Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Modular Locality Criterion: Quantifying the Nonlocality of Entanglement Hamiltonians via Collar Leakage and Interior–Exterior Coupling Obstructions

SIKX HILTON

Published Mar 10, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The modular Hamiltonian KA := − log ∆A is canonical in modular theory butgenerically nonlocal in quantum field theory, with exact locality restricted to specialcases such as the Bisognano–Wichmann theorem for Rindler wedges and the Casini–Huerta–Myers result for balls in CFT vacua. We introduce an operational algebraicdiagnostic for quasi-local modular behavior based on nested collar algebras A(0) ⊂ A(δ)and define the modular leakage functional Λ(δ; t) measuring how far the outer modularflow σA(δ)t pushes inner observables out of A(0). From this we define the modularleakage exponent αT , quantifying the best power-law suppression of leakage as thecollar thickness δ → 0+ on a fixed modular-time window |t| ≤ T . Exact localitycorresponds to αT = ∞. Our main structural result is an interior–exterior obstruction:leakage controls the strength of modularly-induced couplings between the deep interiorA(0) and the exterior algebra A(δ)′. In particular, if αT > 1 (superlinear leakagesuppression), then the interior–exterior commutator witness decays superlinearly in δ,ruling out any effective modular generator whose leading interior–exterior couplingwould produce an O(δ) (or stronger) commutator signal. This converts qualitative“nonlocality of entanglement Hamiltonians” into a falsifiable algebraic constraintwithout reference to stress tensors or background manifolds.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.18947670

Related papers

No-Signaling and Causal Evolution from Modular Flow: Operational Constraints on Emergent Dynamics

SIKX HILTON

Modular automorphisms generated by Tomita–Takesaki theory are canonical butstate-dependent structures. In special QFT regimes (Bisognano–Wichmann wedgesectors, holographic entanglement wedges), modular flow coincides with geometriccausal evolution (Lorentz boosts, bulk modular flow). We define a state-independentsignaling defect ηt(A → B) that measures how much a candidate evolution αt (inparticular modular flow) fails to preserve the commutation structure between twocommuting algebras A and B. The defect is the operator-norm distance from theevolved algebra αt(B) to the commutant A′. We prove a sharp equivalence: ηt(A →B) = 0 if and only if no operational signaling channel exists from lab A to lab B underevolution αt, for all input states and all A-localized interventions. Quantitatively, ηt ≤ε implies the maximal signaling advantage is at most 2ε. In geometric regimes wheremodular flow is causal (Bisognano–Wichmann), the defect must vanish; nontrivialdefect is a hard falsification of the localization–evolution assignment. This yieldsa universal operational causality test applicable to any candidate dynamics, withimmediate consequences for emergent spacetime and holography.

•Mar 10, 2026•0 citations

Estimates for modular theory in algebraic QFT

Adriano Chialastri

The general scope of this PhD thesis is to establish relations between Tomita-Takesaki modular theory, in particular modular Hamiltonians and relative modular Hamiltonians, and physically better understood quantities, such as the stress-energy tensor, energy densities or other modular data in cases where it is known explicitly. In Chapter 1, we will present the basics of operators algebras, Tomita-Takesaki theory, symplectic spaces, and link these concepts to discuss quasi-equivalence of Gaussian states. In Chapter 2, we will discuss algebraic QFTs both in the framework of the Haag-Kastler axioms and of locally covariant QFT, to then specialize to scalar fields and present the stress-energy tensor and the Hadamard condition. In Chapter 3, focussing on Gaussian states of the Weyl-CCR algebra, we study relations between quasi-equivalence of their GNS-representations, differences of the total energy (on some Cauchy surface), and differences between functions of the modular Hamiltonians. Following qualitative relations by Araki and Yamagami, Verch and Longo, we investigate quantitative relations, including in particular estimates of differences between functions of modular Hamiltonians in terms of energy differences. These results will make use of inequalities between p-norms of operators, which we will discuss in Appendix C. In Chapter 4, generalizing the picture beyond Gaussian states, we exploit locality properties of general algebraic QFTs to construct a scheme that allows to estimate relative modular Hamiltonians for suitable pairs of states on some local algebra in terms of modular Hamiltonians of a reference state on bigger or smaller algebras, which might be better understood. For pairs of states susceptible to this scheme, there exist unitaries linking them to the reference state which do not enable superluminal signalling in the sense of Sorkin's paradox. Such unitaries may not however compose the whole class of non-signalling operators, raising the question whether the existence of a non-signalling unitary is a sufficient condition to show the applicability of our estimate. To investigate the strength of our estimates we then consider coherent states for CCR systems, focussing particularly on free scalar fields, where the difference between the upper and lower bounds can be made arbitrarily small, recovering an exact result by squeezing. This yields an independent proof for the relative entropy formula in cases where the relative modular Hamiltonian has not been computed exactly and corroborates the strength of our general estimates. For these results, we will make use of several commutation properties of operators on Fock spaces, which we will present in Appendix A. Results about operator monotone functions will be used throughout this thesis and are explained in Appendix B.

•Oct 16, 2026•0 citations

Modular Self-Duality, Symmetrized Relative Entropy, and Bogoliubov--Kubo--Mori Susceptibility in Quantum Field Theory

Rupak Chatterjee

We develop an operator-algebraic framework for modular self-duality, symmetrized relative entropy, and Bogoliubov--Kubo--Mori (BKM) susceptibility of local states in quantum field theory. In finite dimensions, modular self-duality singles out fixed points at which a state coincides with its modularly reflected partner. At such points, the natural comparison functional is the symmetrized Umegaki relative entropy. It vanishes at coincidence, and its Hessian is governed by the BKM quantum Fisher information along the reflected tangent direction. We then extend this fixed-point construction to the local type~III von Neumann algebras that arise in quantum field theory. Here, a local state is compared with the modular pullback of its commutant restriction, and the intrinsic comparison functional is the symmetrized Araki relative entropy. For sufficiently regular state deformations, the fixed-localization Hessian at the self-dual point defines a type~III BKM susceptibility. This coefficient is obtained by evaluating the BKM bilinear form on the tangent selected by the modular pairing. Exact coherent-state realizations are obtained for the free scalar field on wedge algebras and for the chiral $U(1)$ current on half-line algebras. In both examples, the comparison functional is exactly quadratic in the deformation parameter, and the susceptibility coefficients admit explicit boost-energy, stress-tensor, or half-line integral representations. We also apply the construction to a ball-shaped boundary region in the vacuum state of a conformal field theory with a semiclassical anti-de Sitter (AdS) gravitational dual. For linear bulk coherent excitations in an exact complementary-recovery model of this sector, bulk--boundary modular intertwining identifies the modular partner with the AdS--Rindler-reflected coherent state, and the symmetrized relative entropy is exactly quadratic.

hep-thCross-listedarXiv:2605.19106•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•May 20, 2026•1 citation

First law and quantum correction for holographic entanglement contour

Muxin Han, Qiang Wen

Entanglement entropy satisfies a first law-like relation, which equates the first order perturbation of the entanglement entropy for the region A A to the first order perturbation of the expectation value of the modular Hamiltonian, \delta S_{A}=\delta \langle K_A \rangle δ S A = δ ⟨ K A ⟩ . We propose that this relation has a finer version which states that, the first order perturbation of the entanglement contour equals to the first order perturbation of the contour of the modular Hamiltonian, i.e. \delta s_{A}(\textbf{x})=\delta \langle k_{A}(\textbf{x})\rangle δ s A ( 𝐱 ) = δ ⟨ k A ( 𝐱 ) ⟩ . Here the contour functions s_{A}(\textbf{x}) s A ( 𝐱 ) and k_{A}(\textbf{x}) k A ( 𝐱 ) capture the contribution from the degrees of freedom at \textbf{x} 𝐱 to S_{A} S A and K_A K A respectively. In some simple cases k_{A}(\textbf{x}) k A ( 𝐱 ) is determined by the stress tensor. We also evaluate the quantum correction to the entanglement contour using the fine structure of the entanglement wedge and the additive linear combination (ALC) proposal for partial entanglement entropy (PEE) respectively. The fine structure picture shows that, the quantum correction to the boundary PEE can be identified as a bulk PEE of certain bulk region. While the shows that the quantum correction to the boundary PEE comes from the linear combination of bulk entanglement entropy. We focus on holographic theories with local modular Hamiltonian and configurations of quantum field theories where the applies.

arXiv:2106.12397•SciPost Physics•Sep 14, 2021•30 citations

Relative Entropy and Modular Geometry in Algebraic Quantum Field Theory

Arşen Kaan

This preprint investigates structural relations between relative entropy, modular theory, and information geometry in algebraic quantum field theory (AQFT). In finite‑dimensional quantum systems, the Hessian of Umegaki relative entropy coincides with the Bogoliubov–Kubo–Mori (BKM) metric, and modular automorphisms act by isometries of this geometry; these standard results are reviewed as a mathematically controlled reference model. Motivated by this setting, the work formulates minimal structural conditions under which a perturbative modular information‑geometric programme for Type III1_11 von Neumann algebras could become mathematically meaningful. The analysis focuses on admissible perturbation sectors, Araki relative entropy, modular covariance, and the functional‑analytic obstructions caused by unbounded modular operators. A general consequence of positive semidefiniteness of the perturbative entropy Hessian is recorded: whenever the Hessian defines a well‑defined positive semidefinite bilinear form, its null directions annihilate the full form. In the Rindler wedge model, the corresponding regularity problem for candidate perturbations is formulated in terms of spectral properties and domain issues of the Lorentz boost generator. Throughout, explicit separation is maintained between rigorous results, conditional statements, heuristic motivations, and unresolved analytic problems. A conjecture concerning degenerate modular directions is stated together with a necessary falsifiable condition. This document is exploratory in nature and has not been peer reviewed.

•May 26, 2026•0 citations

Testable Prediction of Modular Criticality in Quantum Simulators

Oleg Nesen

We develop a mathematically rigorous and experimentally testable framework for the classification of physical regimes based on the modular structure of quantum states. The central object of the theory is the modular generator K = −log ρ, which provides a unified language for spectral, geometric, and information-theoretic diagnostics. We introduce a universal instrument panel (MSRO: Modular–Spectral RG Observables) that integrates spectral quantiles, commutator-based response functions, partition-based locality diagnostics, and information-geometric structures. A key requirement of the framework is strong portability: the same diagnostic protocol applies across multiple domains—including open quantum systems, information geometry, entanglement-based models, and RG-like flows—without domain-specific retuning. The main result of the work is the derivation of a universal and experimentally testable scaling law for the modular response signal: ν(λ) ∼ 1 log λ, which characterizes critical regimes in a wide class of quantum systems. We prove that this scaling emerges from spectral asymptotics of the modular operator and establish a strict equivalence between spectral, geometric, and information-theoretic descriptions of criticality: ν ↔ k(q) ↔ I(λ) ↔ K ↔ R ↔ Δ. The framework is supported by functional analytic results (including Fr´echet differentiability of log ρ), operator inequalities (Golden–Thompson, monotonicity of relative entropy), and stability estimates. We further provide a concrete experimental protocol for quantum simulators, including statistical error bounds and Fisher information constraints, making the prediction directly testable. Beyond regime classification, the results suggest a new perspective on criticality as a geometric phenomenon associated with vanishing modular curvature. The approach opens pathways toward large-N limits, quantum field extensions, and the discovery of new classes of non-standard critical behavior.

•Apr 12, 2026•0 citations
The modular Hamiltonian KA := − log ∆A is canonical in modular theory butgenerically nonlocal in quantum field theory, with exact locality restricted to specialcases such as the Bisognano–Wichmann theorem for Rindler wedges and the Casini–Huerta–Myers result for balls in CFT vacua. We introduce an operational algebraicdiagnostic for quasi-local modular behavior based on nested collar algebras A(0) ⊂ A(δ)and define the modular leakage functional Λ(δ; t) measuring how far the outer modularflow σA(δ)t pushes inner observables out of A(0). From this we define the modularleakage exponent αT , quantifying the best power-law suppression of leakage as thecollar thickness δ → 0+ on a fixed modular-time window |t| ≤ T . Exact localitycorresponds to αT = ∞. Our main structural result is an interior–exterior obstruction:leakage controls the strength of modularly-induced couplings between the deep interiorA(0) and the exterior algebra A(δ)′. In particular, if αT > 1 (superlinear leakagesuppression), then the interior–exterior commutator witness decays superlinearly in δ,ruling out any effective modular generator whose leading interior–exterior couplingwould produce an O(δ) (or stronger) commutator signal. This converts qualitative“nonlocality of entanglement Hamiltonians” into a falsifiable algebraic constraintwithout reference to stress tensors or background manifolds.
Modular automorphisms generated by Tomita–Takesaki theory are canonical butstate-dependent structures. In special QFT regimes (Bisognano–Wichmann wedgesectors, holographic entanglement wedges), modular flow coincides with geometriccausal evolution (Lorentz boosts, bulk modular flow). We define a state-independentsignaling defect ηt(A → B) that measures how much a candidate evolution αt (inparticular modular flow) fails to preserve the commutation structure between twocommuting algebras A and B. The defect is the operator-norm distance from theevolved algebra αt(B) to the commutant A′. We prove a sharp equivalence: ηt(A →B) = 0 if and only if no operational signaling channel exists from lab A to lab B underevolution αt, for all input states and all A-localized interventions. Quantitatively, ηt ≤ε implies the maximal signaling advantage is at most 2ε. In geometric regimes wheremodular flow is causal (Bisognano–Wichmann), the defect must vanish; nontrivialdefect is a hard falsification of the localization–evolution assignment. This yieldsa universal operational causality test applicable to any candidate dynamics, withimmediate consequences for emergent spacetime and holography.
The general scope of this PhD thesis is to establish relations between Tomita-Takesaki modular theory, in particular modular Hamiltonians and relative modular Hamiltonians, and physically better understood quantities, such as the stress-energy tensor, energy densities or other modular data in cases where it is known explicitly. In Chapter 1, we will present the basics of operators algebras, Tomita-Takesaki theory, symplectic spaces, and link these concepts to discuss quasi-equivalence of Gaussian states. In Chapter 2, we will discuss algebraic QFTs both in the framework of the Haag-Kastler axioms and of locally covariant QFT, to then specialize to scalar fields and present the stress-energy tensor and the Hadamard condition. In Chapter 3, focussing on Gaussian states of the Weyl-CCR algebra, we study relations between quasi-equivalence of their GNS-representations, differences of the total energy (on some Cauchy surface), and differences between functions of the modular Hamiltonians. Following qualitative relations by Araki and Yamagami, Verch and Longo, we investigate quantitative relations, including in particular estimates of differences between functions of modular Hamiltonians in terms of energy differences. These results will make use of inequalities between p-norms of operators, which we will discuss in Appendix C. In Chapter 4, generalizing the picture beyond Gaussian states, we exploit locality properties of general algebraic QFTs to construct a scheme that allows to estimate relative modular Hamiltonians for suitable pairs of states on some local algebra in terms of modular Hamiltonians of a reference state on bigger or smaller algebras, which might be better understood. For pairs of states susceptible to this scheme, there exist unitaries linking them to the reference state which do not enable superluminal signalling in the sense of Sorkin's paradox. Such unitaries may not however compose the whole class of non-signalling operators, raising the question whether the existence of a non-signalling unitary is a sufficient condition to show the applicability of our estimate. To investigate the strength of our estimates we then consider coherent states for CCR systems, focussing particularly on free scalar fields, where the difference between the upper and lower bounds can be made arbitrarily small, recovering an exact result by squeezing. This yields an independent proof for the relative entropy formula in cases where the relative modular Hamiltonian has not been computed exactly and corroborates the strength of our general estimates. For these results, we will make use of several commutation properties of operators on Fock spaces, which we will present in Appendix A. Results about operator monotone functions will be used throughout this thesis and are explained in Appendix B.
We develop an operator-algebraic framework for modular self-duality, symmetrized relative entropy, and Bogoliubov--Kubo--Mori (BKM) susceptibility of local states in quantum field theory. In finite dimensions, modular self-duality singles out fixed points at which a state coincides with its modularly reflected partner. At such points, the natural comparison functional is the symmetrized Umegaki relative entropy. It vanishes at coincidence, and its Hessian is governed by the BKM quantum Fisher information along the reflected tangent direction. We then extend this fixed-point construction to the local type~III von Neumann algebras that arise in quantum field theory. Here, a local state is compared with the modular pullback of its commutant restriction, and the intrinsic comparison functional is the symmetrized Araki relative entropy. For sufficiently regular state deformations, the fixed-localization Hessian at the self-dual point defines a type~III BKM susceptibility. This coefficient is obtained by evaluating the BKM bilinear form on the tangent selected by the modular pairing. Exact coherent-state realizations are obtained for the free scalar field on wedge algebras and for the chiral U(1)U(1)U(1) current on half-line algebras. In both examples, the comparison functional is exactly quadratic in the deformation parameter, and the susceptibility coefficients admit explicit boost-energy, stress-tensor, or half-line integral representations. We also apply the construction to a ball-shaped boundary region in the vacuum state of a conformal field theory with a semiclassical anti-de Sitter (AdS) gravitational dual. For linear bulk coherent excitations in an exact complementary-recovery model of this sector, bulk--boundary modular intertwining identifies the modular partner with the AdS--Rindler-reflected coherent state, and the symmetrized relative entropy is exactly quadratic.
Entanglement entropy satisfies a first law-like relation, which equates the first order perturbation of the entanglement entropy for the region A A to the first order perturbation of the expectation value of the modular Hamiltonian, \delta S_{A}=\delta \langle K_A \rangle δ S A = δ ⟨ K A ⟩ . We propose that this relation has a finer version which states that, the first order perturbation of the entanglement contour equals to the first order perturbation of the contour of the modular Hamiltonian, i.e. \delta s_{A}(\textbf{x})=\delta \langle k_{A}(\textbf{x})\rangle δ s A ( 𝐱 ) = δ ⟨ k A ( 𝐱 ) ⟩ . Here the contour functions s_{A}(\textbf{x}) s A ( 𝐱 ) and k_{A}(\textbf{x}) k A ( 𝐱 ) capture the contribution from the degrees of freedom at \textbf{x} 𝐱 to S_{A} S A and K_A K A respectively. In some simple cases k_{A}(\textbf{x}) k A ( 𝐱 ) is determined by the stress tensor. We also evaluate the quantum correction to the entanglement contour using the fine structure of the entanglement wedge and the additive linear combination (ALC) proposal for partial entanglement entropy (PEE) respectively. The fine structure picture shows that, the quantum correction to the boundary PEE can be identified as a bulk PEE of certain bulk region. While the shows that the quantum correction to the boundary PEE comes from the linear combination of bulk entanglement entropy. We focus on holographic theories with local modular Hamiltonian and configurations of quantum field theories where the applies.
This preprint investigates structural relations between relative entropy, modular theory, and information geometry in algebraic quantum field theory (AQFT). In finite‑dimensional quantum systems, the Hessian of Umegaki relative entropy coincides with the Bogoliubov–Kubo–Mori (BKM) metric, and modular automorphisms act by isometries of this geometry; these standard results are reviewed as a mathematically controlled reference model. Motivated by this setting, the work formulates minimal structural conditions under which a perturbative modular information‑geometric programme for Type III1_11 von Neumann algebras could become mathematically meaningful. The analysis focuses on admissible perturbation sectors, Araki relative entropy, modular covariance, and the functional‑analytic obstructions caused by unbounded modular operators. A general consequence of positive semidefiniteness of the perturbative entropy Hessian is recorded: whenever the Hessian defines a well‑defined positive semidefinite bilinear form, its null directions annihilate the full form. In the Rindler wedge model, the corresponding regularity problem for candidate perturbations is formulated in terms of spectral properties and domain issues of the Lorentz boost generator. Throughout, explicit separation is maintained between rigorous results, conditional statements, heuristic motivations, and unresolved analytic problems. A conjecture concerning degenerate modular directions is stated together with a necessary falsifiable condition. This document is exploratory in nature and has not been peer reviewed.
We develop a mathematically rigorous and experimentally testable framework for the classification of physical regimes based on the modular structure of quantum states. The central object of the theory is the modular generator K = −log ρ, which provides a unified language for spectral, geometric, and information-theoretic diagnostics. We introduce a universal instrument panel (MSRO: Modular–Spectral RG Observables) that integrates spectral quantiles, commutator-based response functions, partition-based locality diagnostics, and information-geometric structures. A key requirement of the framework is strong portability: the same diagnostic protocol applies across multiple domains—including open quantum systems, information geometry, entanglement-based models, and RG-like flows—without domain-specific retuning. The main result of the work is the derivation of a universal and experimentally testable scaling law for the modular response signal: ν(λ) ∼ 1 log λ, which characterizes critical regimes in a wide class of quantum systems. We prove that this scaling emerges from spectral asymptotics of the modular operator and establish a strict equivalence between spectral, geometric, and information-theoretic descriptions of criticality: ν ↔ k(q) ↔ I(λ) ↔ K ↔ R ↔ Δ. The framework is supported by functional analytic results (including Fr´echet differentiability of log ρ), operator inequalities (Golden–Thompson, monotonicity of relative entropy), and stability estimates. We further provide a concrete experimental protocol for quantum simulators, including statistical error bounds and Fisher information constraints, making the prediction directly testable. Beyond regime classification, the results suggest a new perspective on criticality as a geometric phenomenon associated with vanishing modular curvature. The approach opens pathways toward large-N limits, quantum field extensions, and the discovery of new classes of non-standard critical behavior.