Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Modern Physics Letters A

Quantization Yielding Sharp and Unsharp Observables

Richard Tao Roni Hutagalung, Arief Hermanto, Muhammad Farchani Rosyid

Published Jan 6, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The so-called spectral decomposition quantization (SDQ) involving spectral decompositions of the identity operator has been proposed. The quantization yields the standard (sharp) quantum observables in the form of Hermitian operators acting in the Hilbert space of square-integrable functions. Here, the quantizable classical observables are limited as in the case of geometric quantization (GQ). It has been shown that this quantization leads to the same results as those yielded by geometric quantization in the position representation as well as in the momentum representation. The method of quantization also has been formulated in the representation concerning any pair of canonical observables. Then, the quantization has been generalized by replacing the spectral measure appearing in the spectral decompositions of the identity operator with positive-operator-valued measure constructed by using suitable smearing function (e.g. confidence distribution) so that the quantization yields unsharp quantum observables. It has been shown that the unsharp quantum observables are yielded from the quantization of the so-called unsharp quantizable classical observables. Some properties of unsharp classical observables have been investigated. The explicit expressions of unsharp quantum observables have been obtained.

DOI
10.1142/s021773232650015x

Related papers

Quantifying unsharpness of measurements via uncertainty

Yizhou Liu, Shunlong Luo

In the conventional axiomatic formalism of quantum mechanics, a physical measurement of a quantum observable is mathematically represented by the spectral decomposition of the Hermitian operator associated with the observable. This constitutes the scenario of a L\"uders (projective) measurement, which includes a von Neumann (rank-one projective) measurement as a special and prominent instance. In this context, the measurement is called sharp in the sense that each measurement operator is an orthogonal projection (eigenprojection of the observable). In the modern operational formalism, a measurement is represented by a positive-operator valued measure (POVM), which consists of a family of non-negative definite operators (measurement operators, effects) summing to the identity. In this scenario, a measurement is called unsharp (fuzzy) if some measurement operators are not orthogonal projections. A natural question arises as to how to quantify unsharpness of a measurement. In this work, we address this issue in terms of uncertainty. For this purpose, we study a family of observables associated with a measurement and their uncertainty. By exploiting the difference between the (total) measurement uncertainty and the observable uncertainty, we are led to some information-theoretic quantifiers of unsharpness. We reveal their basic properties and illustrate them through some important measurements. In particular, we characterize L\"uders measurements and equiangular POVMs as extreme measurements in terms of unsharpness.

Physical Review A•Nov 29, 2021•12 citations

From unsharp to sharp quantum observables: The general Hilbert space case

Gianpiero Cattaneo, Giuseppe Nisticò

An unsharp quantum observable can be considered a realization of a sharp observable if and only if it is commutative. In this paper we describe an explicit procedure for reconstructing such a sharp observable and for establishing the probabilistic correlations between the sharp reconstruction and the given unsharp observable.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Jul 1, 2000•18 citations

Sharp reconstruction of unsharp quantum observables

Roberto Beneduci, Giuseppe Nisticò

A well defined procedure exists which allows us to “reconstruct” a sharp, i.e., standard, quantum observable A starting from a given commutative unsharp observable F. In this work we prove that the outcomes of measurements of F can be consistently interpreted as the result of a stochastic diffusion of outcomes of its sharp reconstruction A. Furthermore, for every sharp observable B, such that F is unsharp realization of B, we explicitly construct a real mapping g such that A=g(B).

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Nov 22, 2003•19 citations

Quantization and noiseless measurements

Jukka Kiukas, PEKKA J. LAHTI

In accordance with the fact that quantum measurements are described in terms of positive operator measures (POMs), we consider certain aspects of a quantization scheme in which a classical variable $f:\R^2\to \R$ is associated with a unique positive operator measure (POM) $E^f$, which is not necessarily projection valued. The motivation for such a scheme comes from the well-known fact that due to the noise in a quantum measurement, the resulting outcome distribution is given by a POM and cannot, in general, be described in terms of a traditional observable, a selfadjoint operator. Accordingly, we notice that the noiseless measurements are the ones which are determined by a selfadjoint operator. The POM $E^f$ in our quantization is defined through its moment operators, which are required to be of the form $Γ(f^k)$, $k\in \N$, with $Γ$ a fixed map from classical variables to Hilbert space operators. In particular, we consider the quantization of classical \emph{questions}, that is, functions $f:\R^2\to\R$ taking only values 0 and 1. We compare two concrete realizations of the map $Γ$ in view of their ability to produce noiseless measurements: one being the Weyl map, and the other defined by using phase space probability distributions.

arXiv:quant-ph/0612054•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Feb 14, 2007•2 citations

Continuous Spectra

Tilak Sinha

In this chapter we take up systems whose state spaces form a continuum. These are, naturally, infinite dimensional vector spaces (often called Hilbert spaces). Unfortunately, we could not do any better than treating such systems by formal analogy with their finite dimensional counterparts. A rigorous treatment would require a background in functional analysis and is beyond the scope of the present work. Thus, we essentially lay out a dictionary for translating the mathematical ingredients and formulae, from discrete to continuum descriptions, motivated by plausibility arguments. In particular, we argue why states are now described by complex square integrable functions (called wave functions) and observables by Hermitian differential operators. We then move on to show how to quantize quantum systems with classical analogues, which comprise the bulk of real life physical systems. Here, we explicitly show how the most nontrivial component of the quantization, i.e., the description of the representation of the momentum operator (in position space) can be deduced from both, the de Broglie hypothesis, and the canonical commutation relation. The “particle in a box” problem is treated as an illustration. The parity operator, Ehrenfest's theorem and continuity conditions have been relegated to the problem section.

Chapman & Hall/CRC eBooks•Jun 18, 2021•0 citations

Canonical quantization of constants of motion

Fabián Belmonte

We develop a quantization method, that we name decomposable Weyl quantization, which ensures that the constants of motion of a prescribed finite set of Hamiltonians are preserved by the quantization. Our method is based on a structural analogy between the notions of reduction of the classical phase space and diagonalization of selfadjoint operators. We obtain the spectral decomposition of the emerging quantum constants of motion directly from the quantization process. If a specific quantization is given, we expect that it preserves constants of motion exactly when it coincides with decomposable Weyl quantization on the algebra of constants of motion. We obtain a characterization of when such property holds in terms of the Wigner transforms involved. We also explain how our construction can be applied to spectral theory. Moreover, we discuss how our method opens up new perspectives in formal deformation quantization and geometric quantization.

arXiv:1505.07250•Reviews in Mathematical Physics•May 6, 2020•2 citations
The so-called spectral decomposition quantization (SDQ) involving spectral decompositions of the identity operator has been proposed. The quantization yields the standard (sharp) quantum observables in the form of Hermitian operators acting in the Hilbert space of square-integrable functions. Here, the quantizable classical observables are limited as in the case of geometric quantization (GQ). It has been shown that this quantization leads to the same results as those yielded by geometric quantization in the position representation as well as in the momentum representation. The method of quantization also has been formulated in the representation concerning any pair of canonical observables. Then, the quantization has been generalized by replacing the spectral measure appearing in the spectral decompositions of the identity operator with positive-operator-valued measure constructed by using suitable smearing function (e.g. confidence distribution) so that the quantization yields unsharp quantum observables. It has been shown that the unsharp quantum observables are yielded from the quantization of the so-called unsharp quantizable classical observables. Some properties of unsharp classical observables have been investigated. The explicit expressions of unsharp quantum observables have been obtained.
In the conventional axiomatic formalism of quantum mechanics, a physical measurement of a quantum observable is mathematically represented by the spectral decomposition of the Hermitian operator associated with the observable. This constitutes the scenario of a L\"uders (projective) measurement, which includes a von Neumann (rank-one projective) measurement as a special and prominent instance. In this context, the measurement is called sharp in the sense that each measurement operator is an orthogonal projection (eigenprojection of the observable). In the modern operational formalism, a measurement is represented by a positive-operator valued measure (POVM), which consists of a family of non-negative definite operators (measurement operators, effects) summing to the identity. In this scenario, a measurement is called unsharp (fuzzy) if some measurement operators are not orthogonal projections. A natural question arises as to how to quantify unsharpness of a measurement. In this work, we address this issue in terms of uncertainty. For this purpose, we study a family of observables associated with a measurement and their uncertainty. By exploiting the difference between the (total) measurement uncertainty and the observable uncertainty, we are led to some information-theoretic quantifiers of unsharpness. We reveal their basic properties and illustrate them through some important measurements. In particular, we characterize L\"uders measurements and equiangular POVMs as extreme measurements in terms of unsharpness.
In accordance with the fact that quantum measurements are described in terms of positive operator measures (POMs), we consider certain aspects of a quantization scheme in which a classical variable f:R2→Rf:\R^2\to \Rf:R2→R is associated with a unique positive operator measure (POM) EfE^fEf, which is not necessarily projection valued. The motivation for such a scheme comes from the well-known fact that due to the noise in a quantum measurement, the resulting outcome distribution is given by a POM and cannot, in general, be described in terms of a traditional observable, a selfadjoint operator. Accordingly, we notice that the noiseless measurements are the ones which are determined by a selfadjoint operator. The POM EfE^fEf in our quantization is defined through its moment operators, which are required to be of the form Γ(fk)Γ(f^k)Γ(fk), k∈Nk\in \Nk∈N, with ΓΓΓ a fixed map from classical variables to Hilbert space operators. In particular, we consider the quantization of classical \emph{questions}, that is, functions f:R2→Rf:\R^2\to\Rf:R2→R taking only values 0 and 1. We compare two concrete realizations of the map ΓΓΓ in view of their ability to produce noiseless measurements: one being the Weyl map, and the other defined by using phase space probability distributions.
In this chapter we take up systems whose state spaces form a continuum. These are, naturally, infinite dimensional vector spaces (often called Hilbert spaces). Unfortunately, we could not do any better than treating such systems by formal analogy with their finite dimensional counterparts. A rigorous treatment would require a background in functional analysis and is beyond the scope of the present work. Thus, we essentially lay out a dictionary for translating the mathematical ingredients and formulae, from discrete to continuum descriptions, motivated by plausibility arguments. In particular, we argue why states are now described by complex square integrable functions (called wave functions) and observables by Hermitian differential operators. We then move on to show how to quantize quantum systems with classical analogues, which comprise the bulk of real life physical systems. Here, we explicitly show how the most nontrivial component of the quantization, i.e., the description of the representation of the momentum operator (in position space) can be deduced from both, the de Broglie hypothesis, and the canonical commutation relation. The “particle in a box” problem is treated as an illustration. The parity operator, Ehrenfest's theorem and continuity conditions have been relegated to the problem section.
We develop a quantization method, that we name decomposable Weyl quantization, which ensures that the constants of motion of a prescribed finite set of Hamiltonians are preserved by the quantization. Our method is based on a structural analogy between the notions of reduction of the classical phase space and diagonalization of selfadjoint operators. We obtain the spectral decomposition of the emerging quantum constants of motion directly from the quantization process. If a specific quantization is given, we expect that it preserves constants of motion exactly when it coincides with decomposable Weyl quantization on the algebra of constants of motion. We obtain a characterization of when such property holds in terms of the Wigner transforms involved. We also explain how our construction can be applied to spectral theory. Moreover, we discuss how our method opens up new perspectives in formal deformation quantization and geometric quantization.