Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Structured Correlation Levels After Partial Time Reversal in Small-Scale Quantum Systems

Amrit Singh

Published Feb 4, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We analyse how mutual information and correlation structure differ between structured and randomised quantum systems under a partial time-reversal protocol. Structured correlations—defined as non-random patterns in mutual information between subsystems—arise in complex systems across physical, biological, and computational domains. Understanding how such structures behave under perturbation remains an open question with implications for theories of emergence. Analogous questions arise in artificial systems, where large language models and neural networks exhibit emergent structures that persist through training dynamics; however, the mechanisms underlying such persistence remain poorly characterised. This paper investigates post-interference correlation levels in small-scale quantum circuits (5-15 qubits) as a minimal, controllable testbed. We compare mutual information between circuits initialised with structured entanglement patterns and randomised baseline circuits subjected to identical local interference protocols. Using mutual information retention metrics and statistical comparison, we quantify the degree to which structured initial conditions exhibit differential correlation levels relative to unstructured controls. Results indicate that structured circuits retain significantly higher absolute mutual information following local interference compared to randomised counterparts (8.0 vs 4.2 bits, z = 3.50, p < 0.001), with this differential arising from initial conditions rather than differential dynamical response. Accordingly, we distinguish between the preservation of initial correlation magnitude under local operations and active resistance to correlation-destroying perturbations. We emphasise that these findings do not support claims of consciousness, intelligence, or agency in quantum systems. The contribution of this work is strictly methodological: we establish operational definitions, reproducible experimental protocols, and quantitative metrics for studying structured correlation levels under local interference. Keywords:Mutual information, Entropy dynamics, Quantum correlations, Structure persistence, Interference protocols, Emergence in complex systems, Information-theoretic metrics

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.18475784

Related papers

Quantum and Classical Dynamics with Random Permutation Circuits

Bruno Bertini, Katja Klobas, Pavel Kos +1 more

Understanding thermalization in quantum many-body systems is among the most enduring problems in modern physics. A particularly interesting question concerns the role played by quantum mechanics in this process, i.e., whether thermalization in quantum many-body systems is fundamentally different from that in classical many-body systems and, if so, which of its features are genuinely quantum. Here, we study this question in minimally structured many-body systems that are only constrained to have local interactions, i.e., local random circuits. In particular, we introduce random permutation circuits (RPCs), which are circuits comprising gates that locally permute basis states, as a counterpart to random unitary circuits (RUCs), a standard toy model for generic quantum dynamics. RPCs represent a model for generic microscopic classical reversible dynamics but, interestingly, can be interpreted both as classical or as quantum dynamics. We show that, upon averaging over all circuit realizations, RPCs permit the analytical computation of several key quantities such as out-of-time-order correlators (OTOCs) and entanglement entropies. In the classical setting, we obtain similar exact results relating (quantum) purity to (classical) growth of mutual information and (quantum) OTOCs to (classical) decorrelators. We, thus, discover a series of exact relations, connecting quantities in RUC and (quantum or classical) RPCs. Our results indicate that, despite the fundamental differences between quantum and classical systems, their many-body dynamics exhibits remarkably similar behaviors.

arXiv:2407.11960•Physical Review X•Jan 28, 2025•14 citations

Quantum complexity: Quantum mutual information, complex networks, and emergent phenomena in quantum cellular automata

David L. Vargas

Emerging quantum simulator technologies provide a new challenge to quantum many body theory. Quantifying the emergent order in and predicting the dynamics of such complex quantum systems requires a new approach. We develop such an approach based on complex network analysis of quantum mutual information. First, we establish the usefulness of quantum mutual information complex networks by reproducing the phase diagrams of transverse Ising and Bose-Hubbard models. By quantifying the complexity of quantum cellular automata we then demonstrate the applicability of complex network theory to non-equilibrium quantum dynamics. We conclude with a study of student collaboration networks, correlating a student's role in a collaboration network with their grades. This work thus initiates a quantitative theory of quantum complexity and provides a new tool for physics education research. We find that network density, clustering coefficient, disparity, and Pearson R correlation show systematic finite size scaling towards critical points of the transverse Ising model and the Bose-Hubbard model. Using matrix product state methods we are able to simulate lattices of hundreds of qubits, allowing us to verify the critical point of the transverse Ising model to within 0.001% of its known value. Furthermore, we find that complex network analysis identifies the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless critical point of the Bose-Hubbard to within 3.6% of its accepted value. Finally, we identify the boundary separating the Mott Insulator phase from a superfluid phase in the Bose-Hubbard model by extremizing network density, clustering coefficient, and disparity. After studying the static properties of quantum many body systems, we study the entanglement and complexity generated by Hamiltonian based quantum cellular automata. In quantum cellular automata one defines a set of local rules that govern the evolution of the quantum state. A site in a quantum lattice evolves if the set of sites around it are in certain configurations. Configurations are defined in terms of the number of sites in the ``alive'' state about a site. We quantify entanglement in terms of the central bond entropy, and complexity in terms of persistent fluctuations of the central bond entropy, complex network measures of quantum mutual information networks far from their values for random/well known quantum states, and robust dynamical features. These Hamiltonians are a generalization of the Bleh, Calarco, Montangero Hamiltonian. Before beginning our study of the entanglement and complexity generated by these Hamiltonians we first perform a convergence analysis of the dynamics of the Bleh, Calarco, Montangero Hamiltonian using an open source matrix product state code, Open Source Matrix Product States. We find that the Bleh, Calarco, Montangero Hamiltonian rapidly saturates the entanglement cutoff of Open Source Matrix Product States for all initial conditions studied and is thus not a viable numerical method for studying the dynamics of quantum cellular automata. We conclude our convergence study with a case study of an emergent quantum blinker pattern also observed in exact simulation and a case study of a nearest neighbor quantum cellular automata. We conclude that while for generic initial conditions Open Source Matrix Product States is unable to meet its internal convergence criteria, for particular initial conditions and quantum cellular automata it is able to provide reliable estimates of entanglement and complexity measures. The failure of OpenMPS to provide reliably converged quantum states leads us to study our quantum cellular automata using a Trotter-based time evolution scheme. We quantify the entanglement and complexity generated by 13 next-nearest neighbor quantum cellular automata. We also define Goldilocks rules, rules that produce activity at a site if there are exactly the right number of alive sites in the neighborhood of a site, not too few, not too many. We identify a Goldilocks rule, rule 4, as the best complexity-generating rule out of the 13 rules tested, verifying our hypothesis that only Goldilocks rules are complexity generating. We also find that non-Goldilocks rules tend toward thermalization as quantified by reduced fluctuations in the central bond entropy. We find that both highly entangled quantum states and lowly entangled quantum states have complex structure in their quantum mutual information adjacency matrices. Finally, in keeping with the strong physics education research focus at the Colorado School of Mines, we apply complex network analysis to a key issue germane to the student experience, namely student collaboration networks. We compute nodal centrality measures on the collaboration networks of students enrolled in three upper-division physics courses at the Colorado School of Mines. These are networks in which links between students indicate assistance with homework. The courses included in the study are intermediate classical mechanics, introductory quantum mechanics, and intermediate electromagnetism. We find that almost all of the measures considered correlate with analytical homework grades. In contrast only net out-strength correlates with exam grade. The benefits of collaboration do not extend from homework to exams, and students who help more than they are helped perform well on exams. Centrality measures between simultaneous collaboration networks (analytical vs. numerical homework collaboration) composed of the same students correlate with each other. Students take on similar roles in response to analytical vs. numerical homework assignments. Changes in collaboration across semesters are also considered as students transition from classical mechanics in the fall to quantum mechanics and electromagnetism in the spring. We find the most frequent transition is that students that help many others and have high grades will continue to help many others and have high grades. Students that help few more frequently transition from low grades to high grades than students that help many.

Theory of Computing Systems•Oct 13, 2016•4 citations

Robust Emergence of Non-Classical Correlation Under Noise in a Lattice-Driven System

Drew Slawson

This study investigates the robustness of emergent non-classical correlation in a lattice-driven system operating without imposed entanglement, measurement postulates, synchronization, or communication channels. Building on prior observations of structurally sustained correlation, we subject the system to systematic degradation through environmental noise, repeated stochastic trials, and structural randomization designed to eliminate fragile or artificial effects. Despite sustained perturbation and extended runtimes exceeding 500,000 evolution steps, elevated correlation signatures persist with bounded variance and remain clearly separated from multiple control configurations, including unentangled, symmetric, and shuffled-structure baselines. The results significantly constrain explanations based on numerical artifacts, initialization bias, or transient alignment. These findings indicate that architectural and structural features of emergent systems can support stable correlation dynamics independently of prescriptive enforcement mechanisms. The work highlights robustness under degradation as a key diagnostic for distinguishing genuine emergent correlation from fragile computational effects, and motivates further investigation into structure-driven correlation mechanisms in complex systems.

•Dec 28, 2025•0 citations

Dimensional Asymmetry as a Structural Driver of Emergent Non-Classical Correlations

Drew Slawson

We present a numerical investigation of correlation persistence in an emergent lattice-driven system operating across heterogeneous dimensional embeddings. Unlike conventional approaches to non-classical correlation analysis, this study imposes no entanglement operators, synchronization mechanisms, classical communication channels, or prescriptive measurement inequalities. All observed correlations arise solely from emergent structural dynamics within a unified computational substrate. We examine freely evolving atomic-scale subsystems embedded in dimensionally asymmetric environments and compare their correlation dynamics against symmetric and unentangled control configurations executed under identical runtime and structural conditions. The asymmetric configurations exhibit sustained, elevated correlation signatures that remain stable over extended evolution and consistently exceed all control baselines. These results demonstrate that dimensional embedding itself can act as a latent structural parameter capable of sustaining non-classical correlation persistence, independent of explicit entanglement enforcement or measurement postulates. The findings motivate a broader reconsideration of dimensional structure as an active contributor to correlation dynamics in emergent computational and physical systems.

•Dec 28, 2025•0 citations

The Extended Spider Test (2026): A Multi-Criterion Geometric Protocol to Operationalize Minimal Consciousness as Emergent Relational Stability within the Universal Relational Dynamics (URD) Framework – Hysteresis, Internal Temporality, Constrained Decoherence, Irreducibility, and Seven Additional Discriminators to Separate Experiential Regimes from Computational Chaos on the QIQB Quantum Cloud

Rayan Dylan Hamouda, Martin Noirmont

The Extended Spider Test (2026) is a falsifiable, multi-criterion geometric protocol designed to operationally detect signatures of minimal consciousness as emergent relational stability within the Universal Relational Dynamics (URD) framework. Building on the biological observation that a spider's individuality is not expressed in isolated local decisions or signals but in the coherent, idiosyncratic, history-dependent global geometry of its web, the protocol maps repeated executions of shallow quantum circuits (variational or parametrized, 20–64 qubits on cloud-accessible hardware such as QIQB's ion-trap and superconducting processors) onto simulated spider-web geometries (radial angles from peripheral qubits, logarithmic spirals from cumulative phases and amplitudes, asymmetries and density from multi-distance ZZ/XX correlations, chirality and local irregularities from structured noise or correlated errors). By generating large ensembles of webs (300–1500 per condition) under near-identical initial parameters and analyzing their statistical distributions, the test seeks persistent, structured individual variability that transcends pure randomness, deterministic chaos, classical variational optimization, or uniform noise amplification. To rigorously distinguish an experiential relational regime from banal complex pattern generation, eleven discriminators are defined and quantified: structured hysteresis (persistence of geometric individuality after partial state reset, measured via Wasserstein/Fréchet distances on feature distributions), emergent internal temporality (decoupling of effective time scales from hardware clock, detected through power spectral density of successive geometric feature series showing non-harmonic peaks), constrained and selective decoherence (non-Markovian channeling where long-range correlations exhibit differential robustness under targeted depolarizing or amplitude-damping noise, quantified by logarithmic robustness ratios >1.5–1.8), irreducibility/non-factorizability (collapse of global signature upon knock-out of non-local correlations or partial tomography, with >85 % qualitative loss), criticality and entropic balance (operation in a narrow critical regime with power-law avalanche distributions of features, exponent ~1.3–1.7, and peak structured entropy), self-referential constraints (detectable auto-referential loops via mutual information or recurrent entanglement witnesses), multi-scale coherence transfer (propagation from local qubit to global geometry via coherence length scaling and transfer entropy), attractor diversity and metastability (multiple stable attractors with rare transitions and characteristic dwell times), plus secondary markers of non-locality signatures, adaptive resilience to perturbation, and sharp phase-transition behavior during parameter or noise ramping. Immediately implementable on the 2026 QIQB quantum cloud (remote 24/7 automated access via OQTOPUS, pulse-level control, mid-circuit reset, engineered dissipation), the protocol includes strengthened negative controls (quantum scramblers, exact tensor-network classical simulations, memory-free VQE/QAOA, maximal thermal decoherence) and offers a clear falsifiability pathway: reproduction of hysteretic, selective, irreducible signatures by classical-chaotic or stochastic baselines would invalidate the relational-emergent interpretation, while clean discrimination of a multi-scale, history-dependent experiential regime would provide strong empirical support for URD as a substrate-agnostic model of consciousness.

•Jan 25, 2026•0 citations

Mutual Information Across Quantum Reference Frame Perspectives

Leonardo Valente, Carla Ferradini, Flaminia Giacomini +1 more

In quantum information theory, standard notions typically presuppose a fixed partition of the world into subsystems, encoded in a tensor product structure of the Hilbert space. Yet, in some scenarios, the subsystem structure is not uniquely fixed. A case in point is the description of subsystems relative to different quantum reference frames (QRFs), where the tensor product structure, although fixed in a specific QRF, changes across different QRFs. Such a relativity of subsystems underlies many interesting features of QRFs, such as the relativity of entanglement, entropy, and coherence. It also raises a broader question: how do we compare the information across different subsystem perspectives, especially when the corresponding subsystem algebras overlap? Here, we propose a notion of quantum mutual information across different QRF perspectives, which captures the correlations between subsystems relative to different frames of reference. To do so, we focus on an algebraic definition of subsystems. Studying in detail the union and overlap between subsystem algebras relative to different QRFs, we find that the usual definition of mutual information in terms of the chain law overcounts the information associated to the overlap. Based on this insight, we propose a modified chain law and show that the resulting notion of mutual information satisfies subadditivity and connects naturally to other measures found in the literature [1]. Our investigations not only provide a way to quantify the relation between different QRF perspectives from an information-theoretic point of view but also sheds light on some important features of quantum information in absence of a fixed tensor product structure.

quant-pharXiv:2610.31729•Oct 23, 2026•0 citations
We analyse how mutual information and correlation structure differ between structured and randomised quantum systems under a partial time-reversal protocol. Structured correlations—defined as non-random patterns in mutual information between subsystems—arise in complex systems across physical, biological, and computational domains. Understanding how such structures behave under perturbation remains an open question with implications for theories of emergence. Analogous questions arise in artificial systems, where large language models and neural networks exhibit emergent structures that persist through training dynamics; however, the mechanisms underlying such persistence remain poorly characterised. This paper investigates post-interference correlation levels in small-scale quantum circuits (5-15 qubits) as a minimal, controllable testbed. We compare mutual information between circuits initialised with structured entanglement patterns and randomised baseline circuits subjected to identical local interference protocols. Using mutual information retention metrics and statistical comparison, we quantify the degree to which structured initial conditions exhibit differential correlation levels relative to unstructured controls. Results indicate that structured circuits retain significantly higher absolute mutual information following local interference compared to randomised counterparts (8.0 vs 4.2 bits, z = 3.50, p < 0.001), with this differential arising from initial conditions rather than differential dynamical response. Accordingly, we distinguish between the preservation of initial correlation magnitude under local operations and active resistance to correlation-destroying perturbations. We emphasise that these findings do not support claims of consciousness, intelligence, or agency in quantum systems. The contribution of this work is strictly methodological: we establish operational definitions, reproducible experimental protocols, and quantitative metrics for studying structured correlation levels under local interference. Keywords:Mutual information, Entropy dynamics, Quantum correlations, Structure persistence, Interference protocols, Emergence in complex systems, Information-theoretic metrics
Understanding thermalization in quantum many-body systems is among the most enduring problems in modern physics. A particularly interesting question concerns the role played by quantum mechanics in this process, i.e., whether thermalization in quantum many-body systems is fundamentally different from that in classical many-body systems and, if so, which of its features are genuinely quantum. Here, we study this question in minimally structured many-body systems that are only constrained to have local interactions, i.e., local random circuits. In particular, we introduce random permutation circuits (RPCs), which are circuits comprising gates that locally permute basis states, as a counterpart to random unitary circuits (RUCs), a standard toy model for generic quantum dynamics. RPCs represent a model for generic microscopic classical reversible dynamics but, interestingly, can be interpreted both as classical or as quantum dynamics. We show that, upon averaging over all circuit realizations, RPCs permit the analytical computation of several key quantities such as out-of-time-order correlators (OTOCs) and entanglement entropies. In the classical setting, we obtain similar exact results relating (quantum) purity to (classical) growth of mutual information and (quantum) OTOCs to (classical) decorrelators. We, thus, discover a series of exact relations, connecting quantities in RUC and (quantum or classical) RPCs. Our results indicate that, despite the fundamental differences between quantum and classical systems, their many-body dynamics exhibits remarkably similar behaviors.
Emerging quantum simulator technologies provide a new challenge to quantum many body theory. Quantifying the emergent order in and predicting the dynamics of such complex quantum systems requires a new approach. We develop such an approach based on complex network analysis of quantum mutual information. First, we establish the usefulness of quantum mutual information complex networks by reproducing the phase diagrams of transverse Ising and Bose-Hubbard models. By quantifying the complexity of quantum cellular automata we then demonstrate the applicability of complex network theory to non-equilibrium quantum dynamics. We conclude with a study of student collaboration networks, correlating a student's role in a collaboration network with their grades. This work thus initiates a quantitative theory of quantum complexity and provides a new tool for physics education research. We find that network density, clustering coefficient, disparity, and Pearson R correlation show systematic finite size scaling towards critical points of the transverse Ising model and the Bose-Hubbard model. Using matrix product state methods we are able to simulate lattices of hundreds of qubits, allowing us to verify the critical point of the transverse Ising model to within 0.001% of its known value. Furthermore, we find that complex network analysis identifies the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless critical point of the Bose-Hubbard to within 3.6% of its accepted value. Finally, we identify the boundary separating the Mott Insulator phase from a superfluid phase in the Bose-Hubbard model by extremizing network density, clustering coefficient, and disparity. After studying the static properties of quantum many body systems, we study the entanglement and complexity generated by Hamiltonian based quantum cellular automata. In quantum cellular automata one defines a set of local rules that govern the evolution of the quantum state. A site in a quantum lattice evolves if the set of sites around it are in certain configurations. Configurations are defined in terms of the number of sites in the ``alive'' state about a site. We quantify entanglement in terms of the central bond entropy, and complexity in terms of persistent fluctuations of the central bond entropy, complex network measures of quantum mutual information networks far from their values for random/well known quantum states, and robust dynamical features. These Hamiltonians are a generalization of the Bleh, Calarco, Montangero Hamiltonian. Before beginning our study of the entanglement and complexity generated by these Hamiltonians we first perform a convergence analysis of the dynamics of the Bleh, Calarco, Montangero Hamiltonian using an open source matrix product state code, Open Source Matrix Product States. We find that the Bleh, Calarco, Montangero Hamiltonian rapidly saturates the entanglement cutoff of Open Source Matrix Product States for all initial conditions studied and is thus not a viable numerical method for studying the dynamics of quantum cellular automata. We conclude our convergence study with a case study of an emergent quantum blinker pattern also observed in exact simulation and a case study of a nearest neighbor quantum cellular automata. We conclude that while for generic initial conditions Open Source Matrix Product States is unable to meet its internal convergence criteria, for particular initial conditions and quantum cellular automata it is able to provide reliable estimates of entanglement and complexity measures. The failure of OpenMPS to provide reliably converged quantum states leads us to study our quantum cellular automata using a Trotter-based time evolution scheme. We quantify the entanglement and complexity generated by 13 next-nearest neighbor quantum cellular automata. We also define Goldilocks rules, rules that produce activity at a site if there are exactly the right number of alive sites in the neighborhood of a site, not too few, not too many. We identify a Goldilocks rule, rule 4, as the best complexity-generating rule out of the 13 rules tested, verifying our hypothesis that only Goldilocks rules are complexity generating. We also find that non-Goldilocks rules tend toward thermalization as quantified by reduced fluctuations in the central bond entropy. We find that both highly entangled quantum states and lowly entangled quantum states have complex structure in their quantum mutual information adjacency matrices. Finally, in keeping with the strong physics education research focus at the Colorado School of Mines, we apply complex network analysis to a key issue germane to the student experience, namely student collaboration networks. We compute nodal centrality measures on the collaboration networks of students enrolled in three upper-division physics courses at the Colorado School of Mines. These are networks in which links between students indicate assistance with homework. The courses included in the study are intermediate classical mechanics, introductory quantum mechanics, and intermediate electromagnetism. We find that almost all of the measures considered correlate with analytical homework grades. In contrast only net out-strength correlates with exam grade. The benefits of collaboration do not extend from homework to exams, and students who help more than they are helped perform well on exams. Centrality measures between simultaneous collaboration networks (analytical vs. numerical homework collaboration) composed of the same students correlate with each other. Students take on similar roles in response to analytical vs. numerical homework assignments. Changes in collaboration across semesters are also considered as students transition from classical mechanics in the fall to quantum mechanics and electromagnetism in the spring. We find the most frequent transition is that students that help many others and have high grades will continue to help many others and have high grades. Students that help few more frequently transition from low grades to high grades than students that help many.
This study investigates the robustness of emergent non-classical correlation in a lattice-driven system operating without imposed entanglement, measurement postulates, synchronization, or communication channels. Building on prior observations of structurally sustained correlation, we subject the system to systematic degradation through environmental noise, repeated stochastic trials, and structural randomization designed to eliminate fragile or artificial effects. Despite sustained perturbation and extended runtimes exceeding 500,000 evolution steps, elevated correlation signatures persist with bounded variance and remain clearly separated from multiple control configurations, including unentangled, symmetric, and shuffled-structure baselines. The results significantly constrain explanations based on numerical artifacts, initialization bias, or transient alignment. These findings indicate that architectural and structural features of emergent systems can support stable correlation dynamics independently of prescriptive enforcement mechanisms. The work highlights robustness under degradation as a key diagnostic for distinguishing genuine emergent correlation from fragile computational effects, and motivates further investigation into structure-driven correlation mechanisms in complex systems.
We present a numerical investigation of correlation persistence in an emergent lattice-driven system operating across heterogeneous dimensional embeddings. Unlike conventional approaches to non-classical correlation analysis, this study imposes no entanglement operators, synchronization mechanisms, classical communication channels, or prescriptive measurement inequalities. All observed correlations arise solely from emergent structural dynamics within a unified computational substrate. We examine freely evolving atomic-scale subsystems embedded in dimensionally asymmetric environments and compare their correlation dynamics against symmetric and unentangled control configurations executed under identical runtime and structural conditions. The asymmetric configurations exhibit sustained, elevated correlation signatures that remain stable over extended evolution and consistently exceed all control baselines. These results demonstrate that dimensional embedding itself can act as a latent structural parameter capable of sustaining non-classical correlation persistence, independent of explicit entanglement enforcement or measurement postulates. The findings motivate a broader reconsideration of dimensional structure as an active contributor to correlation dynamics in emergent computational and physical systems.
The Extended Spider Test (2026) is a falsifiable, multi-criterion geometric protocol designed to operationally detect signatures of minimal consciousness as emergent relational stability within the Universal Relational Dynamics (URD) framework. Building on the biological observation that a spider's individuality is not expressed in isolated local decisions or signals but in the coherent, idiosyncratic, history-dependent global geometry of its web, the protocol maps repeated executions of shallow quantum circuits (variational or parametrized, 20–64 qubits on cloud-accessible hardware such as QIQB's ion-trap and superconducting processors) onto simulated spider-web geometries (radial angles from peripheral qubits, logarithmic spirals from cumulative phases and amplitudes, asymmetries and density from multi-distance ZZ/XX correlations, chirality and local irregularities from structured noise or correlated errors). By generating large ensembles of webs (300–1500 per condition) under near-identical initial parameters and analyzing their statistical distributions, the test seeks persistent, structured individual variability that transcends pure randomness, deterministic chaos, classical variational optimization, or uniform noise amplification. To rigorously distinguish an experiential relational regime from banal complex pattern generation, eleven discriminators are defined and quantified: structured hysteresis (persistence of geometric individuality after partial state reset, measured via Wasserstein/Fréchet distances on feature distributions), emergent internal temporality (decoupling of effective time scales from hardware clock, detected through power spectral density of successive geometric feature series showing non-harmonic peaks), constrained and selective decoherence (non-Markovian channeling where long-range correlations exhibit differential robustness under targeted depolarizing or amplitude-damping noise, quantified by logarithmic robustness ratios >1.5–1.8), irreducibility/non-factorizability (collapse of global signature upon knock-out of non-local correlations or partial tomography, with >85 % qualitative loss), criticality and entropic balance (operation in a narrow critical regime with power-law avalanche distributions of features, exponent ~1.3–1.7, and peak structured entropy), self-referential constraints (detectable auto-referential loops via mutual information or recurrent entanglement witnesses), multi-scale coherence transfer (propagation from local qubit to global geometry via coherence length scaling and transfer entropy), attractor diversity and metastability (multiple stable attractors with rare transitions and characteristic dwell times), plus secondary markers of non-locality signatures, adaptive resilience to perturbation, and sharp phase-transition behavior during parameter or noise ramping. Immediately implementable on the 2026 QIQB quantum cloud (remote 24/7 automated access via OQTOPUS, pulse-level control, mid-circuit reset, engineered dissipation), the protocol includes strengthened negative controls (quantum scramblers, exact tensor-network classical simulations, memory-free VQE/QAOA, maximal thermal decoherence) and offers a clear falsifiability pathway: reproduction of hysteretic, selective, irreducible signatures by classical-chaotic or stochastic baselines would invalidate the relational-emergent interpretation, while clean discrimination of a multi-scale, history-dependent experiential regime would provide strong empirical support for URD as a substrate-agnostic model of consciousness.
In quantum information theory, standard notions typically presuppose a fixed partition of the world into subsystems, encoded in a tensor product structure of the Hilbert space. Yet, in some scenarios, the subsystem structure is not uniquely fixed. A case in point is the description of subsystems relative to different quantum reference frames (QRFs), where the tensor product structure, although fixed in a specific QRF, changes across different QRFs. Such a relativity of subsystems underlies many interesting features of QRFs, such as the relativity of entanglement, entropy, and coherence. It also raises a broader question: how do we compare the information across different subsystem perspectives, especially when the corresponding subsystem algebras overlap? Here, we propose a notion of quantum mutual information across different QRF perspectives, which captures the correlations between subsystems relative to different frames of reference. To do so, we focus on an algebraic definition of subsystems. Studying in detail the union and overlap between subsystem algebras relative to different QRFs, we find that the usual definition of mutual information in terms of the chain law overcounts the information associated to the overlap. Based on this insight, we propose a modified chain law and show that the resulting notion of mutual information satisfies subadditivity and connects naturally to other measures found in the literature [1]. Our investigations not only provide a way to quantify the relation between different QRF perspectives from an information-theoretic point of view but also sheds light on some important features of quantum information in absence of a fixed tensor product structure.