Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

American Journal of Physics

Density operators and quantum tomography for optimizing a Bell parameter measurement in the graduate laboratory

Alban Leschallier de Lisle, Marina Kleine, Nicolas Ombredane, Sébastien Massenot, Renaud Mathevet, Bénoît Chalopin

Published Dec 23, 2025• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We discuss how quantum state tomography of entangled photon pairs can be used in the lab as a natural follow-up to popular Bell inequalities experiments for graduate students and to introduce them to more advanced quantum concepts. In addition, we discuss how the measured density matrix can be used to quantitatively estimate the quantum state quality and optimize the Bell measurement to reach its maximum expected value for an arbitrary two-photon entangled state.

DOI
10.1119/5.0280007

Related papers

Undergraduate setup for measuring the Bell inequalities and performing quantum state tomography

Raul Lahoz Sanz, Lidia Lozano‐Martín, A. B. CORTES +3 more

The growth of quantum technologies is attracting the interest of many students eager to learn concepts such as quantum entanglement or quantum superposition. However, the non-intuitive nature of these concepts poses a challenge to understanding them. Here, we present an entangled photon system which can perform a Bell test, i.e. the CHSH inequality, and can obtain the complete tomography of the two-photon state. The proposed setup is versatile, cost-effective and allows for multiple classroom operating modes. We present two variants, both facilitating the measurement of Bell inequalities and quantum state tomography. Experimental results showcase successful manipulation of the quantum state of the photons, achieving high-fidelity entangled states and significant violations of Bell's inequalities. Our setup's simplicity and affordability enhances accessibility for less specialized laboratories, allowing students to familiarize themselves with quantum physics concepts.

arXiv:2407.11570•EPJ Quantum Technology•Dec 1, 2024•7 citations

Testing the Bell’s inequality violations with mixed entangled photons

Weijie Guo, Lian-Fu Wei, Dai-He Fan

Bell’s inequality plays an important role in quantum mechanics. Many experiments have been made to test the Bell’s inequality by using various bipartite entangled sources. However, the maximal violation of the Bell inequality (i.e., the Cirel’son’s limit) has not been reached yet, due to various practically-existing imperfections (e.g., entangled source is not the pure maximally-entangled state, and the measurement settings used are not the best ones). In this paper, we investigate experimentally an approach to enhance the violation degree of Bell’s inequality with the commercialized entangled photons by optimizing the measurement settings for the experimentally-reconstructed density matrix of the entangled photons. It is shown that the measurement setting related to the pure entangled state can not get maximally violation generally. However, upon the density matrix reconstructed by tomographic technique, optimal measurement settings can be found. With these optimal settings, we consequently found that the violation degree of the Bell’s inequality can be increased. This suggests a possible approach to optimize the test of Bell’s inequality.

Zhongguo kexue. Wulixue Lixue Tianwenxue•Aug 1, 2013•0 citations

Optimal estimation of parameters of an entangled quantum state

Salvatore Virzì, Alessio Avella, F Piacentini +4 more

Two-photon entangled quantum states are a fundamental tool for quantum information and quantum cryptography. A complete description of a generic quantum state is provided by its density matrix: the technique allowing experimental reconstruction of the density matrix is called quantum state tomography. Entangled states density matrix reconstruction requires a large number of measurements on many identical copies of the quantum state. An alternative way of certifying the amount of entanglement in two-photon states is represented by the estimation of specific parameters, e.g., negativity and concurrence. If we have a priori partial knowledge of our state, it's possible to develop several estimators for these parameters that require lower amount of measurements with respect to full density matrix reconstruction. The aim of this work is to introduce and test different estimators for negativity and concurrence for a specific class of two-photon states.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•May 1, 2017•2 citations

On the Measurement of Qubits

Daniel F. V. James, Paul G. Kwiat, William J. Munro +1 more

We describe in detail the theory underpinning the measurement of density matrices of a pair of quantum two-level systems (``qubits''). Our particular emphasis is on qubits realized by the two polarization degrees of freedom of a pair of entangled photons generated in a down-conversion experiment; however the discussion applies in general, regardless of the actual physical realization. Two techniques are discussed, namely a tomographic reconstruction (in which the density matrix is linearly related to a set of measured quantities) and a maximum likelihood technique which requires numerical optimization (but has the advantage of producing density matrices which are always non-negative definite). In addition a detailed error analysis is presented, allowing errors in quantities derived from the density matrix, such as the entropy or entanglement of formation, to be estimated. Examples based on down-conversion experiments are used to illustrate our results.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Feb 1, 2005•31 citations

Measurement of qubits

Daniel F. V. James, Paul G. Kwiat, William J. Munro +1 more

We describe in detail the theory underpinning the measurement of density matrices of a pair of quantum two-level systems (``qubits''). Our particular emphasis is on qubits realized by the two polarization degrees of freedom of a pair of entangled photons generated in a down-conversion experiment; however, the discussion applies in general, regardless of the actual physical realization. Two techniques are discussed, namely, a tomographic reconstruction (in which the density matrix is linearly related to a set of measured quantities) and a maximum likelihood technique which requires numerical optimization (but has the advantage of producing density matrices that are always non-negative definite). In addition, a detailed error analysis is presented, allowing errors in quantities derived from the density matrix, such as the entropy or entanglement of formation, to be estimated. Examples based on down-conversion experiments are used to illustrate our results.

arXiv:quant-ph/0103121•Physical Review A•Oct 16, 2001•2,214 citations

Complete Measurement of Two-Photon Density Matrix by Single-Photon Detection

Salini Rajeev, Mayukh Lahiri

The reconstruction of density matrices from measurement data (quantum state tomography) is the most comprehensive method for assessing the accuracy and performance of quantum devices. Existing methods to reconstruct two-photon density matrices require the detection of both photons unless a priori information is available. Based on the concept of quantum-induced coherence by path identity, we present an approach to quantum state tomography that circumvents the requirement of detecting both photons. We show that an arbitrary two-qubit density matrix, which can contain up to fifteen free parameters, can be fully reconstructed from single-photon measurement data without any postselection and a priori information. In addition to advancing an alternative approach to quantum state measurement problems, our results also have notable practical implications. A practical challenge in quantum state measurement arises from the fact that effective single-photon detectors are not readily accessible for a wide spectral range. Our method, which eliminates the need for coincidence measurements, enables quantum state tomography in the case where one of the two photons is challenging or impossible to detect. It therefore opens the door to measuring quantum states hitherto inaccessible.

arXiv:2503.07999•Mar 11, 2025•1 citation
We discuss how quantum state tomography of entangled photon pairs can be used in the lab as a natural follow-up to popular Bell inequalities experiments for graduate students and to introduce them to more advanced quantum concepts. In addition, we discuss how the measured density matrix can be used to quantitatively estimate the quantum state quality and optimize the Bell measurement to reach its maximum expected value for an arbitrary two-photon entangled state.
The growth of quantum technologies is attracting the interest of many students eager to learn concepts such as quantum entanglement or quantum superposition. However, the non-intuitive nature of these concepts poses a challenge to understanding them. Here, we present an entangled photon system which can perform a Bell test, i.e. the CHSH inequality, and can obtain the complete tomography of the two-photon state. The proposed setup is versatile, cost-effective and allows for multiple classroom operating modes. We present two variants, both facilitating the measurement of Bell inequalities and quantum state tomography. Experimental results showcase successful manipulation of the quantum state of the photons, achieving high-fidelity entangled states and significant violations of Bell's inequalities. Our setup's simplicity and affordability enhances accessibility for less specialized laboratories, allowing students to familiarize themselves with quantum physics concepts.
Bell’s inequality plays an important role in quantum mechanics. Many experiments have been made to test the Bell’s inequality by using various bipartite entangled sources. However, the maximal violation of the Bell inequality (i.e., the Cirel’son’s limit) has not been reached yet, due to various practically-existing imperfections (e.g., entangled source is not the pure maximally-entangled state, and the measurement settings used are not the best ones). In this paper, we investigate experimentally an approach to enhance the violation degree of Bell’s inequality with the commercialized entangled photons by optimizing the measurement settings for the experimentally-reconstructed density matrix of the entangled photons. It is shown that the measurement setting related to the pure entangled state can not get maximally violation generally. However, upon the density matrix reconstructed by tomographic technique, optimal measurement settings can be found. With these optimal settings, we consequently found that the violation degree of the Bell’s inequality can be increased. This suggests a possible approach to optimize the test of Bell’s inequality.
Two-photon entangled quantum states are a fundamental tool for quantum information and quantum cryptography. A complete description of a generic quantum state is provided by its density matrix: the technique allowing experimental reconstruction of the density matrix is called quantum state tomography. Entangled states density matrix reconstruction requires a large number of measurements on many identical copies of the quantum state. An alternative way of certifying the amount of entanglement in two-photon states is represented by the estimation of specific parameters, e.g., negativity and concurrence. If we have a priori partial knowledge of our state, it's possible to develop several estimators for these parameters that require lower amount of measurements with respect to full density matrix reconstruction. The aim of this work is to introduce and test different estimators for negativity and concurrence for a specific class of two-photon states.
We describe in detail the theory underpinning the measurement of density matrices of a pair of quantum two-level systems (``qubits''). Our particular emphasis is on qubits realized by the two polarization degrees of freedom of a pair of entangled photons generated in a down-conversion experiment; however the discussion applies in general, regardless of the actual physical realization. Two techniques are discussed, namely a tomographic reconstruction (in which the density matrix is linearly related to a set of measured quantities) and a maximum likelihood technique which requires numerical optimization (but has the advantage of producing density matrices which are always non-negative definite). In addition a detailed error analysis is presented, allowing errors in quantities derived from the density matrix, such as the entropy or entanglement of formation, to be estimated. Examples based on down-conversion experiments are used to illustrate our results.
We describe in detail the theory underpinning the measurement of density matrices of a pair of quantum two-level systems (``qubits''). Our particular emphasis is on qubits realized by the two polarization degrees of freedom of a pair of entangled photons generated in a down-conversion experiment; however, the discussion applies in general, regardless of the actual physical realization. Two techniques are discussed, namely, a tomographic reconstruction (in which the density matrix is linearly related to a set of measured quantities) and a maximum likelihood technique which requires numerical optimization (but has the advantage of producing density matrices that are always non-negative definite). In addition, a detailed error analysis is presented, allowing errors in quantities derived from the density matrix, such as the entropy or entanglement of formation, to be estimated. Examples based on down-conversion experiments are used to illustrate our results.
The reconstruction of density matrices from measurement data (quantum state tomography) is the most comprehensive method for assessing the accuracy and performance of quantum devices. Existing methods to reconstruct two-photon density matrices require the detection of both photons unless a priori information is available. Based on the concept of quantum-induced coherence by path identity, we present an approach to quantum state tomography that circumvents the requirement of detecting both photons. We show that an arbitrary two-qubit density matrix, which can contain up to fifteen free parameters, can be fully reconstructed from single-photon measurement data without any postselection and a priori information. In addition to advancing an alternative approach to quantum state measurement problems, our results also have notable practical implications. A practical challenge in quantum state measurement arises from the fact that effective single-photon detectors are not readily accessible for a wide spectral range. Our method, which eliminates the need for coincidence measurements, enables quantum state tomography in the case where one of the two photons is challenging or impossible to detect. It therefore opens the door to measuring quantum states hitherto inaccessible.