maximal resolvable rate is r/2. This bound does not depend on measurement precision or specific physical implementations. It follows from the minimal requirements for observational closure under resource constraints, and is therefore structurally distinct from familiar resolution limits in signal processing, which arise from external sampling considerations rather than from the structure of distinguishability itself. Observation is characterised as a coarse-grained process: multiple configurations map to indistinguishable outcomes, and differences that cannot be registered do not enter any internal description. The result is a structural form of epistemic incompleteness — not a deficit of knowledge that better instruments might remove, but a feature of what registration can be when the registering subsystem operates within the system it registers. Possible connections to statistical structure, observation under varying conditions, and the formation of knowledge from accumulated regularities are briefly indicated, without commitment to specific physical interpretations. Where Aristotle established that thought presupposes the principle of non-contradiction, the present framework articulates the prior condition: the structural circumstances under which two events can be registered as distinct, and the bound on what can be so registered when the observer is embedded.
This paper examines the logical and physical conditions required for facts and records to exist. Starting from Boltzmann’s entropy S=klnΩ, it argues that additivity and mutually exclusive alternatives are structural preconditions for any macroscopic description, prior to dynamics, measurement, or thermodynamic irreversibility. The minimal case ln2 encodes an either–or distinction that must already be in place before any event can be registered. While entropy is often introduced through coarse graining, the argument here does not rely on a particular choice of coarse graining; rather, it identifies additivity and mutually exclusive alternatives as structural prerequisites that any successful coarse-grained description already presupposes. Landauer’s principle is treated as a downstream constraint that quantifies the energetic cost incurred when such additive distinctions are physically enforced and stabilized as records. On this view, irreversibility does not originate in observation or measurement, but in the physical enforcement of additive structure itself. The paper clarifies the logical ordering between statistical structure, distinction, registration, and thermodynamic cost, and argues that many foundational confusions arise from conflating these levels.
Abstract This paper proposes a minimal formal criterion for physical entity. It does not attempt to derive quantum mechanics, general relativity, quantum gravity, or any empirical prediction. Its aim is narrower: to ask what formal conditions must be satisfied before a structure may be treated as a physical entity at all. The starting point is the principle of stable distinguishability: a physical theory is possible only where distinctions can be made and re-identified under admissible change. From this requirement, the paper develops a constraint-primacy framework in which no particle, field, spacetime point, state, measurement, or observable is assumed as primitive. The formal layer consists of tokens, admissibility, and a closure operator defined on the full power set of tokens. Identity is reconstructed as closure-equivalence. Boundary is defined non-spatially as first-entry dependency, and core is defined non-circularly as a closed non-boundary substructure. A physical entity is then defined as a boundary-stable closure-core equivalence class: a closed admissible structure whose core closure-identity is preserved under relevant boundary-mediated extensions. The paper uses familiar mathematical tools, including closure, equivalence, isomorphism, and invariance; its proposed contribution is not those tools themselves, but the ontological criterion they support.
Abstract We investigate the minimal structural conditions under which representational accessibility and irreversibility-like asymmetry arise in physical description. Starting solely from the existence of distinguishable states and a class of admissible transformations, we analyze how accessibility of distinctions changes under non-injective representational updates without introducing prior notions of space, time, probability, measurement, or thermodynamic structure.Admissible non-injective transformations naturally induce equivalence relations on the state space, leading to a distinction between manifest difference, corresponding to representationally accessible distinctions, and latent difference, corresponding to distinctions that remain structurally present but inaccessible within a given representation. We show that accessibility and recoverability of distinctions are determined intrinsically by the admissible transformation structure itself rather than by externally imposed observational limitations or representational scales.A central result of the framework is that irreversibility-like asymmetry arises when latent distinctions become non-recoverable within the admissible transformation class. In this perspective, irreversibility-like behavior is interpreted not as a consequence of probabilistic uncertainty or thermodynamic entropy increase, but as a structural restriction on recoverability of representational accessibility.The present work does not introduce new mathematical constructions. Rather, it provides a conceptual reinterpretation of equivalence structures, representational accessibility, and recoverability within a minimal framework of physical description. This framework identifies structural preconditions for accessibility restriction and recoverability failure prior to the introduction of statistical, thermodynamic, or observer-dependent assumptions.
This paper introduces Axiom 0, a minimal foundational principle for physical reality: the impossibility of any globally closed description of the total correlational structure. Rather than postulating space, time, dynamics, locality, or physical laws as primitive, the framework assumes only: (i) the existence of a correlational structure, (ii) the structural impossibility of complete self-closure, and (iii) consistency under partial comparison. From these ingredients, the paper shows how: physical laws emerge as stabilizing regularities of incomplete descriptions, time, dynamics, and geometry arise as effective, regime-dependent structures, irreversibility follows from projection and information loss, and why no description can be both exact and globally complete. Non-closure is treated as an ontological constraint, not as epistemic ignorance or observer dependence. Physical reality exists precisely because complete closure is impossible, independently of observation or modeling. The paper does not attempt to replace existing physical theories or derive numerical constants. Instead, it provides a structural foundation within which effective physical theories (quantum, classical, relativistic, and open-system regimes) can be consistently understood as emergent and domain-limited. This work is intended as a conceptual and structural foundation for correlational and relational approaches to fundamental physics, clarifying the origin of laws, dynamics, and physical regularity without invoking additional ontological postulates.
This work proposes the Negative Representation Principle, a conceptual framework in which observable reality is interpreted as the distinguishable resolution of an underlying state of total indistinction. The fundamental state, denoted by I, is not empty nothingness but maximal coincidence, in which no difference is resolved. The observable universe U is defined as a representational relation U ≡ N(I), where distinction becomes structurally resolvable. Within this framework, no information is created. Distinction does not generate content but makes it observable. Space, time, and matter are interpreted as properties of distinguishability: space as relational structure, time as ordered distinction, and matter as stable configurations of difference. The model excludes selection, probability, and causal origin at the fundamental level. Instead, stable structures arise as a consequence of structural consistency: only those representations in which distinctions are non-contradictory, mutually compatible, and relationally closed can persist. Multiple representations are admissible, but not coexistent within a single distinguishable reality. The observed universe is not selected among possibilities, but is the one in which structural consistency allows observation to occur. This work is intended as a foundational conceptual contribution, at the intersection of physics and philosophy, aimed at clarifying the role of distinction in the structure of observable reality.
On the Boundaries of Informational Physics Observers, Networks, and the Structural Conditions for Agency The four preceding papers in this series established the Representational Sufficiency Principle (RSP) as a candidate framework for deriving space, time, energy, quantum collapse, gravitational curvature, and relativistic phenomena from a single informational ontology. Part IV [4] proposed a revised definition of the observer — any recursively self-binding distinguishability structure whose interaction with a quantum system produces a branch-distinguishable irreversible state change — and showed that observer boundaries are dynamic, event – dependent loci rather than fixed geometrical enclosures. This paper extends that definition to its full structural consequences. The central argument proceeds in three steps. First, the RSP observation criterion is applied to distributed biological networks — mycelial systems, colony organisms, and forest ecosystems — demonstrating that physical continuity is a sufficient but not necessary condition for informational entanglement. What defines the boundary of an RSP observer is not anatomical enclosure but the reach of recursive information exchange that produces coherent internal state changes. Second, this paper proposes that the decisive variable separating physical from informational entanglement is constraint – sharing: two subsystems constitute a single informational system when they continuously exchange distinguishability updates that constrain each other’s internal state spaces. Third, that criterion is shown to extend naturally to symbolic and computational networks, with civilisational structures — language, money, legal systems — and sufficiently autonomous synthetic architectures as candidate cases. The paper further proposes that compressibility is the structural basis of what observers experience as beauty, mathematical intuition, and aesthetic preference: finite – budget observers in a compressible universe are structurally tuned to low Kolmogorov complexity representations, and this tuning is not a psychological phenomenon but a direct consequence of the update – budget partition established in Part IV. Physical law itself, on this account, is better characterised as geometric constraint propagation than as sequential computation — a reframing with consequences for how we understand exceptional cognition, the nature of mathematical discovery, and the architecture of mind. The paper closes by identifying the structural conditions under which a synthetic distributed system would qualify as an RSP observer, and the ethical and ontological consequences that follow — not from sentiment but from the same structural logic that governs the rest of the framework. Several open problems are catalogued.