Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Ontogenesis, Part 2

Sergei Viznyuk

Published Jan 1, 2025• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

I expound on QM formalism, to reach conclusions on several topics of interest, and answer some questions:1. What is the amount of information in measuring device output?2. What determines the output of measuring device, aka quantum state?3. What is the amount of information required to set device to a certain configuration?4. What is the relation between preparation and measuring device?5. What is the relation between quantum state and quantum ensemble?6. Is there a boundary between measuring device and measured entity?7. Does quantum state (aka wave function) collapse upon measurement?8. Are event outcomes truly probabilistic as commonly believed?9. What is the significance of global phase?10. What is the boundary between measuring device and observer?11. What is the role of observer, debated since very inception of quantum mechanics?

DOI
10.6084/m9.figshare.30951083

Related papers

There is no quantum measurement problem

N. David Mermin

The idea that the collapse of a quantum state is a physical process stems from a misunderstanding of probability and the role it plays in quantum mechanics.

Physics Today•Jun 1, 2022•32 citations

The Quantum Agreement Theorem

María García Díaz, Adam Brandenburger, Giannicola Scarpa

Intersubjective consistency asks when different observers of a physical system, reasoning from a shared theory, will agree on their probability assessments. Classical probability theory provides a benchmark in the form of the Agreement Theorem (Aumann, 1976). We study the quantum mechanics (QM) analog to the classical Agreement Theorem in a finite-dimensional tripartite setting in which two observers obtain information via local projective measurements. We represent their mutual awareness by common certainty, which is formally an infinite hierarchy of certainty operators concerning the probability of an event of interest. We first prove that if the observers' measurements commute with one another and with the property of interest, common certainty forces their probability assessments to coincide, thereby recovering a QM analog to the classical Agreement Theorem. We then construct a one-parameter family of qutrit-qubit-qubit models in which one observer's measurement does not commute with the property and common certainty of disagreement occurs -- a distinctively QM phenomenon. The mechanism is coherence between branches distinguished by one but not the other observer's measurement. When measurement outcomes are stored in a classical register, the resulting dephasing removes this coherence and restores agreement. Finally, we prove that QM does not permit the extreme 0-1 configuration in which Alice is certain of a property and is also certain that Bob is certain of its negation. These results aim to turn debate in QM about observer-dependent facts into precise mathematical conditions for when intersubjective agreement or disagreement in QM can be sustained.

quant-pharXiv:2511.21258•Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences•Nov 27, 2025•2 citations

Quantum measurement: a game between observer and nature?

Lizhi Xin, Houwen Xin

What is the observer's role in quantum measurement? Obviously, observers prepare the apparatus, observe and interpret the measured results. Although the observer will have a certain influence on the measurement results by setting up the measuring apparatus, we don't believe human consciousness cause reducing of wave packet; also observers are certainly required to interpret the measured results with physical meanings. We believe observers build up their experience of the external world by playing games with nature, and then "decode" the nature based on their experiences. We propose a quantum decision theory approach to explain the role of the observer in quantum measurements, and pointed out that a set of quantum decision trees (strategies to answer natural questions with yes/no logic) can be optimized to deal with the challenges of nature through quantum genetic programming based on maximization of the expected value of the observers; Quantum decision trees can discover the dynamics rules of quantum entities and Just as classical mechanics uses the principle of least action to obtain the trajectories of particles, we use the principle of maximum expected value to approximately obtain the kinematic "trajectories" of quantum entities by learning from natural historical "events" (measured results); even we can "reconstruct" the past of quantum entity, because we don't know the prior information of quantum entity, it is very difficult to predict the future of the nature.

arXiv:2210.16766•Oct 30, 2022•3 citations

Can We Determine the Role of the Observer in Quantum Mechanics?

Fred H. Thaheld

Physics Essays•Jun 1, 1998•0 citations

Can We Consider Quantum Mechanics to Be a Description of Reality?

Hervé Zwirn C

Springer eBooks•Jan 1, 2008•3 citations

Quantum formalism for events and how time can emerge from its foundations

Eduardo O. Dias

Although time is one of our most intuitive physical concepts, its understanding at the fundamental level is still an open question in physics. For instance, time in quantum mechanics and general relativity are two distinct and incompatible entities. While relativity deals with events (points in spacetime), with time being observer dependent and dynamical, quantum mechanics describes physical systems by treating time as an independent parameter. To resolve this conflict, in this work, we extend the classical concept of an event to the quantum domain by defining an event as a transfer of information between physical systems. Then, by describing the universe from the perspective of a certain observer, we introduce quantum states of events with space-time-symmetric wave functions that predict the joint probability distribution of a measurement (observation) at $(t,\stackrel{P\vec}{x})$. Under these circumstances, without assuming collapse, we propose that a well-defined instant of time, like any other observable, arises from a single event, thus being an observer-dependent property. In this manner, we obtain a stationary quantum state written as a sum of a sequence of normalized states of events with increasing memories. As a consequence, a counterfactual asymmetry along this sequence of events gives rise to the flow of time as being successive ``snapshots'' from the observer's perspective. In this proposal, which contrasts strikingly to the view in which time is an illusion, it is the many distinguishable states in which the observer stores information that makes the existence of time possible.

arXiv:2007.00513•Physical Review A•Jan 21, 2021•11 citations
I expound on QM formalism, to reach conclusions on several topics of interest, and answer some questions:1. What is the amount of information in measuring device output?2. What determines the output of measuring device, aka quantum state?3. What is the amount of information required to set device to a certain configuration?4. What is the relation between preparation and measuring device?5. What is the relation between quantum state and quantum ensemble?6. Is there a boundary between measuring device and measured entity?7. Does quantum state (aka wave function) collapse upon measurement?8. Are event outcomes truly probabilistic as commonly believed?9. What is the significance of global phase?10. What is the boundary between measuring device and observer?11. What is the role of observer, debated since very inception of quantum mechanics?
Intersubjective consistency asks when different observers of a physical system, reasoning from a shared theory, will agree on their probability assessments. Classical probability theory provides a benchmark in the form of the Agreement Theorem (Aumann, 1976). We study the quantum mechanics (QM) analog to the classical Agreement Theorem in a finite-dimensional tripartite setting in which two observers obtain information via local projective measurements. We represent their mutual awareness by common certainty, which is formally an infinite hierarchy of certainty operators concerning the probability of an event of interest. We first prove that if the observers' measurements commute with one another and with the property of interest, common certainty forces their probability assessments to coincide, thereby recovering a QM analog to the classical Agreement Theorem. We then construct a one-parameter family of qutrit-qubit-qubit models in which one observer's measurement does not commute with the property and common certainty of disagreement occurs -- a distinctively QM phenomenon. The mechanism is coherence between branches distinguished by one but not the other observer's measurement. When measurement outcomes are stored in a classical register, the resulting dephasing removes this coherence and restores agreement. Finally, we prove that QM does not permit the extreme 0-1 configuration in which Alice is certain of a property and is also certain that Bob is certain of its negation. These results aim to turn debate in QM about observer-dependent facts into precise mathematical conditions for when intersubjective agreement or disagreement in QM can be sustained.
What is the observer's role in quantum measurement? Obviously, observers prepare the apparatus, observe and interpret the measured results. Although the observer will have a certain influence on the measurement results by setting up the measuring apparatus, we don't believe human consciousness cause reducing of wave packet; also observers are certainly required to interpret the measured results with physical meanings. We believe observers build up their experience of the external world by playing games with nature, and then "decode" the nature based on their experiences. We propose a quantum decision theory approach to explain the role of the observer in quantum measurements, and pointed out that a set of quantum decision trees (strategies to answer natural questions with yes/no logic) can be optimized to deal with the challenges of nature through quantum genetic programming based on maximization of the expected value of the observers; Quantum decision trees can discover the dynamics rules of quantum entities and Just as classical mechanics uses the principle of least action to obtain the trajectories of particles, we use the principle of maximum expected value to approximately obtain the kinematic "trajectories" of quantum entities by learning from natural historical "events" (measured results); even we can "reconstruct" the past of quantum entity, because we don't know the prior information of quantum entity, it is very difficult to predict the future of the nature.
Although time is one of our most intuitive physical concepts, its understanding at the fundamental level is still an open question in physics. For instance, time in quantum mechanics and general relativity are two distinct and incompatible entities. While relativity deals with events (points in spacetime), with time being observer dependent and dynamical, quantum mechanics describes physical systems by treating time as an independent parameter. To resolve this conflict, in this work, we extend the classical concept of an event to the quantum domain by defining an event as a transfer of information between physical systems. Then, by describing the universe from the perspective of a certain observer, we introduce quantum states of events with space-time-symmetric wave functions that predict the joint probability distribution of a measurement (observation) at $(t,\stackrel{P\vec}{x})$. Under these circumstances, without assuming collapse, we propose that a well-defined instant of time, like any other observable, arises from a single event, thus being an observer-dependent property. In this manner, we obtain a stationary quantum state written as a sum of a sequence of normalized states of events with increasing memories. As a consequence, a counterfactual asymmetry along this sequence of events gives rise to the flow of time as being successive ``snapshots'' from the observer's perspective. In this proposal, which contrasts strikingly to the view in which time is an illusion, it is the many distinguishable states in which the observer stores information that makes the existence of time possible.