This paper aims to provide a thorough critical analysis of two foundational concepts in modern physics — the Landé g-factor and the electron spin quantum number 1/2. Through meticulous historical examination and logical analysis, this paper argues that these concepts are essentially mathematical fitting parameters introduced to bridge the gap between the old quantum theory and experimental data, lacking a solid foundation in physical mechanism. The core contradiction lies in the subsequent development of wave mechanics, which concluded that "the orbital angular momentum of the hydrogen atom ground state is zero," a conclusion that fundamentally conflicts with observational facts such as the Stern-Gerlach experiment, forcing the spin concept to assume a "remedial" role it never needed to bear. As a solution, this paper presents a new framework based on the "Great Tao Model" and the "Unified Theory of Atomic and Molecular Structure." This framework firmly returns to the realism of classical physics, affirms the orbital motion of electrons around the nucleus and their intrinsic angular momentum, and interprets spin as a real mechanical motion. Crucially, this theory naturally derives the universal magnetic moment-angular momentum relation μ = (e/m) L from the "Existence Field" principle, eliminating the need for any artificial correction factors. Based on this, the paper successfully provides a unified and self-consistent explanation for key phenomena such as the Stern-Gerlach experiment and the normal and anomalous Zeeman effects, thereby achieving a simpler and more fundamental description of physics at the atomic scale.
This paper aims to provide a thorough critical analysis of two foundational concepts in modern physics — the Landé g-factor and the electron spin quantum number 1/2. Through meticulous historical examination and logical analysis, this paper argues that these concepts are essentially mathematical fitting parameters introduced to bridge the gap between the old quantum theory and experimental data, lacking a solid foundation in physical mechanism. The core contradiction lies in the subsequent development of wave mechanics, which concluded that "the orbital angular momentum of the hydrogen atom ground state is zero," a conclusion that fundamentally conflicts with observational facts such as the Stern-Gerlach experiment, forcing the spin concept to assume a "remedial" role it never needed to bear. As a solution, this paper presents a new framework based on the "Great Tao Model" and the "Unified Theory of Atomic and Molecular Structure." This framework firmly returns to the realism of classical physics, affirms the orbital motion of electrons around the nucleus and their intrinsic angular momentum, and interprets spin as a real mechanical motion. Crucially, this theory naturally derives the universal magnetic moment-angular momentum relation μ = (e/m) L from the "Existence Field" principle, eliminating the need for any artificial correction factors. Based on this, the paper successfully provides a unified and self-consistent explanation for key phenomena such as the Stern-Gerlach experiment and the normal and anomalous Zeeman effects, thereby achieving a simpler and more fundamental description of physics at the atomic scale.
Intrinsic spin is a core foundational concept of quantum mechanics and the Standard Model of particle physics. It is regarded as an inherent property of fermions, based on which core laws such as spin angular momentum conservation and lepton number conservation have been established. However, through an experimental traceability and logical deduction of the spin concept, this paper finds that the spins of electrons and protons have never been directly measured. All spin conclusions are indirectly inferred from the macroscopic magnetic effects of neutral atoms and atomic nuclei. In beta decay, protons and neutrinos with a mass difference of more than 6 orders of magnitude participate in conservation with the same spin quantum number, which is only a formal numerical matching and lacks support from real physical mechanisms. The inclusion of neutrinos in the lepton family is essentially a post-hoc expansion to satisfy conservation laws, rather than an essential classification based on the origin of matter. In response to these contradictions, this paper proposes a classical orbital circulation magnetism model: the essence of atomic magnetic moment is the circulation effect formed by electrons orbiting the nucleus, and there is no "intrinsic spin" independent of the orbit. The energy level splitting in the Stern-Gerlach experiment is the statistical result of the orientation of the instantaneous orbital angular momentum of the s orbital in a magnetic field, rather than the manifestation of the intrinsic spin of electrons. Based on this model, this paper further explains the microscopic mechanism of ferromagnetism: whether the atomic magnetic moment can be reversed by an external magnetic field depends on the degree of orbital confinement. Inner orbitals are too strongly bound to turn, while the outermost free electron orbitals have too weak coupling to maintain orientation. Only the sub-outer orbitals of iron group elements are in the critical interval of "reversible and maintainable", thus exhibiting ferromagnetism. This model can self-consistently explain related experimental phenomena without introducing ad-hoc quantum concepts such as intrinsic spin and exchange interaction, and provides an alternative explanation path of classical mechanics for electromagnetic and magnetic phenomena. (本文在英文正文后附有完整中文版,内容与结构完全一致。)
Abstract In 1921, Otto Stern conceived the idea for an experiment that would decide between a classical and a quantum description of atomic behavior, as epitomized by the Bohr–Sommerfeld–Debye model of the atom. This model entailed not only the quantization of the magnitude of the orbital electronic angular momentum but also of the projection of the angular momentum on an external magnetic field – the so‐called space quantization. Stern recognized that space quantization would have observable consequences: namely, that the magnetic dipole moment due to the orbital angular momentum would be space quantized as well, taking two opposite values for atoms whose only unpaired electron has just one quantum of orbital angular momentum. When acted upon by a suitable inhomogeneous magnetic field, a beam of such atoms would be split into two beams consisting of deflected atoms with opposite projections of the orbital angular momentum on the magnetic field. In contradistinction, if atoms behaved classically, the atomic beam would only broaden along the field gradient and have maximum intensity at zero deflection, i. e., where there would be a minimum or no intensity for a beam split due to space quantization. Stern anticipated that, although simple in principle, the experiment would be difficult to carry out – and invited Walther Gerlach to team up with him. Gerlach's realism and experimental skills together with his sometimes stubborn determination to make things work proved invaluable for the success of the Stern–Gerlach experiment (SGE). After a long struggle, Gerlach finally saw, on 8 February 1922, the splitting of a beam of silver atoms in a magnetic field. The absence of the concept of electron spin confused and confounded the interpretation of the SGE, as the silver atoms were, in fact, in a 2S state, with zero orbital and spin angular momentum. However, a key quantum feature whose existence the SGE was designed to test – namely space quantization of electronic angular momentum – was robust enough to transpire independent of whether the electronic angular momentum was orbital or due to spin. The SGE entails other key aspects of quantum mechanics such as quantum measurement, state preparation, coherence, and entanglement. Confronted with the outcome of the SGE, Stern noted: “I still have objections to the idea of beauty of quantum mechanics. But she is correct.”
One of the main aims of the quantum theory was to clarify the atomic structure by making use of the various atomic phenomena as clues. On the basis of the success of Bohr's theory of the hydrogen atom, many kinds of challenge were made one after another. Generally speaking, the clarification of the atomic structure was proceeded through two ways. One way was based on the results in the spectroscopy of X-rays as well as light. The other was one that brought the phenomenological summaries of valuable chemical knowledge, such as represented by Mendelev's table of periodicity in 1869, to a substantialistic stage by analyzing them in connection with the atomic structure. This was the stage that became at length realizable on account of the progress in the quantum theory. The old quantum mechanics, which was developed on the basis of the quantum condition and selection rule, encountered with the difficulty of the factor 2. That is, firstly, the analyses of the anomalous Zeeman effect required half-integer quantum numbers and the anomalous coefficient 2 of magnetic moment. Secondly, in Stern-Gerlach's experiment, which was interpreted as proving the directional quantization, the atomic beam split into two components, instead of three components as in the normal Zeeman effect. Thirdly, the results of experiments on magnetization of matter demanded such a value for the specific charge of the electron as was twice as large as the value hitherto known. The analysis of X-ray spectra brought into existence another kind of spectral fine structure different from the relativistic fine structure. Of the substantialistic processes in which these problems were thrown into relief, not enough analyses have hitherto been made in the field of the history of science. Of the developments through which these problems were brought to solution, more or less similar situation has been seen. Bohr was in doubt about the half-integer quantum number and thus sought to solve the problem in terms of "non-mechanical constraint", introducing two kinds of azimuthal quantum numbers to treat the atomic structure. It was made clear by Landé and by Millikan and Bowen, however, that this was contradictory to experimental observations. Stoner then revised, with the use of half-integer quantum number, Bohr's scheme of configuration of electrons in atoms. This revision opened the way to Pauli's proposal of the exclusion principle and Uhlenbeck-Goudsmidt's introduction of the spin of the electron.
In the introductory remarks to Chapter 5 mention was made of the 1925 proposal of Uhlenbeck and Goudsmit that to an electron there should be assigned an intrinsic angular momentum or spin S = (S x , S y , S z )—this in addition to its quantum angular momentum (or orbital angular momentum) M = (M x , M y , M z ) defined in (5.4.4). This is not to be taken to mean that an electron actually spins about an axis in some physical way. Experiments (in particular the noted Stern-Gerlach experiment) have provided adequate justification for the proposed concept of spin, a proposal also made by R. Bichowsky and H. Urey. Dirac has shown that the notion of spin is necessary if quantum mechanics and Einstein relativity are to be consistent theories. Chemical properties of atoms, and their ability to combine and form molecules, the splitting of spectral lines by a magnetic field applied to an atom (i.e., the Zeeman effect, which we discuss later), all depend on this important notion.
Thus far we have concentrated on the postulates, on their ramifications, and on the means and methods by which they are applied. Connections with classical physics have been featured, and primary notions other than those of Chapter 5 have not been needed. We deviate from this path in the present chapter, introducing a new and extremely important concept; it is based on one of the most significant and fruitful experiments of the quantal era. This experiment was performed by O. Stern and W. Gerlach (1921) and subsequently interpreted by G. Uhlenbeck and S. Goudsmit (1925). The experiment and its elucidation led to the new concept of “intrinsic spin” (in particular to spin “½”), a development that was one of the major turning points in modern physics. The consequences have been monumental, and include primary theoretical developments; the interpretation of data related to, and an understanding of, empirical rules concerning a wide variety of physical systems (e.g., the periodic table of the elements/atomic structure); and the generation of new experimental techniques and of innovative measurements. Our study of intrinsic spin and its correlative, two-state systems, introduces the reader to one of the most profound topics in quantum theory. The Stern–Gerlach experiment and its interpretation The experiment of Stern and Gerlach was designed to test the “spatial quantization” of neutral atoms, i.e., to determine whether the (orbital) angular momentum was quantized. The basic ideas are as follows. Associated with the atom's orbital angular momentum would be a magnetic moment, as in the Bohr model of hydrogen.
The Electron Spin. Entangled StatesThe introduction of spin in QM has far-reaching consequences.The most obvious of them have to do with the Pauli exclusion principle, which is responsible for the orbital structure of atoms and molecules, the subject of Chapter 16.More generally, as will be seen in Chapter 15, the statistics of quantum particles is determined by whether their spin is integer or half-integer.This chapter is essentially devoted to the spin of the electron.The first part deals with its groundbreaking discovery, its introduction into quantum formalism, and some of its most important effects on atomic spectra, notably the anomalous Zeeman effect.Historically, in QM spin has been considered as an angular momentum that particles can have by the mere fact of their existence, which is called "intrinsic" and does not allow any explanation.To address this shortcoming, in Section 4 we present a possible explanation for the origin of electron spin as a result of its interaction with the ZPF.Section 5 introduces the entangled system of two particles with spin, which provides an opportunity for a discussion -necessarily schematic -of the Schrödinger cat and the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) thought experiment, as well as the Bell inequalities. Discovery of the Electron SpinIn the years prior to the establishment of QM, there had been intensive efforts to explain the structure of atomic spectra.In particular, some progress had been made in describing the Zeeman effect, but a full explanation of the phenomenon had to wait until electron spin could be incorporated into Schrödinger's theory.As a reminder of the confusion that prevailed in those years, a certain form of the phenomenon, precisely the part that could not be explained in terms of classical models, is still called the anomalous Zeeman effect to distinguish it from what is known as the normal Zeeman effect, which corresponds to the part due to orbital angular momentum and was studied in Chapter 13.A detailed analysis of the anomalous Zeeman effect led A. Landé 1 in 1921 to propose a modification of the classical formula for the gyromagnetic ratio, that is, the 1 Alfred Landé (1888-1976) was a German-US theoretical physicist who carried out a deep and successful study of the anomalous Zeeman effect, in parallel with a search during forty years for an objectively realistic description of the quantum systems.He became a constant and fierce opponent of the Copenhagen interpretation and of the dualistic (particle and wave) view, and wrote several books on the foundations of the theory.