Porosity of the Frontier Between Classical and Quantum Mechanics
P. Mélinon
Abstract
Despite its status as a core part of contemporary physics, there is no consensus among physicists on the question of what, if anything, the success of quantum theory is telling us about the physical world. This gives rise to the collection of debates and discussions known as "the interpretation of quantum mechanics". Describing quantum mechanics is complicated by there being so many interpretations of it. In text books, classical mechanics is an approximation of the quantum mechanics when ℏ → 0. In a first part, we recall the fundamental differences between the classical mechanics in different formalisms: Newtonian, Lagrangian and Hamiltonian (Jacobi). A second part is dedicated to the deep similarities and differences between classical and quantum mechanics. The third part deals with the misunderstanding between scientific communities about the meaning ℏ → 0. The last part deals with the porous frontier between classical and quantum physics to the light of the algebraic topology illustrated by two major theorems: Borsuk Ulam and Non squeezing Gromov's theorem.