Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Conditions of Objecthood: A Structural Analysis of Energy and Physical States

Yuliya M. Onishchuk

Published Jan 1, 2025• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

This project presents a structural and normative analysis of the conditions under which an object-based descriptive language is physically applicable. Rather than proposing new dynamical laws or models of mass generation, the work identifies minimal structural criteria required for interpreting physical states as objects, understood operationally as localized, temporally persistent entities with internal structure. Key concepts include microstate capacity as a measure of internal structural multiplicity, the role of relativistic kinematics in distinguishing lightlike and timelike excitations, and the separation between propagating correlations and object-like states. The analysis is model-independent and applies across classical, quantum, and relativistic regimes. Its conclusions are intended as constraints on interpretation rather than as causal explanations.

DOI
10.17605/osf.io/3fhtc

Related papers

Formal Stability Criteria and Timescales for Object-Based Descriptions

Yuliya M. Onishchuk

This work introduces a formal and model-independent criterion for the applicability of object-based descriptions in physics. Objecthood is defined operationally as the structural stability of coarse-grained macrostates under microscopic dynamics, quantified through statistical distance and separation of characteristic timescales. The framework is normative rather than predictive: it does not introduce new physical laws, but clarifies when object-based language is justified and when it necessarily breaks down. An explicit example demonstrates how the abstract stability criterion connects to concrete dynamical parameters without committing to a specific model. The results provide a diagnostic foundation for analyzing limiting regimes in statistical mechanics, quantum theory, and the foundations of physical description. Related work: Onishchuk, Y. Conditions of Objecthood: A Structural Analysis of Energy and Physical States. OSF Registration. DOI: 10.17605/OSF.IO/3FHTC

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

The Objecthood Stability Limit

Yuliya M. Onishchuk

This registration documents a completed theoretical study in fundamental physics and statistical mechanics. The work introduces a universal, model-independent stability criterion for the applicability of object-based descriptions in physical theories. Objecthood is treated not as an ontological primitive, but as an operationally defined regime characterized by (i) a separation of characteristic timescales and (ii) the capacity to support persistent internal records under coarse-grained observation. A dimensionless stability parameter is defined as the ratio between the exit time from a coarse-grained state and the intrinsic relaxation time of the system. The central result is the identification of a sharp threshold below which identity-based language (localization, persistence, re-identification) becomes physically uncontrolled, independently of microscopic dynamics. The registration serves to time-stamp and formally fix the theoretical formulation, definitions, assumptions, and conclusions presented in the associated preprint. No data collection, experimental intervention, or hypothesis testing is planned. The results are normative rather than predictive: they do not modify equations of motion but constrain the domain of physical validity of object-based descriptions across classical, quantum, and relativistic regimes. This registration is intended to establish priority and transparency for a foundational theoretical contribution at the interface of statistical mechanics, quantum foundations, and information theory.

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

The Informational Foundations of Physical Reality

Kevin Ellis-Anderson

This preprint presents a foundations-level analysis of physical description based on structural dependency rather than dynamical construction. Quantum mechanics, classical mechanics, and relativistic spacetime are treated as effective regimes arising under different structural conditions, rather than as competing ontologies. The analysis identifies persistence under interaction, irreversible constraint accumulation, stable relational structure, and interaction as minimal requirements for physical behaviour. Collapse is characterised as irreversible loss of compatibility between alternative continuations, without appeal to observers, stochastic dynamics, or additional postulates. Time is treated as structural ordering induced by exclusion, rather than as a primitive background parameter. No new dynamics are proposed and no empirically successful theories are modified. The aim is to clarify explanatory dependencies that underlie familiar physical regimes and to dissolve persistent foundational problems that arise when regime-level descriptions are misidentified as foundations.

•Jan 9, 2026•0 citations

Causal Residual Probability Expression and Gauge-Compatible Memory Geometry

Charles Bruce Cook

Causal Residual Probability Expression and Gauge-Compatible Memory Geometry develops a self-contained framework for distinguishing available probability structure from its capacity to sustain physical expression through a specified channel. Its central contribution is to separate two requirements that are often treated together: the amount of active structure available and the persistence of relationships across separated times, positions, configurations, or scales. The paper constructs a normalized expression-capacity diagnostic from these requirements while keeping it distinct from probability itself, event occurrence, energy, force, amplitude, and detector response. Beginning with classical probability and covariance, the manuscript identifies two independent failure boundaries: the absence of active extent and the absence of relational persistence. It establishes, under stated regularity assumptions, how a residual that respects both boundaries must incorporate both requirements. Within an explicitly restricted minimal-structure class, this leads to a uniquely determined normalized diagnostic. The paper carefully separates this formal result from the physical expression postulate that gives the diagnostic its interpretation. That interpretation remains conditional on the completeness of the chosen channel and is subject to independent testing; it is not presented as a consequence of covariance analysis alone. A substantial methodological contribution is the specification of how the framework can be measured without introducing target-dependent definitions. The manuscript sets out covariance normalization, treatment of changing active dimensions, compatible comparisons between separated observations, and estimation from repeated matched realizations. It distinguishes properties of an ensemble from properties that can legitimately be assigned to individual configurations. It also requires retention of the underlying correlation record, recognizing that a single expression-capacity score cannot recover phase, orientation, internal structure, or a unique dynamical history. Preregistration, independent calibration, uncertainty reporting, and withheld evaluation are integral parts of the proposed protocol. The paper extends this construction to persistence across scales. It describes how matched microscopic histories can be followed through successive coarse-graining steps using a common feature space and declared identity-transport rules. This makes an important distinction between survival at each adjacent scale and survival across an entire scale sequence. Worked counterexamples demonstrate that repeated local success can coexist with cumulative failure. The resulting scale framework is explicitly application-dependent: its physical implementation requires a specified feature map, renormalization procedure, and retained active sector. To connect expression diagnostics with dynamics, the manuscript incorporates established exact projection methods into a gauge-compatible reduced-response architecture. It explains how degrees of freedom excluded from a chosen description return through retarded memory, while separating exact projection identities from subsequent approximations and physical interpretations. Gauge-invariant observables and appropriately transported comparisons are used to prevent changes of gauge frame from being mistaken for physical loss of persistence. The paper also distinguishes persistent correlation from genuine dynamical memory and distinguishes temporal ordering from relativistic locality. Within this architecture, the manuscript develops conditional applications to weak and strong interaction channels. For weak channels, it identifies the response conditions required for screened spatial behavior and separates screening range from detector thresholds and independently measured mediator masses. For strong channels, it specifies the additional requirements for stable transverse localization, surviving longitudinal support, finite tube energy, and a contribution to stored energy that grows with source separation. It treats Wilson-loop observables, string breaking, and enlargement of the relevant channel description as essential consistency checks. These constructions retain established electroweak and quantum chromodynamic content rather than claiming to derive particle properties or gauge structure from the diagnostic alone. The spectral analysis distinguishes the classical diagnostic from proposed expression operators and their action on physical states. It explains why positive expression capacity for every individual state does not, by itself, establish a common positive lower bound across all physical excitations. The manuscript formulates a conditional spectral-gap theorem and identifies the independent closure and energy-comparison requirements needed to apply it. It further separates intrinsic mass gaps from finite-volume effects, lattice cutoffs, thermal screening, material screening, and finite causal-history effects. Overall, the paper provides a structured theoretical and operational research programme linking probability-domain diagnostics, cross-scale persistence, gauge-compatible memory, and conditional field and spectral consequences. Its achievements include explicit definitions, formal results within declared assumptions, measurement protocols, worked counterexamples, control and falsification matrices, and clearly stated proof obligations. It does not claim a completed fundamental theory, an empirical confirmation of the framework, a derivation of observed gauge groups or numerical couplings, or a solution to the Yang–Mills mass-gap problem. Its intended contribution is a testable architecture that makes those remaining tasks precise and prevents conditional results from being presented as completed physical explanations.

•Nov 12, 2026•0 citations

Extended Objects and Bound Systems; From Relativistic Description to Phenomenological Application: Proceedings of the International Symposium

Osamu Hara, Shin Ishida, S. Naka

•Feb 1, 1993•1 citation

The Timeless Light Model: A Minimal Interpretive Completion of Relativistic Constraints

John Christian William McKinley

This paper presents the Timeless Light Model (TLM) as a minimal interpretive completion of standard relativistic constraints on massless excitations. Building on the kinematic result that photons admit no inertial rest frame and experience no proper-time evolution along null propagation, the paper examines how photon language can be used consistently once these constraints are taken seriously. The work makes no dynamical proposals and introduces no new physical structure. Instead, it addresses a persistent mismatch between common informal descriptions of photons as persisting spacetime objects and the resources actually provided by special relativity, general relativity, and quantum field theory. The Timeless Light Model articulates an explicit interpretive discipline in which “photon” language is treated as shorthand for null-mediated correlations between localized interaction events (emission and absorption), rather than as the name of a persisting object with a rest-frame-based internal history. The paper is deliberately conservative and empirically neutral. It does not claim unique correctness, nor does it compete with existing formalisms or interpretations. Its contribution is pedagogical and conceptual: to make explicit a constraint on informal interpretation that is already implicit in relativistic kinematics and field-theoretic practice, thereby reducing a common category error in discussions of photon persistence. This work serves as a companion to No Rest Frame, No Persistence: A Kinematic Constraint on Photon Interpretation, which establishes the underlying no-go result.

•Dec 21, 2025•0 citations
This project presents a structural and normative analysis of the conditions under which an object-based descriptive language is physically applicable. Rather than proposing new dynamical laws or models of mass generation, the work identifies minimal structural criteria required for interpreting physical states as objects, understood operationally as localized, temporally persistent entities with internal structure. Key concepts include microstate capacity as a measure of internal structural multiplicity, the role of relativistic kinematics in distinguishing lightlike and timelike excitations, and the separation between propagating correlations and object-like states. The analysis is model-independent and applies across classical, quantum, and relativistic regimes. Its conclusions are intended as constraints on interpretation rather than as causal explanations.
This work introduces a formal and model-independent criterion for the applicability of object-based descriptions in physics. Objecthood is defined operationally as the structural stability of coarse-grained macrostates under microscopic dynamics, quantified through statistical distance and separation of characteristic timescales. The framework is normative rather than predictive: it does not introduce new physical laws, but clarifies when object-based language is justified and when it necessarily breaks down. An explicit example demonstrates how the abstract stability criterion connects to concrete dynamical parameters without committing to a specific model. The results provide a diagnostic foundation for analyzing limiting regimes in statistical mechanics, quantum theory, and the foundations of physical description. Related work: Onishchuk, Y. Conditions of Objecthood: A Structural Analysis of Energy and Physical States. OSF Registration. DOI: 10.17605/OSF.IO/3FHTC
This registration documents a completed theoretical study in fundamental physics and statistical mechanics. The work introduces a universal, model-independent stability criterion for the applicability of object-based descriptions in physical theories. Objecthood is treated not as an ontological primitive, but as an operationally defined regime characterized by (i) a separation of characteristic timescales and (ii) the capacity to support persistent internal records under coarse-grained observation. A dimensionless stability parameter is defined as the ratio between the exit time from a coarse-grained state and the intrinsic relaxation time of the system. The central result is the identification of a sharp threshold below which identity-based language (localization, persistence, re-identification) becomes physically uncontrolled, independently of microscopic dynamics. The registration serves to time-stamp and formally fix the theoretical formulation, definitions, assumptions, and conclusions presented in the associated preprint. No data collection, experimental intervention, or hypothesis testing is planned. The results are normative rather than predictive: they do not modify equations of motion but constrain the domain of physical validity of object-based descriptions across classical, quantum, and relativistic regimes. This registration is intended to establish priority and transparency for a foundational theoretical contribution at the interface of statistical mechanics, quantum foundations, and information theory.
This preprint presents a foundations-level analysis of physical description based on structural dependency rather than dynamical construction. Quantum mechanics, classical mechanics, and relativistic spacetime are treated as effective regimes arising under different structural conditions, rather than as competing ontologies. The analysis identifies persistence under interaction, irreversible constraint accumulation, stable relational structure, and interaction as minimal requirements for physical behaviour. Collapse is characterised as irreversible loss of compatibility between alternative continuations, without appeal to observers, stochastic dynamics, or additional postulates. Time is treated as structural ordering induced by exclusion, rather than as a primitive background parameter. No new dynamics are proposed and no empirically successful theories are modified. The aim is to clarify explanatory dependencies that underlie familiar physical regimes and to dissolve persistent foundational problems that arise when regime-level descriptions are misidentified as foundations.
Causal Residual Probability Expression and Gauge-Compatible Memory Geometry develops a self-contained framework for distinguishing available probability structure from its capacity to sustain physical expression through a specified channel. Its central contribution is to separate two requirements that are often treated together: the amount of active structure available and the persistence of relationships across separated times, positions, configurations, or scales. The paper constructs a normalized expression-capacity diagnostic from these requirements while keeping it distinct from probability itself, event occurrence, energy, force, amplitude, and detector response. Beginning with classical probability and covariance, the manuscript identifies two independent failure boundaries: the absence of active extent and the absence of relational persistence. It establishes, under stated regularity assumptions, how a residual that respects both boundaries must incorporate both requirements. Within an explicitly restricted minimal-structure class, this leads to a uniquely determined normalized diagnostic. The paper carefully separates this formal result from the physical expression postulate that gives the diagnostic its interpretation. That interpretation remains conditional on the completeness of the chosen channel and is subject to independent testing; it is not presented as a consequence of covariance analysis alone. A substantial methodological contribution is the specification of how the framework can be measured without introducing target-dependent definitions. The manuscript sets out covariance normalization, treatment of changing active dimensions, compatible comparisons between separated observations, and estimation from repeated matched realizations. It distinguishes properties of an ensemble from properties that can legitimately be assigned to individual configurations. It also requires retention of the underlying correlation record, recognizing that a single expression-capacity score cannot recover phase, orientation, internal structure, or a unique dynamical history. Preregistration, independent calibration, uncertainty reporting, and withheld evaluation are integral parts of the proposed protocol. The paper extends this construction to persistence across scales. It describes how matched microscopic histories can be followed through successive coarse-graining steps using a common feature space and declared identity-transport rules. This makes an important distinction between survival at each adjacent scale and survival across an entire scale sequence. Worked counterexamples demonstrate that repeated local success can coexist with cumulative failure. The resulting scale framework is explicitly application-dependent: its physical implementation requires a specified feature map, renormalization procedure, and retained active sector. To connect expression diagnostics with dynamics, the manuscript incorporates established exact projection methods into a gauge-compatible reduced-response architecture. It explains how degrees of freedom excluded from a chosen description return through retarded memory, while separating exact projection identities from subsequent approximations and physical interpretations. Gauge-invariant observables and appropriately transported comparisons are used to prevent changes of gauge frame from being mistaken for physical loss of persistence. The paper also distinguishes persistent correlation from genuine dynamical memory and distinguishes temporal ordering from relativistic locality. Within this architecture, the manuscript develops conditional applications to weak and strong interaction channels. For weak channels, it identifies the response conditions required for screened spatial behavior and separates screening range from detector thresholds and independently measured mediator masses. For strong channels, it specifies the additional requirements for stable transverse localization, surviving longitudinal support, finite tube energy, and a contribution to stored energy that grows with source separation. It treats Wilson-loop observables, string breaking, and enlargement of the relevant channel description as essential consistency checks. These constructions retain established electroweak and quantum chromodynamic content rather than claiming to derive particle properties or gauge structure from the diagnostic alone. The spectral analysis distinguishes the classical diagnostic from proposed expression operators and their action on physical states. It explains why positive expression capacity for every individual state does not, by itself, establish a common positive lower bound across all physical excitations. The manuscript formulates a conditional spectral-gap theorem and identifies the independent closure and energy-comparison requirements needed to apply it. It further separates intrinsic mass gaps from finite-volume effects, lattice cutoffs, thermal screening, material screening, and finite causal-history effects. Overall, the paper provides a structured theoretical and operational research programme linking probability-domain diagnostics, cross-scale persistence, gauge-compatible memory, and conditional field and spectral consequences. Its achievements include explicit definitions, formal results within declared assumptions, measurement protocols, worked counterexamples, control and falsification matrices, and clearly stated proof obligations. It does not claim a completed fundamental theory, an empirical confirmation of the framework, a derivation of observed gauge groups or numerical couplings, or a solution to the Yang–Mills mass-gap problem. Its intended contribution is a testable architecture that makes those remaining tasks precise and prevents conditional results from being presented as completed physical explanations.
This paper presents the Timeless Light Model (TLM) as a minimal interpretive completion of standard relativistic constraints on massless excitations. Building on the kinematic result that photons admit no inertial rest frame and experience no proper-time evolution along null propagation, the paper examines how photon language can be used consistently once these constraints are taken seriously. The work makes no dynamical proposals and introduces no new physical structure. Instead, it addresses a persistent mismatch between common informal descriptions of photons as persisting spacetime objects and the resources actually provided by special relativity, general relativity, and quantum field theory. The Timeless Light Model articulates an explicit interpretive discipline in which “photon” language is treated as shorthand for null-mediated correlations between localized interaction events (emission and absorption), rather than as the name of a persisting object with a rest-frame-based internal history. The paper is deliberately conservative and empirically neutral. It does not claim unique correctness, nor does it compete with existing formalisms or interpretations. Its contribution is pedagogical and conceptual: to make explicit a constraint on informal interpretation that is already implicit in relativistic kinematics and field-theoretic practice, thereby reducing a common category error in discussions of photon persistence. This work serves as a companion to No Rest Frame, No Persistence: A Kinematic Constraint on Photon Interpretation, which establishes the underlying no-go result.