The nature of consciousness, its occurrence in the brain and its ultimate place in the universe are unknown. Probably the most interesting attempt to create a quantum theory of consciousness is that of Roger Penrose (recipient of the 2020 Nobel Prize for Physics) and an American anaesthesiologist Stuart Hameroff. They are both well known for their studies of consciousness and for the thesis that consciousness originates from quantum states in neural microtubules. The starting point for this article are the authors’ considerations contained in their joint work (Penrose & Hameroff, 2017). This paper also proposes an initial attempt to combine this theory with quantum logic.
The nature of consciousness, its occurrence in the brain and its ultimate place in the universe are unknown. Probably the most interesting attempt to create a quantum theory of consciousness is that of Roger Penrose (recipient of the 2020 Nobel Prize for Physics) and an American anaesthesiologist Stuart Hameroff. They are both well known for their studies of consciousness and for the thesis that consciousness originates from quantum states in neural microtubules. The starting point for this article are the authors’ considerations contained in their joint work (Penrose & Hameroff, 2017). This paper also proposes an initial attempt to combine this theory with quantum logic.
It has been over 20 years since the theory of consciousness Penrose–Hameroff was launched. During this time it has not received significant evidence and was subjected to a thorough critique by many prominent scientists. Insolvency of this theory was proclaimed by such authority as Stephen Hawking. Despite all this, Penrose–Hameroffs theory continues to appear in the scientific community and to be advertised in popular literature as a major achievement of consciousness studies. This situation prompts a detailed review and additional critical analysis of the theory of the Penrose–Hameroff. It is understood that one of the reasons for the “support” of this theory is that its co-author and principal founder is a prominent scientist of our time, a mathematician and a specialist in the field of cosmology and astrophysics, Sir Roger Penrose. The article discusses in detail the basic tenets of the theory, the essence of which is associated with the operation of “"objective reduction» ” (OR) as a quantum computing in the brain microtubules. It has been shown that the basic provisions of the theory is based on a number of Penrose’s hypotheses about the future physical theories, which are yet to be created to achieve a quantum-mechanical explanation of consciousness and brain activity. A critique by such experts as A. Shimoni, N. Cartwright, S. Hawking that appeared soon after the appearance of the theory is considered. We should underline special importance of the critical arguments of S. Hawking. He makes a number of reasons, from the standpoint of quantum mechanics. They imply that the objective reduction of the wave function as a form of decoherence can occur through interaction with environment factors or due to fluctuations of space-time. Therefore there is no need to bring order to explain quantum gravity. Especially since according to Penrose, the objective effect of the reduction is so small that it can not be experimentally separated from decoherence caused by interaction with the environment. Hawking stressed that Penrose leaves aside the key questions of the theory of mind about the specific properties of consciousness (what we call in the philosophical language “subjective reality” and associate with the problem of “other minds”). The article underlines the high relevance of the problem of consciousness in modern conditions, discusses methodological issues of constructing a theory of consciousness and related philosophical problems. It is shown that the failure of physicalist approach to the explanation of consciousness is also seen from the standpoint of quantum mechanics. Over the past 20 years, science has made a huge step forward. This applies not only to the biological disciplines, information and cognitive technologies, but to the physics itself, the development of nanotechnology and the whole NBICS convergence system. But all this did not affect in any significant degree of speculation and conceptual problems of “theory” of the Penrose–Hameroff. No “fundamentally new OR-theory” has appeared, no new laws of physics were discovered, whuch, as Penrose hoped, would confirm his hypothesis. To a thorough critical arguments against the theory of Penrose–Hameroff discussed in the article, we can add a number of other counter-arguments, also concerning experimental base of Hameroff research, that will be presented in the second part of the article.
Abstract In neuroscience, the flow of time is a conscious experience produced by the brain. But in physics, time is either a process, or a dimension in four-dimensional spacetime geometry. Could all three explanations be correct? The Penrose–Hameroff ‘Orch OR’ theory suggests consciousness is a sequence of discrete, irreversible quantum state reductions occurring at an objective threshold (‘objective reduction’, ‘OR’) a process in fundamental spacetime geometry. These ‘self-collapses’ of the quantum wavefunction are ‘orchestrated’ in microtubules inside brain neurons. Each Orch OR event selects microtubule states which purposefully regulate neuronal functions, and provide sequences of ‘NOW’ moments of conscious experience. Connected to fundamental spacetime geometry by Penrose ‘OR’, consciousness is quantum state reduction, a set of irreversible steps which ‘ratchet forward’ in the fine scale geometry of the universe, creating a flow of time.
The nature of consciousness, its occurrence in the brain, and its ultimate place in the universe are unknown. We proposed in the mid 1990's that consciousness depends on biologically 'orchestrated' quantum computations in collections of microtubules within brain neurons, that these quantum computations correlate with and regulate neuronal activity, and that the continuous Schrodinger evolution of each quantum computation terminates in accordance with the specific Diosi‐Penrose (DP) scheme of 'objective reduction' of the quantum state (OR). This orchestrated OR activity (Orch OR) is taken to result in a moment of conscious awareness and/or choice. This particular (DP) form of OR is taken to be a quantum-gravity process related to the fundamentals of spacetime geometry, so Orch OR suggests a connection between brain biomolecular processes and fine-scale structure of the universe. Here we review and update Orch OR in light of criticisms and developments in quantum biology, neuroscience, physics and cosmology. We conclude that consciousness plays an intrinsic role in the universe.
As generally accepted, consciousness or mind and material brain are closely related to each other; but how? Quantum mechanics is a new pathway to understand the hard problem of consciousness and its relation to the brain. Consciousness has specific properties such as unity, irreducibility, non-locality, etc. The completely different features of classical physics (locality, reducibility, determinacy, etc.) hindered the success of scientists to study consciousness. But quantum mechanics with its features (non-locality, irreducibility, indeterminacy, etc.) gave scientists hope to study consciousness. Several quantum approaches to consciousness have been proposed in recent decades; the most important point about these approaches is that each one has used its own philosophy to determine its viewpoint about the mind’s nature and even its quantum approach. In general, all scientific theories are based on some metaphysical principles which come from the worldview of scientists. In this article four contemporary approaches are discussed: The Eccles-Beck, Stapp, Penrose-Hameroff, and Avicenna-Bohm theories; philosophical and scientific points are highlighted for each of them. Finally, the theory of Top-Down Causation is discussed because we think it can provide a fertile philosophical ground for theories of “mind-brain relation” and “quantum consciousness”.
This article explores the Orchestrated Objective Reduction hypothesis proposed by Roger Penrose and Stuart Hameroff, which posits that human consciousness arises from quantum-mechanical processes within the brain rather than classical algorithmic computation. The author details how tubulin proteins within neuronal microtubules are suggested to function as qubits that sustain quantum superposition and entanglement by isolating signals from environmental decoherence. Gravitational fluctuations are hypothesized to trigger the objective reduction of these quantum states, generating discrete moments of awareness that form a continuous stream of consciousness. Despite theoretical criticisms regarding the weakness of gravitational influences and the prevalence of thermal decoherence, the paper highlights recent experimental evidence in quantum biology, such as sustained photon luminescence in microtubules, that supports the feasibility of long-lasting quantum states in biological structures.