Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Open Access Journal of Physics

A Proof that Diffraction Grating Experimental Wavelength Conclusions are in Error

Donald C. Aucamp

Published Feb 12, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Photons have been shown in this author's prior papers to be spinning, washer shaped, atomic sized particles which are single electric field corpuscles that move orthogonally to the washer face at the local speed of light.Thus, light has no frequency and is not a wave.Perhaps one of the major arguments in favor of light being a wave is that diffraction grating experiments accurately identify the source of the emitted photons.A fundamental assumption in the analysis involving these experiments is that the incident light at the grating slits is a coherent wave.It will be shown in this work that this assumption cannot be valid.However, in spite of this result, and in spite of light being particle shaped and not a wave, it is briefly outlined in this work and shown in an upcoming paper that the conclusions which are drawn concerning source identities are correct.Thus, these spectroscopy experiments have great value even though the wavelengths they indicate do not exist.

DOI
10.22259/2637-5826.0802001

Related papers

Atoms

W. Graham Richards, P.R. Scott

This chapter addresses the question of whether light consists of waves or particles. This issue was resolved in the nineteenth century when it was shown that light could undergo interference and diffraction. The chapter reviews well-known properties and key features of wave motions that emphasize that a point illuminated by two sources of light can nevertheless be in darkness. It also looks at the measurements of diffraction experiments that allowed the wavelengths of different forms of light to be determined. The chapter explains how and why atoms come together to form molecules and illustrates the structure of the Periodic Table. It discusses electrons which are emitted from metal when the energy of the photon exceeds the work function, which implies that a single quantum of energy must be transferred to a single electron.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Dec 29, 1994•1 citation

Photon chamber --- Showing Particle Nature of Light in 2D-Grating Wave Experiments

hui peng

Young’s double slit experiments, which represent the mystery of quantum mechanics, have been described by wave theories such as the electromagnetic wave, quantum probability waves and pilot waves. Recently, the photon chamber has been proposed to detect the traces of the light beams in the 1D-grating diffraction experiments, namely to visualize the passage of the light beams. In this article we apply the photon chamber to the 2D grating. The experiments show that the light beams behave as rays moving through the photon chamber. The existence of the light tracks indicates the particle nature of the light beams in the wave experiments. The challenge is to explain the fact that the light pass through the photon chamber, which may be placed anywhere between the grating and the detecting screen, as photons, while still distribute as waves on the detecting screen.

•Jun 15, 2022•19 citations

Incompleteness of Wave Interpretations of Double Slit and Grating Experiments

Hui Peng

Young’s double slit experiments, which represent the mystery of quantum mechanics, have been described by wave theories, such as the optical wave theory, the electromagnetic wave (EM wave) theory and pilot wave theory. Recently, the coexistence of the particle nature and the wave distribution of light in double slit and grating experiments has been demonstrated. In this article we utilize the photon chamber to detect the traces of the light beams in the double slit/grating experiments. The existence of the light tracks indicates the particle nature of the light beam in the wave experiments. The particle nature of the light beams is visualized by the tracks, while the wave-like distribution is visualized by the interference/diffraction patterns on screen. Furthermore, we cover the two sides of the photon chamber by metal foils. If the light beams were the EM waves, then the interference/diffraction patterns would be disturbed. The experiments show that the light behave as particles moving through the photon chamber, while distribute as waves without being disturbed. Thus, the double slit/grating + photon chamber experiments visually indicate that the wave interpretations of the optical wave/EM wave theories of the double slit/grating experiments are incomplete, and that the lights are not the EM waves. However, the experiments support the concept of the pilot wave theory at far field. The experiments in this article make the mystery of the double slit experiments even more mysterious, and violate both the wave-particle duality and the complementarity principle.

International Journal of Physics•Aug 15, 2022•15 citations

Light

David M. Scott

Scientific inquiry took millennia to ascertain the true nature of light, and it is not possible here to attempt to recapitulate all of the philosophizing, hypotheses, arguments, and experimentation involved in that great debate. The main point of controversy was whether light should be considered as a particle or as a wave. Empedocles of Acragas (492–432 b.c.e .) was of the opinion that light is a “streaming substance” emitted by luminous bodies, and that light travels at a finite speed ( Sambursky, 1958 ). In the seventeenth century, Isaac Newton postulated that light is composed of particles and that color is connected with the size of those particles; however, his contemporary Christiaan Huygens argued that light is a wave that transfers energy but not substance ( Einstein & Infeld, 1966 , p. 105ff). It turns out that light is indeed a wave propagating via electric and magnetic fields, but in addition to exhibiting properties of waves (such as interference) it also exhibits properties of particles (such as momentum and localization). When treating light as particles, the individual quanta are called photons .

CRC Press eBooks•Oct 8, 2018•0 citations

Photon chamber --- Showing Particle Nature of Light in 2D-Grating Wave Experiments

Hui Hua Peng

Young’s double slit experiments, which represent the mystery of quantum mechanics, have been described by wave theories such as the electromagnetic wave, quantum probability waves and pilot waves. Recently, the photon chamber has been proposed to detect the traces of the light beams in the 1D-grating diffraction experiments, namely to visualize the passage of the light beams. In this article we apply the photon chamber to the 2D grating. The experiments show that the light beams behave as rays moving through the photon chamber. The existence of the light tracks indicates the particle nature of the light beams in the wave experiments. The challenge is to explain the fact that the light pass through the photon chamber, which may be placed anywhere between the grating and the detecting screen, as photons, while still distribute as waves on the detecting screen.

•Jun 15, 2022•2 citations

Diffraction without Waves: Emergence of the Quantum Substructure of Light

Joachim Stohr

Today, the nature of light is accounted for by one of the jewels of physics, quantum electrodynamics (QED), the fundamental theory of light and matter. Yet owing to its infinite complexity, scientists still debate how its central concept, the photon, can be reconciled with the perceived existence of light waves, emerging 200 years ago in the wake of Young's double slit diffraction experiment. Ever since, the phenomenon of diffraction has been viewed to embody the wave nature of light, leading to the schizophrenic wave-particle duality. The latter does not exist in QED which is photon based without the existence of waves. Here we introduce the new paradigm that diffraction images directly reflect the fundamental quantum states of light. This is revealed by analysis of the evolution of modern versions of Young's experiment performed with differently modified laser light and photon-based detection. In conventional quantum mechanics, corresponding to first order QED, the fundamental photon nature of light remains hidden since different quantum states produce only two basic types of diffraction patterns that may also be explained by coherent and incoherent wave superposition. The true photon based substructure of light is shown to clearly emerge through characteristic diffraction images in second order QED. The degeneracy of the first order images is lifted, the wave-particle equivalence breaks down, and the patterns directly reveal the true quantum substructure of light. This allows the replacement of the conventional concept of wave coherence by a precise order-dependent degree of coherence that quantifies the interference and diffraction behavior of all quantum states of light.

arXiv:2003.14217•Mar 28, 2020•4 citations
Photons have been shown in this author's prior papers to be spinning, washer shaped, atomic sized particles which are single electric field corpuscles that move orthogonally to the washer face at the local speed of light.Thus, light has no frequency and is not a wave.Perhaps one of the major arguments in favor of light being a wave is that diffraction grating experiments accurately identify the source of the emitted photons.A fundamental assumption in the analysis involving these experiments is that the incident light at the grating slits is a coherent wave.It will be shown in this work that this assumption cannot be valid.However, in spite of this result, and in spite of light being particle shaped and not a wave, it is briefly outlined in this work and shown in an upcoming paper that the conclusions which are drawn concerning source identities are correct.Thus, these spectroscopy experiments have great value even though the wavelengths they indicate do not exist.
This chapter addresses the question of whether light consists of waves or particles. This issue was resolved in the nineteenth century when it was shown that light could undergo interference and diffraction. The chapter reviews well-known properties and key features of wave motions that emphasize that a point illuminated by two sources of light can nevertheless be in darkness. It also looks at the measurements of diffraction experiments that allowed the wavelengths of different forms of light to be determined. The chapter explains how and why atoms come together to form molecules and illustrates the structure of the Periodic Table. It discusses electrons which are emitted from metal when the energy of the photon exceeds the work function, which implies that a single quantum of energy must be transferred to a single electron.
Young’s double slit experiments, which represent the mystery of quantum mechanics, have been described by wave theories such as the electromagnetic wave, quantum probability waves and pilot waves. Recently, the photon chamber has been proposed to detect the traces of the light beams in the 1D-grating diffraction experiments, namely to visualize the passage of the light beams. In this article we apply the photon chamber to the 2D grating. The experiments show that the light beams behave as rays moving through the photon chamber. The existence of the light tracks indicates the particle nature of the light beams in the wave experiments. The challenge is to explain the fact that the light pass through the photon chamber, which may be placed anywhere between the grating and the detecting screen, as photons, while still distribute as waves on the detecting screen.
Young’s double slit experiments, which represent the mystery of quantum mechanics, have been described by wave theories, such as the optical wave theory, the electromagnetic wave (EM wave) theory and pilot wave theory. Recently, the coexistence of the particle nature and the wave distribution of light in double slit and grating experiments has been demonstrated. In this article we utilize the photon chamber to detect the traces of the light beams in the double slit/grating experiments. The existence of the light tracks indicates the particle nature of the light beam in the wave experiments. The particle nature of the light beams is visualized by the tracks, while the wave-like distribution is visualized by the interference/diffraction patterns on screen. Furthermore, we cover the two sides of the photon chamber by metal foils. If the light beams were the EM waves, then the interference/diffraction patterns would be disturbed. The experiments show that the light behave as particles moving through the photon chamber, while distribute as waves without being disturbed. Thus, the double slit/grating + photon chamber experiments visually indicate that the wave interpretations of the optical wave/EM wave theories of the double slit/grating experiments are incomplete, and that the lights are not the EM waves. However, the experiments support the concept of the pilot wave theory at far field. The experiments in this article make the mystery of the double slit experiments even more mysterious, and violate both the wave-particle duality and the complementarity principle.
Scientific inquiry took millennia to ascertain the true nature of light, and it is not possible here to attempt to recapitulate all of the philosophizing, hypotheses, arguments, and experimentation involved in that great debate. The main point of controversy was whether light should be considered as a particle or as a wave. Empedocles of Acragas (492–432 b.c.e .) was of the opinion that light is a “streaming substance” emitted by luminous bodies, and that light travels at a finite speed ( Sambursky, 1958 ). In the seventeenth century, Isaac Newton postulated that light is composed of particles and that color is connected with the size of those particles; however, his contemporary Christiaan Huygens argued that light is a wave that transfers energy but not substance ( Einstein & Infeld, 1966 , p. 105ff). It turns out that light is indeed a wave propagating via electric and magnetic fields, but in addition to exhibiting properties of waves (such as interference) it also exhibits properties of particles (such as momentum and localization). When treating light as particles, the individual quanta are called photons .
Young’s double slit experiments, which represent the mystery of quantum mechanics, have been described by wave theories such as the electromagnetic wave, quantum probability waves and pilot waves. Recently, the photon chamber has been proposed to detect the traces of the light beams in the 1D-grating diffraction experiments, namely to visualize the passage of the light beams. In this article we apply the photon chamber to the 2D grating. The experiments show that the light beams behave as rays moving through the photon chamber. The existence of the light tracks indicates the particle nature of the light beams in the wave experiments. The challenge is to explain the fact that the light pass through the photon chamber, which may be placed anywhere between the grating and the detecting screen, as photons, while still distribute as waves on the detecting screen.
Today, the nature of light is accounted for by one of the jewels of physics, quantum electrodynamics (QED), the fundamental theory of light and matter. Yet owing to its infinite complexity, scientists still debate how its central concept, the photon, can be reconciled with the perceived existence of light waves, emerging 200 years ago in the wake of Young's double slit diffraction experiment. Ever since, the phenomenon of diffraction has been viewed to embody the wave nature of light, leading to the schizophrenic wave-particle duality. The latter does not exist in QED which is photon based without the existence of waves. Here we introduce the new paradigm that diffraction images directly reflect the fundamental quantum states of light. This is revealed by analysis of the evolution of modern versions of Young's experiment performed with differently modified laser light and photon-based detection. In conventional quantum mechanics, corresponding to first order QED, the fundamental photon nature of light remains hidden since different quantum states produce only two basic types of diffraction patterns that may also be explained by coherent and incoherent wave superposition. The true photon based substructure of light is shown to clearly emerge through characteristic diffraction images in second order QED. The degeneracy of the first order images is lifted, the wave-particle equivalence breaks down, and the patterns directly reveal the true quantum substructure of light. This allows the replacement of the conventional concept of wave coherence by a precise order-dependent degree of coherence that quantifies the interference and diffraction behavior of all quantum states of light.