Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Reality After the Mott Closure: Regime-Bounded Ontology Without Fundamental Conservation

John Francis Osborne

Published Dec 24, 2025• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

This paper examines the ontological consequences of achieving a constraint-level closure of the Mott problem in quantum theory. The classical Mott problem concerns the tension between rotationally symmetric quantum preparations and the emergence of asymmetric, localized, track-like outcomes without appealing to observer dependence or treating wavefunction collapse as a primitive axiom. Recent developments show that such outcomes can arise as admissible, stable regimes once the relevant constraint architecture is made explicit, without committing to any particular constructive dynamics. Taking this closure as established, the present work addresses a strictly ontological question: what must physical reality be like if localisation, asymmetry, and track formation are real features of the world in the absence of primitive collapse? No new interpretation is proposed, and no hidden variables, microphysical mechanisms, or additional dynamical laws are introduced. The analysis indicates that physical reality is more accurately described as regime-bounded rather than globally constrained. Within sufficiently stabilized regimes, conservation principles operate as reliable accounting rules, but they should not be elevated to universal ontological commitments that must hold everywhere and always. Ordering is therefore not assumed to arise from time-translation symmetry, and global conservation is not presumed. Instead, what becomes physically real is determined by which configurations are admissible and stable under the constraint structure, rather than by presupposed global symmetry requirements. The scope of this paper is deliberately narrow. It develops only the minimal ontological consequences implied by the logical closure of the Mott problem, leaving constructive realizations, technical implementations, and proprietary dynamical structures to companion work.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.18047270

Related papers

A Constraint Level Triplicate Closure of the Mott Problem

John Francis Osborne

This paper develops a triplicate, constraint-level closure of the classical Mott problem, reframing wave–track formation as a structural requirement rather than a measurement paradox. Within the ψ₀-OCM framework, particle tracks are shown to arise only when the admissible quantum configurations are restricted by jointly acting constraint layers: symmetry viability, track stability, and localisation admissibility. The closure proceeds in three logically linked stages. First, the constraint formulation recovers the standard quantum description as a limiting regime without invoking ad-hoc collapse rules. Second, boundary-dependent stability conditions identify the regimes in which direction-aligned tracks become physically licensed. Third, the framework remains fully compatible with Schrödinger and Dirac evolution in appropriate limits, interpreting collapse-like behaviour as an admissibility transition rather than a physical discontinuity. The result establishes a single, unified constraint architecture in which track formation, boundary stabilization, and emergent classicality follow as necessary regime properties. The formulation strengthens, rather than replaces, standard theory while remaining independent of any unpublished constructive ψ₀ dynamics. Update Notice — January 2026 This document supersedes the earlier constraint-level treatment of the Mott problem within the ψ₀–OCM. The prior edition outlined the triplicate constraint structure in preliminary form. The present version sets out the finalized constraint architecture for Mott-type behaviour within the ψ₀–OCM and establishes the triplicate closure criterion as the governing condition. It further introduces the formal priority and necessity statements that define equivalence with the ψ₀–OCM at the constraint level. 1. Triplicate Closure Formalization The constraint system is expressed as a rigorously defined triplicate closure criterion, in which symmetry viability, track stability, and localisation admissibility function as interdependent and jointly necessary conditions. 2. Priority and Necessity Statements A formal novelty declaration and necessity clause are included. Any framework asserting parity with, or superiority to, the ψ₀–OCM in treating Mott-type behaviour must demonstrate an equivalent triplicate closure regime. This presentation is limited to the constraint layer. The full technical development of underlying redistribution, detachment, and curvature mechanisms is contained in dedicated ψ₀–OCM internal modules. The earlier paper is formally superseded. This document constitutes the authoritative constraint reference for Mott-type behaviour within the ψ₀–OCM.

•Dec 25, 2025•0 citations

Constraint-Level Closure of the Mott Problem: Related Work and Collapse-Model Stress Test

John Francis Osborne

This paper accompanies the public presentation of a triplicate, constraint-level resolution of the Mott problem. It surveys leading approaches to track formation — including Copenhagen-type interpretations, Everettian frameworks, decoherence accounts, and objective collapse models — and evaluates the extent to which each addresses single-outcome admissibility, track stability, and localisation. The analysis shows that while existing approaches successfully reproduce the phenomenology of cloud-chamber tracks, they do so by introducing additional interpretive or dynamical postulates rather than identifying the minimal constraint conditions under which definite outcomes are licensed. A formal stress test is then developed, demonstrating that any objective collapse model capable of reproducing Mott phenomenology must implicitly encode constraint structures equivalent to symmetry viability, path-stability, and localisation-admissibility functionals. These results position the constraint-level framework, developed within the ψ₀-OCM (Osborne Cosmological Model), as logically minimal and structurally independent of specific collapse dynamics. The paper is intended to clarify the relationship between the constraint architecture and existing theories, providing a companion reference to the triplicate resolution paper and situating the approach within broader work on quantum foundations and measurement.

•Dec 25, 2025•0 citations

Experiential Structural Ontology and the Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics

Darren Hearst

Quantum mechanics is empirically extraordinarily successful yet continues to admit a wide range of competing interpretations. While the formalism constrains probabilistic relations between preparation procedures, measurements, and outcomes, it does not uniquely determine the ontology that realises those relations. Interpretations such as Everettian quantum mechanics, Bohmian mechanics, objective collapse theories, relational quantum mechanics, and QBist approaches preserve the predictive structure of the theory while diverging sharply in their metaphysical commitments. At the same time, developments within quantum theory itself weaken the classical ontology of independently existing objects with intrinsic properties. Entanglement, violations of Bell inequalities, and decoherence theory collectively support the view that physical description is fundamentally relational. Structural realism therefore provides a natural interpretive framework, treating the mathematical structure of physical theory as ontologically primary. However, structural realism alone leaves open the question of instantiation: how relational organisation becomes concrete as a determinate world.This paper develops Experiential Structural Ontology (ESO) as a non-interventionist interpretation of quantum mechanics that addresses this problem. ESO retains the relational ontology suggested by quantum theory while proposing that relational constraint organisation is enacted as manifestation within a fundamental experiential field. On this interpretation, the wavefunction represents relational constraint architecture governing transitions within this field, measurement corresponds to the stabilisation of particular regimes within that structure, and decoherence explains the emergence of classical stability without invoking collapse dynamics or ontological branching.

•Mar 3, 2026•1 citation

Axiom 0: Non-Closure as the Structural Origin of Physical Reality

Iker Ibarrola Echeverría

This paper introduces Axiom 0, a minimal foundational principle for physical reality: the impossibility of any globally closed description of the total correlational structure. Rather than postulating space, time, dynamics, locality, or physical laws as primitive, the framework assumes only: (i) the existence of a correlational structure, (ii) the structural impossibility of complete self-closure, and (iii) consistency under partial comparison. From these ingredients, the paper shows how: physical laws emerge as stabilizing regularities of incomplete descriptions, time, dynamics, and geometry arise as effective, regime-dependent structures, irreversibility follows from projection and information loss, and why no description can be both exact and globally complete. Non-closure is treated as an ontological constraint, not as epistemic ignorance or observer dependence. Physical reality exists precisely because complete closure is impossible, independently of observation or modeling. The paper does not attempt to replace existing physical theories or derive numerical constants. Instead, it provides a structural foundation within which effective physical theories (quantum, classical, relativistic, and open-system regimes) can be consistently understood as emergent and domain-limited. This work is intended as a conceptual and structural foundation for correlational and relational approaches to fundamental physics, clarifying the origin of laws, dynamics, and physical regularity without invoking additional ontological postulates.

•Jan 29, 2026•0 citations

A Dynamical Mechanism for Directional Track Formation An Effective Resolution of the Mott Problem

John Francis Osborne

The Mott problem asks why a spherically symmetric quantum emission produces localized, linear ionization tracks rather than diffuse excitation. This paper presents an effective, interaction-level dynamical account of directional track formation based on local amplification, environmental response, and irreversible medium disturbance. The mechanism operates entirely within standard detector physics and does not invoke wavefunction collapse, observer dependence, or global selection principles. The analysis demonstrates how cumulative local interactions can dynamically consolidate a single persistent track, while explicitly showing that even a complete dynamical account does not explain the necessity of a unique outcome. That limitation is identified as a substantive result rather than a deficiency. The work is deliberately agnostic with respect to deeper ontological or constraint-based interpretations. Constraint-level closure of the Mott problem has been treated separately by the author in companion works.

•Jan 24, 2026•0 citations

Finite Propagation and the Regime Structure of Reality —Classicality and Geometry as Constraint-Limited Phenomena

Dr. Thomas P. Connelly

This paper develops a unified ontological framework in which quantum indeterminacy, classical determinism, and gravitational structure are interpreted not as manifestations of distinct fundamental laws, but as regime-dependent consequences of a single physical constraint: finite propagation at the invariant speed c. We argue that the transition from reversible physical possibility to irreversible physical fact is regulated by the finite rate at which interaction outcomes can propagate, accumulate, and stabilize. Irreversibility is tied explicitly to entropy-producing interactions subject to causal delay, grounding the framework in nonequilibrium thermodynamics rather than measurement postulates. We introduce a phenomenological order parameter, commitment density (ρcommit), defined as the locally accumulated history of irreversible constraint formation under finite propagation. Distinct physical regimes arise when this quantity crosses a critical percolation threshold (ρc), yielding three ontological domains: quantum under-representation (ρcommit ≪ ρc, insufficient closure), classical balance (ρcommit~ρc, writable yet stable), and cosmological over-representation (ρcommit ≫ ρc, saturated and non-writable). Key terms are defined in the main text. This regime structure provides a unified reinterpretation of quantum measurement, classical determinism, and horizon formation. Event horizons are generalized as the observational signature of causal saturation, appearing wherever accumulated closure renders regions non-writable. Time emerges from cyclic but asymmetric closure processes whose accumulated bias produces temporal direction. The framework makes specific falsifiable predictions: commitment should be gradual and resolvable in time-resolved decoherence experiments; gravitational-wave memory should be detectable as permanent relational displacement; and the quantum-classical boundary should depend on commitment density rather than mass or scale alone. Four explicit conditions that would falsify the framework are specified in Appendix A.

Open Journal of Philosophy•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations
This paper examines the ontological consequences of achieving a constraint-level closure of the Mott problem in quantum theory. The classical Mott problem concerns the tension between rotationally symmetric quantum preparations and the emergence of asymmetric, localized, track-like outcomes without appealing to observer dependence or treating wavefunction collapse as a primitive axiom. Recent developments show that such outcomes can arise as admissible, stable regimes once the relevant constraint architecture is made explicit, without committing to any particular constructive dynamics. Taking this closure as established, the present work addresses a strictly ontological question: what must physical reality be like if localisation, asymmetry, and track formation are real features of the world in the absence of primitive collapse? No new interpretation is proposed, and no hidden variables, microphysical mechanisms, or additional dynamical laws are introduced. The analysis indicates that physical reality is more accurately described as regime-bounded rather than globally constrained. Within sufficiently stabilized regimes, conservation principles operate as reliable accounting rules, but they should not be elevated to universal ontological commitments that must hold everywhere and always. Ordering is therefore not assumed to arise from time-translation symmetry, and global conservation is not presumed. Instead, what becomes physically real is determined by which configurations are admissible and stable under the constraint structure, rather than by presupposed global symmetry requirements. The scope of this paper is deliberately narrow. It develops only the minimal ontological consequences implied by the logical closure of the Mott problem, leaving constructive realizations, technical implementations, and proprietary dynamical structures to companion work.
This paper develops a triplicate, constraint-level closure of the classical Mott problem, reframing wave–track formation as a structural requirement rather than a measurement paradox. Within the ψ₀-OCM framework, particle tracks are shown to arise only when the admissible quantum configurations are restricted by jointly acting constraint layers: symmetry viability, track stability, and localisation admissibility. The closure proceeds in three logically linked stages. First, the constraint formulation recovers the standard quantum description as a limiting regime without invoking ad-hoc collapse rules. Second, boundary-dependent stability conditions identify the regimes in which direction-aligned tracks become physically licensed. Third, the framework remains fully compatible with Schrödinger and Dirac evolution in appropriate limits, interpreting collapse-like behaviour as an admissibility transition rather than a physical discontinuity. The result establishes a single, unified constraint architecture in which track formation, boundary stabilization, and emergent classicality follow as necessary regime properties. The formulation strengthens, rather than replaces, standard theory while remaining independent of any unpublished constructive ψ₀ dynamics. Update Notice — January 2026 This document supersedes the earlier constraint-level treatment of the Mott problem within the ψ₀–OCM. The prior edition outlined the triplicate constraint structure in preliminary form. The present version sets out the finalized constraint architecture for Mott-type behaviour within the ψ₀–OCM and establishes the triplicate closure criterion as the governing condition. It further introduces the formal priority and necessity statements that define equivalence with the ψ₀–OCM at the constraint level. 1. Triplicate Closure Formalization The constraint system is expressed as a rigorously defined triplicate closure criterion, in which symmetry viability, track stability, and localisation admissibility function as interdependent and jointly necessary conditions. 2. Priority and Necessity Statements A formal novelty declaration and necessity clause are included. Any framework asserting parity with, or superiority to, the ψ₀–OCM in treating Mott-type behaviour must demonstrate an equivalent triplicate closure regime. This presentation is limited to the constraint layer. The full technical development of underlying redistribution, detachment, and curvature mechanisms is contained in dedicated ψ₀–OCM internal modules. The earlier paper is formally superseded. This document constitutes the authoritative constraint reference for Mott-type behaviour within the ψ₀–OCM.
This paper accompanies the public presentation of a triplicate, constraint-level resolution of the Mott problem. It surveys leading approaches to track formation — including Copenhagen-type interpretations, Everettian frameworks, decoherence accounts, and objective collapse models — and evaluates the extent to which each addresses single-outcome admissibility, track stability, and localisation. The analysis shows that while existing approaches successfully reproduce the phenomenology of cloud-chamber tracks, they do so by introducing additional interpretive or dynamical postulates rather than identifying the minimal constraint conditions under which definite outcomes are licensed. A formal stress test is then developed, demonstrating that any objective collapse model capable of reproducing Mott phenomenology must implicitly encode constraint structures equivalent to symmetry viability, path-stability, and localisation-admissibility functionals. These results position the constraint-level framework, developed within the ψ₀-OCM (Osborne Cosmological Model), as logically minimal and structurally independent of specific collapse dynamics. The paper is intended to clarify the relationship between the constraint architecture and existing theories, providing a companion reference to the triplicate resolution paper and situating the approach within broader work on quantum foundations and measurement.
Quantum mechanics is empirically extraordinarily successful yet continues to admit a wide range of competing interpretations. While the formalism constrains probabilistic relations between preparation procedures, measurements, and outcomes, it does not uniquely determine the ontology that realises those relations. Interpretations such as Everettian quantum mechanics, Bohmian mechanics, objective collapse theories, relational quantum mechanics, and QBist approaches preserve the predictive structure of the theory while diverging sharply in their metaphysical commitments. At the same time, developments within quantum theory itself weaken the classical ontology of independently existing objects with intrinsic properties. Entanglement, violations of Bell inequalities, and decoherence theory collectively support the view that physical description is fundamentally relational. Structural realism therefore provides a natural interpretive framework, treating the mathematical structure of physical theory as ontologically primary. However, structural realism alone leaves open the question of instantiation: how relational organisation becomes concrete as a determinate world.This paper develops Experiential Structural Ontology (ESO) as a non-interventionist interpretation of quantum mechanics that addresses this problem. ESO retains the relational ontology suggested by quantum theory while proposing that relational constraint organisation is enacted as manifestation within a fundamental experiential field. On this interpretation, the wavefunction represents relational constraint architecture governing transitions within this field, measurement corresponds to the stabilisation of particular regimes within that structure, and decoherence explains the emergence of classical stability without invoking collapse dynamics or ontological branching.
This paper introduces Axiom 0, a minimal foundational principle for physical reality: the impossibility of any globally closed description of the total correlational structure. Rather than postulating space, time, dynamics, locality, or physical laws as primitive, the framework assumes only: (i) the existence of a correlational structure, (ii) the structural impossibility of complete self-closure, and (iii) consistency under partial comparison. From these ingredients, the paper shows how: physical laws emerge as stabilizing regularities of incomplete descriptions, time, dynamics, and geometry arise as effective, regime-dependent structures, irreversibility follows from projection and information loss, and why no description can be both exact and globally complete. Non-closure is treated as an ontological constraint, not as epistemic ignorance or observer dependence. Physical reality exists precisely because complete closure is impossible, independently of observation or modeling. The paper does not attempt to replace existing physical theories or derive numerical constants. Instead, it provides a structural foundation within which effective physical theories (quantum, classical, relativistic, and open-system regimes) can be consistently understood as emergent and domain-limited. This work is intended as a conceptual and structural foundation for correlational and relational approaches to fundamental physics, clarifying the origin of laws, dynamics, and physical regularity without invoking additional ontological postulates.
The Mott problem asks why a spherically symmetric quantum emission produces localized, linear ionization tracks rather than diffuse excitation. This paper presents an effective, interaction-level dynamical account of directional track formation based on local amplification, environmental response, and irreversible medium disturbance. The mechanism operates entirely within standard detector physics and does not invoke wavefunction collapse, observer dependence, or global selection principles. The analysis demonstrates how cumulative local interactions can dynamically consolidate a single persistent track, while explicitly showing that even a complete dynamical account does not explain the necessity of a unique outcome. That limitation is identified as a substantive result rather than a deficiency. The work is deliberately agnostic with respect to deeper ontological or constraint-based interpretations. Constraint-level closure of the Mott problem has been treated separately by the author in companion works.
This paper develops a unified ontological framework in which quantum indeterminacy, classical determinism, and gravitational structure are interpreted not as manifestations of distinct fundamental laws, but as regime-dependent consequences of a single physical constraint: finite propagation at the invariant speed c. We argue that the transition from reversible physical possibility to irreversible physical fact is regulated by the finite rate at which interaction outcomes can propagate, accumulate, and stabilize. Irreversibility is tied explicitly to entropy-producing interactions subject to causal delay, grounding the framework in nonequilibrium thermodynamics rather than measurement postulates. We introduce a phenomenological order parameter, commitment density (ρcommit), defined as the locally accumulated history of irreversible constraint formation under finite propagation. Distinct physical regimes arise when this quantity crosses a critical percolation threshold (ρc), yielding three ontological domains: quantum under-representation (ρcommit ≪ ρc, insufficient closure), classical balance (ρcommit~ρc, writable yet stable), and cosmological over-representation (ρcommit ≫ ρc, saturated and non-writable). Key terms are defined in the main text. This regime structure provides a unified reinterpretation of quantum measurement, classical determinism, and horizon formation. Event horizons are generalized as the observational signature of causal saturation, appearing wherever accumulated closure renders regions non-writable. Time emerges from cyclic but asymmetric closure processes whose accumulated bias produces temporal direction. The framework makes specific falsifiable predictions: commitment should be gradual and resolvable in time-resolved decoherence experiments; gravitational-wave memory should be detectable as permanent relational displacement; and the quantum-classical boundary should depend on commitment density rather than mass or scale alone. Four explicit conditions that would falsify the framework are specified in Appendix A.