Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Coherent Interaction and Emergence of Photonic Trimers

Rubens Nunes Caputo

Published Mar 28, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The experiment by Liang et al. (Science, 2018) demonstrated the formation of photonic trimers — bound states of three photons — in ultracold clouds of rubidium atoms in the Rydberg state. The results show: velocity slower than ; effective mass comparable to a fraction of the electron mass; optical phase greater than that of dimers; and shape-preserving wave functions. This paper reinterprets these results within the Conjugate Photonic Model (CPM). In the CPM, the photon is an dipole confined by a self-shielding magnetic field, with a rotating internal structure: the dipole rotates continuously in the plane transversal to motion, with polarisation vector . In the free state, the continuous rotation cancels the external field of the dipole — perfect kinetic shielding. In the trimer, the Rydberg field of rubidium partially disrupts this rotation, exposing the charges. The equilibrium geometry is determined by the synchronous rotation of the three dipoles at : at any instant, two dipoles present opposite charges facing each other (attraction) and the third presents a same-sign charge to one of them (repulsion) — a stable dynamic equilibrium explaining the phase (not ) and the impossibility of a stable tetramer.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.19281283

Related papers

Forming photonic bound states

Ian S. Osborne

Quantum Optics Photons do not naturally interact with each other and must be coaxed into doing so. Liang et al. show that a gas of Rydberg atoms—a cloud of rubidium atoms excited by a sequence of laser pulses—can induce strong interactions between propagating photons. The authors could tune the strength of the interaction to make the photons form dimer and trimer bound states. This approach should prove useful for producing novel quantum states of light and quantum entanglement on demand. Science , this issue p. [783][1] [1]: /lookup/doi/10.1126/science.aao7293

Science•Feb 15, 2018•0 citations

Observation of three-photon bound states in a quantum nonlinear medium

Qiyu Liang, Aditya V. Venkatramani, Sergio Cantu +7 more

Bound states of massive particles, such as nuclei, atoms, or molecules, constitute the bulk of the visible world around us. By contrast, photons typically only interact weakly. We report the observation of traveling three-photon bound states in a quantum nonlinear medium where the interactions between photons are mediated by atomic Rydberg states. Photon correlation and conditional phase measurements reveal the distinct bunching and phase features associated with three-photon and two-photon bound states. Such photonic trimers and dimers possess shape-preserving wave functions that depend on the constituent photon number. The observed bunching and strongly nonlinear optical phase are described by an effective field theory of Rydberg-induced photon-photon interactions. These observations demonstrate the ability to realize and control strongly interacting quantum many-body states of light.

arXiv:1709.01478•Science•Feb 16, 2018•153 citations

Few-body bound states of dipole-dipole-interacting Rydberg atoms

Martin Kiffner, Mingxia Huo, Wenhui Li +1 more

We show that the resonant dipole-dipole interaction can give rise to bound states between two and three Rydberg atoms with nonoverlapping electron clouds. The dimer and trimer states arise from avoided level crossings between states converging to different fine-structure manifolds in the limit of separated atoms. We analyze the angular dependence of the potential wells, characterize the quantum dynamics in these potentials, and discuss methods for their production and detection. Typical distances between the atoms are of the order of several micrometers which can be resolved in state-of-the-art experiments. The potential depths and typical oscillation frequencies are about one order of magnitude larger as compared to the dimer and trimer states investigated by M. Kiffner et al. [Phys. Rev. A 86, 031401(R) (2012)] and M. Kiffner, W. Li, and D. Jaksch [Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 233003 (2013)], respectively. We find that the dimer and trimer molecules can be aligned with respect to the axis of a weak electric field.

arXiv:1404.3825•Physical Review A•May 30, 2014•9 citations

Negative Dwell Time as Phase Perturbation: A CPM Reinterpretation of Weak-Value Experiments Without Longitudinal Photon Extension

Rubens Nunes Caputo

The recent experiment by Angulo, Steinberg et al. (2025) reported the observation of negative weak values for the time atoms spend in the excited state as a photon is transmitted through a cold rubidium gas. Within standard quantum mechanics, this result is interpreted as evidence that the photon must possess real longitudinal spatial extension — a "front" and a "tail" whose phase interference drives the atomic clock backwards. This paper demonstrates that the result admits a complete and causally transparent reinterpretation within the Conjugate Photonic Model (CPM). In the CPM, the photon is a compact rotating electromagnetic dipole — a photonic disc — with along the propagation axis. Atomic matter is itself composed of Hopf-soliton EM structures (electron hopfions) organised by nuclear field confinement. The passage of a photonic disc through a material medium is therefore not the interaction of a wave-packet with passive atoms, but the coupling of one rotating EM field structure with another. The measured "dwell time" is reinterpreted as the integral of the phase displacement of the electron hopfion induced by the passing disc — a displacement that can be negative when the disc arrives out of phase with the hopfion's natural resonance cycle, producing a sub-threshold oscillation that returns to equilibrium without absorption. No longitudinal photon extension is required, no causal paradox arises, and no ontologically negative time exists. The apparent paradox is an artefact of the standard model's assignment of spatial extension to the photon's wavelength — an assignment the CPM identifies as an unwarranted inference from the rotating path geometry of the photonic disc.

•May 22, 2026•0 citations

Theory of interacting cavity Rydberg polaritons

Alexandros Georgakopoulos, Ariel Sommer, Jonathan Simon

Abstract Photonic materials are an emerging platform to explore quantum matter (Carusotto and Ciuti 2013 Rev. Mod. Phys. 85 299; Sommer et al 2015 arXiv: 1506.00341 ) and quantum dynamics (Peyronel et al 2012 Nature 488 57). The development of Rydberg electromagnetically induced transparency (Weatherill et al 2008 J. Phys. B: At. Mol. Opt. Phys. 41 201002; Petrosyan et al 2011 Phys. Rev. Lett. 107 213601) provided a clear route to strong interactions between individual optical photons. In conjunction with carefully designed optical resonators, it is now possible to achieve extraordinary control of the properties of individual photons, introducing tunable gauge fields (Schine et al 2016 Nature 534 671) whilst imbuing the photons with mass and embedding them on curved spatial manifolds (Sommer et al 2016 New J. Phys. 18 035008). Building on work formalizing Rydberg mediated interactions between propagating photons (Gorshkov et al 2011 Phys. Rev. Lett. 107 133602; Gullans et al 2016 Phys. Rev. Lett. 117 113601), we develop a theory of interacting Rydberg polaritons in multimode optical resonators, where the strong interactions are married with tunable single particle properties to build and probe exotic matter. In the presence of strong coupling between the resonator field and a Rydberg-dressed atomic ensemble, a quasiparticle called the ‘cavity Rydberg polariton’ emerges. We investigate its properties, finding that it inherits both the fast dynamics of its photonic constituents and the strong interactions of its atomic constituents. We develop tools to properly renormalize the interactions when polaritons approach each other, and investigate the impact of atomic motion on the coherence of multi-mode polaritons, showing that most channels for atom-polariton cross-thermalization are strongly suppressed. Finally, we propose to harness the repeated diffraction and refocusing of the optical resonator to realize interactions which are local in momentum-space. This work points the way to efficient modeling of polaritonic quantum materials in properly renormalized strongly interacting effective theories, thereby enabling experimental studies of photonic fractional quantum Hall fluids and crystals (Sommer et al 2015 arXiv: 1506.00341 ; Umucalılar et al 2014 Phys. Rev. A 89 023803; Grusdt and Fleischhauer 2013 Phys. Rev. A 87 043628), plus photonic quantum information processors and repeaters (Jaksch et al 2000 Phys. Rev. Lett. 85 2208; Saffman et al 2010 Rev. Mod. Phys. 82 2313; Han et al 2010 Phys. Rev. A 81 , 052311).

arXiv:1805.07315•Quantum Science and Technology•Sep 6, 2018•18 citations

Ghost Frequency-Time Combs Without Ghosts A CPM Reinterpretation of Shih (2026): Rotating Dipole Phase Synchrony, Mode Beating and the Absence of Vacuum Agents

Rubens Nunes Caputo

Shih (2026) reported the observation of ghost frequency-time combs (GFC, 50% contrast) from continuous-wave laser beams, and theoretically predicted quantum ghost frequency-time combs (QGFC, 100% contrast) from entangled coherent states, concluding that classical statistical theory cannot explain the phenomena and that quantum coherence theory — specifically non-local superposition of probability amplitudes — is required. This paper demonstrates that the GFC and QGFC are fully consistent with the Conjugate Photonic Model (CPM) without invoking either vacuum agents or non-local wave-function collapse. In the CPM, each photon is a rotating dipole with internal phase . The GFC emerges from the local beating between the internal phases of randomly paired dipoles across the two detectors — the same mechanism responsible for photonic trimers and mode-locking. The QGFC emerges from the phase synchrony imposed by the energy conservation condition — the macroscopic analogue of the Pi-Cosmic Generating Function . The Path provides fixed propagation conditions (, , ) with no internal structure to act as vacuum agent. The "non-locality" of GFC is resolved: the correlation is local in the phase of each dipole, propagated deterministically through the closed Energy–Path system to the two detectors.

•Apr 2, 2026•0 citations
The experiment by Liang et al. (Science, 2018) demonstrated the formation of photonic trimers — bound states of three photons — in ultracold clouds of rubidium atoms in the Rydberg state. The results show: velocity slower than ; effective mass comparable to a fraction of the electron mass; optical phase greater than that of dimers; and shape-preserving wave functions. This paper reinterprets these results within the Conjugate Photonic Model (CPM). In the CPM, the photon is an dipole confined by a self-shielding magnetic field, with a rotating internal structure: the dipole rotates continuously in the plane transversal to motion, with polarisation vector . In the free state, the continuous rotation cancels the external field of the dipole — perfect kinetic shielding. In the trimer, the Rydberg field of rubidium partially disrupts this rotation, exposing the charges. The equilibrium geometry is determined by the synchronous rotation of the three dipoles at : at any instant, two dipoles present opposite charges facing each other (attraction) and the third presents a same-sign charge to one of them (repulsion) — a stable dynamic equilibrium explaining the phase (not ) and the impossibility of a stable tetramer.
Quantum Optics Photons do not naturally interact with each other and must be coaxed into doing so. Liang et al. show that a gas of Rydberg atoms—a cloud of rubidium atoms excited by a sequence of laser pulses—can induce strong interactions between propagating photons. The authors could tune the strength of the interaction to make the photons form dimer and trimer bound states. This approach should prove useful for producing novel quantum states of light and quantum entanglement on demand. Science , this issue p. [783][1] [1]: /lookup/doi/10.1126/science.aao7293
Bound states of massive particles, such as nuclei, atoms, or molecules, constitute the bulk of the visible world around us. By contrast, photons typically only interact weakly. We report the observation of traveling three-photon bound states in a quantum nonlinear medium where the interactions between photons are mediated by atomic Rydberg states. Photon correlation and conditional phase measurements reveal the distinct bunching and phase features associated with three-photon and two-photon bound states. Such photonic trimers and dimers possess shape-preserving wave functions that depend on the constituent photon number. The observed bunching and strongly nonlinear optical phase are described by an effective field theory of Rydberg-induced photon-photon interactions. These observations demonstrate the ability to realize and control strongly interacting quantum many-body states of light.
We show that the resonant dipole-dipole interaction can give rise to bound states between two and three Rydberg atoms with nonoverlapping electron clouds. The dimer and trimer states arise from avoided level crossings between states converging to different fine-structure manifolds in the limit of separated atoms. We analyze the angular dependence of the potential wells, characterize the quantum dynamics in these potentials, and discuss methods for their production and detection. Typical distances between the atoms are of the order of several micrometers which can be resolved in state-of-the-art experiments. The potential depths and typical oscillation frequencies are about one order of magnitude larger as compared to the dimer and trimer states investigated by M. Kiffner et al. [Phys. Rev. A 86, 031401(R) (2012)] and M. Kiffner, W. Li, and D. Jaksch [Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 233003 (2013)], respectively. We find that the dimer and trimer molecules can be aligned with respect to the axis of a weak electric field.
The recent experiment by Angulo, Steinberg et al. (2025) reported the observation of negative weak values for the time atoms spend in the excited state as a photon is transmitted through a cold rubidium gas. Within standard quantum mechanics, this result is interpreted as evidence that the photon must possess real longitudinal spatial extension — a "front" and a "tail" whose phase interference drives the atomic clock backwards. This paper demonstrates that the result admits a complete and causally transparent reinterpretation within the Conjugate Photonic Model (CPM). In the CPM, the photon is a compact rotating electromagnetic dipole — a photonic disc — with along the propagation axis. Atomic matter is itself composed of Hopf-soliton EM structures (electron hopfions) organised by nuclear field confinement. The passage of a photonic disc through a material medium is therefore not the interaction of a wave-packet with passive atoms, but the coupling of one rotating EM field structure with another. The measured "dwell time" is reinterpreted as the integral of the phase displacement of the electron hopfion induced by the passing disc — a displacement that can be negative when the disc arrives out of phase with the hopfion's natural resonance cycle, producing a sub-threshold oscillation that returns to equilibrium without absorption. No longitudinal photon extension is required, no causal paradox arises, and no ontologically negative time exists. The apparent paradox is an artefact of the standard model's assignment of spatial extension to the photon's wavelength — an assignment the CPM identifies as an unwarranted inference from the rotating path geometry of the photonic disc.
Abstract Photonic materials are an emerging platform to explore quantum matter (Carusotto and Ciuti 2013 Rev. Mod. Phys. 85 299; Sommer et al 2015 arXiv: 1506.00341 ) and quantum dynamics (Peyronel et al 2012 Nature 488 57). The development of Rydberg electromagnetically induced transparency (Weatherill et al 2008 J. Phys. B: At. Mol. Opt. Phys. 41 201002; Petrosyan et al 2011 Phys. Rev. Lett. 107 213601) provided a clear route to strong interactions between individual optical photons. In conjunction with carefully designed optical resonators, it is now possible to achieve extraordinary control of the properties of individual photons, introducing tunable gauge fields (Schine et al 2016 Nature 534 671) whilst imbuing the photons with mass and embedding them on curved spatial manifolds (Sommer et al 2016 New J. Phys. 18 035008). Building on work formalizing Rydberg mediated interactions between propagating photons (Gorshkov et al 2011 Phys. Rev. Lett. 107 133602; Gullans et al 2016 Phys. Rev. Lett. 117 113601), we develop a theory of interacting Rydberg polaritons in multimode optical resonators, where the strong interactions are married with tunable single particle properties to build and probe exotic matter. In the presence of strong coupling between the resonator field and a Rydberg-dressed atomic ensemble, a quasiparticle called the ‘cavity Rydberg polariton’ emerges. We investigate its properties, finding that it inherits both the fast dynamics of its photonic constituents and the strong interactions of its atomic constituents. We develop tools to properly renormalize the interactions when polaritons approach each other, and investigate the impact of atomic motion on the coherence of multi-mode polaritons, showing that most channels for atom-polariton cross-thermalization are strongly suppressed. Finally, we propose to harness the repeated diffraction and refocusing of the optical resonator to realize interactions which are local in momentum-space. This work points the way to efficient modeling of polaritonic quantum materials in properly renormalized strongly interacting effective theories, thereby enabling experimental studies of photonic fractional quantum Hall fluids and crystals (Sommer et al 2015 arXiv: 1506.00341 ; Umucalılar et al 2014 Phys. Rev. A 89 023803; Grusdt and Fleischhauer 2013 Phys. Rev. A 87 043628), plus photonic quantum information processors and repeaters (Jaksch et al 2000 Phys. Rev. Lett. 85 2208; Saffman et al 2010 Rev. Mod. Phys. 82 2313; Han et al 2010 Phys. Rev. A 81 , 052311).
Shih (2026) reported the observation of ghost frequency-time combs (GFC, 50% contrast) from continuous-wave laser beams, and theoretically predicted quantum ghost frequency-time combs (QGFC, 100% contrast) from entangled coherent states, concluding that classical statistical theory cannot explain the phenomena and that quantum coherence theory — specifically non-local superposition of probability amplitudes — is required. This paper demonstrates that the GFC and QGFC are fully consistent with the Conjugate Photonic Model (CPM) without invoking either vacuum agents or non-local wave-function collapse. In the CPM, each photon is a rotating dipole with internal phase . The GFC emerges from the local beating between the internal phases of randomly paired dipoles across the two detectors — the same mechanism responsible for photonic trimers and mode-locking. The QGFC emerges from the phase synchrony imposed by the energy conservation condition — the macroscopic analogue of the Pi-Cosmic Generating Function . The Path provides fixed propagation conditions (, , ) with no internal structure to act as vacuum agent. The "non-locality" of GFC is resolved: the correlation is local in the phase of each dipole, propagated deterministically through the closed Energy–Path system to the two detectors.