Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physics-Bounded Computational Substrate: A Brief Synthesis of Thermodynamic Limits in Analog and Quantum Information Processing

QNFO

Published Dec 17, 2025• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The physical realization of any computational model is fundamentally bounded not by algorithmic complexity alone, but by the thermodynamic and quantum statistical limits of its substrate, a constraint that recasts computationally hard problems as problems of physical resource scaling and forces a distinction between abstract universality and practical realizability.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.17967800

Related papers

Physical Capacity Regions of Computation

Michael Rey

We establish a unified framework for understanding the fundamental physical limits of computation by developing a geometric theory of resource trade-offs. Our approach treats computation as a physical process constrained by thermodynamics, quantum mechanics, and relativity, leading to a multidimensional capacity region in resource space. We prove that any algorithm achieving error ε on problem class P must satisfy joint constraints across five dimensions: space S, time T, bandwidth H, energy E, and coherence C. The capacity region is characterized by fundamental physical constants: Landauer’s principle (kBT ln 2 per bit erasure), the Margolus-Levitin quantum speed limit (2E/(π~) operations per second), the Bekenstein bound (maximum information density), and statistical sampling limits. We provide explicit constructions showing these bounds are achievable within constant factors for canonical problems including matrix multiplication, covariance estimation, and Gaussian process inference. This framework unifies classical complexity theory with quantum information and thermodynamics, providing the first general theory of multi-resource computational limits with applications to algorithm design, hardware optimization, and fundamental physics.

•Sep 1, 2025•0 citations

Introduction and Background

Phillip Kaye, Raymond Laflamme, Michele Mosca

A computer is a physical device that helps us process information by executing algorithms. An algorithm is a well-defined procedure, with finite description, for realizing an information-processing task. An information-processing task can always be translated into a physical task. When designing complex algorithms and protocols for various information-processing tasks, it is very helpful, perhaps essential, to work with some idealized computing model. However, when studying the true limitations of a computing device, especially for some practical reason, it is important not to forget the relationship between computing and physics. Real computing devices are embodied in a larger and often richer physical reality than is represented by the idealized computing model. Quantum information processing is the result of using the physical reality that quantum theory tells us about for the purposes of performing tasks that were previously thought impossible or infeasible. Devices that perform quantum information processing are known as quantum computers. In this book we examine how quantum computers can be used to solve certain problems more efficiently than can be done with classical computers, and also how this can be done reliably even when there is a possibility for errors to occur. In this first chapter we present some fundamental notions of computation theory and quantum physics that will form the basis for much of what follows. After this brief introduction, we will review the necessary tools from linear algebra in Chapter 2, and detail the framework of quantum mechanics, as relevant to our model of quantum computation, in Chapter 3. In the remainder of the book we examine quantum teleportation, quantum algorithms and quantum error correction in detail. We are often interested in the amount of resources used by a computer to solve a problem, and we refer to this as the complexity of the computation. An important resource for a computer is time. Another resource is space, which refers to the amount of memory used by the computer in performing the computation. We measure the amount of a resource used in a computation for solving a given problem as a function of the length of the input of an instance of that problem.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Nov 16, 2006•0 citations

Quantum mechanical computation

James D. Brasher

The physics and the mathematics of computation are examined to provide a foundation and perspective for the investigation of the quantum mechanics of computation. Our purpose is to explore the fundamental limits and constraints imposed on computation by Nature through the laws of physics and the mathematics of computational complexity. Inasmuch as information storage and transmission are an integral part of computation, their physical bounds are considered. The computer is viewed both physically and mathematically as a dynamical system, and is depicted in terms of the basic Turing machine paradigm. Three fundamental classes of the Turing machine are defined; the deterministic, stochastic and quantum Turing machines. Hamiltonian models and physical realizations of quantum computing are described. Quantum computers can perform some tasks which have no classical analogue, but they cannot compute functions that are non-computable by classical means. Some classically intractable problems can be solved with quantum computers.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Mar 1, 1994•0 citations

Computational Constraints on Quantum State Transitions in a Finite-Resource Substrate: A Reinterpretation of the Uncertainty Principle and the Derivation of the Operational Density Zquant

Yuhei Miyazaki

Within the framework of the Computational Resource Finiteness Hypothesis (CRFH), this work presents a computational reinterpretation of the quantum mechanical uncertainty principle as a constraint arising from finite operational resources on a Universal Substrate. Uncertainty is shown to emerge from unavoidable competition between information writing and state-transition buffering, rather than from intrinsic randomness or measurement disturbance. By imposing resource conservation expressed through $L^2$-norm preservation and minimizing operational dissipation, we derive an effective operational density that converges to a stable rated point,\[Z_{\mathrm{quant}} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}} \approx 0.707 .\]This value is interpreted not as an exact instantaneous bound, but as an engineering-rated operating point ensuring long-term stability under finite computational capacity. The result suggests that probabilistic structures in quantum mechanics may reflect an underlying optimization principle governing resource allocation on the Universal Substrate. This formulation provides a scale-consistent bridge between microscopic uncertainty relations and macroscopic operational density limits observed in larger physical systems.

•Jan 6, 2026•0 citations

Ultrametric Physics: Module 7: Thermodynamic Limits with Scaling Ratios

Rowan Brad Quni-Gudzinas

The laws of thermodynamics impose fundamental limits on all physical computation, determining minimum energy requirements, maximum operating temperatures, and ultimate scalability. In the ratio-based framework, the hierarchical tree structure with scaling ratio $q$ creates a distinctive energy landscape with barriers scaling as $E_{\text{barrier}} \propto q^d$, where $d$ is tree depth. This fundamentally alters thermodynamic constraints compared to conventional quantum architectures, introducing the scaling ratio $q$ as a key optimization parameter in thermodynamic tradeoffs.

•Apr 6, 2026•0 citations

Fully Quantum Computational Entropies

Avidan, Noam, Thomas A. Hahn, Joseph M. Renes +1 more

Quantum information theory has provided the formal framework for describing how information is stored, transmitted, and transformed in physical quantum systems [6, 7, 9]. Its entropic formulations underpin our understanding of quantum computation, communication, and cryptography. Yet this theory traditionally treats all quantum operations as freely available, ignoring computational restrictions. In practice, however, any manipulation of quantum information must be performed by devices of bounded complexity and runtime. Capturing such realistic constraints requires extending quantum information theory to include computational efficiency as a fundamental component.This work takes a first step toward building a computational version of quantum information theory, one that treats efficiency as part of the theory itself. The goal is to understand how the behavior of quantum information changes when the parties involved can only perform computationally efficient operations. This approach bridges the abstract, ideal setting of quantum information theory with the practical limitations of real quantum devices, offering a means to study information processing under realistic resource constraints.At the center of this work are two new quantities: the quantum computational min-entropy and the quantum computational max-entropy. These entropies extend standard quantum entropies by explicitly limiting the computational power of the observer or adversary. The quantum computational min-entropy captures how unpredictable a quantum system A remains to an observer holding system B, when that observer is restricted to quantum circuits of bounded size. Formally, for a bipartite state rho AB, we define(c) H-s (min)(A|B)rho := - log d(A) max (epsilon s) B > A' F ((parallel to(A)circle times epsilon(s))(rho(AB)),|Phi (AA')> Quantum information theory; Theory of computation -> Quantum complexity theory

arXiv:2506.14068•Leibniz international proceedings in informatics•Jun 16, 2025•5 citations
The physical realization of any computational model is fundamentally bounded not by algorithmic complexity alone, but by the thermodynamic and quantum statistical limits of its substrate, a constraint that recasts computationally hard problems as problems of physical resource scaling and forces a distinction between abstract universality and practical realizability.
We establish a unified framework for understanding the fundamental physical limits of computation by developing a geometric theory of resource trade-offs. Our approach treats computation as a physical process constrained by thermodynamics, quantum mechanics, and relativity, leading to a multidimensional capacity region in resource space. We prove that any algorithm achieving error ε on problem class P must satisfy joint constraints across five dimensions: space S, time T, bandwidth H, energy E, and coherence C. The capacity region is characterized by fundamental physical constants: Landauer’s principle (kBT ln 2 per bit erasure), the Margolus-Levitin quantum speed limit (2E/(π~) operations per second), the Bekenstein bound (maximum information density), and statistical sampling limits. We provide explicit constructions showing these bounds are achievable within constant factors for canonical problems including matrix multiplication, covariance estimation, and Gaussian process inference. This framework unifies classical complexity theory with quantum information and thermodynamics, providing the first general theory of multi-resource computational limits with applications to algorithm design, hardware optimization, and fundamental physics.
A computer is a physical device that helps us process information by executing algorithms. An algorithm is a well-defined procedure, with finite description, for realizing an information-processing task. An information-processing task can always be translated into a physical task. When designing complex algorithms and protocols for various information-processing tasks, it is very helpful, perhaps essential, to work with some idealized computing model. However, when studying the true limitations of a computing device, especially for some practical reason, it is important not to forget the relationship between computing and physics. Real computing devices are embodied in a larger and often richer physical reality than is represented by the idealized computing model. Quantum information processing is the result of using the physical reality that quantum theory tells us about for the purposes of performing tasks that were previously thought impossible or infeasible. Devices that perform quantum information processing are known as quantum computers. In this book we examine how quantum computers can be used to solve certain problems more efficiently than can be done with classical computers, and also how this can be done reliably even when there is a possibility for errors to occur. In this first chapter we present some fundamental notions of computation theory and quantum physics that will form the basis for much of what follows. After this brief introduction, we will review the necessary tools from linear algebra in Chapter 2, and detail the framework of quantum mechanics, as relevant to our model of quantum computation, in Chapter 3. In the remainder of the book we examine quantum teleportation, quantum algorithms and quantum error correction in detail. We are often interested in the amount of resources used by a computer to solve a problem, and we refer to this as the complexity of the computation. An important resource for a computer is time. Another resource is space, which refers to the amount of memory used by the computer in performing the computation. We measure the amount of a resource used in a computation for solving a given problem as a function of the length of the input of an instance of that problem.
The physics and the mathematics of computation are examined to provide a foundation and perspective for the investigation of the quantum mechanics of computation. Our purpose is to explore the fundamental limits and constraints imposed on computation by Nature through the laws of physics and the mathematics of computational complexity. Inasmuch as information storage and transmission are an integral part of computation, their physical bounds are considered. The computer is viewed both physically and mathematically as a dynamical system, and is depicted in terms of the basic Turing machine paradigm. Three fundamental classes of the Turing machine are defined; the deterministic, stochastic and quantum Turing machines. Hamiltonian models and physical realizations of quantum computing are described. Quantum computers can perform some tasks which have no classical analogue, but they cannot compute functions that are non-computable by classical means. Some classically intractable problems can be solved with quantum computers.
Within the framework of the Computational Resource Finiteness Hypothesis (CRFH), this work presents a computational reinterpretation of the quantum mechanical uncertainty principle as a constraint arising from finite operational resources on a Universal Substrate. Uncertainty is shown to emerge from unavoidable competition between information writing and state-transition buffering, rather than from intrinsic randomness or measurement disturbance. By imposing resource conservation expressed through L2L^2L2-norm preservation and minimizing operational dissipation, we derive an effective operational density that converges to a stable rated point,Zquant=12≈0.707.Z_{\mathrm{quant}} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}} \approx 0.707 .Zquant​=2​1​≈0.707.This value is interpreted not as an exact instantaneous bound, but as an engineering-rated operating point ensuring long-term stability under finite computational capacity. The result suggests that probabilistic structures in quantum mechanics may reflect an underlying optimization principle governing resource allocation on the Universal Substrate. This formulation provides a scale-consistent bridge between microscopic uncertainty relations and macroscopic operational density limits observed in larger physical systems.
The laws of thermodynamics impose fundamental limits on all physical computation, determining minimum energy requirements, maximum operating temperatures, and ultimate scalability. In the ratio-based framework, the hierarchical tree structure with scaling ratio qqq creates a distinctive energy landscape with barriers scaling as Ebarrier∝qdE_{\text{barrier}} \propto q^dEbarrier​∝qd, where ddd is tree depth. This fundamentally alters thermodynamic constraints compared to conventional quantum architectures, introducing the scaling ratio qqq as a key optimization parameter in thermodynamic tradeoffs.
Quantum information theory has provided the formal framework for describing how information is stored, transmitted, and transformed in physical quantum systems [6, 7, 9]. Its entropic formulations underpin our understanding of quantum computation, communication, and cryptography. Yet this theory traditionally treats all quantum operations as freely available, ignoring computational restrictions. In practice, however, any manipulation of quantum information must be performed by devices of bounded complexity and runtime. Capturing such realistic constraints requires extending quantum information theory to include computational efficiency as a fundamental component.This work takes a first step toward building a computational version of quantum information theory, one that treats efficiency as part of the theory itself. The goal is to understand how the behavior of quantum information changes when the parties involved can only perform computationally efficient operations. This approach bridges the abstract, ideal setting of quantum information theory with the practical limitations of real quantum devices, offering a means to study information processing under realistic resource constraints.At the center of this work are two new quantities: the quantum computational min-entropy and the quantum computational max-entropy. These entropies extend standard quantum entropies by explicitly limiting the computational power of the observer or adversary. The quantum computational min-entropy captures how unpredictable a quantum system A remains to an observer holding system B, when that observer is restricted to quantum circuits of bounded size. Formally, for a bipartite state rho AB, we define(c) H-s (min)(A|B)rho := - log d(A) max (epsilon s) B > A' F ((parallel to(A)circle times epsilon(s))(rho(AB)),|Phi (AA')> Quantum information theory; Theory of computation -> Quantum complexity theory