Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

On the True Origin of Quantum Nature in Atoms: A Missing Story

Ghanshyam H. Jadhav

Published Nov 13, 2025• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

The overlooked narrative about the origin of quantum nature in atoms primarily stems from a close examination of two sequential events from the past. The first event was Einstein's attribution of quantum characteristics to light waves in his effort to elucidate the photoelectric effect, which ascribed both a corpuscular and wave nature to light. The second event involved de Broglie's proposal regarding the wave nature of material particles, such as electrons, suggesting that they too possessed both corpuscular and wave characteristics. This advancement led to the emergence of a new branch of mechanics, termed quantum mechanics, which posits that the energy associated with any particle cannot be continuously altered but can assume a specific or some finite value, thereby endowing energy with a quantum form. This quantum nature of matter was perceived to arise from its dual wave-particle nature. It was later revealed that this mechanics exhibits a probabilistic character, which has sparked considerable debate among physicists. Essentially, the prevailing question at that time revolved around how electrons are stabilized within atoms and how these atoms can emit light waves of specific frequencies. In addressing this question, physicists, despite their limited resources, conducted high-quality experiments during the initial three decades of the 20th century, yielding significant conclusions. However, they occasionally overlooked critical signals obtained from these experiments. Had they not done so, the current understanding of physics might have been markedly different. This paper seeks to reassess those signals that were intermittently disregarded and constructs a comprehensive narrative regarding the potential impact they could have had on the evolving mechanics of that era, as well as the alternative perspective of physics that might have emerged from them.

DOI
10.1590/scielopreprints.14027

Related papers

On the True Origin of Quantum Nature in Atoms: A Missing Story

Ghanshyam H. Jadhav

The overlooked narrative about the origin of quantum nature in atoms primarily stems from a close examination of two sequential events from the past. The first event was Einstein's attribution of quantum characteristics to light waves in his effort to elucidate the photoelectric effect, which ascribed both a corpuscular and wave nature to light. The second event involved de Broglie's proposal regarding the wave nature of material particles, such as electrons, suggesting that they too possessed both corpuscular and wave characteristics. This advancement led to the emergence of a new branch of mechanics, termed quantum mechanics, which posits that the energy associated with any particle cannot be continuously altered but can assume a specific or some finite value, thereby endowing energy with a quantum form. This quantum nature of matter was perceived to arise from its dual wave-particle nature. It was later revealed that this mechanics exhibits a probabilistic character, which has sparked considerable debate among physicists. Essentially, the prevailing question at that time revolved around how electrons are stabilized within atoms and how these atoms can emit light waves of specific frequencies. In addressing this question, physicists, despite their limited resources, conducted high-quality experiments during the initial three decades of the 20th century, yielding significant conclusions. However, they occasionally overlooked critical signals obtained from these experiments. Had they not done so, the current understanding of physics might have been markedly different. This paper seeks to reassess those signals that were intermittently disregarded and constructs a comprehensive narrative regarding the potential impact they could have had on the evolving mechanics of that era, as well as the alternative perspective of physics that might have emerged from them.

EPJ Web of Conferences•Jan 1, 2026•1 citation

Quantum Foundations and the Building Blocks of Matter

To trace the evolution of the universe, it is necessary to understand at least the basic ideas behind quantum physics. Science up until the beginning of the 20 th century could be traced back to its ancient Greek origins beginning perhaps in the sixth century B.C. Its evolution became what is known as the classical view of the world and in particular of physics. The beginning of the 20 th century brought with it two great revolutions in physics both due to Albert Einstein. The first was special relativity to be followed later by general relativity or the theory of gravity; the second was quantum mechanics initiated by Einstein’s discovery of the photoelectric effect, which showed that the energy of the electrons emitted by some materials when light is shown on them depends on the frequency of light not on its intensity. The attempt to reconcile quantum mechanics with concepts brought over from classical mechanics has led to an enormous literature on the foundations of quantum mechanics and much confusion especially among non-physicists and students of physics. Part of this is due to the historical approach to teaching the subject coupled with the understandable struggle to carry over the basic concepts of particle and wave from classical physics.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Feb 12, 2018•0 citations

The origin of quantum theory in the crisis of classical physics

Robert Golub, S. K. Lamoreaux

Abstract With the failure of classical physics to explain the experimentally observed black body radiation spectrum, the photoelectric effect and the existence of narrow spectral lines in the light emitted by excited atoms, physicists were forced to reach out for new ideas. Following Planck’s initial “drastic hypothesis” of light “quanta”, Einstein led the way in exploring some of the myriad implications of this idea. In particular, the study of fluctuations led to a new understanding of the interaction of electromagnetic radiation with atoms. Einstein invented the photon by showing, through fluctuation studies, that light emitted by atoms must be in the form of plane waves. These ideas led to the first notions regarding the quantization of matter and its dynamics.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Feb 28, 2023•0 citations

1A Brief Overview of the Quantum Theory of Electromagnetic Fields

Michael A. Parker

The study of light through the centuries has produced a number of theories and experiments. Newton advanced the corpuscular theory, building on the early Greek view of matter composed of atoms. Then Young essentially proved the wave nature of light through the interference experiments. Maxwell provided the firm theoretical basis for the wave nature. During the late 1800s and early 1900s, further experiments showed predictions based on a continuous wave led to the well-known ultraviolet catastrophe. Plank and Einstein originated and developed the notion of the photon as an elementary quantum of propagating electromagnetic (EM) energy. The first half of the 20th century saw the development of the field quantization and the quantum electrodynamics (QED). Feynmann labeled QED as ‘‘the best theory we have’’ to describe the matter-light interaction. The second half of the 20th century witnessed the development of the coherent and squeezed optical states attributable to Glauber and Yuen. The study of light and electromagnetic fields has a long history. This chapter explores the nature of light in terms of quantum optics.

CRC Press eBooks•Oct 3, 2018•0 citations

Quantum mechanics

Yutaka Toyozawa

Quantum mechanics was discovered in 1925 through groping efforts to compromise two apparently contradictory pictures on the fundamental entities in nature. One was the wave picture for light which was later extended to matter by de Broglie, another was the corpuscular picture of matter which was later extended to light by Einstein. Schrödinger's wave equation came as a natural development of the first stream, while Heisenberg's matrix mechanics was presented as a unique proposal from the second stream. In spite of completely different appearances, the two theories proved, within a couple of years after their discoveries, to be equivalent. This is a most beautiful example that the physical reality exists independent of the mathematical framework formulated for its description.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jan 9, 2003•0 citations

Physics of Electrons

HoSung Lee

Light is known to have a wave particle dual nature. The phenomena of light propagation may best be described by the electromagnetic wave theory, while the interaction of light with matter is best described as a particle phenomenon. The correct explanation of the photoelectric effect was given by Einstein in 1905, postulating that a beam of light consisted of small quanta of energy that are now called photons and that an electron in the metal absorbs the incident photon's energy required to escape from the metal. Bohr's theory was replaced by modern quantum mechanics, in which the quantization of energy and angular momentum is a natural consequence of the basic postulates and requires no extra assumptions. In 1924, de Broglie proposed that not only light but all matter, including electrons, has a wave particle dual nature. The use of wave mechanics has been limited by the difficulty of solving the Schrodinger equation for large atoms.

Wiley eBooks•Sep 17, 2016•0 citations
The overlooked narrative about the origin of quantum nature in atoms primarily stems from a close examination of two sequential events from the past. The first event was Einstein's attribution of quantum characteristics to light waves in his effort to elucidate the photoelectric effect, which ascribed both a corpuscular and wave nature to light. The second event involved de Broglie's proposal regarding the wave nature of material particles, such as electrons, suggesting that they too possessed both corpuscular and wave characteristics. This advancement led to the emergence of a new branch of mechanics, termed quantum mechanics, which posits that the energy associated with any particle cannot be continuously altered but can assume a specific or some finite value, thereby endowing energy with a quantum form. This quantum nature of matter was perceived to arise from its dual wave-particle nature. It was later revealed that this mechanics exhibits a probabilistic character, which has sparked considerable debate among physicists. Essentially, the prevailing question at that time revolved around how electrons are stabilized within atoms and how these atoms can emit light waves of specific frequencies. In addressing this question, physicists, despite their limited resources, conducted high-quality experiments during the initial three decades of the 20th century, yielding significant conclusions. However, they occasionally overlooked critical signals obtained from these experiments. Had they not done so, the current understanding of physics might have been markedly different. This paper seeks to reassess those signals that were intermittently disregarded and constructs a comprehensive narrative regarding the potential impact they could have had on the evolving mechanics of that era, as well as the alternative perspective of physics that might have emerged from them.
The overlooked narrative about the origin of quantum nature in atoms primarily stems from a close examination of two sequential events from the past. The first event was Einstein's attribution of quantum characteristics to light waves in his effort to elucidate the photoelectric effect, which ascribed both a corpuscular and wave nature to light. The second event involved de Broglie's proposal regarding the wave nature of material particles, such as electrons, suggesting that they too possessed both corpuscular and wave characteristics. This advancement led to the emergence of a new branch of mechanics, termed quantum mechanics, which posits that the energy associated with any particle cannot be continuously altered but can assume a specific or some finite value, thereby endowing energy with a quantum form. This quantum nature of matter was perceived to arise from its dual wave-particle nature. It was later revealed that this mechanics exhibits a probabilistic character, which has sparked considerable debate among physicists. Essentially, the prevailing question at that time revolved around how electrons are stabilized within atoms and how these atoms can emit light waves of specific frequencies. In addressing this question, physicists, despite their limited resources, conducted high-quality experiments during the initial three decades of the 20th century, yielding significant conclusions. However, they occasionally overlooked critical signals obtained from these experiments. Had they not done so, the current understanding of physics might have been markedly different. This paper seeks to reassess those signals that were intermittently disregarded and constructs a comprehensive narrative regarding the potential impact they could have had on the evolving mechanics of that era, as well as the alternative perspective of physics that might have emerged from them.
To trace the evolution of the universe, it is necessary to understand at least the basic ideas behind quantum physics. Science up until the beginning of the 20 th century could be traced back to its ancient Greek origins beginning perhaps in the sixth century B.C. Its evolution became what is known as the classical view of the world and in particular of physics. The beginning of the 20 th century brought with it two great revolutions in physics both due to Albert Einstein. The first was special relativity to be followed later by general relativity or the theory of gravity; the second was quantum mechanics initiated by Einstein’s discovery of the photoelectric effect, which showed that the energy of the electrons emitted by some materials when light is shown on them depends on the frequency of light not on its intensity. The attempt to reconcile quantum mechanics with concepts brought over from classical mechanics has led to an enormous literature on the foundations of quantum mechanics and much confusion especially among non-physicists and students of physics. Part of this is due to the historical approach to teaching the subject coupled with the understandable struggle to carry over the basic concepts of particle and wave from classical physics.
Abstract With the failure of classical physics to explain the experimentally observed black body radiation spectrum, the photoelectric effect and the existence of narrow spectral lines in the light emitted by excited atoms, physicists were forced to reach out for new ideas. Following Planck’s initial “drastic hypothesis” of light “quanta”, Einstein led the way in exploring some of the myriad implications of this idea. In particular, the study of fluctuations led to a new understanding of the interaction of electromagnetic radiation with atoms. Einstein invented the photon by showing, through fluctuation studies, that light emitted by atoms must be in the form of plane waves. These ideas led to the first notions regarding the quantization of matter and its dynamics.
The study of light through the centuries has produced a number of theories and experiments. Newton advanced the corpuscular theory, building on the early Greek view of matter composed of atoms. Then Young essentially proved the wave nature of light through the interference experiments. Maxwell provided the firm theoretical basis for the wave nature. During the late 1800s and early 1900s, further experiments showed predictions based on a continuous wave led to the well-known ultraviolet catastrophe. Plank and Einstein originated and developed the notion of the photon as an elementary quantum of propagating electromagnetic (EM) energy. The first half of the 20th century saw the development of the field quantization and the quantum electrodynamics (QED). Feynmann labeled QED as ‘‘the best theory we have’’ to describe the matter-light interaction. The second half of the 20th century witnessed the development of the coherent and squeezed optical states attributable to Glauber and Yuen. The study of light and electromagnetic fields has a long history. This chapter explores the nature of light in terms of quantum optics.
Quantum mechanics was discovered in 1925 through groping efforts to compromise two apparently contradictory pictures on the fundamental entities in nature. One was the wave picture for light which was later extended to matter by de Broglie, another was the corpuscular picture of matter which was later extended to light by Einstein. Schrödinger's wave equation came as a natural development of the first stream, while Heisenberg's matrix mechanics was presented as a unique proposal from the second stream. In spite of completely different appearances, the two theories proved, within a couple of years after their discoveries, to be equivalent. This is a most beautiful example that the physical reality exists independent of the mathematical framework formulated for its description.
Light is known to have a wave particle dual nature. The phenomena of light propagation may best be described by the electromagnetic wave theory, while the interaction of light with matter is best described as a particle phenomenon. The correct explanation of the photoelectric effect was given by Einstein in 1905, postulating that a beam of light consisted of small quanta of energy that are now called photons and that an electron in the metal absorbs the incident photon's energy required to escape from the metal. Bohr's theory was replaced by modern quantum mechanics, in which the quantization of energy and angular momentum is a natural consequence of the basic postulates and requires no extra assumptions. In 1924, de Broglie proposed that not only light but all matter, including electrons, has a wave particle dual nature. The use of wave mechanics has been limited by the difficulty of solving the Schrodinger equation for large atoms.