Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Minimizing setup in secure computation

Xia, Yu

Published Nov 11, 2025• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Secure Multi-party Computation (MPC) considers the problem where a set of mutually distrusting parties want to jointly compute a function over their private inputs, without revealing any extra information about these inputs other than what it can be inferred from the output of the function. This setting is well-motivated, and it has many real-world applications such as auction, voting, etc. MPC can be also seen as a generalization of many natural cryptographic primitives. For example, zero-knowledge (ZK) can be viewed as a special case of two-party secure computation. In ZK, a party, called prover aims to convince a second party, called verifier, that the prover’s private input witness w and a public input statement x belong to a relation R. An important research direction in secure computation is to find the trade-off between the required setup (e.g., the use of the broadcast channel, the use of common reference string (CRS) / public key infrastructure (PKI), the upper bound of the parties that can be corrupted, etc.), and the security guarantees that can be achieved. The setups can be viewed as some general assumptions that the protocol needs to satisfy, and they influence the usability of the protocol in real-world scenarios. In principle, having simpler (or no) setups mean that the protocol is more general and can be more useful in real-world scenarios. At the same time, having simpler setups may lead to weaker security guarantees. Therefore, finding the trade-off between setup and security guarantees is important and meaningful. In this thesis, we target MPC and ZK, and we focus on how to minimize the setup for MPC and ZK while still providing meaningful levels of security. More specifically: Regarding MPC, we focus on the dishonest majority (i.e., the adversary can corrupt all but one party), and we aim at 1) minimizing the use of broadcast channels. 2) studying the MPC with pre-processing when no setup is available. • Informally, a broadcast channel guarantees that when a message is sent, this reaches all the parties, without ambiguity. It also guarantees that if an honest party receives a message from a corrupted party, then it is guaranteed that all the honest parties have received the message. To realize broadcast, parties in the protocol could run the broadcast protocol, which may require many rounds of peer-to-peer communications. An alternative way is to rely on physical or external infrastructure such as blockchain. In both cases, broadcast is expensive, as such, we want to minimize its use. In particular, this thesis presents the following results: – When assuming no setup, we give a complete characterization with respect to the use of broadcast channels, and we obtain the optimal results. – We consider the same problem for the case that we only want to allow the black-box use (i.e., do not have access to the code of the algorithm) of the oblivious transfer protocol. We also give a characterization. • In the standard definition of MPC, the parties’ private inputs are fixed before the start of the protocol. However, there is another type of MPC named MPC with pre-processing, where the protocol can pre-compute some messages without using parties’ inputs, and these messages can accelerate computations in the online phase (i.e., other computations that require parties’ inputs). Since some expensive computations can be pre-computed, the online phase could be more lightweight. Therefore, we want to remove the dependency of the input from as many rounds as possible, so that we can do some pre-processing. In this direction, we explore the protocol with no setup. We provide a compiler that can turn a big class of MPC protocol that may require the inputs already to compute the first round, into a new protocol that needs the inputs only in the last two rounds. We also propose new MPC definitions that capture this delayed-input features. Regarding ZK, we do the following: • In standard single-theorem ZK definition, the security of the ZK protocol is guaranteed to hold only when one proof is issued. In the case where multiple zero-knowledge proofs need to be issued (i.e., to prove multiple NP statements), each new zero-knowledge proof requires a freshly generated setup. In the multi-theorem ZK definition, instead, one setup is sufficient for generating multiple zero-knowledge proofs for multiple instances. We propose a multi-theorem protocol (in the format of a compiler) that follows the Fiat-Shamir paradigm and relies on correlation intractable hash functions. Moreover, our protocol remains zero-knowledge and sound even against adversaries that choose the statement to be proven (and the witness for the case of zero-knowledge) adaptively on the key of the hash function. Prior works could achieve this adaptive security only inefficiently via NP reductions. • ZK protocols are secure only when all setups are correctly generated, but in real-world scenarios, some of the setups may not be correctly generated. For instance, to run a non-interactive zero-knowledge (NIZK) protocol, the setup CRS could be chosen with bias. In this case, the security of the NIZK protocol does not hold anymore. Instead of finding a secure ZK candidate, one alternative solution is to have multiple instantiations of ZK candidates and assume that only for a subset of them the setup is generated correctly. More formally, we consider the case where only a subset of the instances are secure. In more detail, given access to n candidate instantiations of a NIZK for some language, we want to have a construction that itself implements a NIZK for the same language without relying on any additional computational assumptions. We refer to this type of construction as combiner, and the combiner is secure assuming at least t of the given candidates are secure. In this work, we provide three different constructions of robust NIZK combiners and show that combiners are impossible to realize unless the majority of the input candidates are secure.

DOI
10.7488/era/6686

Related papers

Broadcast-Efficient Secure Multiparty Computation.

Juan A. Garay, Clint Givens, Rafail Ostrovsky

Secure multiparty computation (MPC) is perhaps the most popular paradigm in the area of cryptographic protocols. It allows several mutually untrustworthy parties to jointly compute a function of their private inputs, without revealing to each other information about those inputs. In the case of unconditional (information-theoretic) security, protocols are known which tolerate a dishonest minority of players, who may coordinate their attack and deviate arbitrarily from the protocol specification. It is typically assumed in these results that parties are connected pairwise by authenticated, private channels, and that in addition they have access to a “broadcast ” channel. Broadcast allows one party to send a consistent message to all other parties, guaranteeing consistency even if the broadcaster is corrupted. Because broadcast cannot be simulated on the point-to-point network when more than a third of the parties are corrupt, it is impossible to construct general MPC protocols in this setting without using a broadcast channel (or some equivalent addition to the model). A great deal of research has focused on increasing the efficiency of MPC, primarily in terms of round complexity and communication complexity. In this work we propose a refinement of the round complexity which we term broadcast complexity. We view the broadcast channel as an expensive resource

•Jan 1, 2012•2 citations

Towards Optimality in Secure Computation

Saikrishna Badrinarayanan

The need for Cryptography arises out of the following fundamental question: can we perform useful computation while ensuring that an adversary does not learn anything about our private sensitive data? The notion of secure multiparty computation (MPC) \\cite{Yao82,GMW87} is a unifying framework for general secure protocols. MPC allows mutually distrusting parties to jointly evaluate any efficiently computable function on their private inputs in such a manner that each party does not learn anything beyond the output of the function. In this thesis, we study the question of building MPC protocols in various security models from standard cryptographic assumptions while minimizing the number of rounds of interaction amongst parties. In the first part of this thesis, (in a joint work with Vipul Goyal, Abhishek Jain, Yael Kalai, Dakshita Khurana and Amit Sahai, CRYPTO 2018) we construct the first round-optimal (i.e., four round) MPC protocol for general functions based on polynomially hard DDH (or QR or N$^{th}$-Residuosity) in the plain model where parties have access to no trusted setup. We further show how to overcome the four-round barrier for MPC by constructing a three-round protocol for ``list coin-tossing'' -- a slight relaxation of coin-tossing that suffices for most conceivable applications -- based on polynomially hard DDH (or QR or N$^{th}$-Residuosity). This result generalizes to randomized input-less functionalities. Previously, four round MPC protocols required sub-exponential-time hardness assumptions and no multi-party three-round protocols were known for any relaxed security notions with polynomial-time simulation against malicious adversaries. In order to build these protocols, we devise a new {\\em partitioned simulation} technique for MPC where the simulator uses different strategies for simulating the view of aborting adversaries and non-aborting adversaries. The protagonist of this technique is a new notion of {\\em promise zero knowledge} (ZK) where the ZK property only holds against non-aborting verifiers. We show how to realize promise ZK in three rounds in the simultaneous-message model assuming polynomially hard DDH (or QR or N$^{th}$-Residuosity). We also rely upon a new {\\em leveled rewinding security} technique that can be viewed as a polynomial-time alternative to leveled complexity leveraging for achieving ``non-malleability'' across different primitives. Then, we also we study the round complexity of concurrently secure multi-party computation (MPC) with super-polynomial simulation (SPS) in the plain model (in a joint work with Vipul Goyal, Abhishek Jain, Dakshita Khurana and Amit Sahai, TCC 2017). In the plain model, there are known explicit attacks that show that concurrently secure MPC with polynomial simulation is impossible to achieve; SPS security is the most widely studied model for concurrently secure MPC in the plain model. We construct a three-round concurrent MPC with SPS security against Byzantine adversaries, assuming sub-exponentially secure DDH and LWE. Prior to our work, the best known round complexity for SPS concurrent MPC was around twenty, although to the best of our knowledge, no previous work even gave an approximation of the constant round complexity that is sufficient for concurrent MPC.In the second part of the thesis, (in a joint work with Abhishek Jain, Rafail Ostrovsky and Ivan Visconti, ASIACRYPT 2018), we study the problem of non-interactive secure computation in the stateless hardware token model where parties have access to physical hardware as part of a trusted setup phase. The notion of non-interactive secure computation (NISC) first introduced in the work of Ishai et al. [EUROCRYPT 2011] studies the following problem: Suppose a receiver $R$ wishes to publish an encryption of her secret input $y$ so that any sender $S$ with input $x$ can then send a message $m$ that reveals $f(x,y)$ to $R$ (for some function $f$). Here, $m$ can be viewed as an encryption of $f(x,y)$ that can be decrypted by $R$. NISC requires security against both malicious senders and receivers, and also requires the receiver's message to be reusable across multiple computations (w.r.t. a fixed input of the receiver). All previous solutions to this problem necessarily rely upon OT (or specific number-theoretic assumptions) even in the common reference string model or the random oracle model or to achieve weaker notions of security such as super-polynomial-time simulation. In this work, we construct a NISC protocol based on the minimal assumption of one way functions, in the stateless hardware token model. Our construction achieves UC security and requires a single token sent by the receiver to the sender.

•Jan 1, 2019•0 citations

The mirage of honesty in cryptography: secure multi-party computation with untrusted devices

Lorenzo Magliocco

Secure Multi-Party Computation (MPC) is a widely acknowledged framework enabling the design of multi-party protocols that preserve the privacy of parties' inputs while ensuring the correct evaluation of the desired functionality. Crucially, these security guarantees should hold even in the presence of external entities who are empowered with some adversarial capabilities, such as controlling the communication channels used throughout the protocol run or forcing a subset of the parties to behave arbitrarily (so-called ``malicious" or ``byzantine" corruptions). Concretely, a user can instantiate secure MPC protocols on a device to carry out computations involving sensitive information with other untrusted parties. Despite capturing very general classes of real-world threats, one limitation of ``traditional" MPC lies in assuming at least one ``honest" party who, throughout the protocol run, behaves exactly as per the theoretical specification of the protocol itself. For several practical settings this may be unrealistic, as the devices used to run the protocol are themselves exposed to a plethora of threats, such as attacks on software or hardware components. Moreover, the security guarantees provided by secure MPC could be voided if a protocol is found to be faulty, be it from cryptographic assumptions falling short or from an incorrect formalization of the protocol itself. In this composition, we explore more expressive frameworks that enable the design of secure MPC protocols and cryptographic primitives even in the presence of untrusted devices. We first consider cryptographic reverse firewalls: lightweight devices that sanitize a party's traffic while preserving the correctness of the protocol. These objects were originally introduced by Mironov and Stephens-Davidowitz (EUROCRYPT'15) and later embedded in the framework of subversion-resilient Universal Composability (srUC) due to Chakraborty et al. (EUROCRYPT'22). Under the srUC framework, it is possible to design protocols that provide meaningful security guarantees even if the devices of honest parties have been tampered with in an undetectable manner with the goal of exfiltrating information (so-called ``specious subversion attacks"). In particular, we focus on the design of protocols for Password-Authenticated Key Exchange (PAKE): a cryptographic primitive that enables two parties to mutually authenticate by establishing a shared high-entropy key leveraging exclusively some (possibly low-entropy) pre-shared password. (1) Our first contribution focuses on sanitizing the PAKE protocol from Oblivious Transfer (OT) due to Canetti et al. (PKC'12). For that, we design and instantiate novel cryptographic primitives with sanitation-friendly properties that may be of independent interest, including sanitizable variants of oblivious transfer, dual-mode cryptosystems, and signature schemes. As an additional contribution, we formalize the unauthenticated setting in the srUC framework by extending the framework of split-authentication due to Barak et al. (CRYPTO'05, JoC'07). This is the first PAKE protocol ever designed in the srUC framework. (2) Our second contribution consists of sanitizing the PAKE protocol from trapdoor smooth-projective hashing due to Benhamouda and Pointcheval (CRYPTO'13). The sanitation requires non-trivial modifications to the original protocol, whose security relies on a CCA-secure encryption scheme - an inherently non-malleable primitive. Along the way, we bring advances to the field of malleable smooth-projective hash functions, originally introduced by Chen et al. (ASIACRYPT'16), and coin the notion of malleable trapdoor smooth-projective hashing. Our resulting PAKE protocol has better communication and round complexity compared to the aforementioned PAKE-from-OT. We then shift our attention to t-out-of-n robust combiners: constructions that take as input n candidate instantiations of some cryptographic primitive to securely realize the same primitive, as long as at least t of the candidates are secure. These objects were first formalized by Harnik et al. (EUROCRYPT'05), where robustness is characterized by explicitly forbidding combiners from re-implementing the desired primitive from scratch. Here, we focus on Non-Interactive Zero-Knowledge (NIZK): a cryptographic primitive that allows a prover to convince a verifier of the veracity of some NP-statement by using a single message (commonly referred to as a ``proof"). (3) Our third contribution provides a comprehensive characterization of robust combiners for NIZK. We show the first formal definition of these objects, and prove that no robust NIZK combiner exists for t ≤ n/2 unless the polynomial hierarchy collapses. To complement our negative results, we provide three incomparable constructions: (i) A black-box combiner for {\em homomorphic} NP languages, where n,t are polynomial and t > n/2; (ii) A non-black-box combiner for any NP language, where n,t are constant and t > n/2; (iii) A non-black-box combiner for any NP language, where n,t are polynomial and t > 2n/3.

•Jan 29, 2026•0 citations

Measures of efficiency for secure multiparty computation

Rafail Ostrovsky, Clint Givens

Multiparty computation (MPC) is a powerful and generic cryptographic framework capable of realizing essentially any cryptographic task (functionality) while preserving privacy and robustness. In the MPC model, a group of mutually distrustful parties seek to jointly compute a function f of their privately held inputs x1, ..., xn, while revealing no information about those inputs beyond what is entailed by the function output(s). Some portion of these players may be corrupted, controlled by a centralized adversary who directs their (mis)behavior and seeks to gain information on private inputs or to disrupt the protocol execution. In this work, we examine the resource requirements of information-theoretically secure multiparty computation. In particular, we look at trade-offs involving what we call assumptions, by which we mean two aspects of the model's setup: (1) the extent to which parties are connected by secure, pairwise communication channels; and (2) the usage (as a black box) of a channel—a primitive which enforces consistency among views by allowing a single party to send a message to all other parties which is guaranteed to be consistent, even if the broadcaster is corrupted. Part I of this work focuses on the first network-model assumption, that of the graph's connectivity by pairwise channels. We show upper and lower bounds on communication complexity in the Secure Message Transmission with Public Discussion (SMT-PD) model, as a function of the threshold of corrupted parties. The SMT-PD model, which abstracts the problem of secure communication over a partially connected network, includes two components: a public and a set of simple channels. We show significant improvements in both areas: on the channel, we reduce communication to logarithmic in terms of the message's bit-length m, where the previous best result was linear in m; on the simple channels, we reduce from O(mn) to O(mn/(n−t)), where n is the number of simple channels and t is a bound on the number of corrupted channels. Using tools from information theory, we show this amount of simple-wire communication is essentially optimal. Finally, we give an amortized solution which drastically improves communication over channel when the protocol is repeated many times sequentially. Part II shifts focus to the second network-model assumption, the use of an atomic broadcast primitive. Here we show that three broadcast rounds suffice for general secure computation, while two broadcast rounds are necessary. In particular we show that even for the natural and important functionality of Weak Secret Sharing—a type of distributed commitment—there is no protocol which uses only a single broadcast and achieves better than an explicit constant probability of success (so the protocol's success cannot be a function of a security parameter).

•Jan 1, 2013•0 citations

Publicly Auditable Secure Multi-Party Computation

Carsten Baum, Ivan Damgård, Claudio Orlandi

In the last few years the efficiency of secure multi-party computation (MPC) increased in several orders of magnitudes. However, this alone might not be enough if we want MPC protocols to be used in practice. A crucial property that is needed in many applications is that everyone can check that a given (secure) computation was performed correctly – even in the extreme case where all the parties involved in the computation are corrupted, and even if the party who wants to verify the result was not participating. This is especially relevant in the clients-servers setting, where many clients provide input to a secure computation performed by a few servers. An obvious example of this is electronic voting, but also in many types of auctions one may want independent verification of the result. Traditionally, this is achieved by using non-interactive zero-knowledge proofs during the computation.A recent trend in MPC protocols is to have a more expensive preprocessing phase followed by a very efficient online phase, e.g., the recent so-called SPDZ protocol by Damgård et al. Applications such as voting and some auctions are perfect use-case for these protocols, as the parties usually know well in advance when the computation will take place, and using those protocols allows us to use only cheap information-theoretic primitives in the actual computation. Unfortunately no protocol of the SPDZ type supports an audit phase.In this paper, we show how to achieve efficient MPC with a public audit. We formalize the concept of publicly auditable secure computation and provide an enhanced version of the SPDZ protocol where, even if all the servers are corrupted, anyone with access to the transcript of the protocol can check that the output is indeed correct. Most importantly, we do so without significantly compromising the performance of SPDZ i.e. our online phase has complexity approximately twice that of SPDZ.

Lecture notes in computer science•Jan 1, 2014•116 citations

On adaptive security and round efficiency in secure multi-party computation

Tal Malkin, Seung Geol Choi

Secure multi-party computation (MPC) enables distrustful parties to jointly perform computations while guaranteeing both the privacy of their inputs and the correctness of the computation. This thesis explores two aspects of secure multi-party computation: adaptive security and round efficiency. Adaptive security is concerned with an adversary that adaptively determines who and when to corrupt during the course of the computation. Even though this is a very natural and realistic assumption about the adversary, most of the MPC literature addresses security only against a static adversary — an adversary that chooses (and fixes) which parties to corrupt before the protocol starts executing. A protocol is called round-efficient if it runs in a small number of rounds. Constructing such protocols is important since efficiency of a protocol is greatly influenced by its round complexity. The security in this thesis is formulated in the universal composability (UC) framework introduced by Canetti [Can01]. Protocols secure in the UC framework remain secure even when executed concurrently with other arbitrary protocols running in some larger network, and can be used as subroutines of larger protocols in a modular fashion. This property is important considering that nowadays many protocols are executed concurrently with others in the Internet. With the focus on adaptive security and round efficiency, we obtain the following results: (1) We show that with access to an ideal commitment functionality, there exists a protocol that UC realizes any well-formed multi-party functionality against a malicious, adaptive adversary that may corrupt any number of parties, with black-box access to any protocol that UC realizes oblivious transfer against a semi-honest, adaptive adversary. (2) We show that there exists a protocol that UC realizes oblivious transfer against a semi-honest, adaptive adversary, with black-box access to a cryptographic primitive called a trapdoor simulatable cryptosystem, which is a natural relaxation of a simulatable cryptosystem introduced by Damgard and Nielsen [3N00]. We also show that the primitive can be constructed based on hardness of factoring. (3) We present a single-message protocol that UC realizes two-party computing with encrypted data (a variant of secure two-party computation), based on the DDH assumption and non- interactive zero-knowledge arguments. The protocol achieves security against a malicious, static adversary. (4) We present two round-efficient protocols that UC realize multi-party computing with encrypted data (a variant of secure multi-party computation), based on the DDH assumption and non-interactive zero-knowledge arguments. The first (resp. second) protocol requires one round (resp. two rounds) with appropriate preprocessing, which is independent of the exact circuit and actual inputs of the specific instance problem to solve — only the bound on the circuit size is known. Although the first protocol is more round-efficient, the preprocessing of the second is sometimes better under some efficiency considerations. Both protocols achieve security against a malicious, static adversary that may corrupt up to all but one parties.

•Jan 1, 2010•0 citations
Secure Multi-party Computation (MPC) considers the problem where a set of mutually distrusting parties want to jointly compute a function over their private inputs, without revealing any extra information about these inputs other than what it can be inferred from the output of the function. This setting is well-motivated, and it has many real-world applications such as auction, voting, etc. MPC can be also seen as a generalization of many natural cryptographic primitives. For example, zero-knowledge (ZK) can be viewed as a special case of two-party secure computation. In ZK, a party, called prover aims to convince a second party, called verifier, that the prover’s private input witness w and a public input statement x belong to a relation R. An important research direction in secure computation is to find the trade-off between the required setup (e.g., the use of the broadcast channel, the use of common reference string (CRS) / public key infrastructure (PKI), the upper bound of the parties that can be corrupted, etc.), and the security guarantees that can be achieved. The setups can be viewed as some general assumptions that the protocol needs to satisfy, and they influence the usability of the protocol in real-world scenarios. In principle, having simpler (or no) setups mean that the protocol is more general and can be more useful in real-world scenarios. At the same time, having simpler setups may lead to weaker security guarantees. Therefore, finding the trade-off between setup and security guarantees is important and meaningful. In this thesis, we target MPC and ZK, and we focus on how to minimize the setup for MPC and ZK while still providing meaningful levels of security. More specifically: Regarding MPC, we focus on the dishonest majority (i.e., the adversary can corrupt all but one party), and we aim at 1) minimizing the use of broadcast channels. 2) studying the MPC with pre-processing when no setup is available. • Informally, a broadcast channel guarantees that when a message is sent, this reaches all the parties, without ambiguity. It also guarantees that if an honest party receives a message from a corrupted party, then it is guaranteed that all the honest parties have received the message. To realize broadcast, parties in the protocol could run the broadcast protocol, which may require many rounds of peer-to-peer communications. An alternative way is to rely on physical or external infrastructure such as blockchain. In both cases, broadcast is expensive, as such, we want to minimize its use. In particular, this thesis presents the following results: – When assuming no setup, we give a complete characterization with respect to the use of broadcast channels, and we obtain the optimal results. – We consider the same problem for the case that we only want to allow the black-box use (i.e., do not have access to the code of the algorithm) of the oblivious transfer protocol. We also give a characterization. • In the standard definition of MPC, the parties’ private inputs are fixed before the start of the protocol. However, there is another type of MPC named MPC with pre-processing, where the protocol can pre-compute some messages without using parties’ inputs, and these messages can accelerate computations in the online phase (i.e., other computations that require parties’ inputs). Since some expensive computations can be pre-computed, the online phase could be more lightweight. Therefore, we want to remove the dependency of the input from as many rounds as possible, so that we can do some pre-processing. In this direction, we explore the protocol with no setup. We provide a compiler that can turn a big class of MPC protocol that may require the inputs already to compute the first round, into a new protocol that needs the inputs only in the last two rounds. We also propose new MPC definitions that capture this delayed-input features. Regarding ZK, we do the following: • In standard single-theorem ZK definition, the security of the ZK protocol is guaranteed to hold only when one proof is issued. In the case where multiple zero-knowledge proofs need to be issued (i.e., to prove multiple NP statements), each new zero-knowledge proof requires a freshly generated setup. In the multi-theorem ZK definition, instead, one setup is sufficient for generating multiple zero-knowledge proofs for multiple instances. We propose a multi-theorem protocol (in the format of a compiler) that follows the Fiat-Shamir paradigm and relies on correlation intractable hash functions. Moreover, our protocol remains zero-knowledge and sound even against adversaries that choose the statement to be proven (and the witness for the case of zero-knowledge) adaptively on the key of the hash function. Prior works could achieve this adaptive security only inefficiently via NP reductions. • ZK protocols are secure only when all setups are correctly generated, but in real-world scenarios, some of the setups may not be correctly generated. For instance, to run a non-interactive zero-knowledge (NIZK) protocol, the setup CRS could be chosen with bias. In this case, the security of the NIZK protocol does not hold anymore. Instead of finding a secure ZK candidate, one alternative solution is to have multiple instantiations of ZK candidates and assume that only for a subset of them the setup is generated correctly. More formally, we consider the case where only a subset of the instances are secure. In more detail, given access to n candidate instantiations of a NIZK for some language, we want to have a construction that itself implements a NIZK for the same language without relying on any additional computational assumptions. We refer to this type of construction as combiner, and the combiner is secure assuming at least t of the given candidates are secure. In this work, we provide three different constructions of robust NIZK combiners and show that combiners are impossible to realize unless the majority of the input candidates are secure.
Secure multiparty computation (MPC) is perhaps the most popular paradigm in the area of cryptographic protocols. It allows several mutually untrustworthy parties to jointly compute a function of their private inputs, without revealing to each other information about those inputs. In the case of unconditional (information-theoretic) security, protocols are known which tolerate a dishonest minority of players, who may coordinate their attack and deviate arbitrarily from the protocol specification. It is typically assumed in these results that parties are connected pairwise by authenticated, private channels, and that in addition they have access to a “broadcast ” channel. Broadcast allows one party to send a consistent message to all other parties, guaranteeing consistency even if the broadcaster is corrupted. Because broadcast cannot be simulated on the point-to-point network when more than a third of the parties are corrupt, it is impossible to construct general MPC protocols in this setting without using a broadcast channel (or some equivalent addition to the model). A great deal of research has focused on increasing the efficiency of MPC, primarily in terms of round complexity and communication complexity. In this work we propose a refinement of the round complexity which we term broadcast complexity. We view the broadcast channel as an expensive resource
The need for Cryptography arises out of the following fundamental question: can we perform useful computation while ensuring that an adversary does not learn anything about our private sensitive data? The notion of secure multiparty computation (MPC) \\cite{Yao82,GMW87} is a unifying framework for general secure protocols. MPC allows mutually distrusting parties to jointly evaluate any efficiently computable function on their private inputs in such a manner that each party does not learn anything beyond the output of the function. In this thesis, we study the question of building MPC protocols in various security models from standard cryptographic assumptions while minimizing the number of rounds of interaction amongst parties. In the first part of this thesis, (in a joint work with Vipul Goyal, Abhishek Jain, Yael Kalai, Dakshita Khurana and Amit Sahai, CRYPTO 2018) we construct the first round-optimal (i.e., four round) MPC protocol for general functions based on polynomially hard DDH (or QR or Nth^{th}th-Residuosity) in the plain model where parties have access to no trusted setup. We further show how to overcome the four-round barrier for MPC by constructing a three-round protocol for ``list coin-tossing'' -- a slight relaxation of coin-tossing that suffices for most conceivable applications -- based on polynomially hard DDH (or QR or Nth^{th}th-Residuosity). This result generalizes to randomized input-less functionalities. Previously, four round MPC protocols required sub-exponential-time hardness assumptions and no multi-party three-round protocols were known for any relaxed security notions with polynomial-time simulation against malicious adversaries. In order to build these protocols, we devise a new {\\em partitioned simulation} technique for MPC where the simulator uses different strategies for simulating the view of aborting adversaries and non-aborting adversaries. The protagonist of this technique is a new notion of {\\em promise zero knowledge} (ZK) where the ZK property only holds against non-aborting verifiers. We show how to realize promise ZK in three rounds in the simultaneous-message model assuming polynomially hard DDH (or QR or Nth^{th}th-Residuosity). We also rely upon a new {\\em leveled rewinding security} technique that can be viewed as a polynomial-time alternative to leveled complexity leveraging for achieving ``non-malleability'' across different primitives. Then, we also we study the round complexity of concurrently secure multi-party computation (MPC) with super-polynomial simulation (SPS) in the plain model (in a joint work with Vipul Goyal, Abhishek Jain, Dakshita Khurana and Amit Sahai, TCC 2017). In the plain model, there are known explicit attacks that show that concurrently secure MPC with polynomial simulation is impossible to achieve; SPS security is the most widely studied model for concurrently secure MPC in the plain model. We construct a three-round concurrent MPC with SPS security against Byzantine adversaries, assuming sub-exponentially secure DDH and LWE. Prior to our work, the best known round complexity for SPS concurrent MPC was around twenty, although to the best of our knowledge, no previous work even gave an approximation of the constant round complexity that is sufficient for concurrent MPC.In the second part of the thesis, (in a joint work with Abhishek Jain, Rafail Ostrovsky and Ivan Visconti, ASIACRYPT 2018), we study the problem of non-interactive secure computation in the stateless hardware token model where parties have access to physical hardware as part of a trusted setup phase. The notion of non-interactive secure computation (NISC) first introduced in the work of Ishai et al. [EUROCRYPT 2011] studies the following problem: Suppose a receiver RRR wishes to publish an encryption of her secret input yyy so that any sender SSS with input xxx can then send a message mmm that reveals f(x,y)f(x,y)f(x,y) to RRR (for some function fff). Here, mmm can be viewed as an encryption of f(x,y)f(x,y)f(x,y) that can be decrypted by RRR. NISC requires security against both malicious senders and receivers, and also requires the receiver's message to be reusable across multiple computations (w.r.t. a fixed input of the receiver). All previous solutions to this problem necessarily rely upon OT (or specific number-theoretic assumptions) even in the common reference string model or the random oracle model or to achieve weaker notions of security such as super-polynomial-time simulation. In this work, we construct a NISC protocol based on the minimal assumption of one way functions, in the stateless hardware token model. Our construction achieves UC security and requires a single token sent by the receiver to the sender.
Secure Multi-Party Computation (MPC) is a widely acknowledged framework enabling the design of multi-party protocols that preserve the privacy of parties' inputs while ensuring the correct evaluation of the desired functionality. Crucially, these security guarantees should hold even in the presence of external entities who are empowered with some adversarial capabilities, such as controlling the communication channels used throughout the protocol run or forcing a subset of the parties to behave arbitrarily (so-called ``malicious" or ``byzantine" corruptions). Concretely, a user can instantiate secure MPC protocols on a device to carry out computations involving sensitive information with other untrusted parties. Despite capturing very general classes of real-world threats, one limitation of ``traditional" MPC lies in assuming at least one ``honest" party who, throughout the protocol run, behaves exactly as per the theoretical specification of the protocol itself. For several practical settings this may be unrealistic, as the devices used to run the protocol are themselves exposed to a plethora of threats, such as attacks on software or hardware components. Moreover, the security guarantees provided by secure MPC could be voided if a protocol is found to be faulty, be it from cryptographic assumptions falling short or from an incorrect formalization of the protocol itself. In this composition, we explore more expressive frameworks that enable the design of secure MPC protocols and cryptographic primitives even in the presence of untrusted devices. We first consider cryptographic reverse firewalls: lightweight devices that sanitize a party's traffic while preserving the correctness of the protocol. These objects were originally introduced by Mironov and Stephens-Davidowitz (EUROCRYPT'15) and later embedded in the framework of subversion-resilient Universal Composability (srUC) due to Chakraborty et al. (EUROCRYPT'22). Under the srUC framework, it is possible to design protocols that provide meaningful security guarantees even if the devices of honest parties have been tampered with in an undetectable manner with the goal of exfiltrating information (so-called ``specious subversion attacks"). In particular, we focus on the design of protocols for Password-Authenticated Key Exchange (PAKE): a cryptographic primitive that enables two parties to mutually authenticate by establishing a shared high-entropy key leveraging exclusively some (possibly low-entropy) pre-shared password. (1) Our first contribution focuses on sanitizing the PAKE protocol from Oblivious Transfer (OT) due to Canetti et al. (PKC'12). For that, we design and instantiate novel cryptographic primitives with sanitation-friendly properties that may be of independent interest, including sanitizable variants of oblivious transfer, dual-mode cryptosystems, and signature schemes. As an additional contribution, we formalize the unauthenticated setting in the srUC framework by extending the framework of split-authentication due to Barak et al. (CRYPTO'05, JoC'07). This is the first PAKE protocol ever designed in the srUC framework. (2) Our second contribution consists of sanitizing the PAKE protocol from trapdoor smooth-projective hashing due to Benhamouda and Pointcheval (CRYPTO'13). The sanitation requires non-trivial modifications to the original protocol, whose security relies on a CCA-secure encryption scheme - an inherently non-malleable primitive. Along the way, we bring advances to the field of malleable smooth-projective hash functions, originally introduced by Chen et al. (ASIACRYPT'16), and coin the notion of malleable trapdoor smooth-projective hashing. Our resulting PAKE protocol has better communication and round complexity compared to the aforementioned PAKE-from-OT. We then shift our attention to t-out-of-n robust combiners: constructions that take as input n candidate instantiations of some cryptographic primitive to securely realize the same primitive, as long as at least t of the candidates are secure. These objects were first formalized by Harnik et al. (EUROCRYPT'05), where robustness is characterized by explicitly forbidding combiners from re-implementing the desired primitive from scratch. Here, we focus on Non-Interactive Zero-Knowledge (NIZK): a cryptographic primitive that allows a prover to convince a verifier of the veracity of some NP-statement by using a single message (commonly referred to as a ``proof"). (3) Our third contribution provides a comprehensive characterization of robust combiners for NIZK. We show the first formal definition of these objects, and prove that no robust NIZK combiner exists for t ≤ n/2 unless the polynomial hierarchy collapses. To complement our negative results, we provide three incomparable constructions: (i) A black-box combiner for {\em homomorphic} NP languages, where n,t are polynomial and t > n/2; (ii) A non-black-box combiner for any NP language, where n,t are constant and t > n/2; (iii) A non-black-box combiner for any NP language, where n,t are polynomial and t > 2n/3.
Multiparty computation (MPC) is a powerful and generic cryptographic framework capable of realizing essentially any cryptographic task (functionality) while preserving privacy and robustness. In the MPC model, a group of mutually distrustful parties seek to jointly compute a function f of their privately held inputs x1, ..., xn, while revealing no information about those inputs beyond what is entailed by the function output(s). Some portion of these players may be corrupted, controlled by a centralized adversary who directs their (mis)behavior and seeks to gain information on private inputs or to disrupt the protocol execution. In this work, we examine the resource requirements of information-theoretically secure multiparty computation. In particular, we look at trade-offs involving what we call assumptions, by which we mean two aspects of the model's setup: (1) the extent to which parties are connected by secure, pairwise communication channels; and (2) the usage (as a black box) of a channel—a primitive which enforces consistency among views by allowing a single party to send a message to all other parties which is guaranteed to be consistent, even if the broadcaster is corrupted. Part I of this work focuses on the first network-model assumption, that of the graph's connectivity by pairwise channels. We show upper and lower bounds on communication complexity in the Secure Message Transmission with Public Discussion (SMT-PD) model, as a function of the threshold of corrupted parties. The SMT-PD model, which abstracts the problem of secure communication over a partially connected network, includes two components: a public and a set of simple channels. We show significant improvements in both areas: on the channel, we reduce communication to logarithmic in terms of the message's bit-length m, where the previous best result was linear in m; on the simple channels, we reduce from O(mn) to O(mn/(n−t)), where n is the number of simple channels and t is a bound on the number of corrupted channels. Using tools from information theory, we show this amount of simple-wire communication is essentially optimal. Finally, we give an amortized solution which drastically improves communication over channel when the protocol is repeated many times sequentially. Part II shifts focus to the second network-model assumption, the use of an atomic broadcast primitive. Here we show that three broadcast rounds suffice for general secure computation, while two broadcast rounds are necessary. In particular we show that even for the natural and important functionality of Weak Secret Sharing—a type of distributed commitment—there is no protocol which uses only a single broadcast and achieves better than an explicit constant probability of success (so the protocol's success cannot be a function of a security parameter).
In the last few years the efficiency of secure multi-party computation (MPC) increased in several orders of magnitudes. However, this alone might not be enough if we want MPC protocols to be used in practice. A crucial property that is needed in many applications is that everyone can check that a given (secure) computation was performed correctly – even in the extreme case where all the parties involved in the computation are corrupted, and even if the party who wants to verify the result was not participating. This is especially relevant in the clients-servers setting, where many clients provide input to a secure computation performed by a few servers. An obvious example of this is electronic voting, but also in many types of auctions one may want independent verification of the result. Traditionally, this is achieved by using non-interactive zero-knowledge proofs during the computation.A recent trend in MPC protocols is to have a more expensive preprocessing phase followed by a very efficient online phase, e.g., the recent so-called SPDZ protocol by Damgård et al. Applications such as voting and some auctions are perfect use-case for these protocols, as the parties usually know well in advance when the computation will take place, and using those protocols allows us to use only cheap information-theoretic primitives in the actual computation. Unfortunately no protocol of the SPDZ type supports an audit phase.In this paper, we show how to achieve efficient MPC with a public audit. We formalize the concept of publicly auditable secure computation and provide an enhanced version of the SPDZ protocol where, even if all the servers are corrupted, anyone with access to the transcript of the protocol can check that the output is indeed correct. Most importantly, we do so without significantly compromising the performance of SPDZ i.e. our online phase has complexity approximately twice that of SPDZ.
Secure multi-party computation (MPC) enables distrustful parties to jointly perform computations while guaranteeing both the privacy of their inputs and the correctness of the computation. This thesis explores two aspects of secure multi-party computation: adaptive security and round efficiency. Adaptive security is concerned with an adversary that adaptively determines who and when to corrupt during the course of the computation. Even though this is a very natural and realistic assumption about the adversary, most of the MPC literature addresses security only against a static adversary — an adversary that chooses (and fixes) which parties to corrupt before the protocol starts executing. A protocol is called round-efficient if it runs in a small number of rounds. Constructing such protocols is important since efficiency of a protocol is greatly influenced by its round complexity. The security in this thesis is formulated in the universal composability (UC) framework introduced by Canetti [Can01]. Protocols secure in the UC framework remain secure even when executed concurrently with other arbitrary protocols running in some larger network, and can be used as subroutines of larger protocols in a modular fashion. This property is important considering that nowadays many protocols are executed concurrently with others in the Internet. With the focus on adaptive security and round efficiency, we obtain the following results: (1) We show that with access to an ideal commitment functionality, there exists a protocol that UC realizes any well-formed multi-party functionality against a malicious, adaptive adversary that may corrupt any number of parties, with black-box access to any protocol that UC realizes oblivious transfer against a semi-honest, adaptive adversary. (2) We show that there exists a protocol that UC realizes oblivious transfer against a semi-honest, adaptive adversary, with black-box access to a cryptographic primitive called a trapdoor simulatable cryptosystem, which is a natural relaxation of a simulatable cryptosystem introduced by Damgard and Nielsen [3N00]. We also show that the primitive can be constructed based on hardness of factoring. (3) We present a single-message protocol that UC realizes two-party computing with encrypted data (a variant of secure two-party computation), based on the DDH assumption and non- interactive zero-knowledge arguments. The protocol achieves security against a malicious, static adversary. (4) We present two round-efficient protocols that UC realize multi-party computing with encrypted data (a variant of secure multi-party computation), based on the DDH assumption and non-interactive zero-knowledge arguments. The first (resp. second) protocol requires one round (resp. two rounds) with appropriate preprocessing, which is independent of the exact circuit and actual inputs of the specific instance problem to solve — only the bound on the circuit size is known. Although the first protocol is more round-efficient, the preprocessing of the second is sometimes better under some efficiency considerations. Both protocols achieve security against a malicious, static adversary that may corrupt up to all but one parties.