Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Coulomb Crystal Studies, Sympathetic Cooling, and Mass Spectrometry Using Laser-Cooled Be+ Ions

U. Fröhlich

Published Jan 1, 2009• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

In this work, the setup of an experiment aimed at high-precision laser spectroscopy of ultracold molecular hydrogen ions, started at the University of Konstanz in 1999 [1,2], was continued and first results were obtained. In particular, a new linear rf trap and a new trap supply electronics were built, the latter being capable of driving the linear rf trap with a maximum rf amplitude of > 1000V at a frequency of 14.2MHz. This made possible the simultaneous trapping of a large mass range (2u For laser cooling of Be+ ions, doubly resonant sum-frequency generation (DR-SFG) of 313nm laser light was performed between a resonantly frequency-doubled monolithic Nd:Yag laser and a Ti:sapphire laser, emitting at 532 and 760nm wavelength, respectively. An output power of P_UV > 100mW was achieved at 313nm wavelength, with a high spectral purity (rms short-term frequency fluctuations With this experimental setup, sympathetic cooling of N+, BeD+, BeH+, 4He+, HD+, and D+ ions by the laser-cooled Be+ ions was demonstrated, using laser-cooled fluorescence mass spectrometry (LCF-MS) to detect the sympathetically cooled species. Accordingly, sympathetic cooling at a minimum mass ratio of m(H2+)/m(Be+) = 0.22 was shown to be possible with both the sympathetically and laser-cooled ions in a cloud-like state. This points out the incorrectness of the theoretical lower limit m_SC/m_LC = 0.53 which was predicted in Ref.[3]. Here, the subscripts SC and LC denote the sympathetically and the laser-cooled species, respectively. In a further experiment, almost pure Be+ ion plasmas were laser-cooled down to temperatures in the milli-Kelvin range, leading to the crystallization of the Be+ ion plasmas. The outer shapes of different-sized Be+ ion crystals in a fully anisotropic trap potential were compared with the charged fluid predictions, showing good agreement at sufficiently large numbers of Be+ ions. By fitting Voigt profiles to the measured fluorescence signal, a typical temperature T(Be+) of 30mK was estimated for the Be+ ions. Finally, an ultracold sample of 4He+ ions [T(He+) approximately 40mK] was produced for the first time by sympathetic crystallization of the 4He+ ions. This may open up perspectives for the high-precision laser spectroscopy of 4He+ (and 3He+). [1] T.K.W. Boley, Diplomarbeit, Universitat Konstanz (1999) [2] H. Schnitzler, Dissertation, Universitat Konstanz (2001) [3] T. Baba and I. Waki, Appl.Phys.B, 74, 375-382 (2002)

Related papers

Ultra-cold molecules in Coulomb crystals

Bernhard Roth, U. Fröhlich, Andreas Ostendorf +2 more

Ultracold molecular hydrogen (D/sub 2//sup +/) is produced by sympathetic cooling in a linear Paul trap. With this method the translational degrees of freedom of the molecules are cooled by Coulomb interaction with laser-cooled /sup 9/Be/sup +/. This work shows that sympathetic cooling and crystallization is possible down to mass ratios of 0.45. Using molecular dynamics simulations, the mass range for sympathetic cooliing is predicted. By employin a light and a heavy species of laser-cooled ions (/sup 9/Be/sup +/ and e.g. /sup 137/Ba/sup +/) the mass range from 2 to 20 000 amu, i.e. from the simplest molecule to complex proteins, can be sympathetically cooled.

European Quantum Electronics Conference (EQEC)•Jan 1, 2003•1 citation

Production of Ultracold Trapped Molecular Hydrogen Ions

P. Blythe, Bernhard Roth, U. Fröhlich +2 more

We have cooled ensembles of the molecular hydrogen ions H2+, H3+, and all their deuterated variants to temperatures of a few mK in a radio frequency trap, by sympathetic cooling with laser-cooled beryllium ions. The molecular ions are embedded in the central regions of Coulomb crystals. Mass spectroscopy and molecular dynamics simulations were used to accurately characterize the properties of the ultracold multispecies crystals. We demonstrate species-selective purification of multispecies ensembles. These molecules are of fundamental importance as the simplest of all molecules, and have the potential to be used for precision tests of molecular structure theory, tests of Lorentz invariance, and measurements of electron to nuclear mass ratios and their time variation.

Physical Review Letters•Oct 26, 2005•128 citations

Sympathetic cooling of a Be+ ion by a Coulomb crystal of Sr+ ions: a test bed for taming antimatter ions (GBAR)

A. Douillet, D. Drapier, Jean‐Philippe Karr +3 more

The GBAR (Gravitational Behaviour of Antihydrogen at Rest) experiment at CERN, situated on the antiproton decelerator ring (AD), is aimed at investigating the free fall of antihydrogen atoms prepared at rest, as suggested by J. Walz and Th. Hänsch [1]. This experiment employs two trapped ions: one is a Be+ ion cooled via laser, while the other, an Hbar+ ion, undergoes cooling through interactions with the Be+ ion (sympathetic cooling). We are developing a test-bed experiment designed to explore sympathetic cooling of a light ion using a cloud of laser-cooled heavy ions, mimicking the conditions anticipated in the GBAR project [2]. The experimental setup involves the pairing of 88Sr+ (laser-cooled ion) and 9Be+ (sympathetically cooled ion). The choice of these ions offers two advantages: the ability to optically address the 9Be+ ion for thermometry measurements and their mass ratio (88/9 ≈ 9.8) closely resembling that in the GBAR project (9/1). Preliminary experimental results [3] demonstrate sympathetic cooling of 9Be+ ions by laser-cooled 88Sr+ ions, forming a Coulomb crystal. Detection of sympathetically cooled ions relies on analyzing Coulomb crystal images, revealing dark areas where non-laser-cooled Be+ ions reside. Molecular dynamics simulations showed strong spatial segregation for both species, due to their high mass ratios [4]. However, the initial experiment did not include laser addressing of the 9Be+ ions for measuring cooling dynamics and control over the initial energy of Be+ ions. The next stage of the project therefore involves adding the 313nm laser for addressing Be+ ions and utilizing a 2-zone trap to control the initial energy of a single Be+ ion. This will enable us to measure for the first time the capture dynamics of a light ion by a Coulomb crystal and to follow its cooling over several decades (typically from 10000K to mK). We will compare these measurements with numerical simulations [4]. Initially, only Sr+ ions were employed to validate trapping and cooling conditions, characterize photon collection optics, and test ion transport protocols between trapping zones. A method utilizing Doppler recooling was developed to characterize the initial energy of Sr+ ions upon arrival in the target trap. Subsequently, using the Be+ ion cooling laser at 313 nm, it will be possible to cool a single Be+ ion and transport it with controlled kinetic energy to the second trapping zone, already loaded with a Sr+ Coulomb crystal. The kinetic energy loss of the Be+ ion is quantified by measuring laser-induced fluorescence rate at resonance, which produces no laser cooling or heating. Thermalization of the light ion via coulomb interactions will then be studied for different heavy-ion crystal temperatures, shapes and ion numbers.

•Jul 7, 2024•0 citations

Ultracold molecular hydrogen ions in a linear radiofrequency trap: Novel systems for molecular frequency metrology

Bernhard Roth, H. Daerr, Jeroen C. J. Koelemeij +2 more

We have measured the ro-vibrational infrared transition (v = 0, J = 2) → (v = 4, J = 1) in ultracold HD+ molecular ions embedded inside Be+ Coulomb crystals, by 1+1 REMPI spectroscopy. The molecular ions, trapped in a linear radiofrequency trap, were cooled to temperatures of few tens of mK, via sympathetic cooling using laser-cooled Be+ ions. For detection, we have used secular excitation of the HD+ ions to monitor their loss rate. The transition frequency agrees with a theoretical prediction.

European Frequency and Time Forum•Jan 1, 2006•1 citation

Sympathetic cooling and crystallization of ions in a linear Paul trap

Michael Drewsen, Paul David Bowe, Liv Hornekær +3 more

Coulomb crystals, containing up to a few hundred ions of which more than 50% were cooled sympathetically by the Coulomb interaction with laser cooled Mg+ ions, have been produced in a linear Paul trap. By controlling the balance of the radiation pressure from the two cooling lasers, the Coulomb crystals could be segregated according to ion species. Previous studies of ion crystals and molecular dynamics simulations suggest that the temperature may be around 10 mK or lower. The obtained results indicate that a wide range of atomic and molecular ions, which due to their internal structures are not amenable to direct laser cooling, can be effectively cooled and localized (crystallized) in linear Paul traps. For high resolution spectroscopy of such ions this may turn out to be very useful.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 1999•0 citations

Studies of trapped, cooled ion ensembles

David Offenberg

This work presents various novel results in the field of experimental and theoretical trapped ion studies. All investigations involve laser-cooled 138Ba+ ions confined in a linear quadrupole ion trap, which serve as coolant for complex molecular ions, as target for collisions with neutral atoms, or as model system in theoretical analyses. The special feature of the apparatus used in this work, is a molecular ion source based on electrospray ionization that allows for the production of gas-phase molecular ions of almost arbitrary species with a maximum mass-to-charge ratio of 2,000 Da. Trapped together with laser-cooled 138Ba+ ions, the molecular ions can be cooled down, kept cold and investigated for many minutes and in principle for up to hours in a nearly collisionless environment. In this work, the sympathetic cooling of complex molecular ions to translational temperatures below 1 K is demonstrated for different types of molecules covering a mass range from 182 to 12,400 Da. Using the example of the protein cytochrome c, with a mass of about 12,400 Da the most massive molecular species sympathetically cooled in an ion trap so far, the methods for detection of successful trapping and cooling, and temperature determination are presented in detail. In one case, multiply protonated molecules of the protein cytochrome c have been cooled to less than 0.75 K. Furthermore, two methods for measuring photodestruction rates of cold, trapped complex molecular ions have been developed that can, for example, be applied in destructive spectroscopy schemes. Both techniques are demonstrated using the example of singly protonated glycyrrhetinic acid molecules (GAH+) dissociated by an ultraviolet (UV) laser. Measurements of the photodestruction rate were performed at different intensities of the UV laser, and rates as low as 0.05 s-1 and less have been determined, which is only possible due to the long ion storage times that can be achieved with this apparatus. For the UV laser wavelength of 266 nm, a destruction cross section of (1.1±0.1)∙10E-17 cm2 for GAH+ has been determined. In this work, feasibility studies towards internal cooling of trapped complex molecular ions have been performed. Such an additional internal cooling could be realized via collisions with laser-cooled neutral atoms. To test their suitability, neutral atoms of Li, Na, K, Rb, Cs, and Yb have been collided with trapped laser-cooled and not cooled Ba+ ions as well as with complex molecular ions. For all species charge exchange reactions with Ba+ ions have been observed excluding these species for collisional cooling. While K, Rb, and Cs showed charge exchange reactions with ground state and laser-excited Ba+ ions, the charge exchange rates of Yb and Ba+ were found to be state dependent. Collisions of neutral Yb atoms were found to be reactive and lead to the formation of adducts and fragments, in contrast to the alkali metals for which no such reactions have been observed. In addition, the motion of cooled, trapped ions has been studied theoretically via simulations. When the translational energy of a trapped ion ensemble is sufficiently reduced, a first-order phase transition from a liquid to a solid state occurs with the ion ensemble changing from a disordered ion cloud to an ordered ion crystal. As ions in a linear quadrupole trap arrange in shell structures, a free motion in radial direction is disabled, and ions can only move to neighboring shells when their kinetic energy is high enough to overcome a certain potential barrier. The simulations have shown that intershell diffusion rates in the considered ion crystals increase exponentially when the ion temperatures exceed values that well agree with the predictions of other established models. Ion ensembles of different ion numbers (300, 500, and 1000 138Ba+ ions) and symmetries (prolate and spherical) have been investigated showing a clear tendency for the phase transition temperatures: The higher the ion number, the lower is the transition temperature.

•Jan 1, 2010•1 citation
In this work, the setup of an experiment aimed at high-precision laser spectroscopy of ultracold molecular hydrogen ions, started at the University of Konstanz in 1999 [1,2], was continued and first results were obtained. In particular, a new linear rf trap and a new trap supply electronics were built, the latter being capable of driving the linear rf trap with a maximum rf amplitude of > 1000V at a frequency of 14.2MHz. This made possible the simultaneous trapping of a large mass range (2u For laser cooling of Be+ ions, doubly resonant sum-frequency generation (DR-SFG) of 313nm laser light was performed between a resonantly frequency-doubled monolithic Nd:Yag laser and a Ti:sapphire laser, emitting at 532 and 760nm wavelength, respectively. An output power of P_UV > 100mW was achieved at 313nm wavelength, with a high spectral purity (rms short-term frequency fluctuations With this experimental setup, sympathetic cooling of N+, BeD+, BeH+, 4He+, HD+, and D+ ions by the laser-cooled Be+ ions was demonstrated, using laser-cooled fluorescence mass spectrometry (LCF-MS) to detect the sympathetically cooled species. Accordingly, sympathetic cooling at a minimum mass ratio of m(H2+)/m(Be+) = 0.22 was shown to be possible with both the sympathetically and laser-cooled ions in a cloud-like state. This points out the incorrectness of the theoretical lower limit m_SC/m_LC = 0.53 which was predicted in Ref.[3]. Here, the subscripts SC and LC denote the sympathetically and the laser-cooled species, respectively.
In a further experiment, almost pure Be+ ion plasmas were laser-cooled down to temperatures in the milli-Kelvin range, leading to the crystallization of the Be+ ion plasmas. The outer shapes of different-sized Be+ ion crystals in a fully anisotropic trap potential were compared with the charged fluid predictions, showing good agreement at sufficiently large numbers of Be+ ions. By fitting Voigt profiles to the measured fluorescence signal, a typical temperature T(Be+) of 30mK was estimated for the Be+ ions.
Finally, an ultracold sample of 4He+ ions [T(He+) approximately 40mK] was produced for the first time by sympathetic crystallization of the 4He+ ions. This may open up perspectives for the high-precision laser spectroscopy of 4He+ (and 3He+).
[1] T.K.W. Boley, Diplomarbeit, Universitat Konstanz (1999)
[2] H. Schnitzler, Dissertation, Universitat Konstanz (2001)
[3] T. Baba and I. Waki, Appl.Phys.B, 74, 375-382 (2002)
Ultracold molecular hydrogen (D/sub 2//sup +/) is produced by sympathetic cooling in a linear Paul trap. With this method the translational degrees of freedom of the molecules are cooled by Coulomb interaction with laser-cooled /sup 9/Be/sup +/. This work shows that sympathetic cooling and crystallization is possible down to mass ratios of 0.45. Using molecular dynamics simulations, the mass range for sympathetic cooliing is predicted. By employin a light and a heavy species of laser-cooled ions (/sup 9/Be/sup +/ and e.g. /sup 137/Ba/sup +/) the mass range from 2 to 20 000 amu, i.e. from the simplest molecule to complex proteins, can be sympathetically cooled.
We have cooled ensembles of the molecular hydrogen ions H2+, H3+, and all their deuterated variants to temperatures of a few mK in a radio frequency trap, by sympathetic cooling with laser-cooled beryllium ions. The molecular ions are embedded in the central regions of Coulomb crystals. Mass spectroscopy and molecular dynamics simulations were used to accurately characterize the properties of the ultracold multispecies crystals. We demonstrate species-selective purification of multispecies ensembles. These molecules are of fundamental importance as the simplest of all molecules, and have the potential to be used for precision tests of molecular structure theory, tests of Lorentz invariance, and measurements of electron to nuclear mass ratios and their time variation.
The GBAR (Gravitational Behaviour of Antihydrogen at Rest) experiment at CERN, situated on the antiproton decelerator ring (AD), is aimed at investigating the free fall of antihydrogen atoms prepared at rest, as suggested by J. Walz and Th. Hänsch [1]. This experiment employs two trapped ions: one is a Be+ ion cooled via laser, while the other, an Hbar+ ion, undergoes cooling through interactions with the Be+ ion (sympathetic cooling). We are developing a test-bed experiment designed to explore sympathetic cooling of a light ion using a cloud of laser-cooled heavy ions, mimicking the conditions anticipated in the GBAR project [2]. The experimental setup involves the pairing of 88Sr+ (laser-cooled ion) and 9Be+ (sympathetically cooled ion). The choice of these ions offers two advantages: the ability to optically address the 9Be+ ion for thermometry measurements and their mass ratio (88/9 ≈ 9.8) closely resembling that in the GBAR project (9/1). Preliminary experimental results [3] demonstrate sympathetic cooling of 9Be+ ions by laser-cooled 88Sr+ ions, forming a Coulomb crystal. Detection of sympathetically cooled ions relies on analyzing Coulomb crystal images, revealing dark areas where non-laser-cooled Be+ ions reside. Molecular dynamics simulations showed strong spatial segregation for both species, due to their high mass ratios [4]. However, the initial experiment did not include laser addressing of the 9Be+ ions for measuring cooling dynamics and control over the initial energy of Be+ ions. The next stage of the project therefore involves adding the 313nm laser for addressing Be+ ions and utilizing a 2-zone trap to control the initial energy of a single Be+ ion. This will enable us to measure for the first time the capture dynamics of a light ion by a Coulomb crystal and to follow its cooling over several decades (typically from 10000K to mK). We will compare these measurements with numerical simulations [4]. Initially, only Sr+ ions were employed to validate trapping and cooling conditions, characterize photon collection optics, and test ion transport protocols between trapping zones. A method utilizing Doppler recooling was developed to characterize the initial energy of Sr+ ions upon arrival in the target trap. Subsequently, using the Be+ ion cooling laser at 313 nm, it will be possible to cool a single Be+ ion and transport it with controlled kinetic energy to the second trapping zone, already loaded with a Sr+ Coulomb crystal. The kinetic energy loss of the Be+ ion is quantified by measuring laser-induced fluorescence rate at resonance, which produces no laser cooling or heating. Thermalization of the light ion via coulomb interactions will then be studied for different heavy-ion crystal temperatures, shapes and ion numbers.
We have measured the ro-vibrational infrared transition (v = 0, J = 2) → (v = 4, J = 1) in ultracold HD+ molecular ions embedded inside Be+ Coulomb crystals, by 1+1 REMPI spectroscopy. The molecular ions, trapped in a linear radiofrequency trap, were cooled to temperatures of few tens of mK, via sympathetic cooling using laser-cooled Be+ ions. For detection, we have used secular excitation of the HD+ ions to monitor their loss rate. The transition frequency agrees with a theoretical prediction.
Coulomb crystals, containing up to a few hundred ions of which more than 50% were cooled sympathetically by the Coulomb interaction with laser cooled Mg+ ions, have been produced in a linear Paul trap. By controlling the balance of the radiation pressure from the two cooling lasers, the Coulomb crystals could be segregated according to ion species. Previous studies of ion crystals and molecular dynamics simulations suggest that the temperature may be around 10 mK or lower. The obtained results indicate that a wide range of atomic and molecular ions, which due to their internal structures are not amenable to direct laser cooling, can be effectively cooled and localized (crystallized) in linear Paul traps. For high resolution spectroscopy of such ions this may turn out to be very useful.
This work presents various novel results in the field of experimental and theoretical trapped ion studies. All investigations involve laser-cooled 138Ba+ ions confined in a linear quadrupole ion trap, which serve as coolant for complex molecular ions, as target for collisions with neutral atoms, or as model system in theoretical analyses. The special feature of the apparatus used in this work, is a molecular ion source based on electrospray ionization that allows for the production of gas-phase molecular ions of almost arbitrary species with a maximum mass-to-charge ratio of 2,000 Da. Trapped together with laser-cooled 138Ba+ ions, the molecular ions can be cooled down, kept cold and investigated for many minutes and in principle for up to hours in a nearly collisionless environment. In this work, the sympathetic cooling of complex molecular ions to translational temperatures below 1 K is demonstrated for different types of molecules covering a mass range from 182 to 12,400 Da. Using the example of the protein cytochrome c, with a mass of about 12,400 Da the most massive molecular species sympathetically cooled in an ion trap so far, the methods for detection of successful trapping and cooling, and temperature determination are presented in detail. In one case, multiply protonated molecules of the protein cytochrome c have been cooled to less than 0.75 K. Furthermore, two methods for measuring photodestruction rates of cold, trapped complex molecular ions have been developed that can, for example, be applied in destructive spectroscopy schemes. Both techniques are demonstrated using the example of singly protonated glycyrrhetinic acid molecules (GAH+) dissociated by an ultraviolet (UV) laser. Measurements of the photodestruction rate were performed at different intensities of the UV laser, and rates as low as 0.05 s-1 and less have been determined, which is only possible due to the long ion storage times that can be achieved with this apparatus. For the UV laser wavelength of 266 nm, a destruction cross section of (1.1±0.1)∙10E-17 cm2 for GAH+ has been determined. In this work, feasibility studies towards internal cooling of trapped complex molecular ions have been performed. Such an additional internal cooling could be realized via collisions with laser-cooled neutral atoms. To test their suitability, neutral atoms of Li, Na, K, Rb, Cs, and Yb have been collided with trapped laser-cooled and not cooled Ba+ ions as well as with complex molecular ions. For all species charge exchange reactions with Ba+ ions have been observed excluding these species for collisional cooling. While K, Rb, and Cs showed charge exchange reactions with ground state and laser-excited Ba+ ions, the charge exchange rates of Yb and Ba+ were found to be state dependent. Collisions of neutral Yb atoms were found to be reactive and lead to the formation of adducts and fragments, in contrast to the alkali metals for which no such reactions have been observed. In addition, the motion of cooled, trapped ions has been studied theoretically via simulations. When the translational energy of a trapped ion ensemble is sufficiently reduced, a first-order phase transition from a liquid to a solid state occurs with the ion ensemble changing from a disordered ion cloud to an ordered ion crystal. As ions in a linear quadrupole trap arrange in shell structures, a free motion in radial direction is disabled, and ions can only move to neighboring shells when their kinetic energy is high enough to overcome a certain potential barrier. The simulations have shown that intershell diffusion rates in the considered ion crystals increase exponentially when the ion temperatures exceed values that well agree with the predictions of other established models. Ion ensembles of different ion numbers (300, 500, and 1000 138Ba+ ions) and symmetries (prolate and spherical) have been investigated showing a clear tendency for the phase transition temperatures: The higher the ion number, the lower is the transition temperature.