Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Relational Existence and the Architecture of Time: A Closure-Based Framework for Physical Description

Magdalena Forsberg

Published Apr 11, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

I present a formally minimal architectural framework for universal description grounded in two foundational commitments: a closure postulate, according to which the domain of description admits no external observer or meta-domain, and a relational existence criterion, according to which a node exists within the domain if and only if it satisfies two simultaneous conditions: it maintains at least one active relation to another node, and it maintains at least one recursive relation to itself. A configuration constitutes a state if and only if every node within it satisfies both conditions. From these commitments I derive three results. First, temporal ordering arises wherever fully connected structures undergo relational transition; time is not a primitive parameter but is observer-relative in a precise architectural sense. Second, the directionality of time follows as an architectural necessity from the idempotence of the accessibility functor, without appeal to thermodynamic or anthropic considerations. Third, when an observer node loses active morphism to a subset of a structure, that subset ceases to be a state relative to that observer — a result I call relational bifurcation. This provides an architectural account of the quantum measurement problem requiring no collapse postulate, no branching ontology, and no privileged observer. The framework resolves the Wigner’s Friend paradox: Wigner and his friend have a communicative break at the moment of measurement, and therefore genuinely different temporal relations to the measured system. No time passes for the system relative to Wigner because no bifurcation occurs relative to him; time passes for the friend because bifurcation does. When they communicate, the outcome becomes accessible to Wigner — not because facts change, but because his morphism structure does. Bell inequality violations are architecturally expected: the entangled pair is a single state relative to the observer, spatial separation is a morphism within the domain rather than a division of it, and properties are constituted by relation rather than carried independently. I contrast the framework with Barbour, Everett, Wheeler, Spencer-Brown, Rovelli, and Ontic Structural Realism, identifying precise points of divergence in each case. The framework makes no empirical predictions but clarifies the structural preconditions any physical theory must satisfy to support observation, temporal ordering, and self-reference without regress.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.19520089

Related papers

Axiom 0: Non-Closure as the Structural Origin of Physical Reality

Iker Ibarrola Echeverría

This paper introduces Axiom 0, a minimal foundational principle for physical reality: the impossibility of any globally closed description of the total correlational structure. Rather than postulating space, time, dynamics, locality, or physical laws as primitive, the framework assumes only: (i) the existence of a correlational structure, (ii) the structural impossibility of complete self-closure, and (iii) consistency under partial comparison. From these ingredients, the paper shows how: physical laws emerge as stabilizing regularities of incomplete descriptions, time, dynamics, and geometry arise as effective, regime-dependent structures, irreversibility follows from projection and information loss, and why no description can be both exact and globally complete. Non-closure is treated as an ontological constraint, not as epistemic ignorance or observer dependence. Physical reality exists precisely because complete closure is impossible, independently of observation or modeling. The paper does not attempt to replace existing physical theories or derive numerical constants. Instead, it provides a structural foundation within which effective physical theories (quantum, classical, relativistic, and open-system regimes) can be consistently understood as emergent and domain-limited. This work is intended as a conceptual and structural foundation for correlational and relational approaches to fundamental physics, clarifying the origin of laws, dynamics, and physical regularity without invoking additional ontological postulates.

•Jan 29, 2026•0 citations

The Observer as a Local Breakdown of Atemporality

Gabriel Jorge Orlando Giani Moreno

This project investigates the emergence of time from a fundamentally timeless description of the universe. Rather than assuming time as a primitive background parameter, we study the physical and informational conditions under which temporal ordering, dynamics, and irreversibility appear for an observer embedded in the system. The core of the framework is a unified relational formula—extending the Page–Wootters mechanism—that shows how three traditionally distinct aspects of the “problem of time” arise from the same operational structure: (i) quantum dynamics from conditioning on physical clock states, (ii) the thermodynamic arrow from partial access to environmental degrees of freedom, and (iii) observer-dependent time from the locality of the clock subsystem. Crucially, the framework does not modify unitary quantum mechanics, introduce collapse postulates, or assume a fundamental flow of time. All temporal features emerge from projection, partial trace, and normalization applied to a single global atemporal state satisfying a Hamiltonian constraint. The project includes analytical results, numerical simulations (implemented in QuTiP), pedagogical companion notes, and philosophical analysis. Together, these components support a central claim: time is not a property of the universe itself, but a property of restricted descriptions generated by physical observers with limited informational access. This OSF repository serves as a living container for the formal development, conceptual interpretation, and future extensions of this observer-dependent approach to temporal emergence.

•Feb 9, 2026•0 citations

The Composite Architecture of Time: Temporal Unity, Relational Compatibility, and the Emergence of a Classical Temporal World

Babu P GEORGE

Physics provides several rigorous temporal structures without requiring them to collapse into a single, observer-independent time variable. Quantum dynamics can be conditioned on internal clocks; relativity supplies local proper times and causal relations; decoherence can make probabilities for selected histories approximately autonomous; records make parts of those histories accessible; and statistical mechanics accounts for macroscopic temporal orientation under suitable boundary conditions. This article asks how these achievements can coexist within one robust classical description. I call the proposed account Composite Temporal Emergence (CTE). It treats temporal unity as relational and scale-sensitive, making a narrower claim than theories in which time itself arises from a timeless ontology. For an accessible macroscopic history, temporal unity obtains when overlapping clock comparisons, causal constraints, quasiclassical histories, records, and thermodynamic conditions support a shared, appropriately localized effective model. I compare this account with Page–Wootters relational dynamics, thermal time, consistent and decoherent histories, quantum reference frames, and spacetime functionalism. A graph-theoretic compatibility functional gives the proposal precise content: on a connected comparison network, pairwise fitting is automatic on a tree, whereas global coordination requires independent cycle conditions. A three-clock example measures the resulting obstruction. The analysis then extends to causal, historical, and thermodynamic data through a constrained joint-admissibility functional, without assuming a natural scalar measure for unlike quantities. The framework identifies a specific explanatory target and research method but supplies neither new dynamics nor independent experimental evidence. Its value depends on whether joint compatibility exposes constraints that component-wise reconstructions obscure.

•Oct 24, 2026•0 citations

Collapsing onto the Same Record: First-Person Actualisation, Shared Records, and the Collapse Chain

H Y Rao

We develop an account on which the future, before it is observed, is real potential without definite values, and on which observation actualises it relative to the observer. For an observer who has not yet observed an event, the event is not merely unknown but indefinite; time, for each observer, is a chain of such collapses, causal but indeterminate. The account faces the question that observer-relative views share: how do separate observers come to live in one world? We distinguish two layers of every collapse, a record layer of public traces and an interpretation layer of private readings. Agreement on asking, already established as conviviality in convivial solipsism and as consensus in quantum Darwinism, follows for any shared classical record. We go further and propose that co-readers of a record collapse onto one record-fact, and defend this as the best explanation of agreement, compatible with Zwirn’s prohibition on comparing perceptions because what is shared is a record, not a perception. Financial markets supply such records by institutional design: each second, a changing set of readers co-collapses onto one price while interpreting it divergently. A minimal first-person formalism identifies where non-classical structure could appear and reduces to a classical Markov model when all updates commute. We separate the interpretive claims, which no experiment decides, from testable consequences framed as no-signalling-in-time conditions. Version 2 (November 2026). Changes from version 1: Section 3.3: added support for the scope limitation from Zwirn (2026), “Are events absolute?” (EPJ Web of Conferences 366, 01002). Three of his reservations about the Wigner’s-friend theorems are cited: undoing a measurement makes it hard to regard the outcome as a fact; experiments with macroscopic observers would require apparatus larger than the universe; and photons are not clearly valid stand-ins for observers. Added Adlam (2026, arXiv:2604.12094), who argues from within relational quantum mechanics that explaining collapse requires giving up the completeness of the quantum formalism. Section 3.4: distinguished the potentialities of convivial solipsism, which belong to the observer and are selected without a physical process, from the real potentials and real actualisation of this paper. Section 4.4: stated Zwirn’s position more precisely: agreement on asking holds because asking is itself a measurement, while two observers may still see different results. Added that Zwirn (2026) treats consensus among observers as an open question, and positioned Postulate 1 as one proposal for it. References: added Zwirn (2026), Zwirn (2024, Foundations of Physics 54, 39), Adlam (2026) and Proietti et al. (2019). No claim, lemma, postulate or formal result has been changed. Version 3 (November 2026). Changes from version 2: Section 2.2: added a comparison with Del Santo and Gisin (2021), “The relativity of indeterminacy”. Their determinacy is relative to spacetime regions and independent of knowledge; ours is relative to observation. Added the argument that, before observation, not knowing coincides with indeterminacy because observation creates the value. Section 2.4: related the collapse chain to the creative time of Del Santo and Gisin (2024), with the difference that it passes for each observer separately. Section 3.1: replied to Del Santo and Gisin (2023), “The open past in an indeterministic physics”. Irreversibility belongs to the collapse itself, not to the persistence of records; forgetting removes access to a fact, not the fact. Stated the resulting asymmetry before and after observation. Added Table 1, which sets this account beside Einstein’s realism and Del Santo and Gisin on two questions: whether the unobserved is determinate, and whether the observed past stays determinate when every record is gone. Identified the commitment as that of the growing block universe (Broad 1923), and the opposing view as Dummett’s (1969). New Appendix A: the core claims stated as four axioms, a model showing that they are jointly consistent (in which values come into existence only at observation), and three theorems (the asymmetry, agreement on asking, and the direction of time). A remark shows that dropping each axiom yields a rival position. References: added Del Santo and Gisin (2021, 2023, 2024), Broad (1923), Dummett (1969), Pais (1979), Mermin (1985), Bourne (2002) and Braddon-Mitchell (2004). The core claims of the paper are unchanged; this version makes their foundations and their relation to rival positions explicit. Table numbers after Section 3.1 have shifted by one.

•Nov 6, 2026•0 citations

The Structure of Observation Derived from the Observer Problem A Reinterpretation of Schr¨odinger's Cat and Wigner's Friend

Fumiyoshi Tamura

The observer problem remains one of the central unresolved questions in the foundations of quantum mechanics. This paper derives the logical structure of observation without assuming an observer, consciousness, measurement, or information as primitive concepts. Starting from the primitive notion of Meaning, the following logical sequence is derived: Meaning → Being → Closure → I₄ → Update → Time → 0 < δ < ∞ → Self-Reference → Observer → Observation → Record → Synchronization → Information. Within this framework, an observer is shown to emerge necessarily from persistent self-referential closure possessing finite residual relation. Observation is interpreted as the generation of persistent internal representations, while measurement is reformulated as synchronization between independent closures. Information is derived as synchronized records supported by an information medium. This logical structure provides a unified reinterpretation of Schrödinger's cat and Wigner's friend. The apparent paradoxes are shown to originate from synchronization between independent observers rather than from consciousness, observer-dependent reality, or wave-function collapse. The paper establishes an ontological hierarchy connecting Meaning, Being, observation, synchronization, and information within the MBC (Meaning-Based Constraint) framework.

•Jul 8, 2026•0 citations

Structural Closure and Admissibility in Physical Theory A Constraint-Based Framework for Foundational Consistency

Nathan Scott Brown

Foundational problems in physics—including quantum measurement, spacetime emergence, gravitational dynamics, nonlocality, the arrow of time, and the status of physical existence—are typically addressed in isolation, via model-dependent extensions or interpretive assumptions. This work proposes a different approach. We introduce a constraint-based framework, the Closure Admissibility Principle (CAP), which specifies minimal structural conditions any physical description must satisfy in order to be globally consistent. CAP is formulated in operational terms, using admissibility of states, recoverability under refinement, and stability of closed records, without assuming spacetime, dynamics, or ontology a priori. We show that enforcing these constraints induces a unifying closure structure on law-space, from which several persistent foundational puzzles are resolved as structural consequences rather than postulates. In particular, collapse is reclassified as record selection, spacetime and gravity emerge only in compressible regimes, General Relativity appears as an infrared universality class rather than a fundamental law, singularities correspond to failures of admissible description, and null (“nothing”) models are excluded as inadmissible fixed points. The framework is explicitly falsifiable via operational and weak-field tests, and its scope and limits are stated precisely. The results suggest that many foundational paradoxes arise not from incomplete dynamics, but from admitting globally incoherent physical descriptions.

•Feb 16, 2026•0 citations
I present a formally minimal architectural framework for universal description grounded in two foundational commitments: a closure postulate, according to which the domain of description admits no external observer or meta-domain, and a relational existence criterion, according to which a node exists within the domain if and only if it satisfies two simultaneous conditions: it maintains at least one active relation to another node, and it maintains at least one recursive relation to itself. A configuration constitutes a state if and only if every node within it satisfies both conditions. From these commitments I derive three results. First, temporal ordering arises wherever fully connected structures undergo relational transition; time is not a primitive parameter but is observer-relative in a precise architectural sense. Second, the directionality of time follows as an architectural necessity from the idempotence of the accessibility functor, without appeal to thermodynamic or anthropic considerations. Third, when an observer node loses active morphism to a subset of a structure, that subset ceases to be a state relative to that observer — a result I call relational bifurcation. This provides an architectural account of the quantum measurement problem requiring no collapse postulate, no branching ontology, and no privileged observer. The framework resolves the Wigner’s Friend paradox: Wigner and his friend have a communicative break at the moment of measurement, and therefore genuinely different temporal relations to the measured system. No time passes for the system relative to Wigner because no bifurcation occurs relative to him; time passes for the friend because bifurcation does. When they communicate, the outcome becomes accessible to Wigner — not because facts change, but because his morphism structure does. Bell inequality violations are architecturally expected: the entangled pair is a single state relative to the observer, spatial separation is a morphism within the domain rather than a division of it, and properties are constituted by relation rather than carried independently. I contrast the framework with Barbour, Everett, Wheeler, Spencer-Brown, Rovelli, and Ontic Structural Realism, identifying precise points of divergence in each case. The framework makes no empirical predictions but clarifies the structural preconditions any physical theory must satisfy to support observation, temporal ordering, and self-reference without regress.
This paper introduces Axiom 0, a minimal foundational principle for physical reality: the impossibility of any globally closed description of the total correlational structure. Rather than postulating space, time, dynamics, locality, or physical laws as primitive, the framework assumes only: (i) the existence of a correlational structure, (ii) the structural impossibility of complete self-closure, and (iii) consistency under partial comparison. From these ingredients, the paper shows how: physical laws emerge as stabilizing regularities of incomplete descriptions, time, dynamics, and geometry arise as effective, regime-dependent structures, irreversibility follows from projection and information loss, and why no description can be both exact and globally complete. Non-closure is treated as an ontological constraint, not as epistemic ignorance or observer dependence. Physical reality exists precisely because complete closure is impossible, independently of observation or modeling. The paper does not attempt to replace existing physical theories or derive numerical constants. Instead, it provides a structural foundation within which effective physical theories (quantum, classical, relativistic, and open-system regimes) can be consistently understood as emergent and domain-limited. This work is intended as a conceptual and structural foundation for correlational and relational approaches to fundamental physics, clarifying the origin of laws, dynamics, and physical regularity without invoking additional ontological postulates.
This project investigates the emergence of time from a fundamentally timeless description of the universe. Rather than assuming time as a primitive background parameter, we study the physical and informational conditions under which temporal ordering, dynamics, and irreversibility appear for an observer embedded in the system. The core of the framework is a unified relational formula—extending the Page–Wootters mechanism—that shows how three traditionally distinct aspects of the “problem of time” arise from the same operational structure: (i) quantum dynamics from conditioning on physical clock states, (ii) the thermodynamic arrow from partial access to environmental degrees of freedom, and (iii) observer-dependent time from the locality of the clock subsystem. Crucially, the framework does not modify unitary quantum mechanics, introduce collapse postulates, or assume a fundamental flow of time. All temporal features emerge from projection, partial trace, and normalization applied to a single global atemporal state satisfying a Hamiltonian constraint. The project includes analytical results, numerical simulations (implemented in QuTiP), pedagogical companion notes, and philosophical analysis. Together, these components support a central claim: time is not a property of the universe itself, but a property of restricted descriptions generated by physical observers with limited informational access. This OSF repository serves as a living container for the formal development, conceptual interpretation, and future extensions of this observer-dependent approach to temporal emergence.
Physics provides several rigorous temporal structures without requiring them to collapse into a single, observer-independent time variable. Quantum dynamics can be conditioned on internal clocks; relativity supplies local proper times and causal relations; decoherence can make probabilities for selected histories approximately autonomous; records make parts of those histories accessible; and statistical mechanics accounts for macroscopic temporal orientation under suitable boundary conditions. This article asks how these achievements can coexist within one robust classical description. I call the proposed account Composite Temporal Emergence (CTE). It treats temporal unity as relational and scale-sensitive, making a narrower claim than theories in which time itself arises from a timeless ontology. For an accessible macroscopic history, temporal unity obtains when overlapping clock comparisons, causal constraints, quasiclassical histories, records, and thermodynamic conditions support a shared, appropriately localized effective model. I compare this account with Page–Wootters relational dynamics, thermal time, consistent and decoherent histories, quantum reference frames, and spacetime functionalism. A graph-theoretic compatibility functional gives the proposal precise content: on a connected comparison network, pairwise fitting is automatic on a tree, whereas global coordination requires independent cycle conditions. A three-clock example measures the resulting obstruction. The analysis then extends to causal, historical, and thermodynamic data through a constrained joint-admissibility functional, without assuming a natural scalar measure for unlike quantities. The framework identifies a specific explanatory target and research method but supplies neither new dynamics nor independent experimental evidence. Its value depends on whether joint compatibility exposes constraints that component-wise reconstructions obscure.
We develop an account on which the future, before it is observed, is real potential without definite values, and on which observation actualises it relative to the observer. For an observer who has not yet observed an event, the event is not merely unknown but indefinite; time, for each observer, is a chain of such collapses, causal but indeterminate. The account faces the question that observer-relative views share: how do separate observers come to live in one world? We distinguish two layers of every collapse, a record layer of public traces and an interpretation layer of private readings. Agreement on asking, already established as conviviality in convivial solipsism and as consensus in quantum Darwinism, follows for any shared classical record. We go further and propose that co-readers of a record collapse onto one record-fact, and defend this as the best explanation of agreement, compatible with Zwirn’s prohibition on comparing perceptions because what is shared is a record, not a perception. Financial markets supply such records by institutional design: each second, a changing set of readers co-collapses onto one price while interpreting it divergently. A minimal first-person formalism identifies where non-classical structure could appear and reduces to a classical Markov model when all updates commute. We separate the interpretive claims, which no experiment decides, from testable consequences framed as no-signalling-in-time conditions. Version 2 (November 2026). Changes from version 1: Section 3.3: added support for the scope limitation from Zwirn (2026), “Are events absolute?” (EPJ Web of Conferences 366, 01002). Three of his reservations about the Wigner’s-friend theorems are cited: undoing a measurement makes it hard to regard the outcome as a fact; experiments with macroscopic observers would require apparatus larger than the universe; and photons are not clearly valid stand-ins for observers. Added Adlam (2026, arXiv:2604.12094), who argues from within relational quantum mechanics that explaining collapse requires giving up the completeness of the quantum formalism. Section 3.4: distinguished the potentialities of convivial solipsism, which belong to the observer and are selected without a physical process, from the real potentials and real actualisation of this paper. Section 4.4: stated Zwirn’s position more precisely: agreement on asking holds because asking is itself a measurement, while two observers may still see different results. Added that Zwirn (2026) treats consensus among observers as an open question, and positioned Postulate 1 as one proposal for it. References: added Zwirn (2026), Zwirn (2024, Foundations of Physics 54, 39), Adlam (2026) and Proietti et al. (2019). No claim, lemma, postulate or formal result has been changed. Version 3 (November 2026). Changes from version 2: Section 2.2: added a comparison with Del Santo and Gisin (2021), “The relativity of indeterminacy”. Their determinacy is relative to spacetime regions and independent of knowledge; ours is relative to observation. Added the argument that, before observation, not knowing coincides with indeterminacy because observation creates the value. Section 2.4: related the collapse chain to the creative time of Del Santo and Gisin (2024), with the difference that it passes for each observer separately. Section 3.1: replied to Del Santo and Gisin (2023), “The open past in an indeterministic physics”. Irreversibility belongs to the collapse itself, not to the persistence of records; forgetting removes access to a fact, not the fact. Stated the resulting asymmetry before and after observation. Added Table 1, which sets this account beside Einstein’s realism and Del Santo and Gisin on two questions: whether the unobserved is determinate, and whether the observed past stays determinate when every record is gone. Identified the commitment as that of the growing block universe (Broad 1923), and the opposing view as Dummett’s (1969). New Appendix A: the core claims stated as four axioms, a model showing that they are jointly consistent (in which values come into existence only at observation), and three theorems (the asymmetry, agreement on asking, and the direction of time). A remark shows that dropping each axiom yields a rival position. References: added Del Santo and Gisin (2021, 2023, 2024), Broad (1923), Dummett (1969), Pais (1979), Mermin (1985), Bourne (2002) and Braddon-Mitchell (2004). The core claims of the paper are unchanged; this version makes their foundations and their relation to rival positions explicit. Table numbers after Section 3.1 have shifted by one.
The observer problem remains one of the central unresolved questions in the foundations of quantum mechanics. This paper derives the logical structure of observation without assuming an observer, consciousness, measurement, or information as primitive concepts. Starting from the primitive notion of Meaning, the following logical sequence is derived: Meaning → Being → Closure → I₄ → Update → Time → 0 < δ < ∞ → Self-Reference → Observer → Observation → Record → Synchronization → Information. Within this framework, an observer is shown to emerge necessarily from persistent self-referential closure possessing finite residual relation. Observation is interpreted as the generation of persistent internal representations, while measurement is reformulated as synchronization between independent closures. Information is derived as synchronized records supported by an information medium. This logical structure provides a unified reinterpretation of Schrödinger's cat and Wigner's friend. The apparent paradoxes are shown to originate from synchronization between independent observers rather than from consciousness, observer-dependent reality, or wave-function collapse. The paper establishes an ontological hierarchy connecting Meaning, Being, observation, synchronization, and information within the MBC (Meaning-Based Constraint) framework.
Foundational problems in physics—including quantum measurement, spacetime emergence, gravitational dynamics, nonlocality, the arrow of time, and the status of physical existence—are typically addressed in isolation, via model-dependent extensions or interpretive assumptions. This work proposes a different approach. We introduce a constraint-based framework, the Closure Admissibility Principle (CAP), which specifies minimal structural conditions any physical description must satisfy in order to be globally consistent. CAP is formulated in operational terms, using admissibility of states, recoverability under refinement, and stability of closed records, without assuming spacetime, dynamics, or ontology a priori. We show that enforcing these constraints induces a unifying closure structure on law-space, from which several persistent foundational puzzles are resolved as structural consequences rather than postulates. In particular, collapse is reclassified as record selection, spacetime and gravity emerge only in compressible regimes, General Relativity appears as an infrared universality class rather than a fundamental law, singularities correspond to failures of admissible description, and null (“nothing”) models are excluded as inadmissible fixed points. The framework is explicitly falsifiable via operational and weak-field tests, and its scope and limits are stated precisely. The results suggest that many foundational paradoxes arise not from incomplete dynamics, but from admitting globally incoherent physical descriptions.