Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Resource requirements for quantum cryptography

G. Muguruza Lasa

Published Jan 1, 2025• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

In this thesis we explore communication between parties with access to quantum resources, such as channels, qudits, and computers. We start by studying types of quantum channels. In particular, we consider a scenario where the sender knows a classical description of the qudit they intend to send, and the receiver’s operations are restricted to classical ones. Our main result is that the accuracy of the transmission scales inverse exponentially with the number of pre-shared entangled qudits. We later look into possible extra properties of quantum channels by giving a protocol for authenticating a noisy channel. Moreover, we prove that our protocol requires access to poly-logarithmic fewer qubits than the previously known techniques. For the rest of the dissertation we look at what ideal quantum channels could be useful for. Our first result is a round-optimal quantum protocol for oblivious transfer which can be instantiated both in the plain and quantum random oracle models (by basically lifting the properties of an underlying zero-knowledge protocol), but we obtain round optimality in the quantum random oracle model only. The last chapters of this dissertation are an exploration of a particular set-up assumption, quantum pseudorandomness; i.e. assuming the existence of random (looking) quantum states. We first show that in contrast to the classical case, the size of a quantum pseudorandom object cannot be shrunk. Finally, we prove that if there is a promise problem that admits a quantum reduction that loses information about its input, then certain quantum pseudorandom primitives exit.

Related papers

Capacity Approaching Coding for Low Noise Interactive Quantum Communication Part I: Large Alphabets

Debbie Leung, Ashwin Nayak, Ala Shayeghi +3 more

We consider the problem of implementing two-party interactive quantum communication over noisy channels, a necessary endeavor if we wish to fully reap quantum advantages for communication. For an arbitrary protocol with n messages, designed for a noiseless qudit channel over a poly (n ) size alphabet, our main result is a simulation method that fails with probability less than 2-Θ(nϵ)and uses a qudit channel over the same alphabet n(1 + Θ(√{ϵ} )) times, of which an ϵ fraction can be corrupted adversarially. The simulation is thus capacity achieving to leading order, and we conjecture that it is optimal up to a constant factor in the √{ϵ} term. Furthermore, the simulation is in a model that does not require pre-shared resources such as randomness or entanglement between the communicating parties. Our work improves over the best previously known quantum result where the overhead is a non-explicit large constant [Brassard et al., SICOMP'19] for low ϵ.

arXiv:2001.02818•IEEE Transactions on Information Theory•Jun 8, 2021•2 citations

Computationally secure quantum cryptography without one-way functions

Luowen Qian

Most interesting cryptography happens in the computational realm where all parties can only perform efficient computations. On one hand, without this constraint many practically relevant cryptographic tasks are infeasible; on the other, this constraint still captures the power of any physical attacker with limited resources. Classically, if the task of attacking almost any interesting computational cryptography is provably hard, then we would also derive from it the existence of one-way functions, and thus P ≠ NP as well. Quantum mechanics offers a more complete model of physical information in the real world. Recent works have proved oracle separations (Kretschmer’21; Kretschmer, Qian, Sinha, Tal’23; Lombardi, Ma, Wright’23) suggesting that computationally secure quantum cryptography could exist even if P = NP, or in other words, that classical cryptography is infeasible. This hints at the possibility of constructing a quantum cryptosystem and establishing its security without unproven assumptions, liberating cryptographers from the perpetual cat-and-mousegame. In this dissertation, we make initial progress towards this goal by developing a theory of quantum computational cryptography without assuming the existence ofone-way functions. More specifically, we establish the following results: • We introduce a simple and natural quantum cryptographic primitive called EFI pairs, and prove its existential equivalence to various other quantum cryptographic primitives, including commitment schemes, oblivious transfer, and zero knowledge.• We establish the “minimality” of EFI pairs by showing that their existence is implied by many natural cryptographic primitives. EFI pairs thus appear easier to construct than other primitives. • We show that the existence of EFI pairs (and the existentially equivalent primitives) is robust by showing how to upgrade various notions of “weak” security to standard security without any additional assumption. • We finally construct commitment schemes, oblivious transfer, and zero knowledge unconditionally if a piece of quantum advice is allowed. In contrast, classical analogues of these are impossible without first settling P ≠ NP even if we allow randomized advice.

•Jan 1, 2024•0 citations

Authentication of quantum messages

Howard Barnum, Claude Crépeau, Daniel Gottesman +2 more

Authentication is a well-studied area of classical cryptography: a sender A and a receiver B sharing a classical secret key want to exchange a classical message with the guarantee that the message has not been modified or replaced by a dishonest party with control of the communication line. In this paper we study the authentication of messages composed of quantum states. We give a formal definition of authentication in the quantum setting. Assuming A and B have access to an insecure quantum channel and share a secret, classical random key, we provide a non-interactive scheme that enables A to both encrypt and authenticate an m qubit message by encoding it into m+s qubits, where the error probability decreases exponentially in the security parameter s. The scheme requires a secret key of size 2m+O(s). To achieve this, we give a highly efficient protocol for testing the purity of shared EPR pairs. It has long been known that learning information about a general quantum state will necessarily disturb it. We refine this result to show that such a disturbance can be done with few side effects, allowing it to circumvent cryptographic protections. Consequently, any scheme to authenticate quantum messages must also encrypt them. In contrast, no such constraint exists classically. This reasoning has two important consequences: It allows us to give a lower bound of 2m key bits for authenticating m qubits, which makes our protocol asymptotically optimal. Moreover, we use it to show that digitally signing quantum states is impossible.

arXiv:quant-ph/0205128•Annual Symposium on Foundations of Computer Science•Jun 26, 2003•293 citations

Semi-Quantum Cryptography: Designing Protocols with Classical Verification

Yusuf Alnawakhtha

Properties of quantum mechanics such as entanglement and the no-cloning theorem enable new forms of cryptography that are unattainable in classical models of computation. Quantum information, however, is harder to process, store, and transmit than classical information. As such, it is desirable to construct semi-quantum cryptographic protocols where only a subset of the parties have quantum capabilities while the rest operate classically. In this dissertation, we analyze the security of semi-quantum protocols based on two approaches: (i) nonlocality-based techniques and (ii) the hardness of the Learning with Errors (LWE) problem. In the first part of the dissertation, we leverage a form of Bell test to construct a quantum position verification (QPV) protocol. Initial QPV protocols required verifiers to prepare and send quantum states to an honest prover to achieve security against adversaries with bounded memory or entanglement. Later work constructed QPV protocols with classical verifiers but required additional assumptions such as the hardness of LWE or of random circuit sampling. We construct a variant of QPV where classical verifiers verify the spatial locations of two provers. We use the nonlocal correlations produced by the two provers to show security against adversaries with bounded quantum memory without making any computational intractability assumptions. In the second part of the dissertation, we use trapdoor claw-free functions (TCFs) to construct semi-quantum cryptographic protocols. TCFs, which are constructible from the hardness of LWE, have been shown to be immensely valuable in the construction of classically verifiable quantum cryptographic protocols. As opposed to previous work where the server is asked to prepare a claw state and perform Pauli-X and Z measurements, we use a technique that leverages the entire range of qubit measurements on the XY-plane. We use this technique to construct three protocols: (i) a one-round blind remote state preparation protocol that delegates the preparation of an arbitrary state on the XY-plane up to a Pauli-X correction; (ii) a two-round proof of quantumness whose security is directly in terms of the hardness of LWE and only requires the prover to prepare and measure a single claw state; and (iii) a 1-of-2 Puzzle with a single qubit auxiliary state.

•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

Capacity approaching coding for low noise interactive quantum communication

Debbie Leung, Ashwin Nayak, Ala Shayeghi +3 more

We consider the problem of implementing two-party interactive quantum communication over noisy channels, a necessary endeavor if we wish to fully reap quantum advantages for communication. For an arbitrary protocol with n messages, designed for noiseless qudit channels (where d is arbitrary), our main result is a simulation method that fails with probability less than 2−Θ (nє) and uses a qudit channel n (1 + Θ (√є)) times, of which an є fraction can be corrupted adversarially. The simulation is thus capacity achieving to leading order, and we conjecture that it is optimal up to a constant factor in the √є term. Furthermore, the simulation is in a model that does not require pre-shared resources such as randomness or entanglement between the communicating parties. Perhaps surprisingly, this outperforms the best known overhead of 1 + O(√є loglog1/є) in the corresponding classical model, which is also conjectured to be optimal [Haeupler, FOCS’14]. Our work also improves over the best previously known quantum result where the overhead is a non-explicit large constant [Brassard et al., FOCS’14] for low є.

ACM Symposium on Theory of Computing (STOC)•Jun 20, 2018•4 citations

On communication over an entanglement-assisted quantum channel

A. Nayak, Julia Salzman

Shared entanglement is a resource available to parties communicating over a quantum channel, much akin to public coins in classical communication protocols: the two parties may be given some number of quantum bits jointly prepared in a fixed superposition, prior to communicating with each other. The quantum channel is then said to be "entanglement-assisted." Shared randomness does not help in the transmission of information from one party to another. Moreover, it does not significantly reduce the classical complexity of computing functions vis-a-vis private-coin protocols. On the other hand, prior entanglement leads to startling phenomena such as "quantum teleportation" and "superdense coding." The problem of characterising the power of prior entanglement has baffled many researchers, especially in the setting of bounded-error protocols. It is open whether it leads to more than a factor of two savings (using superdense coding) or more than an additive O(log) savings (when used to create shared randomness). Few lower bounds are known for communication problems in this setting, and are all derived using sophisticated information theoretic techniques. In this paper, we focus on the most basic problem in the setting of communication over an entanglement-assisted quantum channel, that of communicating classical bits from one party to another. We derive optimal bounds on the number of quantum bits required for this task, for any given probability of error.

IEEE Conference on Computational Complexity (CCC)•Jun 25, 2003•10 citations
In this thesis we explore communication between parties with access to quantum resources, such as channels, qudits, and computers. We start by studying types of quantum channels. In particular, we consider a scenario where the sender knows a classical description of the qudit they intend to send, and the receiver’s operations are restricted to classical ones. Our main result is that the accuracy of the transmission scales inverse exponentially with the number of pre-shared entangled qudits. We later look into possible extra properties of quantum channels by giving a protocol for authenticating a noisy channel. Moreover, we prove that our protocol requires access to poly-logarithmic fewer qubits than the previously known techniques. For the rest of the dissertation we look at what ideal quantum channels could be useful for. Our first result is a round-optimal quantum protocol for oblivious transfer which can be instantiated both in the plain and quantum random oracle models (by basically lifting the properties of an underlying zero-knowledge protocol), but we obtain round optimality in the quantum random oracle model only. The last chapters of this dissertation are an exploration of a particular set-up assumption, quantum pseudorandomness; i.e. assuming the existence of random (looking) quantum states. We first show that in contrast to the classical case, the size of a quantum pseudorandom object cannot be shrunk. Finally, we prove that if there is a promise problem that admits a quantum reduction that loses information about its input, then certain quantum pseudorandom primitives exit.
We consider the problem of implementing two-party interactive quantum communication over noisy channels, a necessary endeavor if we wish to fully reap quantum advantages for communication. For an arbitrary protocol with n messages, designed for a noiseless qudit channel over a poly (n ) size alphabet, our main result is a simulation method that fails with probability less than 2-Θ(nϵ)and uses a qudit channel over the same alphabet n(1 + Θ(√{ϵ} )) times, of which an ϵ fraction can be corrupted adversarially. The simulation is thus capacity achieving to leading order, and we conjecture that it is optimal up to a constant factor in the √{ϵ} term. Furthermore, the simulation is in a model that does not require pre-shared resources such as randomness or entanglement between the communicating parties. Our work improves over the best previously known quantum result where the overhead is a non-explicit large constant [Brassard et al., SICOMP'19] for low ϵ.
Most interesting cryptography happens in the computational realm where all parties can only perform efficient computations. On one hand, without this constraint many practically relevant cryptographic tasks are infeasible; on the other, this constraint still captures the power of any physical attacker with limited resources. Classically, if the task of attacking almost any interesting computational cryptography is provably hard, then we would also derive from it the existence of one-way functions, and thus P ≠ NP as well. Quantum mechanics offers a more complete model of physical information in the real world. Recent works have proved oracle separations (Kretschmer’21; Kretschmer, Qian, Sinha, Tal’23; Lombardi, Ma, Wright’23) suggesting that computationally secure quantum cryptography could exist even if P = NP, or in other words, that classical cryptography is infeasible. This hints at the possibility of constructing a quantum cryptosystem and establishing its security without unproven assumptions, liberating cryptographers from the perpetual cat-and-mousegame. In this dissertation, we make initial progress towards this goal by developing a theory of quantum computational cryptography without assuming the existence ofone-way functions. More specifically, we establish the following results: • We introduce a simple and natural quantum cryptographic primitive called EFI pairs, and prove its existential equivalence to various other quantum cryptographic primitives, including commitment schemes, oblivious transfer, and zero knowledge.• We establish the “minimality” of EFI pairs by showing that their existence is implied by many natural cryptographic primitives. EFI pairs thus appear easier to construct than other primitives. • We show that the existence of EFI pairs (and the existentially equivalent primitives) is robust by showing how to upgrade various notions of “weak” security to standard security without any additional assumption. • We finally construct commitment schemes, oblivious transfer, and zero knowledge unconditionally if a piece of quantum advice is allowed. In contrast, classical analogues of these are impossible without first settling P ≠ NP even if we allow randomized advice.
Authentication is a well-studied area of classical cryptography: a sender A and a receiver B sharing a classical secret key want to exchange a classical message with the guarantee that the message has not been modified or replaced by a dishonest party with control of the communication line. In this paper we study the authentication of messages composed of quantum states. We give a formal definition of authentication in the quantum setting. Assuming A and B have access to an insecure quantum channel and share a secret, classical random key, we provide a non-interactive scheme that enables A to both encrypt and authenticate an m qubit message by encoding it into m+s qubits, where the error probability decreases exponentially in the security parameter s. The scheme requires a secret key of size 2m+O(s). To achieve this, we give a highly efficient protocol for testing the purity of shared EPR pairs. It has long been known that learning information about a general quantum state will necessarily disturb it. We refine this result to show that such a disturbance can be done with few side effects, allowing it to circumvent cryptographic protections. Consequently, any scheme to authenticate quantum messages must also encrypt them. In contrast, no such constraint exists classically. This reasoning has two important consequences: It allows us to give a lower bound of 2m key bits for authenticating m qubits, which makes our protocol asymptotically optimal. Moreover, we use it to show that digitally signing quantum states is impossible.
Properties of quantum mechanics such as entanglement and the no-cloning theorem enable new forms of cryptography that are unattainable in classical models of computation. Quantum information, however, is harder to process, store, and transmit than classical information. As such, it is desirable to construct semi-quantum cryptographic protocols where only a subset of the parties have quantum capabilities while the rest operate classically. In this dissertation, we analyze the security of semi-quantum protocols based on two approaches: (i) nonlocality-based techniques and (ii) the hardness of the Learning with Errors (LWE) problem. In the first part of the dissertation, we leverage a form of Bell test to construct a quantum position verification (QPV) protocol. Initial QPV protocols required verifiers to prepare and send quantum states to an honest prover to achieve security against adversaries with bounded memory or entanglement. Later work constructed QPV protocols with classical verifiers but required additional assumptions such as the hardness of LWE or of random circuit sampling. We construct a variant of QPV where classical verifiers verify the spatial locations of two provers. We use the nonlocal correlations produced by the two provers to show security against adversaries with bounded quantum memory without making any computational intractability assumptions. In the second part of the dissertation, we use trapdoor claw-free functions (TCFs) to construct semi-quantum cryptographic protocols. TCFs, which are constructible from the hardness of LWE, have been shown to be immensely valuable in the construction of classically verifiable quantum cryptographic protocols. As opposed to previous work where the server is asked to prepare a claw state and perform Pauli-X and Z measurements, we use a technique that leverages the entire range of qubit measurements on the XY-plane. We use this technique to construct three protocols: (i) a one-round blind remote state preparation protocol that delegates the preparation of an arbitrary state on the XY-plane up to a Pauli-X correction; (ii) a two-round proof of quantumness whose security is directly in terms of the hardness of LWE and only requires the prover to prepare and measure a single claw state; and (iii) a 1-of-2 Puzzle with a single qubit auxiliary state.
We consider the problem of implementing two-party interactive quantum communication over noisy channels, a necessary endeavor if we wish to fully reap quantum advantages for communication. For an arbitrary protocol with n messages, designed for noiseless qudit channels (where d is arbitrary), our main result is a simulation method that fails with probability less than 2−Θ (nє) and uses a qudit channel n (1 + Θ (√є)) times, of which an є fraction can be corrupted adversarially. The simulation is thus capacity achieving to leading order, and we conjecture that it is optimal up to a constant factor in the √є term. Furthermore, the simulation is in a model that does not require pre-shared resources such as randomness or entanglement between the communicating parties. Perhaps surprisingly, this outperforms the best known overhead of 1 + O(√є loglog1/є) in the corresponding classical model, which is also conjectured to be optimal [Haeupler, FOCS’14]. Our work also improves over the best previously known quantum result where the overhead is a non-explicit large constant [Brassard et al., FOCS’14] for low є.
Shared entanglement is a resource available to parties communicating over a quantum channel, much akin to public coins in classical communication protocols: the two parties may be given some number of quantum bits jointly prepared in a fixed superposition, prior to communicating with each other. The quantum channel is then said to be "entanglement-assisted." Shared randomness does not help in the transmission of information from one party to another. Moreover, it does not significantly reduce the classical complexity of computing functions vis-a-vis private-coin protocols. On the other hand, prior entanglement leads to startling phenomena such as "quantum teleportation" and "superdense coding." The problem of characterising the power of prior entanglement has baffled many researchers, especially in the setting of bounded-error protocols. It is open whether it leads to more than a factor of two savings (using superdense coding) or more than an additive O(log) savings (when used to create shared randomness). Few lower bounds are known for communication problems in this setting, and are all derived using sophisticated information theoretic techniques. In this paper, we focus on the most basic problem in the setting of communication over an entanglement-assisted quantum channel, that of communicating classical bits from one party to another. We derive optimal bounds on the number of quantum bits required for this task, for any given probability of error.