Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

On the impossibility of the physical implementation of quantum computing: A proof of the impossibility of revising the superposition principle and the eigenvalue measurement principle for controlling the superposition state of a single qubit

Bowen Liu

Published Jan 1, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.13140/rg.2.2.23152.52484

Related papers

Introduction to Quantum Computing

J. Vinoj, R. Swathika, Shanmugam Gavaskar +1 more

Quantum computing is poised to revolutionize the world as the next big technological advancement. Combining principles from quantum physics, computer science, and information theory, it overcomes the complexities that classical computers struggle with and transcends their limitations. Unlike classical computers, which follow classical physics, quantum computers are based on the principles of quantum mechanics, enabling them to exploit quantum phenomena. Quantum entanglement and quantum superposition are key quantum mechanical principles used in this technology. Quantum computers utilize these principles to perform complex tasks that classical computers cannot handle. The hardware components of quantum computers consist of the quantum data plane, control and measurement plane, control processor plane, and host processor. The quantum data plane houses physical qubits and related systems, along with support circuits for measuring the qubit's state and executing gate operations on them for gate-based systems. The control and measurement plane converts digital signals from the control processor into analog control signals required to operate the qubits in the quantum data plane. The control processor plane, on the other hand, translates compiled code into commands for the control and measurement layer. One of the groundbreaking features of quantum computers is their ability to operate on qubits, allowing information to be processed simultaneously as both 1s and 0s, represented by [00, 01, 11, 10]. This is achieved through the implementation of quantum mechanical principles, namely, superposition and entanglement. The quantum superposition principle enables a qubit to exist in multiple states simultaneously, setting it apart from classical bits. Moreover, the quantum entanglement property causes the state of one entangled qubit to instantly influence the state of its paired qubit, significantly accelerating the processing speed of quantum computers.

Wiley eBooks•Mar 7, 2025•0 citations

On the state of superposition and the parallel or not parallel nature of quantum computing: a controversy raising view point

M. Nicolaidis

•Jun 16, 2008•1 citation

On The Fundamental Flaws of Qubit Concept for General-Purpose Quantum Computing

Journals Invention

•Jan 28, 2015•0 citations

Proof-of-Principle Implementation of Quantum Key Distribution in an Indefinite Causal Order

Yann Valibouse, Martí Cladera-Rosselló, Michael Antesberger +6 more

In quantum physics, the order in which different operations occur can be placed in superposition. The resulting processes have an indefinite causal order, which is of fundamental interest and can be viewed as a novel quantum resource enabling new protocols. Here, we report an experimental proof-of-principle implementation of one such protocol, where we perform BB84-like quantum cryptography by placing \AB's measurement-and-preparation operations in a photonic quantum SWITCH. By embedding \AB\ within the quantum SWITCH, the protocol achieves an average eavesdropper detection probability of $0.15 \pm 0.02$ per shared qubit, with eavesdropper detection performed through measurements of the control qubit rather than comparing the key. Unlike standard BB84 and related schemes, which detect eavesdropping by publicly revealing and discarding a fraction of the raw key, our approach requires no disclosure of key material: every retained qubit can, in principle, be tested for eavesdropping while remaining available for key generation. Although the present implementation does not yet constitute a secure quantum key distribution protocol, owing to post-selection required for measurements within the quantum SWITCH, it provides a proof of principle that indefinite causal order can be exploited to detect eavesdropping without sacrificing key bits.

quant-pharXiv:2608.13561•Entropy•Aug 14, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Computers Require Multi-Universe Operation — Proof by Andrew Stewart Caldin — E8 Intelligence Research

Andrew Stewart Caldin

A quantum computer cannot function within a single universe. The proof emerges from a fundamental constraint: quantum superposition collapse creates irreversible information loss that makes quantum computation logically impossible within any single spacetime manifold. THE PROOF Premise 1 — Information Conservation Paradox In any single universe U, information must be conserved (Landauer's principle). Quantum computation requires superposition states, measurement-induced collapse, and computational paths through multiple probability amplitudes simultaneously. The contradiction: when the state collapses, the information in the unused coefficient is irreversibly destroyed within U. This violates information conservation. Premise 2 — Computational Completeness Requirement For quantum algorithms (Shor's, Grover's) to achieve exponential speedup, they must explore multiple computational paths simultaneously, maintain coherent superposition across all paths, and collapse only after explori Author: Andrew Stewart Caldin, Independent Researcher, UK. Part of the E8 Intelligence Research series. Platform: e8intelligence.com

•May 28, 2026•0 citations

On the State of Superposition and the Parallel or not Parallel Nature of Quantum Computing: a controversy raising point of view

M. Nicolaidis

•Apr 4, 2011•0 citations
Quantum computing is poised to revolutionize the world as the next big technological advancement. Combining principles from quantum physics, computer science, and information theory, it overcomes the complexities that classical computers struggle with and transcends their limitations. Unlike classical computers, which follow classical physics, quantum computers are based on the principles of quantum mechanics, enabling them to exploit quantum phenomena. Quantum entanglement and quantum superposition are key quantum mechanical principles used in this technology. Quantum computers utilize these principles to perform complex tasks that classical computers cannot handle. The hardware components of quantum computers consist of the quantum data plane, control and measurement plane, control processor plane, and host processor. The quantum data plane houses physical qubits and related systems, along with support circuits for measuring the qubit's state and executing gate operations on them for gate-based systems. The control and measurement plane converts digital signals from the control processor into analog control signals required to operate the qubits in the quantum data plane. The control processor plane, on the other hand, translates compiled code into commands for the control and measurement layer. One of the groundbreaking features of quantum computers is their ability to operate on qubits, allowing information to be processed simultaneously as both 1s and 0s, represented by [00, 01, 11, 10]. This is achieved through the implementation of quantum mechanical principles, namely, superposition and entanglement. The quantum superposition principle enables a qubit to exist in multiple states simultaneously, setting it apart from classical bits. Moreover, the quantum entanglement property causes the state of one entangled qubit to instantly influence the state of its paired qubit, significantly accelerating the processing speed of quantum computers.
In quantum physics, the order in which different operations occur can be placed in superposition. The resulting processes have an indefinite causal order, which is of fundamental interest and can be viewed as a novel quantum resource enabling new protocols. Here, we report an experimental proof-of-principle implementation of one such protocol, where we perform BB84-like quantum cryptography by placing \AB's measurement-and-preparation operations in a photonic quantum SWITCH. By embedding \AB\ within the quantum SWITCH, the protocol achieves an average eavesdropper detection probability of 0.15±0.020.15 \pm 0.020.15±0.02 per shared qubit, with eavesdropper detection performed through measurements of the control qubit rather than comparing the key. Unlike standard BB84 and related schemes, which detect eavesdropping by publicly revealing and discarding a fraction of the raw key, our approach requires no disclosure of key material: every retained qubit can, in principle, be tested for eavesdropping while remaining available for key generation. Although the present implementation does not yet constitute a secure quantum key distribution protocol, owing to post-selection required for measurements within the quantum SWITCH, it provides a proof of principle that indefinite causal order can be exploited to detect eavesdropping without sacrificing key bits.
A quantum computer cannot function within a single universe. The proof emerges from a fundamental constraint: quantum superposition collapse creates irreversible information loss that makes quantum computation logically impossible within any single spacetime manifold. THE PROOF Premise 1 — Information Conservation Paradox In any single universe U, information must be conserved (Landauer's principle). Quantum computation requires superposition states, measurement-induced collapse, and computational paths through multiple probability amplitudes simultaneously. The contradiction: when the state collapses, the information in the unused coefficient is irreversibly destroyed within U. This violates information conservation. Premise 2 — Computational Completeness Requirement For quantum algorithms (Shor's, Grover's) to achieve exponential speedup, they must explore multiple computational paths simultaneously, maintain coherent superposition across all paths, and collapse only after explori Author: Andrew Stewart Caldin, Independent Researcher, UK. Part of the E8 Intelligence Research series. Platform: e8intelligence.com