In this dissertation we investigate superconductivity in strongly correlated systems, with a specific focus on copper oxides, known as cuprates. These materials exhibit a variety of emerging phases as we vary parameters such as temperature, doping, and pressure. In addition to the superconducting phase, other phases, such as the pseudogap, remain poorly understood. The pseudogap phase is characterized by a suppression of spectral weight in certain directions in momentum space. Understanding this phase is fundamental to understanding superconductivity, as it is believed that there are signatures of the superconducting phase in the pseudogap phase. The Hubbard model is used to describe strongly correlated systems, as it well describes the competition between the kinetic energy and the Coulomb interaction of electrons. It is believed that much can be learned about cuprates considering the Hubbard model in two spatial dimensions, corresponding to the planes of copper and oxygen, in the presence of doping, arising from the other atoms. However, the model does not have an exact solution in two dimensions, requiring the use of a numerical method for its resolution. In previous work by the group, the model was solved numerically without considering superconductivity via extensions of Dynamical Mean Field Theory (DMFT). This technique maps the Hubbard model onto the Anderson impurity problem, simplifying the resolution. The results obtained revealed two distinct metallic phases, conventional and pseudogap, as the system doping varied. The objective of this dissertation is to verify whether the different metallic phases mentioned above give rise to different superconducting phases. For this, an electron pair formation term was added to the Hamiltonian and new numerical DMFT results were obtained. These results are difficult to understand; to analyze them, we use a phenomenological model that describes electron dynamics at low energies. We built a code that simultaneously adjusts the DMFT curves for the real and imaginary parts of the normal and anomalous self-energies to the phenomenological model for each doping value, allowing the analysis of the model parameters starting from the different metallic regions. Our preliminary results show fluctuations in these parameters when we vary the doping, suggesting that it would be desirable to obtain more accurate DMFT results, which is in progress, so that new adjustments to the phenomenological model can be made.
In this dissertation we investigate superconductivity in strongly correlated systems, with a specific focus on copper oxides, known as cuprates. These materials exhibit a variety of emerging phases as we vary parameters such as temperature, doping, and pressure. In addition to the superconducting phase, other phases, such as the pseudogap, remain poorly understood. The pseudogap phase is characterized by a suppression of spectral weight in certain directions in momentum space. Understanding this phase is fundamental to understanding superconductivity, as it is believed that there are signatures of the superconducting phase in the pseudogap phase. The Hubbard model is used to describe strongly correlated systems, as it well describes the competition between the kinetic energy and the Coulomb interaction of electrons. It is believed that much can be learned about cuprates considering the Hubbard model in two spatial dimensions, corresponding to the planes of copper and oxygen, in the presence of doping, arising from the other atoms. However, the model does not have an exact solution in two dimensions, requiring the use of a numerical method for its resolution. In previous work by the group, the model was solved numerically without considering superconductivity via extensions of Dynamical Mean Field Theory (DMFT). This technique maps the Hubbard model onto the Anderson impurity problem, simplifying the resolution. The results obtained revealed two distinct metallic phases, conventional and pseudogap, as the system doping varied. The objective of this dissertation is to verify whether the different metallic phases mentioned above give rise to different superconducting phases. For this, an electron pair formation term was added to the Hamiltonian and new numerical DMFT results were obtained. These results are difficult to understand; to analyze them, we use a phenomenological model that describes electron dynamics at low energies. We built a code that simultaneously adjusts the DMFT curves for the real and imaginary parts of the normal and anomalous self-energies to the phenomenological model for each doping value, allowing the analysis of the model parameters starting from the different metallic regions. Our preliminary results show fluctuations in these parameters when we vary the doping, suggesting that it would be desirable to obtain more accurate DMFT results, which is in progress, so that new adjustments to the phenomenological model can be made.
It has been more than two decades since the copper-oxide high temperature superconductors were discovered. However, building a satisfactory theoretical framework to study these compounds still remains one of the major challenges in condensed matter physics. In addition to the mechanism of superconductivity, understanding the properties of the normal state is a major puzzle in itself. As these materials are doped Mott insulators, the interaction between electrons is particularly strong. The strong electron correlations are responsible for the breakdown of Fermi-liquid behavior in the normal state. A variety of experimental probes reveal anomalous features in these materials. Such anomalies are reflected in the photoemission spectra as well as transport coefficients such as resistivity, optical conductivity, Hall coefficient, thermoelectric power etc. The objective of this dissertation is to understand the anomalous features as universal features of doped Mott insulators arising entirely as a consequence of strong electron correlations, using the two-dimensional square lattice Hubbard model as the model Hamiltonian. This dissertation is organized into eight chapters. Chapter 1 is an introductory chapter that discusses some key issues. A brief introduction to the superconducting cuprates and their anomalous physical properties is given. Also included is an outline on Mott insulators and the concept of Mottness. Chapter 2 contains a discussion on Cluster Dynamical Mean Field Theory (CDMFT), the principal numerical technique to be implemented in this dissertation. Chapter 3 describes the exact low-energy theory of doped Mott insulators, which largely provides a theoretical framework to this dissertation. In Chapter 4, we compute the spectral function of the two-dimensional Hubbard model using CDMFT and study the origin of the kink feature observed in the electron dispersion measured by ARPES (Angle Resolved Photoemission Spectroscopy). In Chapter 5, the origin of the mid-IR band seen in optics experiments is studied. In Chapter 6, we study the universal sign change of the thermopower in the vicinity of optimal doping in the cuprates. Chapter 7 uses experimental data from Hall measurements to establish a connection between the pseudogap state and the charge-2e boson which emerges naturally in the exact low-energy theory of Mott systems. Chapter 8 is the concluding chapter which attempts to present all of our findings within the context of the central unifying theme of Mottness.
Correlated electron systems exhibit a variety of intriguing emergent phenomena, including Mott physics, pseudogap behavior, and unconventional superconductivity. One of the most widely used numerical approaches for investigating these systems is dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT). This dissertation addresses two related problems: how to develop better quantum impurity solvers for DMFT and how to use DMFT results to gain a better understanding of correlated electron systems. The first part of this dissertation develops numerical methods for solving quantum impurity problems, which constitute the central computational task in DMFT calculations. In Chap. 4, we develop a method that combines a tensor-train numerical integration scheme with the inchworm hybridization expansion for quantum impurity problems. Benchmarks on spinless, single-orbital, and multi-orbital impurity models demonstrate the convergence of the Green’s functions to exact or reference results and identify the regimes in which tensor-train compression of Feynman diagrams and the inchworm expansion itself are effective. In Chap. 5, we introduce the concept of counterterms within the hybridization expansion and apply it to a bare hybridization expansion solver that relies on a sum-of-exponentials integration technique. Tests on spinless, multi-orbital, and realistic embedding impurity problems show that counterterms can significantly reduce the required perturbative order and improve the efficiency of hybridization-expansion calculations. The second part of this dissertation applies the cluster extension of DMFT to the single-band Hubbard model. In Chap. 6, we introduce a fluctuation decomposition for the self-energy that eliminates the Fierz ambiguity encountered in conventional fluctuation diagnostics of the Hubbard model. The resulting analysis shows that spin fluctuations make an important contribution to the pseudogap self-energy, while multi-boson contributions are also necessary for a complete description. In Chap. 7, we analyze the spin-fermion coupling and its role in d-wave pairing. Our calculations show that, for antinodal fermions in the pseudogap regime, their coupling to antiferromagnetic spin fluctuations is strongly enhanced relative to the non-interacting limit. A modified Bethe–Salpeter equation analysis further shows that this enhanced spin–fermion coupling boosts the spin-fluctuation-induced contribution to the d-wave pairing susceptibility.
The cuprates, known to superconduct at exceptionally high temperatures when they are doped with holes, all descend from parent compounds that are standard Mott insulators.Because conductivity in these materials is dominated by transport within the copper-oxide planes, we focus our attention on the electronic structure of a single copper-oxide plane.These are well-described at low temperatures by the 2d Hubbard model, which, over the past sixty years, has been largely immune to analytic treatment in the physically relevant parameter regime.A simplification of the 2d Hubbard model is therefore in order, if we are to understand the microscopic basis for hightemperature superconductivity in the cuprates.While phase transitions around the Mott insulator lack a symmetry-based description, their phases are characterized by the spectral features associated with Mottness.These include a separation of spectral weight into upper and lower Hubbard bands, a Luttinger surface of zeros in the single-electron propagator, and spectral weight transfer from high to low energies.In this thesis, we turn from 2d Hubbard to the Hatsugai-Kohmoto (HK) model, which retains the features of Mottness while providing analytic traction.For instance, we can calculate all important physical observables as well as the finite-and zero-temperature state.In chapter 5, we examine entanglement and entropy across the interaction-driven metal-insulator transition in the HK model, finding features that distinguish the HK metal from Fermi liquid-like band metals.In chapter 6, we find that the HK metal is unstable to superconductivity and proceed to study a mean field theory of this superconducting phase.This superconductor displays a number of features found in the cuprates.These include Bogoliubov-like electronic excitations that descend from the HK metal and the appearance of a color change (i.e. the transfer of spectral weight from high to low energies brought about by the onset of superconductivity).Overall we find that this simple Hamiltonian can model coarse spectral features of the Mott insulating, metallic, and superconducting phases of the underdoped cuprates.Its simplicity provides a clear view of the microscopics that emerge as this doped Mott system and its superconducting instability.I am here and happily defended thanks to my incredible parents Stephen and Lai Wah, my goated brother John, my loving partner Amber, and my dear friends Dima, Phil, and Tom.It's been easy to pour myself into this work with their unwavering support, and it's been a treat to do it with their company.Philip Phillips took me into his group and introduced me to the cuprate problem.He led me across corners of condensed matter physics to piece together the faces of strongly-correlated electrons described in this text.He showed me how to move boldly in research, and how to present my ideas simply and clearly.I'm grateful for the lightness he brought to difficult conversations about funding or technical obstructions to research.I'm grateful as well for the friends and collaborators I found in his group.Gabriele showed me how to think about conformal field theories, Edwin showed me how to think about the Hubbard model, and Christian showed me how to think about surface probes of charge fluctuations.I can't imagine completing this PhD without the tireless assistance of our staff at the Department of Physics and the Institute for Condensed Matter Theory: Lance Cooper, Wendy Wimmer, and Janice Benner.Thank you all! 2 Unless next-nearest-neighbor hopping is introduced to the 2d Hubbard model, particle-hole symmetry is maintained such that both hole-and electron-doping must result in the same physics, i.e.Fermi surface topology and Luttinger surface volume.3 Fermi arcs that extend and eventually join into a closed Fermi surface as holes are doped.
High temperature superconductivity in copper oxides (cuprates) represents one of the most striking phenomena in condensed matter physics. These materials host superconducting states with the highest known critical temperatures, emerging upon doping antiferromagnetic insulator compounds. The antiferromagnetic (AF) insulating and superconducting (SC) phases defy standard descriptions in terms of band picture and conventional phonon-mediated superconductivity. In fact, these phenomena are genuine signatures of strong electronic correlations which hinder effective single-particle descriptions of the many-electron system. After 40 years since their discovery, it is widely accepted that the Hubbard model on the square lattice provides a minimal description of the low-energy electronic properties of cuprates. The model describes the competition between the electronic kinetic energy, modelled by nearest-neighbours hopping t, and the Coulomb repulsion, modelled by a purely local interaction potential U. At half-filling, this competition results in the so-called "Mott localisation" phenomenon, which distinguishes the metallic phase for U/t « 1 from an insulating phase for U/t » 1. The latter is characterised by the almost complete localisation of electrons due to the high energetic cost of hopping towards occupied sites. Interestingly, this basic competition is intimately related to AF ordering and, upon doping, to the formation of the SC state with characteristic d-wave symmetry. The fact that a purely repulsive interaction U is responsible for the formation of a SC state is remarkable, being superconductivity typically associated with an effective attractive interaction. In fact, a d-wave SC state can also be obtained, in general, by considering an attractive potential between electrons of neighbouring sites. Motivated by this observation, in this thesis, we study a modified version of the Hubbard model, dubbed as the "extended Hubbard model", in which we include a nearest-neighbours attractive potential -V. The general goal of this work is to explore the interplay between the purely local repulsion and the non-local attraction. This is not only motivated by the fact that both interactions are, in principle, responsible for d-wave superconductivity, but also by recent experimental observations which strongly suggest that the term -V needs to be included in order to accurately describe the magnetic spectra of some specific compounds. In this thesis, we study the extended Hubbard model using the Hartree-Fock method. Namely, we approximate the ground state by implementing a variational search in the subspace of the many-body Hilbert space of gaussian states. Despite its simplicity, the Hartree-Fock method provides a powerful framework to study competition among different phases, originating from different symmetry breaking mechanisms. In particular, we study the competition between three different phases: the normal phase, characterised by no symmetry breaking, the AF phase, characterised by a lowering of SU(2) symmetry, and the SC phase, characterised by the breaking of U(1) charge conservation. This thesis work led to a number of original results, which can be summarised by the general observation that the non-local attraction -V acts cooperatively with the local repulsion U for the stabilisation of the various phases hosted by the Hubbard model. For the normal phase, we find that the non-local attraction acts as a source of Mott localisation, leading to an effective reduction of the electronic bandwidth. In particular, for values of V larger than a critical value and close to half-filling, we find a strong Mott localisation characterised by the complete flattening of the electronic bands. Interestingly, this result shows an example of Mott localisation that can be described at the level of the Hartree-Fock approximation, whereas Mott localisation in the conventional Hubbard model usually requires more sophisticated approximation schemes. For the AF phase, we restrict our analysis to the half-filled case. We find that the pairing-induced Mott localisation leads to a significant enhancement of the magnetisation, primarily originating from the local repulsion U. Finally, we focus on the superconducting phase and derive self-consistency equations in both singlet and triplet Cooper pairing channels, showing how Cooper pairing can be mediated simultaneously by both the local repulsion and the non-local attraction. Therefore, we numerically investigate the singlet channel and find evidence of "symmetry mixing", namely, the formation of a superconducting gap that is neither symmetric nor anti-symmetric under rotations of π/2 in the plane. We show that symmetry mixing is connected to the emergence of a finite nematic order parameter, that signals the breaking of planar rotational symmetry. This nematic symmetry breaking results in the fact that the renormalisation of bands becomes anisotropic, producing a difference in electronic kinetics in the x and y directions. To summarise, the original results obtained in this thesis show that the non-local pairing provides a different route towards the formation of key strongly correlated phenomena, including Mott localisation and nematic superconductivity, and call for future investigation using more sophisticated methods such as, for example, the Dynamical Mean Field Theory.
We study the three-band Hubbard model for the copper oxide plane of the high-temperature superconducting cuprates using determinant quantum Monte Carlo and the dynamical cluster approximation (DCA) and provide a comprehensive view of the pairing correlations in this model using these methods. Specifically, we compute the pair-field susceptibility and study its dependence on temperature, doping, interaction strength, and charge-transfer energy. Using the DCA, we also solve the Bethe-Salpeter equation for the two-particle Green's function in the particle-particle channel to determine the transition temperature to the superconducting phase on smaller clusters. Our calculations reproduce many aspects of the cuprate phase diagram and indicate that there is an ``optimal'' value of the charge-transfer energy for the model where Tc is largest. These results have implications for our understanding of superconductivity in both the cuprates and other doped charge-transfer insulators.
Superconductivity in the cuprates exhibits many unusual features. We study the two-dimensional Hubbard model with plaquette dynamical mean-field theory to address these unusual features and relate them to other normal-state phenomena, such as the pseudogap. Previous studies with this method found that upon doping the Mott insulator at low temperature a pseudogap phase appears. The low-temperature transition between that phase and the correlated metal at higher doping is first-order. A series of crossovers emerge along the Widom line extension of that first-order transition in the supercritical region. Here we show that the highly asymmetric dome of the dynamical mean-field superconducting transition temperature Tc(d), the maximum of the condensation energy as a function of doping, the correlation between maximum Tc(D) and normal-state scattering rate, the change from potential-energy driven to kinetic-energy driven pairing mechanisms can all be understood as remnants of the normal state first-order transition and its associated crossovers that also act as an organizing principle for the superconducting state.