Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Centrality, Noncentral Selection, and the Scope of Bell-CHSH: A Measure-Theoretic Critique, Sharp Inflation Bounds, Canonical Reweighting Constructions, and an Experimental Protocol

Parker Emmerson

Published Dec 18, 2025• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Bell-CHSH is frequently paraphrased as "local realism is impossible" after experimental violations of CHSH. The theorem is correct, but the paraphrase hides a structural assumption: selection centrality (fair sampling), i.e. that the detected sample is not a setting-and hiddenvariable-dependent reweighting of the hidden prior. We give a precise measure-theoretic separation between (i) the central sector, where E obs = E full and CHSH≤ 2 holds under measurement independence and locality, and (ii) the noncentral sector, where the observed correlations are computed under a reweighted measure dν a,b = w(a, b, λ) dρ. We prove a sharp CHSH inflation bound

DOI
10.22541/au.176607125.57257811/v1

Related papers

Centrality, Noncentral Selection, and the Scope of Bell–CHSH:

Emmerson, Parker

Bell--CHSH is frequently paraphrased as ``local realism is impossible'' after experimentalviolations of CHSH. The theorem is correct, but the paraphrase hides a structural assumption:\emph{selection centrality} (fair sampling), i.e.\ that the detected sample is not asetting- and hidden-variable--dependent reweighting of the hidden prior.We give a precise measure-theoretic separation between (i) the \emph{central} sector, where$E_{\mathrm{obs}}=E_{\mathrm{full}}$ and CHSH$\le 2$ holds under measurement independence and locality,and (ii) the \emph{noncentral} sector, where the observed correlations are computed under areweighted measure $d\nu_{a,b}=w(a,b,\lambda)\,d\rho$.We prove a sharp CHSH inflation bound\[S_{\mathrm{obs}}\le 2+4\delta,\qquad\delta:=\sup_{a,b}\int |w(a,b,\lambda)-1|\,\rho(d\lambda),\]so reproducing Tsirelson's $2\sqrt2$ by strictly local measurement-independent models via selectionrequires $\delta\ge (2\sqrt2-2)/4\approx0.2071$.We provide (A) a canonical Radon--Nikod\'ym construction (piecewise constants on sign regions plusa small positive remainder), (B) an explicit local factorized detection-loophole construction thatreproduces arbitrary finite correlation tables, and (C) an implementable optics protocol to estimateor upper-bound $\delta$ from time-tag data via window dithering, threshold and spectral sweeps, andauxiliary-tag binning.This paper critiques not the validity of Bell's theorem, but the common overstatement of what CHSHviolations imply without an explicit, quantitative centrality audit.

•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

Bell–CHSH Under Setting-Dependent Selection: Sharp Total-Variation Bounds and an Experimental Audit Protocol

Parker Emmerson

Bell–CHSH is an inequality about unconditional expectations: under measurement independence, Bell locality, and bounded outcomes, the CHSH value satisfies S≤2. Experimental correlators, however, are often computed on an accepted subset of trials defined by detection logic, coincidence matching, quality cuts, and analysis windows. We model this by an acceptance probability γ(a,b,λ)∈[0,1] and the resulting accepted hidden-variable law νab obtained by weighting the measurement-independent prior ρ by γ and renormalizing. If νab depends on the setting pair then the four correlators entering CHSH are expectations under four different measures, and a Bell-local measurement-independent model can yield Sobs>2 by selection alone. We quantify the required setting dependence in total variation (TV) distance. For any reference law μ we prove the sharp bound Sobs≤2+2∑q∈QTV(νq,μ) for a CHSH quartet Q. Optimizing over μ yields the intrinsic dispersion bound Sobs≤2+2ΔQ, and, in particular, Sobs≤min{4,2+6DQ}, where DQ is the quartet TV diameter. The constants are optimal. Consequently, reproducing Tsirelson’s value 22 within Bell-local measurement-independent models via setting-dependent acceptance requires ΔQ≥2−1 (hence, DQ≥(2−1)/3). We then propose a two-lane experimental audit protocol: (i) prior-relative fair-sampling diagnostics using tags recorded on all trials, and (ii) prior-free dispersion diagnostics using accepted-tag distributions across settings, with ΔQ,X computable by linear programming on finite tag alphabets.

Quantum Reports•Jan 23, 2026•2 citations

Sharp Bell–CHSH Bounds Under Total-Variation Measurement Dependence

William He

This work derives an exact and operational tradeoff between Bell–CHSH violation and measurement dependence in local hidden-variable models. Measurement independence is relaxed via a single parameter MMM, defined as the maximum total-variation distance between hidden-variable distributions conditioned on different setting pairs. Under locality, we prove the sharp inequality ∣S∣≤min⁡(2+6M,4)|S| \le \min(2 + 6M, 4)∣S∣≤min(2+6M,4), valid for all admissible MMM, and construct an explicit two-state local model saturating the bound for every M∈[0,1/3]M \in [0, 1/3]M∈[0,1/3]. The result is invertible: any observed CHSH value ∣S∣=2+Δ|S| = 2 + \Delta∣S∣=2+Δ certifies a minimum required measurement dependence M≥Δ/6M \ge \Delta/6M≥Δ/6. The parameter MMM has a direct hypothesis-testing interpretation, placing Bell violations and setting predictability in the same operational units used in statistical distinguishability and cryptography. The paper also provides a linear-programming template that reproduces the analytic frontier and can be adapted to other Bell functionals.

•Jan 3, 2026•0 citations

Phenomenological Velocity and Bell–CHSH: Exceptional-Locus Semantics, Selection Simulations of − cos, and a Microcausal Realization

Parker Emmerson

This is the data set for the published, peer reviewed paper: https://ijqf.org/archives/8027 "Phenomenological Velocity and Bell–CHSH: Exceptional-Locus Semantics, Selection Simulations of − cos, and a Microcausal Realization:" https://ijqf.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/IJQF2026v12n2p10.pdf Bell--CHSH is often read as a universal prohibition on \emph{local hidden variables}. Mathematically, however, the CHSH bound $S\le 2$ is a theorem about a particular hypothesis class: a \emph{single} Kolmogorov probability space carrying all counterfactual outcomes, together with measurement independence, Bell locality (factorized response functions), and bounded outputs. On that class the proof is pointwise and unconditional, so no algebraic reformulation of a parameter (including a ``phenomenological velocity'' (PV)) can yield Tsirelson-scale singlet correlations $E(a,b)=-\cos(a-b)$ on a Tsirelson quartet. We then make precise two distinct ways in which PV can remain meaningful as a \emph{local} and in that sense ``hidden'' parameter while coexisting with Tsirelson-scale correlations, without contradicting Bell's theorem. First, we formalize ``exceptional-locus/defined-only'' conventions as setting-dependent acceptance (post-selection): reported correlators are conditional expectations under a setting-indexed family of accepted laws $\{\nu_{ab}\}$. Within this rung-1 semantics we give an explicit Bell-local deterministic base model whose accepted-sample joint law exactly matches the singlet law (unbiased marginals and correlator $-\cos(a-b)$) for all $a,b$, via an explicit acceptance rule $\gamma(a,b,\lambda)\in[0,1]$. Second, we give a PV-indexed microcausal (operator-algebraic) realization: PV parameterizes a canonical $SU(2)$ unitary that conjugates local observables inside commuting Alice/Bob subalgebras, and in the singlet state the unconditional correlator equals $-\cos(a-b)$ and attains Tsirelson's value $2\sqrt2$. The results clarify a semantic and structural trichotomy: any ``PV-to-Tsirelson'' account must (i) change the effective ensemble by selection/context, or (ii) leave the Kolmogorov (commutative) model class (e.g.\ via noncommutativity or quasi-probability), or (iii) relax a Bell premise such as measurement independence or Bell locality. In this sense, Bell--CHSH constrains a specific formalization of hidden variables rather than ownership of the terms ``local'', ``real'', or ``hidden'' in physics discourse.

•Feb 22, 2026•0 citations

The exact price of local realism in CHSH experiments: a measurement-dependence-detection trade-off surface, a moiré phase-locking mechanism that saturates it, and an unmeasured fringe in the fourfold coincidence sum

Aaron Alai

For local hidden-variable accounts of the CHSH experiment that are faithful -- reproducing the observed singles and coincidence rates and unbiased marginals of a polarization singlet with symmetric detector efficiency $η_{\rm eff}$ -- I determine the minimal measurement dependence $M$ (Hall's measure) needed to reach a CHSH value $S$. Linear programming over all local strategies yields $M(S,η_{\rm eff})=\max\{0,η_{\rm eff}((S+2)η_{\rm eff}-4)/6\}$, whose edges reproduce Hall's bound, the Garg-Mermin threshold, and the postselection ceiling. The quantum point is certified exactly: $M(2\sqrt{2},9/10)=(27\sqrt{2}-33)/100$, by primal and dual certificates in $\mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{2})$. I solve the detection profile under which a deterministic sign model reproduces the singlet exactly, and prove exact quantum correlations and angle-independent coincidence rates jointly impossible in this class. Mixtures of this profile with measurement dependence trade $M$ against a $\cos 4(a-b)$ modulation of the fourfold coincidence sum, up to 12.4% in relative amplitude, identical at the two CHSH angles; existing data exclude its full amplitude and bound its mixtures with flat detection to a detection share of order 15%; its sub-percent content is unbounded. A two-setting cross-ratio and a settings-torus log-Fourier protocol, calibrated against channel-efficiency imbalance, reach $5σ$ at 0.1% within hours; a flat result excludes the solved family to a detection share of order 1%. A local mechanism, moiré phase locking, with deterministic phase evolution and quenched randomness, attains the certified floor exactly at $η_{\rm eff}=1$ and, with the solved profile, reaches $M=0$ at $η_{\rm eff}\approx 0.80$. Its floor-attaining census shares a low-order Fourier skeleton across independent solutions and is not realizable by station-local offsets on the terrains tested.

quant-pharXiv:2608.18886•Aug 20, 2026•0 citations

Fair-sampling assumption is not necessary for testing local realism

Dominic William Berry, Hyunseok Jeong, Magdalena Stobińska +1 more

Almost all Bell inequality experiments to date have used postselection and therefore relied on the fair sampling assumption for their interpretation. The standard form of the fair sampling assumption is that the loss is independent of the measurement settings, so the ensemble of detected systems provides a fair statistical sample of the total ensemble. This is often assumed to be needed to interpret Bell inequality experiments as ruling out hidden-variable theories. Here we show that it is not necessary; the loss can depend on measurement settings, provided the detection efficiency factorizes as a function of the measurement settings and any hidden variable. This condition implies that Tsirelson's bound must be satisfied for entangled states. On the other hand, we show that it is possible for Tsirelson's bound to be violated while the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH)-Bell inequality still holds for unentangled states, and present an experimentally feasible example.

arXiv:0712.2490•Physical Review A•Jan 13, 2010•32 citations
Bell-CHSH is frequently paraphrased as "local realism is impossible" after experimental violations of CHSH. The theorem is correct, but the paraphrase hides a structural assumption: selection centrality (fair sampling), i.e. that the detected sample is not a setting-and hiddenvariable-dependent reweighting of the hidden prior. We give a precise measure-theoretic separation between (i) the central sector, where E obs = E full and CHSH≤ 2 holds under measurement independence and locality, and (ii) the noncentral sector, where the observed correlations are computed under a reweighted measure dν a,b = w(a, b, λ) dρ. We prove a sharp CHSH inflation bound
Bell--CHSH is frequently paraphrased as ``local realism is impossible'' after experimentalviolations of CHSH. The theorem is correct, but the paraphrase hides a structural assumption:\emph{selection centrality} (fair sampling), i.e.\ that the detected sample is not asetting- and hidden-variable--dependent reweighting of the hidden prior.We give a precise measure-theoretic separation between (i) the \emph{central} sector, whereEobs=EfullE_{\mathrm{obs}}=E_{\mathrm{full}}Eobs​=Efull​ and CHSH≤2\le 2≤2 holds under measurement independence and locality,and (ii) the \emph{noncentral} sector, where the observed correlations are computed under areweighted measure dνa,b=w(a,b,λ) dρd\nu_{a,b}=w(a,b,\lambda)\,d\rhodνa,b​=w(a,b,λ)dρ.We prove a sharp CHSH inflation boundSobs≤2+4δ,δ:=sup⁡a,b∫∣w(a,b,λ)−1∣ ρ(dλ),S_{\mathrm{obs}}\le 2+4\delta,\qquad\delta:=\sup_{a,b}\int |w(a,b,\lambda)-1|\,\rho(d\lambda),Sobs​≤2+4δ,δ:=supa,b​∫∣w(a,b,λ)−1∣ρ(dλ),so reproducing Tsirelson's 222\sqrt222​ by strictly local measurement-independent models via selectionrequires δ≥(22−2)/4≈0.2071\delta\ge (2\sqrt2-2)/4\approx0.2071δ≥(22​−2)/4≈0.2071.We provide (A) a canonical Radon--Nikod\'ym construction (piecewise constants on sign regions plusa small positive remainder), (B) an explicit local factorized detection-loophole construction thatreproduces arbitrary finite correlation tables, and (C) an implementable optics protocol to estimateor upper-bound δ\deltaδ from time-tag data via window dithering, threshold and spectral sweeps, andauxiliary-tag binning.This paper critiques not the validity of Bell's theorem, but the common overstatement of what CHSHviolations imply without an explicit, quantitative centrality audit.
Bell–CHSH is an inequality about unconditional expectations: under measurement independence, Bell locality, and bounded outcomes, the CHSH value satisfies S≤2. Experimental correlators, however, are often computed on an accepted subset of trials defined by detection logic, coincidence matching, quality cuts, and analysis windows. We model this by an acceptance probability γ(a,b,λ)∈[0,1] and the resulting accepted hidden-variable law νab obtained by weighting the measurement-independent prior ρ by γ and renormalizing. If νab depends on the setting pair then the four correlators entering CHSH are expectations under four different measures, and a Bell-local measurement-independent model can yield Sobs>2 by selection alone. We quantify the required setting dependence in total variation (TV) distance. For any reference law μ we prove the sharp bound Sobs≤2+2∑q∈QTV(νq,μ) for a CHSH quartet Q. Optimizing over μ yields the intrinsic dispersion bound Sobs≤2+2ΔQ, and, in particular, Sobs≤min{4,2+6DQ}, where DQ is the quartet TV diameter. The constants are optimal. Consequently, reproducing Tsirelson’s value 22 within Bell-local measurement-independent models via setting-dependent acceptance requires ΔQ≥2−1 (hence, DQ≥(2−1)/3). We then propose a two-lane experimental audit protocol: (i) prior-relative fair-sampling diagnostics using tags recorded on all trials, and (ii) prior-free dispersion diagnostics using accepted-tag distributions across settings, with ΔQ,X computable by linear programming on finite tag alphabets.
This work derives an exact and operational tradeoff between Bell–CHSH violation and measurement dependence in local hidden-variable models. Measurement independence is relaxed via a single parameter MMM, defined as the maximum total-variation distance between hidden-variable distributions conditioned on different setting pairs. Under locality, we prove the sharp inequality ∣S∣≤min⁡(2+6M,4)|S| \le \min(2 + 6M, 4)∣S∣≤min(2+6M,4), valid for all admissible MMM, and construct an explicit two-state local model saturating the bound for every M∈[0,1/3]M \in [0, 1/3]M∈[0,1/3]. The result is invertible: any observed CHSH value ∣S∣=2+Δ|S| = 2 + \Delta∣S∣=2+Δ certifies a minimum required measurement dependence M≥Δ/6M \ge \Delta/6M≥Δ/6. The parameter MMM has a direct hypothesis-testing interpretation, placing Bell violations and setting predictability in the same operational units used in statistical distinguishability and cryptography. The paper also provides a linear-programming template that reproduces the analytic frontier and can be adapted to other Bell functionals.
This is the data set for the published, peer reviewed paper: https://ijqf.org/archives/8027 "Phenomenological Velocity and Bell–CHSH: Exceptional-Locus Semantics, Selection Simulations of − cos, and a Microcausal Realization:" https://ijqf.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/IJQF2026v12n2p10.pdf Bell--CHSH is often read as a universal prohibition on \emph{local hidden variables}. Mathematically, however, the CHSH bound S≤2S\le 2S≤2 is a theorem about a particular hypothesis class: a \emph{single} Kolmogorov probability space carrying all counterfactual outcomes, together with measurement independence, Bell locality (factorized response functions), and bounded outputs. On that class the proof is pointwise and unconditional, so no algebraic reformulation of a parameter (including a ``phenomenological velocity'' (PV)) can yield Tsirelson-scale singlet correlations E(a,b)=−cos⁡(a−b)E(a,b)=-\cos(a-b)E(a,b)=−cos(a−b) on a Tsirelson quartet. We then make precise two distinct ways in which PV can remain meaningful as a \emph{local} and in that sense ``hidden'' parameter while coexisting with Tsirelson-scale correlations, without contradicting Bell's theorem. First, we formalize ``exceptional-locus/defined-only'' conventions as setting-dependent acceptance (post-selection): reported correlators are conditional expectations under a setting-indexed family of accepted laws {νab}\{\nu_{ab}\}{νab​}. Within this rung-1 semantics we give an explicit Bell-local deterministic base model whose accepted-sample joint law exactly matches the singlet law (unbiased marginals and correlator −cos⁡(a−b)-\cos(a-b)−cos(a−b)) for all a,ba,ba,b, via an explicit acceptance rule γ(a,b,λ)∈[0,1]\gamma(a,b,\lambda)\in[0,1]γ(a,b,λ)∈[0,1]. Second, we give a PV-indexed microcausal (operator-algebraic) realization: PV parameterizes a canonical SU(2)SU(2)SU(2) unitary that conjugates local observables inside commuting Alice/Bob subalgebras, and in the singlet state the unconditional correlator equals −cos⁡(a−b)-\cos(a-b)−cos(a−b) and attains Tsirelson's value 222\sqrt222​. The results clarify a semantic and structural trichotomy: any ``PV-to-Tsirelson'' account must (i) change the effective ensemble by selection/context, or (ii) leave the Kolmogorov (commutative) model class (e.g.\ via noncommutativity or quasi-probability), or (iii) relax a Bell premise such as measurement independence or Bell locality. In this sense, Bell--CHSH constrains a specific formalization of hidden variables rather than ownership of the terms ``local'', ``real'', or ``hidden'' in physics discourse.
For local hidden-variable accounts of the CHSH experiment that are faithful -- reproducing the observed singles and coincidence rates and unbiased marginals of a polarization singlet with symmetric detector efficiency ηeffη_{\rm eff}ηeff​ -- I determine the minimal measurement dependence MMM (Hall's measure) needed to reach a CHSH value SSS. Linear programming over all local strategies yields M(S,ηeff)=max⁡{0,ηeff((S+2)ηeff−4)/6}M(S,η_{\rm eff})=\max\{0,η_{\rm eff}((S+2)η_{\rm eff}-4)/6\}M(S,ηeff​)=max{0,ηeff​((S+2)ηeff​−4)/6}, whose edges reproduce Hall's bound, the Garg-Mermin threshold, and the postselection ceiling. The quantum point is certified exactly: M(22,9/10)=(272−33)/100M(2\sqrt{2},9/10)=(27\sqrt{2}-33)/100M(22​,9/10)=(272​−33)/100, by primal and dual certificates in Q(2)\mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{2})Q(2​). I solve the detection profile under which a deterministic sign model reproduces the singlet exactly, and prove exact quantum correlations and angle-independent coincidence rates jointly impossible in this class. Mixtures of this profile with measurement dependence trade MMM against a cos⁡4(a−b)\cos 4(a-b)cos4(a−b) modulation of the fourfold coincidence sum, up to 12.4% in relative amplitude, identical at the two CHSH angles; existing data exclude its full amplitude and bound its mixtures with flat detection to a detection share of order 15%; its sub-percent content is unbounded. A two-setting cross-ratio and a settings-torus log-Fourier protocol, calibrated against channel-efficiency imbalance, reach 5σ5σ5σ at 0.1% within hours; a flat result excludes the solved family to a detection share of order 1%. A local mechanism, moiré phase locking, with deterministic phase evolution and quenched randomness, attains the certified floor exactly at ηeff=1η_{\rm eff}=1ηeff​=1 and, with the solved profile, reaches M=0M=0M=0 at ηeff≈0.80η_{\rm eff}\approx 0.80ηeff​≈0.80. Its floor-attaining census shares a low-order Fourier skeleton across independent solutions and is not realizable by station-local offsets on the terrains tested.
Almost all Bell inequality experiments to date have used postselection and therefore relied on the fair sampling assumption for their interpretation. The standard form of the fair sampling assumption is that the loss is independent of the measurement settings, so the ensemble of detected systems provides a fair statistical sample of the total ensemble. This is often assumed to be needed to interpret Bell inequality experiments as ruling out hidden-variable theories. Here we show that it is not necessary; the loss can depend on measurement settings, provided the detection efficiency factorizes as a function of the measurement settings and any hidden variable. This condition implies that Tsirelson's bound must be satisfied for entangled states. On the other hand, we show that it is possible for Tsirelson's bound to be violated while the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH)-Bell inequality still holds for unentangled states, and present an experimentally feasible example.