Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Persistence Criterion:Distinguishing Epistemic Obscuration from OntologicalElimination in Physical Theories

Chirag Rathi

Published Feb 8, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

This preprint introduces the Persistence Criterion (PC), a conceptual and mathematical framework for distinguishing epistemic obscuration from ontological elimination in physical theories. The central claim is that uncertainty, noise, decoherence, or coarse-graining reduce empirical distinguishability of states or observables without implying that the underlying theoretical structures cease to exist. The framework is developed across classical estimation theory, stochastic dynamical systems, and quantum theory. In the classical domain, noisy observation models and information-theoretic metrics are used to show how distinguishability contracts while state variables persist, consistent with standard treatments in estimation theory and statistical physics (e.g., Fisher information and Bayesian filtering). For dynamical systems, stochastic differential equations and Fokker–Planck dynamics illustrate how deterministic generators remain structurally present despite diffusion-dominated behavior, aligning with established results in open-system dynamics and control theory. In the quantum domain, the Persistence Criterion is formulated using density operators, completely positive trace-preserving (CPTP) maps, and the algebraic (C*-algebraic) formulation of quantum mechanics. Decoherence is treated as an obscuring process acting on states via CPTP channels, while the underlying observable algebra remains invariant. This formulation draws on standard results from quantum information theory and algebraic quantum mechanics, emphasizing that loss of coherence or distinguishability does not entail annihilation of observables or dynamical structure (Holevo, 2011; Nielsen & Chuang, 2010; Breuer & Petruccione, 2002). The Persistence Criterion is interpretation-neutral and consistent with quantum no-go theorems, including Bell, Kochen–Specker, and PBR-type results, as it makes no assumption of value definiteness or hidden variables. Instead, it functions as a criterion of ontological coherence, identifying and excluding a specific interpretational error: the conflation of indistinguishability with non-existence. The work is aligned with non-eliminative structural realism and contemporary discussions of decoherence and ontology in quantum foundations (Ladyman & Ross, 2007; Wallace, 2012; Ruetsche, 2018). No new physical dynamics or empirical predictions are proposed. The contribution is conceptual and formal: clarifying how existing mathematical frameworks already encode persistence under uncertainty, and providing a principled interpretational constraint applicable across classical and quantum theories.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.18525587

Related papers

The Persistence Criterion:Distinguishing Epistemic Obscuration from OntologicalElimination in Physical Theories

Chirag Rathi

A recurring interpretive move in quantum physics treats the loss of observational distinguishability as equivalent to the loss of ontological structure. In this paper, I show that the formal structure of the theory does not support that move. I prove the Structural Persistence Theorem, which identifies precisely which algebraic invariants survive arbitrary completely positive trace-preserving (CPTP) maps. The invariants form a natural and complete set: the C*-algebra of observables A = B(H), its norm, commutation relations, and positivity structure. No CPTP process removes any observable from the algebra. State-space distinguishability contracts; algebraic structure does not. This partition — preserved structure versus contracted epistemic access — is the core formal result of the paper. I identify and formally diagnose a specific class of ontological overclaiming in the decoherence literature: instances where pointer-basis selection and suppression of off-diagonal density matrix elements are treated as eliminative of superposition. I show exactly where these inferences overreach the formalism and provide corrected formulations. I then demonstrate that this criterion places formal constraints on how the major quantum interpretations can consistently attribute ontological change. Many-Worlds and pilot-wave theory are fully consistent with the criterion. Copenhagen's physical-collapse reading carries an unspecified mechanism burden. GRW and CSL objective collapse models are PC-violating by deliberate design — which the framework clarifies rather than criticizes. Any empirical confirmation of GRW/CSL predictions would constitute direct evidence for PC-violation in nature. Two practical applications are discussed. In quantum error correction, the success of the fault-tolerance threshold theorem is indirect empirical evidence for the Persistence Criterion: decoherence degrades distinguishability but leaves the algebraic structure intact, which is precisely what makes error recovery possible. In effective field theory, the persistence of UV degrees of freedom under coarse-graining is consistent with the same structural partition. This work proposes no new experimental predictions. It clarifies what the existing formalism entails and does not entail — drawing a sharp, formal boundary between what the mathematics licenses and what must be supplied by interpretation.

•Apr 24, 2026•0 citations

Persistence Criterion for Ontological States under Uncertainty

Chirag Rathi

This project presents a conceptual and mathematical investigation into the relationship between uncertainty, distinguishability, and the ontological persistence of physical variables. Rather than treating uncertainty as a mechanism that alters or destroys underlying system states, the work develops a formal framework in which uncertainty acts as an obscuring layer that limits epistemic access while leaving fundamental structure intact. Using tools from information theory, stochastic dynamics, and quantum state evolution, the study introduces a Persistence Criterion that distinguishes between genuine ontological change and mere loss of distinguishability. The framework is applied across classical noise models, feedback-controlled systems, and quantum decoherence processes to demonstrate that contraction of information measures does not imply elimination of underlying states. The project aims to clarify common interpretational confusions in physics and complex systems, particularly in contexts involving strong noise, coarse-graining, and measurement limits. It is intended as a foundations-oriented contribution, with relevance to physical modeling, control theory, and the philosophy of uncertainty.

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

The Objecthood Stability Limit

Yuliya M. Onishchuk

This registration documents a completed theoretical study in fundamental physics and statistical mechanics. The work introduces a universal, model-independent stability criterion for the applicability of object-based descriptions in physical theories. Objecthood is treated not as an ontological primitive, but as an operationally defined regime characterized by (i) a separation of characteristic timescales and (ii) the capacity to support persistent internal records under coarse-grained observation. A dimensionless stability parameter is defined as the ratio between the exit time from a coarse-grained state and the intrinsic relaxation time of the system. The central result is the identification of a sharp threshold below which identity-based language (localization, persistence, re-identification) becomes physically uncontrolled, independently of microscopic dynamics. The registration serves to time-stamp and formally fix the theoretical formulation, definitions, assumptions, and conclusions presented in the associated preprint. No data collection, experimental intervention, or hypothesis testing is planned. The results are normative rather than predictive: they do not modify equations of motion but constrain the domain of physical validity of object-based descriptions across classical, quantum, and relativistic regimes. This registration is intended to establish priority and transparency for a foundational theoretical contribution at the interface of statistical mechanics, quantum foundations, and information theory.

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Why Classical Physics Is an Approximation: Decoherence, Coarse-Graining, and the Limits of Determinism

Guillermo C. Barraza

This article is the third and final part of a three-paper sequence developing Ontological Field Theory (OFT) as a unified framework grounding quantum mechanics in foundational ontological principles. The trilogy is structured as follows: Part I — Conceptual Necessity:Why Quantum Mechanics Is Inevitable: Ontological Continuity and the Necessity of Quantum Dynamics establishes that quantum mechanics follows necessarily from minimal requirements on coherent being, independently of specific physical postulates. Part II — Technical Realization:Derivation of the Schrödinger Equation from Ontological Field Theory provides the explicit field-theoretic derivation showing how the Schrödinger equation emerges as the non-relativistic limit of a covariant ontological field. Part III — Critical Context:Why Classical Physics Is an Approximation: Decoherence, Coarse-Graining, and the Limits of Determinism explains why classical determinism and trajectories arise only as emergent, approximate descriptions of fundamentally quantum and relational dynamics. Each article is logically self-contained, but the full argument is distributed across the three contributions. The conceptual analysis motivates the mathematics; the mathematics grounds the physics; and the critical examination situates classical intuition as a limiting case rather than a foundation. The papers are intended to be read as a coherent whole. We argue that quantum mechanics is not an arbitrary empirical framework but an inevitable consequence of minimal ontological requirements. Assuming only that being must exist necessarily, remain consistent, be relational, and admit self-reference, we show that classical deterministic physics is structurally insufficient. Quantum dynamics emerges as the unique low-energy realization of coherent ontological continuity. This work completes the ontological grounding of quantum mechanics by clarifying why it could not have been otherwise.

•Dec 25, 2025•0 citations

Persistence Is the Law: Noise-Driven Selection Across Quantum and Gravitational Regimes

T HUNT

his paper proposes persistence under stochastic interaction as a unifying physical constraint across quantum, gravitational, and macroscopic regimes. Rather than treating noise as a nuisance or generative force, it is framed as a universal selector that eliminates informational structures incapable of maintaining coherence under compression. Across quantum decoherence, gravitational coarse-graining, renormalization, and entropy production, stable laws emerge not through optimization or design, but through selective survival. Structures that persist do so because they tolerate loss, averaging, and repeated perturbation; those that cannot are eliminated. Physical law is therefore interpreted as residue rather than prescription. The framework formalizes persistence as an informational viability condition, independent of substrate or ontology, and integrates results from decoherence theory, renormalization group flow, and gravitational thermodynamics. It predicts abrupt regime transitions, scaling cliffs, hysteresis, and lawful failure modes rather than smooth unification. This work extends the Living Information Theory (LIT) program by positioning persistence as a primitive constraint shaping which physical regularities can exist at all.

•Jan 2, 2026•0 citations

An Ontological Completion of Geometric Quantum Mechanics

Zayn Blore

Decades of work in geometric quantum mechanics and decoherence theory have clarified how quantum behaviour arises from underlying symplectic and dynamical structures, yet both leave unresolved why measurements yield definite outcomes with |ψ|² frequencies. This paper proposes a deterministic geometric account that retains the strengths of those approaches while eliminating the need for stochastic collapse or multiple-world postulates. The result is a unified description in which observed statistics follow from conserved geometry rather than from probabilistic axioms. Physical reality is represented by a single trajectory ω(t) evolving under Hamiltonian flow on a compact symplectic manifold Σ. Interaction with an environment imposes new constraints that dynamically partition Σ into isolated outcome regions {Ωᵢ}, whose invariant volume ratios μ(Ωᵢ)/μ(Ω₀) reproduce Born weights. Outcome definiteness arises from trajectory confinement within an isolated region, and the framework predicts a quantitative correspondence between interference visibility V and the dynamical separation I of outcome regions. In the macroscopic limit, V ≈ 1 − I, so high separation (I → 1) corresponds to classical definiteness and negligible remaining visibility. The exact functional form, together with parameter-free calculations and proposed experimental tests, is developed in the forthcoming Paper C and a companion note (2025–2026). The paper establishes a complete ontological basis for deterministic quantum measurement, defines how isolation and re-isolation govern the appearance of classicality, and clarifies compliance with Bell, Kochen–Specker, Fine, and PBR constraints. It shows that a finite, measure-preserving geometry can reproduce the statistical structure of quantum theory while remaining open to empirical refutation. This framework, termed Constraint-Surface Dynamics, thus offers a deterministic and falsifiable alternative foundation for quantum mechanics.

•Nov 3, 2025•0 citations
This preprint introduces the Persistence Criterion (PC), a conceptual and mathematical framework for distinguishing epistemic obscuration from ontological elimination in physical theories. The central claim is that uncertainty, noise, decoherence, or coarse-graining reduce empirical distinguishability of states or observables without implying that the underlying theoretical structures cease to exist. The framework is developed across classical estimation theory, stochastic dynamical systems, and quantum theory. In the classical domain, noisy observation models and information-theoretic metrics are used to show how distinguishability contracts while state variables persist, consistent with standard treatments in estimation theory and statistical physics (e.g., Fisher information and Bayesian filtering). For dynamical systems, stochastic differential equations and Fokker–Planck dynamics illustrate how deterministic generators remain structurally present despite diffusion-dominated behavior, aligning with established results in open-system dynamics and control theory. In the quantum domain, the Persistence Criterion is formulated using density operators, completely positive trace-preserving (CPTP) maps, and the algebraic (C*-algebraic) formulation of quantum mechanics. Decoherence is treated as an obscuring process acting on states via CPTP channels, while the underlying observable algebra remains invariant. This formulation draws on standard results from quantum information theory and algebraic quantum mechanics, emphasizing that loss of coherence or distinguishability does not entail annihilation of observables or dynamical structure (Holevo, 2011; Nielsen & Chuang, 2010; Breuer & Petruccione, 2002). The Persistence Criterion is interpretation-neutral and consistent with quantum no-go theorems, including Bell, Kochen–Specker, and PBR-type results, as it makes no assumption of value definiteness or hidden variables. Instead, it functions as a criterion of ontological coherence, identifying and excluding a specific interpretational error: the conflation of indistinguishability with non-existence. The work is aligned with non-eliminative structural realism and contemporary discussions of decoherence and ontology in quantum foundations (Ladyman & Ross, 2007; Wallace, 2012; Ruetsche, 2018). No new physical dynamics or empirical predictions are proposed. The contribution is conceptual and formal: clarifying how existing mathematical frameworks already encode persistence under uncertainty, and providing a principled interpretational constraint applicable across classical and quantum theories.
A recurring interpretive move in quantum physics treats the loss of observational distinguishability as equivalent to the loss of ontological structure. In this paper, I show that the formal structure of the theory does not support that move. I prove the Structural Persistence Theorem, which identifies precisely which algebraic invariants survive arbitrary completely positive trace-preserving (CPTP) maps. The invariants form a natural and complete set: the C*-algebra of observables A = B(H), its norm, commutation relations, and positivity structure. No CPTP process removes any observable from the algebra. State-space distinguishability contracts; algebraic structure does not. This partition — preserved structure versus contracted epistemic access — is the core formal result of the paper. I identify and formally diagnose a specific class of ontological overclaiming in the decoherence literature: instances where pointer-basis selection and suppression of off-diagonal density matrix elements are treated as eliminative of superposition. I show exactly where these inferences overreach the formalism and provide corrected formulations. I then demonstrate that this criterion places formal constraints on how the major quantum interpretations can consistently attribute ontological change. Many-Worlds and pilot-wave theory are fully consistent with the criterion. Copenhagen's physical-collapse reading carries an unspecified mechanism burden. GRW and CSL objective collapse models are PC-violating by deliberate design — which the framework clarifies rather than criticizes. Any empirical confirmation of GRW/CSL predictions would constitute direct evidence for PC-violation in nature. Two practical applications are discussed. In quantum error correction, the success of the fault-tolerance threshold theorem is indirect empirical evidence for the Persistence Criterion: decoherence degrades distinguishability but leaves the algebraic structure intact, which is precisely what makes error recovery possible. In effective field theory, the persistence of UV degrees of freedom under coarse-graining is consistent with the same structural partition. This work proposes no new experimental predictions. It clarifies what the existing formalism entails and does not entail — drawing a sharp, formal boundary between what the mathematics licenses and what must be supplied by interpretation.
This project presents a conceptual and mathematical investigation into the relationship between uncertainty, distinguishability, and the ontological persistence of physical variables. Rather than treating uncertainty as a mechanism that alters or destroys underlying system states, the work develops a formal framework in which uncertainty acts as an obscuring layer that limits epistemic access while leaving fundamental structure intact. Using tools from information theory, stochastic dynamics, and quantum state evolution, the study introduces a Persistence Criterion that distinguishes between genuine ontological change and mere loss of distinguishability. The framework is applied across classical noise models, feedback-controlled systems, and quantum decoherence processes to demonstrate that contraction of information measures does not imply elimination of underlying states. The project aims to clarify common interpretational confusions in physics and complex systems, particularly in contexts involving strong noise, coarse-graining, and measurement limits. It is intended as a foundations-oriented contribution, with relevance to physical modeling, control theory, and the philosophy of uncertainty.
This registration documents a completed theoretical study in fundamental physics and statistical mechanics. The work introduces a universal, model-independent stability criterion for the applicability of object-based descriptions in physical theories. Objecthood is treated not as an ontological primitive, but as an operationally defined regime characterized by (i) a separation of characteristic timescales and (ii) the capacity to support persistent internal records under coarse-grained observation. A dimensionless stability parameter is defined as the ratio between the exit time from a coarse-grained state and the intrinsic relaxation time of the system. The central result is the identification of a sharp threshold below which identity-based language (localization, persistence, re-identification) becomes physically uncontrolled, independently of microscopic dynamics. The registration serves to time-stamp and formally fix the theoretical formulation, definitions, assumptions, and conclusions presented in the associated preprint. No data collection, experimental intervention, or hypothesis testing is planned. The results are normative rather than predictive: they do not modify equations of motion but constrain the domain of physical validity of object-based descriptions across classical, quantum, and relativistic regimes. This registration is intended to establish priority and transparency for a foundational theoretical contribution at the interface of statistical mechanics, quantum foundations, and information theory.
This article is the third and final part of a three-paper sequence developing Ontological Field Theory (OFT) as a unified framework grounding quantum mechanics in foundational ontological principles. The trilogy is structured as follows: Part I — Conceptual Necessity:Why Quantum Mechanics Is Inevitable: Ontological Continuity and the Necessity of Quantum Dynamics establishes that quantum mechanics follows necessarily from minimal requirements on coherent being, independently of specific physical postulates. Part II — Technical Realization:Derivation of the Schrödinger Equation from Ontological Field Theory provides the explicit field-theoretic derivation showing how the Schrödinger equation emerges as the non-relativistic limit of a covariant ontological field. Part III — Critical Context:Why Classical Physics Is an Approximation: Decoherence, Coarse-Graining, and the Limits of Determinism explains why classical determinism and trajectories arise only as emergent, approximate descriptions of fundamentally quantum and relational dynamics. Each article is logically self-contained, but the full argument is distributed across the three contributions. The conceptual analysis motivates the mathematics; the mathematics grounds the physics; and the critical examination situates classical intuition as a limiting case rather than a foundation. The papers are intended to be read as a coherent whole. We argue that quantum mechanics is not an arbitrary empirical framework but an inevitable consequence of minimal ontological requirements. Assuming only that being must exist necessarily, remain consistent, be relational, and admit self-reference, we show that classical deterministic physics is structurally insufficient. Quantum dynamics emerges as the unique low-energy realization of coherent ontological continuity. This work completes the ontological grounding of quantum mechanics by clarifying why it could not have been otherwise.
his paper proposes persistence under stochastic interaction as a unifying physical constraint across quantum, gravitational, and macroscopic regimes. Rather than treating noise as a nuisance or generative force, it is framed as a universal selector that eliminates informational structures incapable of maintaining coherence under compression. Across quantum decoherence, gravitational coarse-graining, renormalization, and entropy production, stable laws emerge not through optimization or design, but through selective survival. Structures that persist do so because they tolerate loss, averaging, and repeated perturbation; those that cannot are eliminated. Physical law is therefore interpreted as residue rather than prescription. The framework formalizes persistence as an informational viability condition, independent of substrate or ontology, and integrates results from decoherence theory, renormalization group flow, and gravitational thermodynamics. It predicts abrupt regime transitions, scaling cliffs, hysteresis, and lawful failure modes rather than smooth unification. This work extends the Living Information Theory (LIT) program by positioning persistence as a primitive constraint shaping which physical regularities can exist at all.
Decades of work in geometric quantum mechanics and decoherence theory have clarified how quantum behaviour arises from underlying symplectic and dynamical structures, yet both leave unresolved why measurements yield definite outcomes with |ψ|² frequencies. This paper proposes a deterministic geometric account that retains the strengths of those approaches while eliminating the need for stochastic collapse or multiple-world postulates. The result is a unified description in which observed statistics follow from conserved geometry rather than from probabilistic axioms. Physical reality is represented by a single trajectory ω(t) evolving under Hamiltonian flow on a compact symplectic manifold Σ. Interaction with an environment imposes new constraints that dynamically partition Σ into isolated outcome regions {Ωᵢ}, whose invariant volume ratios μ(Ωᵢ)/μ(Ω₀) reproduce Born weights. Outcome definiteness arises from trajectory confinement within an isolated region, and the framework predicts a quantitative correspondence between interference visibility V and the dynamical separation I of outcome regions. In the macroscopic limit, V ≈ 1 − I, so high separation (I → 1) corresponds to classical definiteness and negligible remaining visibility. The exact functional form, together with parameter-free calculations and proposed experimental tests, is developed in the forthcoming Paper C and a companion note (2025–2026). The paper establishes a complete ontological basis for deterministic quantum measurement, defines how isolation and re-isolation govern the appearance of classicality, and clarifies compliance with Bell, Kochen–Specker, Fine, and PBR constraints. It shows that a finite, measure-preserving geometry can reproduce the statistical structure of quantum theory while remaining open to empirical refutation. This framework, termed Constraint-Surface Dynamics, thus offers a deterministic and falsifiable alternative foundation for quantum mechanics.