Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

BMC Artificial Intelligence

Overcoming SVM limitations in lung cancer classification with a quantum feature map

Achraf Toufah, Mohamed Achraf Kadim, Moulay Youssef El Hafidi

Published Dec 9, 2025• 5 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Background Lung cancer is a leading cause of cancer mortality, and early detection is critical for patient outcomes. Support Vector Machines (SVM) have been widely applied to diagnostic classification, but their performance can be limited in terms of sensitivity. Quantum Support Vector Machines (QSVM) offer a potential approach to improve this aspect. Methods We compared SVM and QSVM on balanced lung cancer subsets (1,000 samples each) using k-fold cross-validation. QSVM employed ZZFeatureMap and FidelityQuantumKernel for quantum feature encoding. Results QSVM achieved an average recall improvement of about 8% over classical SVM, while maintaining comparable precision and accuracy. Under a realistic 1:100 class imbalance, precision declined, highlighting challenges with highly skewed data. Conclusion QSVM shows promise for enhancing sensitivity in medical diagnostics but requires further validation on larger, heterogeneous datasets and real quantum hardware. Clinical trial number Not applicable.

DOI
10.1186/s44398-025-00016-3

Related papers

Overcoming SVM Limitations in Lung Cancer Classification with Quantum Machine Learning

Achraf Toufah, Mohamed Achraf Kadim, Moulay Youssef El Hafidi

Abstract In this study, we compare the performance of classical Support Vector Machines (SVM) and Quantum Support Vector Machines (QSVM) on binary classification tasks, using 149 balanced datasets derived from a lung cancer diagnosis dataset. Each dataset consists of 120 samples and 12 features. Our primary objective is to evaluate whether QSVM provides measurable advantages over SVM, particularly in low-performing scenarios. To this end, we identified the 15 datasets where classical SVM exhibited the lowest F1-scores and conducted a focused comparative analysis. Results show that, in these challenging cases, QSVM achieved an average recall improvement of 99% over SVM, without compromising precision. This substantial gain in recall also led to a corresponding 48% increase in F1-score, on average. Statistical analysis using a normality test followed by a paired t-test confirmed the significance of these results. These findings suggest that QSVM can serve as a valuable alternative in situations where classical models struggle, especially when high recall is critical for early cancer detection.

•Jul 11, 2025•0 citations

Investigating Quantum Feature Maps in Quantum Support Vector Machines for Lung Cancer Classification

Achraf Toufah, MA Kadim, Moulay Youssef El Hafidi

Background: Classical algorithms often struggle with the high dimensionality of medical data critical for early lung cancer diagnosis. While Quantum Machine Learning (QML) offers enhanced pattern recognition capabilities, the impact of specific quantum feature encoding strategies on diagnostic accuracy remains underexplored.Methods: We evaluated Quantum Support Vector Machines (QSVM) using a dataset of 309 lung cancer patients, divided into six balanced subsets to mitigate class imbalance. Models were implemented on a qasm simulator, comparing three encoding strategies: ZFeatureMap, ZZFeatureMap, and PauliFeatureMap. Performance was assessed using standard classification metrics.Results: The choice of feature map significantly influenced model efficacy. The PauliFeatureMap outperformed other kernels, achieving 100% classification accuracy in three of the six subsets, whereas ZFeatureMap and ZZFeatureMap yielded lower predictive consistency.Conclusion: Quantum feature map selection is a decisive factor in QSVM performance. Specifically, the PauliFeatureMap demonstrates high separability for medical data, highlighting the potential of optimized quantum kernels to improve diagnostic precision.

arXiv:2506.03272•Journal of Artificial Intelligence Research and Innovation•Dec 29, 2025•11 citations

Quantum Support Vector Machine for Prostate Cancer Detection: A Performance Analysis

Walid El Maouaki, Taoufik Said, Mohamed Bennai

Abstract This study addresses the urgent need for improved prostate cancer detection methods by harnessing the power of advanced technological solutions. We introduce the application of Quantum Support Vector Machine (QSVM) to this critical healthcare challenge, showcasing an enhancement in diagnostic performance over the classical Support Vector Machine (SVM) approach. Our study not only outlines the remarkable improvements in diagnostic performance made by QSVM over the classic SVM technique, but it delves into the advancements brought about by the quantum feature map architecture, which has been carefully identified and evaluated, ensuring it aligns seamlessly with the unique characteristics of our prostate cancer dataset. This architecture succeded in creating a distinct feature space, enabling the detection of complex, non-linear patterns in the data. The findings reveal not only a comparable accuracy with classical SVM (92%) but also a 7.14% increase in sensitivity and a notably high F1-Score (93.33%). This study's important combination of quantum computing in medical diagnostics marks a pivotal step forward in cancer detection, offering promising implications for the future of healthcare technology.

arXiv:2403.07856•Jan 17, 2024•24 citations

Comparative Performance Analysis of SVM and QSVM in Breast Cancer Diagnosis

Gita Kartika, Muhamad Akrom

The application of machine learning has shown significant progress in various fields, including clinical data classification. This study presents a comparative analysis between the classical Support Vector Machine (SVM) and Quantum Support Vector Machine (QSVM) for breast cancer classification using the Wisconsin Diagnostic Breast Cancer (WDBC) dataset. Principal Component Analysis (PCA) was applied as dimension reduction strategy across three configurations (PCA = 2, PCA = 4, and PCA = 6) to evaluate the sensitivity of both models to the feature space dimension. Preprocessing included log1p transformation on 22 skewed features, Manual SMOTE balancing, and MinMaxScaler normalization. SVM was optimized via GridSearchCV (80 parameter combinations, cv = 5), while QSVM employed a ZZFeatureMap quantum kernel (reps = 2, entanglement = full) on qasm_simulator. Experimental results demonstrate that SVM achieved superior accuracy across all configurations, with peak performance at PCA = 6 (Accuracy= 98.83%, AUC = 0.9985, Specificity = 1.0000, Sensitivity = 0.9688, Precision = 1.0000, NPV = 0.9817, and F1-score for malignant = 0.98). QSVM achieved its highest accuracy at PCA = 4 (92.98%), AUC = 0.9622, Sensitivity = 0.9219, Precision = 0.8939, NPV = 0.9524, and F1-score for malignant = 0.91. Across the three PCA configurations, QSVM exhibited a non-monotonic relationship between PCA dimensions and quantum kernel performance . These findings provide a quantitative benchmark for comparing quantum and classical machine learning in breast cancer diagnosis.

Journal of Applied Informatics and Computing•Oct 18, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Kernel based Support Vector Machine with Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm Embedding for improved Lung Cancer Prediction

Shivanya Shomir Dutta, Sahil Sandeep, Sriadibhatla Sridevi +2 more

The integration of classical machine learning with quantum computing has sparked a remarkable revolution, opening avenues to tackle previously insurmountable challenges in diverse fields, particularly in clinical applications. One such challenging task is to predict lung cancer with minimal clinical samples and features. The prominent objective of this proposed research is to introduce a novel Quantum Kernel Support Vector Machine (QKSVM) constructed with the Quantum Kernel Circuit (QKC) enriched with Quantum Approximation Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) embedding circuit to classify highly complex lung cancer using a minimal number of samples and minimal feature dimensions. In this context, to compare the classification performance of the transformative potential of the proposed QAOA embedding QKSVM classifier model, we implemented two other variants of the QKC leveraging Angle embedding (Angle Embedding QKSVM) and Instantaneous Quantum Polynomial embedding (IQP Embedding QKSVM). We also compared their performance with that of a classical SVM classifier. In this study, we delve into the transformative potential classification performance of the proposed QAOA Embedding-based QKSVM classifier, which is contrasted particularly in scenarios with limited sample size and feature dimensions. Our investigation reveals the quantum kernel’s superiority, even when operating with smaller datasets. This remarkable performance is attributed to the quantum models’ robustness in extracting intricate diagnosing features, enabling it to extract more pertinent insights from fewer data points. Notably, the QKSVM model trained with a significantly selected feature vector of 4-Dimensions (4D) with Principal Component Analysis (PCA) emerges as the frontrunner in lung cancer predictions, achieving an outstanding test accuracy of 94.64% and the highest area under curve (AUC) metric of 82.33%.

International Conference on Computing, Communication and Networking Technologies (ICCCNT)•Jun 24, 2024•9 citations

Evaluating the Impact of Different Quantum Kernels on the Classification Performance of Support Vector Machine Algorithm: A Medical Dataset Application

Emine Akpinar, Sardar M. N. Islam, Murat Oduncuoğlu

The support vector machine algorithm with a quantum kernel estimator (QSVM-Kernel), as a leading example of a quantum machine learning technique, has undergone significant advancements. Nevertheless, its integration with classical data presents unique challenges. While quantum computers primarily interact with data in quantum states, embedding classical data into quantum states using feature mapping techniques is essential for leveraging quantum algorithms Despite the recognized importance of feature mapping, its specific impact on data classification outcomes remains largely unexplored. This study addresses this gap by comprehensively assessing the effects of various feature mapping methods on classification results, taking medical data analysis as a case study. In this study, the QSVM-Kernel method was applied to classification problems in two different and publicly available medical datasets, namely, the Wisconsin Breast Cancer (original) and The Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA) Glioma datasets. In the QSVM-Kernel algorithm, quantum kernel matrices obtained from 9 different quantum feature maps were used. Thus, the effects of these quantum feature maps on the classification results of the QSVM-Kernel algorithm were examined in terms of both classifier performance and total execution time. As a result, in the Wisconsin Breast Cancer (original) and TCGA Glioma datasets, when Rx and Ry rotational gates were used, respectively, as feature maps in the QSVM-Kernel algorithm, the best classification performances were achieved both in terms of classification performance and total execution time. The contributions of this study are that (1) it highlights the significant impact of feature mapping techniques on medical data classification outcomes using the QSVM-Kernel algorithm, and (2) it also guides undertaking research for improved QSVM classification performance.

arXiv:2407.09930•Jul 13, 2024•25 citations
Background Lung cancer is a leading cause of cancer mortality, and early detection is critical for patient outcomes. Support Vector Machines (SVM) have been widely applied to diagnostic classification, but their performance can be limited in terms of sensitivity. Quantum Support Vector Machines (QSVM) offer a potential approach to improve this aspect. Methods We compared SVM and QSVM on balanced lung cancer subsets (1,000 samples each) using k-fold cross-validation. QSVM employed ZZFeatureMap and FidelityQuantumKernel for quantum feature encoding. Results QSVM achieved an average recall improvement of about 8% over classical SVM, while maintaining comparable precision and accuracy. Under a realistic 1:100 class imbalance, precision declined, highlighting challenges with highly skewed data. Conclusion QSVM shows promise for enhancing sensitivity in medical diagnostics but requires further validation on larger, heterogeneous datasets and real quantum hardware. Clinical trial number Not applicable.
Abstract In this study, we compare the performance of classical Support Vector Machines (SVM) and Quantum Support Vector Machines (QSVM) on binary classification tasks, using 149 balanced datasets derived from a lung cancer diagnosis dataset. Each dataset consists of 120 samples and 12 features. Our primary objective is to evaluate whether QSVM provides measurable advantages over SVM, particularly in low-performing scenarios. To this end, we identified the 15 datasets where classical SVM exhibited the lowest F1-scores and conducted a focused comparative analysis. Results show that, in these challenging cases, QSVM achieved an average recall improvement of 99% over SVM, without compromising precision. This substantial gain in recall also led to a corresponding 48% increase in F1-score, on average. Statistical analysis using a normality test followed by a paired t-test confirmed the significance of these results. These findings suggest that QSVM can serve as a valuable alternative in situations where classical models struggle, especially when high recall is critical for early cancer detection.
Background: Classical algorithms often struggle with the high dimensionality of medical data critical for early lung cancer diagnosis. While Quantum Machine Learning (QML) offers enhanced pattern recognition capabilities, the impact of specific quantum feature encoding strategies on diagnostic accuracy remains underexplored.Methods: We evaluated Quantum Support Vector Machines (QSVM) using a dataset of 309 lung cancer patients, divided into six balanced subsets to mitigate class imbalance. Models were implemented on a qasm simulator, comparing three encoding strategies: ZFeatureMap, ZZFeatureMap, and PauliFeatureMap. Performance was assessed using standard classification metrics.Results: The choice of feature map significantly influenced model efficacy. The PauliFeatureMap outperformed other kernels, achieving 100% classification accuracy in three of the six subsets, whereas ZFeatureMap and ZZFeatureMap yielded lower predictive consistency.Conclusion: Quantum feature map selection is a decisive factor in QSVM performance. Specifically, the PauliFeatureMap demonstrates high separability for medical data, highlighting the potential of optimized quantum kernels to improve diagnostic precision.
Abstract This study addresses the urgent need for improved prostate cancer detection methods by harnessing the power of advanced technological solutions. We introduce the application of Quantum Support Vector Machine (QSVM) to this critical healthcare challenge, showcasing an enhancement in diagnostic performance over the classical Support Vector Machine (SVM) approach. Our study not only outlines the remarkable improvements in diagnostic performance made by QSVM over the classic SVM technique, but it delves into the advancements brought about by the quantum feature map architecture, which has been carefully identified and evaluated, ensuring it aligns seamlessly with the unique characteristics of our prostate cancer dataset. This architecture succeded in creating a distinct feature space, enabling the detection of complex, non-linear patterns in the data. The findings reveal not only a comparable accuracy with classical SVM (92%) but also a 7.14% increase in sensitivity and a notably high F1-Score (93.33%). This study's important combination of quantum computing in medical diagnostics marks a pivotal step forward in cancer detection, offering promising implications for the future of healthcare technology.
The application of machine learning has shown significant progress in various fields, including clinical data classification. This study presents a comparative analysis between the classical Support Vector Machine (SVM) and Quantum Support Vector Machine (QSVM) for breast cancer classification using the Wisconsin Diagnostic Breast Cancer (WDBC) dataset. Principal Component Analysis (PCA) was applied as dimension reduction strategy across three configurations (PCA = 2, PCA = 4, and PCA = 6) to evaluate the sensitivity of both models to the feature space dimension. Preprocessing included log1p transformation on 22 skewed features, Manual SMOTE balancing, and MinMaxScaler normalization. SVM was optimized via GridSearchCV (80 parameter combinations, cv = 5), while QSVM employed a ZZFeatureMap quantum kernel (reps = 2, entanglement = full) on qasm_simulator. Experimental results demonstrate that SVM achieved superior accuracy across all configurations, with peak performance at PCA = 6 (Accuracy= 98.83%, AUC = 0.9985, Specificity = 1.0000, Sensitivity = 0.9688, Precision = 1.0000, NPV = 0.9817, and F1-score for malignant = 0.98). QSVM achieved its highest accuracy at PCA = 4 (92.98%), AUC = 0.9622, Sensitivity = 0.9219, Precision = 0.8939, NPV = 0.9524, and F1-score for malignant = 0.91. Across the three PCA configurations, QSVM exhibited a non-monotonic relationship between PCA dimensions and quantum kernel performance . These findings provide a quantitative benchmark for comparing quantum and classical machine learning in breast cancer diagnosis.
The integration of classical machine learning with quantum computing has sparked a remarkable revolution, opening avenues to tackle previously insurmountable challenges in diverse fields, particularly in clinical applications. One such challenging task is to predict lung cancer with minimal clinical samples and features. The prominent objective of this proposed research is to introduce a novel Quantum Kernel Support Vector Machine (QKSVM) constructed with the Quantum Kernel Circuit (QKC) enriched with Quantum Approximation Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) embedding circuit to classify highly complex lung cancer using a minimal number of samples and minimal feature dimensions. In this context, to compare the classification performance of the transformative potential of the proposed QAOA embedding QKSVM classifier model, we implemented two other variants of the QKC leveraging Angle embedding (Angle Embedding QKSVM) and Instantaneous Quantum Polynomial embedding (IQP Embedding QKSVM). We also compared their performance with that of a classical SVM classifier. In this study, we delve into the transformative potential classification performance of the proposed QAOA Embedding-based QKSVM classifier, which is contrasted particularly in scenarios with limited sample size and feature dimensions. Our investigation reveals the quantum kernel’s superiority, even when operating with smaller datasets. This remarkable performance is attributed to the quantum models’ robustness in extracting intricate diagnosing features, enabling it to extract more pertinent insights from fewer data points. Notably, the QKSVM model trained with a significantly selected feature vector of 4-Dimensions (4D) with Principal Component Analysis (PCA) emerges as the frontrunner in lung cancer predictions, achieving an outstanding test accuracy of 94.64% and the highest area under curve (AUC) metric of 82.33%.
The support vector machine algorithm with a quantum kernel estimator (QSVM-Kernel), as a leading example of a quantum machine learning technique, has undergone significant advancements. Nevertheless, its integration with classical data presents unique challenges. While quantum computers primarily interact with data in quantum states, embedding classical data into quantum states using feature mapping techniques is essential for leveraging quantum algorithms Despite the recognized importance of feature mapping, its specific impact on data classification outcomes remains largely unexplored. This study addresses this gap by comprehensively assessing the effects of various feature mapping methods on classification results, taking medical data analysis as a case study. In this study, the QSVM-Kernel method was applied to classification problems in two different and publicly available medical datasets, namely, the Wisconsin Breast Cancer (original) and The Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA) Glioma datasets. In the QSVM-Kernel algorithm, quantum kernel matrices obtained from 9 different quantum feature maps were used. Thus, the effects of these quantum feature maps on the classification results of the QSVM-Kernel algorithm were examined in terms of both classifier performance and total execution time. As a result, in the Wisconsin Breast Cancer (original) and TCGA Glioma datasets, when Rx and Ry rotational gates were used, respectively, as feature maps in the QSVM-Kernel algorithm, the best classification performances were achieved both in terms of classification performance and total execution time. The contributions of this study are that (1) it highlights the significant impact of feature mapping techniques on medical data classification outcomes using the QSVM-Kernel algorithm, and (2) it also guides undertaking research for improved QSVM classification performance.