Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Wavefunction's Dilemma: Reality, Knowledge, and the Space In-Between

Aanchal Saraf

Published Jan 1, 2025• 0 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.2139/ssrn.5772282

Related papers

On the Reality of the Wavefunction

Martin Ringbauer

Springer theses•Jan 1, 2017•2 citations

Measurements on the reality of the wavefunction

Martin Ringbauer, B. Duffus, Cyril Branciard +3 more

arXiv:1412.6213•Nature Physics•Feb 2, 2015•132 citations

The Reality of the Wavefunction: Old Arguments and New

Harvey R. Brown

Synthese Library/Synthese library•Jan 1, 2019•15 citations

Could wavefunctions simultaneously represent knowledge and reality?

Jonte R. Hance, JG Rarity, J Ladyman

In discussion of the interpretation of quantum mechanics the terms ‘ontic’ and ‘epistemic’ are often used in the sense of pertaining to what exists, and pertaining to cognition or knowledge respectively. The terms are also often associated with the formal definitions given by Harrigan and Spekkens for the wavefunction in quantum mechanics to be �ψ-ontic or �ψ-epistemic in the context of the ontological models framework. The formal definitions are contradictories, so that the wavefunction can be either ψ�-epistemic or ψ �-ontic but not both. However, we argue, nothing about the informal ideas of epistemic and ontic interpretations rules out wavefunctions representing both reality and knowledge. The implications of the Pusey–Barrett–Rudolph theorem and many other issues may be rethought in the light of our analysis.

•Aug 1, 2022•0 citations

Could wavefunctions simultaneously represent knowledge and reality?

Jonte R. Hance, John Rarity, James Ladyman

Abstract In discussion of the interpretation of quantum mechanics the terms ‘ontic’ and ‘epistemic’ are often used in the sense of pertaining to what exists, and pertaining to cognition or knowledge respectively. The terms are also often associated with the formal definitions given by Harrigan and Spekkens for the wavefunction in quantum mechanics to be $$\psi $$ ψ -ontic or $$\psi $$ ψ -epistemic in the context of the ontological models framework. The formal definitions are contradictories, so that the wavefunction can be either $$\psi $$ ψ -epistemic or $$\psi $$ ψ -ontic but not both. However, we argue, nothing about the informal ideas of epistemic and ontic interpretations rules out wavefunctions representing both reality and knowledge. The implications of the Pusey–Barrett–Rudolph theorem and many other issues may be rethought in the light of our analysis.

arXiv:2101.06436•Quantum Studies Mathematics and Foundations•Apr 27, 2022•32 citations

Quantum information isomorphism: Beyond the dilemma of the Scylla of ontology and the Charybdis of instrumentalism

Ryszard Horodecki, Michał Horodecki, Paweł Horodecki

In order to deal most effectively with the unanalyzable quantum whole, the Copenhagen interpretation takes as a “frame of reference” the preparation parameters and outcomes of measurements. It represents a passive, Ptolemaic-like instrumentalism directly related to “what we see in the sky,” i.e., to the “surface” of reality. However, the notion of quantum information leads to an active, Copernican-like realism which involves an (intrinsic) ordering principle and the view that the quantum whole is analyzable. It is then possible to consider subsystems as localized in space, controlled individually, and communicated. This makes it natural to treat quantum information (quantum states) not merely as knowledge. Moreover, it involves complementarity between local and nonlocal information. To avoid the dilemma between the Scylla of ontology and the Charybdis of instrumentalism, we propose the concept of quantum information isomorphism, according to which the quantum description of nature is isomorphic to nature itself. By definition it is not just one-to-one mapping, but it preserves the full structure of nature. In particular, it allows the treatment of the wave function of isomorphic images of quantum systems in the laboratory, implying that quantum information is indeed carried by these quantum systems.

arXiv:quant-ph/0305024•IBM Journal of Research and Development•Jan 1, 2004•13 citations
In discussion of the interpretation of quantum mechanics the terms ‘ontic’ and ‘epistemic’ are often used in the sense of pertaining to what exists, and pertaining to cognition or knowledge respectively. The terms are also often associated with the formal definitions given by Harrigan and Spekkens for the wavefunction in quantum mechanics to be �ψ-ontic or �ψ-epistemic in the context of the ontological models framework. The formal definitions are contradictories, so that the wavefunction can be either ψ�-epistemic or ψ �-ontic but not both. However, we argue, nothing about the informal ideas of epistemic and ontic interpretations rules out wavefunctions representing both reality and knowledge. The implications of the Pusey–Barrett–Rudolph theorem and many other issues may be rethought in the light of our analysis.
Abstract In discussion of the interpretation of quantum mechanics the terms ‘ontic’ and ‘epistemic’ are often used in the sense of pertaining to what exists, and pertaining to cognition or knowledge respectively. The terms are also often associated with the formal definitions given by Harrigan and Spekkens for the wavefunction in quantum mechanics to be ψ\psi ψ ψ -ontic or ψ\psi ψ ψ -epistemic in the context of the ontological models framework. The formal definitions are contradictories, so that the wavefunction can be either ψ\psi ψ ψ -epistemic or ψ\psi ψ ψ -ontic but not both. However, we argue, nothing about the informal ideas of epistemic and ontic interpretations rules out wavefunctions representing both reality and knowledge. The implications of the Pusey–Barrett–Rudolph theorem and many other issues may be rethought in the light of our analysis.
In order to deal most effectively with the unanalyzable quantum whole, the Copenhagen interpretation takes as a “frame of reference” the preparation parameters and outcomes of measurements. It represents a passive, Ptolemaic-like instrumentalism directly related to “what we see in the sky,” i.e., to the “surface” of reality. However, the notion of quantum information leads to an active, Copernican-like realism which involves an (intrinsic) ordering principle and the view that the quantum whole is analyzable. It is then possible to consider subsystems as localized in space, controlled individually, and communicated. This makes it natural to treat quantum information (quantum states) not merely as knowledge. Moreover, it involves complementarity between local and nonlocal information. To avoid the dilemma between the Scylla of ontology and the Charybdis of instrumentalism, we propose the concept of quantum information isomorphism, according to which the quantum description of nature is isomorphic to nature itself. By definition it is not just one-to-one mapping, but it preserves the full structure of nature. In particular, it allows the treatment of the wave function of isomorphic images of quantum systems in the laboratory, implying that quantum information is indeed carried by these quantum systems.