European Journal for Philosophy of Science
Everettian chance in no uncertain terms
Jer Steeger, James Read
Abstract
Abstract The current landscape of views on the role of chance in the Everett interpretation is rocky. Everettians (Wallace, 2012; Sebens and Carroll, 2018; McQueen and Vaidman, 2019) agree that chance values should be derived using rules of rationality governing agents’ uncertain reasoning and/or decision-making, but they cannot agree on how. Critics (Baker, 2007; Dawid and Thébault, 2025; Mandolesi, 2019) maintain that these approaches are circular. We smooth the landscape by shifting focus from rules of rationality to physical facts on which Everettians agree: namely, the conditions under which branches are isolated. Our approach to isolation resolves the main tensions among the different Everettian chance derivations while clarifying how they avoid circularity.