This thesis covers research in three separate but interlinked areas: superfluidity in driven-dissipative polariton systems, path integral methods for the study of metastability in Markovian systems, and phase space methods for spin master equations. The unifying theme of the three works is their non-equilibrium nature, but other overlaps are also present. The first two topics share a primary analytical tool, the Feynman-Vernon path integral, with the first applying it to quantum field theory and the second to quantum mechanics. The first and third both utilise the TruncatedWigner method, albeit for very different purposes and rather different phase spaces, while the second and third illustrate the twin approaches of geometric and deformation quantisation. The first part is subdivided into three, dealing with different sub-projects undertaken under the broad umbrella of superfluidity. These are, in order, the absence of it in coherently driven polaritons, the application of TruncatedWigner to its study in Markovian polariton systems, and the analysis of whether non-linear dissipation can cause a non-interacting bosonic gas to exhibit it. Non-equilibrium functional integral methods are extensively used for all three but with varying emphasis: the first features extensive diagrammatic calculations, the second focuses on the stochastic semi-classical limit of the integral, while the third foregoes Feynman diagrams for a generating function approach. Conclusive results are obtained in the first project2, which completes a calculation by a predecessor in the group to show that no regime of coherently driven polaritons exhibits superfluidity; in the second I derive a method to extract the linear response tensor used for identifying superfluid components via the Truncated Wigner method derived from the functional integral, which should allow the numerical study of systems too complicated for the analytical tools employed in the first sub-part; in the final, third part I analyse a non-interacting bosonic system with non-linear dissipation, serving as a minimal model of a dye cavity photon Bose-Einstein condensate, to find that at mean-field level it is predicted to exhibit superfluidity. I then perform a significant portion of the associated fluctuation correction calculation, though difficulties with model regularisation prevent a conclusive answer being given at this time. Part II is devoted to calculations of Lindbladian spectra via the coherent state path integral, the initial aim of which was the study of metastability of systems governed by such Markovian superoperators. A working perturbation theory based on the exact propagator for a coherently driven-dissipative harmonic oscillator is derived and tested on some toy models. This perturbation theory in principle can be applied to systems not covered by the existing methods of third quantisation3 and exact expressions for truncated Fock bases. The part also includes a review of the two pre-eminent approaches to the coherent state path integral, emphasizing its links to holomorphic polarisation and highlighting the difficulties associated with it and consequently instanton calculations performed using it. Finally, moving away from bosonic systems, I develop a stochastic Truncated Wigner approach to spin degrees of freedom of arbitrary magnitude. This builds on earlierwork constructing the Stratonovich-Weyl representation of spin as functions on the 2-sphere S2 by calculating the explicit form of the series expansion of the associated star product to higher order than previously available in the literature. This is then used to study nearest-neighbour and long-range anisotropic XY models in two dimensions, obtaining promising results, in particular the direct observation of vortices associated with the BKT transition that destroy the staggered XY phase in the first model. This method differs from existing discrete Truncated Wigner methods and those specialised to spin-1 2, in particular being based around an expansion in a small parameter proportional to ℏ. This allows it to be easily integrated with bosonic phase space methods, since a truncation can then be carried out at a consistent order in ℏ.
This thesis covers research in three separate but interlinked areas: superfluidity in driven-dissipative polariton systems, path integral methods for the study of metastability in Markovian systems, and phase space methods for spin master equations. The unifying theme of the three works is their non-equilibrium nature, but other overlaps are also present. The first two topics share a primary analytical tool, the Feynman-Vernon path integral, with the first applying it to quantum field theory and the second to quantum mechanics. The first and third both utilise the TruncatedWigner method, albeit for very different purposes and rather different phase spaces, while the second and third illustrate the twin approaches of geometric and deformation quantisation. The first part is subdivided into three, dealing with different sub-projects undertaken under the broad umbrella of superfluidity. These are, in order, the absence of it in coherently driven polaritons, the application of TruncatedWigner to its study in Markovian polariton systems, and the analysis of whether non-linear dissipation can cause a non-interacting bosonic gas to exhibit it. Non-equilibrium functional integral methods are extensively used for all three but with varying emphasis: the first features extensive diagrammatic calculations, the second focuses on the stochastic semi-classical limit of the integral, while the third foregoes Feynman diagrams for a generating function approach. Conclusive results are obtained in the first project2, which completes a calculation by a predecessor in the group to show that no regime of coherently driven polaritons exhibits superfluidity; in the second I derive a method to extract the linear response tensor used for identifying superfluid components via the Truncated Wigner method derived from the functional integral, which should allow the numerical study of systems too complicated for the analytical tools employed in the first sub-part; in the final, third part I analyse a non-interacting bosonic system with non-linear dissipation, serving as a minimal model of a dye cavity photon Bose-Einstein condensate, to find that at mean-field level it is predicted to exhibit superfluidity. I then perform a significant portion of the associated fluctuation correction calculation, though difficulties with model regularisation prevent a conclusive answer being given at this time. Part II is devoted to calculations of Lindbladian spectra via the coherent state path integral, the initial aim of which was the study of metastability of systems governed by such Markovian superoperators. A working perturbation theory based on the exact propagator for a coherently driven-dissipative harmonic oscillator is derived and tested on some toy models. This perturbation theory in principle can be applied to systems not covered by the existing methods of third quantisation3 and exact expressions for truncated Fock bases. The part also includes a review of the two pre-eminent approaches to the coherent state path integral, emphasizing its links to holomorphic polarisation and highlighting the difficulties associated with it and consequently instanton calculations performed using it. Finally, moving away from bosonic systems, I develop a stochastic Truncated Wigner approach to spin degrees of freedom of arbitrary magnitude. This builds on earlierwork constructing the Stratonovich-Weyl representation of spin as functions on the 2-sphere S2 by calculating the explicit form of the series expansion of the associated star product to higher order than previously available in the literature. This is then used to study nearest-neighbour and long-range anisotropic XY models in two dimensions, obtaining promising results, in particular the direct observation of vortices associated with the BKT transition that destroy the staggered XY phase in the first model. This method differs from existing discrete Truncated Wigner methods and those specialised to spin-1 2, in particular being based around an expansion in a small parameter proportional to ℏ. This allows it to be easily integrated with bosonic phase space methods, since a truncation can then be carried out at a consistent order in ℏ.
The present thesis is devoted to the dynamics in open or closed many-body bosonic systems, with the use of beyond mean-field methods. In the first part, inspired by the state-of-the-art experiments, we study the dynamics of a Bose-Einstein condensation which is loaded in an optical lattice with localized loss channels for the atoms. We prove that the particular form of the dissipation can help us to control the many-body dynamics. The loss allows the local manipulation of the system’s coherence properties and creates attractive fixed points in the classical (mean-field) phase space. We predict the dynamical creation of stable nonlinear structures like discrete bright and dark solitons. Furthermore, for specific initial states, the systems produces highly entangled and long-living states, which are of high relevance for practical applications. The first part of this thesis ends with the study of non-equilibrium bosonic transport across optical one-dimensional lattices. In the second part, we present techniques for bosonic many-body systems which are based on path integrals. We analyze the Bose-Einstein condensation phenomenon by using tools from quantum information theory and field theory. Finally, we introduce a coherent state path integral formalism in the continuum, which allows us the systematic development of approximate methods for the study of bosons in optical lattices.
This thesis is comprised of four separate parts: in the first we calculate the second and third virial coefficients of 3He and 4He at low temperatures with an empirical interatomic potential by Janzen and Aziz and using the Path Integral Monte Carlo (PIMC) technique. We show that, for the calculation of the second coefficient, the method is successful whereas for the third the particular implementation that we chose (free particle sampling) is not sufficient to produce reliable results at low temperatures. In the second part we consider the Josephson Effect between two spatially separated Bose-Einstein condensates of atoms each of which can be in two hyperfine states. We derive simple equations of motion for this system closely analogous to the Bloch equations. We also map the dynamics of the system onto those of a classical particle in a well. We find novel density and spin modes of oscillation and new stable equilibrium points of the motion. Finally we analyze the oscillation modes in the spin-1 (F = 1) case. In the third part of the thesis we propose a powerful method to study the time evolution of Bose condensed gases perturbed from an initial thermal equilibrium, based on the Wigner representation of the N-body density operator. We show how to generate an ensemble of random classical fields sampling the initial Wigner distribution in the number conserving Bogoliubov approximation. The fields are then evolved with the time dependent Gross-Pitaevskii equation. We illustrate the method with the damping of a collective excitation of a one dimensional Bose gas. The fourth part deals with inhomogeneous superconductivity in the presence of magnetic fields that couple only to the spin and not to the orbital motion. They induce a splitting of the Fermi surfaces of up and down spins. We start by considering a one dimensional system and explicitly write down the wavefunction that pairs states with unequal energies due to the splitting. Next we consider an extension to three dimensions and work out explicitly certain aspects of the crossover from one to two dimensions. We then discuss the relationship of this state with those of Fulde, Ferrell, Larkin and Ovchinnikov. Finally, we consider an extension to the case of a paired state which has a gap with a spherically symmetric spatial dependence.
We review recent results on the coherence and superfluidity of driven dissipative condensates, i.e., systems of weakly interacting nonconserved bosons, such as polariton condensates. The presence of driving and dissipation has dramatically different effects depending on dimensionality and anisotropy. In three dimensions, equilibrium behaviour is recovered at large scales for static correlations, while the dynamical behaviour is altered by the microscopic driving. In two dimensions, for an isotropic system, drive and dissipation destroy the algebraic order that would otherwise exist; however, a sufficiently anisotropic system can still show algebraic phase correlations. We discuss the consequences of this behaviour for recent experiments measuring phase coherence and outline potential measurements that might directly probe superfluidity. Introduction This chapter is dedicated to superfluidity and its relation to Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC), a topic with a long history. Many reviews of the concepts of condensation and superfluidity in thermal equilibrium can be found; see for example Refs. [1, 2, 3, 4]. The focus of this chapter is on how these concepts apply (or fail to apply) to driven dissipative condensates – systems of bosons with a finite lifetime, in which loss is balanced by continuous pumping. We focus entirely on the steady state of such systems, neglecting transient, time-dependent behaviour. Experimentally, the most studied example of a driven dissipative condensate has been microcavity polaritons, an overview of which is given in Ref. [5] and Chapter 4. However, similar issues can arise in many other systems, most obviously photon condensates [6] (see also Chapter 19), magnon condensates [7] (see also Chapters 25–26), and potentially exciton condensates (although typical exciton lifetimes are much longer than for polaritons). Even experiments on cold atoms (see, e.g., Chapter 3) could be driven into a regime in which such physics occurs, when considering continuous loading of atoms balancing threebody losses [8] or atom laser setups [9, 10, 11]. Experiments on polaritons are two-dimensional, and in two dimensions it is particularly important to clearly distinguish three concepts often erroneously treated as equivalent: superfluidity, condensation, and phase coherence. This is because no true Bose-Einstein condensate exists in a homogeneous two-dimensional system.
The study of many-body quantum physics has been recently challenged by the appearance of an increasing number of experimental platforms where genuine quantum phenomena take place notwithstanding the presence of an environment and of dissipation. Exciton-polaritons, lossy atomic and molecular gases, cavity QED arrays, arrays of trapped ions and Rydberg atoms, are only few prominent examples of a long list. The present work is ideally divided into two parts, the former is devoted to methodological results; the latter to the theoretical characterization of experimental data. Whereas the notion of equilibrium has been a fruitful guide to the development of standard many-body physics, these setups are inherently out of equilibrium and their modelisation requires the introduction of new theoretical tools. Several methods for addressing this dissipative out-of-equilibrium dynamics have been proposed, based for instance on quantum trajectories, truncated Wigner expansions, tensor networks, machine learning, but the solution of many-body physics for open quantum systems remains a formidable task. Clearly, techniques developed in the framework of Hamiltonian closed systems are a continuous source of inspiration for novel developments, and in this work we present the generalization of one such technique, the so-called flow equations, to the dissipative framework where the generator of the dynamics is a linear non-Hermitian operator; notable examples include non-Hermitian Hamiltonians and Lindblad master equations. In the second part of this work we focus on two-body lossy dynamics in strongly-correlated cold atomic gases. In particular, we derive an effective description for the long-time dynamics of a spin ½ fermionic system by extending a pre-existing theory for the bosonic case.
In this thesis we explore different phenomena occurring in open quantum many-body systems. This is a research field which is becoming increasingly more important due to the experimental progress towards realization of quantum-simulators and quantum computers using a variety of platforms, from ultracold atoms to superconducting qubit arrays. These systems are inherently driven and open, and it is an ongoing effort to develop theoretical tools and approaches to study their non-equilibrium physics. In the first part of this thesis we explore the different non-equilibrium condensate phases of resonantly interacting bosons in the presence of coherent pump and incoherent losses. This study might be of relevance to existing Rydberg-polariton setups. We derive an effective non-equilibrium field-theory of this model and study its resulting phase diagram. We find a rich phase diagram in- cluding a phase where particles form a condensate of tightly bound molecules. By changing the detuning from the scattering resonance it is possible to drive an Ising phase transition from the molecule condensate phase to a more standard atom condensate phase. In the second part of this thesis we explore the many-body localization (MBL) transition in an open-driven system. Typically, coupling to a bath is expected to destroy localization and transform the sharp MBL transition to a crossover. Here we show how one can use the couplings to non- equilibrium baths in order to detect sharp signatures of the transition, including the divergence of the dynamical exponent in the Griffith regime of the ergodic phase. This is done by solving for the steady-state of the Lindblad quantum-master equation using matrix-product operator tech- niques. Our work here suggests a new scalable numerical approach to study the MBL transition. In the third part of this thesis we study the entanglement properties of measurement trajectories in a free-fermion system subject to dephasing noise. These trajectories describe the evolution of an open system when photons exiting the system are continuously monitored. We are inspired by recent works which studied the entanglement dynamics in hybrid quantum circuits consisting of random-unitary gates and projective measurements. There it was found that a phase transition between a phase with volume-law scaling of entanglement and an area-law phase occurs at a critical value of the measurement rate. In our case we find a new regime, where at weak noise rate the system exhibits logarithmic entanglement scaling, similar to that of (1 + 1)d conformal field- theories. For some measurement protocols, we find a transition to an area-law phase at a critical noise strength.
The study of out-of-equilibrium dynamics in ultra-cold gases is a new and exciting field, driven largely by the recent experimental advances in controlling and imaging cold clouds. The experimental and theoretical work thus far has been somewhat exploratory and largely numerical in nature, as the very paradigms for thinking about these systems are not well established. In this thesis I consider several different scenarios of ultra-cold bosonic and fermionic gases driven out of equilibrium and study their properties. In Chapter 1, I provide an overview of the phenomenology of ultra-cold gases, highlighting the timescales governing these systems and how the experimentalist can tune them. I discuss how cold gases can be cooled and trapped and discuss the basic physics behind optical lattices. I also discuss experimental probes of these gases, in particular the new high resolution imaging techniques developed recently at Chicago, Munich and Harvard. In Chapter 2, I discuss an early experiment (circa. 2008) which observed long lived spin dynamics in a thermal spin-1/2 Fermi gas. This experiment is an nice illustration of interesting physics resulting from the separation of timescales between spin and collisional dynamics. In my opinion, it is an excellent example of why cold gases are naturally suited to studying non-equilibrium dynamics. I simulate the experiment numerically using a collisionless Boltzmann equation and explain the observed spin dynamics both qualitatively and quantitively. In Chapter 3, I continue the discussion of spin waves in thermal gases by extending previous works on spin-1/2 gases to spin-1 Bose gases. In contrast to Chapter 2, the bulk of the work in this Chapter is analytic in nature. In particular, I find a spin wave instability in the thermal spin-1 Bose gas, which is the high temperature analog of the polar to ferromagnetic transition in a spin-1 Bose Einstein condensate. In Chapter 3, I turn my attention to bosonic systems and briefly review the the Bogoliubov mean-field theory. I calculate the momentum distribution and density-density correlation function of an interacting Bose gas within the Bogoliubov framework. Then I consider bosons in an optical lattice, and introduce the Bose Hubbard model. I calculate the mean-field phase diagram of the Bose Hubbard model and then consider fluctuations about the mean field, and derive the excitation spectrum of the lattice gas in the superfluid and insulating regimes. In Chapter 4, I ask what we learn by studying the dynamics of correlation functions following a sudden change in the interactions in a superfluid. Using the Bogoliubov theory developed in Chapter 3, I will show how the underlying excitation spectrum influences the long and short time behavior of the correlation functions. By considering a lattice dispersion, I study the analogous problem in a weak optical lattice and discuss how the lattice dispersion leads to additional features in the correlation functions. I will also discuss the timescale governing the revival of the condensate fraction in a quantum depleted gas. In Chapter 5, I derive equations of motion governing the dynamics of one and two body correlation functions in the single-band Bose Hubbard model, applicable to bosons in deep lattices. I then consider a simple quench from a Mott insulating initial state to a weakly interacting final state and produce analytic expressions describing the dynamics of correlations following such a quench. I discuss the timescale for the development of long range order following such a quench. I study the problem of chapter 4 using an equations of motion approach. This approach complements the Bogoliubov approach of Chapter 4. First, I derive exact expressions for a quench to a non-interacting state. I then consider how interactions redistribute quasi-momentum to first order in perturbation theory in different dimensions. In Chapter 6, I calculate the relevant timescales for local and global dynamics in trapped lattice Bose gases, a work done in collaboration with Dr. Kaden R. A Hazzard. Using a time-dependent Gutzwiller mean-field theory, I show that the timescale for local equilibration in these systems is fast in experimental terms. I then show that due to the spatial inhomogeneities inherent to cold gases, achieving global equilibrium can be quite complicated, sometimes taking longer than the lifetime of the experiment, an issue of practical importance to current day experiments. I continue this discussion in Chapter 7 which is a collaborative work with experimentalists David McKay and Prof. Brian DeMarco from the University of Toronto and the University of Illinois, Urbana Champaign. Using experimental and numerical methods, we show that the rapid timescales for local dynamics in interacting systems invalidates a frequently used cold atom technique for mapping out the momentum distribution of atoms in an optical lattice.