Technical paper abstract: Significant open issues remain in conventional quantum theory that may need novel ideas to resolve. The usual model of a quantum wave function is an epistemic one in which the wave function encodes probabilities of future measurement outcomes. This model often falls short of adequately explaining certain basics, like the double slit experiment. We present here a new approach to modeling the wave function as a physical object, supported by analogies to the revolutionary theory of information conceived by Claude Shannon in the 1940’s. Our theory, we term Actualation Theory (AT), where actualation is a physical analog to information, provides a foundation for development of the physical, or ontic, wave function. We also provide some extension to Shannon Theory (ST) in developing comprehensive analogies to Actualation Theory (AT) in support of the physical wave function model.This paper does not represent a declaration that the concepts are valid and should be preferred, instead it is a proposal for consideration and further development.
Technical paper abstract: Significant open issues remain in conventional quantum theory that may need novel ideas to resolve. The usual model of a quantum wave function is an epistemic one in which the wave function encodes probabilities of future measurement outcomes. This model often falls short of adequately explaining certain basics, like the double slit experiment. We present here a new approach to modeling the wave function as a physical object, supported by analogies to the revolutionary theory of information conceived by Claude Shannon in the 1940’s. Our theory, we term Actualation Theory (AT), where actualation is a physical analog to information, provides a foundation for development of the physical, or ontic, wave function. We also provide some extension to Shannon Theory (ST) in developing comprehensive analogies to Actualation Theory (AT) in support of the physical wave function model.This paper does not represent a declaration that the concepts are valid and should be preferred, instead it is a proposal for consideration and further development.
Schroedinger's wave function shows many aspects of a state of incomplete knowledge or information ("bit"): (1) it is usually defined on a space of classical configurations, (2) its generic entanglement is, therefore, analogous to statistical correlations, and (3) it determines probabilities of measurement outcomes. Nonetheless, quantum superpositions (such as represented by a wave function) define individual physical states ("it"). This conceptual dilemma may have its origin in the conventional operational foundation of physical concepts, successful in classical physics, but inappropriate in quantum theory because of the existence of mutually exclusive operations (used for the definition of concepts). In contrast, a hypothetical realism, based on concepts that are justified only by their universal and consistent applicability, favors the wave function as a description of (thus nonlocal) physical reality. The (conceptually local) classical world then appears as an illusion, facilitated by the phenomenon of decoherence, which is consistently explained by the very entanglement that must dynamically arise in a universal wave function.
Preprint paper abstract: We develop the concept of a physical value primitive — the most fundamental mathematical representation of a single instance of any physical value — and argue that the complex Gaussian wave packet uniquely satisfies all physical constraints on such a primitive. We show that this primitive is forced by five independent lines of reasoning: physical realizability constraints, Fourier self-duality, minimum uncertainty saturation, maximum entropy under finite mean and variance, and basis-independence. We introduce the Shannon wave function as a novel extension of Shannon information theory to complex amplitudes, showing that it naturally assumes the form of a complex Gaussian wave packet with linear phase variation across symbols, by reasoning directly analogous to the emergence of a Gaussian amplitude spectrum in laser physics. We distinguish indefiniteness — an ontic property of the primitive — from uncertainty — an epistemic property of an observer — and argue that this distinction resolves foundational paradoxes in quantum mechanics, including the Bell test non-locality conclusion and the wave-particle duality of the double slit experiment. We argue that Shannon’s mathematical framework, extended by the Shannon wave function, has broader foundational application than currently acknowledged, providing a unified theory of indefiniteness resolution across physics and information theory.
The wave function gives probabilities, but is it a real physical quantity, as in the ontic interpretation of quantum mechanics, or just a measure of human belief about a physical system, as in an epistemic interpretation? These questions are introduced by treating Schrödinger’s cat and Wigner’s friend. An important question is whether quantum mechanics applies to macroscopic objects, for example, cats. SQUID experiments have been performed that see quantum interference in very large objects, whereas with most macroscopic objects quantum interference disappears because of decoherence. Various views of the meaning of quantum mechanics are discussed: the Copenhagen interpretation, continuous spontaneous localization, Everett’s many-worlds interpretation, Bohm’s hidden-variable model, and quantum Bayesianism. The latter holds that the wave function represents one’s best belief about the state of a quantum system, rather than an actual physical property. This leads to discussions of recent theories and experiments explicitly designed to test wave function reality.
The ontological status of the quantum wavefunction remains one of the most debated questions in quantum theory. While epistemic interpretations regard the wavefunction as a reflection of our knowledge or beliefs, ontic interpretations treat it as a real physical object. In this paper, we argue that epistemic approaches struggle to explain the universality and precision of the uncertainty principle, a core feature of quantum mechanics. By contrast, treating the wave-function as ontic allows a consistent and natural derivation of quantum uncertainty from the mathematical structure of Hilbert space. We examine key interpretations on both sides and highlight why the epistemic view falls short in addressing constraints that appear to be intrinsic to nature.
In these first few chapters, our aim is to establish a firm grounding so that we can address some fundamental questions regarding information transmission over quantum channels. This area of study has become known as “quantum Shannon theory” in the broader quantum information community, in order to distinguish this topic from other areas of study in quantum information science. In this text, we will use the terms “quantum Shannon theory” and “quantum information theory” somewhat interchangeably. We will begin by briefly overviewing several fundamental aspects of the quantum theory. Our study of the quantum theory, in this chapter and future ones, will be at an abstract level, without giving preference to any particular physical system such as a spin-1/2 particle or a photon. This approach will be more beneficial for the purposes of our study, but, here and there, we will make some reference to actual physical systems to ground us in reality.
In these first few chapters, our aim is to establish a firm grounding so that we can address some fundamental questions regarding information transmission over quantum channels. This area of study has become known as “quantum Shannon theory” in the broader quantum information community, in order to distinguish this topic from other areas of study in quantum information science. In this text, we will use the terms “quantum Shannon theory” and “quantum information theory” somewhat interchangeably. We will begin by briefly overviewing several fundamental aspects of the quantum theory. Our study of the quantum theory, in this chapter and future ones, will be at an abstract level, without giving preference to any particular physical system such as a spin-1/2 particle or a photon. This approach will be more beneficial for the purposes of our study, but, here and there, we will make some reference to actual physical systems to ground us in reality.