Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Phase-Shifted Bell States and Potential Implications in the understanding of ‘Spooky action at a Distance’

Jeffery Jonathan Joshua Davis

Published Oct 1, 2025• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

This paper conveys briefly and concisely what could be the implications of the Einstein-Bohr debate when we consider the results of Phase-Shifted EPR-Bell states from a study conducted in Maarten Hoogerland’s Lab in the Dodd-Walls Centre for Photonics and Quantum Technologies, University of Auckland, New Zealand (2018-2024). The results of this study were presented at the first Biological Physics and Meaning Mini Conference on ‘QUANTUM MECHANICS, THE MEASUREMENT PROBLEM AND HUMAN CONSCIOUSNESS’ (Feb. 2024). Here, I also examine the nature of correlated pairs of photons produced by Spontaneous Parametric Down Conversion (SPDC) Type II, when the photon of one path is altered with a Quarter Wave Plate (QWP), shifting the polarization from linear to elliptical or circular. As stated in the above mentioned study, surprisingly, some of these Phase Shifted Bell states (correlated pairs) produce no violation of the Clauser, Horne, Shimony and Holt (CHSH) inequality, raising yet again a question mark on the meaning of ‘entanglement’ when understood as ‘spooky action at a distance’, in the context of the formalism of Quantum Mechanics and the different associated interpretations. If ‘spooky action at a distance’ is ruled out from physical systems and we consider new more general stochastic laws, then we open the way for a more interesting future physics on the side of Einstein and realism that, under some regimes, may manifest as nonlocality in terms of information structures. Perhaps, religious, spiritual and mystical experience (RSME) may have a place in physics and the sciences in general, as experienced information and meaning within physical restrictions in a classically consciously experienced lived life in spacetime.

Related papers

Phase-shifted Bell states

J. J. Joshua Davis, Carey L. Jackman, R. Leonhardt +2 more

Inspired by previous studies and pioneers of the field, we present new results on an extensive Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen (EPR)–Bell experiment using photons generated by parametric down-conversion, where one of the photons is deliberately phase-shifted. Our experiments show some surprising results for particular angles of this phase shift, where, for some states, the Clauser, Horne, Shimony, and Holt inequality shows no violations, requiring us to review our understanding of “entangled” states vis-à-vis the correlations obtained via experimental coincidence counts in agreement with quantum mechanics theoretical predictions. We give some possible explanations about the correlated states that show no violations of these inequalities.

arXiv:2501.09874•Journal of the Optical Society of America B•Apr 9, 2025•4 citations

Reconciling Spooky Action with Relativity through Phase‑Oriented Particles, Quantum Gravity and Intrinsic Spin Momentum

Ellis Ammons

This work demystifies quantum paradoxes by showing that the phenomena often labeled as “spooky action” arise from unfactorizable classical local processes that lie outside the scope of Bell’s tests, indicating that the universe remains locally real and that physical states exist independently of measurement. It presents a deterministic hidden‑variable framework, relativistically compatible with quantum entanglement, based on Intrinsic Spin Momentum (ISM). In this model, spin is treated as a real internal momentum circulation with definable vector structure, phase, curvature, and acceleration. Phase‑created correlations between intrinsic spin momenta reproduce CHSH‑type values without superluminal signaling or Einstein’s so‑called “spooky action at a distance.” The Bloch sphere emerges as the geometric representation of internal spin structure, and phase alignment on this sphere provides the mechanism for entanglement correlations, demonstrating that classical unfactorizable processes can reproduce Bell‑inequality violations without breaking any known laws of physics. This stands in stark contrast to the widely publicized interpretation of the 2022 Nobel Prize in Physics, which claimed that Bell‑test violations imply that the universe is “not locally real.” The model generalizes naturally to higher‑spin systems, linking intrinsic spin geometry to gravitational curvature. Gravitational waves dynamically modulate intrinsic spin acceleration, offering a physical mechanism for quantum gravity that diverges worldlines through localized curvature rather than as a purely coordinate effect of spacetime geometry. This unified picture replaces “spooky action” with correlated spin geometry embedded in a dynamic relativistic spacetime. Contact: ellis.ammons1@gmail.com Keywords: Intrinsic Spin Momentum, quantum gravity, entanglement, Bloch sphere, CHSH correlations, relativity, hidden variables, gravitational waves, phase geometry, spin structure.

•May 20, 2026•2 citations

Bell inequality violation in relativity theory

Aleksandr V. Belinsky, Джадан Игорь Иванович

Abstract A violation of Bell local realism inequalities in Clauser–Horne–Shimony–Holt form has been discovered in a relativistic Gedankenexperiment. This means that there are no definite joint probabilities and this finds a classical explanation in the structure of special relativity. The discovered nonlocality is weaker than Albert Einstein’s quantum ‘spooky action at a distance’, and its presence suggests certain parallels between special relativity and quantum mechanics.

arXiv:2405.20789•Laser Physics Letters•Jun 25, 2024•2 citations

Two Faced Janus of Quantum Nonlocality

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

This paper is a new step towards understanding why "quantum nonlocality" is a misleading concept. Metaphorically speaking, "quantum nonlocality" is Janus faced. One face is an apparent nonlocality of the Lüders projection and another face is Bell nonlocality (a wrong conclusion that the violation of Bell type inequalities implies the existence of mysterious instantaneous influences between distant physical systems). According to the Lüders projection postulate, a quantum measurement performed on one of the two distant entangled physical systems modifies their compound quantum state instantaneously. Therefore, if the quantum state is considered to be an attribute of the individual physical system and if one assumes that experimental outcomes are produced in a perfectly random way, one quickly arrives at the contradiction. It is a primary source of speculations about a spooky action at a distance. Bell nonlocality as defined above was explained and rejected by several authors; thus, we concentrate in this paper on the apparent nonlocality of the Lüders projection. As already pointed out by Einstein, the quantum paradoxes disappear if one adopts the purely statistical interpretation of quantum mechanics (QM). In the statistical interpretation of QM, if probabilities are considered to be objective properties of random experiments we show that the Lüders projection corresponds to the passage from joint probabilities describing all set of data to some marginal conditional probabilities describing some particular subsets of data. If one adopts a subjective interpretation of probabilities, such as QBism, then the Lüders projection corresponds to standard Bayesian updating of the probabilities. The latter represents degrees of beliefs of local agents about outcomes of individual measurements which are placed or which will be placed at distant locations. In both approaches, probability-transformation does not happen in the physical space, but only in the information space. Thus, all speculations about spooky interactions or spooky predictions at a distance are simply misleading. Coming back to Bell nonlocality, we recall that in a recent paper we demonstrated, using exclusively the quantum formalism, that CHSH inequalities may be violated for some quantum states only because of the incompatibility of quantum observables and Bohr's complementarity. Finally, we explain that our criticism of quantum nonlocality is in the spirit of Hertz-Boltzmann methodology of scientific theories.

arXiv:2001.02977•Entropy•Mar 6, 2020•51 citations

Readers offer their own magic moments with John Bell

Michael Nauenberg

I read with pleasure Reinhold Bertlmann’s article about remembrances of John Bell and his contributions to physics. Bell is famous for establishing an inequality between the prediction of quantum mechanics and local hidden-variable theories, and Bertlmann wrote that “so far, all experiments looking for violations in Bell inequalities have found them, so we have to conclude, along with John, that nature contains a nonlocality in its structure.” But that conclusion is valid only in the context of Bell’s conviction that classical “realism is the proper position for a scientist.”Experiments have revealed that the nature of reality in the quantum world is different from our experience in the classical world.11. A. Aspect, Nature 446, 866 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1038/446866a Properties like the direction of an electron spin and its position and momentum remain undetermined until a measurement has been performed,22. W. Heisenberg, Physics and Philosophy: The Revolution in Modern Science, Prometheus Books (1999), p. 44. 9781573926942 but the colors of Bertlmann’s socks are fixed after he puts them on. Albert Einstein’s famous quotation, “spooky action at a distance,”33. A. Einstein, M. Born, H. Born, The Born–Einstein Letters: Correspondence Between Albert Einstein and Max and Hedwig Born from 1916–1955, I. Born, trans., MacMillan (1971), p. 159. that appears in Bertlmann’s amusing cartoon, is also misleading, because quantum correlations for entangled electron or photon pairs also occur at atomic distance of separation—for example, in the ground state of the helium atom. What would be spooky is if those correlations were altered when the entangled pair moved apart without further interactions, but experiments have shown that this is not the case.REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<CITING ARTICLES1. A. Aspect, Nature 446, 866 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1038/446866a, Google ScholarCrossref2. W. Heisenberg, Physics and Philosophy: The Revolution in Modern Science, Prometheus Books (1999), p. 44. 9781573926942, Google Scholar3. A. Einstein, M. Born, H. Born, The Born–Einstein Letters: Correspondence Between Albert Einstein and Max and Hedwig Born from 1916–1955, I. Born, trans., MacMillan (1971), p. 159. Google Scholar© 2015 American Institute of Physics.

Physics Today•Nov 30, 2015•3 citations

A Critical Analysis of the Quantum Nonlocality Problem: On the Polemic Assessment of What Bell Did

Justo Pastor Lambare

Despite their Nobel Prize-winning empirical falsification, the interpretation of the Bell inequality remains a subject of controversy. This article discusses and attempts to clarify the reasons John S. Bell and A. Einstein claimed that quantum entanglement implies puzzling nonlocal correlations that Einstein famously termed ``spooky action at a distance.'' The issue remains notoriously controversial and has roughly divided the scientific community into localists and nonlocalists. Without taking a stance on either side in the long-standing, polarized debate, we examine Bell's actual argument, highlighting how it differs from the current orthodoxy.

•Oct 29, 2025•0 citations
This paper conveys briefly and concisely what could be the implications of the Einstein-Bohr debate when we consider the results of Phase-Shifted EPR-Bell states from a study conducted in Maarten Hoogerland’s Lab in the Dodd-Walls Centre for Photonics and Quantum Technologies, University of Auckland, New Zealand (2018-2024). The results of this study were presented at the first Biological Physics and Meaning Mini Conference on ‘QUANTUM MECHANICS, THE MEASUREMENT PROBLEM AND HUMAN CONSCIOUSNESS’ (Feb. 2024). Here, I also examine the nature of correlated pairs of photons produced by Spontaneous Parametric Down Conversion (SPDC) Type II, when the photon of one path is altered with a Quarter Wave Plate (QWP), shifting the polarization from linear to elliptical or circular. As stated in the above mentioned study, surprisingly, some of these Phase Shifted Bell states (correlated pairs) produce no violation of the Clauser, Horne, Shimony and Holt (CHSH) inequality, raising yet again a question mark on the meaning of ‘entanglement’ when understood as ‘spooky action at a distance’, in the context of the formalism of Quantum Mechanics and the different associated interpretations. If ‘spooky action at a distance’ is ruled out from physical systems and we consider new more general stochastic laws, then we open the way for a more interesting future physics on the side of Einstein and realism that, under some regimes, may manifest as nonlocality in terms of information structures. Perhaps, religious, spiritual and mystical experience (RSME) may have a place in physics and the sciences in general, as experienced information and meaning within physical restrictions in a classically consciously experienced lived life in spacetime.
Inspired by previous studies and pioneers of the field, we present new results on an extensive Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen (EPR)–Bell experiment using photons generated by parametric down-conversion, where one of the photons is deliberately phase-shifted. Our experiments show some surprising results for particular angles of this phase shift, where, for some states, the Clauser, Horne, Shimony, and Holt inequality shows no violations, requiring us to review our understanding of “entangled” states vis-à-vis the correlations obtained via experimental coincidence counts in agreement with quantum mechanics theoretical predictions. We give some possible explanations about the correlated states that show no violations of these inequalities.
This work demystifies quantum paradoxes by showing that the phenomena often labeled as “spooky action” arise from unfactorizable classical local processes that lie outside the scope of Bell’s tests, indicating that the universe remains locally real and that physical states exist independently of measurement. It presents a deterministic hidden‑variable framework, relativistically compatible with quantum entanglement, based on Intrinsic Spin Momentum (ISM). In this model, spin is treated as a real internal momentum circulation with definable vector structure, phase, curvature, and acceleration. Phase‑created correlations between intrinsic spin momenta reproduce CHSH‑type values without superluminal signaling or Einstein’s so‑called “spooky action at a distance.” The Bloch sphere emerges as the geometric representation of internal spin structure, and phase alignment on this sphere provides the mechanism for entanglement correlations, demonstrating that classical unfactorizable processes can reproduce Bell‑inequality violations without breaking any known laws of physics. This stands in stark contrast to the widely publicized interpretation of the 2022 Nobel Prize in Physics, which claimed that Bell‑test violations imply that the universe is “not locally real.” The model generalizes naturally to higher‑spin systems, linking intrinsic spin geometry to gravitational curvature. Gravitational waves dynamically modulate intrinsic spin acceleration, offering a physical mechanism for quantum gravity that diverges worldlines through localized curvature rather than as a purely coordinate effect of spacetime geometry. This unified picture replaces “spooky action” with correlated spin geometry embedded in a dynamic relativistic spacetime. Contact: ellis.ammons1@gmail.com Keywords: Intrinsic Spin Momentum, quantum gravity, entanglement, Bloch sphere, CHSH correlations, relativity, hidden variables, gravitational waves, phase geometry, spin structure.
This paper is a new step towards understanding why "quantum nonlocality" is a misleading concept. Metaphorically speaking, "quantum nonlocality" is Janus faced. One face is an apparent nonlocality of the Lüders projection and another face is Bell nonlocality (a wrong conclusion that the violation of Bell type inequalities implies the existence of mysterious instantaneous influences between distant physical systems). According to the Lüders projection postulate, a quantum measurement performed on one of the two distant entangled physical systems modifies their compound quantum state instantaneously. Therefore, if the quantum state is considered to be an attribute of the individual physical system and if one assumes that experimental outcomes are produced in a perfectly random way, one quickly arrives at the contradiction. It is a primary source of speculations about a spooky action at a distance. Bell nonlocality as defined above was explained and rejected by several authors; thus, we concentrate in this paper on the apparent nonlocality of the Lüders projection. As already pointed out by Einstein, the quantum paradoxes disappear if one adopts the purely statistical interpretation of quantum mechanics (QM). In the statistical interpretation of QM, if probabilities are considered to be objective properties of random experiments we show that the Lüders projection corresponds to the passage from joint probabilities describing all set of data to some marginal conditional probabilities describing some particular subsets of data. If one adopts a subjective interpretation of probabilities, such as QBism, then the Lüders projection corresponds to standard Bayesian updating of the probabilities. The latter represents degrees of beliefs of local agents about outcomes of individual measurements which are placed or which will be placed at distant locations. In both approaches, probability-transformation does not happen in the physical space, but only in the information space. Thus, all speculations about spooky interactions or spooky predictions at a distance are simply misleading. Coming back to Bell nonlocality, we recall that in a recent paper we demonstrated, using exclusively the quantum formalism, that CHSH inequalities may be violated for some quantum states only because of the incompatibility of quantum observables and Bohr's complementarity. Finally, we explain that our criticism of quantum nonlocality is in the spirit of Hertz-Boltzmann methodology of scientific theories.
I read with pleasure Reinhold Bertlmann’s article about remembrances of John Bell and his contributions to physics. Bell is famous for establishing an inequality between the prediction of quantum mechanics and local hidden-variable theories, and Bertlmann wrote that “so far, all experiments looking for violations in Bell inequalities have found them, so we have to conclude, along with John, that nature contains a nonlocality in its structure.” But that conclusion is valid only in the context of Bell’s conviction that classical “realism is the proper position for a scientist.”Experiments have revealed that the nature of reality in the quantum world is different from our experience in the classical world.11. A. Aspect, Nature 446, 866 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1038/446866a Properties like the direction of an electron spin and its position and momentum remain undetermined until a measurement has been performed,22. W. Heisenberg, Physics and Philosophy: The Revolution in Modern Science, Prometheus Books (1999), p. 44. 9781573926942 but the colors of Bertlmann’s socks are fixed after he puts them on. Albert Einstein’s famous quotation, “spooky action at a distance,”33. A. Einstein, M. Born, H. Born, The Born–Einstein Letters: Correspondence Between Albert Einstein and Max and Hedwig Born from 1916–1955, I. Born, trans., MacMillan (1971), p. 159. that appears in Bertlmann’s amusing cartoon, is also misleading, because quantum correlations for entangled electron or photon pairs also occur at atomic distance of separation—for example, in the ground state of the helium atom. What would be spooky is if those correlations were altered when the entangled pair moved apart without further interactions, but experiments have shown that this is not the case.REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<CITING ARTICLES1. A. Aspect, Nature 446, 866 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1038/446866a, Google ScholarCrossref2. W. Heisenberg, Physics and Philosophy: The Revolution in Modern Science, Prometheus Books (1999), p. 44. 9781573926942, Google Scholar3. A. Einstein, M. Born, H. Born, The Born–Einstein Letters: Correspondence Between Albert Einstein and Max and Hedwig Born from 1916–1955, I. Born, trans., MacMillan (1971), p. 159. Google Scholar© 2015 American Institute of Physics.
Despite their Nobel Prize-winning empirical falsification, the interpretation of the Bell inequality remains a subject of controversy. This article discusses and attempts to clarify the reasons John S. Bell and A. Einstein claimed that quantum entanglement implies puzzling nonlocal correlations that Einstein famously termed ``spooky action at a distance.'' The issue remains notoriously controversial and has roughly divided the scientific community into localists and nonlocalists. Without taking a stance on either side in the long-standing, polarized debate, we examine Bell's actual argument, highlighting how it differs from the current orthodoxy.