Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Entanglement as a More Fundamental Notion of Information than Shannon and von Neumann Entropy

Michael W Barry

Published Dec 27, 2025• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Classical information theory, built on Shannon entropy, and quantum information theory, built on von Neumann entropy, quantify uncertainty and compression properties of probability distributions and density operators. Both are powerful, but both treat information as a property of states of individual systems or ensembles. In this manuscript we argue that entanglement—the pattern of non-classical correlations between systems—is more fundamental than either Shannon or von Neumann information. We motivate this claim with a condensate thought experiment in which many bosons occupy the same single-particle state: Shannon and von Neumann entropies assign them identical information content, yet they can be distinguished by their distinct entanglement histories with external systems. Formally, states with identical marginal density operators but different purifications represent different global information, accessible only through their entanglement structure. Entropic quantities are then seen as coarse-grained summaries of this underlying relational information. We connect this perspective to an entanglement-geometric view of physics, including Entanglement Manifold Cosmology (EMC), in which spacetime and physical “truth” emerge from the geometry of correlations. The goal is an information-theoretic narrative that is rigorous enough for physics and information theory while readable to a non-specialist who is comfortable with basic linear algebra and quantum mechanics.

DOI
10.5121/csit.2025.152507

Related papers

Entanglement as a More Fundamental Notion of Information than Shannon and Von Neumann Entropy

CS&IT

Classical information theory, built on Shannon entropy, and quantum information theory, built on von Neumann entropy, quantify uncertainty and compression proper ties of probability distributions and density operators. Both are powerful, but both treat information as a property of states of individual systems or ensembles. In this manuscript we argue that entanglement the pattern of non-classical correlations be tween systems is more fundamental than either Shannon or von Neumann information. We motivate this claim with a condensate thought experiment in which many bosons occupy the same single-particle state: Shannon and von Neumann entropies as sign them identical information content, yet they can be distinguished by their distinct entanglement histories with external systems. Formally, states with identical marginal density operators but different purifications represent different global information, accessible only through their entanglement structure. Entropic quantities are then seen as coarse-grained summaries of this underlying relational information. We connect this perspective to an entanglement-geometric view of physics, including Entanglement Manifold Cosmology (EMC), in which spacetime and physical truth emerge from the geometry of correlations. The goal is an information-theoretic narrative that is rigorous enough for physics and information theory while readable to a non-specialist who is comfortable with basic linear algebra and quantum mechanics.

•Aug 26, 2026•0 citations

A Geometry of entanglement and entropy

Ramita Sarkar, Soumik Mahanti, Prasanta Kumar Panigrahi

This paper explores the fundamental relationship between the geometry of entanglement and von Neumann entropy, shedding light on the intricate nature of quantum correlations. We provide a comprehensive overview of entanglement, highlighting its crucial role in quantum mechanics. Our focus centers on the connection between entanglement, von Neumann entropy, a measure of the information content within quantum systems and the geometry of composite Hilbert spaces. We discuss various methods for quantifying and characterizing entanglement through a geometric perspective and elucidate how this connection unveils the nature of quantum entanglement, offering valuable insights into the underlying structure of quantum systems. This study underscores the significance of geometry as a key tool for understanding the rich landscape of quantum correlations and their implications across various domains of physics and information theory. An example of entanglement as an indispensable resource for the task of state teleportation is presented at the end.

arXiv:2402.15880•Feb 24, 2024•2 citations

Entanglement and non-classical correlations

The presence of correlations shared among the subparts of a given physical system, and which do not have a classical counterpart, is a clear signature of non-classicality for a quantum state. As we saw in Chap. 2, such correlations can be captured by entanglement, one of the most intriguing features predicted by quantum theory, which points directly to a violation of the Bell’s inequalities. In this chapter we provide a rigorous definition of entanglement, and review its basic properties together with the general framework that is needed to quantify it for bipartite states. We present the common criteria that are used to detect whether a state is entangled or not, and discuss the most common entanglement quantifiers in the bipartite context. The latter follow an introduction of the cornerstone concepts of classical Shannon entropy and quantum von Neumann entropy. Subsequently, the multipartite scenario is briefly addressed. Although entanglement is the most remarkable among non-classical correlations, even some separable (not entangled) mixed states can exhibit a non-classical behaviour. In this wider context we discuss the quantum discord, which is expressed as the difference between two entropic quantities and is extractable by performing a local measure on one of the subsystems. This, and other related quantifiers, enlighten the impossibility of recovering the information contained in a composite quantum system after the measurement process. A special-topic section on the different definitions of entropy used in physics closes the chapter.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Dec 1, 2018•1 citation

Quantum Information and Entropy

Mark M. Wilde

In this chapter, we discuss several information measures that are important for quantifying the amount of information and correlations that are present in quantum systems. The first fundamental measure that we introduce is the von Neumman entropy. It is the quantum analog of the Shannon entropy, but it captures both classical and quantum uncertainty in a quantum state. The von Neumann entropy gives meaning to a notion of the information qubit . This notion is different from that of the physical qubit, which is the description of a quantum state in an electron or a photon. The information qubit is the fundamental quantum informational unit of measure, determining how much quantum information is in a quantum system. The beginning definitions here are analogous to the classical definitions of entropy, but we soon discover a radical departure from the intuitive classical notions from the previous chapter: the conditional quantum entropy can be negative for certain quantum states. In the classical world, this negativity simply does not occur, but it takes a special meaning in quantum information theory. Pure quantum states that are entangled have stronger-than-classical spatial correlations and are examples of states that have negative conditional entropy. The negative of the conditional quantum entropy is so important in quantum information theory that we even have a special name for it: the coherent information. We discover that the coherent information obeys a quantum data-processing inequality, placing it on a firm footing as a particular informational measure of quantum correlations.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Apr 18, 2013•0 citations

Localizing quantum information

Fahimeh Bayeh, Andre Kornell

The idea that information can be localized is pervasive in physics. In thermodynamics, entropy flows from one reservoir to another, and in quantum gravity, the entropy content of some spatial regions is bounded. In quantum information theory, information is transmitted from one place to another, and entanglement can provide an advantage when there are constraints on such transmission. Shannon entropy quantifies localizable information in the sense that marginalization defines an outer measure on the set of parts of a classical multipartite system. In contrast, von Neumann entropy does not quantify localizable information in this sense. However, a variant of von Neumann entropy, which originates in noncommutative geometry, does. We prove that this adjusted von Neumann entropy is the minimum quantum entropy that quantifies localizable information. We also prove that this is the unique quantum entropy that characterizes Bell states in terms of redundant information, directly generalizing the classical case. We work with finite-dimensional $C^*$-algebras throughout, modeling finite quantum systems that may have superselection sectors.

quant-pharXiv:2609.01966•Sep 3, 2026•0 citations

Entropy in general physical theories

Anthony J Short, Stephanie Wehner

Information plays an important role in our understanding of the physical world. Hence we propose an entropic measure of information for any physical theory that admits systems, states and measurements. In the quantum and classical worlds, our measure reduces to the von Neumann and Shannon entropies, respectively. It can even be used in a quantum or classical setting where we are only allowed to perform a limited set of operations. In a world that admits superstrong correlations in the form of non-local boxes, our measure can be used to analyze protocols such as superstrong random access encodings and the violation of 'information causality'. However, we also show that in such a world no entropic measure can exhibit all the properties we commonly accept in a quantum setting. For example, there exists no 'reasonable' measure of conditional entropy that is subadditive. Finally, we prove a coding theorem for some theories that is analogous to the quantum and classical settings, providing us with an appealing operational interpretation.

arXiv:0909.4801•New Journal of Physics•Mar 15, 2010•102 citations
Classical information theory, built on Shannon entropy, and quantum information theory, built on von Neumann entropy, quantify uncertainty and compression properties of probability distributions and density operators. Both are powerful, but both treat information as a property of states of individual systems or ensembles. In this manuscript we argue that entanglement—the pattern of non-classical correlations between systems—is more fundamental than either Shannon or von Neumann information. We motivate this claim with a condensate thought experiment in which many bosons occupy the same single-particle state: Shannon and von Neumann entropies assign them identical information content, yet they can be distinguished by their distinct entanglement histories with external systems. Formally, states with identical marginal density operators but different purifications represent different global information, accessible only through their entanglement structure. Entropic quantities are then seen as coarse-grained summaries of this underlying relational information. We connect this perspective to an entanglement-geometric view of physics, including Entanglement Manifold Cosmology (EMC), in which spacetime and physical “truth” emerge from the geometry of correlations. The goal is an information-theoretic narrative that is rigorous enough for physics and information theory while readable to a non-specialist who is comfortable with basic linear algebra and quantum mechanics.
Classical information theory, built on Shannon entropy, and quantum information theory, built on von Neumann entropy, quantify uncertainty and compression proper ties of probability distributions and density operators. Both are powerful, but both treat information as a property of states of individual systems or ensembles. In this manuscript we argue that entanglement the pattern of non-classical correlations be tween systems is more fundamental than either Shannon or von Neumann information. We motivate this claim with a condensate thought experiment in which many bosons occupy the same single-particle state: Shannon and von Neumann entropies as sign them identical information content, yet they can be distinguished by their distinct entanglement histories with external systems. Formally, states with identical marginal density operators but different purifications represent different global information, accessible only through their entanglement structure. Entropic quantities are then seen as coarse-grained summaries of this underlying relational information. We connect this perspective to an entanglement-geometric view of physics, including Entanglement Manifold Cosmology (EMC), in which spacetime and physical truth emerge from the geometry of correlations. The goal is an information-theoretic narrative that is rigorous enough for physics and information theory while readable to a non-specialist who is comfortable with basic linear algebra and quantum mechanics.
This paper explores the fundamental relationship between the geometry of entanglement and von Neumann entropy, shedding light on the intricate nature of quantum correlations. We provide a comprehensive overview of entanglement, highlighting its crucial role in quantum mechanics. Our focus centers on the connection between entanglement, von Neumann entropy, a measure of the information content within quantum systems and the geometry of composite Hilbert spaces. We discuss various methods for quantifying and characterizing entanglement through a geometric perspective and elucidate how this connection unveils the nature of quantum entanglement, offering valuable insights into the underlying structure of quantum systems. This study underscores the significance of geometry as a key tool for understanding the rich landscape of quantum correlations and their implications across various domains of physics and information theory. An example of entanglement as an indispensable resource for the task of state teleportation is presented at the end.
The presence of correlations shared among the subparts of a given physical system, and which do not have a classical counterpart, is a clear signature of non-classicality for a quantum state. As we saw in Chap. 2, such correlations can be captured by entanglement, one of the most intriguing features predicted by quantum theory, which points directly to a violation of the Bell’s inequalities. In this chapter we provide a rigorous definition of entanglement, and review its basic properties together with the general framework that is needed to quantify it for bipartite states. We present the common criteria that are used to detect whether a state is entangled or not, and discuss the most common entanglement quantifiers in the bipartite context. The latter follow an introduction of the cornerstone concepts of classical Shannon entropy and quantum von Neumann entropy. Subsequently, the multipartite scenario is briefly addressed. Although entanglement is the most remarkable among non-classical correlations, even some separable (not entangled) mixed states can exhibit a non-classical behaviour. In this wider context we discuss the quantum discord, which is expressed as the difference between two entropic quantities and is extractable by performing a local measure on one of the subsystems. This, and other related quantifiers, enlighten the impossibility of recovering the information contained in a composite quantum system after the measurement process. A special-topic section on the different definitions of entropy used in physics closes the chapter.
In this chapter, we discuss several information measures that are important for quantifying the amount of information and correlations that are present in quantum systems. The first fundamental measure that we introduce is the von Neumman entropy. It is the quantum analog of the Shannon entropy, but it captures both classical and quantum uncertainty in a quantum state. The von Neumann entropy gives meaning to a notion of the information qubit . This notion is different from that of the physical qubit, which is the description of a quantum state in an electron or a photon. The information qubit is the fundamental quantum informational unit of measure, determining how much quantum information is in a quantum system. The beginning definitions here are analogous to the classical definitions of entropy, but we soon discover a radical departure from the intuitive classical notions from the previous chapter: the conditional quantum entropy can be negative for certain quantum states. In the classical world, this negativity simply does not occur, but it takes a special meaning in quantum information theory. Pure quantum states that are entangled have stronger-than-classical spatial correlations and are examples of states that have negative conditional entropy. The negative of the conditional quantum entropy is so important in quantum information theory that we even have a special name for it: the coherent information. We discover that the coherent information obeys a quantum data-processing inequality, placing it on a firm footing as a particular informational measure of quantum correlations.
The idea that information can be localized is pervasive in physics. In thermodynamics, entropy flows from one reservoir to another, and in quantum gravity, the entropy content of some spatial regions is bounded. In quantum information theory, information is transmitted from one place to another, and entanglement can provide an advantage when there are constraints on such transmission. Shannon entropy quantifies localizable information in the sense that marginalization defines an outer measure on the set of parts of a classical multipartite system. In contrast, von Neumann entropy does not quantify localizable information in this sense. However, a variant of von Neumann entropy, which originates in noncommutative geometry, does. We prove that this adjusted von Neumann entropy is the minimum quantum entropy that quantifies localizable information. We also prove that this is the unique quantum entropy that characterizes Bell states in terms of redundant information, directly generalizing the classical case. We work with finite-dimensional C∗C^*C∗-algebras throughout, modeling finite quantum systems that may have superselection sectors.
Information plays an important role in our understanding of the physical world. Hence we propose an entropic measure of information for any physical theory that admits systems, states and measurements. In the quantum and classical worlds, our measure reduces to the von Neumann and Shannon entropies, respectively. It can even be used in a quantum or classical setting where we are only allowed to perform a limited set of operations. In a world that admits superstrong correlations in the form of non-local boxes, our measure can be used to analyze protocols such as superstrong random access encodings and the violation of 'information causality'. However, we also show that in such a world no entropic measure can exhibit all the properties we commonly accept in a quantum setting. For example, there exists no 'reasonable' measure of conditional entropy that is subadditive. Finally, we prove a coding theorem for some theories that is analogous to the quantum and classical settings, providing us with an appealing operational interpretation.