Theoretical methods that are accurate for both short-distance observables and long-wavelength collective modes are still being developed for the Hubbard model. Here, we benchmark an approach that combines dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT) observables with the two-particle self-consistent theory (TPSC). This offers a way to include non-local correlations in DMFT while also improving TPSC. The benchmarks are published diagrammatic quantum Monte Carlo results for the two-dimensional square lattice Hubbard model with nearest-neighbor hopping. This method (
TPSC+DMFT) is relevant for weak to intermediate interaction, satisfies the local Pauli principle, and allows us to compute a spin susceptibility that satisfies the Mermin-Wagner theorem. The DMFT double occupancy determines the spin and charge vertices through local spin and charge sum rules. The TPSC self-energy is also improved by replacing its local part with the local DMFT self-energy. With this method, we find improvements for both spin and charge fluctuations and for the self-energy. We also find that the accuracy check developed for TPSC is a good predictor of deviations from benchmarks for this model.
TPSC+DMFT can be used in regimes where quantum Monte Carlo is inaccessible. In addition, this method paves the way to multiband generalizations of TPSC that could be used in advanced electronic structure codes that include DMFT.
In this paper, we present a multiorbital form of the two-particle self-consistent approach (TPSC) where the effective local and static irreducible interaction vertices are determined by means of the dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT). This approach replaces the approximate ansatz equations for the double-occupations $\ensuremath{\langle}{n}_{\ensuremath{\alpha},\ensuremath{\sigma}}^{}{n}_{\ensuremath{\beta},{\ensuremath{\sigma}}^{\ensuremath{'}}}^{}\ensuremath{\rangle}$ by sampling them directly for the same model using DMFT. Compared to the usual Hartree-Fock-like ansatz, this leads to more accurate local vertices in the weakly correlated regime and provides access to stronger correlated systems that were previously out of reach. This approach is extended by replacing the local component of the TPSC self-energy by the DMFT impurity self-energy, which results in an improved self-energy that incorporates strong local correlations but retains a nontrivial momentum dependence. We find that this combination of TPSC and DMFT provides a significant improvement over the multiorbital formulation of TPSC as it allows to determine the components of the spin vertex without artificial symmetry assumptions and opens the possibility to include the transversal particle-hole channel. The new approach is also able to remove unphysical divergences in the charge vertices in TPSC. We find a general trend that lower temperatures can be accessed in the calculation. Benchmarking single-particle quantities, such as the local spectral function with other many-body methods, we find significant improvement in the more strongly correlated regime.
Theoretical studies of semiconductors and band insulators are usually based on variants of the
GW method without full self-consistency, like single-shot
G0W0 or quasiparticle self-consistent
GW. Fully self-consistent
GW provides a poor description of the gap size and electronic structure due to the lack of vertex corrections. While it is hard to predict at which order corrections can be neglected, local vertex corrections to all orders can be consistently included by combining
GW with extended dynamical mean field theory (EDMFT). Here, we show that \textit{ab initio} multitier
GW+EDMFT calculations, which achieve full self-consistency in a suitably defined low-energy space, provide an accurate description of semiconductors and band insulators, comparable to the established methods which are typically used for this class of materials. Our results demonstrate that the range of applicability of
GW+EDMFT extends to weakly correlated systems, and they imply that despite the weak correlations, local vertex corrections are an important ingredient in the diagrammatic treatment of semiconductors and band insulators.